Christian missionaries say, “Kabah in Mecca did not exist before the 4th century.” Some of them even say that the Kaaba in Mecca where Muslims go for pilgrimage annually has no history before the advent of Islam. These ridiculous fictitious claims have no basis whatsoever. The Kabah in Makah did exist in history long before the coming of Prophet Muhammed (pbuh). Diodorus Siculus was a Greek historian, who wrote works of history in the 1st Century BC. He is known for the monumental universal history of Bibliotheca historica. Diodorus is the first known Historian long before the coming of Islam that makes mention of Mecca. Reverend Charles Augustus Goodrich a Christian, was an American author and Congregational minister. He writes: “Among the variety of fabulous traditions which have been propagated by the followers of Mahomet, concerning the origin of this building, we find it asserted, that its existence is coeval with our parents, and that it was built by Adam, after his expulsion from paradise, from a representation of the celestial temple, which the almighty let down from heaven in curtains of light and placed in Mecca, perpendicular under the original. To this the patriarch was commanded to turn his face when he prayed and to compass it by way of devotion, as the angels did the heavenly one. After the destruction of this temple by the deluge, it was rebuilt by Abraham and his son Ishmael on the same spot, and after the same model, according to directions, which they received by revelation; and since that time, it has continued to be the object of veneration to Ishmael’s descendants. Whatever discredit we may give to these, and other ravings of the Moslem imposter concerning the Caaba its high antiquity cannot be disputed; and the most probable account is, that it was built and used for religious purposes by some of the early patriarchs; and after the introduction of idols, it came to be appropriated to the reception of the pagan divinities. Diodorus Siculus, in his description of the cost of the Red Sea, mentions this temple as being, in his time, held in great veneration by all Arabians; and Pocoke informs us, that the linen or silken veil, with which it is covered, was first offered by a pious King of the Hamyarites, seven hundred years before the time of Mahomet.” [1] ***John Reynell Morell: “…historically speaking, Mecca was a holy city long before Mohammed. Diodorus Siculus, following agatharcides, relates that not far from the Red Sea, between the country of the Sabeans and of the Thamudites there existed a celebrated temple, venerated throughout Arabia.”[2] Encyclopædia Britannica: Or, A Dictionary of Arts, Sciences and Miscellaneous Literature - Colin Macfarquhar: “The science of astronomy was cultivated at Babylon, but the school of the Arabs was a clear firmament and a naked plain. In their nocturnal marches, they were steered by the guidance of the stars: their names order and daily station were familiar to the curiosity and devotion of the bedouins een; and he was taught by experience to divide into 28 parts of the Zodiac of the moon, and to bless the constellations who refreshed, with salutary rains, the thirst of the desert. The reign of the heavenly orbs could not be extended beyond the visible sphere, and some metaphorical powers were necessary to sustain the transmigration of the souls and the resurrection of bodies: a camel was left to perish on the grave, that he might serve his master in another life; and the invocation of departed spirits implies that they were still endowed with consciousness and power. Each tribe, each family, each independent warrior, created and changed the rites and the object of this fantastic worship; but the nation in every age has bowed to the religion as well as to the language, of Mecca. The genuine antiquity of the Caaba extends beyond the Christian era: in describing the coast of the Red Sea, the Greek historian Diodorus has remarked, between the Thamaudites and the Sabeans a famous temple, whose superior sanctity was revered by ALL THE ARABIANS: the linen or silken veil, which is annually renewed by the Turkish Emperor, was first offered by a pious King of the Homerites, who reigned 700 years before the time of Mahomet.“ [3] ***Andrew Crichton also comments on the ‘Kabah’ in his book; ‘The history of Arabia, ancient and modern.’ “From the celebrity of the place, a vast concourse of pilgrims flocked to it from all quarters. Such was the commencement of the city and the superstitious fame of Mecca, the very name of which implies a place of great resort. Whatever credit may be due to these traditions, the antiquity of the Kaaba is unquestionable; for its origin ascends far beyond the beginning of the Christian era. A passage in Diodorus has an obvious reference to it, who speaks of a famous temple among the people he calls Bizomenians, revered as most sacred by all Arabians.” [4] ***Claudius Ptolemy (Born: 90 AD - Died: 168 AD) Claudius Ptolemy was a Greco-Roman writer of Alexandria, known as a mathematician, astronomer, and geographer; is another person, centuries before Islam who makes mention of Makkah. He uses the name ‘Makoraba’ for Makkah. The Book: ‘The New Encyclopedia of Islam’, written by Cyril Glassé says that Ptolemy, in the second century mentioned Makkah. Here is what he wrote, “Mecca (Makkah al-Mukarramah, lit ‘Mecca the blessed’). For thousands of years, Mecca has been a spiritual center. Ptolemy, the second-century Greek geographer, mentioned Mecca, calling it ‘Makoraba’. Some have interpreted this to mean temple (from Maqribah in south Arabian) but it may also mean ‘Mecca of the Arabs.” [5] ***Ilya Pavlovich Petrushevsky (1898-1977) was a Professor of History of the Near East at the University of Leningrad for twenty years, he also mentions that Ptolemy in the second Century mentioned Makkah: “On the caravan route from Syria to Yemen, in the Hijaz neighborhood, lay Mecca. Ptolemy, the Greek geographer, mentions it as early as the second century calling it Makoraba, which is derived from the south Arab word Maqrab meaning ‘sanctuary’. [6] ***Michael Wolfe: “Mecca lies midway along the west coast of Arabia in a mountainous barrier region named the Hijaz. This narrow tract of land is about nine hundred miles long with the Tropic of Cancer passing through its center. The second-century Greco-Egyptian geographer Ptolemy called the city Makoraba, the temple.” [7] ***Paul Wheatley: “it was its virtual monopoly of Hijaz commerce which made of Mecca, in the words of the Quran, ‘a city secure and at peace; provisions flowing in from every side’. But all this is concerned with the expansion of the influence of a city that already existed. The name Mecca (strictly transliterated as Makkah) had been mentioned in the Ptolemaic corpus in the 2nd century AD under the orthography Makoraba, which itself derived from the Sabaean Makuraba, meaning ‘sanctuary’. Long before Muhammad the Ka’bah had served as the central shrine of a group of clans, each of whom had deposited its ritual stone, symbolizing its own god, in the sacred precinct.” [8] In the book ‘A Comparative Study of Thirty City-state Cultures: An Investigation’, by Mogens Herman Hansen; in Note 24 he makes it clear when Ptolemy mentioned the name ‘Macoraba’, that he meant Mecca: ***“Ptolemy in Geographies refers to Mecca as Macoraba.” [9] From all the evidence, from objective and academic sources, it can clearly be seen that it is a fact that Kabaah existed before the advent of Islam and Muhammad (peace be upon him). Reverend Charles Augustus Goodrich, a Christian historian, admitted that the Kabaah existed and was built by the Patriarchs. In his own words, he says, “Caaba its high antiquity cannot be disputed; and the most probable account is, that it was built and used for religious purposes by some of the early patriarchs.”
I am watching this video again (By Chance), and have further comments to add. Bro. Siraj gave a good kick on the A*s of this ruined Tamil Christian preacher who lost his mind a few years back in "Speaker Corner" for being unable to achieve a mark to get the Visa of his dreams. Siraj knows his Deen and their Bible far better than the miserable preacher. Unfortunately, these fake preachers will even argue with Jesus (AS) if he were in the Park, for they worship material wealth. -------------------- BAKKAH You must keep in mind; that Psalms and the Torah are written in Semitic language. The Abrahamic religion has descended from the Semitic Language. Europeans who don't even recognize that Abrahamic Faith was sent in Semitic won't be able to answer you. Becca is the Ancient name of Mecca. Becca's geography is Mecca. We see this in the article according to (1) Cambridge commentary, (2) Jewish Encyclopedia Volume II, and (3) Encyclopedia Biblical in Arabic and other sources. Ample Jewish and Christian references declare Becca's geography to be modern-day Mecca. Christianity and Judaism are a Semitic Religion like Islam. A European Language like English can corrupt the Words when translated. --------- Quran and Islam were first revealed in the city of Makkah, located in the known place, which is some 50 kilometers off the Red Sea's eastern coast. Both names were used once in the Qur'an: In Surat Aal-e-Imran chapter (3:96) referring to the house of Kaa’ba in Makkah “Verily, the first House (of worship) appointed for mankind was that at Bakkah (ie. Makkah), full of blessing, and guidance for Al-'Alamin (the mankind and jinns).” *In Surat Al-Fath chapter (48:24) “And He it is Who has withheld their hands from you and your hands from them amid Makkah after He had made you victors over them. And Allah is Ever the All-Seer of what you do.” *However, there is a very delicate point here that many might overlook especially none Arabic speakers and those who are unfamiliar with Qura'nic recitation rules: The use of name Bakkah was not used discretely rather it was mentioned joined as ببكة ie atBakkah, pronounced in Arabic as BiBakkah, which is lighter on the tongue to pronounce than بمكة ie BiMakkah. In Quranic recitation certain letters or diacritics at word ending are usually flipped into the preceding letter (called إقلاب) such as the two words من بعدهم becomes ممبعدهم or the following letter (called إدغام متجانسين) such as the two words قالت طائفة becomes قالطّائفة. In our case, The two letters م and ب are usually interchanged in old Arabic and the word Bakkah could be a result of a similar but different analogy of above. One final suggested explanation, which can be strongly noticed from the above two verses, is that Bakkah relates to the actual location of the house of Ka'bah at the heart of the city, and Makkah relates to the entire city area and its surroundings.
@@hudsontd7778According to who ? History according to Christians? Or Hindu? Remember we all have different History... UK History from US... Go bring strong argument... 😮
WELLDONE BRO SIRAJ ASSELAAMWWB BLESS SHUQRAN ASK THIS UGLY ABOUT THE TWO BIBLE THEY HAVE KING JAMES AND ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE AND WEN IT WAS WRITTEN AND IT WAS MIX INTHE 16 T CENTUARY BY KING CONSTATINE GHAAA HAAA ALLAHU AQBAR YAA RASULLALAH SAW
Cant be from psalm 84, it describes pools collected from the rain and people passing through, to go to Zion, Some say its not a place but a analogy. As in Hebrew it means to weep,
This mad preacher is punch drunk boxser He gets humiliated week By week but can't Fathom the Truth his heart IS sealed He should study his Bible not mark luke paul but the Iljine of Jesus and the Torah the bible came hundreds of years after Jesus 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Siraj is the medicine for this ruffian preacher, he tramples him like an Elephant tramples an irritating hyena.
The Christian was Fantastic, Thanks for the Upload.
@@hudsontd7778The Christian was fantastic at running away from his own claim.
Why can't he give evidence that bakka was a city in Jerusalem?
@@hudsontd7778 so can you give us the evidence that bacca was a city in jerusalem instead of him because he failed
@@hudsontd7778 Yeah, a fantastic liar (He could prove nothing), He is paid to deceive ignorant people like you
Siraj is the demon of interruptions
Christian missionaries say, “Kabah in Mecca did not exist before the 4th century.” Some of them even say that the Kaaba in Mecca where Muslims go for pilgrimage annually has no history before the advent of Islam. These ridiculous fictitious claims have no basis whatsoever. The Kabah in Makah did exist in history long before the coming of Prophet Muhammed (pbuh). Diodorus Siculus was a Greek historian, who wrote works of history in the 1st Century BC. He is known for the monumental universal history of Bibliotheca historica. Diodorus is the first known Historian long before the coming of Islam that makes mention of Mecca. Reverend Charles Augustus Goodrich a Christian, was an American author and Congregational minister. He writes: “Among the variety of fabulous traditions which have been propagated by the followers of Mahomet, concerning the origin of this building, we find it asserted, that its existence is coeval with our parents, and that it was built by Adam, after his expulsion from paradise, from a representation of the celestial temple, which the almighty let down from heaven in curtains of light and placed in Mecca, perpendicular under the original. To this the patriarch was commanded to turn his face when he prayed and to compass it by way of devotion, as the angels did the heavenly one. After the destruction of this temple by the deluge, it was rebuilt by Abraham and his son Ishmael on the same spot, and after the same model, according to directions, which they received by revelation; and since that time, it has continued to be the object of veneration to Ishmael’s descendants. Whatever discredit we may give to these, and other ravings of the Moslem imposter concerning the Caaba its high antiquity cannot be disputed; and the most probable account is, that it was built and used for religious purposes by some of the early patriarchs; and after the introduction of idols, it came to be appropriated to the reception of the pagan divinities. Diodorus Siculus, in his description of the cost of the Red Sea, mentions this temple as being, in his time, held in great veneration by all Arabians; and Pocoke informs us, that the linen or silken veil, with which it is covered, was first offered by a pious King of the Hamyarites, seven hundred years before the time of Mahomet.” [1]
***John Reynell Morell:
“…historically speaking, Mecca was a holy city long before Mohammed. Diodorus Siculus, following agatharcides, relates that not far from the Red Sea, between the country of the Sabeans and of the Thamudites there existed a celebrated temple, venerated throughout Arabia.”[2]
Encyclopædia Britannica: Or, A Dictionary of Arts, Sciences and Miscellaneous Literature - Colin Macfarquhar: “The science of astronomy was cultivated at Babylon, but the school of the Arabs was a clear firmament and a naked plain. In their nocturnal marches, they were steered by the guidance of the stars: their names order and daily station were familiar to the curiosity and devotion of the bedouins een; and he was taught by experience to divide into 28 parts of the Zodiac of the moon, and to bless the constellations who refreshed, with salutary rains, the thirst of the desert. The reign of the heavenly orbs could not be extended beyond the visible sphere, and some metaphorical powers were necessary to sustain the transmigration of the souls and the resurrection of bodies: a camel was left to perish on the grave, that he might serve his master in another life; and the invocation of departed spirits implies that they were still endowed with consciousness and power. Each tribe, each family, each independent warrior, created and changed the rites and the object of this fantastic worship; but the nation in every age has bowed to the religion as well as to the language, of Mecca. The genuine antiquity of the Caaba extends beyond the Christian era: in describing the coast of the Red Sea, the Greek historian Diodorus has remarked, between the Thamaudites and the Sabeans a famous temple, whose superior sanctity was revered by ALL THE ARABIANS: the linen or silken veil, which is annually renewed by the Turkish Emperor, was first offered by a pious King of the Homerites, who reigned 700 years before the time of Mahomet.“ [3]
***Andrew Crichton also comments on the ‘Kabah’ in his book; ‘The history of Arabia, ancient and modern.’
“From the celebrity of the place, a vast concourse of pilgrims flocked to it from all quarters. Such was the commencement of the city and the superstitious fame of Mecca, the very name of which implies a place of great resort. Whatever credit may be due to these traditions, the antiquity of the Kaaba is unquestionable; for its origin ascends far beyond the beginning of the Christian era. A passage in Diodorus has an obvious reference to it, who speaks of a famous temple among the people he calls Bizomenians, revered as most sacred by all Arabians.” [4]
***Claudius Ptolemy (Born: 90 AD - Died: 168 AD)
Claudius Ptolemy was a Greco-Roman writer of Alexandria, known as a mathematician, astronomer, and geographer; is another person, centuries before Islam who makes mention of Makkah. He uses the name ‘Makoraba’ for Makkah.
The Book: ‘The New Encyclopedia of Islam’, written by Cyril Glassé says that Ptolemy, in the second century mentioned Makkah. Here is what he wrote,
“Mecca (Makkah al-Mukarramah, lit ‘Mecca the blessed’). For thousands of years, Mecca has been a spiritual center. Ptolemy, the second-century Greek geographer, mentioned Mecca, calling it ‘Makoraba’. Some have interpreted this to mean temple (from Maqribah in south Arabian) but it may also mean ‘Mecca of the Arabs.” [5]
***Ilya Pavlovich Petrushevsky (1898-1977) was a Professor of History of the Near East at the University of Leningrad for twenty years, he also mentions that Ptolemy in the second Century mentioned Makkah: “On the caravan route from Syria to Yemen, in the Hijaz neighborhood, lay Mecca. Ptolemy, the Greek geographer, mentions it as early as the second century calling it Makoraba, which is derived from the south Arab word Maqrab meaning ‘sanctuary’. [6]
***Michael Wolfe: “Mecca lies midway along the west coast of Arabia in a mountainous barrier region named the Hijaz. This narrow tract of land is about nine hundred miles long with the Tropic of Cancer passing through its center. The second-century Greco-Egyptian geographer Ptolemy called the city Makoraba, the temple.” [7]
***Paul Wheatley: “it was its virtual monopoly of Hijaz commerce which made of Mecca, in the words of the Quran, ‘a city secure and at peace; provisions flowing in from every side’. But all this is concerned with the expansion of the influence of a city that already existed. The name Mecca (strictly transliterated as Makkah) had been mentioned in the Ptolemaic corpus in the 2nd century AD under the orthography Makoraba, which itself derived from the Sabaean Makuraba, meaning ‘sanctuary’. Long before Muhammad the Ka’bah had served as the central shrine of a group of clans, each of whom had deposited its ritual stone, symbolizing its own god, in the sacred precinct.” [8]
In the book ‘A Comparative Study of Thirty City-state Cultures: An Investigation’, by Mogens Herman Hansen; in Note 24 he makes it clear when Ptolemy mentioned the name ‘Macoraba’, that he meant Mecca:
***“Ptolemy in Geographies refers to Mecca as Macoraba.” [9]
From all the evidence, from objective and academic sources, it can clearly be seen that it is a fact that Kabaah existed before the advent of Islam and Muhammad (peace be upon him). Reverend Charles Augustus Goodrich, a Christian historian, admitted that the Kabaah existed and was built by the Patriarchs. In his own words, he says, “Caaba its high antiquity cannot be disputed; and the most probable account is, that it was built and used for religious purposes by some of the early patriarchs.”
I am watching this video again (By Chance), and have further comments to add. Bro. Siraj gave a good kick on the A*s of this ruined Tamil Christian preacher who lost his mind a few years back in "Speaker Corner" for being unable to achieve a mark to get the Visa of his dreams. Siraj knows his Deen and their Bible far better than the miserable preacher. Unfortunately, these fake preachers will even argue with Jesus (AS) if he were in the Park, for they worship material wealth.
--------------------
BAKKAH
You must keep in mind; that Psalms and the Torah are written in Semitic language. The Abrahamic religion has descended from the Semitic Language. Europeans who don't even recognize that Abrahamic Faith was sent in Semitic won't be able to answer you.
Becca is the Ancient name of Mecca.
Becca's geography is Mecca. We see this in the article according to (1) Cambridge commentary, (2) Jewish Encyclopedia Volume II, and (3) Encyclopedia Biblical in Arabic and other sources. Ample Jewish and Christian references declare Becca's geography to be modern-day Mecca.
Christianity and Judaism are a Semitic Religion like Islam. A European Language like English can corrupt the Words when translated.
---------
Quran and Islam were first revealed in the city of Makkah, located in the known place, which is some 50 kilometers off the Red Sea's eastern coast. Both names were used once in the Qur'an: In Surat Aal-e-Imran chapter (3:96) referring to the house of Kaa’ba in Makkah
“Verily, the first House (of worship) appointed for mankind was that at Bakkah (ie. Makkah), full of blessing, and guidance for Al-'Alamin (the mankind and jinns).”
*In Surat Al-Fath chapter (48:24) “And He it is Who has withheld their hands from you and your hands from them amid Makkah after He had made you victors over them. And Allah is Ever the All-Seer of what you do.” *However, there is a very delicate point here that many might overlook especially none Arabic speakers and those who are unfamiliar with Qura'nic recitation rules:
The use of name Bakkah was not used discretely rather it was mentioned joined as ببكة ie atBakkah, pronounced in Arabic as BiBakkah, which is lighter on the tongue to pronounce than بمكة ie BiMakkah.
In Quranic recitation certain letters or diacritics at word ending are usually flipped into the preceding letter (called إقلاب) such as the two words من بعدهم becomes ممبعدهم or the following letter (called إدغام متجانسين) such as the two words قالت طائفة becomes قالطّائفة.
In our case, The two letters م and ب are usually interchanged in old Arabic and the word Bakkah could be a result of a similar but different analogy of above.
One final suggested explanation, which can be strongly noticed from the above two verses, is that Bakkah relates to the actual location of the house of Ka'bah at the heart of the city, and Makkah relates to the entire city area and its surroundings.
siraj shouldnt even try debating until he learns to understand the question..what a waste of time siraj is.
Siraj, soldier of ALLAH!!!❤❤❤❤
What proof of Macca before the 7th Century?
@@hudsontd7778According to who ? History according to Christians? Or Hindu? Remember we all have different History... UK History from US... Go bring strong argument... 😮
He is rounding around the bush instead of hitting the shot.😅😅😅
WELLDONE BRO SIRAJ ASSELAAMWWB BLESS SHUQRAN ASK THIS UGLY ABOUT THE TWO BIBLE THEY HAVE KING JAMES AND ROMAN CATHOLIC BIBLE AND WEN IT WAS WRITTEN AND IT WAS MIX INTHE 16 T CENTUARY BY KING CONSTATINE GHAAA HAAA ALLAHU AQBAR YAA RASULLALAH SAW
3:10 RESSUURACTED 😂
Please Siraj don't talk to him, he only bla bla bla😂
Your two debates makes so many Muslim's leave Islam 😂😂😂😂
Cant be from psalm 84, it describes pools collected from the rain and people passing through, to go to Zion, Some say its not a place but a analogy. As in Hebrew it means to weep,
Since when this Hanuman has become a Christian? He was a Hindu.
siraj needs to learn how to debate
@3:55 Even the children recognize a falsehood.
Valley of bacca always exists. What the heck is he talking about
This mad preacher is punch drunk boxser He gets humiliated week By week but can't Fathom the Truth his heart IS sealed He should study his Bible not mark luke paul but the Iljine of Jesus and the Torah the bible came hundreds of years after Jesus 😂😂😂😂😂😂
👈🛑🤔👇👇👇 your baby sister's ha? I promise you before my last i get this stopped as well as islam globally siraj should be named sirabidi tray TOR🤖
Sam too all bk people in this cult man seriously shame on you all imagine they use something else OTHER THAN their mother tongue ha? Hmm stoooo ped
Well done bro siraj antichrist good name for the indian