Did Tarkin Know Darth Vader Was Anakin Skywalker? (Canon) - Star Wars Explained
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 сен 2024
- In this video we'll go over whether Tarkin knew Darth Vader was Anakin Skywalker or not, and if so, how? Tarkin fought along Anakin for the Republic in the Clone Wars, and then later in life, for the Empire...
Facebook Page - / starwarstheorytoos
Twitter - / toos_swtheory
Patreon - / starwarstheory
Instagram - / star.wars.theory
ALL of Darth Vader’s Injuries and His Thoughts About Them
• ALL of Darth Vader’s I...
What if Anakin WAS Granted the Rank of Master -
• What if Anakin WAS Gra...
Anakin's Thoughts While Being Burned on Mustafar and Turning Into Darth Vader -
• Anakin's Thoughts Whil...
8 Jedi Master Who Became Sith Lords -
• 8 Jedi Masters Who Bec...
How Did Anakin Kill All Jedi at the Temple During Order 66? Revenge of the Sith -Star Wars Explained
• How Did Anakin Kill Al...
What if Order 66 Failed? Star Wars Theory
• What if Order 66 Faile...
The Story and Reason Behind Darth Maul's Double Bladed Lightsaber
• The Story and Reason B...
Count Dooku's Reaction to Qui Gon Jinn's Death
• Count Dooku's Reaction...
What If Qui Gon Jinn Trained Anakin Skywalker?
• What If Qui Gon Jinn T...
What if Darth Maul Trained Anakin Skywalker? • What If Darth Maul Tra...
What if Padme Survived?
• What If Padme Survived...
What if Mace Windu Killed Darth Sidious?
• What if Mace Windu Kil...
Music - William Maytook
![How Thrawn Trolled Darth Vader on Being Anakin Skywalker [Canon] - Star Wars Explained](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qOwXlRd1MKo/mqdefault.jpg)
![How Thrawn Trolled Darth Vader on Being Anakin Skywalker [Canon] - Star Wars Explained](/img/tr.png)
Hey guys, let's hear em!!!
Star Wars Theory do what if Yoda trained Palpatine!!
can you do the delta squad from Republic Commando
Do; why did the empire choose to equip the stormtroopers with the E11 blaster rifle instead of any other weapon.
Star Wars Theory what if mace turned completely to the darkside during his training, and became a sith.
Star Wars Theory, Can U do "If Savage Opress was still alive.
Darth Maul: "Obi-Wan cut off my legs!"
Darth Vader: "Aw that's cute."
The Force It was self-defense!
You can Just their legs and you kidnapped his childrens
Oğulcan Kırmızıaltın I was just saving the galaxy...
and make them suffer your best friend and kidnapped his son and daughter worse life espically his son
What is your attack
'You my friend, are all that's left of their religion.' - Of course he knew. Sidious probably confirmed it, too.
ptthunder but did Tarkin know Palpatine was Darth Sidious
Harrambou not that he was Darth sidious necessarily but a Sith Lord, yea
Tarkin is old enough, of course he knew
@Yoda but he knew that obi-wan was anakin's and vader's master. I think Tarkin is smart enough to do the math
And in that same conversation they mention Obi-Wan being his old master so of course he knew.
When Vader said that Obi-wan was his old master, Tarkin may have figured out right then and there that Vader is Anakin.
loudboy317 right! It's a dead giveaway. He's foolish in this video for not saying that. I waited the whole time for him to bring that up..
Maybe Disney will retcon it in a Marvel Comic adaptation of A New Hope.
but tarkin said 'you my friend are all thats left of their religion' which suggests he knew anyway
loudboy317 ahhhh...
He told Tarkin that he felt a tremor in the force that he had not felt since the last time he was in the presence of his "master" (they were talking about Obi-Wan). Question answered, Tarkin knew. No further discussion necessary.
I always thought that the term "old master" was a reference to Yoda. But I agree that Tarkin knew.
@@Dan4CW What? They said Obi- wan
Absolutely he knew from day one
I didn't think about it till you said it but your right, He knew vader used to be a Jedi as implied by his answer. I assume he would have made the connection at least by the time obi wan showed up on the ds.
Yeah, if there was any lingering doubt in Tarkin’s mind that Vader was Anakin, then that was his confirmation. Vader literally confessed to being Obi-Wan’s apprentice in that moment, and I think he knew Tarkin suspected it at the very least the whole time.
I loved CGI Tarkin in Rogue One. The film would have felt weird without Tarkin's presence as he was such an integral part in the Death Star project. The CGI looked very realistic.
i agree with this, but in five years (maybe less) the cg is gonna look like garbage.
maybe, i think up to now, Jurassic parks CG looks good, but you can see how it aged.
agreed, very well done, very well acted out as well.
Can't wait for the CGI Carrie Fisher in the Last Jedi
She won't be CGI... Carrie Fisher finished her work on the film before she passed away... Atleast I heard that a while back.
It was made clear in the first movie.
Governor Tarkin: Obi-Wan Kenobi?
Darth Vader: He is here.
Governor Tarkin: What makes you think so?
Darth Vader: A tremor in the Force. The last time I felt it was in the presence of my old master.
Vader wouldn’t reveal that much about himself and his relation to Kenobi if it wasn’t clear that Tarkin already knew.
I might be in the minority but I had NO problems with Tarkin's CGI in Rogue One. There were only a few times, specifically with his mouth, that it looked "wonky" but overall I thought it was very well done. I shake my head at those who've said "It totally took me out of the movie".....really??? Well ok then.
If a little wrong special effect will take them out of the movie, then episodes 4, 5 and 6 are unwatchable.
I found Leia's CGI to be more jarring, only when she did that small smile. The rest of her face wasn't bad (maybe a little too perfect) but it was the mouth that always bothered me. Tarkin however was done well I think
Bill Sembach Rogue One sucks
I think they did a really good job with that. It was really good to see him again.
I think it would’ve been better if we were limited to seeing him as a reflection on the star destroyer viewport, that would have been far less obvious.
What if Luke accidentally killed himself with the lightsaber in Ben's house?
Jasper like, he looks straight down the handle as he turns it on?
Jasper well.... He did point it in his face
Oh great now it's all on me. Thanks useless bro.
Leia
Jasper Notice how close he came to lobbing off C-3PO's head also. (No really watch the clip closely)
The end
What if vader, tarkin and palpatine starred in a pop band and how their lives as famous singers changed their actions in the empire
"the old republic" xD
😂
What If Dooku killed Obi Wan in Episode 3
Forget pop bands, they would do epic METAL bands with Vader and the Empire’s epic ness! Not some talentless auto-tune-no-instrument crap. If they had a metal band, they would be TWICE as intimidating. Plus they would be BRUTAL! If they had a pop band, their intimidation wouldn’t be there anymore and they rebels would just destroy them immediately.
+Storm Shred lets take it one step further. a POWER METAL band. look up "Darth Vader sings Fury of the Storm" and u'll see why I think its a good idea.
CGI Tarkin looks better than CGI Leia.
When first I saw CGI Leia i thought she was fine, but the uncanny valley when she starts to talk is huge...
@@Elkarus when was CGI leia
Kaiser Wilhelm II My Kaiser, it was CGI in Rouge One. Long live the Kaiserreich!
@@basedtvrk9125 danke
Way way better
What if Obi Wan gave Anakin a Pepsi before there duel?
Vader's suit would be Pepsi Man.
maybe that's what all he wanted, just one pepsi.
Joaquin Vazquez The real question is what if Obi-Wan gave him a Snickers?
@@gamersinacontainer Oh damn you beat me to it
@DaCadet - Coke tastes like liquid shit. Pepsi is better.
Vader: “The last time I felt this was in the presence of my old master.”
Tarkin: “bro wasn’t anakin obi wans old pandawan... ahh never mind you’re not him...”
I like the CGI Tarkin in ROGUE ONE and the implications for a few reasons:
1. We got to see Peter Cushing again. That's a plus for me. I kinda teared up a little in the theater.
2. It helps the transition into EPISODE IV. People have already merged the ending/beginning together and it would be jarring to see Tarkin look completely different from a back-to-back comparison.
3. Cushing enjoyed working on STAR WARS (in contrast to his friend Alec Guiness) and he wanted to come back had his character not died. So it wasn't an abuse of his likeness because he would most likely have approved. It's not as if they revived him for a porno.
4. It gives filmmakers the opportunity to revive actors who have passed on a chance to do things they never had the freedom to do in life. Think of Vincent Price, Boris Karloff, and other actors who had exceptional skills, but were stuck doing horror movies their entire careers. We would have the ability to give them comedies, musicals, even Westerns (imagine Cushing in a Western!) and show people what they could have had if the cultures of the 1960s and 1970s had not been so tasteless and accepted more variety.
5. We can re-introduce new generations of audiences to old actors who would otherwise become forgotten. Then, they will go out and re-discover their old films, thus ensuring new fondness for classic cinema. Think about it: one day kids won't know who Alan Rickman is...would you want them to live a life like that? I think not.
I got wll kinds of goosebumps man it worked so well and it was unexpected o was geeking out haha
I sense respect on both parts, Vader & Tarkin, so it'd be cool to see a one-off movie b/w Episode 3 & 4 with both Vader & Tarkin. Also, more Peter Cushing is a bonus, like you said, he enjoyed his role more than Guiness; & he isn't being ridiculed or misuse. Tons better than that wanna-be Tarkin General Hux; gag.
True
what if Qui Gon Jinn never found Anakin Skywalker
RJW 32 the Jedi believe everything happens for a reason.
For such a scenario to make sense it would require either Qui Gon being more loyal to the Jedi Council than to the living force, or the Living Force never guiding Qui Gon to Tatooine. First scenario would require Qui Gon to be different, second would require Anakin to be unimportant to the plot, I mean, The Living Force.
Dooku
The force brought them together. There was no way that he wouldn’t have been found
Why did Tusken raiders shoot the pod racers?
In TPM
Because Sandpeople are assholes. They shot at the Jawas when they were trying to salvage the crashed Pod
As I understand, it was a kind of target practice, and it gave a Tusken bragging rights if they could shoot down something traveling several hundred miles per hour.
THE FORCE
Few guesses
1. Target Practice
2. Nothing better to do
3. They might of been hired by the race officials as an added challenge/ hazard at that part of the track. -- If they weren't invited or wanted there, I figure they would of been run off or killed.
Tarkin's CGI was acceptable, although I didn't think leia looked good.
You said the opposite of everyone else I heard.
Billybob Schneider Exactly.
Billybob Schneider TBH both were... weird but acceptable
Hold the fuck up, it was CGI in episode 3? He looked so much alive, as if Lucas went throughout the world to find an actor that would look like a young Tarkin actor... Or simply hire his son. Damn...
Blicz B no they're talking about the CGI Tarkin in Rogue One (the one we saw in Episode III was indeed a lookalike)
What if Princess Leia was placed on Tatooine? (and Luke on Alderaan)
That's an interesting one!
Thank you ^_^
Joseph Willis Didn't he already do that?
I honestly don't know, I'm new by a few months, sorry :s
read a amazing fanfic like that, emperor discovers Luke because as son of bail organa he have to go to important events on coursant and Luke was more noticeable in the force then leia, so emp kills bail and raises Luke himself, while obi-one realizing they lost Luke trains leia properly, luke has a really shitty childhood
How did the Empire choose its officers/generals. What traits or personalities were sought after? And how did the Empire know their commanding officers would be loyal? Do you think they were put through a special training program like the stormtroopers? Through the movies not one officer thinks of rebellion even when they witness Darth Vader's ruthless command. It's interesting that more stormtroopers/officers didn't leave the Empire (like Fin did) after wintnessing the hatred and brutality it is fueled by. It's almost as if the Empire altered their moral understanding of life.
Good questions. As for the Empire changing the citizens' morality, I think you're onto something there. They did use the traditional methods of propaganda and secrecy to mold public opinion. That certainly played a role. But I theorize that Palpatine, living on Coruscant, used the Dark Side to influence the minds of millions. It happened explicitly in Legends, when he wiped the memories of millions of people.
But ignoring Legends, I can see this happening in two ways. Either Sidious reached out with the Force and actually changed their minds, slowly and without being noticed. Or, his actions of destroying the Jedi and the Republic changed the balance of the Force in the universe. The Dark Side became very stong across the galaxy, and *that* made everyone a little more evil. That's the explanation that I subscribe to.
As to why officers and troopers didn't tend to defect, it's probably a combination of things. Partly what I just talked about, either Palpatine was directly influencing them, or the strength of the Dark Side itself was influencing them. But more than that, the Sith have always been good at controlling the lesser beings. They use fear, revenge, and violence to maintain order amoung their ranks. A horrible strategy in theory, but when you can choke someone from across the galaxy it becomes a more viable option. Every officer knew that any failure could mean their death. But even more pressing was their uncertainty. It wasn't that they knew what Vader would do to them - rather, they *didnt* know what Vader and The Emperor were truly capable of. Maybe they can read minds. Maybe they can see an officer's mistakes even when they aren't physically around to see it. That never-ending fear kept anyone from thinking of rebellion from within.
What's more, many officers believed in Palpatine and his methods. They actually believed (possibly influenced by the Dark Side or Sidious) that Sidious saved the galaxy from the evil Jedi and the corrupt Republic. They believed that Palpatine's violent methods and Palpatine's unquestioned leadership saved the galaxy. People are generally willing to overlook a lot of badness, when it's coming from their heroes.
On top of all that, officers were chosen and monitored by the Sith. Vader or the Emperor would keep a close eye on any important pawns. In other words, the important people were hand-chosen. That made any rebel sympathies unlikely. Coupled with everything else I've said, it's understandable why so few rebelled.
Yes tarkin knew. He knew obi-wan used to be his master. He knew exactly who he was. All you need is the exact scene you showed in the beginning
What if Han Solo didn't accept Ben Kenobi's request?
What if Han Solo wore a condom 🤔🤔🤔🤔
What if Luke was raised by Old Ben instead of his uncle?
then aunt Beru and Uncle Owen would of never been roasted
What if He was raised by uncle bens rice?
In a New Hope Tarken calls Vader his friend, so he had respect for him, he also says that Vader has a "religion" as a force user, which given that basically no one else at that time cares about the force, at least reiterates that respect for Vader, if not the force itself....
What if Tarkin survived the first Death Star ?
Sarah Lee He probably would have used the second to blow-up another planet.
Well he would have argued against the second one just like the first.
He did and changed his name to Supreme Leader Snoke
@@andrewlacerenza667 no.
What if the Yuuzhan Vong invaded during the Clone Wars?
Luke Munoz this!!!
Luke Munoz YES!!!!
YEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSS
Luke Munoz Jesús Cristo, please!
Luke Munoz YASSSSS
what if the deathstar blew up Yavin just before luke shot the torpedos blowing up the deathstar?
If you can't understand that, perhaps you should learn English
Did he edit it? It seems pretty clear to me.
that's a good question, and in english also lol
Jpspartin117 there is a RUclips video where somebody did their own CGI and made their own edit of the Battle of Yavin. At the very end of the Battle, just after Luke fired the torpeedoes, you can hear the Death Star Gunner saying, "Standby.......standby" then they show the exterior shot of the Death Star just before the explosion they show the laser effect starting to fire from the big gun on the Death Star just as it had done on Jedha, Scarif, and Alderan when suddenly the Death Star explodes. It was an excellent special effect and addition to the destruction of the Death Star and frankly, where they were in the firing sequence of the Death Star superweapon, it should have been in the movie already and not had to have been been added by a fan edit of the Battle of Yavin.
I think that the technology is convincing enough to make CGI characters now. Tarkin and Leia were pivotal characters during the time of Rogue One and I was elated to see them in the film.
Leia wasn't CGI in Rogue One. it was a real actor. not carrie
@@bexa9011 not true
@@finn.25 seems they CGId the face only and the rest was Norwegian actress Ingvild Deila
What if Maul and Savage killed Palpatine on Mandalore?🤔🤔🤔
Toaster B I don't know the star wars movie would be messed up
What if pigs could fly? Those two beat me? 🙄
@ヅStarstuff yes
@@ramonetrowbridge5054 Maul and Savage VS sidious wasn't in the clone wars movie, it was in the clone wars show
What if Padme got triplets?
It's a boy
Luke
It's a girl
Leia
It's an Attack Helicopter
*Padme dies
Guillermo Wang HELLO, WORLD, TIS I! HELICOPTER SKYWALKER!
MOTHER JUST DIED AND I HAVE ASCENDED INTO THE HEAVENS TO FIND MY FATHER
I WANT TO BE THE NEXT JEDI, BUT I HAVE NO ARMS--
The premise of bad fanfiction.
I don't know if you already had this but, many empires had civil wars when a leader died, so my Suggestion is: who would win if the emperor simply did not decide to life forever, won endor and died of old age.
What if it was Padme who let the dogs out?
What if Luke was raised by Sand?
oh the irony
It's treason then....
✌(ʘ‿ʘ)✌ 6iX hahahaha, you're ma man
What if Uncle Owen let Luke Skywalker go to tosche station to pick up some power converters
it would have been funnier if Leia was raised on Tatooine, and Padme named her Sandy
I would love a Cad Bane vs Jango Fett episode!
Jimmy G boba fett
What if Padmes vote of no confidence against Chancellor Valorum had failed?
Then, Palpatine would never become supreme chancellor. He also wouldn't be in any position to:
- form a separatist movement.
-create both clone and droid armies.
-start the clone wars.
-corrupt Anakin Skywalker into becoming Darth Vader.
- kill the Jedi.
-establish the Galactic Empire.
or
-build the Death Star.
In short, the entire Star Wars series would never happened the way they did.
loudboy317 Which also means that all the Disney changes wouldn't have happened.
+TJ347 there wouldn't have been Star Wars PERIOD
Eh, not exactly true. The clone armies were created almost 100% through the actions of Darth Plagueis. Palpatine didn't really have anything to do with actually placing the order with the Kaminoans. If the vote of no confidence had failed, it would have had to have been incredibly close, and there's nobody who can control a chaotic Senate like Palpatine can. So he would have found a way to skew the situation in his favor. That was Darth Sidious' greatest ability: controlling the masses practically effortlessly.
@@loudboy317 Palpatine will probably gain power somehow in the senate, after all the whole clone wars was a manipulation, I'm pretty sure they had something up their sleeve if the vote failed.
What if Darth Vader stayed and died on the first deathstar:)
Daniel Bubble hats Darth Jar Jar might have to rise
Daniel Bubble hats I am the senate
What if General Grievous discovered the truth behind the framing of the Jedi for the bombing of his shuttle and secret brain implants carried out by the Sith and Banking Clan? I wanna see your creative take on it. :)
Here are three that have been bugging me for awhile:
1: Did tarkin know about the Yuuzhan Vong, and did that play a role in his behavior for the republic/empire.
2: Was there ever a time when chewbacca separated from Han? If not then what is his struggle post murder?
3: What happened to the Sith race after/during the empire? I know that the purebloods were interbred into the dark Jedi overlords of the past 2,000 years but what of the remnants? Was Darth Sideous of any pure blood descent? If so did that play a factor into his desire to record history and write books that were meant to be passed to future sith?
Thanks for the awesome videos Star Wars Theory! I hope you consider these questions.
The fact that they could cgi tarkin and Leia so well was amazing. I know the truth now tarkin I knew something was up but Leia i was genuinely confused. Totally caught me off guard seeing her young again. Id relive that moment
I am the Senate
Not yet
its treason then
AAAARRGHHHG
Tell that to Kanjiklub.
Why is Vader never seen coughing/wheezing like grievous especially after all the damage to his lungs? Did his suit aid with soothing his lungs preventing irritation? - I know having Vader coughing in the films would be slightly underwhelming but when he is in his meditation chamber/bacta tank without his helmet/suit seeing him weaker and acting 'human' for a change would be interesting.
Dan Zadeh He used his bacta tank to help heal some of his injuries, including his lungs and skin. Obviously he never reached 100 percent rehabilitation, but it was probably enough to stop him from coughing or having his skin get caught on his suit
What if Luke Skywalker joined Darth Vader in Empire Strikes Back?
Would Darth Vader be able to beat General Grievous?
darth vader is everything Grievous tries to be. Vader would maul him. force crush his lungs the same way mace windu did. it wouldn't even be a contest. now, if they fought lightsaber combat only, that fight is a 50/50 and can go either way in my opinion.
Technically if they fought sabers as vader and grievous the general might very well win. Remember vader had some very limiting movements especially when it came to saber fighting. But I digress because vader would have used the force to win the fight rather than keep it fair.
keep it fair? Grievous has 4 lightsabers xD if they both had one it would be fair
Force Crush ✌️
Cyberdran96 No.
What if Starkiller was still Vader's apprentice in the original trilogy?
well he couldn't be snoke because snoke is clearly older as told about in the novels. so I think he would just be anther bad guy to throw in and that seems a bit crowded to me
What if time travel is also part of the Star Wars universe?
Starkiller is real, he's real in my canon, he's my favorite sith.
It's treason then.
Gannon he died a Jedi
What if all clones managed to remove their inhibitor chips and disobey Order 66?
Bill Diamantopoulos I was disappointed by this... realistically, it doesn't require literal mind-control to manipulate mass waves of people into doing terrible things
Just look at Nazi Germany; several psychological experiments and studies were done regarding this and the average human is quite likely to submit to an authority once they're "locked in"
With all due respect your question sucks Anthony because most clone fans would rather have an alternate timeline where order 66 never occurs because Palpatine ends up dying before that happens and later on new threats arise with the evil counter parts to the rebels alliance.
What if Han Solo killed Kylo Ren and not the other way round?
We'll have to wait for episodes 8 and 9 before we can speculate on what that would change.
Bill Diamantopoulos Before Carrie died ( Rest In Peace) she said there was gonna be a funeral scene
Not sure if you've covered it already since I'm new to the channel. Awesome stuff. But I'd like a video about race-specific lightsabers such as Yoda's short saber. Why aren't there many others such as a special handle made for certain hand shapes. If not, maybe a video on how Luke's lightsaber got into the possession of Maz Kanata? Thanks for doing the giveaway!
jedis make their own lightsabers when theyre still younglings or if they were recruited later in their lives, when they faced their jedi trials.
What if Yoda raised Princess Leia
We'll she'd definitely have less of a sense of fashion..
Braindead More like a better fashion sense!
If you like Obi-Wan, High Ground memes and Hello There's, like this comment!
Hello There
Boba Fett But he didn't!*insert diss track*
Ryan Barrie Hello Ryan
General Kenobi!
Obi-Wan Kenobi of course I like them, we made all those memes
please cover the physics of how lightsabers work
i agree with you that
Daniel Mann YESSSSSSS
There is a book which describes this, it's called Physics of the impossible, written by Michio Kaku
Daniel Mann simple , they don't work xD
they dont, not by physics as we know
Nice condensing of information as always. As for a topic I'm not sure how to word this right so it will be a little longwinded.
"Why did the Rebel Alliance have so much support/standing against an Empire that for all intensive purposes was accepted by the people and worked out well for the majority of the galaxy."
What if clone trooper fives exposed order 66
Haraldr Very good idea
Yes!
How did the fall of the empire and destruction of the second deathstar effect the citizens of the empire
We will see from Battlefront 2.
What if Qui-Gon Jinn didn't die? Do you think he would've been granted to train Anakin?
What if Padme fell in love with Obi-Wan Kenobi
The result would have been the same....just Qui-Gon Jinn would assist Dooku and Anakin should have done killing his own master to overthrow the Emperror...
What if Qui-Gon married Darth Maul?
This is my favourite what-if. Qui-gon would not care if he got permission. He'd train Anakin no matter what. Being the light-leaning gray Jedi that he was, he'd be the perfect master for Anakin. Kenobi's problem was that he was too light-side to teach Anakin how to deal with his dark side feelings. Qui-gon would have been perfect at that. Under his teaching, Anakin would have become the true Chosen One. Perfectly balanced in the Force, immensely powerful, and free from the faults of the modern Jedi Order. This true Anakin would have identified and destroyed the Sith before their plans could be realized.
I believe this is what the Force intended to happen. Or perhaps, what the Light Side intended. But the Sith, the Rule of Two, Darth Bane's legacy - they were too strong. Or rather, just strong enough to make that one change. To make that one kill. After Qui-gon was dead, the door was open to corrupt the Chosen One. And Palpatine being the master that he is, succeeded in doing exactly that.
makes no sense.
Can you PLEASE do a video about what happened to Anakins star fighter? Like what happened to it after mustafar??
Well since Anakin flew it.... It blew up.
I think he modified it into his TIE
Fernex It’s kinda stupid to turn your ship into a whole other instead of just making the new one from scratch
Close, but not entirely true. Ever notice how close in appearance the later Jedi Starfighters were to the TIE's? I do believe that much of the technology involved with the Jedi Starfighters went into the work on the TIE Advanced and TIE Defender series, especially since those craft were both extremely agile, had shields and more firepower than that of the basic bitch TIE Fighter spam, which were designed solely with the idea of quantity over quality.
Someone found it on storage wars...😋
what relationship did thrawn have with vader
Darth Pug 2 words booty call
Far Habah gg
Respect and Rivalry. they had a mutual respect for each other but Thrawn sought to outdo Vader and surpass him.
*WHAT IF:* On the Clone Wars episode where obi wan goes under cover as Rako Hardeen, Dooku says if the Republic doesn't meet his demands once they kidnap Palpatine, they would kill him, what if this had happened and Palpatine faked his death therefore becoming Lord Sidious full time.
Such an event would result in the Republic collapsing completely under a renewed assault by the Separatists. However, Anakin may never have been coerced into siding with Palpatine as he would never have moved to confront the Sith himself.
In the event, the Republic would fall, and the Rebel Alliance would be forged under the banner of Onderon, with Republic loyalists and the Jedi becoming the new timeline's version of the Alliance
Order Sixty-Six would never be given since there would be nobody with the authority to give it, and thus the clones will support their Jedi generals and the remaining Republic figureheads. It would become a Galactic Civil War without an effective government. The Jedi would militarize and take the fight straight to the CIS, without the Republic being able to stop them.
What if fives lived
Ryal Bot yes do this
Ryal Bot nah what if 99 lived xD
I think it would be better "What if Anakin had believed what Fives said about Order 66"
Obi-wan: here anakin have a snickers, your extra angry when you are hungry.
Anakin:(chomp)
Obi-wan:better?
Anakin:better.
A topic I'd like to see: What if Obi Wan Kenobi defeated Darth Vader on the Death Star?
SAMCRO JT Fan bye bye episode 5 and 6
what if anakin healed from his injuries later on and didnt need a suit anymore
Nissim Dana Im no doctor but I don’t think legs and lungs grow back
In a few books and other comics I read that he did in fact begin to heal. However, its said that Palpatine designed his suit and cybernetics in a specific way to hinder him forcing Vader to become too reliant on his suit, so that he would never become too strong that he could directly oppose and defeat Palpatine. - This is actually something I quite like since it just makes Vader even cooler, how despite the hindrance he still kicks ass.
Another one goes he only just barely started to heal in Rogue One (As a Sith he was pretty much self taught, Palps left him to dry most of the time), in addition bunch of stuff happened that hindered his efforts (left for weeks on a planet after Death Star 1 got kekked).
Still, considering all the battles he was injured in, especially the 20 years between III and IV, he coulda looked much worse when his mask was taken off in VI.
@Akina What books and comics are you refering to? The only one that comes to mind is Darth Vader and the Lost Command where he can temporarily survive without his mask due to his rage.
ToreDL87 "Got kekked" lmao
I know responce videos aren't really your thing, but I'd like to see you address Mr. Plinketts points in his Reviews. Red Letter Media makes some good points, but they are unfair in places, and I'd like to see those issues addressed.
While I do believe that it’s a slippery slope when it comes to resurrecting long-dead actors via cgi, I confess to being delighted to see Peter Cushing’s likeness used for Tarkin in Rogue One. The actor who did the voice & the physical acting did a fine job, and I personally appreciated the continuity that was maintained by having Cushing’s features “painted” over his.
I’d always wondered about whether Tarkin knew of Vader’s true, former identity; this pretty much definitively answers that.
As always, SWT, thank you. You’re a true-blue fan & an amazing person. I deeply appreciate all your work. How & why Lucasfilm hasn’t already hired you is beyond me, but their loss is our gain! May the Force be with you - always!
What if the rebellion didn't receive the plans for the death star?
"directed by George Lucas"
What would happen if Galen Erso decided to remain loyal to the empire and sabotage the rebels?
That would be a good twist...what if the Empire fed disinformation to the Rebels in order to ferret them out?
What if Kylo Ren didn't kill Han?
Jesse Singh then Harrison Ford would sigh, frustrated that he'd essentially be obligated to return
I love how Rouge One Credits Krenic for the death star yet in Tarkin it was his idea and the Death star was being built before the events of Rouge One, Hell the plans for it were thought of during the Clone Wars yet noone seems to talk about this.
Yes and no. Tarkin give him ideas which he did and krennic got ideas for construction from looking at the moon i assume
Could you talk about why Han didn't believe in the Force?
Would be interesting stuff to show in the Han Movie...Maybe the Jedi disappointed him. I read something about the possibility of Quinlan Vos being in the movie..I think Han must have been born in the old republic so the Jedi could have been around and possibly couldn't save i dunno his fam or something...Looking forward to find out next spring
there's literally millions of planets in a galaxy. the jedi were a religious cult. depending on where you grew up in the galaxy, chances are probably extremely high that many systems have never even heard of jedi before, or thought they were just "folk tales", or "legends".
Yes thats where my thought comes from....of course he hadn't seen the force....but there could have been a Jedi who wasn't able to do the things Han expected him to do, which possibly triggered his scepticism...or he just didnt believe in the force because he was to young to meet any Jedi and therefore didnt know anything about it....thats pretty realistic as well...but id love to see the Jedi disappointment theory :D
What if Luke had struck down Vader and joined Palpatine and turned to the darkside in Return of the Jedi.
then I think he would probably be the snoke character in this trilogy
Outcome is kind of explained in Episode V, when Luke enters the Cave/Tree. He off's Vader's head, it explodes and inside - Luke takes Anakin's face.
It's treason then!
Milan Kostić No....that scene was foreshadowing that Luke was Vader's son, it was showing that they are connected somehow...
ReaperCaliber It was also showing Luke his potential to join the dark side. Luke takes the fast track through his training which Yoda warns him is the way of the dark side.
After all the Politics, romance, senates, and, *high grounds*
I’m dead 🤣
😂😂😂😂
Tarkin was always my favorite character and I spent many hours perfecting an imitation of him and his speeches from my Star Wars storybook record as a child. I'm sure my parents found it very strange to have a seven-year-old reciting in a clipped British accent monologues about destruction of hidden rebel bases!
I liked the CGI reconstruction of Peter Cushing although immediately I clearly knew it was fake because I knew he had passed; my friend when asked about it said she thought "he looked really good for his age"! So I think it filled its role in convincing most people that didn't know how old that actor would be, and didn't jump out as fake except to those people who knew he had passed away or knew he would be 125 years old if he were alive. Thanks for your thoughtful videos! I don't always agree but I always enjoy!
I thought the "You, my friend, are all that's left of their religion" line in the original movie made that pretty clear …….
Please do: What if Anakin had the highground?
Or another suggestion: What if admiral akbar(or basically any rebel leader) would have died at the beginning of the galactic civil war.
Elias Wöginger he's covered in previous videos topics like "What if Anakin won the duel" or "What if Anakin wasn't so badly injured", that essentially answers the same.
Could you do a video about the Force Awakens lightsaber theory made by 'Jon In Theory'? I think it's an interesting topic. :)
Also, I'm fine with the Tarkin CGI in Rogue One. I think there should have been less of it, though.
CG is just a tool. They created a very, very credible Tarkin in Rogue One. So convincing that a lot of people didn´t even realize, he was not real. They´ve put a lot of dedication and love into the work. Kudos deserved!
I would had rather liked more use of prosthetics and a bit of CGI touch ups for Tarkin, Guy Henry already had a quite similar face to Peter Cushing, but I dont mind CGI Tarkin at all. Since the Premier it looked good to me, the only problem I have now with it its his eyes, they look too...bright, like videogame/crystal eyes, at least for me. But for sure I LOVED Tarkin in Rogue One, I remember when the movie was just announced and there was a rumor going on (even listed on Wikipedia) about Tarkin being on the movie thanks to CGI, but later there was not sight of what I saw, so I gave up hope on it. Boi o boi, I was so excited and losing it when I saw him on the cinema haha. The more Tarkin the better!! (After all, Star Wars has been always a way to bring up advancements and discoveries to the industry of cinema, OT with practical effects, PT with the early stage of CGI and RO with bringing back to life old actors with impressive results.)
And for the topic that you could talk about that I find interesting is:
What if Darth Sidious accepted Maul and Savage to join him back in The Clone Wars?
I know theres the rule of 2 that Sidious followed, and that he already had plans on turning Anakin to the Dark Side, but this could be an interesting scenario, they could had ''fastened'' the process on Sidious plans by having two ''Sith assassins''on his side.
Great videos as always, and remember, MTFBWY:)
Was Peter Cushing tall? Because Guy Henry seemed to tower over Krennic in their scenes.
Aparently for what I could get from Internet, Peter Cushing was 1.82 mts, meanwhile Guy Henry is 1.93 mts. Interesting, Tarkin has always been a tall guy for me, but I didnt noticed this while watching Rogue One, good catch there!
Tarkin CGI is awesome, I'd love to see more of that type of things in movies overall. So that characters can be portrayed and not the actor playing the character.
What if Padme witnessed Anakin burn on Mustafar, How would she react to it and Obi Wan??
PLEASE!!!!!!
Omg yes
That scene in Rogue One is a hype moment, to see the Wilhuff Tarkin on screen again was awesome.
@00:27 _He's not dead....and stop calling me Shirley_
What if Obi Wan saw the battle take place between Maul, Savage & Sidious (DEW IT)
killaka786 Yes! please do this one!
I think that is not canon anymore :/ Altho if he did Sidious would kill him and that's it i think :P
It is in the animated clone wars series => It IS canon.
All completed content from the "Star Wars: Clone Wars" series (And accompanying movie) remained intact as part of the Disney Canon. Ahsoka, Rex, Gregor and Saw Gerrera made the jump into the Rebels series, and Saw Gerrera even made the jump into the live action movie "Rogue One".
What if the empire went with quality over quantity
@@clankerspanker8905 why?
@@davidhatcher7016 Germany during the second world war focused mainly on the quality of their weapons. Its a big reason why they lost like they did. Research and over engineering.
@@clankerspanker8905 how So?
@Nam Trần Hải no more like the CIS to be frank, now the CIS had some damn good droid models for more specialized military operations but their frontline soldiers were very "quantity over quality"
The novel is wrong.
Vader: He is here.Tarkin:
Obi wan kenobi? What makes you think so?
Vader: A tremor in the force. The last time I felt it was in the presence of my old master.
Tarkin: Surely, he must be dead by now.
Vader: Don’t underestimate the force.
Tarkin: The Jedi are extinct. Their fire has gone out in the universe. You my friend, are all that’s left of their religion.
The conversation acknowledges that Tarkin knows Kenobi was Vader's old master. And CloneWars establishes that Tarkin knows Anakin was Kenobi's padawan. Therefore he knows they're the same person.
He could only doubt this if he thinks Kenobi had more than Anakin as a padawan but his first conclusion would be that they're the same person.
You should do what if Padme broke up with Anakin
Danny O'Neil I spy with my little eye yet another goofy fanfic....
This wouldn't really be goofy
Danny O'Neil she did in the clone wars tv show
Then he would bang Ahsoka?
I love tarkin in rogue one
what if the ewoks pushed the empire back to corisaunt and built the death rock to hurl rocks at them from orbit
Great video! :)
Okay, here's the one I want to see: exactly what would Palpatine have done if Padme had lived, but everything else was the same?
I've never seen a video that was on this exact topic. There are a couple theorizing about what would have happened if Anakin had won the fight with Obi-Wan AND Padme also lived. But I don't think anybody has really gone into detail about what Palpatine would have done and what would have happened if she hadn't died, but nothing else had been different-- Anakin still had all the injuries, etc. Would Anakin still have fallen completely to the dark side? What about his relationship with Obi-Wan? What about the rebellion? What about the rest of the Jedi? Luke and Leia? How would the scenario play out if Palpatine had been trying to kill her in the first place vs. if her death was basically a coincidence? Etc, etc, etc. I think this topic needs to be explored in a video.
What if Padme was never queen of naboo?
Aaron Parsons She'll always be the queen of NaBOOB! Badumchi
What would happen if anakin saved his mother
I think he did this already.
would love to see more information on the grey Jedi and why the Jedi and seith hate them
Would love to win the novel! My topic is: just how much did Anakin understand what was happening to him near the end of the prequel trilogy?
We saw three solid attempts by him to try and stop what was happening: when he talks with Padme in their apartment, when he meets with Yoda, and the last time he speaks with Obi-Wan before turning to the Dark Side (and also, to a degree, after killing the Tuscan Raiders). I've always thought about what he was *truly* thinking during these moments.
Thanks for your great work!
What if Dooku never turned to the dark side? I think everything would have changed had Dooku remained a Jedi.
Did the dark side have bad effects on vader? If so how?
CommandoInvert check out his previous videos, he's talked about this stuff before
great video. I would be interested in knowing what happened to the clones Caminos after after all the Clones were done and then the Stormtroopers come about thank you and please keep up the great work. also I would be interested in getting a copy of that book thank you
As always ur vids are great. I love watching ur older stuff (older to me anyways) and yes Tarkin in Rogue One was needed and I thought done very well. I love ur channel. May the force be with you
Topic for next vid: Do blasters need ammo??
:=)
What happened if Jyn or casian from rogue one survived? Please do this theory.
What if? they werent all thst special
Ben W I agree with that question
What if palpatine was found by the Jedi as a boy
I don't know of anything specific you should cover, but I would love to hear more about Tarkin, he's one of my favorite characters
Did Rex have the order 66 chip
Who was stronger in the force/ light Saber fighting anakin clone wars time or Luke return of the Jedi time
all of the clones had it.. but Rex and co removed it after what happened to Fives..
Yes but he had it removed along with his men and they didn't participate in order 66.
Little known fact (you guys might know it anyway tho lol.) Captain Rex was in Return of the Jedi. He is seen as one of the people invading the Empire's shield generator on Endor. Pretty neat.
I'd like to hear about what happened to the clone trooper deserter that mated with that Twi'lek girl and created two half-breeds(Which really shoudln't be possible seeing as how different the people two are even with the similiarities, even Neanderthals which are basically humans were almost not compatible and it's believed that only a few of them could with us).
MRBlackfatrat and here we are. Virtually all of humans alive today (outside of Africa) descend from those Homo sapiens and Neanderthals that interbred all those years ago. Pretty cool I think
What if the republic didn't have the Clone army.
Hey man, love the channel. I had an idea for an episode, how come none of the separatist leaders pointed out the fact that all the clones were a dead ringer for Jango Fett? They definitely saw him without his helmet and with Count Dooku a lot! Just a thought, keep up the awesome work man