I absolutely love the Selle Anatomica. I have them on most of my bikes. They're heavy but I think the comfort is worth it. At least to me. It's the only saddle I can be in all day without getting sore.
Kate still has it and only put about 200 miles on it. I’m trying to decide if I want to give it a go or sell it. I may do a long ride or two on it before deciding.
What works for one person not always works for an other. Since doing longer rides I started to hate the Volt, finding it painful to my sit bones and numbing while riding in the drops. Guess a saddle with a cutout would be a better option for me.
I ride a brooks c13 143 carved on my cross bike and a repente quasar on my road bike (both steel frames) . I was complete surprised about the repente saddle. I never have hear before from this saddle brand but saw a review on road cc.they say: very good comfort, 170 g light, titanium rails, top quality made in italy and 90-100€ very cheap for a high quality light road saddle made in europe... I have this saddle for 2 years now use it with all kind of pants and in every weather. This saddle still looks like new, is super comfy and light....I like the brooks too (looks better 😅)but the repente is my best saddle so far...
I use a stem from SR Suntour ( - Spiral shock dampener saddle post, adjustable damping force, SP12 NCX 50mm shock length, Ø 27,2x350mm post, black version (can get them in aluminium finish), can get them in various widths for various frames also thicker than this one). And on it I use a aluminium bridged saddle. With survives it...perfectly fine, even for some down hilling a bit even without use of dropper, must say I don't travel 10K miles on it, so maybe that is a reason. But some longer rides. And without back packs. With a backpack leads to needing a much stronger upgrade to other materials like shown in the video indeed. Yet I don't want to say anything really bad about aluminium, it is made for a specific application though, which is correct I guess. But it without it is sure enough resistible is my experience But I am not a stunt driver, more like a MTB traveler/tour/gravel/with here and there a more challenging surface is all. Saying my idea of aluminium is more or less based, on what kind of rides you want it to use it on, what it's maximum capacity must be to carry, how comfortable it has to be, how long and varied the rides are, the more dependable it needs to be, just like with off road, and heavy terrains, unexpected routes, etc. It depends on what and how your ride your bike, what type of bike, and the load. I will personally add that I like it to have good looks as well. I often use a brooks or a Selle Italia, leather saddle. Always fine, just needs a cover on it when it rains, which ways a 4.something grams.
I finally settled on the Brooks England B17 Carved (the one with the carved hole and stitching). I just haven't found anything as comfortable (right from the start even before breaking in) and it is relatively light. I previously had the Brooks B17 without the carved hole and I really can't tell any difference between the two. I cycle in a more upright position and find this type of saddle suits this style very well. I recommend either of the B17s.
Seats are inherently difficult as the good ones can be expensive and you usually need to ride them a while to know if right for you. The sit bone cardboard trick seems clever. Will give it a try. What did you and Kate think about the stock saddle on the Diverge? I was surprised how small it looks.
I’ve spent WAY too much on saddles that didn’t work for me. Hopefully this video will get riders closer to what works before spending the money like I did. That stock saddle gave Kate a lot trouble. Mostly because it’s designed with men in mind. She did one long ride on it and decided to find a different option.
Great video. Balanced approach to the broad discussion of saddles. I have a Brooks B17 on my gravel bike, and like it. Considering a cambium c17 for my road bike. Been curious about them for a while. What did you think about the cambium?
Positive and negatives to both. I like the Cambium because there is no break-in period-no sore butt for the first 500 miles like you get with leather, but the overall comfort just doesn’t equal that of a leather saddle.
I got a question for all those fellow bike tourers who use a leather saddle. I know that you are supposed to protect the saddle from rain by placing a cover on it when leaving the bike outside. But what about riding in bad weather? Do you have to protect the saddle while riding through rain or snow?
Weather does damage leather and it is ideal to prevent rain and snow from getting on a leather saddle, but moisture damage takes longer than one would think. damage occurs when you leave leather in the rain or snow long-term. Store your bike with a leather saddle indoors and use a protectant like Brooks Proofide. When you are a on a ride in the rain or snow, wipe down the leather after the ride. If you are on a multi-day tour or long adventure, put a saddle cover or plastic bag on the leather when you are done riding for the day. In 2016, I rode from Anacortes, WA to to Madison, WI with a Brooks B17. The first three days in the Pacific Northwest lived up to it's rainy reputation. I'm still using that same leather saddle today because of the way I cared for it.
I have the same size and color wolverine. I also have two Cambiums, and both feel like sitting on a brick. Once a year I swap them on to my bikes just to see if my butt has changed.
I bought a Cambium when it first came out. It was so comfortable, but it got destroyed by a car. These new ones just aren’t the same. How have you spec’d your Wolverine?
Are you talking about the montage that begins at 0:49? Yeah, I swapped out three different saddles to create this effect. I didn't actually ride like that. My Brooks C17 is positioned perfectly when I'm not messing around to create a video effect.
THis means a lot to me. Thanks! I'm going to get back to creating videos on here soon. Lot's of life happened that got in the way of creating content. I'm looking forward to getting back at it soon.
@@GreatEgretAdventure I remember you from when I rode the Northern Tier, 2016. You started about two weeks before me but had to stop, I forget why. I've since ridden the Southern Tier, and half of the Great Divide. Hope you're doing well. Happy trails!
@Mike-vd2qt hey Mike! I remember you too! Good to see you on here! I’ve followed a few of your other adventures on IG. Happy trails to you too, my friend!
I have the preconceived impression that all serious cyclists wear cushioned shorts. So I presume this entire video presumes cushioned shorts. You never addressed cushioned shorts, so I am left doubting everything you said.
Never assume anything unless someone states it. I never presumed anyone watching this video would or would not wear a chamois. Unless you’re on a trials bike, everyone that rides a bike uses a saddle. Not everyone uses cycling shorts. Also known as chamois. Any ride equal to or shorter than my 8-mile commute to work, I don’t wear them. It’s just not necessary. I wear chamois if the situation requires it. That is to say only on long rides. There are riders that have won the Tour Divide that have placed 1st in their category and in the top 10 overall that never were chamois. Are these riders not “serious riders”? I don’t differentiate between “serious rider” and other riders. Wearing chamois does not make a rider a serious rider. Getting on a bike and pedaling, no matter what a rider is wearing, makes them a serious rider.
![Oasis - Oasis Live '25 [Official Trailer]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/gol_JnuEtKM/mqdefault.jpg)
Brilliant tip on how to measure your sitbones!
Quickest, easiest, and best of all cheapest method of doing it!
I absolutely love the Selle Anatomica. I have them on most of my bikes. They're heavy but I think the comfort is worth it. At least to me. It's the only saddle I can be in all day without getting sore.
Kate still has it and only put about 200 miles on it. I’m trying to decide if I want to give it a go or sell it. I may do a long ride or two on it before deciding.
I'm a fan of brooks but another favorite is the wtb volt. Inexpensive, durable, options for carbon rails, it's been a great saddle!
The Volt is the trifecta saddle. Inexpensive, comfortable, and durable. I’ve had my butt on more Brooks than any other saddle. I love ‘em!
@@GreatEgretAdventure you can't go wrong with the brooks that's for sure!
What works for one person not always works for an other. Since doing longer rides I started to hate the Volt, finding it painful to my sit bones and numbing while riding in the drops. Guess a saddle with a cutout would be a better option for me.
@@kingfonk1937 agreed, I haven't used a saddle with a cutout but I do agree not all saddles work for everyone!
I ride a brooks c13 143 carved on my cross bike and a repente quasar on my road bike (both steel frames) . I was complete surprised about the repente saddle. I never have hear before from this saddle brand but saw a review on road cc.they say: very good comfort, 170 g light, titanium rails, top quality made in italy and 90-100€ very cheap for a high quality light road saddle made in europe...
I have this saddle for 2 years now use it with all kind of pants and in every weather. This saddle still looks like new, is super comfy and light....I like the brooks too (looks better 😅)but the repente is my best saddle so far...
I use a stem from SR Suntour ( - Spiral shock dampener saddle post, adjustable damping force, SP12 NCX 50mm shock length, Ø 27,2x350mm post, black version (can get them in aluminium finish), can get them in various widths for various frames also thicker than this one). And on it I use a aluminium bridged saddle. With survives it...perfectly fine, even for some down hilling a bit even without use of dropper, must say I don't travel 10K miles on it, so maybe that is a reason. But some longer rides. And without back packs. With a backpack leads to needing a much stronger upgrade to other materials like shown in the video indeed. Yet I don't want to say anything really bad about aluminium, it is made for a specific application though, which is correct I guess.
But it without it is sure enough resistible is my experience But I am not a stunt driver, more like a MTB traveler/tour/gravel/with here and there a more challenging surface is all. Saying my idea of aluminium is more or less based, on what kind of rides you want it to use it on, what it's maximum capacity must be to carry, how comfortable it has to be, how long and varied the rides are, the more dependable it needs to be, just like with off road, and heavy terrains, unexpected routes, etc. It depends on what and how your ride your bike, what type of bike, and the load. I will personally add that I like it to have good looks as well. I often use a brooks or a Selle Italia, leather saddle. Always fine, just needs a cover on it when it rains, which ways a 4.something grams.
I finally settled on the Brooks England B17 Carved (the one with the carved hole and stitching). I just haven't found anything as comfortable (right from the start even before breaking in) and it is relatively light. I previously had the Brooks B17 without the carved hole and I really can't tell any difference between the two. I cycle in a more upright position and find this type of saddle suits this style very well. I recommend either of the B17s.
Good choice! I’ve been using the B17 Carved for seven years now. I love it!
And what about the flyer?
Personally, Brooks B17 but I guess anything leather would work as they mold to you - after the first 250 painful miles.
I've used all of those listed, except the Specialized. Current favorite is an ISM PR saddle (noseless).
As strange as those ISM PR saddles look, they make a lot of sense and look really comfortable. I’d like to get my butt on one.
Enjoyed the video! Keep it up :)
Thanks, Joff! That means a lot to me!
Still haven't found the perfect saddle yet but the Brooks Swift and Wittkopp Medicus were the best so far.
Sometimes it’s really difficult to find what works. I use different saddles on different bikes. Frame geometry really can change how a saddle feels.
Marvelous
Seats are inherently difficult as the good ones can be expensive and you usually need to ride them a while to know if right for you. The sit bone cardboard trick seems clever. Will give it a try. What did you and Kate think about the stock saddle on the Diverge? I was surprised how small it looks.
I’ve spent WAY too much on saddles that didn’t work for me. Hopefully this video will get riders closer to what works before spending the money like I did. That stock saddle gave Kate a lot trouble. Mostly because it’s designed with men in mind. She did one long ride on it and decided to find a different option.
Great video. Balanced approach to the broad discussion of saddles. I have a Brooks B17 on my gravel bike, and like it. Considering a cambium c17 for my road bike. Been curious about them for a while. What did you think about the cambium?
Positive and negatives to both. I like the Cambium because there is no break-in period-no sore butt for the first 500 miles like you get with leather, but the overall comfort just doesn’t equal that of a leather saddle.
I got a question for all those fellow bike tourers who use a leather saddle. I know that you are supposed to protect the saddle from rain by placing a cover on it when leaving the bike outside. But what about riding in bad weather? Do you have to protect the saddle while riding through rain or snow?
Weather does damage leather and it is ideal to prevent rain and snow from getting on a leather saddle, but moisture damage takes longer than one would think. damage occurs when you leave leather in the rain or snow long-term. Store your bike with a leather saddle indoors and use a protectant like Brooks Proofide. When you are a on a ride in the rain or snow, wipe down the leather after the ride. If you are on a multi-day tour or long adventure, put a saddle cover or plastic bag on the leather when you are done riding for the day. In 2016, I rode from Anacortes, WA to to Madison, WI with a Brooks B17. The first three days in the Pacific Northwest lived up to it's rainy reputation. I'm still using that same leather saddle today because of the way I cared for it.
I have the same size and color wolverine. I also have two Cambiums, and both feel like sitting on a brick. Once a year I swap them on to my bikes just to see if my butt has changed.
I bought a Cambium when it first came out. It was so comfortable, but it got destroyed by a car. These new ones just aren’t the same.
How have you spec’d your Wolverine?
Whoa, that saddle on the SOMA slammed forward? Maybe a bike fit is in order.
Are you talking about the montage that begins at 0:49? Yeah, I swapped out three different saddles to create this effect. I didn't actually ride like that. My Brooks C17 is positioned perfectly when I'm not messing around to create a video effect.
Miss your videos man. I hope you’re still enjoying some rides though
THis means a lot to me. Thanks! I'm going to get back to creating videos on here soon. Lot's of life happened that got in the way of creating content. I'm looking forward to getting back at it soon.
At 2:46 I swear I recognize the southwest commuter trail 😁
You got it! Madison is a wonderful place.
I need 1 to stop my ass bone aching like a mother. Especially on the second half of a journey.
Did anyone told you that you have the voice of… Steve Jobs? Just that you know. Great voice and great comments.
You are now the third person over two RUclips channels in the last few years to tell me that. There might be something to that.
@@GreatEgretAdventure At some point in the video, I could NOT let it go! I could not UN-hear it 😀
I used a various saddles in my life, none that made me enjoy riding bicycles. I hate saddles despite I love cycling.
I definitely can relate to that.
Got epilepsy at .50
Yeah, not my best work. I agree
Brooks B-17
I have a B-17 on my touring bike. Darn comfy!
More than the flyer?
The flyer is nice, but I think the springs on it are overkill. There are better ways to dampen road chatter.
@@GreatEgretAdventure I remember you from when I rode the Northern Tier, 2016. You started about two weeks before me but had to stop, I forget why. I've since ridden the Southern Tier, and half of the Great Divide. Hope you're doing well. Happy trails!
@Mike-vd2qt hey Mike! I remember you too! Good to see you on here! I’ve followed a few of your other adventures on IG. Happy trails to you too, my friend!
That image transitioning in the video was annoying.
Yeah, not my best work.
I have the preconceived impression that all serious cyclists wear cushioned shorts. So I presume this entire video presumes cushioned shorts. You never addressed cushioned shorts, so I am left doubting everything you said.
Never assume anything unless someone states it. I never presumed anyone watching this video would or would not wear a chamois. Unless you’re on a trials bike, everyone that rides a bike uses a saddle. Not everyone uses cycling shorts. Also known as chamois. Any ride equal to or shorter than my 8-mile commute to work, I don’t wear them. It’s just not necessary. I wear chamois if the situation requires it. That is to say only on long rides.
There are riders that have won the Tour Divide that have placed 1st in their category and in the top 10 overall that never were chamois. Are these riders not “serious riders”?
I don’t differentiate between “serious rider” and other riders. Wearing chamois does not make a rider a serious rider. Getting on a bike and pedaling, no matter what a rider is wearing, makes them a serious rider.
I rode over the Rockies from Calgary to Vancouver wearing either a pair of Levis with the leg rolled up or a pair of cutoff Dickies work pants.
@christophermcdowell9063 you sir, are a badass!