I have no problem being loyal to America and Philippines... Many proud Filipinos have served in the United States Military.. l am one of them.. Born Philippines and grew up USA...
Dual citizenship is legal and accepted by both US and Philippines by virtue of agreement. Whether it is moral, really should not be an issue because the term is subjective. I'm a dual citizen of the US and Philippines. I immigrated to the US when I was 16 years old through my parents. I've served the US military for 23 years, placing my life in harms way and participated in four wars. I was also in law enforcement for 7 years, after my military career, and I was disabled in the line of duty. I've served my community where I lived in the US for 43 years. What's wrong if I decide to retire in the Philippines and spend the rest of my life serving Filipinos this time? So, I dare anyone to challenge my loyalty. Can't one be loyal to both one's wife and children at the same time? Is is immoral? @Philippine Retirement & Travels: Sir, there's really no point justifying your decision of becoming a dual citizen to myopic minded people. Thanks for your insights!
Same here. I served in the U.S Army for 14 years and was force out because of Reduction in Force(RIF). I was deployed to the war zone in Iraq. I am planning to acquire my dual citizenship because I am retiring next year at the age of 62. I have a total of 30 years of government service but going back to my roots is not being a traitor. A traitor is not willing to sacrifice themselves for their country. I already done that. Thanks for clarifying that, sir. Comment from a Gulf War Veteran. Big Red One. 1st Inf. Div.
Thank you both for your service. I'm 40 years old and serving in my 18th year in the military. I have actually never heard of being a dual citizen as a negative thing. I'm afraid he is taking someone's comment to serious. There's racist jerks everywhere, especially here on RUclips. We just need to learn how to ignore them. I met my soulmate (Filipina) in Saudi Arabia, of all places and I plan on retiring in the Philippines. I have several years to go but the sooner the better ;)
It is not really legal because the US govt has no law stating that you are allowed to have dual citizenship and it is wrong to say mutual agreement between govt because there really no such agreement. the US govt has no law allowing you to have dual citizenship or require a person to choose one nationality or another. . Having dual citizenship could be or is a loophole in taking away your citizenship though the US govt has not really paid attention to it but again it is a loophole.. Mind you that the oath for Pilipino citizenship you renounce your citizenship to your present citizenship just as the same as you take oath for your US citizenship.
The intent of Balikbayan or dual citizenships law in the Philippines is to encourage former Filipinos to return home for ecomic reasons.(posibly) The other reason is to bring back those skills learned from other countries and put them to use in the Philippines.
First citizenship is not by choice of the holder but by parents. Dual citizenship is by choice to take advantage of the laws of the countries as a citizen.
@BadBoyJR Yup. My parents are both Dominican and born in DR so they are Dual citizens because they moved to the US and had me. My parents got their US citizen after they immigrated. I'm a US citizen because I was born in America by default. Because my parents are both Dominican, I can also become a Dominican citizen! I just need to get my Cedula(Dominican ID) and a few other things. I have all my documents. I want to open a Bank Account in DR so I just need my Cedula. I have the rest I need. It's a good thing to be Dual Citizenship. Im a proud 🇩🇴Dominican but not a 🇩🇴 citizen. I don't feel complete unless i'm a citizen! Everyone from my family supports me.
"PERFECTLY" legal and moral? I disagree! It's a complex subject and to say it is "perfectly" legal and moral is a gross over simplification! Complex subjects have complex answers. It's not simple, and to question what country one gives their true loyalty to is indeed a legitimate question.
I am an Indian by birth and American by choice. Love all your videos. I am so fascinated with your presentations and the crisp, clear explanations you provide with some humor. Thank you and keep up the good work Sir. Have a terrific day!
You always have really good information and discussions. LOL...funny about being called a traitor, as you mentioned when ILLEGAL immigrants come here with NO intention of assimilation and are here 20 years an never even attempt to make themselves legal. Glad to have had you here sir in the USA for the past 40 years...Legally. Enjoy your Retirement. The Philippines is an awesome country, especially in Faith. God bless you sir.
You made me reach the conclusion to become a dual citizen. Thank you Sir! We can tell that you are an educated Filipino. God bless you and your family.
I worked so many years here in the USA. I didn’t think of becoming a naturalized citizen before, but later I realized, I owe so much to this country in terms of giving me the opportunity to build my dreams and reach my goals. As a token of appreciation I decided to become an American citizen, and renounced my citizenship as a Filipino. I am now retired but the thought of having a dual citizenship doesn’t cross my mind. It doesn’t make sense to me. I will remain an American citizen. My allegiance and loyalty is now for America. Not that I have forgotten my roots and heritage. A part of me being a Filipino by heart is still there. We must not forget where we came from. But having two allegiances and loyalties to two countries doesn’t really work for me. I have to be loyal and keep my allegiance to only one country of my citizenship. I can come and visit the Philippines and respect and obey the laws and authority as just like before.
thank you for taking the time to do this...my wife has been in the US for 9 yr....worked hard,paid into the system..(income tax)...been able to send $$ back home.ph...but has not wanted to give up ph ciz.ship....has talked about dual....now i have enough info to help her get it done...thanks man!!
l was born in Germany in 1947 to a German mother and English father. lt was shortly after the war ended and my parents were unmarried at the time of my birth, so l was born a german. However, 7 months later they married and both my mother and l lost our german nationality and aquired the British one. l have lived in the UK all my life but for around 2 decades have been trying to get dual nationality as l am obviously both, but with little success. However, now, due to a very recent change in the law, l have a very good chance of getting it and l am so happy. l FEEL both german and english, and by blood l AM both. To deny anyone in similar circumstances their birthright is like asking them " who do you love most, your father or your mother" !! An impossible question to answer !!!
I bet my bottom dollar that if the government ask that person to pick up a gun, go in battle and fight and die for his country, he would coward down. Don't let stuff like this get into you, sir. We have so many Arm Chair Warriors these days. I am in the service myself and I have no problem with people getting dual citizen.
Well said. We’re on the same point where being a US citizen for almost 45 years now since Nixon time. I missed my motherland and it’s always gonna be in my heart forever. So it’s reasonable & convenient. Thank you!
Very well explained Grandpa!👍tama lang na mayroong law at binigyan tayo ng karapatan na makakuha tayo ng dual citizenship. Yan ang gagawin ko ngayon for my retirement and enjoy traveling back home no worries 😍 be positive not negative! be grateful ang thankful that they give us this opportunity to be back home and enjoying our stay 👍🤗 for those people who are not favor for this law that is your choices and opinions! God Bless everyone !🙏❤️
Resident Pinoys are generally rabid about dual citizenship for a Filipino. I don’t find it amongst other countries citizens. I think it is just jealousy of the residents. Respect Po!
Sometimes some people are closed minded (its their way or the highway). They claim to be inclusive as long as you stay in their lane. We cannot change their minds with logic or facts kaya its better na be knowledgeable about dual citizenship para we can act appropriately just in case magkaroon ng conflict. I'm glad you covered this topic. Thank you po.
I'm a dual Citizen and I love it. Both Countries makes ma proud, i was raised and molded in the Philippines and my employer here in the US is benefiting from it as i work really hard because i grew up having nothing, so i don't take for granted all the great opportunities that are given to me. :)
Continue what you are doing Sir Danny! You are considered a great motivational speaker and thumbs up for that! You are wise and experienced and a mentor to us.
well done , as I am an American planning on become an expat to the Philippines . With marriage and possibility of kids, This had me worried . Thank You
There are several situations in the US where dual citizenship is not allowed: 1. You work in a Federal agency where your role requires SECRET clearance 2. You work at a Federal contractor (example, Lockheed-Martin) where your role requires SECRET clearance 3. You are running for or occupying a political position (classic example of Ted Cruz renouncing his Canadian citizenship) 4. You are a commissioned officer in the US military (foreign enlisted personnel currently serve in the military)
Correct... one will have to make a choice.... to retain those 4 categories or pursue dual citizenship. Of course, if you are not retirement age, it's a no brainer choice... but once you've reach retirement age and is thinking of retiring in the Philippines, the weight of dual citizenship option tilts more favorably...
What is important is you are abiding the laws in both countries...pay tax in both countries...loyal to both countries..I see no problem being a dual citizen .
If some of the transaction ca be done thru online, why then worry of having a physical address, like the Credit Cards. SSS pension can stay here in U S Banks and just withdraw in the Philippines, to avoid multiple charges (ATM fees) just withdraw it at once and deposit it in you're Ph bank account.
Physical address because some of them are a bit uneasy about using a PO Box. You can do as you wish if it will work for you. But it is likely that one of them be it a bank, credit card, Social Security, insurance, etc. will have an issue with a PO Box. The fact that you can do transactions online does not negate the fact that they may need to know where you are actually located. By the way, I understand that you can have your Social Security checks mailed to you directly to the Philippines. I understand there is also an office in the Philippines and forms specifically for Filipinos. Some people may prefer to leave some money in the US, while others may want 100% to go to the Philippines. So it's all up to you. This is the reason why I'm hesitant to make a video about this. Because this all depends on what one wants to do and how to do it. Cheers.
@robertnepomuceno There are multiple challenges on the scenario you want to advocate as follows: * most banks have a limit for ATM withdrawals (it varies by bank). Also, most banks normally charge a hefty fee for ATM withdrawals. * if you deposit a foreign check in the Philippines, it common practice by the PH banks to hold your funds for up to 30 days * @PhilippineRetirement&Travels actually did an extensive video on this matter ruclips.net/video/l0Wj922a7n4/видео.html
Hi.. its very interesting all your information.. I am a follower bec I have Family leaving in the US. Good to hear Differnt topics everytime I watch your blog. Thanks .. 🙏 hoping more information.. its keep me updated Take care and be safe.. 😍
I love your videos please continue the good work of helping your Kababayans understand dual citizenship. I am planning to get mine this year, wish me luck. More power to you
@Philippine Retirement & Travels Hi Danny, Once again, you delivered a very informative topic to better understand this subject of multiple nationality. Let me add a few more features (re Multiple Citizenship) which are practically not feasible to relay in less than 30 mins of discussion. I use the word "multiple" instead of dual because there is a minority of US citizens who have acquired more than 2 citizenship. First. The US-Philippines relationship is very unique when it comes to Dual Citizenship. As a former US colony/territory, the Philippines is privilege to possess certain advantages unlike most countries. Even before the passage of R.A. 9225 aka Citizen Retention and Reacquisition Act of 2003, some Filipinos were allowed to join the US military... a very unique arrangement between sovereign nations. This unique relationship played a major role in finally adopting the retention/re-acquisition of Philippine citizenship by the Philippine Congress. If one will pay very close attention to RA 9225, the title is not "Dual Citizen Act of 2003". Why? Because of the dynamic debate in the Philippine Congress (before it became law) between those who are "for" and those who are "against" the passage of the law. As a compromise, RA 9225 was renamed to what it is now. Second. Another feature of RA 9225 is the provision of "derivative citizenship" as quoted below... "Under the principle of derivative citizenship, unmarried children below eighteen (18) years of age, whether legitimate, illegitimate, or adopted, of those who reacquired their Philippine citizenship under this law shall also be deemed Filipino citizens. A child who is 18 years of age or older at the time of the parent’s reacquisition of Philippine citizenship, but was born when either parent was still a Filipino citizen, shall be considered to have been a natural born Filipino and may apply for reacquisition of Philippine citizenship on his/her own behalf." Third. Surely, the continuous retirement of Fil-American "baby boomers" and other Filipino descent retirees all over the world will create an economic impact to the Philippines. According to recent surveys, there are at least 200k retired Fil-Americans who have intentions to retire in the Philippines. However, the most significant obstacle to making those intentions into reality is the portability of their Medicare coverage to the Philippines. Although there are certain work around approaches, the process is still tedious (in reference to my recent private email to you on this subject matter).
I have a natural born Filipino friend who is now a U.S.citizen living on disability insurance worth $700/mo. in the U.S. I told my friend that you can't live a good life with that amount there and instead why not live here with that money here in the Philippines in order for my friend to live a better life. Your thoughts and advice on this matter would be appreciated sir, thank you, Mr. J. Dadivas
Best to ask the office making disability payments directly. Another is to keep a U.S. residence active and simply use the Philippines as a "vacation" place. Have your disability remittances to a U.S. bank account and make a transfer to the Philippine bank yourself. Just a thought.
I know a lot of Philippine women who have married US servicemen or other US men formerly involved in businesses in the Philippines. I am a US national by birth. I wonder if upon divorce or some other separation between these married individuals in the US, the women return to the Philippines. One of the women at my bank is a Philippine born person married to a US citizen. I often ask her about going to the Philippines to retire and she says absolutely, with enthusiasm. She says without hesitation, that I would love it there.
Having dual citizenship is like having your two parents, you receive the best from them and love them equally. I believe that really the big problem would be if the countries that you are citizen of have conflicts. At that point, I really believe that one's has to decide which one to keep and be 100 percent loyal to that one.
I am dual citizen, every time I travel to the Philippines I am presenting my 2 passports. Entering and leaving Philippines. Only presenting 2 passports in the Philippines. Entering other countries I am only presenting 1 passport.
I lost my PH citizenship 5 yrs ago when I did pledge of allegiance and become US citizen. And now getting Dual? will think about it, thanks for your explanations.
I'm planning to go back to the phil. on June 1, 2021. I'm a dual citizen. But my problem is I've lost the original copy of the certificate of Retention and I only have a copy of it. Is it sufficient or acceptable to show to the Immigration at the airport? Do I need to get it notarized or is there is another way of securing a certified true copy of the Certificate of Retention? I only have 4 months to go to before my flight to the phil. Thank you for your help.
You can apply for a certified true copy of your Certificate BUT it has to be at the same consulate where you became a dual citizen. The fee was $25 around 4 years ago; it might have gone up.
I have a co worker who’s a Canadian and US Citizen. Negative people just needed to be noticed because nobody cares about them. Best thing to do is to ignore them.
Hey, great videos and I love the content. I'm a US citzen born here and my parents are from here (no blood ties back to the Philippines). My understanding is it's not possible to get dual citzenship as a US citzen in the Philippines? I'm only 27 and I am mostly surrounded by Filipinos and really enjoy the culture and I'm looking ahead at retiring in the Philippines but want to have property there, however it sounds like this isn't possible without giving up my US citizenship?
That is correct. You will need to be a Filipino citizen originally, or with parents who was once a Filipino when you were born. The only way you can get Filipino citizenship is by applying after 10 years, or 5 years if married to a Filipino. Also, you will have to give up your U.S. citizenship.
That was my thought when I first heard about dual citizenship, the loyalty issue. Because once a person becomes a naturalized citizen of any country one pledges allegiance to the new acquired country.
Grandpa, about "taxation" do we have to pay our taxes to both, (double taxed)? Please, explain, what taxes are being required by us to both countries, like what?
Hi,,one question,,I know that Indonesia doesn't accept dual citizenship, when you become a citizen in Indonesia, you renounce any other citizenship,,of cause, in this case,,USA doesn't care , renouncing USA citizenship takes a long process, so they don't care about words while becoming a citizen in another country,,,,,,my question,,im a usa citizen, if I become an Indonesian citizen, how can I travel with two passports, if not , which passport would be best to use to avoid problems,,,lets say,,I want to go back home, USA,,,I cant use the Indonesian passport because the usa won't just give me a visa, but if I use my usa passport,.on my return to Indonesia, if I usa the usa passport again,,than since I live Indonesia, my Indonesian visa would expire,,,,and if I come back from the usa with the Indonesian passport, and later I want to visit the usa again I won't be able to use my usa passport because the visa has been expired,,,,can you please advise me on a strategy on how to use both passports,,I know that there has to be an smart way to do this,,thanks
Use the passport that gives you the best benefit. That's why you are dual. I don't know about Indonesia, but just understand the law differences between countries. I have a vlog on how this is handled in the Philippines. Here's the link to my channel. ruclips.net/channel/UCYU70S4jYvhw0BOetMFdD6Avideos
@@vloggergrandpa2707 thanks,, the problem is if I travel with the usa passport back home and I return back to indonesia with the same usa passport,,than I may find my self in a difficult situation, since I'm planning to stay one year ,that means that my entry visa from usa would expire long before the year end.......
If you are citizen of both US and Indonesia, and you have passport in both countries, you will not usually need a visa. I don't understand the question.
@@vloggergrandpa2707 ok,,if I go to the usa with my usa passport, I have to come back to indonesia with my usa passport,,by doing that,,I only have 60 days visa in Indonesia and than I have to go back to usa,,,if I was to show my Indonesian passport together with the usa,,than I could get fines,,and even the revocation of my citizenship, I know there is away to use both passports with out having a problem,,I red something about leaving one passport in Malaysia with a friend and continue with the other passport,,I dint get a chance to read the whole thing
My granduncle now a retiree in the US. "CLAIMED"(not reclaimed) his FILIPINO CITIZENSHIP sometime after 2003 i guess and suggested ro his siblings and their kids and grandkids that they do the same because it's their BIRTHRIGHT.... He and his siblings were born in the PHILIPPINES of an AMERICAN father and FILIPINO mother...
@@vloggergrandpa2707 Growing up they were made to understand-think that they are American Citizens because of their American Father. When he and some of his siblings migrated to the U.S. they went there as American Citizens already. So when these laws touching about citizenship were passed he claimed his Filipino Citizenship as well. That is just my layman's understanding sir. 😂 Basta, he is Dual Citizen 😊
So true about America lolo! I love the great country of America. I’m an American Citizen since I was 5. However, I am also loyal to my native country the Philippines. As long as we abide by the law, forget what the hypocrites say 💪😎🇺🇸🇵🇭
If your itinerary is going to Vietnam from the Philippines and then to the US, it means your going back home to the mainland, and your Vietnam trip will only be like a long stop over so you must use your US passport all the way.
Hello again! I don't have my dual citizenship yet, but if I do, can it affect my family's plan to travel to the Phillipines next year as well as visit Japan for a week on our way back to the US? Also, I am now working at a Federal Hospital in the US. Will this affect my duel citizenship if I apply for one? Thanks again!😊
We don't watch CNN, Fox,MSNBC and other fake media. Thank you for all the info.. I have 10 years more to go to retire. As being Filipino US citizen how long I am allowed to stay in the Philippines??
Patty Stephens what calling us a users I came to the United States legally and work for so many years and was deducted every pay check for the social security purposes and paid my taxes every year even I’m I already retired right now so is that you called a users ? I have a dual citizenship and planning to retire in the Philippines and will continue to pay my tax every year in the USA so still calling me a users?
Hello! I am planning to apply for dual citizenship after coming here to the US by marriage and naturalized as a US citizen since 1997. I have two children, 18 and 23 years of age, and same husband. My question is when I apply for a dual citizenship, where can I do it from Virginia and also, could my husband and kids apply it with me for dual as well? We plan to retire in 10 years or less from now. We would like to be able to visit in the Phillipines during that time and to come back here in the US when we want to. Can it be possible for me and my family to do that? I really will appreciate your comments and I do enjoy watching your videos! Salamat po!👍😊🤩
You can apply for dual citizenship. Your husband cannot because dual citizenship is only granted to "former" Filipino citizens. I assume that your children were born in the U.S. At least one parent (meaning, you) should be a *_Filipino Citizen at the time of birth of each child_* . If one of your child (the 18 year old) meets that requirement, he will be considered born Filipino and you simply have to file a Report of Birth. He can then apply for Philippine passport and considered a dual citizen.
@@vloggergrandpa2707 thank you so much sa reply nyo po!😊 Napakalaking bagay na maitulong po sa mga kagaya ko na wla masyadong kaalaman tungkol sa mga immigration laws.😊 Salamat ng marami... So may age limit pala to consider for my kids. Anyway, where can we apply from Virginia? Also, I'm hoping na may videos din kayo about benefits pag dual citizen ka or not and how to own a property sa Pinas or pwede ba? Salamat po uli!🙂 More power sa mga vlogs nyo po Sir!👍🤩
You may want to check with the Philippine Consulate. My understanding is that dual citizenship is only granted to those who were formerly Filipino Citizen but lost citizenship due to naturalization. Your children don't meet this test. I was hoping that they will be considered born Filipino citizen at time of their birth. But, since mother and father were both American citizens at the time of their birth, I feel they don't meet this requirement either. I would encourage you to talk to the Philippine Consulate just to be sure. And, let me know what happens. Here's the list of consular offices with jurisdiction where you live: www.philippinessanfrancisco.org/philippines-sf/consulate-finder-sf/
How are you accused of being a traitor when you pay the US taxes from retirement even when living abroad? The guy that told you this is just miserable.
My family members are US citizens for over 260 years. In the 1980's and 1990's my brother and and his US citizen wife were missionaries in the Philippines. While in the Philippines there daughter was born in San Fernando La Union. I first met his daughter at five years old. She spoke English, Tagalog and Ilocano. My question is, is my niece a natural born filipina? Please explain.
If I understand correctly all parties here are Americans. But the subject were talking about is the child who was born in the Philippines and spoke English, Tagalog, and Ilocano. My understanding is that citizenship in the Philippines is established by blood and not by birth. Therefore, my guess is that she will not be considered a Filipino citizen although she could apply for naturalization after 10 years of residence. I think it's best for you to discuss this with the immigration office. Maybe there's something else they can do that I am not aware of.
Thanks for the reply. I thought that my be the answer. I myself am marred to a filipina for 28 years who is a dual citizen. Also my daughter is a dual citizen.
It is impossible to be US citizens for over 260 years since the US has only been around for 243 years. Before July 4, 1776, your ancestors were subjects of the British Empire. Too bad they did not allow dual citizens back then. 8-)
@richardcamp Allow me to add a relevant history to this discussion. Filipinos in the United States mainland began its presence in the late 1500's in California and Louisiana via the Philippine-Acapulco galleon trade. So technically, Filipinos were part of the early settlers in America just like the Europeans. Source: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Filipino_Americans
Whoever that person was who called Filipinos "traitor" by becoming a US citizen, has to know what is the real definition of "traitor". He has a very narrow definition of the word.
How come Duterte, he's a Filipino and yet a TRAITOR by allowing China to claim the islands in west Philippines little by little without "Barking" loud as he does against the Catholic Church and its clergy.
Hu U 2 say DU30 s a traitor? Open ur eyes how the Philippines is evolving to b a First World country. Be apolitical wd ur Comment as Bob does. I admire those Filipinos who were once the group of the BRAIN DRAIN and now availing of the Retirement Law. At least they are NOW sharing their savings to the Philippines as required by the Law. Unlike others, who remained in the US til their twilight years. Please include in your bucket lists to share NOW your blessings. Salamat po ng marami.
@@paididoy Allow me to qualify your statement... no country that I know of has "officially" declared that they allowed China to claim and allowed to establish a military base at the disputed islands... (unless you have knowledge or proof ). The facts: None of the countries in South East Asia would dare wage war against China's military might. Only the United States has the means and military might to counter the Chinese aggression... unfortunately, the USA was negligent and did not prevent China from building a military base in the Spratly islands.
Hi Good day. Do you have any knowledge regarding US Citizens born in the Philippines? Does it immediately make me a dual citizen? I really need your help please.
The nationality law of the Philippines is based on Jus Saguinis (right of blood). So you could only be a FIlipino citizen if either of your parent is a Filipino citizen at the time of your birth, regardless of where.
I would like to share this, my husband as a us citizen works in the law enforcement agency. He cant apply for a dual citizenship while actively serving the US police force. This is even when US and Phil has a good relationship.
I wonder if the Philippine Embassies or consulates would know if one has obtained a foreign citizenship. I was told they wouldn't have a record of that. If that's the case, then one can renew an expired Philippine passport, say for example in the US, without having to apply for dual citizenship or reacquiring Philippine citizenship first.
@Canis Paco I believe you are asked that question when you apply for your passport. What happens when you lie? You can try it to find out! You may be banned from entering the Philippines the rest of your life. So why risk it when it's so easy to get a legal one? After the pandemic, of course.
One of the documentary requirements to renew a PHL passport at the consulate by a permanent resident is his green card. You will not be able to present this since you surrendered your green card when you became a naturalized citizen.
currently that is he ony way I can go to the philippines. american citizen i cannot go to PI under covid restricktens withiut my wife having dual citizen she cant even go as she is currently a naturalized citizen of US
i naturalized in 2006, after getting my US passport, i renewed my philippine passport and to seal the deal for dual citizenship i paid $50 at the philippine consulate in los angeles back in 2011 to get a 3 page document which i present together with my 2 passports whenever i leave or enter the philippines.
give it to them gramp you're correct legally & morally. I'll take my hard earned money to where its treated the best! I am researching Chile & Colombia, Puerto Rico and many tax friendly countries. I ruled out Philippines as tax friendly
I’m a dual citizen of Canada and Phil. And I agreed with what The Engineer said to Miss Saigon: “If you want to die in bed, don’t care too much of country...”
As long as they were born after 1973, all they have to do is to file a Report of Birth since they do not have a birth certificate in the Philippines. They could then get a Philippine Passport.
This is a gray area. No question that they are Filipino citizen. However, to avoid headache on your children's part in the future, you might want to consult with Philippine Immigration and inquire if you need to file a Recognition Certificate because, I assume, that they got their U.S. Passport AFTER they already had the Philippine Passport. If you applied for Philippine Passport AFTER they already had a U.S. Passport, did you disclose that they possess the U.S. passport. There should have been a question to this effect on the application. Again, I would double check with the Philippine Immigration to be sure.
@@MyLifeMyTravelsMyAdventures Yes, that's true. I'm automatically Filipino Citizen too since my mom was still a Filipino citizen when I was born in the US. So this is not my choice but I'm happy that I have dual citizenship automatically. Not all Asian countries are nice enough to give dual citizenship.
@@sidlee7205 sorry to break the news... dual citizenship is not automatic... you still have to apply for it and go through the process... the good news is.. it normally just takes a day to do it at any Philippine consulate.
@MarGallardo & @PhilippineRetirement&Travels The IRS accepts online filing of taxes. You may do it yourself or have a US licensed tax preparer do it for you. US Licensed tax preparers can entertain your tax issues via video (skype, messenger, facetime etc).
Whats their to love if the corruption is piled so high you cant see over it, there isnt anything there except ,small pay, expensive living for that pay, cheap girls, and red horse
@Christopher Nelson Open your eyes. The corruption in US is so much more severe and open. Not only from politicians, but from the media itself. Just watch CNN! There's corruption anywhere you go. It's just the extent of it and how open it is being done.
good morning po Sir! Gusto ko lamang pong malaman o magtanong ' Puwede po bang mag stay na permanently ang isang pilipino na US Citizen at isa rin pong filipino citizen ( dual ) sa Philippines na hindi na po kinakailangang bumalik na ng America. Mag stay na po permanente sa Pilipinas at doon na lang po niya tatanggapin ang kaniyang benepisyo ( SS Pension sa US ) sa Pilipinas. Maraming Salamat po.
@@vloggergrandpa2707 thank you po Sir. Tama po ba Sir na kung hindi ako dual ay kinakailangan kong bumalik ng US before six months o before one year para hindi maapektuhan ang citizenship ko, ganoon din po ang ss pension? Maraming Salamat po muli.
@@ramongamir3676 I thought you said you are dual? If you are not dual, you must follow what the Philippine immigration gives you when you enter the country as to the amount of time you can spend in the Philippines. It should not affect your SS. Just be careful not to overstay in the Philippines.
What happen now that the Manila embassy is closing.where do we get our dual citizenship,and what is needed if I to go home to the Philippines what kind of paperwork that I need to take from USA.
The US Embassy in Manila is NOT closing down. It is just the CIS (Citizenship and Immigration Services) department that was shut down. The CIS in several other foreign countries are also being shut down. The official reason is 'low workload' but others claim that it is really a part of the Trump administration's efforts to make it more difficult for chain migration.
![Insurance for Dual Citizens and Foreigners who are retired overseas [About Advantage Plan]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pv_clqrJ8ew/mqdefault.jpg)
I have no problem being loyal to America and Philippines... Many proud Filipinos have served in the United States Military.. l am one of them.. Born Philippines and grew up USA...
Dual citizenship is legal and accepted by both US and Philippines by virtue of agreement. Whether it is moral, really should not be an issue because the term is subjective. I'm a dual citizen of the US and Philippines. I immigrated to the US when I was 16 years old through my parents. I've served the US military for 23 years, placing my life in harms way and participated in four wars. I was also in law enforcement for 7 years, after my military career, and I was disabled in the line of duty. I've served my community where I lived in the US for 43 years. What's wrong if I decide to retire in the Philippines and spend the rest of my life serving Filipinos this time? So, I dare anyone to challenge my loyalty. Can't one be loyal to both one's wife and children at the same time? Is is immoral? @Philippine Retirement & Travels: Sir, there's really no point justifying your decision of becoming a dual citizen to myopic minded people. Thanks for your insights!
Same here. I served in the U.S Army for 14 years and was force out because of Reduction in Force(RIF). I was deployed to the war zone in Iraq. I am planning to acquire my dual citizenship because I am retiring next year at the age of 62. I have a total of 30 years of government service but going back to my roots is not being a traitor. A traitor is not willing to sacrifice themselves for their country. I already done that. Thanks for clarifying that, sir. Comment from a Gulf War Veteran. Big Red One. 1st Inf. Div.
Thank you both for your service. I'm 40 years old and serving in my 18th year in the military. I have actually never heard of being a dual citizen as a negative thing. I'm afraid he is taking someone's comment to serious. There's racist jerks everywhere, especially here on RUclips. We just need to learn how to ignore them. I met my soulmate (Filipina) in Saudi Arabia, of all places and I plan on retiring in the Philippines. I have several years to go but the sooner the better ;)
Respect to you and your family l hope your life is good.
Thank you for your service to my adopted country. God bless you and your family!
It is not really legal because the US govt has no law stating that you are allowed to have dual citizenship and it is wrong to say mutual agreement between govt because there really no such agreement. the US govt has no law allowing you to have dual citizenship or require a person to choose one nationality or another. . Having dual citizenship could be or is a loophole in taking away your citizenship though the US govt has not really paid attention to it but again it is a loophole.. Mind you that the oath for Pilipino citizenship you renounce your citizenship to your present citizenship just as the same as you take oath for your US citizenship.
The intent of Balikbayan or dual citizenships law in the Philippines is to encourage former Filipinos to return home for ecomic reasons.(posibly) The other reason is to bring back those skills learned from other countries and put them to use in the Philippines.
I love your channel! Short intro, informative, honest and to the point.
First citizenship is not by choice of the holder but by parents. Dual citizenship is by choice to take advantage of the laws of the countries as a citizen.
@BadBoyJR Yup. My parents are both Dominican and born in DR so they are Dual citizens because they moved to the US and had me. My parents got their US citizen after they immigrated.
I'm a US citizen because I was born in America by default. Because my parents are both Dominican, I can also become a Dominican citizen! I just need to get my Cedula(Dominican ID) and a few other things. I have all my documents. I want to open a Bank Account in DR so I just need my Cedula. I have the rest I need. It's a good thing to be Dual Citizenship.
Im a proud 🇩🇴Dominican but not a 🇩🇴 citizen. I don't feel complete unless i'm a citizen! Everyone from my family supports me.
It is perfectly legal and moral. Anybody saying otherwise is just envious of people who can. Life is never fair.
Of course, they do not have any good arguments and are just bad people and stupid
"PERFECTLY" legal and moral? I disagree! It's a complex subject and to say it is "perfectly" legal and moral is a gross over simplification! Complex subjects have complex answers. It's not simple, and to question what country one gives their true loyalty to is indeed a legitimate question.
I am an Indian by birth and American by choice. Love all your videos. I am so fascinated with your presentations and the crisp, clear explanations you provide with some humor. Thank you and keep up the good work Sir.
Have a terrific day!
You always have really good information and discussions. LOL...funny about being called a traitor, as you mentioned when ILLEGAL immigrants come here with NO intention of assimilation and are here 20 years an never even attempt to make themselves legal. Glad to have had you here sir in the USA for the past 40 years...Legally. Enjoy your Retirement. The Philippines is an awesome country, especially in Faith. God bless you sir.
0
Great to hear what you had to say to refute others question of "loyalty."
Bumped on your video. Very informative to dual citizens. I am enjoying my retirement here in the Philippines since 2007. Carry on.
You made me reach the conclusion to become a dual citizen. Thank you Sir! We can tell that you are an educated Filipino. God bless you and your family.
I worked so many years here in the USA. I didn’t think of becoming a naturalized citizen before, but later I realized, I owe so much to this country in terms of giving me the opportunity to build my dreams and reach my goals. As a token of appreciation I decided to become an American citizen, and renounced my citizenship as a Filipino. I am now retired but the thought of having a dual citizenship doesn’t cross my mind. It doesn’t make sense to me. I will remain an American citizen. My allegiance and loyalty is now for America. Not that I have forgotten my roots and heritage. A part of me being a Filipino by heart is still there. We must not forget where we came from. But having two allegiances and loyalties to two countries doesn’t really work for me. I have to be loyal and keep my allegiance to only one country of my citizenship. I can come and visit the Philippines and respect and obey the laws and authority as just like before.
thank you for taking the time to do this...my wife has been in the US for 9 yr....worked hard,paid into the system..(income tax)...been able to send $$ back home.ph...but has not wanted to give up ph ciz.ship....has talked about dual....now i have enough info to help her get it done...thanks man!!
You do an excellent job giving us information on the PH. Do not let the trolls get you down!! Thanks for the video!
l was born in Germany in 1947 to a German mother and English father. lt was shortly after the war ended and my parents were unmarried at the time of my birth, so l was born a german. However, 7 months later they married and both my mother and l lost our german nationality and aquired the British one. l have lived in the UK all my life but for around 2 decades have been trying to get dual nationality as l am obviously both, but with little success.
However, now, due to a very recent change in the law, l have a very good chance of getting it and l am so happy. l FEEL both german and english, and by blood l AM both. To deny anyone in similar circumstances their birthright is like asking them " who do you love most, your father or your mother" !! An impossible question to answer !!!
im loyal to USA ... my heart belongs to the Philippines.
I bet my bottom dollar that if the government ask that person to pick up a gun, go in battle and fight and die for his country, he would coward down. Don't let stuff like this get into you, sir. We have so many Arm Chair Warriors these days. I am in the service myself and I have no problem with people getting dual citizen.
U.S and Philippines have some kind of agreement to pick up U.S citizen who are wanted in U.S
Well said. We’re on the same point where being a US citizen for almost 45 years now since Nixon time. I missed my motherland and it’s always gonna be in my heart forever. So it’s reasonable & convenient. Thank you!
Very well explained Grandpa!👍tama lang na mayroong law at binigyan tayo ng karapatan na makakuha tayo ng dual citizenship. Yan ang gagawin ko ngayon for my retirement and enjoy traveling back home no worries 😍 be positive not negative! be grateful ang thankful that they give us this opportunity to be back home and enjoying our stay 👍🤗 for those people who are not favor for this law that is your choices and opinions! God Bless everyone !🙏❤️
Being a dual citizen is not Being a traitor.
To have a dual citizen is a personal choice and not coerced. Much more not a traitor.
Resident Pinoys are generally rabid about dual citizenship for a Filipino. I don’t find it amongst other countries citizens. I think it is just jealousy of the residents. Respect Po!
Sometimes some people are closed minded (its their way or the highway). They claim to be inclusive as long as you stay in their lane. We cannot change their minds with logic or facts kaya its better na be knowledgeable about dual citizenship para we can act appropriately just in case magkaroon ng conflict. I'm glad you covered this topic. Thank you po.
I'm a dual Citizen and I love it. Both Countries makes ma proud, i was raised and molded in the Philippines and my employer here in the US is benefiting from it as i work really hard because i grew up having nothing, so i don't take for granted all the great opportunities that are given to me. :)
Economically and Filipino traits and close family relationship are most valuable assets one country can be proud of.
I did research before I decided to be dual citizen and it was done here in US at the Philippine Embassy.
maraming Salamat po Sir at napakarami po ninyong taong matutulungan.
Loyalty is not coming from citizenship it come from a person of morality and values to be loyal and general
Continue what you are doing Sir Danny! You are considered a great motivational speaker and thumbs up for that! You are wise and experienced and a mentor to us.
Thank you so much for your valuable information! 👍🏻
God bless you always!
well done , as I am an American planning on become an expat to the Philippines . With marriage and possibility of kids, This had me worried . Thank You
I am a retired US military with a pension and also a dual citizen of the Philippines. I asked the US Military if I lose my pension they said no.
thank u so much for giving us knowledge cz Mabuhay !!!! PILIPINAS /USA
There are several situations in the US where dual citizenship is not allowed:
1. You work in a Federal agency where your role requires SECRET clearance
2. You work at a Federal contractor (example, Lockheed-Martin) where your role requires SECRET clearance
3. You are running for or occupying a political position (classic example of Ted Cruz renouncing his Canadian citizenship)
4. You are a commissioned officer in the US military (foreign enlisted personnel currently serve in the military)
Correct... one will have to make a choice.... to retain those 4 categories or pursue dual citizenship.
Of course, if you are not retirement age, it's a no brainer choice... but once you've reach retirement age and is thinking of retiring in the Philippines, the weight of dual citizenship option tilts more favorably...
What is important is you are abiding the laws in both countries...pay tax in both countries...loyal to both countries..I see no problem being a dual citizen .
just an fyi... for foreigners and/or dual citizens, only income derived from the Philippines are taxable in the Philippines.
thanks I appreciate your comment
Yes to both, it’s legal and moral
If some of the transaction ca be done thru online, why then worry of having a physical address, like the Credit Cards. SSS pension can stay here in U S Banks and just withdraw in the Philippines, to avoid multiple charges (ATM fees) just withdraw it at once and deposit it in you're Ph bank account.
Physical address because some of them are a bit uneasy about using a PO Box. You can do as you wish if it will work for you. But it is likely that one of them be it a bank, credit card, Social Security, insurance, etc. will have an issue with a PO Box. The fact that you can do transactions online does not negate the fact that they may need to know where you are actually located. By the way, I understand that you can have your Social Security checks mailed to you directly to the Philippines. I understand there is also an office in the Philippines and forms specifically for Filipinos. Some people may prefer to leave some money in the US, while others may want 100% to go to the Philippines. So it's all up to you. This is the reason why I'm hesitant to make a video about this. Because this all depends on what one wants to do and how to do it. Cheers.
@robertnepomuceno
There are multiple challenges on the scenario you want to advocate as follows:
* most banks have a limit for ATM withdrawals (it varies by bank). Also, most banks normally charge a hefty fee for ATM withdrawals.
* if you deposit a foreign check in the Philippines, it common practice by the PH banks to hold your funds for up to 30 days
* @PhilippineRetirement&Travels actually did an extensive video on this matter
ruclips.net/video/l0Wj922a7n4/видео.html
On the flip side, it would be wonderful to be able to become a Philippine citizen!
Hi.. its very interesting all your information.. I am a follower bec I have Family leaving in the US.
Good to hear Differnt topics everytime I watch your blog.
Thanks .. 🙏 hoping more information.. its keep me updated
Take care and be safe.. 😍
I love your videos please continue the good work of helping your Kababayans understand dual citizenship. I am planning to get mine this year, wish me luck. More power to you
Good luck!
@Philippine Retirement & Travels
Hi Danny, Once again, you delivered a very informative topic to better understand this subject of multiple nationality. Let me add a few more features (re Multiple Citizenship) which are practically not feasible to relay in less than 30 mins of discussion. I use the word "multiple" instead of dual because there is a minority of US citizens who have acquired more than 2 citizenship.
First. The US-Philippines relationship is very unique when it comes to Dual Citizenship. As a former US colony/territory, the Philippines is privilege to possess certain advantages unlike most countries. Even before the passage of R.A. 9225 aka Citizen Retention and Reacquisition Act of 2003, some Filipinos were allowed to join the US military... a very unique arrangement between sovereign nations. This unique relationship played a major role in finally adopting the retention/re-acquisition of Philippine citizenship by the Philippine Congress. If one will pay very close attention to RA 9225, the title is not "Dual Citizen Act of 2003". Why? Because of the dynamic debate in the Philippine Congress (before it became law) between those who are "for" and those who are "against" the passage of the law. As a compromise, RA 9225 was renamed to what it is now.
Second. Another feature of RA 9225 is the provision of "derivative citizenship" as quoted below...
"Under the principle of derivative citizenship, unmarried children below eighteen (18) years of age, whether legitimate, illegitimate, or adopted, of those who reacquired their Philippine citizenship under this law shall also be deemed Filipino citizens.
A child who is 18 years of age or older at the time of the parent’s reacquisition of Philippine citizenship, but was born when either parent was still a Filipino citizen, shall be considered to have been a natural born Filipino and may apply for reacquisition of Philippine citizenship on his/her own behalf."
Third. Surely, the continuous retirement of Fil-American "baby boomers" and other Filipino descent retirees all over the world will create an economic impact to the Philippines. According to recent surveys, there are at least 200k retired Fil-Americans who have intentions to retire in the Philippines. However, the most significant obstacle to making those intentions into reality is the portability of their Medicare coverage to the Philippines. Although there are certain work around approaches, the process is still tedious (in reference to my recent private email to you on this subject matter).
Thank you.
Great points!
I have a natural born Filipino friend who is now a U.S.citizen living on disability insurance worth $700/mo. in the U.S. I told my friend that you can't live a good life with that amount there and instead why not live here with that money here in the Philippines in order for my friend to live a better life. Your thoughts and advice on this matter would be appreciated sir, thank you, Mr. J. Dadivas
Answered above.
How can my friend get its disability benefit money monthly from the US to the Philippines? Thanks
Philippine Retirement & Travels: How can my friend get its disability benefit money monthly from the US to the Philippines? Thanks
Best to ask the office making disability payments directly. Another is to keep a U.S. residence active and simply use the Philippines as a "vacation" place. Have your disability remittances to a U.S. bank account and make a transfer to the Philippine bank yourself. Just a thought.
Much love & respect to your opinion ✌️
I know a lot of Philippine women who have married US servicemen or other US men formerly involved in businesses in the Philippines. I am a US national by birth. I wonder if upon divorce or some other separation between these married individuals in the US, the women return to the Philippines. One of the women at my bank is a Philippine born person married to a US citizen. I often ask her about going to the Philippines to retire and she says absolutely, with enthusiasm. She says without hesitation, that I would love it there.
Having dual citizenship is like having your two parents, you receive the best from them and love them equally. I believe that really the big problem would be if the countries that you are citizen of have conflicts. At that point, I really believe that one's has to decide which one to keep and be 100 percent loyal to that one.
Great point! Few here are thinking about a "what if" scenario.
I am dual citizen, every time I travel to the Philippines I am presenting my 2 passports. Entering and leaving Philippines. Only presenting 2 passports in the Philippines. Entering other countries I am only presenting 1 passport.
Grandpa , I'm a filipino but im a citizens here in USA .can i stay 4months in the Philippines without any problem? Im planing to visit soon.
I lost my PH citizenship 5 yrs ago when I did pledge of allegiance and become US citizen. And now getting Dual? will think about it, thanks for your explanations.
I'm planning to go back to the phil. on June 1, 2021. I'm a dual citizen. But my problem is I've lost the original copy of the certificate of Retention and I only have a copy of it. Is it sufficient or acceptable to show to the Immigration at the airport? Do I need to get it notarized or is there is another way of securing a certified true copy of the Certificate of Retention? I only have 4 months to go to before my flight to the phil. Thank you for your help.
You can apply for a certified true copy of your Certificate BUT it has to be at the same consulate where you became a dual citizen. The fee was $25 around 4 years ago; it might have gone up.
I have a co worker who’s a Canadian and US Citizen. Negative people just needed to be noticed because nobody cares about them. Best thing to do is to ignore them.
Hey, great videos and I love the content. I'm a US citzen born here and my parents are from here (no blood ties back to the Philippines). My understanding is it's not possible to get dual citzenship as a US citzen in the Philippines? I'm only 27 and I am mostly surrounded by Filipinos and really enjoy the culture and I'm looking ahead at retiring in the Philippines but want to have property there, however it sounds like this isn't possible without giving up my US citizenship?
That is correct. You will need to be a Filipino citizen originally, or with parents who was once a Filipino when you were born. The only way you can get Filipino citizenship is by applying after 10 years, or 5 years if married to a Filipino. Also, you will have to give up your U.S. citizenship.
@@vloggergrandpa2707 thank you for taking the time to confirm my thoughts. I will look into other avenues for retiring there then.
But it is your parents born in Philippines?
That was my thought when I first heard about dual citizenship, the loyalty issue. Because once a person becomes a naturalized citizen of any country one pledges allegiance to the new acquired country.
But some U.S. citizen, due to his/her job with the federal government, can't have dual citizenship because of security clearance policy.
Right!
Very informative Thanks for sharing Granpa Godbless
Grandpa, about "taxation" do we have to pay our taxes to both, (double taxed)? Please, explain, what taxes are being required by us to both countries, like what?
@Federico Nevalasca. That is covered in one of my vlogs. Here's the link to my channel. ruclips.net/channel/UCYU70S4jYvhw0BOetMFdD6Avideos
Hi,,one question,,I know that Indonesia doesn't accept dual citizenship, when you become a citizen in Indonesia, you renounce any other citizenship,,of cause, in this case,,USA doesn't care , renouncing USA citizenship takes a long process, so they don't care about words while becoming a citizen in another country,,,,,,my question,,im a usa citizen, if I become an Indonesian citizen, how can I travel with two passports, if not , which passport would be best to use to avoid problems,,,lets say,,I want to go back home, USA,,,I cant use the Indonesian passport because the usa won't just give me a visa, but if I use my usa passport,.on my return to Indonesia, if I usa the usa passport again,,than since I live Indonesia, my Indonesian visa would expire,,,,and if I come back from the usa with the Indonesian passport, and later I want to visit the usa again I won't be able to use my usa passport because the visa has been expired,,,,can you please advise me on a strategy on how to use both passports,,I know that there has to be an smart way to do this,,thanks
Use the passport that gives you the best benefit. That's why you are dual. I don't know about Indonesia, but just understand the law differences between countries. I have a vlog on how this is handled in the Philippines. Here's the link to my channel. ruclips.net/channel/UCYU70S4jYvhw0BOetMFdD6Avideos
@@vloggergrandpa2707 thanks,, the problem is if I travel with the usa passport back home and I return back to indonesia with the same usa passport,,than I may find my self in a difficult situation, since I'm planning to stay one year ,that means that my entry visa from usa would expire long before the year end.......
If you are citizen of both US and Indonesia, and you have passport in both countries, you will not usually need a visa. I don't understand the question.
@@vloggergrandpa2707 ok,,if I go to the usa with my usa passport, I have to come back to indonesia with my usa passport,,by doing that,,I only have 60 days visa in Indonesia and than I have to go back to usa,,,if I was to show my Indonesian passport together with the usa,,than I could get fines,,and even the revocation of my citizenship, I know there is away to use both passports with out having a problem,,I red something about leaving one passport in Malaysia with a friend and continue with the other passport,,I dint get a chance to read the whole thing
Very informative and empowering video! Thank you sir.
Whoever claims being loyal is a crap. Don't get affected by someone's negative and narrow-minded opinion.
My granduncle now a retiree in the US. "CLAIMED"(not reclaimed) his FILIPINO CITIZENSHIP sometime after 2003 i guess and suggested ro his siblings and their kids and grandkids that they do the same because it's their BIRTHRIGHT.... He and his siblings were born in the PHILIPPINES of an AMERICAN father and FILIPINO mother...
Please give me more details. Don't know what you mean "claimed."
@@vloggergrandpa2707 Growing up they were made to understand-think that they are American Citizens because of their American Father. When he and some of his siblings migrated to the U.S. they went there as American Citizens already. So when these laws touching about citizenship were passed he claimed his Filipino Citizenship as well. That is just my layman's understanding sir. 😂 Basta, he is Dual Citizen 😊
What does morality have anything to do with dual citizenship?
So true about America lolo! I love the great country of America. I’m an American Citizen since I was 5. However, I am also loyal to my native country the Philippines. As long as we abide by the law, forget what the hypocrites say
💪😎🇺🇸🇵🇭
If your itinerary is going to Vietnam from the Philippines and then to the US, it means your going back home to the mainland, and your Vietnam trip will only be like a long stop over so you must use your US passport all the way.
And are not citizens of any U.S. Territory citizens of the U.S. too?
Hello again! I don't have my dual citizenship yet, but if I do, can it affect my family's plan to travel to the Phillipines next year as well as visit Japan for a week on our way back to the US? Also, I am now working at a Federal Hospital in the US. Will this affect my duel citizenship if I apply for one? Thanks again!😊
I don't see why it should affect your travel and employment since you are not required to have security clearance by your employer, are you?
@@vloggergrandpa2707 thanks po!😊
Very informative! Thank you sir!
Saw this video by accident. Very timely as I am doing my thesis on dual allegiance vis-a-vis dual citizenship right now.
What is the conclusion of your thesis? Is there a moral issue regarding dual citizenship?
Enjoy!
We don't watch CNN, Fox,MSNBC and other fake media. Thank you for all the info.. I have 10 years more to go to retire. As being Filipino US citizen how long I am allowed to stay in the Philippines??
@Myrna Hall You can go to the Philippines under the Balikbayan Program and stay for a year. If you are dual citizen, you can stay forever.
Very informative..thank you Sir.
Patty Stephens what calling us a users I came to the United States legally and work for so many years and was deducted every pay check for the social security purposes and paid my taxes every year even I’m I already retired right now so is that you called a users ? I have a dual citizenship and planning to retire in the Philippines and will continue to pay my tax every year in the USA so still calling me a users?
Hello! I am planning to apply for dual citizenship after coming here to the US by marriage and naturalized as a US citizen since 1997. I have two children, 18 and 23 years of age, and same husband. My question is when I apply for a dual citizenship, where can I do it from Virginia and also, could my husband and kids apply it with me for dual as well? We plan to retire in 10 years or less from now. We would like to be able to visit in the Phillipines during that time and to come back here in the US when we want to. Can it be possible for me and my family to do that? I really will appreciate your comments and I do enjoy watching your videos! Salamat po!👍😊🤩
You can apply for dual citizenship. Your husband cannot because dual citizenship is only granted to "former" Filipino citizens. I assume that your children were born in the U.S. At least one parent (meaning, you) should be a *_Filipino Citizen at the time of birth of each child_* . If one of your child (the 18 year old) meets that requirement, he will be considered born Filipino and you simply have to file a Report of Birth. He can then apply for Philippine passport and considered a dual citizen.
@@vloggergrandpa2707 thank you so much sa reply nyo po!😊 Napakalaking bagay na maitulong po sa mga kagaya ko na wla masyadong kaalaman tungkol sa mga immigration laws.😊 Salamat ng marami... So may age limit pala to consider for my kids. Anyway, where can we apply from Virginia? Also, I'm hoping na may videos din kayo about benefits pag dual citizen ka or not and how to own a property sa Pinas or pwede ba? Salamat po uli!🙂 More power sa mga vlogs nyo po Sir!👍🤩
You may want to check with the Philippine Consulate. My understanding is that dual citizenship is only granted to those who were formerly Filipino Citizen but lost citizenship due to naturalization. Your children don't meet this test. I was hoping that they will be considered born Filipino citizen at time of their birth. But, since mother and father were both American citizens at the time of their birth, I feel they don't meet this requirement either. I would encourage you to talk to the Philippine Consulate just to be sure. And, let me know what happens. Here's the list of consular offices with jurisdiction where you live: www.philippinessanfrancisco.org/philippines-sf/consulate-finder-sf/
@@vloggergrandpa2707 cge po Sir! Salamat ng marami! 🤩 I'll be following your videos palagi po! God bless!☺
How are you accused of being a traitor when you pay the US taxes from retirement even when living abroad? The guy that told you this is just miserable.
ITS CALLED "BURR UP HIS @SS"
You answered my question about reinstatement of citizenship. Thank you.
My family members are US citizens for over 260 years. In the 1980's and 1990's my brother and and his US citizen wife were missionaries in the Philippines. While in the Philippines there daughter was born in San Fernando La Union. I first met his daughter at five years old. She spoke English, Tagalog and Ilocano. My question is, is my niece a natural born filipina? Please explain.
If I understand correctly all parties here are Americans. But the subject were talking about is the child who was born in the Philippines and spoke English, Tagalog, and Ilocano. My understanding is that citizenship in the Philippines is established by blood and not by birth. Therefore, my guess is that she will not be considered a Filipino citizen although she could apply for naturalization after 10 years of residence. I think it's best for you to discuss this with the immigration office. Maybe there's something else they can do that I am not aware of.
Thanks for the reply. I thought that my be the answer. I myself am marred to a filipina for 28 years who is a dual citizen. Also my daughter is a dual citizen.
It is impossible to be US citizens for over 260 years since the US has only been around for 243 years. Before July 4, 1776, your ancestors were subjects of the British Empire. Too bad they did not allow dual citizens back then. 8-)
@richardcamp Allow me to add a relevant history to this discussion. Filipinos in the United States mainland began its presence in the late 1500's in California and Louisiana via the Philippine-Acapulco galleon trade. So technically, Filipinos were part of the early settlers in America just like the Europeans.
Source: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Filipino_Americans
Whoever that person was who called Filipinos "traitor" by becoming a US citizen, has to know what is the real definition of "traitor". He has a very narrow definition of the word.
Well said.
How come Duterte, he's a Filipino and yet a TRAITOR by allowing China to claim the islands in west Philippines little by little without "Barking" loud as he does against the Catholic Church and its clergy.
Hu U 2 say DU30 s a traitor? Open ur eyes how the Philippines is evolving to b a First World country. Be apolitical wd ur Comment as Bob does. I admire those Filipinos who were once the group of the BRAIN DRAIN and now availing of the Retirement Law. At least they are NOW sharing their savings to the Philippines as required by the Law. Unlike others, who remained in the US til their twilight years. Please include in your bucket lists to share NOW your blessings. Salamat po ng marami.
@@paididoy
Allow me to qualify your statement... no country that I know of has "officially" declared that they allowed China to claim and allowed to establish a military base at the disputed islands... (unless you have knowledge or proof ).
The facts: None of the countries in South East Asia would dare wage war against China's military might. Only the United States has the means and military might to counter the Chinese aggression... unfortunately, the USA was negligent and did not prevent China from building a military base in the Spratly islands.
I am a dual citizen, gusto ko sanang malaman kung Gaano ako puwedeng magstay dito sa Phil .Thank you
As long as you want if you are both a US and Philippine citizen.
@@vloggergrandpa2707 Thanks a lot
Thank you sir, Jose Mari Chan, for the clarification. God bless.
Good day Sir, thank you very much for the complete informations. Happy Easter and God bless.
I have found myself 40 years from now!
THANK YOU VLOPGGER GRANDPA for the information , GOD BLESS you .
Hi Good day. Do you have any knowledge regarding US Citizens born in the Philippines? Does it immediately make me a dual citizen? I really need your help please.
The nationality law of the Philippines is based on Jus Saguinis (right of blood). So you could only be a FIlipino citizen if either of your parent is a Filipino citizen at the time of your birth, regardless of where.
How about travel tax upon leaving the Philippines? US passport holders does not have to pay but Philippine passport holders must.
My knowledge dual citizens are not subject to travel tax provided they do not stay longer than 12 months.
I would like to share this, my husband as a us citizen works in the law enforcement agency. He cant apply for a dual citizenship while actively serving the US police force. This is even when US and Phil has a good relationship.
Hey Mr.Leonardo Manaois Jr why do you have a husband ? Same sex marriage is not recognized yet in the Philippines and that is a huge problem .
Great segment, I have learned a lot from you... thank you so much.
I wonder if the Philippine Embassies or consulates would know if one has obtained a foreign citizenship. I was told they wouldn't have a record of that. If that's the case, then one can renew an expired Philippine passport, say for example in the US, without having to apply for dual citizenship or reacquiring Philippine citizenship first.
@Canis Paco I believe you are asked that question when you apply for your passport. What happens when you lie? You can try it to find out! You may be banned from entering the Philippines the rest of your life. So why risk it when it's so easy to get a legal one? After the pandemic, of course.
One of the documentary requirements to renew a PHL passport at the consulate by a permanent resident is his green card. You will not be able to present this since you surrendered your green card when you became a naturalized citizen.
currently that is he ony way I can go to the philippines. american citizen i cannot go to PI under covid restricktens withiut my wife having dual citizen she cant even go as she is currently a naturalized citizen of US
I thought those with Philippine Passports can go!
I'm a U.S. Citizens, if I retire in the Philippines do I have to pay tax?
I understand I have to pay in US deducted from my SS.
That is covered in one of my vlogs. Here's the link to my channel. ruclips.net/channel/UCYU70S4jYvhw0BOetMFdD6Avideos
i naturalized in 2006, after getting my US passport, i renewed my philippine passport and to seal the deal for dual citizenship i paid $50 at the philippine consulate in los angeles back in 2011 to get a 3 page document which i present together with my 2 passports whenever i leave or enter the philippines.
give it to them gramp you're correct legally & morally. I'll take my hard earned money to where its treated the best! I am researching Chile & Colombia, Puerto Rico and many tax friendly countries. I ruled out Philippines as tax friendly
Dual citizenship is dual loyalty.
OK, but what happens when these two countries are in conflict? Which one are you loyal to then?
@@jasonjames4254 : So if your parents have conflicts, whose side will you take?
I am only loyal to myself and my family and my friends. No exceptions.
I’m a dual citizen of Canada and Phil. And I agreed with what The Engineer said to Miss Saigon: “If you want to die in bed, don’t care too much of country...”
I believe my children are dual, mom is filipina, children born here. I'm American
Got them us passports when they were 2
As long as they were born after 1973, all they have to do is to file a Report of Birth since they do not have a birth certificate in the Philippines. They could then get a Philippine Passport.
@@vloggergrandpa2707 misunderstanding, born in Philippines (here) got them us consular report of birth abroad and us pass ports
This is a gray area. No question that they are Filipino citizen. However, to avoid headache on your children's part in the future, you might want to consult with Philippine Immigration and inquire if you need to file a Recognition Certificate because, I assume, that they got their U.S. Passport AFTER they already had the Philippine Passport. If you applied for Philippine Passport AFTER they already had a U.S. Passport, did you disclose that they possess the U.S. passport. There should have been a question to this effect on the application. Again, I would double check with the Philippine Immigration to be sure.
@@vloggergrandpa2707 I will look into it, we have not gotten Filipino passports for them
Great! Let me know how it goes.
first comment here. not all dual citizenship is by choice some are by birth.
@@MyLifeMyTravelsMyAdventures Yes, that's true. I'm automatically Filipino Citizen too since my mom was still a Filipino citizen when I was born in the US. So this is not my choice but I'm happy that I have dual citizenship automatically. Not all Asian countries are nice enough to give dual citizenship.
@@sidlee7205 sorry to break the news... dual citizenship is not automatic... you still have to apply for it and go through the process... the good news is.. it normally just takes a day to do it at any Philippine consulate.
Im sure you file income tax in US Govt. my question is this can you file income tax in the US embassy in Manila, if you are retire in the Phils.
@MarGallardo & @PhilippineRetirement&Travels
The IRS accepts online filing of taxes. You may do it yourself or have a US licensed tax preparer do it for you. US Licensed tax preparers can entertain your tax issues via video (skype, messenger, facetime etc).
additional info... look for Section under Taxable Income: www.taxesforexpats.com/philippines/us-tax-preparation-in-philippines.html
Majority we come to America to survive but deep in our hearts we love our own native land !
Whats their to love if the corruption is piled so high you cant see over it, there isnt anything there except ,small pay, expensive living for that pay, cheap girls, and red horse
@Christopher Nelson Open your eyes. The corruption in US is so much more severe and open. Not only from politicians, but from the media itself. Just watch CNN! There's corruption anywhere you go. It's just the extent of it and how open it is being done.
good morning po Sir! Gusto ko lamang pong malaman o magtanong ' Puwede po bang mag stay na permanently ang isang pilipino na US Citizen at isa rin pong filipino citizen ( dual ) sa Philippines na hindi na po kinakailangang bumalik na ng America. Mag stay na po permanente sa Pilipinas at doon na lang po niya tatanggapin ang kaniyang benepisyo ( SS Pension sa US ) sa Pilipinas. Maraming Salamat po.
As a citizen of both countries, puede kang mag stay in both countries na walang limit. At ang SS benefit mo sa U.S. ay hindi maaafecto.
@@vloggergrandpa2707 thank you po Sir. Tama po ba Sir na kung hindi ako dual ay kinakailangan kong bumalik ng US before six months o before one year para hindi maapektuhan ang citizenship ko, ganoon din po ang ss pension? Maraming Salamat po muli.
@@ramongamir3676 I thought you said you are dual? If you are not dual, you must follow what the Philippine immigration gives you when you enter the country as to the amount of time you can spend in the Philippines. It should not affect your SS. Just be careful not to overstay in the Philippines.
What happen now that the Manila embassy is closing.where do we get our dual citizenship,and what is needed if I to go home to the Philippines what kind of paperwork that I need to take from USA.
The US Embassy in Manila is NOT closing down. It is just the CIS (Citizenship and Immigration Services) department that was shut down. The CIS in several other foreign countries are also being shut down. The official reason is 'low workload' but others claim that it is really a part of the Trump administration's efforts to make it more difficult for chain migration.
Agree with you!! After work so hard and paying taxes in US
GOOD MAN,,, YOU SHOULD BE ABLE TO TRAVEL THE WORLD ONCE YOU RETIRED...😊
Grandpa, is it possible to have 2 pensions for dual citizen? Philippines and US?
Yes, but I understand that it affects the amount you will receive.
I M in the process of doing dual citizenship, my other question is who do I contact to ship my Harley over to Philippines
Contact any International shipper.