Sadly we have arrived at the point where it's obvious that peaceful protests etc even convincing explanations are ineffective to a single agenda driven organization that desires to benefit the elite and drain the people . Our Peacefulness is seen by the Government as our uselessness and weakness which provides them added time to continue the loot presented as tax.
Look at the Finance Ministers face ..not just worst FM but also a worst person ever....She behaves as if she is doing every citizen a favor being the FM of India...Supriya is so articulate, eloquent and just amazing raising the real issues.
Supriya ma'am - Fabulous points !You nailed it ma'am !! Govt will go mum - they have stopped discussing these points in the parliament. They only discuss Hindu- Muslim, Mr. Nehru, Indira Gandhi. Shame on this Govt.
Bro all these points will be nullified by bhakt/IT cell as they are not able to comprehend it... I am sure, FM will be clueless as ever and bhakts will put blame on opposition...
Who pressed the like button before watching her speech,just by seeing the thumbnail 😂…According to me she one of the best MP who alway rises the common issue without beating the bushes around…..
I was the biggest shipper in the 80's and today it is easy to import from China and trade in India whereas very difficult to export due to Government Officers looking out to just trap and extort money
I used to to export handmade goods from India. The post office made up so many rules just to discourage me. They said i have to pack all my packages in the post office in front of them and not send more than 3 packages a day.. What nonsense. So, i stopped and now export from China and keep my income in US bank. I can't wait to leave this hellhole.
See, businessmen are important for the economy. They play a role to fix unemployment But the tax burden is too high for the Middle class. To fix that we should not punish businesses. We should be focussed on increasing our tax base. For example rich farmers are not taxed because they are categorised as farmers. For instance, Amitabh Bachchan declared himself a farmer so that he doesn't have to pay high taxes
See, businessmen are important for the economy. They play a role to fix unemployment But the tax burden is too high for the Middle class. To fix that we should not punish businesses. We should be focussed on increasing our tax base. For example rich farmers are not taxed because they are categorised as farmers. For instance, Amitabh Bachchan declared himself a farmer so that he doesn't have to pay high taxes
Supriya Sule is a true parliamentarian. She conducts herself with intelligence and grace. The questions are genuine and relevant and are delivered without the confrontational stance adopted by many MPs which makes a shambolic joke of parliamentary proceedings. This is actual women’s power.
Hope opposition will raise more of such questions and try to force current govt to reduc taxes. Instead of focusing on top businessmens, opposition should focus making taxes as their main objective.
All legit questions…but the opposition will try to play fair here…but i like the way Ms.Supriya ji raised all the concerned topics of her state….we need more of such MLAs in every state 🙏🏽
She spoke what is required and it's true FDI is going away from India and it will surely it has jobs and our youths will be more unemployed.. Hope the Govt take good steps..
We want to export. But in ice gate the approvals aren't happening as some agents said customs won't do it for a long time and don't work on time basis. There is another way to"expedite approvals via an agent" for a fee... This is the case for an expert who wants to earn foreign exchange for the country
Unpopular opinion: What if the middle class (like myself) realized that we will continue getting squeezed till the last penny (come every election), and decide to offer our talents to other countries (by migrating there), and happily paying taxes there (considering the value provided on those taxes)?
Present government is torturing MSMEs that even we are moving to Vietnam with our intellectual property rights and will supply to India as our country is fit for trading
All good, but Nestle topic was not correct. Any company is welcome to do business, until they have the right intentions. Poisoning people to make profits is not acceptable, even if it can take the country to #1. They create jobs, but don't say they give people wealth. They circulate Indian money and make profits out of it. Not like they make in India and export stuff. The government has been giving excess freedom to businesses in the name of ease of doing business. As a result, there was a recent headline that companies are making more profit but the employees are not benefitting proportionately.
FM seemed zoned out…. The lady in blue is asking an array of complex questions while the other party is not even competent to select slightly better educated employees. Like all of govt institutions it’s virtually quid pro quo
Even after paying tax in India, people of business and salaried class have no security, what does the government give security to honest tax payers? Tomorrow if I die, which government will come to secure my family's future? If I want to buy term and health insurance to secure my family future, even their government is greedy to get 18% tax from people of this country. Government please remove tax at least on insurance and health services. Small steps will help people secure their future.
Honorable finance minister has no answers for any of her questions. She will simply say Middle class we have lot of death rate in India. So let us have GST for cremation and Cemetery.
Reduce the taxes on personal gains and gst and Alert to stop increasing population make it one collective tax and provide best healthcare and education facilities like other America & UK
Nirmala does everything contrary to the name she has been given by her predecessor! Under Gobhiji she has become insufferable and cannot be tolerated in her own house!😂
I really don't understand why mrs.supriya acts so diplomatic when asking something so genuine which is taking our country downward, and nothing is going to happen whatever the oppositions suggest, they will do what they like, whether the ship is sinking or not that's not the problem for them, the answer they have is they didn't built the ship. Any leadership or the ruling party who cannot be questioned is termed as system abuse, and unfortunately these people are following this system. Pathetic last 10 years. Indulge me...
Why cant they tax people of who is earning 2 lacs per annum? like 2.5% that will boost the revenue to the govt and give some tax relief to the people who is paying more tax?
she gud before i m not happy abt sule.. now days she prominently giving gud thoughtss and nice mp as well congress mps need to find this and behave good like this in parliament as well these day cnges mp are making too mny noisessssssss
I feel the politicians are special people with special skills. they are not meant to talk but walk (do). their performance shd do the talk. the fact that we are so far behind when we look at the developed nations, it calls for introspection for these politicians. simply speaking don't join politics if you cannot make india like a developed country. modi fooled people when bjp got their first mandate 10 years back. he failed on all major promises he made. he betrayed the country when people trusted with hope. in fact he made the country weak from inside and today humanity is barely seen on streets which was some we cherished all the time despite not being rich country.
i am surprised why are u guys worried about economy. u wanted mandir so u got it,, u never voted on economy or better administration.. u wanted hate, division in society, no accountability from leaders, compromised systems and criminals and convicted people running ur daily affairs. so be happy and proud of ur achievement now,, and dont worry if your finances are messed up. once u get tired in employment line then u can go and stand in ration line.. all of u are blind .. so reap what u sow.. so print a t-shirt with great slogans now and wear it as u are citizens of a country which has great hollow talks.. vishwaguru, 56 inch, 80/20, and many others.. keep up the good work u are buliding great nation for ur future generations..
Beautiful! This is how the sessions should be held. With politeness and calmness instead of ranting and raving!
That is the hallmark of a educated lady unlike others blowing their own trumpet talking about religion, past history and hate speach
Sadly we have arrived at the point where it's obvious that peaceful protests etc even convincing explanations are ineffective to a single agenda driven organization that desires to benefit the elite and drain the people . Our Peacefulness is seen by the Government as our uselessness and weakness which provides them added time to continue the loot presented as tax.
The thing is.... Nimmy tai hasn't spoken a word in reply... That's why the session was civilized.
People have vote for Mandir and Mahjid’s never voted for Good Economy or Education, so what ever bjp is doing now nothing wrong in it.
No 1 can work on actual issues because the vote banks are uneducated..@@pratyush1010
Supriya Sule is sensible sincere and concerned about her views unlike the overreacting furious short temper ed Finance minister 🎉❤ 👌👌
She is very polite the way she is talking.
Sharad Pawar is a biggest corrupted politician
@@Khunlem come to her constituency and see her politeness. She has made pune a hell of a place to exist.
Don't get carried away with mere speeches.
she has a handbag worth 45 lakhs btw
Save middle class salaried families by giving tax benefits
Bro what benefits you want from these corrupted people? You want their healthcare, education, roads? They don’t give a shit about common man.
I wish common people can understand this common thing... Unhe toh Hindu/Muslim, Nehru/ambedkar main laga rakha hain...
@@anshdoc007
Supriya, my next PM and FM. Modi &
Nirmala hatao, India bachao. Jai Hind,
I love India and hate corrupt Nirmala !!
Vote for bjp .😅
save yourself and dont be a middle class. Not for us, for our next generation.
Love the way she is speaking her mind and not just reading a piece of paper 🙏
Look at the Finance Ministers face
..not just worst FM but also a worst person ever....She behaves as if she is doing every citizen a favor being the FM of India...Supriya is so articulate, eloquent and just amazing raising the real issues.
@@Bruno_and_Mizu most arrogant
And sorry to say, we the people of India are responsible for this, who blindly voted for Modi Govt
We need financial support during job loss. In India, even after paying taxes for 20 years, there are no benefits provided when we lose our job.
Supriya Sule is very good MP
The way she is debating and questioning... This should be the ideal conduct with which the opposition should conduct themselves.
Kudos to Ma'am
Good questions. Thanks for putting up the voice of middle class and farmers of india.
From 1100 employees i have come down to 200 and may reduce it to Zero as all Government schemes are a mockery
Supriya ma'am - Fabulous points !You nailed it ma'am !! Govt will go mum - they have stopped discussing these points in the parliament.
They only discuss Hindu- Muslim, Mr. Nehru, Indira Gandhi.
Shame on this Govt.
Bro all these points will be nullified by bhakt/IT cell as they are not able to comprehend it...
I am sure, FM will be clueless as ever and bhakts will put blame on opposition...
@@anshdoc007
Supriya, my next PM and FM. Modi &
Nirmala hatao, India bachao. Jai Hind,
I love India and hate corrupt Nirmala !!
This is what happens when you elect a cunning businessman as your PM
So well spoken🙌🏻 each & every point was so clear✅️ much needed issue raised👍🏻
Who pressed the like button before watching her speech,just by seeing the thumbnail 😂…According to me she one of the best MP who alway rises the common issue without beating the bushes around…..
she's damn hot🎉
This is how the session should run. No politics but right questions
She grilled FM and shut her mouth in her own language... inglees ingleees showoff
We need more people like her in the opposition
I was the biggest shipper in the 80's and today it is easy to import from China and trade in India whereas very difficult to export due to Government Officers looking out to just trap and extort money
I used to to export handmade goods from India. The post office made up so many rules just to discourage me. They said i have to pack all my packages in the post office in front of them and not send more than 3 packages a day.. What nonsense. So, i stopped and now export from China and keep my income in US bank. I can't wait to leave this hellhole.
India has made like a hell hole for honest businessmen and a gambling den for rogues and rascals
She has sucha nice way of putting things and stating it out and also all the questions are appreciated and represent the ppl too..
I was waiting for finance ministers reply 😂😂 not in this video maybe after next elections 😅
Why government is so keen on supporting Businessmen than common man🎉
See, businessmen are important for the economy. They play a role to fix unemployment
But the tax burden is too high for the Middle class. To fix that we should not punish businesses. We should be focussed on increasing our tax base. For example rich farmers are not taxed because they are categorised as farmers. For instance, Amitabh Bachchan declared himself a farmer so that he doesn't have to pay high taxes
See, businessmen are important for the economy. They play a role to fix unemployment
But the tax burden is too high for the Middle class. To fix that we should not punish businesses. We should be focussed on increasing our tax base. For example rich farmers are not taxed because they are categorised as farmers. For instance, Amitabh Bachchan declared himself a farmer so that he doesn't have to pay high taxes
@@anahita9980 because they are giving funds to run social media IT cell crores of rupees
@@ashuvssut23 There is a fine line before a country becomes a hostage to large businesses. learn about South Korea's Chaebols
Because they fund their elections with black money.
Straight to the point... just ask these things in every session to governing team..
double taxation needs to be removed.. period.
Tough questions and I don't think FM have the answer for us.
Supriya Sule is a true parliamentarian. She conducts herself with intelligence and grace. The questions are genuine and relevant and are delivered without the confrontational stance adopted by many MPs which makes a shambolic joke of parliamentary proceedings.
This is actual women’s power.
I am into medical devices which the country is importing and this too i am closing down because of this Government
Sure
Supriya should be the finance minister as she speaks finance
That's what should be discussed in parliament. Not religious debates
Superb this is constructive feedback and questioning. Kudos asking Right Questions.
Income tax slab should be revised ..let common spend some money for entertainment..economy automatically improves
They are doing it in DTC. Just that the tax will be increased to 35%.
GST slab increased to 35%🤣🤣
No no no. People shouldn’t have any money. All money should be with the government.😛
She wore a wonderful Sambalpuri pasapalli saree from odisha.. ❤
2:42 look at her face!
😂😂 hatable
She is evil fm
Wow this lady is asking the right questions and pointing to the right direction
Finance minister is not for beginners 😂😂
@@kuldipxaxa6910 😂
Pasand aaya joke !
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@sohamjadhav1
Supriya, my next PM and FM. Modi &
Nirmala hatao, India bachao. Jai Hind,
I love India and hate corrupt Nirmala !!
Stop using this phrase and degrading our Indian diaspora around the world!!!!
Uneducated behaviour.
Can someone please share how the FM or PM responded to Supriya ji? I could not find the video.
@@EvanE-d4q so true
Hope opposition will raise more of such questions and try to force current govt to reduc taxes. Instead of focusing on top businessmens, opposition should focus making taxes as their main objective.
Rbi interest is coming down continuously and tax also increasing continuously. It's difficult if I think of our future in high inflation environment
Nice debate. But government is doing absolutely nothing. The government favors everyone except hard working middle class amd honest taxpayers.
God dayum, finally someone asking correct questions
All legit questions…but the opposition will try to play fair here…but i like the way Ms.Supriya ji raised all the concerned topics of her state….we need more of such MLAs in every state 🙏🏽
Finally some civilised ideas are coming in parliament .
Popcorn pe tax lagayenge .. problem solved 😂😂😂🤡
To Make people invest more, increase the 80c limits. Also organise the tax schemes in such a way that people have more take home salary.
She spoke what is required and it's true FDI is going away from India and it will surely it has jobs and our youths will be more unemployed.. Hope the Govt take good steps..
There would not be many MPs who could understand this speech
Can someone please share the link for video where Finance minister has given replies to the questions?
We want to export. But in ice gate the approvals aren't happening as some agents said customs won't do it for a long time and don't work on time basis. There is another way to"expedite approvals via an agent" for a fee... This is the case for an expert who wants to earn foreign exchange for the country
We need Supriya Sule as finance minister
She is one of the gems in our parliament. BJP trolls might not agree, though.
Steps=more tax
Maam understands the economy than FM in this case.
zero discussion on heavy taxation with an unemployment hit country
Hindu should be united, Ek hai toh safe hai
Please talk about the non-condusive environment in India and who is to blame
Unpopular opinion:
What if the middle class (like myself) realized that we will continue getting squeezed till the last penny (come every election), and decide to offer our talents to other countries (by migrating there), and happily paying taxes there (considering the value provided on those taxes)?
This is how everyone should speak in parliament - Supriya has always been a dignified parliamentarian.
Good question
Isnt RBI regulator for the NBFC's?
BJP no answer
Better make her the FM instead of that Headmistress.
👌🏾
Present government is torturing MSMEs that even we are moving to Vietnam with our intellectual property rights and will supply to India as our country is fit for trading
Isko bolte hain real questioning
Indian taxation is madness
Finance minister and Modi 🤡😂
she should be the FM!!
framework provide info there kept
Complete loan waver for middle class when ?
All good, but Nestle topic was not correct. Any company is welcome to do business, until they have the right intentions. Poisoning people to make profits is not acceptable, even if it can take the country to #1.
They create jobs, but don't say they give people wealth. They circulate Indian money and make profits out of it. Not like they make in India and export stuff.
The government has been giving excess freedom to businesses in the name of ease of doing business. As a result, there was a recent headline that companies are making more profit but the employees are not benefitting proportionately.
She is someone from whom we can learn how to articulate thought and present it in the meeting session discussion
Pray for nirmala tai...
FM seemed zoned out…. The lady in blue is asking an array of complex questions while the other party is not even competent to select slightly better educated employees. Like all of govt institutions it’s virtually quid pro quo
Even after paying tax in India, people of business and salaried class have no security, what does the government give security to honest tax payers?
Tomorrow if I die, which government will come to secure my family's future?
If I want to buy term and health insurance to secure my family future, even their government is greedy to get 18% tax from people of this country.
Government please remove tax at least on insurance and health services.
Small steps will help people secure their future.
She is asking very sensible questions to a nonsense finance minister...
🌻
👍
Finally we can see some decent politics now.
give foundation work
Honorable finance minister has no answers for any of her questions. She will simply say Middle class we have lot of death rate in India. So let us have GST for cremation and Cemetery.
Food inflation?? We just add More GST to Prevent 😅
There is no point in grilling the shameless finance minister. She doesn't need to win elections 😂😂😂😂
❤❤❤❤
I have business in billions and the Make in India is preventing this from happening
cover for what distant
I am walking out with unbearable harassment with cases being foisted on me
Reduce the taxes on personal gains and gst and Alert to stop increasing population make it one collective tax and provide best healthcare and education facilities like other America & UK
Nirmala does everything contrary to the name she has been given by her predecessor! Under Gobhiji she has become insufferable and cannot be tolerated in her own house!😂
finance minister reply bhi karti hain ya nai ? Bill paas karte waqt to bohot boli thiiin !!!
Middle class pays IT, GST amd LTCG on their investments. Triple taxation
I really don't understand why mrs.supriya acts so diplomatic when asking something so genuine which is taking our country downward, and nothing is going to happen whatever the oppositions suggest, they will do what they like, whether the ship is sinking or not that's not the problem for them, the answer they have is they didn't built the ship. Any leadership or the ruling party who cannot be questioned is termed as system abuse, and unfortunately these people are following this system. Pathetic last 10 years. Indulge me...
Vishwaguru we are al Pa. Jeets now!!!!
Govt is sitting like there is no problem. When govt closed door for all problems how can problem enter let people face govt has closed the shop.
Why cant they tax people of who is earning 2 lacs per annum? like 2.5% that will boost the revenue to the govt and give some tax relief to the people who is paying more tax?
How will they(people with 2lac per annum)survive the rise in food inflation then?
@ like how others surviving by paying heavy taxes. Inflation hits every single person irrespective of their income.
@@66nagarajreddy because other have heavy salaries
she gud before i m not happy abt sule.. now days she prominently giving gud thoughtss and nice mp as well
congress mps need to find this and behave good like this in parliament as well
these day cnges mp are making too mny noisessssssss
This FM will be the reason people won't BJP
I like the government,but FM is egoistic Maniac 🤦🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️i wonder who made her FM😡
By taxing....
I feel the politicians are special people with special skills. they are not meant to talk but walk (do). their performance shd do the talk. the fact that we are so far behind when we look at the developed nations, it calls for introspection for these politicians. simply speaking don't join politics if you cannot make india like a developed country. modi fooled people when bjp got their first mandate 10 years back. he failed on all major promises he made. he betrayed the country when people trusted with hope. in fact he made the country weak from inside and today humanity is barely seen on streets which was some we cherished all the time despite not being rich country.
Looks whoes talking about corruption
i am surprised why are u guys worried about economy. u wanted mandir so u got it,, u never voted on economy or better administration.. u wanted hate, division in society, no accountability from leaders, compromised systems and criminals and convicted people running ur daily affairs. so be happy and proud of ur achievement now,, and dont worry if your finances are messed up. once u get tired in employment line then u can go and stand in ration line.. all of u are blind .. so reap what u sow.. so print a t-shirt with great slogans now and wear it as u are citizens of a country which has great hollow talks.. vishwaguru, 56 inch, 80/20, and many others.. keep up the good work u are buliding great nation for ur future generations..
@@MegaMushfiq so whom do wana vote congress 😂? Which was gonna make even worse