Siii lo mismo pensé cuando escuché spark por 1era vez y además Winter hace un movimiento que Taeyeon hace en INVU en el 16:55, sin duda ambas dan ese sentimiento etéreo y majestuoso 😍✨️💫
I have so much respect for Winter, going through what she did with the lungs surgery and all, and she still give her all every performance regardless if that puts her life in danger or not, she's a performer a true artist ♥
@@DifferentlyAlike she’s also mentioned she had a pneumothorax at some point during her trainee years too, though unsure if she had surgery at that time too
@@LetxItxRainx3yes, she was not well whilst training. Winter is so strong for that, she deserves all the success for her hard work. She clearly loves her job and it shows, she’s a great artist vocally, dance wise and performance wise.
All the girls participated in their solos! Karina wrote the lyrics to Up entirely by herself, Ningning participated in the lyrics and Giselle and Winter both took part in composition and lyrics for their songs! For spark specifically, Winter worked really hard thinking about the performance (she also has a vlog of her practice session) and she came up with the idea of the silhouette shot because she wanted to have the Mys and their lightsticks behind her and it kinda unintentionally became a fan song for her 🥹 (Would suggest finding the Tokyo dome performances, whether as a reaction or just on your own, because they change some things)
@@xyxyxyzz yeah I think some places put all the people involved in creating the song as a “writer” but karina is the sole lyricist! She’s mentioned it in concert and she’s shown her notebook with all her work on it before, I believe Apple Music puts her down as the sole lyricist too!
Certifiable proof Winter is an actual Siren, my favourite solo, her tone, her visual, her choreo, the outfit and her expressions plus she didn't just write she composed her own song too (like Gigi) 10/10 🌟🧜♀🧚🏻♂ Esosa is so real for this reaction, the performance is extra special imo because once you tie it with the meaning of the lyrics which Winter wrote dedicated to the fans, the spark is the Aespa lightstick and the connection between her and us fans. She really took it to the next LEVUHL ♡
thank you for loving winter and spark so much. it was the first time she wrote the lyrics and composed her own song. spark is a masterpiece and winter managed to deliver it perfectly. you know even when the recording was in a really bad condition, she even had to record while sitting down. but, she always worked really hard and proved that she is really great! i love winter so much that i die ❤❤❤❤😭😭😭
winter gave a lot of input on her spark performance. they all were hands on with the performances and even songs. winter even spoke about how she wanted to add a blackout moment to hers, which you will see on later performances of spark. i think she did really well creating a performance that teleported you to an ethereal place if you saw it in person. i love how far winter as come as an artist. she truly thinks about the little things too ❤
aespa is that group where everyone is GIVING, their growth is really something to be proud of, as pre-debut MY I knew these girls have so much potential to unlock and I love seeing that real time
I love that Esosa and I had the same reaction to "Spark". Bro... Winter brought so many things to this song, and I really can't describe what I felt when I heard it. I mean... AAAAAAAAA SHE’S SO GORGEOUS😭😭😭🤧🩵🛐
Spark is really sooo magical fr the tokyo dome performance is sooo magical toooo🥲🥲🥲she added some little changes to the performance.I hope you react to their content too i love them soo much ❤️❤️❤️
Winter has full input in how Spark would be performed in their concert that's why it felt finished and complete. She shared on her weverse live and magazine interview how she made sure to checl even the lights, the camera angles, everything, just to make sure to deliver the best performance of Spark.
the girls had a lot of freedom to work with their solos, and Winter grabbed that opportunity with full force, she participated in a lot of things, including the lighting, she's a perfectionist and have an amazing eye for this stuff, both the song and performance were built thinking (about) and thanking the fans, she even choose to film them (that's why she's turning her back) to highlight their importance in the show and to her, to represent that they're her spark 😭💞 i'm having goosebumps and crying too as i write this comment because she's so thoughtful, so grateful to her fans, she wanted to give them the best experience possible and really did it, I LOVE THIS GIRL WITH MY WHOLE HEART, thank you so much for this amazing reaction and for recognizing Winter's efforts and the magical beauty of Spark 💖
I never realized how insane Winter's growth was until i watched her fancam. I still remember in 2020-2022 when her stage presence was kind of mediocre, but ever since Girls era, she's been improving so much. Honestly the same applies to Giselle, except her dancing and confidence has also improved. Ningning has always been the #1 performer imo, but her dancing has also improved a ton. Karina also improved, but i feel like she was always so well rounded that it's hard to notice her gradual improvement when it comes to her presence on stage, but if you really watch her old vs new performances, you can really see her improvement
The best thing about their solos this time is that they each have a great participation in the production, from composing to the lyrics making. If i may talk about Winter, she got credited as composer and lyricist for Spark which is such a levuel up.
The girls had full control over their solos this tour. In Hyperline (their first tour) the company picked the solos and assigned them to the girls, but the girls had full creative control this time around. They were all also very involved with all the aspects of their stage and even sometimes helped each other out. The girls all put their heart and soul into each of their stages and had a vision. This really made me excited to see what each member does on her own, and want to see them have more control in group music
I honestly don't think they planned on releasing the solo songs officially but because Karina's solo went viral, they chose to release not just hers, but all of the solos. That's probably why they didn't put much effort into promoting it. That and also likely because then it would become somewhat of a solo debut for the members and they probably want each member to have a more elaborate debut.
Seeing Spark in person was SUCH a blessing. Winter really sold it with her live performance, it was soooo good. Same with Karina’s Up… it just is so different with the choreo and performance. Also I need Sua to cover Dopamine.
Karina UP kind of has its own music video/performance video made with Mnet KPOP. My Arti Film x Karina episode 6, and it is sooo gooood!!! I think I've watched it over 100 times, the energy and the dancing that she and the background dancers bring to the video is on a different level
To whover will say Winter lacks stage presence I’m gonna show them this performance of Spark. Everybody says that Winter is the best at popping that her popping is very powerful and even in her sleep she can pop.
So the Winter solo from SYNK: HYPERLINE was called "Lips". I have a great fancam video version of it from the show I went to, and I also have a stage cam version of Spark. I would be more than happy to send them to you guys somehow if you want. (They're raw videos, not RUclips links.)
there’s actually an official performance video for Karina’s UP! theres a storyline in the beginning of the video, and her performance is towards the end of the video. you should check it out!!
Winter is Literally Taeyeon's daughter. She's an amazing performer and I agree her solo deserved more and no I'm not saying this just because she's my bias but it's literally the thruth in my opinion.
You could check out another aespa performance 1. aespa's full performance at MMA (Melon Music Award) 2023 2. aespa 'Hold on Tight' Synk Hyper Line in Tokyo Dome. 3. aespa 'Girls' in Synk Hyper Line concert 4. The Mirotic cover, cause I barely see aespa cover song from another group, so you might check this out.
I don't think there has ever been a combination of ten out of ten looks, ten out of ten body, top 20 vocalist AND top 20 dancer EVER , and that describes Karina
idk why but Ningning's solo is amazing especially the Wake Up, the choreo of that song, and her voice sounds a bit of Ariana.. that's so criminally underrated 😭
![[SUB] ※새내기 필수 교양※ 술자리에서 살아남기 [차린건 쥐뿔도 없지만] EP.34 #이영지 #트와이스 #TXT](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ceGXF7zTk1Y/mqdefault.jpg)
![[SUB]"나야, 에스파” 프리티 핫 걸즈 젤닝이가 놀러왔어요 근데 이제 우정을 곁들인...♥EP.1(EN/TH)](/img/1.gif)
Sparks give me the same vibe as INVU even their hair and outfits are similar. This song is so angelic😭
@comforyt Taeyeon having a song named Spark too, that's really her daughter
Siii lo mismo pensé cuando escuché spark por 1era vez y además Winter hace un movimiento que Taeyeon hace en INVU en el 16:55, sin duda ambas dan ese sentimiento etéreo y majestuoso 😍✨️💫
@@zephyrec winter spark is giving when taeyeon spark and invu had a daughter
Honestly, Aespa is becoming that ideal group where you put 4 IT girls together ❤.
@@renhyuck236 Yeah bro. All rounders indeed!!🛐🛐🩵
Fact 🎉❤
@@renhyuck236 i am seeing you everywhere 😊
Yes me too Hhh
Fr
I have so much respect for Winter, going through what she did with the lungs surgery and all, and she still give her all every performance regardless if that puts her life in danger or not, she's a performer a true artist ♥
Wait wait wait what happened????
@@DifferentlyAlike she was diagnosed with a collapsed lung so she had to go through a Pneumothorax surgery to prevent reoccurrences
@@DifferentlyAlikein April winter went through a surgery for pneumothorax (collapsed lung)
@@DifferentlyAlike she’s also mentioned she had a pneumothorax at some point during her trainee years too, though unsure if she had surgery at that time too
@@LetxItxRainx3yes, she was not well whilst training. Winter is so strong for that, she deserves all the success for her hard work. She clearly loves her job and it shows, she’s a great artist vocally, dance wise and performance wise.
i'm sorry but winter showing us a show. a reallll showw😭😭the act, song, concept. OH MY GOODNESS 😭😭😭✨
Start to finish actual perfection like what?????
All the girls participated in their solos! Karina wrote the lyrics to Up entirely by herself, Ningning participated in the lyrics and Giselle and Winter both took part in composition and lyrics for their songs!
For spark specifically, Winter worked really hard thinking about the performance (she also has a vlog of her practice session) and she came up with the idea of the silhouette shot because she wanted to have the Mys and their lightsticks behind her and it kinda unintentionally became a fan song for her 🥹
(Would suggest finding the Tokyo dome performances, whether as a reaction or just on your own, because they change some things)
DAMN THIS MAKES ME TEAR UP
i look up the song credits and i saw 9 ppl participating in writing up tho?
@@xyxyxyzz yeah I think some places put all the people involved in creating the song as a “writer” but karina is the sole lyricist! She’s mentioned it in concert and she’s shown her notebook with all her work on it before, I believe Apple Music puts her down as the sole lyricist too!
Spark makes me so proud of Winter. She's been involved in composing and writing the song and gave input in stage direction 🤍
Spark is THAT song. I love to see Winter's evolution
The most correct thing in my life is went to the concert and saw Spark in my own eyes!
Certifiable proof Winter is an actual Siren, my favourite solo, her tone, her visual, her choreo, the outfit and her expressions plus she didn't just write she composed her own song too (like Gigi) 10/10 🌟🧜♀🧚🏻♂ Esosa is so real for this reaction, the performance is extra special imo because once you tie it with the meaning of the lyrics which Winter wrote dedicated to the fans, the spark is the Aespa lightstick and the connection between her and us fans. She really took it to the next LEVUHL ♡
Spark really happy and sad in the same Time 🙂🥲
"emerging from the darkness, a goddess comes to earth to bless us all with her spark" [cries some more] 😂😂😂 girl same
The amount of reactors that I’ve seen absolutely falling for winter recently is awesome 😂
everything about that fancam of winter's spark is literal perfection
thank you for loving winter and spark so much. it was the first time she wrote the lyrics and composed her own song. spark is a masterpiece and winter managed to deliver it perfectly. you know even when the recording was in a really bad condition, she even had to record while sitting down. but, she always worked really hard and proved that she is really great! i love winter so much that i die ❤❤❤❤😭😭😭
Your reaction to Spark is so real omg I play it literally every freaking day
winter gave a lot of input on her spark performance. they all were hands on with the performances and even songs. winter even spoke about how she wanted to add a blackout moment to hers, which you will see on later performances of spark. i think she did really well creating a performance that teleported you to an ethereal place if you saw it in person. i love how far winter as come as an artist. she truly thinks about the little things too ❤
This is already incredible, but the Tokyo Dome version of Spark?? It must have been life changing to witness live
aespa is that group where everyone is GIVING, their growth is really something to be proud of, as pre-debut MY I knew these girls have so much potential to unlock and I love seeing that real time
Winter is a fairy she's SO GORGEOUS
I love that Esosa and I had the same reaction to "Spark". Bro... Winter brought so many things to this song, and I really can't describe what I felt when I heard it. I mean... AAAAAAAAA SHE’S SO GORGEOUS😭😭😭🤧🩵🛐
WINTER gives the futuristic utopian popstar vibe. UP was great, but SPARK has my heart.
The auraaaa in Winter’s… goddess
Spark is really sooo magical fr the tokyo dome performance is sooo magical toooo🥲🥲🥲she added some little changes to the performance.I hope you react to their content too i love them soo much ❤️❤️❤️
spark is so underrated!
Dopamine is such as masterpiece from vocal,rap,dance 🔥🔥
Winter has full input in how Spark would be performed in their concert that's why it felt finished and complete. She shared on her weverse live and magazine interview how she made sure to checl even the lights, the camera angles, everything, just to make sure to deliver the best performance of Spark.
I FEEL YOU !! Spark is literally such a banger as both an audio track and a visual treat performance-wise
All 4 solos are amazing!
I've been a Wake up fan since day 1 and THEY STILL WONT RELEASE THIS MASTERPIECEEEEe
@@zoroleplusnul8286 literally a crime, like why did they not release the solos from hyperline, Ningning has the best solo from that tbh so idk 😶
Same
PLEASE watch the tokyo dome performance for spark, winter made some changes and it's SO GOOD
I need moreee spark recognition!! that masterpiece deserves moreee
aespa's WINTER is awesome. Her vocals are so good. Her dancing is amazing. Her visuals are insane.
Winter spark the best❤
I am Winter bias and Spark is addicting and this performance is levitating ngl
the fancam game for Winter's Spark is ✨
Aespa always ate, if you were a predebut MY, you see how well they have grown and see how they have come so far ❤
the Spark performance in tokyo dome tho. Majestic
the girls had a lot of freedom to work with their solos, and Winter grabbed that opportunity with full force, she participated in a lot of things, including the lighting, she's a perfectionist and have an amazing eye for this stuff, both the song and performance were built thinking (about) and thanking the fans, she even choose to film them (that's why she's turning her back) to highlight their importance in the show and to her, to represent that they're her spark 😭💞 i'm having goosebumps and crying too as i write this comment because she's so thoughtful, so grateful to her fans, she wanted to give them the best experience possible and really did it, I LOVE THIS GIRL WITH MY WHOLE HEART, thank you so much for this amazing reaction and for recognizing Winter's efforts and the magical beauty of Spark 💖
aespa's WINTER is awesome. Her 'Spark' is phenomenal. The song is so good. What a track !
I never realized how insane Winter's growth was until i watched her fancam. I still remember in 2020-2022 when her stage presence was kind of mediocre, but ever since Girls era, she's been improving so much. Honestly the same applies to Giselle, except her dancing and confidence has also improved. Ningning has always been the #1 performer imo, but her dancing has also improved a ton. Karina also improved, but i feel like she was always so well rounded that it's hard to notice her gradual improvement when it comes to her presence on stage, but if you really watch her old vs new performances, you can really see her improvement
The best thing about their solos this time is that they each have a great participation in the production, from composing to the lyrics making. If i may talk about Winter, she got credited as composer and lyricist for Spark which is such a levuel up.
The girls had full control over their solos this tour. In Hyperline (their first tour) the company picked the solos and assigned them to the girls, but the girls had full creative control this time around. They were all also very involved with all the aspects of their stage and even sometimes helped each other out. The girls all put their heart and soul into each of their stages and had a vision. This really made me excited to see what each member does on her own, and want to see them have more control in group music
WINTER IS UNREAL
Ningning is such an amazing performer
I honestly don't think they planned on releasing the solo songs officially but because Karina's solo went viral, they chose to release not just hers, but all of the solos. That's probably why they didn't put much effort into promoting it. That and also likely because then it would become somewhat of a solo debut for the members and they probably want each member to have a more elaborate debut.
Seeing Spark in person was SUCH a blessing. Winter really sold it with her live performance, it was soooo good. Same with Karina’s Up… it just is so different with the choreo and performance.
Also I need Sua to cover Dopamine.
agree.. Spark nih stage performance nya perfect banget buat konser
You must check spark performance at tokyo dome concert
aespa's KARINA is amazing. Her dancing is phenomenal. Her rapping is impressive. Her vocals are good. Her visuals are top-notch.
Ningning stage presence is on another level 🔥🔥
Spark is a perfect performance. The Menagerie performance you watched is in Tokyo Dome concert. Karina added a dance break on there.
Karina UP kind of has its own music video/performance video made with Mnet KPOP. My Arti Film x Karina episode 6, and it is sooo gooood!!!
I think I've watched it over 100 times, the energy and the dancing that she and the background dancers bring to the video is on a different level
NINGNING'S SOLOS ARE THE BEST😎🔥🔥🔥
WAKE UP AND BORED🔥🔥🔥
To whover will say Winter lacks stage presence I’m gonna show them this performance of Spark. Everybody says that Winter is the best at popping that her popping is very powerful and even in her sleep she can pop.
WHAT????
SPARKK😭😭
Karina best performer😍 the demand for her solo was so high she went so viral for Up.😍😍
So the Winter solo from SYNK: HYPERLINE was called "Lips". I have a great fancam video version of it from the show I went to, and I also have a stage cam version of Spark. I would be more than happy to send them to you guys somehow if you want. (They're raw videos, not RUclips links.)
Watch the behind of their concerts you'll see how coordinated they are with their dancers, team aespa are full of hard working people and it shows
aespa's NINGNING is something else. Her vocals are nice.
You should check out the Tokyo dome versions of the solos, they changed the outfit, choreo with a remixed version of the songs.
G is my bias and Dopamine is such a dope song. I love her chilling vibes outfit ❤️🔥
I have waited all these years for 2hot4u and menagerie release, I'm just thankful this time SM released the solos lol.
Please check out Aespa Girls live at their Hyperline concert. It so freaking good. The whole performance leave me breatheless every single time.
NINGNING 🔥🔥🔥
there’s actually an official performance video for Karina’s UP! theres a storyline in the beginning of the video, and her performance is towards the end of the video. you should check it out!!
ruclips.net/video/K7qryogPQes/видео.htmlsi=-VJ1WdR-4E7lZL6f
her dance actually starts at 1:53, and she does some acting too!!
I love aespa.
Winter is Literally Taeyeon's daughter. She's an amazing performer and I agree her solo deserved more and no I'm not saying this just because she's my bias but it's literally the thruth in my opinion.
QUEENS ALWAYS GIVING THE PEOPLE WHAT THEY WANT
Winter absolutely ATE!!
im so obsessed with Giselle Dopamine!!
ningning solo songs are super crazyyy
UP and Spark are my fav😍
ningning solos are my absolute favourite wake up not being released is indeed A CRIME.
My fav giselle song I love dopamine & 2hot4u
Yessss Winterrrr
I'VE NEVER CLICKED FASTER !!!
Giselle's voice is very nice. and she is very beautiful😍
I'm so proud of AESPA 😭😭
You could check out another aespa performance
1. aespa's full performance at MMA (Melon Music Award) 2023
2. aespa 'Hold on Tight' Synk Hyper Line in Tokyo Dome.
3. aespa 'Girls' in Synk Hyper Line concert
4. The Mirotic cover, cause I barely see aespa cover song from another group, so you might check this out.
Finally someone gets winter like I do!!!
I'm with you!!! The solos have soooo much potential I'm still very mad the first 4 solos weren't released
winter also has a solo called lips and giselle a song called keep goin if yall ever want to check them out in your own time 😁😁
Theres a MV by MNET for Karina - Up, ive sent the link in another comment but it seems it hides it as spam, but its truly the link lol
ARTiFilm?
idk if anyone has commented about it yet, but Winter’s solo for the Synk: Hyperline concert is called “Lips”
I am happy that you are uploading videos on daily basis so we can keep in touch with you and as usual aespa slayed keep uploading
spark their best solo YUP!
Managerie by karina is insane. But not release yet 😢
Thank you reaction aespa more please Karina is so Beautiful
NINGNING😍
you won't handle aespa on lace outfit in mirotic cover 😍
I love Karina and I love you all 🫶 Greetings from Chile
aespa's WINTER is awesome. Her '입모양 (Lips)' is great. The song is really good. What a track !
WINTER'S SOLO IN SYNK HYPERLINE IS CALLED "LIPS". ITS A SLOW BALLAD N ITS BEAUTIFUL
ruclips.net/video/z7Ci2XqVT7Y/видео.htmlsi=fdcB6JLQDbPHyAh4
Hope they see this!!
Lips is one of my favorites 💔
I don't think there has ever been a combination of ten out of ten looks, ten out of ten body, top 20 vocalist AND top 20 dancer EVER , and that describes Karina
I wonder what your reaction would be for the Girls and Drama concert version, that would be insane!
I love them! I love aespa!
The solos were amazing. I cant believe only "Up" got recognition😢
Hmmm? Dopamine was ALL OVER my fyp
idk why but Ningning's solo is amazing especially the Wake Up, the choreo of that song, and her voice sounds a bit of Ariana.. that's so criminally underrated 😭
You need listen Karina - "Sad Waltz" and Winter -"With you"
Aespa Tokyo dome performance so good they include with dance break😍omg love the so much🎉🎉🎉