A whole tsw catalog tier list would be great! I really appreciate your reviews because youre not overly negative, and still mention the positives on routes that are otherwise hated. Great video!
Fife Circle is a very good route. I think most people who are critical of Fife Circle haven't played it. The 158 is also a good addition to the Circle as well. I wasn't sure about LIRR with the safety systems mandatory, but actually makes a good change of play. Have to pay attention and learn the route. Not recommended if you want a casual play, where as Suffragette Line is an easy, sit back and run kind of route
LIRR and Amtrak routes with safety systems off are just you running for awhile then chasing reds for the rest of the service. ATC/ACSES are there to keep you from chasing reds and to keep the trains running on schedule, you'd be super early until you started chasing reds with them off.
The only gameplay pack i really liked was s bahn koln it ads so much traffic and makes it more lively. Right now with the xbox sale im looking at salzburg and lirr commuter
I mostly agree with this list. I do agree that the continued hate for Fife is mostly due to general hate for Rivet, it was bad when it first came out but has gotten better (similar to the hate for NEC:Trenton, it was awful when it first came out, now it's the 2nd best US route behind LIRR Commuter). I will disagree on LIRR commuter, it's a spectacular route, hands down the best US route and among the best overall, but I also always play with safety systems on and on the US routes ATC/ACSES is part of the sim experience, just like PZB/LZB is part of the experience driving on German routes. Goblin line does get boring quick, but it is very well done in terms of fit and finish and the 710 is a great train, but there's zero variation in the service pattern, it's always a 45ish min full stopper.
I think my ranking for LIRR 2.0 is solely down to that I prefer casual play and it doesn't really suit my driving style! But it hands down one of the best US routes other than that!
Love this tier list. It would be great to do a list ranking of all the routes you own. Bernina Line is realy good and has some of the best secenary in the whole series, would highly recommend picking it up. It blows Semmeringbahn out of the water. I'm happy with the TSW4 DLC however I didn’t like Voralberg and Semmeringbahn.
Your "meh" and "not a fan" categories should've been squashed into one as one or the other, not two separate categories since you've put nothing in it. So much you haven't played makes it rather pointless. Where have you ever seen the West Somerset Railway DLC getting sold for a little as £4 on any platform? DTG were never that generous.
@@ops7917 I’ve sent up the tier list that way for other people to participate! I do say from the outset that ‘meh’ is ‘it’s alright could be much better’. As for WSR being £4 on sale, it was that cheap in the sales in February/March time!
What was your favourite Train Sim World 4 DLC? Let me know!!
Let me know your choices on Discord: discord.gg/bdeyp7aEdk
Mine has to be the rog 37 👍👍
probably the blackpool branches by just trains it’s scenery is spectacular
Goblin Line
Mine is the Southeastern high speed
@@Toasted_IQI kinda want that DLC quite badly 😅
A whole tsw catalog tier list would be great! I really appreciate your reviews because youre not overly negative, and still mention the positives on routes that are otherwise hated. Great video!
I'm a UK route and traction fan as well, but picked up Berninaline on sale and it is excellent. Just so different.
I will have a look into it! I'm gonna wait for a sale!
I agree with the goblin line. Really looked forward to it but got bored real quick. I am however looking forward to the new one built in to the WCML
I agree, the Lioness Line will be fun to drive!
Now rank different tsw4 community projects
Sounds like a plan!
Fife Circle is a very good route. I think most people who are critical of Fife Circle haven't played it. The 158 is also a good addition to the Circle as well. I wasn't sure about LIRR with the safety systems mandatory, but actually makes a good change of play. Have to pay attention and learn the route. Not recommended if you want a casual play, where as Suffragette Line is an easy, sit back and run kind of route
LIRR and Amtrak routes with safety systems off are just you running for awhile then chasing reds for the rest of the service. ATC/ACSES are there to keep you from chasing reds and to keep the trains running on schedule, you'd be super early until you started chasing reds with them off.
I agree that the LIRR safety systems do provide a different type of play but it's a nightmare to stream hahah!
The only gameplay pack i really liked was s bahn koln it ads so much traffic and makes it more lively. Right now with the xbox sale im looking at salzburg and lirr commuter
The Koln pack was solid! That's what you call a gameplay pack!
Noice!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
also 120 views and 20 likes damn your famous I remember before 1k good job
I'm not quite famous but the channel is doing very well! Thank you for contributing to it doing so well!
I mostly agree with this list. I do agree that the continued hate for Fife is mostly due to general hate for Rivet, it was bad when it first came out but has gotten better (similar to the hate for NEC:Trenton, it was awful when it first came out, now it's the 2nd best US route behind LIRR Commuter). I will disagree on LIRR commuter, it's a spectacular route, hands down the best US route and among the best overall, but I also always play with safety systems on and on the US routes ATC/ACSES is part of the sim experience, just like PZB/LZB is part of the experience driving on German routes. Goblin line does get boring quick, but it is very well done in terms of fit and finish and the 710 is a great train, but there's zero variation in the service pattern, it's always a 45ish min full stopper.
I think my ranking for LIRR 2.0 is solely down to that I prefer casual play and it doesn't really suit my driving style! But it hands down one of the best US routes other than that!
Did you do this for earlier versions on TSW? For EX (ranking every train sim world 3 dlc). If not, please do it.
I haven't no as I've only been doing RUclips for 6 months of so aha!
You’ve not played the Centro 323? What kind of Brummie are you??
Brilliant vid as usual, mate, getting more and more pumped for the GCR!
I mean it makes sense but it’s a gameplay pack he probably wasn’t interested
It's a gameplay pack, you know how I feel about gameplay packs!
Love this tier list. It would be great to do a list ranking of all the routes you own.
Bernina Line is realy good and has some of the best secenary in the whole series, would highly recommend picking it up. It blows Semmeringbahn out of the water.
I'm happy with the TSW4 DLC however I didn’t like Voralberg and Semmeringbahn.
I'm glad you liked the video! I think I've avoided Bernina as I'm not really a narrow gauge fan!
I did this a couple of days ago
Now rank all the games!
Will do!
Cross city line of course Richy!!(Although TSW3 route) Blackpool, Gospel-Barking are decent
Cross City Line is top tier!
Fun idea!
W vid
W comment!
You should do a British route tier list!
Good idea. but only do UK if he's not keen on playing with German or US safety systems.
I like all regions but own more UK stuff than any other!
Nice one richy, in my opinion I’d put ECML in not a fan, it’s not that good tbh
It gets better once you have all the layers, but still falls under the "play a service every few days or so" kind of route like AVL
I think ECML is well made and has a lot of service variety!
I feel like you should’ve ranked different tsw games is well
@@SWFXEDITZ that can be done in a different video
@@RichyRail_where is Birmingham cross city?
@@SWFXEDITZ that’s train sim world 3
@@RichyRail_ oh I have a bad memory
i can agree with you on the cargo line packs, they dont exactly add much and we already have the wagons in the game :/
Nearly £700 worth of DLC packs since Sept 2023. Crazy prices. They really don't care about their customers.
Your "meh" and "not a fan" categories should've been squashed into one as one or the other, not two separate categories since you've put nothing in it. So much you haven't played makes it rather pointless. Where have you ever seen the West Somerset Railway DLC getting sold for a little as £4 on any platform? DTG were never that generous.
@@ops7917 I’ve sent up the tier list that way for other people to participate! I do say from the outset that ‘meh’ is ‘it’s alright could be much better’.
As for WSR being £4 on sale, it was that cheap in the sales in February/March time!