Requested by Patreon Supporter: Silas Subscribe to my second channel: ruclips.net/channel/UCqaCloOBhiRprsiVFIKQ3JQ Support me on Patreon: www.patreon.com/random_k Schedule & Patreon Requests: randomk.me/
I actually thought she had sung a lot because the quantity of screen time she gets! Ireh on the other hand, I notice her cause I've seen a blond girl on the dance formation, but no screen time and no lines.
yeah, like.. dosie and ireh have less lines, but i can clearly remember them on the mv.. they stand out on the coreography too.. kinda sad, but anyways
Me too I thought dosie have more lines cause her screen time but doesn"t Same as jieun when i think she just have some line but the result she have more lines then i thought
@@cocovixx2267 agreed, they gave more screen time to dosie. ireh and dosie were center in the dance break. it really makes the viewer feel their presence even though they have the least lines.
This is just their debut song so it’s not surprising that they wanted to showcase the best vocalists of the group. Honestly I’m satisfied cause Ireh and Dosie have their time to shine in the mv and in the choreo. I’m sure they’ll have time to adjust the line distribution. PURPLE ON THE TOP!
I was thinking the opposite, this is their debut and fans are just getting to know them so I’m thinking that they would want to showcase all the members. But this usually does happen with most debuts and then as time progresses the distribution gets better so I hope that happens for Purple Kiss.
No, I not agree with you, cuz all their songs are the same with line distribution, if it was only this, okay, but, no, it's the same type of line distribution with my heart skip a beat, skip skip, can we talk again, this and another song I don't remember ' but just watch yourself. It's not normal to do that with all their songs when all members are able to sing as good and are confident enough. (cuz someone said that it's bcs of their confidence wtf,)
@@lalala6011 skip skip and My heart skip a beat actually have pretty decent line distribution. The other songs on their ep are ballads so it’s normal for them to let the main vocalists shine more. I do agree that Swan and Goeun have many lines but again, this was just their debut they probably just want to see how the public will react to them. I’m hopeful for a fairer line distribution in the future
For those who don't know, these girls actively contribute in the writing of the songs. For example, Yuki (who is Japanese) wrote the rap lines herself, while most of the song was written by Swan back when she was just a trainee. Much like Mamamoo, they decide the line distributions on their own, so don't worry about anyone feeling "robbed". That's how RBW works. Jieun, Ireh and Dosie have a far better line distribution in the other songs on the album.
Just because a couple members decide doesn't mean they got what they deserved. Goeun and Swan could have given away more lines. Stop replying to me. Swan and Goeun wrote the song. No one debuts in a group to just dance. If they weren't ready they wouldn't have debuted.Take your petty arguments somewhere else.
@@arilovestoast Are you dumb? If Dosie and Ireh wanted more lines, they could stand up for it, you know? It's not like Goeun and Swan decide it all by themselves.
@@arilovestoast they're main dancers so they are more focused on dancing than on singing and literally got a whole dance break, so it gave justice to their main position. it's a debut so that's normal to showcase strongest vocals in the song
@@yeaboi564 I'm not dumb. And how do you even know that they didn'task for more? It is their debut song. Of course they want lines. They became idols not backup dancers. Take several seats.
@@arilovestoast they didn't become backup dancers in this song. girls slayed whole dance break, what's the point of giving dance break & also intro to backup dancer, hm? also ireh centering on the first lalala part. they will shine more during performance, with their amazing dancing skills but also they both got light hairstyles so it's quite obvious that they will stand out more because of it
maybe the company didn't want to push the 7 seven members voice straight, i believe ireh & dosie gon' have more line in their new comeback, don't worry it just start, they have a long journey, btw check their bside she's have a lot line tbh
Kyaaaa~ hi teume !(the best fanbase💙) my bias in purple kiss was Ireh and Chaein 💙💜 (Sorry my english is si bad because im french fan) my bias in treasure is Yoshiii🐯💎👑 and you?
honestly, it's not that bad. it's just a debut song, everyone had their moment. sujin and goeun slayed vocals. yuki had her raps, chaein and jieun also slayed vocals. maybe ireh and dosie didn't get many lines, but they got whole dance break +dosie's visuals really stood out in mv. also this two got to whisper that "ponzoña" part & made it really memorable with their facials. that's just a debut song, so it's normal to showcase the best vocalists. i'm sure that next comebacks main dancer duo will shine also as vocalists cuz honestly there's no bad vocal in this group. that's probably the longest com, i've ever written. sorry for my bad english, stream ponzoña mv & have a good day!!
Omg! Same thoughts. The moment Ireh and Dosie like screamed in Ponzoña in a sexy and aggressive manner is the best part of the song. They did it so well with those gorgeous and alluring facial expression.
I think the position of this girls is Goeun - Main Vocal Swan - Main Vocal Yuki - Main Rapper, Lead Dancer Chaein - Lead Vocal, Lead Dancer Jieun - Vocal Ireh - Vocal, Main Dancer Dosie - Vocal, Main Dancer
@@midnightstheworld Ikr, I think Main vocals should be - Swan and Goeun Lead vocals - Jieun and Chaein Sub vocals - Ireh and dosie Main rapper - Yuki Lead rapper - Chain or Dosie Main dancer - Dosie and Ireh Lead dancer - Yuki and Jieun Visual - ( even though all of them are, I'm gonna pick using stereotypes) Jieun Center - Swan ( because good expretions) and probably Goeun ( because the most stage presence from what I see) Face - Goeun ( cause she seems the most confident)
Honestly, IREH and Dosie shined in the Dance break and Dosie's facial expression was on point, so it didn't seem too little. This distribution is not equal, but IN MY OPINION, it's fair.
exactly this right here, and people forget their positions in the group, I mean its not like their main vocals or lead vocals, they make up for those lines with their dancing and presence and they bring that to the group
Cause they are the main vocals, they got the most lines. Lines will be more even after there debut. They had to show there best capabilities here, the main dancers got a dance break AND they were in the middle of the dances many times. The rapper wrote her own rap lines. It will be more fair next time, just support the girls with there debut cause they seem happy with it 😌
@@athleticgal I was chill while writing that comment, and it doesn't seem like you guys get it cause they're are SO many comments complaining. Your not a fan of you already start to complain, give the girls a break
even though ireh and dosie don’t have a lot of lines, they had a lot of screen time on the mv that made them stand out more than others so please everyone do not take it out on goeun and swan, they’re the main vocalists. if u want to blame someone, blame whoever distributed the lines.
i mean, technically the members distributed the lines, so you *could* blame them..... jk but fr they all decided to distribute it this way bc swan and goeun wrote it and their vocals suited it the best. it's the debut song, they're all top heavy to get people hooked, and then things even out as people start stanning and sticking around
I disagree! Im not usually one to look or care too deeply into the lines debacle, but it must be said... the line distribution is the sole thing that puts me off Everglow. They just always make it about Mia. They have had so many releases to show growth but it's always Mia overshadowing the rest in the lines department. I don't think this is nearly as bad as Everglows case especially considering its only their debut, they still have time.
I really wish people wouldn't always get so on the attack about line distributions ALL THE TIME. I'm not here to offend or upset anyone, but i'm just giving my two cents on the matter. As a HUGE long time Mamamoo fan, I have followed Purple Kiss since their teasers and have been SO excited for their debut. From how I see it; GoEun & Swan are the strongest vocalists, then Chaein & JiEun are the other two primary vocalists so its expected they get the most lines on their debut to show off. Ireh and Dosie are the primary dancers of the group, they by default aren't gonna get as many lines on the debut title track and have more focus on their dance and visuals too. Yuki is the sole rapper and writes the lyrics herself, much like Soyeon, shes going to end up with alot of lines. This is literally their debut and people are immediately salty about it, when I can guarantee all of the members are happy with the outcome - as they are part of a great company and all got to participate in writing and composing this title track & mini album. Give them time to flesh out their discography before calling "mistreatment" or who "deserved" what...I think we are so used to seeing Mamamoo's consistently equal distribution across their releases, but we are looking at a 4 member group to a 7 member, its just never going to appear as even especially on their DEBUT.
All of this? YES Also - Mamamoo in the early days had a HEAVY focus on Wheein and Solar. Their debut song had only two parts for Moonbyul. This continued until Pink Funky era where Moonbyul got most of Esna's lines in Ahh Oop, and the lengthy rap sections in Um Oh Ah Yeh. From then on, the distributions became more fair. So I agree, if the girls are happy, leave it be. The line distributions will eventually become more fair as the girls continue to explore their composition, vocal, and rap skills.
Kpop fans say anything these days, thinking they know EVERYTHING about their idols. "Oh obviously these members want to sing more!" "No, they are satisfied with this because they were involved in the line distribution!" Your response is the most logical one tbh. Kpop IS a business, not a college presentation group.
Not a fully Purple Kiss stan yet but I really feel like: Goeun, Dosie, Chaein and Swan really own Ponzoña as a whole! (These four charisma are really shine a lot for me~)
Interesting...I don’t disagree on Go Eun & Swan but that’s probably because they dominated the vocal lines. They did write the song (together with rapper Yuki) so I guess that makes sense, they clearly vibe really well with the song. Speaking of Yuki (rapper), maybe it’s just me but I think she jumps off the screen anytime she appears....not just when rapping but in that red gown! She just looks so expensive! Definite bias material & you should go back & check out her pre debut teaser.....talk about charisma! & she only just turned 18. Unfortunately, other than the short dance break I thought both Chaein & Dosie were kind of lost but that’s ok because they both shined in the pre debut songs. Knowing RBW, they’ll keep everything fairly harmonious.
Dont worry people they will sing in the future, this is just like how RBW did to Mamamoo... the surprise shall be in the future not now 🥰🥰🥰 They were the one that do the distribution themselves
I am honestly so happy and in love with purple kiss and this fandom because it is so peaceful and everyone understands rbw and their artist so well. I hope we can keep it this way forever💜💜💜💜
I love Goeun and Swan to death, they're literally my 2 biases, but what is this distribution? 😐 RBW, I know Goeun and Swan are insanely talented but don't disregard the fact that this is a 7-MEMBER GROUP. There's literally a whole minute gap between Goeun and Ireh and Dosie. Really upsetting.
I’m pretty sure that this isn’t rbw and the girls distribute the song themselves, since that’s what mamamoo did and it would make sense since swan was the one who wrote the whole song minus yuki’s rap
@@rizzizzippi their debut is already successful. it's the debut that sold the most copies in the last two years on the first day. these girls are doing amazing as is. Ireh and Dosie got less lines but an entire dance break since their main dancers, and not only that but dosie got a ton of screen time because of her iconic hair. I'd say it's pretty fair. And most importantly, all debuts are not balanced when it comes to lines, dancers focus on dancing and singers focus on singing. so chill out, everything is fine
Dont worry, go to PurKi channel and watch their old videos where they do oldies covers~ I should say they are all vocalists, well it's RBW thing hahaha I love Ji Eun nasally vocals in one of their video
The line distribution surprised me so much, watching the MV i wouldn’t have noticed how bad it was cuz each member shines to much in it and the choreography
Say all you want about the line distribution, but i think rbw is actually smart with this move. Every member gets a killing part of their own. Goeun, Swan and Chaein gets most of the vocal and chorus centres because their vocal colours are PK's main charm; Dosie and Ireh get the centres during the dance break because main dancers; Yuki gets her charismatic rap parts; Jieun is the least confident member and her higher registers are not as distinct as the main vocal line (not saying she's not a good vocalist) so rather than giving her parts she's less comfortable with, she gets lines that fit her voice perfectly and also the outro part which is just long enough for her charisma (and visuals. i knew she is the visual but omg i was shooketh at that part) to show through but not too long that her confidence starts to wane. It is important for each member to be at least recognised for one thing now. They just debuted. There's still plenty of time for them to grow and show more
I'm not surprised or mad about the distribution. Swan and Na Goeun are clearly the best singers in the group *and* they're the ones who wrote and composed the song, not knowing it would be used as the debut track, so it was created to suit their voices. This is not Mamamoo which had 3 equally fantastic, top tier vocalists + a quite solid rapper. There's a definite range of singing and dancing capabilities in the group. Some of the girls who didn't sing as much were in the center for dancing. Anyway, the other tracks have more lines for the other girls, and this is just the debut.
Yuki also took part in producing this song. She wrote her rap and I'm so amazed, because she is Japanese and her rap in Korean is fire even tho it's not her 1st language so it could be problematic to her
That's not an excuse. Everyone in purple kiss can sing aell and the fact Goeun and Swan are the best singers doesn't change the fact the others can sing well. I would understand if they were all poor singer but everyone can sing so well.
I don't mind the Line distribution all too much. I do wish the other girls had a bit more. But I seen a lot of people assuming the girls positions. Here is my assumtion(Not sayings its true- only what I think) Goeun> Main Vocalist, Lead Dancer, Center Jieun> Lead Vocalist, Visual Chaein> Lead Vocalist, Lead Dancer, Rapper Yuki> Main Rapper, Lead Dancer, Sub-Vocalist Dosie> Main Dancer, Lead Rapper, Sub-Vocalist Ireh> Main Dancer, Sub-Vocalist Swan> Main Vocalist, Maknae IF THIS IS TRUE- Then it makes sense for the way the line distribution is. Although you'd think with Jieun/Chaein possibly being Lead Vocalist, they'd get more lines. But I'm not mad at Dosie and Ireh lack of lines. ONLY because they are clearly apart of the dance line regardless of what position they have and it shows. They own the dance break and most choreo they do. But thats my opinion, please don't hate..
While others may be debating or disappointed about the line distribution, to me it's perfect! The screen time on the mv, including the live performance. They do get their own screen time and their center position - making everyone equal. Besides, each member contributed to the overall performance which I believe is far more important than line distribution. Unless you do only "listen" to the song itself without the video, you'd be quite surprised that each member stands out with their unique voices. PLEASE SUPPORT PURPLE KISS. They do deserve the love, recognition as well as a chance in this industry.
You know this song's distribution would be better if 0:36 - 0:38 : Ireh 0:38 - 0:43: Dosie 1:13 - 1:15 : Jieun and Ireh 2:37 - 2:44 : Jieun 2:45 - 2:53 : Ireh 2:59 - 3:02 - Jieun and Dosie 3:07 - 3:09 - Jieun and Ireh Dosie doesn't need a lot of line since she has a lot of center and the dance break (As a dance line with Ireh and Goeun)
RBW is really smart. This is really fair. Go Eun and Swan may have the most lines, it is only good considering they are the best vocalists of the group. Eventho Ireh and Dosie had the least lines, they had the most screen time AND centers of the dance break. I dont get why people in the comments should be arguing it is like Go Eun and Swan, ft. Members. Some are also saying this is just like Everglow when they debuted cause its totally different. If u watch their stage performances, you can see that no one overshadows or outcasted the group. So lets appreciate this masterpiece instead of only focusing on the line distribution alone.
@@ggstan2439 lmao. Its FAIR. Do u really expect it to be equal as the main vocals?? FYI, Yuki was given a rap. Ji Eun was the center in the last part. Chaein had great lines. Ireh and Dosie had the center dance break. In their mv, Dosie and Ireh as well as the others had the most screentime than the two vocals: go eun and swan. Its not like NO LIE as ur referring. If u still think its unfair, idk whats the meaning of ur FAIR.
@@briespen The meaning of Fair means not only 2 members in a 7 membered group sing more than half of the song alone when the vocal gap isn't even big compared to the rest (mainly Swan) while true GREAT vocals for smaller groups gets way less than that, just like Wendy and actually Yuju. Doesn't matter screentime, dancebreak or whatever, it doesn't affect their vocal thing, they also trained as singers and also deserve lines, if they have a breakdance, ok they are good dancers but this doesn't change the fact they need singing lines. If Swan and Go eun still on the top but with less lines it would be fair. In what world 2 members in a 7 membered group sing the start, verses, high notes, adlibs, the chorus, bridge, pre-chorus it's fair?? Again, they are a grouo with 2 Mias and 5 Ondas. Not to mention screentime is the most mediocre thing, they will not promote the MV everytime they sing the song, it's just them and the song, not the MV and eventho some have more and some have less everyone still apear a lot.
@@ggstan2439 but they still sang tho?? I think its fair since the members with the least lines have the the most screentime in their stages. And they have predebut solo songs that showcased their abilities. This is getting annoying. Why the heck does people complain in lines as if their the one singing the songs. FYI, the members are a self produced meaning they picked the lines they are comfortable with. The dance is very tiring too so they might not have the great stability especially since their singing live. This is just their debut and people are complaining AS IF theyve been around for years and still have that so called unfair lines.
1:54 is dosie not go eun dosie sang that part at the midnight idol show. 2:58 is everyone singing. (maybe) that's what I saw and heard at the midnight idol show too.
Finally Goeun debuted! I had expected this since the Produce 48 season back in 2018. She was one of my favorites at the time and unfortunately ended up not making her debut as an IzOne member. But I'm happy to see her now on PurpleKiss. Dragging on the lines, l and visuals “what is this wonderful purple hair, so shocked”! 😍 She is definitely my bias already in that group. 드디어 고은이 데뷔! 2018 년 프로듀스 48 시즌 이후로 기대 했었죠. 당시 제가 가장 좋아하는 사람 중 하나 였는데 안타깝게도 아이즈 원 멤버로 데뷔하지 못했어요. 하지만 지금 PurpleKiss에서 그녀를 만나서 기쁩니다. 라인, l, 비주얼 드래그 "이 멋진 보라색 머리카락이 뭐야, 너무 깜짝이야"! 그녀는 이미 그 그룹에있는 나의 편견입니다. 🤍
Honestly, Goeun and Swan's lines could have easily been divided between Ireh, Jieun and Dosie as they are genuinely great vocalists (as shown in predebut clips), so I am quite disappointed but it's a good debut song.
I wrote singable English lyrics 😃 try it out! Purple on the top PURPLE KISS on bloody top Oh bloody top, I'm on my way It's time for me to take my seat now ooh Oh you must have been waiting for so long Don't you know? There is no way to stop, no way to stop You should hold your breath real tight As I colour you I, colour you I It's the poison that's in my kiss mark As it's spreading you are surely losing it, no But you cannot deny it still Ponzona Baby PURPLE KISS on bloody top I am painting purple everything I have made you crazy, fall in love You better know, you better know Can't escape me no more La la la la shout it out La la la la louder In a world that's been lost so Purple on the top I know you can feel it spreading everywhere My arrow that landed right there where I meant I know you want something Where do you see your own self Throw everything you have at me at once Born that night, I'm special, it's so mystical And my skill is to be a charming criminal Come and follow me and see and don't say what you don't need I am bang bang aiming for the heart but keep on shining now ay As it's spreading you are surely losing it, no But you cannot deny it still Ponzona Baby PURPLE KISS on bloody top I am painting purple everything I have made you crazy, fall in love You better know, you better know Can't escape me no more La la la la shout it out La la la la louder In a world that's been lost so Purple on the top Purple on the top Try to find some piece in a place that shines bright As I keep walking my scent will haunt you and you'll be confused to see Actually you don't know any of this story You keep falling deeper now Into this unknown ground Baby kiss me eh eh Oh-oh ooh-woah Ponzona PURPLE KISS on bloody top Baby PURPLE KISS on bloody top I am painting purple everything I have made you crazy, fall in love You better know, you better know Can't escape me no more You're addicted no doubt And there is no way out La la la la shout it out La la la la louder You're addicted no doubt And there is no way out La la la la shout it out Purple on the top If you liked this you can find more like this on my channel!
Yes Ireh and Dosie got nice screen time that covers up the lack of lines, but Jieun has very little lines and half of the seconds of lines here are shared with Goeun (the La la la la part) and she has like 10 seconds only of screen time despite being the visual. I feel like she was done the dirtiest here cause I barely noticed her in the MV.
I feel like this makes sense for a début song, they had to show off their strongest singers -- Dosie and Ireh really do stand out in the performance, and I honestly can't get over Jieun's few lines as well :')
Mistakes in this video: 1:221:26 Dosie 'oh oh oh' 1:53 is Dosie's line and not Goeun's 2:02 Jieun sings 'Bloody top' together with Goeun here, not just Goeun 2:552:583:043:06 Jieun sings 'Yeah' 'Oh' not Goeun
Since everglow have more fair line distributions now, somebody had to replace them and to be the most unfair line distributed group Edit: I know, that Everglow isn’t the only group, which has bad line distributions, they’re also loona and groups, but they still have not really good distributed lined, although Everglow is doing changes and I meant that if everglow has more fair line distribution, then some group has to replace them and to be one of the most unfair distributed groups
there's some mistakes. the "purple kiss on bloody top" is Swan, not Chaein. i know they showed Chaein in the live performances but she could be only lipsyncing. that's Swan's voice (and they even showed her in the mv) you also gave one of Dosie's lines to Goeun
but other members still stands out. Their Mv screen time is fair, the dance line (Dosie & Ireh) who have a least line have dance break. I think thats fair.
Ok I think it is totally ok that Swan and Goeun sing the most (since they sing each chorus) but I don't get why there are still members with not even 5 seconds like huuuh?!?!? Mamamoo also had a balanced line distribution so I don't get why they do this to Purple Kiss now
Jeez y'all need to get a brain and understand that they were the main dancers and if you look at there dance, they got the most center. They had to show there best capabilities for debut it'll get more even after that. And not all are gonna be the vocals, the dancers will get best at dancing, rapper will get the rap, visual will get the most screen time
Plz use ur brains. Cause eventho Ireh and Dosie had the least lines, they were THE CENTER of the dance break. And also has the most screen time. It is only fair.
i love how the members that dont have as much lines are highlighted in the actual music video! like i would’ve totally thought that dosie and ireh had the most lines just based on their presence and screen time! good job rbw!!!
OMG this too me is like what if Yena was in EVERGLOW Green-Mia Pink-ish-Sihyeon Purple- Aisha Red-Yena Pink-Yiren And then the last two are Eu and Onda
@@Aoir I'm very chilled, thank you. I proposed a valid question since a lot of groups that start out with line distributions like this often take years to change.
@@candirita literally jieun dosie and Ireh are always last in LD even in their bsides. Have you seen period, jieun ireh have less than 2sec and dosie 5sec on that song, the only pretty fair LD is Skip Skip.
Okay goeun and Swan have beautiful voices but if the line distribution is gonna be like this, why didn't they debut a duo. The other girls have great voices too
first of all… this line distribution is pretty damn fair compared to a lot of these other groups, and its VERY fair regarding positions… they all shined some way during this, I mean yeah dosie and ireh didnt get much lines but keep in mind they’re most likely sub vocalists, meaning lines wont really be present… meaning they have a whole other thing to give to the plate aka their dancing, dosie was most talked about plus she got hella screen time, now yuki got a good amount of lines, rappers dont rap the whole time so ya know.. shes a sub vocalist too, now as for chaein and jieun they got a good amount of lines too since they’re lead vocals
I love this song and I don't blame the girls but... The hypocrisy right here is incredible. Because apparently they all chose their lines, it's totally fine if 2 members of the group share 2/3 of the song. This shows how people hate Soyeon just to hate on her, because it's the same for idle, but everyone hates Soyeon for it meanwhile everyone is happy about this line distribution.
it's their debut song ofc they want to put the main vocalists front and center to showcase that they do have strong vocals in the group and their screen time and dance center distribution is pretty good, im sure that their next songs would include more lines for the other members
Requested by Patreon Supporter: Silas
Subscribe to my second channel: ruclips.net/channel/UCqaCloOBhiRprsiVFIKQ3JQ
Support me on Patreon: www.patreon.com/random_k
Schedule & Patreon Requests: randomk.me/
Can someone request Skip Skip and Period pleaseeeeeee
omg i love you 😭😭😭💕💞💓💗💖💘💞💓💞💖💓
@@samanthakim5035 and the whole album!
Skip Skip pls
1:52 is Dosie, not Goeun
Even though Dosie has the least lines, She really stand out to me because of her visuals and her masterpiece short blonde hair
and she had a lot of center time as well
I actually thought she had sung a lot because the quantity of screen time she gets! Ireh on the other hand, I notice her cause I've seen a blond girl on the dance formation, but no screen time and no lines.
yeah, like.. dosie and ireh have less lines, but i can clearly remember them on the mv.. they stand out on the coreography too.. kinda sad, but anyways
it’s because she had a lot of mv time like a lot
is it a wig?
I never realized that the line distribution was like this because of the screen time
Same
Me too
I thought dosie have more lines cause her screen time but doesn"t
Same as jieun when i think she just have some line but the result she have more lines then i thought
exactly there's company are very smart
@@cocovixx2267 agreed, they gave more screen time to dosie. ireh and dosie were center in the dance break. it really makes the viewer feel their presence even though they have the least lines.
same!!!
This is just their debut song so it’s not surprising that they wanted to showcase the best vocalists of the group. Honestly I’m satisfied cause Ireh and Dosie have their time to shine in the mv and in the choreo. I’m sure they’ll have time to adjust the line distribution. PURPLE ON THE TOP!
EXACTLY! MV center is pretty well distrbuted... It's all fine :)
I was thinking the opposite, this is their debut and fans are just getting to know them so I’m thinking that they would want to showcase all the members. But this usually does happen with most debuts and then as time progresses the distribution gets better so I hope that happens for Purple Kiss.
@@Lyssa3Lynn i was thinking the same
No, I not agree with you, cuz all their songs are the same with line distribution, if it was only this, okay, but, no, it's the same type of line distribution with my heart skip a beat, skip skip, can we talk again, this and another song I don't remember ' but just watch yourself. It's not normal to do that with all their songs when all members are able to sing as good and are confident enough. (cuz someone said that it's bcs of their confidence wtf,)
@@lalala6011 skip skip and My heart skip a beat actually have pretty decent line distribution. The other songs on their ep are ballads so it’s normal for them to let the main vocalists shine more. I do agree that Swan and Goeun have many lines but again, this was just their debut they probably just want to see how the public will react to them. I’m hopeful for a fairer line distribution in the future
For those who don't know, these girls actively contribute in the writing of the songs. For example, Yuki (who is Japanese) wrote the rap lines herself, while most of the song was written by Swan back when she was just a trainee. Much like Mamamoo, they decide the line distributions on their own, so don't worry about anyone feeling "robbed". That's how RBW works. Jieun, Ireh and Dosie have a far better line distribution in the other songs on the album.
Just because a couple members decide doesn't mean they got what they deserved. Goeun and Swan could have given away more lines.
Stop replying to me. Swan and Goeun wrote the song. No one debuts in a group to just dance. If they weren't ready they wouldn't have debuted.Take your petty arguments somewhere else.
@@arilovestoast Are you dumb? If Dosie and Ireh wanted more lines, they could stand up for it, you know? It's not like Goeun and Swan decide it all by themselves.
@@arilovestoast they're main dancers so they are more focused on dancing than on singing and literally got a whole dance break, so it gave justice to their main position. it's a debut so that's normal to showcase strongest vocals in the song
@@yeaboi564 I'm not dumb. And how do you even know that they didn'task for more? It is their debut song. Of course they want lines. They became idols not backup dancers. Take several seats.
@@arilovestoast they didn't become backup dancers in this song. girls slayed whole dance break, what's the point of giving dance break & also intro to backup dancer, hm? also ireh centering on the first lalala part. they will shine more during performance, with their amazing dancing skills but also they both got light hairstyles so it's quite obvious that they will stand out more because of it
Ireh and Dosie just sung Ponzona and some small parts and they're done
but dosie had a LOT of center parts, while Ireh don't
@@claravitoriacf she had one center time too in the performance but was also too short which is sad
maybe the company didn't want to push the 7 seven members voice straight, i believe ireh & dosie gon' have more line in their new comeback, don't worry it just start, they have a long journey, btw check their bside she's have a lot line tbh
Yes, knowing that Ireh can literally sing and can fit in a lead vocal position.
Kyaaaa~ hi teume !(the best fanbase💙) my bias in purple kiss was Ireh and Chaein 💙💜
(Sorry my english is si bad because im french fan) my bias in treasure is Yoshiii🐯💎👑 and you?
honestly, it's not that bad. it's just a debut song, everyone had their moment. sujin and goeun slayed vocals. yuki had her raps, chaein and jieun also slayed vocals. maybe ireh and dosie didn't get many lines, but they got whole dance break +dosie's visuals really stood out in mv. also this two got to whisper that "ponzoña" part & made it really memorable with their facials.
that's just a debut song, so it's normal to showcase the best vocalists.
i'm sure that next comebacks main dancer duo will shine also as vocalists cuz honestly there's no bad vocal in this group.
that's probably the longest com, i've ever written. sorry for my bad english, stream ponzoña mv & have a good day!!
ur English is like perfect
@@malinalikeskpop oh, thank you!!
Omg! Same thoughts. The moment Ireh and Dosie like screamed in Ponzoña in a sexy and aggressive manner is the best part of the song. They did it so well with those gorgeous and alluring facial expression.
@@stanmamamoo5785 exactly!! they all had their moments so i don't understand why people are complaining
exactly!
1:53 Is Dosie ✋
I think the position of this girls is
Goeun - Main Vocal
Swan - Main Vocal
Yuki - Main Rapper, Lead Dancer
Chaein - Lead Vocal, Lead Dancer
Jieun - Vocal
Ireh - Vocal, Main Dancer
Dosie - Vocal, Main Dancer
Jieun then will probably get Vocal and Visual, but no official positions yet I believe ( correct me if I'm wrong but don't be rude )
Jieun is the 4th when it comes to vocals so i think she deserves the lead vocal title
@@midnightstheworld Ikr, I think
Main vocals should be - Swan and Goeun
Lead vocals - Jieun and Chaein
Sub vocals - Ireh and dosie
Main rapper - Yuki
Lead rapper - Chain or Dosie
Main dancer - Dosie and Ireh
Lead dancer - Yuki and Jieun
Visual - ( even though all of them are, I'm gonna pick using stereotypes) Jieun
Center - Swan ( because good expretions) and probably Goeun ( because the most stage presence from what I see)
Face - Goeun ( cause she seems the most confident)
@@SurendraKumar-fc2ej i think Center should be dosie;-;-
YUKI’S RAP GAVE ME LIFE MAN
Honestly, IREH and Dosie shined in the Dance break and Dosie's facial expression was on point, so it didn't seem too little. This distribution is not equal, but IN MY OPINION, it's fair.
All of them shine on their positions.
exactly this right here, and people forget their positions in the group, I mean its not like their main vocals or lead vocals, they make up for those lines with their dancing and presence and they bring that to the group
It’s literally like Goeun and Swan having a sing-off
Cause they are the main vocals, they got the most lines. Lines will be more even after there debut. They had to show there best capabilities here, the main dancers got a dance break AND they were in the middle of the dances many times. The rapper wrote her own rap lines. It will be more fair next time, just support the girls with there debut cause they seem happy with it 😌
@@SurendraKumar-fc2ej we get it omg calm down
@@athleticgal I was chill while writing that comment, and it doesn't seem like you guys get it cause they're are SO many comments complaining. Your not a fan of you already start to complain, give the girls a break
even though ireh and dosie don’t have a lot of lines, they had a lot of screen time on the mv that made them stand out more than others so please everyone do not take it out on goeun and swan, they’re the main vocalists. if u want to blame someone, blame whoever distributed the lines.
and jieun? lmao they didnt even bother cover up the little lines they gave her with enough screen time
ya ampun coy, baru juga debut, kita tunggu aja, lambat laun pasti pembagiannya bakal adil kok.
Ireh didn't get screen time, and the actual only reason why Dosie is maintaining her popularity is because of how incredible her presence is.
also in their debut it shows on what they are more comfortable in
i mean, technically the members distributed the lines, so you *could* blame them..... jk but fr they all decided to distribute it this way bc swan and goeun wrote it and their vocals suited it the best. it's the debut song, they're all top heavy to get people hooked, and then things even out as people start stanning and sticking around
the song is so good but the line distribution.. this is like Everglow bside level
You are not wrong and also Loona Hi high level too
@@tammybeboso4968 oof that hits different when you're both an orbit and a forever
@@igotchumandontworry5370 haseul: ottokee😭
@@slaypa 💀
I disagree! Im not usually one to look or care too deeply into the lines debacle, but it must be said... the line distribution is the sole thing that puts me off Everglow. They just always make it about Mia.
They have had so many releases to show growth but it's always Mia overshadowing the rest in the lines department. I don't think this is nearly as bad as Everglows case especially considering its only their debut, they still have time.
*Stan Purple Kiss*
Or get a bloody top
I really wish people wouldn't always get so on the attack about line distributions ALL THE TIME. I'm not here to offend or upset anyone, but i'm just giving my two cents on the matter. As a HUGE long time Mamamoo fan, I have followed Purple Kiss since their teasers and have been SO excited for their debut.
From how I see it; GoEun & Swan are the strongest vocalists, then Chaein & JiEun are the other two primary vocalists so its expected they get the most lines on their debut to show off. Ireh and Dosie are the primary dancers of the group, they by default aren't gonna get as many lines on the debut title track and have more focus on their dance and visuals too. Yuki is the sole rapper and writes the lyrics herself, much like Soyeon, shes going to end up with alot of lines.
This is literally their debut and people are immediately salty about it, when I can guarantee all of the members are happy with the outcome - as they are part of a great company and all got to participate in writing and composing this title track & mini album. Give them time to flesh out their discography before calling "mistreatment" or who "deserved" what...I think we are so used to seeing Mamamoo's consistently equal distribution across their releases, but we are looking at a 4 member group to a 7 member, its just never going to appear as even especially on their DEBUT.
All of this? YES
Also - Mamamoo in the early days had a HEAVY focus on Wheein and Solar. Their debut song had only two parts for Moonbyul. This continued until Pink Funky era where Moonbyul got most of Esna's lines in Ahh Oop, and the lengthy rap sections in Um Oh Ah Yeh. From then on, the distributions became more fair.
So I agree, if the girls are happy, leave it be. The line distributions will eventually become more fair as the girls continue to explore their composition, vocal, and rap skills.
This commentary should be on top, up up up
I won’t be surprised though since that’s what kpop fans say most of the time 🤣
Kpop fans say anything these days, thinking they know EVERYTHING about their idols. "Oh obviously these members want to sing more!" "No, they are satisfied with this because they were involved in the line distribution!" Your response is the most logical one tbh. Kpop IS a business, not a college presentation group.
Some of them saying that this is mistreatment like it is just the start, how do you say so
WOW I didn't expect this 😳 Because the screentime seems very good
Not a fully Purple Kiss stan yet but I really feel like:
Goeun, Dosie, Chaein and Swan really own Ponzoña as a whole! (These four charisma are really shine a lot for me~)
Interesting...I don’t disagree on Go Eun & Swan but that’s probably because they dominated the vocal lines. They did write the song (together with rapper Yuki) so I guess that makes sense, they clearly vibe really well with the song. Speaking of Yuki (rapper), maybe it’s just me but I think she jumps off the screen anytime she appears....not just when rapping but in that red gown! She just looks so expensive! Definite bias material & you should go back & check out her pre debut teaser.....talk about charisma! & she only just turned 18.
Unfortunately, other than the short dance break I thought both Chaein & Dosie were kind of lost but that’s ok because they both shined in the pre debut songs. Knowing RBW, they’ll keep everything fairly harmonious.
Dont worry people they will sing in the future, this is just like how RBW did to Mamamoo... the surprise shall be in the future not now 🥰🥰🥰
They were the one that do the distribution themselves
1:54 is actually Dosie line, I knew this video is old but when I rewatched the performance live Dosie sung that part
Correction:
0:11 is Swan not Chaein
1:53 is Dosie not Goeun
Also 2:48 adlib is Goeun, she sang it in the performance
yaasssss
I noticed it too
Watch their performance
Up
Thanks for noticing
at 1:53, it's actually Dosie. she sang that line live while Goeun didnt.
3:03 an update to the layout the message was attached to each other wow 🤩
I thought it was a mistake lmaoo
@@harshmallowiee im confused
Their vocals are out of this world wooow and unique ..... They have potential
I am honestly so happy and in love with purple kiss and this fandom because it is so peaceful and everyone understands rbw and their artist so well. I hope we can keep it this way forever💜💜💜💜
Goeun really really improved
Hope they will make many best comebacks.
yea since pd48 she didn't really get screentime for some one who was in the A class like what????????
I love Goeun and Swan to death, they're literally my 2 biases, but what is this distribution? 😐 RBW, I know Goeun and Swan are insanely talented but don't disregard the fact that this is a 7-MEMBER GROUP. There's literally a whole minute gap between Goeun and Ireh and Dosie. Really upsetting.
I’m pretty sure that this isn’t rbw and the girls distribute the song themselves, since that’s what mamamoo did and it would make sense since swan was the one who wrote the whole song minus yuki’s rap
@@rizzizzippi their debut is already successful. it's the debut that sold the most copies in the last two years on the first day. these girls are doing amazing as is. Ireh and Dosie got less lines but an entire dance break since their main dancers, and not only that but dosie got a ton of screen time because of her iconic hair. I'd say it's pretty fair. And most importantly, all debuts are not balanced when it comes to lines, dancers focus on dancing and singers focus on singing. so chill out, everything is fine
Some groups do that for their for showcase the best vocalist
@@pennymikk how many albums they sold on first day?
Dont worry, go to PurKi channel and watch their old videos where they do oldies covers~
I should say they are all vocalists, well it's RBW thing hahaha
I love Ji Eun nasally vocals in one of their video
The line distribution surprised me so much, watching the MV i wouldn’t have noticed how bad it was cuz each member shines to much in it and the choreography
I really like Jieun's voice 😍 She did great
when I first saw the title I was like: *shoot! take a ✨Ponzona✨*
Dosie didn’t have many lines, but she stood out the most to me
Jieun is a good vocalist. Hope she'll get more lines in their near comebacks.
Say all you want about the line distribution, but i think rbw is actually smart with this move. Every member gets a killing part of their own.
Goeun, Swan and Chaein gets most of the vocal and chorus centres because their vocal colours are PK's main charm; Dosie and Ireh get the centres during the dance break because main dancers; Yuki gets her charismatic rap parts; Jieun is the least confident member and her higher registers are not as distinct as the main vocal line (not saying she's not a good vocalist) so rather than giving her parts she's less comfortable with, she gets lines that fit her voice perfectly and also the outro part which is just long enough for her charisma (and visuals. i knew she is the visual but omg i was shooketh at that part) to show through but not too long that her confidence starts to wane.
It is important for each member to be at least recognised for one thing now. They just debuted. There's still plenty of time for them to grow and show more
Happy debut, girls! 🎊
I'm not surprised or mad about the distribution. Swan and Na Goeun are clearly the best singers in the group *and* they're the ones who wrote and composed the song, not knowing it would be used as the debut track, so it was created to suit their voices. This is not Mamamoo which had 3 equally fantastic, top tier vocalists + a quite solid rapper. There's a definite range of singing and dancing capabilities in the group. Some of the girls who didn't sing as much were in the center for dancing.
Anyway, the other tracks have more lines for the other girls, and this is just the debut.
Yuki also took part in producing this song. She wrote her rap and I'm so amazed, because she is Japanese and her rap in Korean is fire even tho it's not her 1st language so it could be problematic to her
That's not an excuse. Everyone in purple kiss can sing aell and the fact Goeun and Swan are the best singers doesn't change the fact the others can sing well. I would understand if they were all poor singer but everyone can sing so well.
1:52 that's dosie, the live performances say its her part
I don't mind the Line distribution all too much. I do wish the other girls had a bit more. But I seen a lot of people assuming the girls positions. Here is my assumtion(Not sayings its true- only what I think)
Goeun> Main Vocalist, Lead Dancer, Center
Jieun> Lead Vocalist, Visual
Chaein> Lead Vocalist, Lead Dancer, Rapper
Yuki> Main Rapper, Lead Dancer, Sub-Vocalist
Dosie> Main Dancer, Lead Rapper, Sub-Vocalist
Ireh> Main Dancer, Sub-Vocalist
Swan> Main Vocalist, Maknae
IF THIS IS TRUE- Then it makes sense for the way the line distribution is. Although you'd think with Jieun/Chaein possibly being Lead Vocalist, they'd get more lines. But I'm not mad at Dosie and Ireh lack of lines. ONLY because they are clearly apart of the dance line regardless of what position they have and it shows. They own the dance break and most choreo they do.
But thats my opinion, please don't hate..
I agree with the positions
A debut that give chills and dark vibes to the group's universe 😍 a baby dreamcatcher but more sweet
Yuki rap is just so powerful it gave me chills
While others may be debating or disappointed about the line distribution, to me it's perfect! The screen time on the mv, including the live performance. They do get their own screen time and their center position - making everyone equal. Besides, each member contributed to the overall performance which I believe is far more important than line distribution.
Unless you do only "listen" to the song itself without the video, you'd be quite surprised that each member stands out with their unique voices.
PLEASE SUPPORT PURPLE KISS. They do deserve the love, recognition as well as a chance in this industry.
I 100% agree!
1:53-:1:16 it’s Dosie
They should have put a flash warning in the mv other people will get dizzy when watching Ponzoña mv.
Yea
Have other mvs with the same flashs and don't have it...
@@Agnaldo_sju yeah
@@Agnaldo_sju yeah but they should because some people who are sensitive can have seizures
@@user-hy7jm3ws3m And you think if they care about this??? The company just care about money...
You know this song's distribution would be better if
0:36 - 0:38 : Ireh
0:38 - 0:43: Dosie
1:13 - 1:15 : Jieun and Ireh
2:37 - 2:44 : Jieun
2:45 - 2:53 : Ireh
2:59 - 3:02 - Jieun and Dosie
3:07 - 3:09 - Jieun and Ireh
Dosie doesn't need a lot of line since she has a lot of center and the dance break (As a dance line with Ireh and Goeun)
Chaein is a part of the dance line
Goeun is not part of dance line
@@iicrazyii7575 she is go to kpop profiles
@@foodiepotato74 ik but it ain’t accurate
@@iicrazyii7575 the dance line is confirmed as Dosie,Ireh,Chaein,Yuki and Goeun
istg they deserve more recognition.
RBW is really smart. This is really fair. Go Eun and Swan may have the most lines, it is only good considering they are the best vocalists of the group. Eventho Ireh and Dosie had the least lines, they had the most screen time AND centers of the dance break.
I dont get why people in the comments should be arguing it is like Go Eun and Swan, ft. Members. Some are also saying this is just like Everglow when they debuted cause its totally different. If u watch their stage performances, you can see that no one overshadows or outcasted the group. So lets appreciate this masterpiece instead of only focusing on the line distribution alone.
IKR, on music shows i keep focusing on dosie,ireh and jieun because if their stage presence even though they got less lines they get your attention
It's just like No lie. I wondered why everyone it sounded like two voices and it ended to be Go eun and Swan lmao. It's not fair.
@@ggstan2439 lmao. Its FAIR. Do u really expect it to be equal as the main vocals?? FYI, Yuki was given a rap. Ji Eun was the center in the last part. Chaein had great lines. Ireh and Dosie had the center dance break. In their mv, Dosie and Ireh as well as the others had the most screentime than the two vocals: go eun and swan. Its not like NO LIE as ur referring. If u still think its unfair, idk whats the meaning of ur FAIR.
@@briespen The meaning of Fair means not only 2 members in a 7 membered group sing more than half of the song alone when the vocal gap isn't even big compared to the rest (mainly Swan) while true GREAT vocals for smaller groups gets way less than that, just like Wendy and actually Yuju. Doesn't matter screentime, dancebreak or whatever, it doesn't affect their vocal thing, they also trained as singers and also deserve lines, if they have a breakdance, ok they are good dancers but this doesn't change the fact they need singing lines.
If Swan and Go eun still on the top but with less lines it would be fair. In what world 2 members in a 7 membered group sing the start, verses, high notes, adlibs, the chorus, bridge, pre-chorus it's fair?? Again, they are a grouo with 2 Mias and 5 Ondas.
Not to mention screentime is the most mediocre thing, they will not promote the MV everytime they sing the song, it's just them and the song, not the MV and eventho some have more and some have less everyone still apear a lot.
@@ggstan2439 but they still sang tho?? I think its fair since the members with the least lines have the the most screentime in their stages. And they have predebut solo songs that showcased their abilities. This is getting annoying. Why the heck does people complain in lines as if their the one singing the songs. FYI, the members are a self produced meaning they picked the lines they are comfortable with. The dance is very tiring too so they might not have the great stability especially since their singing live. This is just their debut and people are complaining AS IF theyve been around for years and still have that so called unfair lines.
1:54 is dosie not go eun
dosie sang that part at the midnight idol show.
2:58 is everyone singing. (maybe) that's what I saw and heard at the midnight idol show too.
Last number of like is your bias :
1. Goeun
2. Chaein
3. Swan
4. Ireh
5. Yuki
6. Jieun
7. Dosie
8. All
9. Goeun & Yuki
0. Chaein & Swan
jieun
In 1:53 it has been confirmed that is Dosie who sings instead of Goeun
the line "bujeonghal su eomneun jinsil" the one who sings is the original dosie but random_k thinks it's goeun who sings before ireh say "ponzona"
Popular opinion: Everyone wants to see this song as soon as possible
What does it mean in Spanish?
@@coronavirus3102 poison
@@juansuarez0126 oh thanks
someone did this line distribution and thought it was okay omg...
Why no one is talking about goeun's vocals , it's fire 🔥
I already have my bias❤️
Finally Goeun debuted! I had expected this since the Produce 48 season back in 2018. She was one of my favorites at the time and unfortunately ended up not making her debut as an IzOne member. But I'm happy to see her now on PurpleKiss. Dragging on the lines, l and visuals “what is this wonderful purple hair, so shocked”! 😍 She is definitely my bias already in that group.
드디어 고은이 데뷔! 2018 년 프로듀스 48 시즌 이후로 기대 했었죠. 당시 제가 가장 좋아하는 사람 중 하나 였는데 안타깝게도 아이즈 원 멤버로 데뷔하지 못했어요. 하지만 지금 PurpleKiss에서 그녀를 만나서 기쁩니다. 라인, l, 비주얼 드래그 "이 멋진 보라색 머리카락이 뭐야, 너무 깜짝이야"! 그녀는 이미 그 그룹에있는 나의 편견입니다. 🤍
I find this to be pretty fair, Dosie seemed to get lots of screen time, whcih makes her 4 secs seem like 15
i think it would be a lot of work for random_k to make a 'random_j' like japanese line distributions aaaa
Honestly, Goeun and Swan's lines could have easily been divided between Ireh, Jieun and Dosie as they are genuinely great vocalists (as shown in predebut clips), so I am quite disappointed but it's a good debut song.
Goeun and Swan - PONZONA (MV) (Feat. Chaein and Yuki of Purple Kiss)
😍
jieun got way more lines than i expected
definitely, it wasn’t noticeable in the mv but once you learn their voices you realize how many times she was harmonizing with some members
That patreon deserves an award
I wrote singable English lyrics 😃 try it out!
Purple on the top
PURPLE KISS on bloody top
Oh bloody top, I'm on my way
It's time for me to take my seat now ooh
Oh you must have been waiting for so long
Don't you know?
There is no way to stop, no way to stop
You should hold your breath real tight
As I colour you I, colour you I
It's the poison that's in my kiss mark
As it's spreading you are surely losing it, no
But you cannot deny it still
Ponzona
Baby PURPLE KISS on bloody top
I am painting purple everything
I have made you crazy, fall in love
You better know, you better know
Can't escape me no more
La la la la shout it out
La la la la louder
In a world that's been lost so
Purple on the top
I know you can feel it spreading everywhere
My arrow that landed right there where I meant
I know you want something
Where do you see your own self
Throw everything you have at me at once
Born that night, I'm special, it's so mystical
And my skill is to be a charming criminal
Come and follow me and see
and don't say what you don't need
I am bang bang aiming for the heart but keep on shining now ay
As it's spreading you are surely losing it, no
But you cannot deny it still
Ponzona
Baby PURPLE KISS on bloody top
I am painting purple everything
I have made you crazy, fall in love
You better know, you better know
Can't escape me no more
La la la la shout it out
La la la la louder
In a world that's been lost so
Purple on the top
Purple on the top
Try to find some piece in a place that shines bright
As I keep walking my scent will haunt you
and you'll be confused to see
Actually you don't know any
of this story
You keep falling deeper now
Into this unknown ground
Baby kiss me eh eh
Oh-oh ooh-woah
Ponzona
PURPLE KISS on bloody top
Baby PURPLE KISS on bloody top
I am painting purple everything
I have made you crazy, fall in love
You better know, you better know
Can't escape me no more
You're addicted no doubt
And there is no way out
La la la la shout it out
La la la la louder
You're addicted no doubt
And there is no way out
La la la la shout it out
Purple on the top
If you liked this you can find more like this on my channel!
Excelente trio! espera....
1: 53 It's Dosie
This was a pretty fair line distribution if you ask me
Yes Ireh and Dosie got nice screen time that covers up the lack of lines, but Jieun has very little lines and half of the seconds of lines here are shared with Goeun (the La la la la part) and she has like 10 seconds only of screen time despite being the visual. I feel like she was done the dirtiest here cause I barely noticed her in the MV.
I feel like this makes sense for a début song, they had to show off their strongest singers -- Dosie and Ireh really do stand out in the performance, and I honestly can't get over Jieun's few lines as well :')
dosie didnt get so many lines but her beauty is no joke
IKR, HER BEAUTY MAKES YOU FOCUS ON HER EVEN THOUGH SHE HAS LESS LINES.
Currently whipping
Mistakes in this video:
1:22 1:26 Dosie 'oh oh oh'
1:53 is Dosie's line and not Goeun's
2:02 Jieun sings 'Bloody top' together with Goeun here, not just Goeun
2:55 2:58 3:04 3:06 Jieun sings 'Yeah' 'Oh' not Goeun
Thanks 😊
Omg you're right
@@cookiejareveluv ♥
@@vg4025 source?
@@auternionn_ u can literally hear it + see during stage performances
1:54 is actually Dosie :)
idk what a ponzona is but it sounds cool... so here i am
Ponzona means Poison in Spanish
Those two who got so many lines, their voices are so beautiful.. i know they are main vocalists.. i'm a new fan btw.. i'm in love with their voices..
Well, as a hispanic i feel sad bcz of the fact they didn't sing "Ponzoña" that much. But at the same time i feel sad bcz of the line distribution
ok I'm an Hispanic too and wth is a ponzona? am I dumb for not knowing that?
@@rosy3447 Ponzona means Poison.
@@thepuppyplayer890 oh ok thx for telling me!
ITS THE DEBUT WHICH WAS PRODUCED GOOD FOR ME
NA GOEUN canta muy hermoso
good job!
Since everglow have more fair line distributions now, somebody had to replace them and to be the most unfair line distributed group
Edit: I know, that Everglow isn’t the only group, which has bad line distributions, they’re also loona and groups, but they still have not really good distributed lined, although Everglow is doing changes and I meant that if everglow has more fair line distribution, then some group has to replace them and to be one of the most unfair distributed groups
Dude this is just their debut calm down
@Nirupama Urs B blackpink isn't unfair compared to so many other groups
@Nirupama Urs B lmao sure
@Nirupama Urs B they all have like 20% every cb LMAO wym
@Nirupama Urs B ever heard of (g)idle or iz*one or loona those groups have unfair LDs not bp
0:12 Swan
1:54 Dosie
So Ireh is the last
there's some mistakes. the "purple kiss on bloody top" is Swan, not Chaein. i know they showed Chaein in the live performances but she could be only lipsyncing. that's Swan's voice (and they even showed her in the mv)
you also gave one of Dosie's lines to Goeun
I'm obsessed with Yuki's rap
Oh I thought they were saying "purple all the time" lol
since this's a debut song. i hope the line distribution will slowly even out over time.
Dosie and Ireh: a
company: Okay you already sang a lot
YYEAAH PURPLE ON THE TOP:"""
is this a duet or a group song? cuz clearly two girls are the only ones singing like 80% of the song lmao
they choose their own line sooo
but other members still stands out. Their Mv screen time is fair, the dance line (Dosie & Ireh) who have a least line have dance break. I think thats fair.
I am enchanted with how eloquently Yuki is able to rap in a rhythmic manner.
Sorry for my bad English
Ok I think it is totally ok that Swan and Goeun sing the most (since they sing each chorus) but I don't get why there are still members with not even 5 seconds like huuuh?!?!?
Mamamoo also had a balanced line distribution so I don't get why they do this to Purple Kiss now
moonbyul literally had 2 lines in their debut though??
Mamamoo's vocalists were all equally good, this isn't the case with PK.
@@miracledtimeline Moonbyul is an exception cuz she is a rapper
Jeez y'all need to get a brain and understand that they were the main dancers and if you look at there dance, they got the most center. They had to show there best capabilities for debut it'll get more even after that. And not all are gonna be the vocals, the dancers will get best at dancing, rapper will get the rap, visual will get the most screen time
Plz use ur brains. Cause eventho Ireh and Dosie had the least lines, they were THE CENTER of the dance break. And also has the most screen time. It is only fair.
these girls shall be the revolution
Goeun on the thumbnail really reminds me of Lia of Itzy :D
It's the "Purple on the top" that sends me
i love how the members that dont have as much lines are highlighted in the actual music video! like i would’ve totally thought that dosie and ireh had the most lines just based on their presence and screen time! good job rbw!!!
OMG this too me is like what if Yena was in EVERGLOW
Green-Mia
Pink-ish-Sihyeon
Purple- Aisha
Red-Yena
Pink-Yiren
And then the last two are Eu and Onda
?? Yena is the most popular domestically and the best singer. She would be atleast green.
The gap- Im ded girlie right there really sang a whole minute and left no crumbs
Is this gonna be one of those groups where we have to wait 4 years for a decent line distribution on a title track ?
this is only their debut chill out
@@Aoir I'm very chilled, thank you. I proposed a valid question since a lot of groups that start out with line distributions like this often take years to change.
Their bsides look better so I'm not actually sure. Or maybe they're focusing on 2 members per era?
@@candirita literally jieun dosie and Ireh are always last in LD even in their bsides. Have you seen period, jieun ireh have less than 2sec and dosie 5sec on that song, the only pretty fair LD is Skip Skip.
@@aki2957 Oh lol I've only checked skip skip since I'm lazy. Ignore my last message then I just read it somewhere else
hope the one who requested this a very bloody top 👌
Okay goeun and Swan have beautiful voices but if the line distribution is gonna be like this, why didn't they debut a duo. The other girls have great voices too
first of all… this line distribution is pretty damn fair compared to a lot of these other groups, and its VERY fair regarding positions… they all shined some way during this, I mean yeah dosie and ireh didnt get much lines but keep in mind they’re most likely sub vocalists, meaning lines wont really be present… meaning they have a whole other thing to give to the plate aka their dancing, dosie was most talked about plus she got hella screen time, now yuki got a good amount of lines, rappers dont rap the whole time so ya know.. shes a sub vocalist too, now as for chaein and jieun they got a good amount of lines too since they’re lead vocals
dosie’s “ponzona” gives me chills every time, she is my bias i think (new plory)
I love this song and I don't blame the girls but... The hypocrisy right here is incredible. Because apparently they all chose their lines, it's totally fine if 2 members of the group share 2/3 of the song. This shows how people hate Soyeon just to hate on her, because it's the same for idle, but everyone hates Soyeon for it meanwhile everyone is happy about this line distribution.
it's their debut song ofc they want to put the main vocalists front and center to showcase that they do have strong vocals in the group and their screen time and dance center distribution is pretty good, im sure that their next songs would include more lines for the other members
imagine training your whole life just to have about 5 seconds
most groups are like that, unfortunately. bts, loona, everglow, izone and many others have idols who have trained a lot and have few lines
Vivi and haseul's hey intensifies
@@coronavirus3102 😂😂
Purple kiss is amazing