The tall woman who appears beginning at 4:18 is Blanche Payson. She had film roles opposite many comedians including Laurel and Hardy and Buster Keaton.
So much art is variations on a theme. Bach takes a series of notes, produces 64 variations of it and it becomes Partita Ciaccona. Morandi's and Cy Twombly's paintings are endless variations on simple themes. Charlie Chaplin takes the simplest possible theme, a stick stuck in a grid, and turns into a dramatic confrontation.
I loveeeee 6:19 - couldn't stop laughing. The shopkeeper is saying for the tramp to use his head, and then he mistakes it for his hat, and then you can see the shopkeeper mouth, "Oh, Jesus Christ!" Too funny.
I watched this flick when they showed it at college in the early 80s and I thought it was hilarious, but especially the poking-the-stick bit, I can't believe it was cut. Later I'd see the movie on TV waiting for the scene and it wasn't there! : (
I tend to agree. In all honesty, Chaplin probably thought so too. I’m sure that’s why it was cut. I am glad it survives as a “deleted scene” because it’s certainly brilliant, amusing and well crafted. The thing about Chaplin is he was spending his own money and he could indulge himself all he wanted...working out ideas on film, doing multiple takes on a scene. This film notoriously took him forever to complete.
According to Unknown Chaplin, this was to have been our introduction to Charlie in City Lights. While I applaud all of the elements of this scene, I can see why Chaplin put it to the side. No faulting it’s construction or execution. But there’s no denying that the rhythm is laboured and even if it was tightened it would be stretching the limits of logic. Just my opinion. It’s brilliant for an outtake, but it is an outtake. That was his process and it worked for him. He found a far stronger way to enter the story and we are lucky that this escaped the flames and can enjoy an artist at work.
Чарли Чаплин самый выдающийся трагикомик! Когда смотришь его фильмы, забываешь любые стрессы, его маленький человек так близок к сердцу, вместо с ним поживаешь его невзгоды.
Они все там. Все они. Они вышли из повседневной жизни, чтобы стать мгновенным фоном в фильме. Теперь их всех нет. Все исчезло, кроме фрагмента пленки. Реальные они или нет, но все они исчезли. Фильм кричит. Вы слышите его?
The messenger boy is played by Charles Lederer who was Marion Davies's nephew. He went on to be a director and screenwriter whose screenwriting credits include "Gentlemen Prefer Blondes" and "Ocean's 11."
The other two great endings (not including Schindler's List) are La Strada by Fellini, and Les Enfants du Paradis by Carne. Also The 400 Blows by Truffaut and Bicycle Thieves by de Sica. There are more- - Shoot the Piano Player also by Truffaut, Once Upon a Time in the West by Leoni, Mon Oncle by Tati. These have endings that change lives.
Ça ne lui est pas convenu et il n'a pas retenu ces scènes mais ces fort drôle. Chaplin est éternel et intemporel pour des siecles comme buster keaton laurel et hardy.
Charlie Chaplin is always funny and one of the things funny about this scene is the fact that all those people passing by are getting just "almost" out of frame before turning around and making circuit back around!
Every little things in the corner of life could be very very funny, Charlie he knew that so well , that little thing could attract big thing,, , 🤣😂🙄, to day comedian make big things end up nothing but depressed, 😭 that is also funny,, . The truth is all human are look funny, the best comedian are the one who aware of that,,. Comedia veritas,
Such a depiction wouldn't be allowed in films today. Even though this classic was made nearly a century ago, it's rather painful and uncomfortable watching the messenger in this scene. He probably could've been presented as one of average intelligence and done what you suggested. I like the idea CC had of the Tramp becoming obsessed with such a trivial concern--the humor's in his fascination over how it works or the purpose it serves. One drawback--CC's looking away with disinterest whenever the public stops and stares at his poking at the wooden-piece in the grate with his cane--he does this a few times too many, dissipating his quick-change into an indifferent "gentleman", making it look like the passersby are nuts for staring at him. Amusing once or twice but loses its comical effect eventually. Still a great scene that probably could've worked, if handled a little differently and trimmed to make shorter.
They are all there. All of them. They stepped out of daily life to become momentary background in a film. They're all gone now. Its all gone except for a clip of film. Real or not they are all gone. The film screams. Can you hear it?
Chaplin is the greatest comedian of all time. Period.
Couldn't agree more.
@@alexorlov8634 bruh
You’ll get no argument from me.
Buster all the way
Without a single dialogue how come he laughs everyone, what a legend he is ... hats off...
His timing is perfect, a Genius actor
He even composed the wonderful music.. genius
It's true, il a composé de formidables musiques, marvelous ❤
I love the times when everybody wears beautiful hats 👒🎩💖
Even his deleted picture's are incredible. Leave it to Charlie Chaplin to make everything he does just magical. ❤
The tall woman who appears beginning at 4:18 is Blanche Payson. She had film roles opposite many comedians including Laurel and Hardy and Buster Keaton.
And The Three Stooges
@@raulbarrientos7042 And who was that gaping fruit eating actor??
@@gothatch2502 ese personaje es muy interesante. Realmente me maravillo ante la genialidad y profundidad de Chaplin.
Thank you Joe!
@@raulbarrientos7042🤭
This could be a half hour longer and I'd still watch it.
Exactly!
Besides being a great film. One thing I loved are the background women walking the streets. They all looked stylish & beautiful.
CHARLIE CHAPLIN ACTUALLY KNEW WHAT WAS THE BEST 😊IN EACH OF HIS MOVIES 🎥 TO PHYSICALY USES FOR THE MOST POPULAR MUSIC 🎶 OF IT'S TIME!
Just a stick stuck between the bars and he is poking it, trying to push it in. And HE managed to make it so hilarious and unique.
I'm sure Charlie had his reasons to cut this out, but i found it amusing and enjoyed that entire sequence.
So much art is variations on a theme. Bach takes a series of notes, produces 64 variations of it and it becomes Partita Ciaccona. Morandi's and Cy Twombly's paintings are endless variations on simple themes. Charlie Chaplin takes the simplest possible theme, a stick stuck in a grid, and turns into a dramatic confrontation.
Charlie was the best Actor ever.
That’s what Laurence Olivier said about him!
Thank God he deleted this. Doesn't take story forward. But then he was a master. And what a brilliant movie!
I loveeeee 6:19 - couldn't stop laughing.
The shopkeeper is saying for the tramp to use his head, and then he mistakes it for his hat, and then you can see the shopkeeper mouth, "Oh, Jesus Christ!" Too funny.
I watched this flick when they showed it at college in the early 80s and I thought it was hilarious, but especially the poking-the-stick bit, I can't believe it was cut. Later I'd see the movie on TV waiting for the scene and it wasn't there! : (
Nothing in the world is funnier than this.
I see why this wasn’t put into the final film. It seems to drag on a little bit.
I tend to agree. In all honesty, Chaplin probably thought so too. I’m sure that’s why it was cut. I am glad it survives as a “deleted scene” because it’s certainly brilliant, amusing and well crafted.
The thing about Chaplin is he was spending his own money and he could indulge himself all he wanted...working out ideas on film, doing multiple takes on a scene. This film notoriously took him forever to complete.
@@scottmoore1614SO TRUE 😮
Classic. Far better than any of today's rubbish
Yes
Nce ....
Most modern pop music is absolute rubbish.
@@observer1670 what the....
Chaplin’s throwaways!
My friends might find me weird but I really love his movies
why would you be weird about seeing Chaplin's movies ?
Change your friends. They're maybe too ordinary
@@balastegi 👍👍👍👍
You aren't weird, Anna. You simply have good taste.
Not a thing wrong with that. They’re timeless, hilarious and beautiful. City Lights is arguably the greatest film ever made about love.
According to Unknown Chaplin, this was to have been our introduction to Charlie in City Lights. While I applaud all of the elements of this scene, I can see why Chaplin put it to the side. No faulting it’s construction or execution. But there’s no denying that the rhythm is laboured and even if it was tightened it would be stretching the limits of logic. Just my opinion. It’s brilliant for an outtake, but it is an outtake. That was his process and it worked for him. He found a far stronger way to enter the story and we are lucky that this escaped the flames and can enjoy an artist at work.
Thanks parents to be there in earth to watching that legendary Chaplin 😊😊😊
Saw these on a Chaplin special many years ago. I loved this scene, it was too bad it didn't make it in the film!
It's mad to think this was over a 100 years ago
I myself love very much Charlie Chaplin film and I believe there is no one can play like him in this s now day
It's like weird meets a weirder.... Lol
Kept staring at him untill he left.
Charlie Chaplin was a very intelligent person. He has written many great Music works.
with simple matter he created the episode, legend..
I think Charlie was so charming in City Lights.
I love ❤️ Charlie Chaplin 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
The whole movie theater was laughing loud at that time. Very funny silent movies.
I have never seen this scene before. It is as good as the whole movie. It is a shame they cut it out.
I love you LEGEND 😊😊😊😊
Love you always sir Charlie Chaplin 🙏🏽💫 from a remote village odisha, India❤️
Can’t. Stop. Laughing. At. Charlie.
one man show. brilliant
The master ..the crowd work was exceptional.
Charlie siempre me hace el día más feliz 😁❤️.
Hi
Hii
It always makes me laugh when he bends his bamboo cane while leaning against it :D
Just to be there for a day and come back home! Decent folks, well I would definately think so!
p
Man I love Charlie
Looking at the passers by in the back ground, made my head spin how fast they walk!..lol..
His silence said everything
@Sanjoy Ghosh. What? Do you mean he is now entertaining God in Heaven?
Charlie was the king of silent films.
His talkies were amazing too (Limelight, The Great Dictator, Monsieur Verdoux, A King in New York).
Chaplin y la tablita...como me hizo reír con algo tan condenadamente simple?
Чарли Чаплин самый выдающийся трагикомик! Когда смотришь его фильмы, забываешь любые стрессы, его маленький человек так близок к сердцу, вместо с ним поживаешь его невзгоды.
Они все там. Все они. Они вышли из повседневной жизни, чтобы стать мгновенным фоном в фильме. Теперь их всех нет. Все исчезло, кроме фрагмента пленки. Реальные они или нет, но все они исчезли. Фильм кричит.
Вы слышите его?
The extras are the same people just going around in circles
Qué Dios te guarde ati y atu familiares
i like the way women are dressed.
I wish he still exist
Good
Why don't you include the year the film was made ?
City Lights 1931.
i could watch this for hours :))
Good as this was I can see why he cut it from the film.
The Same Here!😮
Juste génial !
Oui génial ! On ne retrouve plus des acteurs si professionnels et si imaginatifs 😭 Charlot on aime beaucoup ❤👍
At 1st when I see the thumbnail I almost thought that it's Buster Keaton and Charles Chaplin Collabs. Almost jumped out from the chair
Thought the same shame they never worked together in the early years
@@Ben-fx5pbTHAT'S ABSOLUTELY RIGHT!😊
“Express” messenger slouching along, has nothing but time, hahaha.
I think I’ve used that service.
The messenger boy is played by Charles Lederer who was Marion Davies's nephew. He went on to be a director and screenwriter whose screenwriting credits include "Gentlemen Prefer Blondes" and "Ocean's 11."
@@victorbrunswickTHAT'S ABSOLUTELY RIGHT ABOUT CHARLES LEDERER!😂😅
Where are those people....
going!?🤔
This movie has the BEST ending of scene of all time. Second would have to be Schindler's List ending scene.
The other two great endings (not including Schindler's List) are La Strada by Fellini, and Les Enfants du Paradis by Carne. Also The 400 Blows by Truffaut and Bicycle Thieves by de Sica. There are more- - Shoot the Piano Player also by Truffaut, Once Upon a Time in the West by Leoni, Mon Oncle by Tati. These have endings that change lives.
@@tobiolopainto🤔👌🧠
Look at their city, so many rabbits not enough room to breathe the polluted air.
Charlie Chaplin was a very intelligent person and what an incredible career !!! 👍🎬 je l'aime beaucoup 😙
ALASBUENAS aparte de disfrutar del Maestro Chaplin uno más y Guapo capicúa APASALOBIEN TÔS
Should have been left in the original. This was seriously funny.
Love this part is so funny And Chaplin looks so cute 😄👍🏻
Melissa Ordonez ya u r right
Love
Yes
OOOOOHHHHH CHARLIE IS SO CUTE WHEN HE SMILES!😊
too funny and interesting, i like it very much.
Ça ne lui est pas convenu et il n'a pas retenu ces scènes mais ces fort drôle.
Chaplin est éternel et intemporel pour des siecles comme buster keaton laurel et hardy.
Oh yes you meant CHARLIE CHAPLIN,BUSTER KEATON😮,LAUREL AND HARDY!😂😅😂
Legend
Damn deleted scene 😂
Really genius
😌🧐🧠
Genial!!!
Count how many times the same people walk by.
That is how street demo sellers operate. Just one watching and everyone flocks
THAT'S ABSOLUTELY RIGHT!😮
Jaja he is a little bit compulsive and obsessive besides of curious 😂😂😂🤪🤪🤪🤪
Aku suka banget sama videonya 🙏🙏🙏
Women were so beautiful and elegant back then.
La Belle Epoch.!
Until they smiled ...
@For Truth fastfood are the death of femminility
@@costabotes9107😀😃😄😁🙂🙃😊😑😏😺😸😹😻
@@pietrobarbato2813SO TRUE 🤢🤮☠️
Charlie Chaplin is always funny and one of the things funny about this scene is the fact that all those people passing by are getting just "almost" out of frame before turning around and making circuit back around!
This scene should be in part of the movie before he met the blind girl ❤️
🤔👌
அருமை... 👌
I do want to see Chaplin statue!
This scene is so Seinfeld before Seinfeld
YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT!😂😅
Це непередавано,яка краса, який зліт мірки, його треба дивитися та вивчати
🤔
Thank you so much for showing this seen
Vinod Rathod nice boro
I love this shtick about a stick!
@@DEB781THE SAME HERE!😂😅
That is a BIG woman @ 04:40 - considering Chaplin was well under 5'6"
CHARLIE CHAPLIN IS REALLY 5 FEET 6 INCHES TALL!🤨
@@jeanbaumgartner4052 He's 162.6 cm according to our British Museum. One needs to be 165 cm for the American's 5'5" if I recall correctly.
Me gustaría vivir en los años de chaplin 😃😃
Who's still watching this comedy show in 2019
ME
Me too
@@LegrejLeforlivet cool
You and me
Not me I’m here in the future 2020 in 2020 there was corona virus and everyone hated it
Lol 😆 🤣
Ilove you charli
I Love 😍😻 CHARLIE Too!
Hi my dear friend
In those era there's no McDonald junk foods that's why all people are skinny.
YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT ABOUT THAT ONE!😊
The persona of the Tramp had become a cliché after so many years. I can't understand what's funny about it.
YOU HAVE NO SINCE OF HUMOR 😀😃😄😁😆😅🤣😂🙂🙃😉😊🥰😍🤩😘😗☺️😚😙🥲😋😛😜🤪😝🤑🤗🤭😏🤤🥳🥸😺😸😹😻😼😽
all tym favorite, forever, and legend 1
🤭
Every little things in the corner of life could be very very funny, Charlie he knew that so well , that little thing could attract big thing,, , 🤣😂🙄, to day comedian make big things end up nothing but depressed, 😭 that is also funny,, . The truth is all human are look funny, the best comedian are the one who aware of that,,. Comedia veritas,
Hola mi corazoncito, ya vine.😃
It would have been funnier if the "learning disabled" man showed him how to push the stick through the grate.
Such a depiction wouldn't be allowed in films today. Even though this classic was made nearly a century ago, it's rather painful and uncomfortable watching the messenger in this scene. He probably could've been presented as one of average intelligence and done what you suggested. I like the idea CC had of the Tramp becoming obsessed with such a trivial concern--the humor's in his fascination over how it works or the purpose it serves. One drawback--CC's looking away with disinterest whenever the public stops and stares at his poking at the wooden-piece in the grate with his cane--he does this a few times too many, dissipating his quick-change into an indifferent "gentleman", making it look like the passersby are nuts for staring at him. Amusing once or twice but loses its comical effect eventually. Still a great scene that probably could've worked, if handled a little differently and trimmed to make shorter.
@@jackbuckley7816YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT ABOUT THAT ONE!😮
Notice how the people of that time were thin? No big bellies on men
Food was more expensive.
Wages were lower...and there was no McDonald's or supersizing meals
Maybe just Hollywood extras were thin.
There weren't any McDonalds on every corner
?
Uncle buster Keaton another of my favourite relative's
BUSTER KEATON IS ONE OF YOUR UNCLES!😎
Gentleman Good Nice man🐶
Hi
They are all there. All of them. They stepped out of daily life to become momentary background in a film. They're all gone now. Its all gone except for a clip of film. Real or not they are all gone. The film screams.
Can you hear it?
😱🙀👂🦻
Charlie Chaplin like here
🤭