It's art, not mathematics. There is no perfect performance, no perfect solution. Just enjoy it. And if you don't, just be on your way, don't leave a comment. It's not an unwillingness to hear criticism, but simply being polite.
I have to agree with many of those who say this isn’t up to the high standards we’re used to. Nick’s drumming is understandably not how he’s played. The vocals are unharmonious. I could go on. But surely some of the issues are because of the sound recording, which probs loses so much? Long live Floyd.
I don't know why RUclips is constantly pushing fake Pink Floyd and fake Hawkwind on me. And Beatle bullshit promo. You click on one of these things once and you're doomed for life to hitting the "not interested" button .
Para mi Nik Mason es un bateria infravalorado pues yo lo pondría a la altura de Keith Moon, Jhon Bonhan, Mich Michel etc un saudiño dende GALIZA ESPAÑA
Ничто не сравнится с оригиналом!!!, но все равно - спасибо!!!! У тех людей была душа и искусство!!! Сейчас- это просто технически не плохо сделанная копия!!!! Спасибо и низкий поклон рок группе Pink Floyd!!! Они превзошли это фальшивый мир!!!!Их невозможно скопировать!!!!
😂❤🎉😂❤🎉😂?THANK'S NICK MASON'S FOR THIS CRETION😂❤🎉🎉BEAUTIFUL, WONDERFUL, MERVEILLOUS,......😅I LOVE YOUR MUSIC😂❤🎉🎉😂❤🎉❤😂🎉❤😂🎉❤CONGRATULATIONS WITH TO MY RESPECTS😂🎉❤😂❤🎉😂❤🎉😂🎉❤SUPER CADEAU D'ANNIVERSAIRE......ET DE NOEL AUSSI
Had front n center seats for their Cincinnati show, then covid did away with that show entirely. Now i gotta figure out how to see him before its too damn late. David doesn't tour anymore n ive seen roger enough times to pay my mortgage.
It lacks the enchanting passion of the original Pompei video version-the oldie but goodie...sort of like an elevator sanitized version of Echos. It's nice, but not magical. And I agree...Nick is a fine fellow. Not dissing the band of fine musicians, but there's an emotional punch that's just not here.
I saw David and Richard play echoes at Massey Hall in 2006 that was a million time better. Even Guy Pratt doesn't seem to be at his best. What is going on here? That doesn't sounds right at all.
Nick and his team make a good job 👍🏼 and bring to us the chance to see the Pink Floyd early years live. Meanwhile Roger Waters makes a desservice / shit creating a new version of DSotM trying to kill one of the best music records of all times.
Lei allora non ha compreso il messaggio musicale profondo che ha dato Roger con DSOTM REDUX. Non sono paragonabili le due opere!!! Comunque resta il fatto che i testi delle opere Floydiane sono per la maggior parte frutto dell’ ingegno di Roger Water. Senza Roger e Syd non ci sarebbero stati i Pink!!!
Tout à fait d’accord …. J’adore Nick mais il faut admettre queil est peut-être temps d’arrêter tout ça. Sur certaines autres chansons ça peut toujours aller mais Echoes. Non
@@tjprptchable How did they not agree? David and Nik are triends and the fact that The Band brought Pink Floyd's first albums , which neither David nor Roger did , they welcomed this whth great enthusiasm.
@sebastianocangini3834 in all respects I cannot understand anything you just wrote 💀. But I should clarify what I ment by they couldn't get along. I'm not talking about all of them I men David and Roger. I understand that David cannot play echoes live ever again without Richard Wright but I don't see it being disrespectful that nick mason and his band played it on there tour. Also first of all Syd barret made the band and was the leader of the band so pink Floyd's first elbum has nothing to do with david gilmore because david didint join the band and help on there music till there second elbum. And Roger was a important factor to pink floyds sound and he definitely worked on floyds first elbum same as Nick and Wright.I saw nick mason and his band play and they were fantastic and better than Roger's current tour wich I saw as well. Overall Nick Mason is not being disrespectful, he is spreading the legacy on in respects to Syd, David, Roger, and Wright they even talked about them at the show it's a tribute to the once forever pink floyd that sadly came to an end but shall it's music be passed on for ever.
It's art, not mathematics. There is no perfect performance, no perfect solution. Just enjoy it. And if you don't, just be on your way, don't leave a comment. It's not an unwillingness to hear criticism, but simply being polite.
I have to agree with many of those who say this isn’t up to the high standards we’re used to. Nick’s drumming is understandably not how he’s played. The vocals are unharmonious. I could go on. But surely some of the issues are because of the sound recording, which probs loses so much? Long live Floyd.
I don't know why RUclips is constantly pushing fake Pink Floyd and fake Hawkwind on me. And Beatle bullshit promo. You click on one of these things once and you're doomed for life to hitting the "not interested" button .
Para mi Nik Mason es un bateria infravalorado pues yo lo pondría a la altura de Keith Moon, Jhon Bonhan, Mich Michel etc un saudiño dende GALIZA ESPAÑA
It's not supposed to be PF
Makes you realise how majestic David Gilmour is..
Ничто не сравнится с оригиналом!!!, но все равно - спасибо!!!! У тех людей была душа и искусство!!! Сейчас- это просто технически не плохо сделанная копия!!!! Спасибо и низкий поклон рок группе Pink Floyd!!! Они превзошли это фальшивый мир!!!!Их невозможно скопировать!!!!
Absolutely fantastic
the jam part is awful. organ sounds like a carnival
O love pink floid
Love that reference.
😂❤🎉😂❤🎉😂?THANK'S NICK MASON'S FOR THIS CRETION😂❤🎉🎉BEAUTIFUL, WONDERFUL, MERVEILLOUS,......😅I LOVE YOUR MUSIC😂❤🎉🎉😂❤🎉❤😂🎉❤😂🎉❤CONGRATULATIONS WITH TO MY RESPECTS😂🎉❤😂❤🎉😂❤🎉😂🎉❤SUPER CADEAU D'ANNIVERSAIRE......ET DE NOEL AUSSI
Om 🎶🎉
Had front n center seats for their Cincinnati show, then covid did away with that show entirely. Now i gotta figure out how to see him before its too damn late. David doesn't tour anymore n ive seen roger enough times to pay my mortgage.
Молодцы! Отлично!
😂🎉❤😂🎉😂🎉❤JE PRéFèRE CETTE VERSION à l'ANCIENNE🎉😂❤🎉❤😂🎉❤😂🎉❤😂🎉❤MERCI BEAUCOUP😅😊
Poveri ma belli!
NO !
Amo amo amarei
Saucerful of Secrets NO it's Echoes change the title to the correct one
It is Echoes they are playing, but Saucerful of Secrets is the name of his band.
David, help!!!
I like Nick a lot, but seriously I don’t know… this is just not good. especially the drums.
It lacks the enchanting passion of the original Pompei video version-the oldie but goodie...sort of like an elevator sanitized version of Echos. It's nice, but not magical. And I agree...Nick is a fine fellow. Not dissing the band of fine musicians, but there's an emotional punch that's just not here.
It appears to be recorded on a cell phone from the side of the stage, no surprise the sound quality is poor.
@CHEISTEN13 well seeing this live in chicago definitely gave me that feeling that I've always wanted to experience.
I saw David and Richard play echoes at Massey Hall in 2006 that was a million time better. Even Guy Pratt doesn't seem to be at his best. What is going on here? That doesn't sounds right at all.
This is very good but there is no soul from the heart in it, its being done just because.
Are you a mind-reader?
Nick and his team make a good job 👍🏼 and bring to us the chance to see the Pink Floyd early years live.
Meanwhile Roger Waters makes a desservice / shit creating a new version of DSotM trying to kill one of the best music records of all times.
Lei allora non ha compreso il messaggio musicale profondo che ha dato Roger con DSOTM REDUX.
Non sono paragonabili le due opere!!!
Comunque resta il fatto che i testi delle opere Floydiane sono per la maggior parte frutto dell’ ingegno di Roger Water.
Senza Roger e Syd non ci sarebbero stati i Pink!!!
Mason devrait profiter de sa retraite dorée plutôt que de jouer les has been .😢 . C'est triste ...
Tout à fait d’accord …. J’adore Nick mais il faut admettre queil est peut-être temps d’arrêter tout ça. Sur certaines autres chansons ça peut toujours aller mais Echoes. Non
Money. Tel est le problème. Et sa solution. Plus c'est riche, plus c'est dépensier et dans le besoin
on sent que Guy prend les rênes en mains, et que Nick a quelques années de trop !!!
This is insult to Pink Floyd, David and Rick.
Becaus ???😮
How? Because they couldn't get along?
@@tjprptchable
How did they not agree?
David and Nik are triends and the fact that The Band brought Pink Floyd's first albums ,
which neither David nor Roger did , they welcomed this whth great enthusiasm.
@sebastianocangini3834 in all respects I cannot understand anything you just wrote 💀. But I should clarify what I ment by they couldn't get along. I'm not talking about all of them I men David and Roger. I understand that David cannot play echoes live ever again without Richard Wright but I don't see it being disrespectful that nick mason and his band played it on there tour. Also first of all Syd barret made the band and was the leader of the band so pink Floyd's first elbum has nothing to do with david gilmore because david didint join the band and help on there music till there second elbum. And Roger was a important factor to pink floyds sound and he definitely worked on floyds first elbum same as Nick and Wright.I saw nick mason and his band play and they were fantastic and better than Roger's current tour wich I saw as well. Overall Nick Mason is not being disrespectful, he is spreading the legacy on in respects to Syd, David, Roger, and Wright they even talked about them at the show it's a tribute to the once forever pink floyd that sadly came to an end but shall it's music be passed on for ever.
i am Italian.....troppo lunga la traduzione.
Perché Roger e David possono suonare i Pink Floyd e Nik Mason no ???
Non capisco.
FANTASTICI 😍😍😍😍❤❤❤