Dono mahan singer hai... lekin Rafi sahab ki awaz dil ko choo rahi hai.... Sad version aur normal version dono me... Unki awaz me jadu hai... he is always no.1...
यह गाना रिकॉर्ड होना था। रफीसाब गा रहे हैं, आरडी बर्मनजी कंपोज कर रहे हैं। लेकिन रफीजी ने कहा कि किशोर बेहतर गाएंगे, किशोरजी ने कहा कि रफीजी बेहतर गाएंगे। अंत में बर्मनजी ने दोनों गानो को अलग-अलग रिकॉर्ड किया और एक ही फिल्म में 2 अलग-अलग पात्रों पर फिल्माया और रिलीज़ किया, दर्शकों को यह तय करने के लिए छोड़ दिया कि किसने बेहतर गाया है। 50 साल हो गए हैं, दर्शक अभी भी अनिर्णीत हैं। देखें कि पिछले गायक कैसे थे। दोनों स्वरों में आज के गीत का आनंद लें। सच में वह स्वर्ण युग था।
Sahi kaha situation bhi alag alag hai ak jaisi situation ke gane ko to compare kar lege log lakin alag alag situation ke geet ko kisi ka jyada kisi ka kam achcha bataya jaa raha hai ak sad verson hai ak romantic love song hai to comparison kaisa dono sad ya dono romantic situation ho tab thk lagta hai warna apni apni jagah dono thk hai music bhi alag hai
Marhum rafi sahab...aap jesa koi nhi...hum jese k dilo pe bhi aap raaj kar rahe ho..29 saal ki aeg he meri is time..2023 me...dil ki chhu jaati he aap ki awaaj ..salaam he dil se..❤❤❤
यही एकमात्र romantic गीत है जो कि मुझे किशोर से ज़्यादा रफी साहब की आवाज़ में अच्छा लगता है. नहीं तो romantic songs के लिए मुझे किशोर कुमार के गाने ज़्यादा पसंद आते हैं
दोनो ही पहली पसन्द हैं कल भी थे आज भी हैं और तुलना करना तो हमारे बस की बात है ही नहीं जिनकी आवाज हमारे मन में बसी हो उनकी क्या तुलना करें किशोर da तहेदिल से प्यार करते थे रफ़ी साब को
This song was copied by Kishore Kumar from Mohd Rafi. KK only agreed to record this song after Mohd Rafi had recorded his version. Had it not had yodeling added to it nobody would gave given it a 2nd thought.
Only experienced singer can tell about this comparison,,, continuity in tune, voice volume, peach,,, all the things are without any doubt completed in Rafi sahab singing…..
nonsense romantic is Rafisahab's version. Kishoreda's is more painful than romantic. Both versions are apt according to film's situation. Rafishab has another sad version as well... So he did what was required and so did Kishoreda
Both of them have sang so beautifully, that song has become a phenomenon. Kishore Da ki awaz kaano me mahekti hai To Rafi sahab ki awaz Dil ko chhuti hai. we miss these great singers a lot.
Very difficult even now to say which is better. Both Kishore Da and Rafi saheb Jewels in India's crown Great iconic singers RD Burman ji knows it better than any body in india He is another Iconic music director
Both singers contribution are "super", each one at his best in his forte. The best is the Music Director exploiting the talents so well, congrats to him.
Both r legend kishor da putting hard efforts but rafi saahab singing lyk its very easy to him no doubt rafi saahab can sing any song easily its true 👍👍👍👍
Nobody in this world can give that divinely voice and outwordly heavenly effect of that great divinely down to earth humble personality devine man Mohammed Rafi sahab if someone tries to sing a song sang by Mohammad Rafi Sahab will be badly exposed my advice to all the singers please don't try this mis adventure please go and sing Kishore Kumar's manna day's Mukesh's song they were having ordinary voices and range.. when Rafi Sahab sang the lip movement body language and facial expressions were of Rafi Sahab's but the original singer was the all mighty God who was In the heart of that great personnality Mohammad Rafi Sahab .
Mr.Kishore da had brought loud in voice with twist which that time many people's like but Mr.Rafi saheb had sung so smooth sweet and melodiously that it feels honey in ear.
Tum bin jaau kaha Song me jo High pitch Voice Mohd Rafi Shahab ki hai aur jo Voice k sath Harkat li hai wo hi batata hai kya Class hai Rafi Shahab ka Legend Singer.... (kishore Da Bhi legend Singer the)
Actually Rafi ji and Hemanta ji have the most surile mithe awaaz....lekin Kishor ji kaa joh voice texture hai aaj k Arijit da Na bhi hai aur Na hi aisa koi Kishore ji ayega
Rafi Sahab and Kishore Kumar Ji both are God Gifted Singer, there is no meaning of comparison and above all Music Director like Shri R.D. Burman and Lyricist Anand Bakshi Ji makes this song a sensation❤❤❤❤❤❤
Comparison of 2 greats cannot be done, both have made this song a unique masterpiece by their magical voice and what great music. The lyrics writer would have not imagined this would go as one of his greatest composition as R.D Burman has not only provided the feeling or emotions with his music but put soul to it by asking Rafi Sahab and Kishorda to sing it in their own style. Pure magic and nothing else, especially the way song turns into a different stage of love….be it displaying the affection by saying you can’t live without me and hearing my pain even the biggest of wall will fall, letting the person know you are the only one for her and then when it goes to a sad stage letting love of your life know don’t say my story to anyone and keep quiet when my name comes in any of the discussion…..will take the pain and live but you stay safe😊
2nd antra bahut jayada acha or sweetness lagta hai dil ko sakun deta hai bahut hi romentic andaz me gaaya suro ke sahansah n.1 Bollywood singer Rafi sahab ne
What a phenomenon ! A most famous song sung by two legends in their own way. It's a masterstroke by the maestro Pancham popularly known as Rahul Dev Burman. Extra ordinary as well as extra brilliant !
दोस्त आपकी जानकारी के लिए बता दूं किशोर कुमार ने इस गाने में अपना अंदाज यूडलिंग जो निकाली है उसे बार-बार सुनने का मन चाहता है और गाने को वह डिफरेंट बनाती है सबसे ज्यादा शेयर किशोर कुमार के गाने को ही मिले थे😊
किशोर दा की आवाज़ ज्यादा पावरफुल और भावनात्मक है वैसे रफी साहब ने भी अच्छा गाया है ये गाना किशोर दा ने तब गाया था जब किशोर दा को कोई संगीतकार अच्छा गायक मानता ही नहीं था, लेकिन किशोर दा ने बिना दवाब में आए रफी साहब के सामने गाकर ये साबित कर दिया था कि वो ही आने वाले समय के बादशाह हैं इस गाने में रफी साहब के सेड वर्जन को भी लिया गया है परंतु इस गीत का असल तुरुप का इक्का किशोर दा के सेड वर्जन को गायब कर दिया लोग किशोर दा वाला सेड वर्जन सुनेंगे तो उनको निर्णय करने में कोई दिक्कत नहीं होगी 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
@@andy12829 Mohammed Rafi Sahab is most versatile singer . Atleast there is no question on his versatility. Can't believe ignorant people like you exist😂
किशोर दा जी ने दो भाषाओं में ये गाना गाया है पर रफ़ि साहब जी ने दो अलग अलग ट्रैक पर गाया है--- मैं ये भी कहना चाहूंगा कि- सम्बन्द्ध अनुसार गाने के शब्द इतने सुंदर है कि - किशोर दा जी की तरह गाने के बीच " आ हा आ आ अहा आ " की थीम को कोई ऐसे सुनना चाहेगा जैसे रफ़ि साहेब जी ने गीत-संगीत की लय को क्रमबद्ध करके गाया है।
यह गाने को दोनो गायकोने अच्छी तरहसे गाया है.पर रफी साहब का गीत सुननेमे और पडदे पर देखनेमें अच्छा लगता है,तो किशोरकुमार का गीत रेडियोपे सुननेमे अच्छा लगता है.
Style of singing of both the singers is different. They respected each other to the extent that they always recommended each other for a particular song if they felt other's voice is fit for the particular song . We are very small to judge the legend like great kishore da and great Rafi sahab.
All of these Hindi songs 🎶 are recalling a immortal history in our childhood. Most of our immediate relations are passed away at present who enjoyed these songs with us almost five decades ago. Still we love Indian culture! From Sri Lanka
Развлечения
![NoCap - Maliboo [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FUV7E0QyniU/mqdefault.jpg)
Dono mahan singer hai...
lekin Rafi sahab ki awaz dil ko choo rahi hai.... Sad version aur normal version dono me...
Unki awaz me jadu hai...
he is always no.1...
Hmmmm baat to Sahi hai
Stop comparing you stupid. They both are legends and had their own immortal styles..
यह गाना रिकॉर्ड होना था। रफीसाब गा रहे हैं, आरडी बर्मनजी कंपोज कर रहे हैं। लेकिन रफीजी ने कहा कि किशोर बेहतर गाएंगे, किशोरजी ने कहा कि रफीजी बेहतर गाएंगे। अंत में बर्मनजी ने दोनों गानो को अलग-अलग रिकॉर्ड किया और एक ही फिल्म में 2 अलग-अलग पात्रों पर फिल्माया और रिलीज़ किया, दर्शकों को यह तय करने के लिए छोड़ दिया कि किसने बेहतर गाया है। 50 साल हो गए हैं, दर्शक अभी भी अनिर्णीत हैं। देखें कि पिछले गायक कैसे थे। दोनों स्वरों में आज के गीत का आनंद लें। सच में वह स्वर्ण युग था।
Both are brilliant
100% Shatpratishat sahi baat..👌👍🙏
Aasmaan ka aage piche nahi hota. Playback singer me dono hi samrat hay.
Great comment! Thanks.
किशोर की गायकी इसमें कहीं बेहतर और जीवंत हैं हर वो गीत जो रफी साहब और किशोर ने गया किशोर का गीत ही हमेशा आगे रहा है।
Iss gaane mein Kishore ji ki awaaz mein dard hai aur rafi saab ki awaaz mein nasha. 🙂Dono hi andaaz lajawab hain❤❤
Sahi kaha situation bhi alag alag hai ak jaisi situation ke gane ko to compare kar lege log lakin alag alag situation ke geet ko kisi ka jyada kisi ka kam achcha bataya jaa raha hai ak sad verson hai ak romantic love song hai to comparison kaisa dono sad ya dono romantic situation ho tab thk lagta hai warna apni apni jagah dono thk hai music bhi alag hai
Bilkul sahi kaha Nasha aur dard ek hi gaane me
@@zubairkhan2622sahi vishleshan hai
Jo gane rafi sir ne Gaye hai.
Merl nazar main koie doosra singer nahi ga sakta hai. Yeh mera challenge ha in.
Woh rafi saab aapki awaaz ❤
मधुरता और रोमांटिक नेचर जो रफी साहब जी के आवाज़ में नेचुरली झलकता है, उसका क्या कहना 🙏🙏
Marhum rafi sahab...aap jesa koi nhi...hum jese k dilo pe bhi aap raaj kar rahe ho..29 saal ki aeg he meri is time..2023 me...dil ki chhu jaati he aap ki awaaj ..salaam he dil se..❤❤❤
Why do we stupidly keep comparing these two immortal singers ? There is no need and no use asking who is better. They are both absolutely incredible.
Agreed that they were both divine singers, the likes of which will not likely grace this world again.
भाई आपकी बात से सहमत हूं
😂😂😂😂
Kishore ko sun kr puri body jhoom jati ha but rafi ko sunkr body ruk jati ha kun ki un ki awaz straight dil ko lagati ha
No doubt Rafi sahab wala jada achha hai. Rafi sahab jaisa feeling or kisime nahi
दोनों ने है फिल्म की सिचुएशन के हिसाब से गाया है ।
और दोनो ही लाजवाब है ।
Kon si movie hai ye
यही एकमात्र romantic गीत है जो कि मुझे किशोर से ज़्यादा रफी साहब की आवाज़ में अच्छा लगता है. नहीं तो romantic songs के लिए मुझे किशोर कुमार के गाने ज़्यादा पसंद आते हैं
Mujhe toh Rafi ji ki version achha laga.
Yes brother I am agree with you ❤
Mujhe bhi Rafi sahab ka verson achcha laga
रफी साहब रोमँटिक हुके गीत मे घुसके रोमँटिक गाते हे रफी साहब एक नंबर
रफी सहाब की style पंसद है♥♥♥♥♥👌👌👌गम और खुशी दोनों मे गाया है🙏खुशी वाला पंसद आया♥
रफ़ी साहब ने ज्यादा बेहतर गाया है.
दोनो ही पहली पसन्द हैं कल भी थे आज भी हैं और तुलना करना तो हमारे बस की बात है ही नहीं जिनकी आवाज हमारे मन में बसी हो उनकी क्या तुलना करें किशोर da तहेदिल से प्यार करते थे रफ़ी साब को
मे किशोर कुमार का फॅन हुं मगर ये गाना रफी साहब का अच्छा लगा.
मुझे तो दोनों की आवाज में अच्छा लगता है और दोनों ही बेहतर गायक हैं
और सदा रहेंगे ।
Absolutely correct ❤.
Kishore Da is legendary singer, salute, and Rafi shab is number 1 to number 10, others follow from 11, no one can come closer to Rafi sahab ..
मोहम्मद रफी साहब ने इसे रोमांटिक गया है और गंभीरता गाया है किशोर कुमार जीने
Muhammad Rafi jaisa koi nhi 😒
रफी रफी साहब जवान आदमी की तरह रोमँटिक गाते है रवी साहेब एक नंबर
Ilove Rafi sahib ji more n yeh Geet meri rooh tak ja chuka hai Kishore Kumar bhi khoobsurat gate hain
दो महानतम गायक। वाह। दोनों ही शानदार। दोनों को नमन।
rafi ka koi competitor nahi unke jaisa koi ga he nahi sakta
I cannot believe that people think that Kishore was on level par with Rafi Sahab one was a master n the rest were behind the master
This song was copied by Kishore Kumar from Mohd Rafi. KK only agreed to record this song after Mohd Rafi had recorded his version. Had it not had yodeling added to it nobody would gave given it a 2nd thought.
Kishore Kumar ki power full voice ke aage baki sab fika lagta hai ❤ Tiger jesi power full voice ke Malik Kishore Kumar ka koi jawab nahi 😊
Ishwar ki awaj ek hi hoti hai...both are God of music industry...
To my ear,Rafiji is more pleasing and sweeter than Kishore ji.
TUM BIN JAON KAHAN
SONG RAFI & KISHORE DONO KI AWAAZ ME SUPER HIT SONG HAI 👍👍
50. 50. Dóno
Only experienced singer can tell about this comparison,,, continuity in tune, voice volume, peach,,, all the things are without any doubt completed in Rafi sahab singing…..
Kishoreda changed the song by his youdling make more romantic❣❣😘😘
nonsense romantic is Rafisahab's version. Kishoreda's is more painful than romantic. Both versions are apt according to film's situation.
Rafishab has another sad version as well... So he did what was required and so did Kishoreda
Rafi saheb more classic, sweet and heart touching voice pure simple and outstanding ❤❤
Well said Rafi Sahab was outstanding period
We should not compare them. Both of them were and are great. Personally I like them equally ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Both the LEGENDS have sung well but RAFI sab style of singing is from the HEART SO DIVINE N SOFT FOR ROMANTIC N.EMOTIONAL
Both of them have sang so beautifully, that song has become a phenomenon. Kishore Da ki awaz kaano me mahekti hai To Rafi sahab ki awaz Dil ko chhuti hai.
we miss these great singers a lot.
Very difficult even now to say which is better.
Both Kishore Da and Rafi saheb Jewels in India's crown
Great iconic singers
RD Burman ji knows it better than any body in india
He is another Iconic music director
Why going to decide which one is better. Why not just enjoy this song sang by the two legends 😌. Everyone's singing style is different.
Both great legends but I think Rafi was outstanding.
Rafi ji and Kishore ji voices are par excellence! Both singers sung this song in their style melodiously! Hats off!
मुझे जितना संगीत मे गाने मै दावे के साथ देता हु रफी साहब एक नंबर गुन्हे भारतरत्न देना चाहिये
Soulful and sweet voice Rafi ji ka. Kya voice thi Rafi ji ki.....
Waaaaaaaaaaa kya baat kahi aapne
Beautiful songs Mohammad Rafi sahab
Both singers contribution are "super", each one at his best in his forte. The best is the Music Director exploiting the talents so well, congrats to him.
Kishore da aur Rafi sahab dono ka gaya hua gaana super hai
Though I'm a hard-core Kishore Kumar fan.but i like the version of Rafi more.
Rafi & Kishore both created havoc in singing. Just marvellous.❤❤❤❤❤
This song has been sung equally nice by both singers. Hats off
Rafi ji sung rommantically . Kishor kumar sung painfully
Kishore's yodeling and Rafi's pure singing, that's the best!
Both the singers are unbeatable Legends
Rafi had unmatched pitch
Kishor had unbeatable jolly mixture
Perfect analysis. But in this song Kishorji 5% more. Actually i am always Rafi saab fan and stopped (almost ) watching Hindi movies after 1980.
Perfect analysis. But in this song Kishorji 5% more. Actually i am always Rafi saab fan and stopped (almost ) watching Hindi movies after 1980.
Me too Sir, Please rafi Sahab wapas aa jaao na
Lovely song by Rafi sahab 👌👌👌👌👌🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹Very very Handsome Shashiji ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🌹🌹👌👌
सॉलेट रफी साहब सॉलेट एक नंबर रफी साहब
Both are incomparable great legends god gifted personality will never forget till death
I love kishor sir but yahan to rafi sahab waaaaaah❤❤❤❤
Both r legend kishor da putting hard efforts but rafi saahab singing lyk its very easy to him no doubt rafi saahab can sing any song easily its true 👍👍👍👍
Rafi saheb ka version is more melodious no doubt about it.
Nobody in this world can give that divinely voice and outwordly heavenly effect of that great divinely down to earth humble personality devine man Mohammed Rafi sahab if someone tries to sing a song sang by Mohammad Rafi Sahab will be badly exposed my advice to all the singers please don't try this mis adventure please go and sing Kishore Kumar's manna day's Mukesh's song they were having ordinary voices and range.. when Rafi Sahab sang the lip movement body language and facial expressions were of Rafi Sahab's but the original singer was the all mighty God who was In the heart of that great personnality Mohammad Rafi Sahab .
Are you idiot, Kishore Kumar's versitality and Range can never be matched , people can sing like rafi but Kishore Kumar's magic no one can recreate
Bahut Sunder gaya hai aap ne Rafi Sahab ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Mr.Kishore da had brought loud in voice with twist which that time many people's like but Mr.Rafi saheb had sung so smooth sweet and melodiously that it feels honey in ear.
Yar ab mai kya bolu..mohd rafi has sungb10 k se uper so hs i luv hin💙 bt jo mera kishore kumar hai vo koi nhi vill luv him till last my luv he iz💙💙
Superb song ❤❤.. Excellent 👌👌 voice.Evergreen song.worthlistening md outstanding song 🎉🎉
This song takes me back to the 1970's when I was in school...
Brilliant thanks very much..
Both the Voice of Mohd Rafi n Kishore Da are in their own place 😊
Both singer were amazing singer ...it is impossible to judge that who is best .... I think no one can judged ....Dr. P. R. Singh...
Both the songs are most beautiful. Unmatchable by Rafisaab and Kishoreda touched the soul. Very good 👍 👏 👌 😀 ☺ 🙌
No comparison Rafi sahab and kishor da legend
Near yes a presence yes an intimacy
Yet afar more than a presence and more than an intimacy
A yearning more heartbreaking yet sweet.
Kishore Version Hodling Bahuth....Accha hai.🎉🎉❤❤
Tum bin jaau kaha Song me jo High pitch Voice Mohd Rafi Shahab ki hai aur jo Voice k sath Harkat li hai wo hi batata hai kya Class hai Rafi Shahab ka Legend Singer.... (kishore Da Bhi legend Singer the)
Actually Rafi ji and Hemanta ji have the most surile mithe awaaz....lekin Kishor ji kaa joh voice texture hai aaj k Arijit da Na bhi hai aur Na hi aisa koi Kishore ji ayega
Amar ho gai yeh awaz great rafi sahab
*Abb hai sanam har mousam;pyar ke qabil,,,,,that's mindblowing,,,,
Mai here hamesha achi vice chahata hu our o dono legend singer me hai I am fully satisfied both legend singerse. ❤
Rafi Sahab and Kishore Kumar Ji both are God Gifted Singer, there is no meaning of comparison and above all Music Director like Shri R.D. Burman and Lyricist Anand Bakshi Ji makes this song a sensation❤❤❤❤❤❤
Sweetest sounds in the world. Singing a romantic song in romantic way......Rafi sb voice is heavenly.
Comparison of 2 greats cannot be done, both have made this song a unique masterpiece by their magical voice and what great music. The lyrics writer would have not imagined this would go as one of his greatest composition as R.D Burman has not only provided the feeling or emotions with his music but put soul to it by asking Rafi Sahab and Kishorda to sing it in their own style. Pure magic and nothing else, especially the way song turns into a different stage of love….be it displaying the affection by saying you can’t live without me and hearing my pain even the biggest of wall will fall, letting the person know you are the only one for her and then when it goes to a sad stage letting love of your life know don’t say my story to anyone and keep quiet when my name comes in any of the discussion…..will take the pain and live but you stay safe😊
2nd antra bahut jayada acha or sweetness lagta hai dil ko sakun deta hai bahut hi romentic andaz me gaaya suro ke sahansah n.1 Bollywood singer Rafi sahab ne
No doubt to say Rafi saheb is out standing in all departments in this song, Kishore da is good but looking like master and student are singing,
After each,,every sides,,, style in short No can even touch The Mr Best Rafi sb.
🎉❤Aise gaane baar baar nahi bante.Hats of to Pancham da Rafiji n Kishorji. .
Panchamda has really has SHOWN the REALITY of BOTH LEGENDS....this the BEAUTY of MUSIC!!!😊👍👌✌️❤️🌺🌷💐🙏☘️🛐
What a phenomenon ! A most famous song sung by two legends in their own way. It's a masterstroke by the maestro Pancham popularly known as Rahul Dev Burman. Extra ordinary as well as extra brilliant !
Unmatchable Great Rafi sb and versatile kishore da. Both will be legend forever.
Muhammed Rafi sb.
The 1st choice of music lovers.
दोनों महान थे इसमें कोई संदेह नहीं है किंतु इस romantic गीत में जो रूमानियत चाहिए थी उसे रफ़ी साहब ने बेहतर ढंग से निभाया..🙏
Bcz he (rafi sahab) is sung for his lover so it was romantic, another(kishor kumar) by a father to his son so here is more pain...
Hey listen carefully the pain of love is more in the Kishore da's song .
lekin hit to jyada kishore ka hua.
दोस्त आपकी जानकारी के लिए बता दूं किशोर कुमार ने इस गाने में अपना अंदाज यूडलिंग जो निकाली है उसे बार-बार सुनने का मन चाहता है और गाने को वह डिफरेंट बनाती है सबसे ज्यादा शेयर किशोर कुमार के गाने को ही मिले थे😊
Notice how most high pitched songs and without much music is given to the master Rafi sahab
Raffi saab godly voice.
किशोर दा की आवाज़ ज्यादा पावरफुल और भावनात्मक है वैसे रफी साहब ने भी अच्छा गाया है
ये गाना किशोर दा ने तब गाया था जब किशोर दा को कोई संगीतकार अच्छा गायक मानता ही नहीं था, लेकिन किशोर दा ने बिना दवाब में आए रफी साहब के सामने गाकर ये साबित कर दिया था कि वो ही आने वाले समय के बादशाह हैं
इस गाने में रफी साहब के सेड वर्जन को भी लिया गया है परंतु इस गीत का असल तुरुप का इक्का किशोर दा के सेड वर्जन को गायब कर दिया
लोग किशोर दा वाला सेड वर्जन सुनेंगे तो उनको निर्णय करने में कोई दिक्कत नहीं होगी
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
One is Classical and other Side One Natural.....❤ Like two sides of the coin 😌
Only Rafi ji can sang same song as sad and romantic
Rafi saheb was a versatile singer. Miles ahead of that so called singer.
Ghanta so called , Rafi was Qawwali singer Kishore Kumar was most versatile
@@andy12829 Mohammed Rafi Sahab is most versatile singer . Atleast there is no question on his versatility. Can't believe ignorant people like you exist😂
किशोर दा जी ने दो भाषाओं में ये गाना गाया है पर रफ़ि साहब जी ने दो अलग अलग ट्रैक पर गाया है---
मैं ये भी कहना चाहूंगा कि-
सम्बन्द्ध अनुसार गाने के शब्द इतने सुंदर है कि - किशोर दा जी की तरह गाने के बीच " आ हा आ आ अहा आ " की थीम को कोई ऐसे सुनना चाहेगा जैसे रफ़ि साहेब जी ने गीत-संगीत की लय को क्रमबद्ध करके गाया है।
यह गाने को दोनो गायकोने अच्छी तरहसे गाया है.पर रफी साहब का गीत सुननेमे और पडदे पर देखनेमें अच्छा लगता है,तो किशोरकुमार का गीत रेडियोपे सुननेमे अच्छा लगता है.
Kishore Da🙌❤
Style of singing of both the singers is different. They respected each other to the extent that they always recommended each other for a particular song if they felt other's voice is fit for the particular song . We are very small to judge the legend like great kishore da and great Rafi sahab.
Rafi jaisa koi ni hai
So true
My most favorite song.. it's th soulful and very nice indeed 👌 👍 🎉❤
All of these Hindi songs 🎶 are recalling a immortal history in our childhood. Most of our immediate relations are passed away at present who enjoyed these songs with us almost five decades ago.
Still we love Indian culture!
From Sri Lanka
Rafi saab like a makkhan very soft voice. Amazing Rafi saab
Definetly Rafi's version is more romantic and melodious
No
Overall impact of Kishore da despite being picturised on Bharat Bhusan is no less
Ek mulla dusre mulle ki khujata hi hai
3 versions of the song all are different than each other great work by Majrooh Sahab i cant getting words to praise.
Md. Rafi sahab ke dwara gaya version best hai