The worst thing is that all Germans outside Baden-Württemberg think that only Baden and Swabians live in Baden-Württemberg. But the Württembergers are completely forgotten today. The enmity between Swabians and Württembergers lasted well into the 20th century. Three counties should actually be shown here: Baden, Württemberg and Swabia.
@@einfbenjamin No, Würtembergers are NOT Swabians, even if they speak Swabian. If you had asked that 100 years ago, you would have been slapped in the face.
The video is good for one thing, namely to show that the so-called Holy Roman Empire actually fell with the death of Kaiser Otto I. Because Baden and Württemberg were actually independent states over the centuries, like all the other German small states. In fact, the German small states were actually permanently at war with each other, so that a united state could not arise! 1000 years they killed each other. One of the highlights was the Thirty Years' War. But they also fought each other before and after Thirty Years' War. The areas inhabited by Germans were a patchwork of territories! Consisting of hundreds of smaller sub-units of principalities, bailiwicks, margraviates, lordships, free cities, baronies, duchies and even simple counties and bishoprics and other domains. The kaiser title was only status without real political meaning! Because the Holy Roman Empire was not a state, but a complex of territories. The siege of Vienna in 1683 was also proof that the kaiser's title had no political significance. The kaiser title was only status without real political meaning! So the Holy Roman Empire was over the centuries without central authority! For example the so-called Kaiser Leopold could not order the other German states at the second siege of Vienna in 1683 to send troops to save his capital, for his capital was not recognized as the capital of the all other German states. Leopold's will was meaningless to the other Rulers of the other German small states. Only a few German states sent troops to support the Habsburgs. Because there was not enough support from the other German states and and the Habsburgs were too weak alone, so Leopold had to ask Polish Empire for help! Also these Germans of this small states often killed each other with the support of non-German allies. A completely ridiculous and stupid nation that was in a civil war for 1000 years and only managed to found a united German state in 1871. It was only in 1871 that the first permanent unified German state emerged. That is why the Germans are also known as the late nation. Because the first unified German state was only founded in 1871! Whereby the English term Holy Roman Empire is based on an incorrect translation and is actually wrong. The German term "Heiliges Römisches Reich" was also incorrectly translated into English as "Holy Roman Empire" and since then this wrong translation has been used incorrectly again and again. "Imperium" is empire in German not "Reich"! The term "Reich" is correctly explained in this German wikipedia link on the subject Reich (Territorium)! Quote from this German wikipeia link translated: "Reich denotes the territory of a ruler, a state or, more generally, a politically organized community" So Reich is the same as realm. In German every kingdom can be called a "Reich"even if it is not an empire at all. The German word "Königreich" for kingdom actually contains the word Reich! König-Reich. Realm of Kings! So the correct translation is "Holy Romen Realm" and not "Holy Roman Empire"! Despite it still, ignorant fools use the wrong term "Holy Roman Empire". An alternative would be to use the German proper name in English. So Holy Roman Reich! This is also done in other contexts. As for example with the term the "Third Reich". In the meantime, people also speak of the "Fourth Reich" when one wants to polemically criticize Germany's attempts to dominate in Europe. I have already read texts where the term "Reich Progrom Night" was used. In the wiki link to the "Reichswehr" there is talk of "Reich Defense" as a translation. The same also applies to the wiki link to the "Reichsmarine" there is also the talk of "Reich Navy" as a translation. There are certainly other examples that show that the term "Reich" is used as a German proper name in English. So it would actually make sense to do this principally in order to avoid this translation error of wrong Holy Roman Empire! So it would be correct Holy Roman Reich or Holy Roman Realm! By the way, at most, one could call this patchwork of territories a military alliance. But even that is actually wrong, because within a military alliance the allies do not fight each other all the time! The various German states also founded alliances, which also makes it clear that the Holy Romen Realm did not in fact exist! For example the Rheinische Allianz or the Welfenallianz or the Hildesheimer Allianz or the Kurrheinian alliance. It is interesting that these alliances could also include non-German states. For example was Sweden member of the Rheinische Allianz and France too! This demostrates the confusion and the absurdity of the the Holy Romen Realm.
all that video things 0:10: wait a small Würrttemburg 0:26: oh Baden is here 1:19: Baden got some land 1:44: great job Würrtemberg 2:05: How 2:10: HOWWWW wait border with Baden :P 2:19: HOW THAT BIG WÜRTTEMBURG 2:57: did you guys just walk to get land 3:08: wait what 3:11: who is that 3:12: so far 3:26: who is that there 3:31: annex the sus state now 3:41: STOP 3:48: baden wat 3:51: how can you be that big 3:58: stop adding states 4:20: STOP 6:11: are you sure 6:12: oh yes wait AMONG US ON BADEN 6:17: bro zones 7:16: NAZI 7:19: BIG LAND 7:22: three states? 7:25: the end
The video is good for one thing, namely to show that the so-called Holy Roman Empire actually fell with the death of Kaiser Otto I. Because Baden and Württemberg were actually independent states over the centuries, like all the other German small states. In fact, the German small states were actually permanently at war with each other, so that a united state could not arise! 1000 years they killed each other. One of the highlights was the Thirty Years' War. But they also fought each other before and after Thirty Years' War. The areas inhabited by Germans were a patchwork of territories! Consisting of hundreds of smaller sub-units of principalities, bailiwicks, margraviates, lordships, free cities, baronies, duchies and even simple counties and bishoprics and other domains. The kaiser title was only status without real political meaning! Because the Holy Roman Empire was not a state, but a complex of territories. The siege of Vienna in 1683 was also proof that the kaiser's title had no political significance. The kaiser title was only status without real political meaning! So the Holy Roman Empire was over the centuries without central authority! For example the so-called Kaiser Leopold could not order the other German states at the second siege of Vienna in 1683 to send troops to save his capital, for his capital was not recognized as the capital of the all other German states. Leopold's will was meaningless to the other Rulers of the other German small states. Only a few German states sent troops to support the Habsburgs. Because there was not enough support from the other German states and and the Habsburgs were too weak alone, so Leopold had to ask Polish Empire for help! Also these Germans of this small states often killed each other with the support of non-German allies. A completely ridiculous and stupid nation that was in a civil war for 1000 years and only managed to found a united German state in 1871. It was only in 1871 that the first permanent unified German state emerged. That is why the Germans are also known as the late nation. Because the first unified German state was only founded in 1871! Whereby the English term Holy Roman Empire is based on an incorrect translation and is actually wrong. The German term "Heiliges Römisches Reich" was also incorrectly translated into English as "Holy Roman Empire" and since then this wrong translation has been used incorrectly again and again. "Imperium" is empire in German not "Reich"! The term "Reich" is correctly explained in this German wikipedia link on the subject Reich (Territorium)! Quote from this German wikipeia link translated: "Reich denotes the territory of a ruler, a state or, more generally, a politically organized community" So Reich is the same as realm. In German every kingdom can be called a "Reich"even if it is not an empire at all. The German word "Königreich" for kingdom actually contains the word Reich! König-Reich. Realm of Kings! So the correct translation is "Holy Romen Realm" and not "Holy Roman Empire"! Despite it still, ignorant fools use the wrong term "Holy Roman Empire". An alternative would be to use the German proper name in English. So Holy Roman Reich! This is also done in other contexts. As for example with the term the "Third Reich". In the meantime, people also speak of the "Fourth Reich" when one wants to polemically criticize Germany's attempts to dominate in Europe. I have already read texts where the term "Reich Progrom Night" was used. In the wiki link to the "Reichswehr" there is talk of "Reich Defense" as a translation. The same also applies to the wiki link to the "Reichsmarine" there is also the talk of "Reich Navy" as a translation. There are certainly other examples that show that the term "Reich" is used as a German proper name in English. So it would actually make sense to do this principally in order to avoid this translation error of wrong Holy Roman Empire! So it would be correct Holy Roman Reich or Holy Roman Realm! By the way, at most, one could call this patchwork of territories a military alliance. But even that is actually wrong, because within a military alliance the allies do not fight each other all the time! The various German states also founded alliances, which also makes it clear that the Holy Romen Realm did not in fact exist! For example the Rheinische Allianz or the Welfenallianz or the Hildesheimer Allianz or the Kurrheinian alliance. It is interesting that these alliances could also include non-German states. For example was Sweden member of the Rheinische Allianz and France too! This demostrates the confusion and the absurdity of the the Holy Romen Realm.
Jakie bzdury napisałeś? Żaden Polak to lubi! Poza tym nie było czego podziwiać. W kolejnym komentarzu poniżej opiszę, dlaczego to była kompletna bzdura. To jest kopia mojego komentarza, który zamieściłem pod filmem. Jeśli nie rozumiesz, możesz skorzystać z tłumacza.
The video is good for one thing, namely to show that the so-called Holy Roman Empire actually fell with the death of Kaiser Otto I. Because Baden and Württemberg were actually independent states over the centuries, like all the other German small states. In fact, the German small states were actually permanently at war with each other, so that a united state could not arise! 1000 years they killed each other. One of the highlights was the Thirty Years' War. But they also fought each other before and after Thirty Years' War. The areas inhabited by Germans were a patchwork of territories! Consisting of hundreds of smaller sub-units of principalities, bailiwicks, margraviates, lordships, free cities, baronies, duchies and even simple counties and bishoprics and other domains. The kaiser title was only status without real political meaning! Because the Holy Roman Empire was not a state, but a complex of territories. The siege of Vienna in 1683 was also proof that the kaiser's title had no political significance. The kaiser title was only status without real political meaning! So the Holy Roman Empire was over the centuries without central authority! For example the so-called Kaiser Leopold could not order the other German states at the second siege of Vienna in 1683 to send troops to save his capital, for his capital was not recognized as the capital of the all other German states. Leopold's will was meaningless to the other Rulers of the other German small states. Only a few German states sent troops to support the Habsburgs. Because there was not enough support from the other German states and and the Habsburgs were too weak alone, so Leopold had to ask Polish Empire for help! Also these Germans of this small states often killed each other with the support of non-German allies. A completely ridiculous and stupid nation that was in a civil war for 1000 years and only managed to found a united German state in 1871. It was only in 1871 that the first permanent unified German state emerged. That is why the Germans are also known as the late nation. Because the first unified German state was only founded in 1871! Whereby the English term Holy Roman Empire is based on an incorrect translation and is actually wrong. The German term "Heiliges Römisches Reich" was also incorrectly translated into English as "Holy Roman Empire" and since then this wrong translation has been used incorrectly again and again. "Imperium" is empire in German not "Reich"! The term "Reich" is correctly explained in this German wikipedia link on the subject Reich (Territorium)! Quote from this German wikipeia link translated: "Reich denotes the territory of a ruler, a state or, more generally, a politically organized community" So Reich is the same as realm. In German every kingdom can be called a "Reich"even if it is not an empire at all. The German word "Königreich" for kingdom actually contains the word Reich! König-Reich. Realm of Kings! So the correct translation is "Holy Romen Realm" and not "Holy Roman Empire"! Despite it still, ignorant fools use the wrong term "Holy Roman Empire". An alternative would be to use the German proper name in English. So Holy Roman Reich! This is also done in other contexts. As for example with the term the "Third Reich". In the meantime, people also speak of the "Fourth Reich" when one wants to polemically criticize Germany's attempts to dominate in Europe. I have already read texts where the term "Reich Progrom Night" was used. In the wiki link to the "Reichswehr" there is talk of "Reich Defense" as a translation. The same also applies to the wiki link to the "Reichsmarine" there is also the talk of "Reich Navy" as a translation. There are certainly other examples that show that the term "Reich" is used as a German proper name in English. So it would actually make sense to do this principally in order to avoid this translation error of wrong Holy Roman Empire! So it would be correct Holy Roman Reich or Holy Roman Realm! By the way, at most, one could call this patchwork of territories a military alliance. But even that is actually wrong, because within a military alliance the allies do not fight each other all the time! The various German states also founded alliances, which also makes it clear that the Holy Romen Realm did not in fact exist! For example the Rheinische Allianz or the Welfenallianz or the Hildesheimer Allianz or the Kurrheinian alliance. It is interesting that these alliances could also include non-German states. For example was Sweden member of the Rheinische Allianz and France too! This demostrates the confusion and the absurdity of the the Holy Romen Realm.
Very nice, however i have some corrections on the flag for Württemberg. You see, the Black-Red bicolor was only adopted after 1817 by Wihelm I. Before that, the flag that has most evidence of usage as a "national" flag is a tricolor, Yellow-Black-Red from around 1803 to 1816. Some may argue that the flag was a Black-Yellow bicolor before 1817, being connected to the royal colors. However, there is little to no evidence of it being used (at least after 1803) in written or drawn form. The striped Black-Red one is a gigantic error, as it was, for some reason, put on wikipedia as the electorate flag, even though the only proof of it ever existing was a painting of a river vessel from 1839... Still, the history and usage of the flag of Württemberg is still on construction so this isnt the final say, as there is always more info to consider/discover...
Actually yes. The German language as we know it today came exactly from this region. (Hochdeutsch) it spread all over Germany to the north at the second vowel shift, and the region that was not affected speaks dutch today
@@robert48719 Standard german is an artificially created language not natively spoken anywhere pre modern times. And standard german and high german are not to be confused. Also standard nederlands isnt the only low german which exists to this day, its just the only official one.
A littlebit of a guess, but rooted in what devides both sides of the state today aswell: Baden ruled with a kinda excentric aspect, because it was on the wealthy shores of the Rhine. While Württemberg always struggeld economically up until the last two centuries and had to focus on getting people paid.
Germany didn’t exist until the 19th century. It was a collection of many small states. I don’t think you could call them countries, but there were similarities
The video is good for one thing, namely to show that the so-called Holy Roman Empire actually fell with the death of Kaiser Otto I. Because Baden and Württemberg were actually independent states over the centuries, like all the other German small states. In fact, the German small states were actually permanently at war with each other, so that a united state could not arise! 1000 years they killed each other. One of the highlights was the Thirty Years' War. But they also fought each other before and after Thirty Years' War. The areas inhabited by Germans were a patchwork of territories! Consisting of hundreds of smaller sub-units of principalities, bailiwicks, margraviates, lordships, free cities, baronies, duchies and even simple counties and bishoprics and other domains. The kaiser title was only status without real political meaning! Because the Holy Roman Empire was not a state, but a complex of territories. The siege of Vienna in 1683 was also proof that the kaiser's title had no political significance. The kaiser title was only status without real political meaning! So the Holy Roman Empire was over the centuries without central authority! For example the so-called Kaiser Leopold could not order the other German states at the second siege of Vienna in 1683 to send troops to save his capital, for his capital was not recognized as the capital of the all other German states. Leopold's will was meaningless to the other Rulers of the other German small states. Only a few German states sent troops to support the Habsburgs. Because there was not enough support from the other German states and and the Habsburgs were too weak alone, so Leopold had to ask Polish Empire for help! Also these Germans of this small states often killed each other with the support of non-German allies. A completely ridiculous and stupid nation that was in a civil war for 1000 years and only managed to found a united German state in 1871. It was only in 1871 that the first permanent unified German state emerged. That is why the Germans are also known as the late nation. Because the first unified German state was only founded in 1871! Whereby the English term Holy Roman Empire is based on an incorrect translation and is actually wrong. The German term "Heiliges Römisches Reich" was also incorrectly translated into English as "Holy Roman Empire" and since then this wrong translation has been used incorrectly again and again. "Imperium" is empire in German not "Reich"! The term "Reich" is correctly explained in this German wikipedia link on the subject Reich (Territorium)! Quote from this German wikipeia link translated: "Reich denotes the territory of a ruler, a state or, more generally, a politically organized community" So Reich is the same as realm. In German every kingdom can be called a "Reich"even if it is not an empire at all. The German word "Königreich" for kingdom actually contains the word Reich! König-Reich. Realm of Kings! So the correct translation is "Holy Romen Realm" and not "Holy Roman Empire"! Despite it still, ignorant fools use the wrong term "Holy Roman Empire". An alternative would be to use the German proper name in English. So Holy Roman Reich! This is also done in other contexts. As for example with the term the "Third Reich". In the meantime, people also speak of the "Fourth Reich" when one wants to polemically criticize Germany's attempts to dominate in Europe. I have already read texts where the term "Reich Progrom Night" was used. In the wiki link to the "Reichswehr" there is talk of "Reich Defense" as a translation. The same also applies to the wiki link to the "Reichsmarine" there is also the talk of "Reich Navy" as a translation. There are certainly other examples that show that the term "Reich" is used as a German proper name in English. So it would actually make sense to do this principally in order to avoid this translation error of wrong Holy Roman Empire! So it would be correct Holy Roman Reich or Holy Roman Realm! By the way, at most, one could call this patchwork of territories a military alliance. But even that is actually wrong, because within a military alliance the allies do not fight each other all the time! The various German states also founded alliances, which also makes it clear that the Holy Romen Realm did not in fact exist! For example the Rheinische Allianz or the Welfenallianz or the Hildesheimer Allianz or the Kurrheinian alliance. It is interesting that these alliances could also include non-German states. For example was Sweden member of the Rheinische Allianz and France too! This demostrates the confusion and the absurdity of the the Holy Romen Realm.
@@octopus_72 No, this is my first comment. I then copied this comment and posted it under other comments because I wanted as many people as possible to read this information. Because i made an effort to write this long text.
@@Ghreinos What you obviously can do is to write pathetically vulgar comments. The vulgarity is probably intended to hide the fact that you have no logical and good counterarguments.
This is absolute nonsense, filled with hostility and disrespect. The German states were not constantly at war with each other, and "Heiliges Römisches Reich" is the German translation of "Sacrum Imperium Romanum", which of course means "Holy Roman Empire", not "realm. The nation state is a relatively recent invention. Germany became one at about the same time as Italy. Most nation states of today are younger.
The worst thing is that all Germans outside Baden-Württemberg think that only Baden and Swabians live in Baden-Württemberg. But the Württembergers are completely forgotten today. The enmity between Swabians and Württembergers lasted well into the 20th century. Three counties should actually be shown here: Baden, Württemberg and Swabia.
Dont forget us franconians in the north east
würtembergers are swabians arent they
@@einfbenjamin No, Würtembergers are NOT Swabians, even if they speak Swabian. If you had asked that 100 years ago, you would have been slapped in the face.
@@lancelot- so they just completely their own Group?
Württemberg and Schwaben are simply two terms that are not in the same category…
The Music with the History its so cool!, Keep Going.
I'm really excited about this video!
The video is good for one thing, namely to show that the so-called Holy Roman Empire actually fell with the death of Kaiser Otto I. Because Baden and Württemberg were actually independent states over the centuries, like all the other German small states. In fact, the German small states were actually permanently at war with each other, so that a united state could not arise! 1000 years they killed each other. One of the highlights was the Thirty Years' War. But they also fought each other before and after Thirty Years' War. The areas inhabited by Germans were a patchwork of territories! Consisting of hundreds of smaller sub-units of principalities, bailiwicks, margraviates, lordships, free cities, baronies, duchies and even simple counties and bishoprics and other domains. The kaiser title was only status without real political meaning! Because the Holy Roman Empire was not a state, but a complex of territories. The siege of Vienna in 1683 was also proof that the kaiser's title had no political significance. The kaiser title was only status without real political meaning! So the Holy Roman Empire was over the centuries without central authority! For example the so-called Kaiser Leopold could not order the other German states at the second siege of Vienna in 1683 to send troops to save his capital, for his capital was not recognized as the capital of the all other German states. Leopold's will was meaningless to the other Rulers of the other German small states. Only a few German states sent troops to support the Habsburgs. Because there was not enough support from the other German states and and the Habsburgs were too weak alone, so Leopold had to ask Polish Empire for help! Also these Germans of this small states often killed each other with the support of non-German allies. A completely ridiculous and stupid nation that was in a civil war for 1000 years and only managed to found a united German state in 1871. It was only in 1871 that the first permanent unified German state emerged. That is why the Germans are also known as the late nation. Because the first unified German state was only founded in 1871!
Whereby the English term Holy Roman Empire is based on an incorrect translation and is actually wrong. The German term "Heiliges Römisches Reich" was also incorrectly translated into English as "Holy Roman Empire" and since then this wrong translation has been used incorrectly again and again. "Imperium" is empire in German not "Reich"! The term "Reich" is correctly explained in this German wikipedia link on the subject Reich (Territorium)! Quote from this German wikipeia link translated: "Reich denotes the territory of a ruler, a state or, more generally, a politically organized community" So Reich is the same as realm. In German every kingdom can be called a "Reich"even if it is not an empire at all. The German word "Königreich" for kingdom actually contains the word Reich! König-Reich. Realm of Kings! So the correct translation is "Holy Romen Realm" and not "Holy Roman Empire"! Despite it still, ignorant fools use the wrong term "Holy Roman Empire".
An alternative would be to use the German proper name in English. So Holy Roman Reich! This is also done in other contexts. As for example with the term the "Third Reich". In the meantime, people also speak of the "Fourth Reich" when one wants to polemically criticize Germany's attempts to dominate in Europe. I have already read texts where the term "Reich Progrom Night" was used. In the wiki link to the "Reichswehr" there is talk of "Reich Defense" as a translation. The same also applies to the wiki link to the "Reichsmarine" there is also the talk of "Reich Navy" as a translation. There are certainly other examples that show that the term "Reich" is used as a German proper name in English. So it would actually make sense to do this principally in order to avoid this translation error of wrong Holy Roman Empire! So it would be correct Holy Roman Reich or Holy Roman Realm!
By the way, at most, one could call this patchwork of territories a military alliance. But even that is actually wrong, because within a military alliance the allies do not fight each other all the time! The various German states also founded alliances, which also makes it clear that the Holy Romen Realm did not in fact exist! For example the Rheinische Allianz or the Welfenallianz or the Hildesheimer Allianz or the Kurrheinian alliance. It is interesting that these alliances could also include non-German states. For example was Sweden member of the Rheinische Allianz and France too! This demostrates the confusion and the absurdity of the the Holy Romen Realm.
Appreciate you posting this. My uncle was KIA there.
Nett hier, aber waren Sie schonmal in Baden-Württemberg?
Bin hier geboren und lebe schon mein ganze Leben hier.
Süd-ost, nur Süd-ost 😊
Süd-ost, nur Süd-ost 😊
all that video things
0:10: wait a small Würrttemburg
0:26: oh Baden is here
1:19: Baden got some land
1:44: great job Würrtemberg
2:05: How
2:10: HOWWWW wait border with Baden :P
2:19: HOW THAT BIG WÜRTTEMBURG
2:57: did you guys just walk to get land
3:08: wait what
3:11: who is that
3:12: so far
3:26: who is that there
3:31: annex the sus state now
3:41: STOP
3:48: baden wat
3:51: how can you be that big
3:58: stop adding states
4:20: STOP
6:11: are you sure
6:12: oh yes wait AMONG US ON BADEN
6:17: bro zones
7:16: NAZI
7:19: BIG LAND
7:22: three states?
7:25: the end
4:07 a your lunch break can’t hear my
epic, can't wait
The video is good for one thing, namely to show that the so-called Holy Roman Empire actually fell with the death of Kaiser Otto I. Because Baden and Württemberg were actually independent states over the centuries, like all the other German small states. In fact, the German small states were actually permanently at war with each other, so that a united state could not arise! 1000 years they killed each other. One of the highlights was the Thirty Years' War. But they also fought each other before and after Thirty Years' War. The areas inhabited by Germans were a patchwork of territories! Consisting of hundreds of smaller sub-units of principalities, bailiwicks, margraviates, lordships, free cities, baronies, duchies and even simple counties and bishoprics and other domains. The kaiser title was only status without real political meaning! Because the Holy Roman Empire was not a state, but a complex of territories. The siege of Vienna in 1683 was also proof that the kaiser's title had no political significance. The kaiser title was only status without real political meaning! So the Holy Roman Empire was over the centuries without central authority! For example the so-called Kaiser Leopold could not order the other German states at the second siege of Vienna in 1683 to send troops to save his capital, for his capital was not recognized as the capital of the all other German states. Leopold's will was meaningless to the other Rulers of the other German small states. Only a few German states sent troops to support the Habsburgs. Because there was not enough support from the other German states and and the Habsburgs were too weak alone, so Leopold had to ask Polish Empire for help! Also these Germans of this small states often killed each other with the support of non-German allies. A completely ridiculous and stupid nation that was in a civil war for 1000 years and only managed to found a united German state in 1871. It was only in 1871 that the first permanent unified German state emerged. That is why the Germans are also known as the late nation. Because the first unified German state was only founded in 1871!
Whereby the English term Holy Roman Empire is based on an incorrect translation and is actually wrong. The German term "Heiliges Römisches Reich" was also incorrectly translated into English as "Holy Roman Empire" and since then this wrong translation has been used incorrectly again and again. "Imperium" is empire in German not "Reich"! The term "Reich" is correctly explained in this German wikipedia link on the subject Reich (Territorium)! Quote from this German wikipeia link translated: "Reich denotes the territory of a ruler, a state or, more generally, a politically organized community" So Reich is the same as realm. In German every kingdom can be called a "Reich"even if it is not an empire at all. The German word "Königreich" for kingdom actually contains the word Reich! König-Reich. Realm of Kings! So the correct translation is "Holy Romen Realm" and not "Holy Roman Empire"! Despite it still, ignorant fools use the wrong term "Holy Roman Empire".
An alternative would be to use the German proper name in English. So Holy Roman Reich! This is also done in other contexts. As for example with the term the "Third Reich". In the meantime, people also speak of the "Fourth Reich" when one wants to polemically criticize Germany's attempts to dominate in Europe. I have already read texts where the term "Reich Progrom Night" was used. In the wiki link to the "Reichswehr" there is talk of "Reich Defense" as a translation. The same also applies to the wiki link to the "Reichsmarine" there is also the talk of "Reich Navy" as a translation. There are certainly other examples that show that the term "Reich" is used as a German proper name in English. So it would actually make sense to do this principally in order to avoid this translation error of wrong Holy Roman Empire! So it would be correct Holy Roman Reich or Holy Roman Realm!
By the way, at most, one could call this patchwork of territories a military alliance. But even that is actually wrong, because within a military alliance the allies do not fight each other all the time! The various German states also founded alliances, which also makes it clear that the Holy Romen Realm did not in fact exist! For example the Rheinische Allianz or the Welfenallianz or the Hildesheimer Allianz or the Kurrheinian alliance. It is interesting that these alliances could also include non-German states. For example was Sweden member of the Rheinische Allianz and France too! This demostrates the confusion and the absurdity of the the Holy Romen Realm.
Lubię Świente Cesarstwo Rzymskie narodu Niemieckiego i jego mały lub duzyczch członków
Jakie bzdury napisałeś? Żaden Polak to lubi! Poza tym nie było czego podziwiać. W kolejnym komentarzu poniżej opiszę, dlaczego to była kompletna bzdura. To jest kopia mojego komentarza, który zamieściłem pod filmem. Jeśli nie rozumiesz, możesz skorzystać z tłumacza.
The video is good for one thing, namely to show that the so-called Holy Roman Empire actually fell with the death of Kaiser Otto I. Because Baden and Württemberg were actually independent states over the centuries, like all the other German small states. In fact, the German small states were actually permanently at war with each other, so that a united state could not arise! 1000 years they killed each other. One of the highlights was the Thirty Years' War. But they also fought each other before and after Thirty Years' War. The areas inhabited by Germans were a patchwork of territories! Consisting of hundreds of smaller sub-units of principalities, bailiwicks, margraviates, lordships, free cities, baronies, duchies and even simple counties and bishoprics and other domains. The kaiser title was only status without real political meaning! Because the Holy Roman Empire was not a state, but a complex of territories. The siege of Vienna in 1683 was also proof that the kaiser's title had no political significance. The kaiser title was only status without real political meaning! So the Holy Roman Empire was over the centuries without central authority! For example the so-called Kaiser Leopold could not order the other German states at the second siege of Vienna in 1683 to send troops to save his capital, for his capital was not recognized as the capital of the all other German states. Leopold's will was meaningless to the other Rulers of the other German small states. Only a few German states sent troops to support the Habsburgs. Because there was not enough support from the other German states and and the Habsburgs were too weak alone, so Leopold had to ask Polish Empire for help! Also these Germans of this small states often killed each other with the support of non-German allies. A completely ridiculous and stupid nation that was in a civil war for 1000 years and only managed to found a united German state in 1871. It was only in 1871 that the first permanent unified German state emerged. That is why the Germans are also known as the late nation. Because the first unified German state was only founded in 1871!
Whereby the English term Holy Roman Empire is based on an incorrect translation and is actually wrong. The German term "Heiliges Römisches Reich" was also incorrectly translated into English as "Holy Roman Empire" and since then this wrong translation has been used incorrectly again and again. "Imperium" is empire in German not "Reich"! The term "Reich" is correctly explained in this German wikipedia link on the subject Reich (Territorium)! Quote from this German wikipeia link translated: "Reich denotes the territory of a ruler, a state or, more generally, a politically organized community" So Reich is the same as realm. In German every kingdom can be called a "Reich"even if it is not an empire at all. The German word "Königreich" for kingdom actually contains the word Reich! König-Reich. Realm of Kings! So the correct translation is "Holy Romen Realm" and not "Holy Roman Empire"! Despite it still, ignorant fools use the wrong term "Holy Roman Empire".
An alternative would be to use the German proper name in English. So Holy Roman Reich! This is also done in other contexts. As for example with the term the "Third Reich". In the meantime, people also speak of the "Fourth Reich" when one wants to polemically criticize Germany's attempts to dominate in Europe. I have already read texts where the term "Reich Progrom Night" was used. In the wiki link to the "Reichswehr" there is talk of "Reich Defense" as a translation. The same also applies to the wiki link to the "Reichsmarine" there is also the talk of "Reich Navy" as a translation. There are certainly other examples that show that the term "Reich" is used as a German proper name in English. So it would actually make sense to do this principally in order to avoid this translation error of wrong Holy Roman Empire! So it would be correct Holy Roman Reich or Holy Roman Realm!
By the way, at most, one could call this patchwork of territories a military alliance. But even that is actually wrong, because within a military alliance the allies do not fight each other all the time! The various German states also founded alliances, which also makes it clear that the Holy Romen Realm did not in fact exist! For example the Rheinische Allianz or the Welfenallianz or the Hildesheimer Allianz or the Kurrheinian alliance. It is interesting that these alliances could also include non-German states. For example was Sweden member of the Rheinische Allianz and France too! This demostrates the confusion and the absurdity of the the Holy Romen Realm.
Can you tell me the title of the second song?
Badnerlied
@@larsjohn8445 thanks👍
nice job dude
ah yes Baden-Baden
Very nice, however i have some corrections on the flag for Württemberg. You see, the Black-Red bicolor was only adopted after 1817 by Wihelm I. Before that, the flag that has most evidence of usage as a "national" flag is a tricolor, Yellow-Black-Red from around 1803 to 1816. Some may argue that the flag was a Black-Yellow bicolor before 1817, being connected to the royal colors. However, there is little to no evidence of it being used (at least after 1803) in written or drawn form. The striped Black-Red one is a gigantic error, as it was, for some reason, put on wikipedia as the electorate flag, even though the only proof of it ever existing was a painting of a river vessel from 1839...
Still, the history and usage of the flag of Württemberg is still on construction so this isnt the final say, as there is always more info to consider/discover...
I be in Waldkirch gbore und in Balinge‘ uffgwachse. Deswege bin i badensischer Schwob.
This is the real Allemagne.
Actually yes. The German language as we know it today came exactly from this region. (Hochdeutsch) it spread all over Germany to the north at the second vowel shift, and the region that was not affected speaks dutch today
@@robert48719 Standard german is an artificially created language not natively spoken anywhere pre modern times. And standard german and high german are not to be confused. Also standard nederlands isnt the only low german which exists to this day, its just the only official one.
Zrobisz ''history of germany every month'' albo modern albo every year?
7:07 Why do the leaders of Baden change regularly while the leaders of Württemberg last longer?
A littlebit of a guess, but rooted in what devides both sides of the state today aswell: Baden ruled with a kinda excentric aspect, because it was on the wealthy shores of the Rhine. While Württemberg always struggeld economically up until the last two centuries and had to focus on getting people paid.
In the interwar years, Württemberg was relatively stable compared to the rest of Germany.
I was in baden Wurttemberg last month 🎉
my german grandmas from baden
Apparently this is where 98 percent of my genes come from lol Cool video
Where do you live, if you don’t mind I ask?
Baden and wutenberg should be separate land to this day in my opinion
you mean “Württemburg”?
Crazy names to memorise, shall be Baden-Baden and it’s done.
Badenser sturbock oder wie kommst du zu dieser hirnlosen meinung
Hitler intended to merge Baden with Alsace, so at least Württemberg would have been its own if Germany had won WWII.
Definitely
Is the first song like French anthem?
It's a German parody of "La Marseillaise".
@@candyneige6609Not exactly a parody, more like heavily inspired. The Badenserlied is as well tho, they're not better than us.
@@Rio_1111 It's still a sort of parody.
can you make modern history of China(1840-2022) every month,please？
Wow, they really got their land from the Napoleonic wars, didn't they?
My dad's cousin lives in baden-wurttemberg
Montebéliard is Mömpelgard in german
I love black Forest
Premier is now
Why are they like countries? I think they have accents. I think that's why.
Germany didn’t exist until the 19th century. It was a collection of many small states. I don’t think you could call them countries, but there were similarities
@@robert48719in the 1800s you could call them countries.
Deutschland
History of Germany next ? Russia ?
Dr Hartmann ancestors
Rip ww2 2 states
Baden-Württemberg?
Ja Heinz, Baden-Württemberg.
Baden ist besser als Württemberg
They are the same
Rauss
The video is good for one thing, namely to show that the so-called Holy Roman Empire actually fell with the death of Kaiser Otto I. Because Baden and Württemberg were actually independent states over the centuries, like all the other German small states. In fact, the German small states were actually permanently at war with each other, so that a united state could not arise! 1000 years they killed each other. One of the highlights was the Thirty Years' War. But they also fought each other before and after Thirty Years' War. The areas inhabited by Germans were a patchwork of territories! Consisting of hundreds of smaller sub-units of principalities, bailiwicks, margraviates, lordships, free cities, baronies, duchies and even simple counties and bishoprics and other domains. The kaiser title was only status without real political meaning! Because the Holy Roman Empire was not a state, but a complex of territories. The siege of Vienna in 1683 was also proof that the kaiser's title had no political significance. The kaiser title was only status without real political meaning! So the Holy Roman Empire was over the centuries without central authority! For example the so-called Kaiser Leopold could not order the other German states at the second siege of Vienna in 1683 to send troops to save his capital, for his capital was not recognized as the capital of the all other German states. Leopold's will was meaningless to the other Rulers of the other German small states. Only a few German states sent troops to support the Habsburgs. Because there was not enough support from the other German states and and the Habsburgs were too weak alone, so Leopold had to ask Polish Empire for help! Also these Germans of this small states often killed each other with the support of non-German allies. A completely ridiculous and stupid nation that was in a civil war for 1000 years and only managed to found a united German state in 1871. It was only in 1871 that the first permanent unified German state emerged. That is why the Germans are also known as the late nation. Because the first unified German state was only founded in 1871!
Whereby the English term Holy Roman Empire is based on an incorrect translation and is actually wrong. The German term "Heiliges Römisches Reich" was also incorrectly translated into English as "Holy Roman Empire" and since then this wrong translation has been used incorrectly again and again. "Imperium" is empire in German not "Reich"! The term "Reich" is correctly explained in this German wikipedia link on the subject Reich (Territorium)! Quote from this German wikipeia link translated: "Reich denotes the territory of a ruler, a state or, more generally, a politically organized community" So Reich is the same as realm. In German every kingdom can be called a "Reich"even if it is not an empire at all. The German word "Königreich" for kingdom actually contains the word Reich! König-Reich. Realm of Kings! So the correct translation is "Holy Romen Realm" and not "Holy Roman Empire"! Despite it still, ignorant fools use the wrong term "Holy Roman Empire".
An alternative would be to use the German proper name in English. So Holy Roman Reich! This is also done in other contexts. As for example with the term the "Third Reich". In the meantime, people also speak of the "Fourth Reich" when one wants to polemically criticize Germany's attempts to dominate in Europe. I have already read texts where the term "Reich Progrom Night" was used. In the wiki link to the "Reichswehr" there is talk of "Reich Defense" as a translation. The same also applies to the wiki link to the "Reichsmarine" there is also the talk of "Reich Navy" as a translation. There are certainly other examples that show that the term "Reich" is used as a German proper name in English. So it would actually make sense to do this principally in order to avoid this translation error of wrong Holy Roman Empire! So it would be correct Holy Roman Reich or Holy Roman Realm!
By the way, at most, one could call this patchwork of territories a military alliance. But even that is actually wrong, because within a military alliance the allies do not fight each other all the time! The various German states also founded alliances, which also makes it clear that the Holy Romen Realm did not in fact exist! For example the Rheinische Allianz or the Welfenallianz or the Hildesheimer Allianz or the Kurrheinian alliance. It is interesting that these alliances could also include non-German states. For example was Sweden member of the Rheinische Allianz and France too! This demostrates the confusion and the absurdity of the the Holy Romen Realm.
r/copypasta
@@octopus_72 No, this is my first comment. I then copied this comment and posted it under other comments because I wanted as many people as possible to read this information. Because i made an effort to write this long text.
@@GreatPolishWingedHussars Yeah, bullshit.
@@Ghreinos What you obviously can do is to write pathetically vulgar comments. The vulgarity is probably intended to hide the fact that you have no logical and good counterarguments.
This is absolute nonsense, filled with hostility and disrespect. The German states were not constantly at war with each other, and "Heiliges Römisches Reich" is the German translation of "Sacrum Imperium Romanum", which of course means "Holy Roman Empire", not "realm. The nation state is a relatively recent invention. Germany became one at about the same time as Italy. Most nation states of today are younger.
Terrible map. It would be MUCH better if they would show a shadow of current Germany for reference. 👎