I can see your careful planning in the end results, very elegant solutions to all the construction details. All the finishing is so well considered that nothing disrupts the overall look. The result is perfectly scaled and trimmed in keeping with the existing room. It is not just a remodel or upgrade, but something that looks like it always was or always should have been there. Lovely work.
Man, this really turned out nice! we are doing something very similar for a client with bookcases on each side. I can only hope it turns out as nice as this. Great work.
just what I was looking for. so many videos show essentially finished product w/ few details, if any, of the mounting technique. I'm not sure about your suggestion of anchoring into the mortar, instead of the brick, but I imagine that's for being able to undo the whole thing in future if desired and not having holes in the brick. Seems to me the mortar is a lot thinner/shallower and more prone to chip out, thereby providing less grip for the fasteners. Maybe my thinking is wrong. Also, the tip about the combustibles around the firebox being a code issue is very appreciative. I don't know that I would have considered checking local code, especially since I'm the homeowner.
Beautiful job. Only thing I would have done different was made the top trim piece of the mantle larger so when you added the crown it would be the same reveal as the rest of the trim boxes on the mantle. But great job.
Yea it looks even all way around the top but what I meant was you have what looks like 2 inch trim on the legs to give it the shaker style look the top piece of that trim is mostly covered by the crown molding leaving a 3/4” reveal I would have made the top piece of that trim big enough so when the crown was on top of it it would have the same 2 inch reveal as the trim pieces on the legs. I guess it’s just personal preference and I dont want to take anything away from your work it’s beautiful.
I see your point now. The main issue I was fighting here was the height, since there was a raised hearth. It's a very tricky dimension to get right when the raised heath essentially takes away 12-14 inches from the equation. The width is set by the firebox and the raised hearth as well. Often these designs are compromised in some way since you aren't starting with a clean sheet of paper.
GORGEOUS! I’m stealing this and I’m so excited lol I’m putting mine in a blank wall. Would using 1x8 pine wood be better than using plywood or should I use mdf? Not sure about that part.
It really comes down to the quality of the available wood in your area. The point of using plywood or MDF is assured straightness and stability over real wood. But, if you can source good quality pine or poplar in your area there's nothing wrong with going that route.
You have to examine the particular installation you are working on, because there is no standard for this and there could be differences. That said, typically the bricks are built as a facade over or on top of the brick firebox itself. You often find wallboard or studs behind the first few layers of brick on top. So, to remove a couple-few layers is just a matter of using a cold-chisel and hammer to chip away the mortar joints and remove each brick as you go. I wouldn't recommend using a diamond blade in a grinder because it makes a lot of nasty dust. Start on one end and chip off the first brick and I think you'll find the rest goes fairly quickly.
Looks good. The code is the same here. I always wonder back in those days the brick area or whatever was so wide, now these days ah 6 inches is fine. lol What changed? Was that just a style thing back than?
A well-built brick fireplace was certainly a status symbol for several centuries. Only in recent decades have other styles become popular, I think. Of course, far fewer homeowners actually use their fireplaces anymore anyway. I see many that have been converted to natural gas, or that contain candles, or that have been closed off for years.
The crown under the mantel shelf is a standard cove profile. The box stores may not carry it, but any local lumberyard should be able to help you. It's typically a stock item at a lumberyard.
@@enduringcharm sorry I meant the trim that goes around the tile on the bottom, you mentioned in the video as "trim piece" but I am not sure as I am not familiar with constructions jargons. Also: the wood you used was pinewood?, except for the "nailer" wood which is a different part, I think? Sorry for so many questions, I love the video and thinking of doing the same myself. thanks much.
Oh, okay. That's just a piece of wood to wrap around the edge of the tile and hide it. It could be a custom made piece like I did, or you could choose a moulding from a lumberyard. The choice of wood you use is not that critical. You might choose a hardwood like oak or maple if it is to be stained, or pine or poplar if it will be painted.
There's just too many variables to consider, which is why I price out each project individually for clients. The tile can vary from as little as $1.50 to $12 a square foot. Lumber prices vary by season and lately due to trade tariffs. You can buy paint that costs $20 a gallon or $70 a gallon. The size of the mantle may mean you'll have no leftover or a lot of leftover material due to the lengths needed. It's in the high hundreds or low thousand, anyway.
Sorry, there's no list. I work with clients individually to develop each design and it's tailored to the circumstances in the home. In any case, all you really need are basic lumber and moldings, and a white marbly tile.
It's simple. You listen to what he is saying in the video Than play the video again and again and again, until you finally catch was he was doing... Good luck!
EnduringCharm, I just wanted to say it's nice to see a detail (may I say OCD level) oriented Craftsman doing what he likes in his trade! You've just given me an idea how to change a builder grade level. Much appreciated
Just about to start my fireplace remodel this weekend. One question, what do you use to attach the metal edging to the brick? Thanks! Love the video - so helpful!!
@@kimcampion4095 You can generally cement that in place with the thinset. If necessary you could use tapcon screws to temporarily hold in place until the thinset cures.
The client chose the tile, which was actually not a cheap ceramic but an expensive porcelain tile. Stone is an option, but in that case the expense will be greater for both the materials and the installation since the stone will need to be sealed. The stone will also need to be resealed from time to time if it is a marble or other softer stone since staining from the ashes, wood and occasional snow or rain runoff is possible. The porcelain tile gives the carrara look but without the staining risk and with a little more durability.
Love the way it came out, I am looking for something just like this in my home. Thank you for the detailed instructions and inspiration.
This is exactly what we needed to see! We’re doing a DIY of almost the same project. THANK YOU!
Can you redo my fireplace? 😊
Beautiful work.
Very nice job!!
I can see your careful planning in the end results, very elegant solutions to all the construction details. All the finishing is so well considered that nothing disrupts the overall look. The result is perfectly scaled and trimmed in keeping with the existing room. It is not just a remodel or upgrade, but something that looks like it always was or always should have been there. Lovely work.
Man, this really turned out nice! we are doing something very similar for a client with bookcases on each side. I can only hope it turns out as nice as this. Great work.
Thanks, bud!
Great! Thanks for the tips!
It’s perfect I love it
Good job dude.
just what I was looking for. so many videos show essentially finished product w/ few details, if any, of the mounting technique. I'm not sure about your suggestion of anchoring into the mortar, instead of the brick, but I imagine that's for being able to undo the whole thing in future if desired and not having holes in the brick. Seems to me the mortar is a lot thinner/shallower and more prone to chip out, thereby providing less grip for the fasteners. Maybe my thinking is wrong. Also, the tip about the combustibles around the firebox being a code issue is very appreciative. I don't know that I would have considered checking local code, especially since I'm the homeowner.
NICE!!
Beautiful job. Only thing I would have done different was made the top trim piece of the mantle larger so when you added the crown it would be the same reveal as the rest of the trim boxes on the mantle. But great job.
Actually, that reveal is about the same --3/4". Maybe it just didn't come across well on video.
Yea it looks even all way around the top but what I meant was you have what looks like 2 inch trim on the legs to give it the shaker style look the top piece of that trim is mostly covered by the crown molding leaving a 3/4” reveal I would have made the top piece of that trim big enough so when the crown was on top of it it would have the same 2 inch reveal as the trim pieces on the legs. I guess it’s just personal preference and I dont want to take anything away from your work it’s beautiful.
I see your point now. The main issue I was fighting here was the height, since there was a raised hearth. It's a very tricky dimension to get right when the raised heath essentially takes away 12-14 inches from the equation. The width is set by the firebox and the raised hearth as well. Often these designs are compromised in some way since you aren't starting with a clean sheet of paper.
GORGEOUS! I’m stealing this and I’m so excited lol I’m putting mine in a blank wall. Would using 1x8 pine wood be better than using plywood or should I use mdf? Not sure about that part.
It really comes down to the quality of the available wood in your area. The point of using plywood or MDF is assured straightness and stability over real wood. But, if you can source good quality pine or poplar in your area there's nothing wrong with going that route.
How did you remove the bricks (sticking out) that supported the old mantle? I have the same and want to know your steps. Thanks
You have to examine the particular installation you are working on, because there is no standard for this and there could be differences. That said, typically the bricks are built as a facade over or on top of the brick firebox itself. You often find wallboard or studs behind the first few layers of brick on top. So, to remove a couple-few layers is just a matter of using a cold-chisel and hammer to chip away the mortar joints and remove each brick as you go. I wouldn't recommend using a diamond blade in a grinder because it makes a lot of nasty dust. Start on one end and chip off the first brick and I think you'll find the rest goes fairly quickly.
Looks good. The code is the same here. I always wonder back in those days the brick area or whatever was so wide, now these days ah 6 inches is fine. lol What changed? Was that just a style thing back than?
A well-built brick fireplace was certainly a status symbol for several centuries. Only in recent decades have other styles become popular, I think. Of course, far fewer homeowners actually use their fireplaces anymore anyway. I see many that have been converted to natural gas, or that contain candles, or that have been closed off for years.
Does anyone know approximately how much something like this would cost if I only need to do the hearst? Great job by the way!
Cost varies by region and by the details of your particular fireplace. Find a local contractor to take a look--it's usually no cost.
Dude. Your going to have to sue me for plagiarism. Hahah. I love your projects.
Glad you find them helpful, and I can't afford a lawyer anyway so I think you're safe from plagiarism!
Where did you get the crown molding? I can’t find that anywhere
The crown under the mantel shelf is a standard cove profile. The box stores may not carry it, but any local lumberyard should be able to help you. It's typically a stock item at a lumberyard.
Great craftmanship! Did the client paint the fire box?
I'm not sure about that, actually.
Sorry what is the trim piece around the tile that you mentioned ? Thanks
You mean the aluminum strip? It probably has different names, "edging" being a common one. Any tile store or box store that sells tile will have it.
@@enduringcharm sorry I meant the trim that goes around the tile on the bottom, you mentioned in the video as "trim piece" but I am not sure as I am not familiar with constructions jargons. Also: the wood you used was pinewood?, except for the "nailer" wood which is a different part, I think? Sorry for so many questions, I love the video and thinking of doing the same myself. thanks much.
Oh, okay. That's just a piece of wood to wrap around the edge of the tile and hide it. It could be a custom made piece like I did, or you could choose a moulding from a lumberyard. The choice of wood you use is not that critical. You might choose a hardwood like oak or maple if it is to be stained, or pine or poplar if it will be painted.
Roughly, how much does a project like this cost in material?
There's just too many variables to consider, which is why I price out each project individually for clients. The tile can vary from as little as $1.50 to $12 a square foot. Lumber prices vary by season and lately due to trade tariffs. You can buy paint that costs $20 a gallon or $70 a gallon. The size of the mantle may mean you'll have no leftover or a lot of leftover material due to the lengths needed. It's in the high hundreds or low thousand, anyway.
Can you send me a list of materials? I LOVE this design and want to use it. Ready to start my project in about 2 weeks. Thanks!!
Sorry, there's no list. I work with clients individually to develop each design and it's tailored to the circumstances in the home. In any case, all you really need are basic lumber and moldings, and a white marbly tile.
It's simple.
You listen to what he is saying in the video
Than play the video again and again and again, until you finally catch was he was doing...
Good luck!
EnduringCharm,
I just wanted to say it's nice to see a detail (may I say OCD level) oriented Craftsman doing what he likes in his trade!
You've just given me an idea how to change a builder grade level.
Much appreciated
Just about to start my fireplace remodel this weekend. One question, what do you use to attach the metal edging to the brick? Thanks! Love the video - so helpful!!
@@kimcampion4095 You can generally cement that in place with the thinset. If necessary you could use tapcon screws to temporarily hold in place until the thinset cures.
nice mantle and surround but tile should be some kind of nice stone instead of cheap ceramic
The client chose the tile, which was actually not a cheap ceramic but an expensive porcelain tile. Stone is an option, but in that case the expense will be greater for both the materials and the installation since the stone will need to be sealed. The stone will also need to be resealed from time to time if it is a marble or other softer stone since staining from the ashes, wood and occasional snow or rain runoff is possible. The porcelain tile gives the carrara look but without the staining risk and with a little more durability.