GUITAR RIG 5 PRO | Native Instruments

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 окт 2024

Комментарии • 363

  • @chusssMusic
    @chusssMusic 4 года назад +7

    Still one of the best guitar tone software even after 9 years. Thanks NI for such a great software.

  • @CaribSurfKing1
    @CaribSurfKing1 10 лет назад +11

    Yamaha THR10 in bypass mode - > guitar rig 5 -> yamaha THR10 audio in!
    Wow, amazing sound
    Heaviest metal crunch authentic tones I have ever heard modeled!

  • @mar990
    @mar990 4 года назад +21

    9 years and counting, Bring some new updates guys! Where the hell is the passion!!!

    • @trulyblessed4796
      @trulyblessed4796 4 года назад

      Do you need a guitar?

    • @mar990
      @mar990 4 года назад

      Truly Blessed for guitar rig? If so then yeah, you need a guitar for guitar rig

    • @trulyblessed4796
      @trulyblessed4796 4 года назад

      @@mar990 thx for the help

    • @minionslayer
      @minionslayer 3 года назад +1

      I'm prety sure literally any input will work.

    • @MITTEL.PUNKT_13
      @MITTEL.PUNKT_13 3 года назад

      There it is

  • @CaribSurfKing1
    @CaribSurfKing1 8 лет назад +118

    5 years guys!
    Come on, you have to get a new version out!

    • @gotrain4me
      @gotrain4me 7 лет назад +3

      Please do!

    • @RedIng-Argentina
      @RedIng-Argentina 6 лет назад

      Do it!

    • @pauldavis3904
      @pauldavis3904 5 лет назад +6

      7 years and still waiting..... i use loads of NI products but 7 years..... not good. Really guitar rig 5 was ahead of the curve too in many ways....

    • @jjm9741
      @jjm9741 5 лет назад

      im mean really

    • @gulbeturbo
      @gulbeturbo 3 года назад +1

      Guitar rig 6 released in 2021

  • @happyhamster1411
    @happyhamster1411 12 лет назад +4

    I just bought this the other day. It was on sale for $99. I just had to do it ;)
    Today is the last day for the sale 11/26. RUN!!!!!!

  • @panpipesjohn
    @panpipesjohn 13 лет назад +4

    sounds very nice and the versatility
    is absolutely amazing!
    keep up the outstanding work.
    ... but nothing beats a real tube amp!!!

  • @polarispkk
    @polarispkk 12 лет назад

    Pinch harmonics are made by the player, the effects or amps just bring them out more. A skill to develop, and I'm sure RUclips has plenty of tutorials that will show you how.

  • @mrolympia2774
    @mrolympia2774 4 года назад

    The best in the world, since I met in 2012

  • @tzetzo_tzetzov
    @tzetzo_tzetzov 8 лет назад +60

    Amazing torrent would recommend!!

  • @kangjaehong
    @kangjaehong 10 лет назад

    I love it......Future of recording........

  • @hardminder
    @hardminder 12 лет назад

    I'm going to cra...buy it right now!

  • @IwishIwereJoe
    @IwishIwereJoe 11 лет назад

    To those who are saying this sounds bad or nasty . Make sure you're settings are correct. You need a decent interface and asio4all . The sound clips aren't far from what they sound like to me. And I use a cheaper schecter guitar . It can have singing awesome leads or beautiful effected clean tones

  • @myonline88
    @myonline88 10 лет назад

    I got the guitar rig 4 and it's awesome. Good for playing like a pro. But carrying a laptop on stage is quite cumbersome. I got Amplitube for iPhone and it's even better. I could even mount the iPhone on the edge of the guitar using mounting pods for convenient operation.

  • @instrumentalist28
    @instrumentalist28 12 лет назад

    turn on input monitoring and make sure the input is selected on the track

  • @jeroen2062
    @jeroen2062 12 лет назад

    Cool! im waiting for my mk2 delivery at my door cant wait 2 give this a try :)

  • @curszondax
    @curszondax 9 лет назад +46

    needs more bass amps

  • @Harrysound
    @Harrysound 13 лет назад

    I have this and i'm liking it alot!

  • @kennyken7278
    @kennyken7278 10 лет назад

    For people who are totally new to Amp sim softwares like Guitar Rig and Amplitube.....you can try the $10 GuitarLink (generic) off Ebay ...it works pretty well for its purpose, but you cannot record with it, but I swear to god it beats most guitar FX out there when it comes to sound quality.....And If you want to step up, that's where USB Audio interface comes into play, it will sound better and has lesser noise and distorted signals....I had my LEXICON ALPHA for $100, unbeatable value for what it does! And I'm only using a PC speaker

  • @ljohn787
    @ljohn787 13 лет назад

    @ballaststoffel2 It's all about your sound card. If you get the guitar rig kontroller, for example, I believe there is a built-in card that keeps latency pretty low (like any decent sound card would).

  • @messengercrow
    @messengercrow 12 лет назад

    yes you do. try m-audio fastrack

  • @ThatMellon
    @ThatMellon 12 лет назад

    @kristofreynders Basicaly just plug your Guitar lead into the Mic socket on your PC/Laprop you'll need a 1/4 - 1/8 converter though.

  • @cast390
    @cast390 12 лет назад

    While I do like TH2 better.GR5 Pro sounds great.The tube amp emulations are very realistic.They respond and feel like the real deal.

  • @alpyre
    @alpyre 12 лет назад

    Yes surely you can...

  • @pariahthe
    @pariahthe 13 лет назад

    Amazing

  • @Opranius
    @Opranius 11 лет назад

    Just my sweet little Tascam US-122 MKII. (I'm a poor student :-) )
    There are no really good metal-tone presets. At the moment I go for "Pure Rammfire G" and then I increase the lows and highs with the Parametric EQ (i just have the demo). Sounds pretty good in D.

  • @Opranius
    @Opranius 11 лет назад

    additionally you need an average guitar for a decent sound. I use a Shecter too - for 600 euros (normal price-range I'd say) - and it sounds like in the video (the clean-sounds and solo-sounds are brilliant!).
    It's a bit hard to get a good metal-sound with GuitarRig but it still works fine with a good guitar. :-)

  • @thoseenglish
    @thoseenglish 11 лет назад

    I'll upload one shortly, getting mine today, with pedal :) So I'll upload a vid this week probably

  • @dbrckovic
    @dbrckovic 12 лет назад

    you might know this already, but you can download fender universal ASIO driver. It should work on any sound card. There's also ASIO4ALL universal driver that does the same thing but it didn't work on one laptop for me.

  • @imeego2
    @imeego2 13 лет назад

    hey! this is an amazing prog for recording! especially as VST

  • @caseylockwood5512
    @caseylockwood5512 11 лет назад

    Try a different DAW, maybe Reaper? Also, make sure you are running the ASIO drivers, if its not working with your current set up.

  • @fabianrr
    @fabianrr 8 лет назад +9

    waiting for guitar rig 6 :3

    • @frickethan
      @frickethan 4 года назад +2

      got some news for ya

    • @fabianrr
      @fabianrr 4 года назад +1

      @@frickethan 🤣😂

    • @raulrgh
      @raulrgh 4 года назад +2

      just about timeee

  • @TheAssaschan
    @TheAssaschan 11 лет назад

    Ah ok that makes sense, cheers man.

  • @PeopleintheStatic
    @PeopleintheStatic 12 лет назад

    Time to set sail to thepiratebay!

  • @chumbalum
    @chumbalum 12 лет назад

    Just downloaded Guitar Rig 5 Player .. I use it with my M-Audio Fast Track MKII .. this software is beautiful, easy and very powerful. I really would buy Pro but 180€ is way too much for a student :\

  • @GuitarsAndSynths
    @GuitarsAndSynths 7 лет назад

    Love this software! How would I get an external effects pedal to work with Guitar Rig 5?

  • @imeego2
    @imeego2 13 лет назад

    @alpinestate ,using a sound card (USB or PCI) !

  • @imeego2
    @imeego2 12 лет назад

    hey!i have the guitar rig control .. and it has a midi in -out .....but you can use the sounds of guitar rig for your midi piano .you can do that with recording software (cubase for example ) [use the guitar rig 5 as vst ]

  • @anotherytnameyk
    @anotherytnameyk 12 лет назад

    would it be ok to use this for most of the mix ? even if a song doesnt have a guitar ?

  • @blink7777777
    @blink7777777 11 лет назад

    do i have to buy the full version in order to load a preset/impulse? (I think they're the same (preset/impulse) I'm not sure.) is that the only way I can use the chain feature too?

  • @1818Santana
    @1818Santana 11 лет назад

    PLS tellme if u found it! I love it.

  • @lanceaxeman1532
    @lanceaxeman1532 10 лет назад +1

    I have a laptop with GR5. Use a usb cable to either my Personus AudioBox interface or the Rig Control 3. From the outs I go into a Carvin TS100 power amp and then out to 2 Marshall 1936 2x12 cabs. I'm seriously working on this being my main "Gig Rig." The sound I get from this is pretty much unmatched by any of my many rigs. The only one that comes some what close is the Axe Fx II. The only real problem I have is I wish there was an alternate view that would show just the patch name and parameters in a full screen mode so it's easier to see on stage...

    • @KyleCarrington
      @KyleCarrington 10 лет назад

      way too thin for live. go for axe FX or real amps

    • @lanceaxeman1532
      @lanceaxeman1532 10 лет назад

      Might have to disagree with you on that Kyle. I have acouple banks of patches set up for a higher volume ... yes they did thin out a hair but not really that much. Just for the hell of it I added a Behringer xenyx 1202fx before the power amp to control the levels.I sprang this rig on my sound tech and he was floored. I had a couple un desirable patches where the delay or verb was too over the top but it was the first time out...

    • @KyleCarrington
      @KyleCarrington 10 лет назад

      Lance Axeman yeah actually ive been getting some pretty reasonable sounds from G5 too. it has an overall synthetic - ness to it.. that i honestly cant hear when i listen to Axe FX. But who can afford that stuff, wow. on that note, probably the best "synthetic" rig ive heard is my guitarists Fender Mustang III Stack. i hate to admit it, but that f'n thing is amazing. I love my Mesa Boogie, but man i think about what he spent and how much versatility it has... i mean... crap, the whole stack cost about $800 tops LOL its ridiculously cool

  • @Master90912
    @Master90912 4 года назад +1

    Guysss! I have beginning amp (Marshall MG10CD). Can i use this program to my amp???

  • @Billd0z3r
    @Billd0z3r 4 года назад

    The cleans are great, it has some interesting fx that may or may not come with a good daw or guitar pedals. I cannot for the life of me dial in a good distorted sound. I guess my Peavey 6505 + spoiled me? Or the real thing just cannot be replicated close enough.

  • @niko6454
    @niko6454 8 лет назад

    It works with Pro Tools? Like Reason with rewire plugin by example.

  • @DoktrDub
    @DoktrDub 11 лет назад

    @messengercrow most interfaces should be compatible aslong as you can jack a lead up to it like most interfaces can anyway, or you might be able to link it up through a digital amp via USB

  • @variancewithin
    @variancewithin 7 лет назад

    Does Jonny ive work for Native Instruments too?

  • @IwishIwereJoe
    @IwishIwereJoe 11 лет назад

    Yeah that's the one thing I haven't really been able to achieve as well as I wanted. A good metal tone. I've messed around with a few settings and have found some playable settings,but guitar rig doesn't really feel like a super high gain monster. Still very good software though. what kind of interface do you use?

  • @cperalta
    @cperalta 13 лет назад

    Did you guys make any changes to "Live Mode"? I love Guitar Rig 4, but Live Mode seriously sucks when you use it live. Also, will you guys be coming out with a new Rig Kontrol any time soon? Thanks.

  • @crappytoast
    @crappytoast 10 лет назад

    Would it be possible to use a bass guitar as a midi instrument through NI massive?, for a say a dirty electro synth sound? also be able to set it up for live use? and to be able to switch back to guitar rig for non synth sounds with an external midi controller, like a programmable stomp box?

  • @jhuffman64
    @jhuffman64 7 лет назад

    What is the best system to use for live play with guitar rig?

  • @firdausHITMAN
    @firdausHITMAN 12 лет назад

    This or the yamaha thr10? both are emulations but which would be better?

  • @guildfly51
    @guildfly51 8 лет назад

    im guessing this will all work fine through line in on pc
    looking for something that works like an effects pedal im guessing this is it

  • @burgeruniversity
    @burgeruniversity 11 лет назад +1

    For the people complaining that they get no sound, you need to download ASIO drivers.

  • @richardrahl3546
    @richardrahl3546 11 лет назад

    Can you use it for programming guitar tunes as well or is it only for "shaping" the sound that comes dirictly from a guitar?

  • @PandaBrutality
    @PandaBrutality 12 лет назад

    can you use guitar rig in tandem with other native instrument products to say use your guitar as a controller for absynth?

  • @antonkokic
    @antonkokic 12 лет назад

    this contains guitar instruments also?

  • @DimitriFrondizi
    @DimitriFrondizi 5 лет назад

    Hello, it is a great software better than amplitube for example, i tried it a few time ago in a friend's pc (should be the 5.2 version) , but i noticed there was a kind of annoying graphic issue : when i selected with the mouse a knob or a parameter often it missed to show the actual value to have the reference to be changed. I am almost sure that happened when i try to click on effects that was not visible among those showed in full hight of the window , so effects that needs to scroll down the window to become visible. Is it a known bug? is there a version in which has been solved?

  • @andrewkadar
    @andrewkadar 9 месяцев назад

    Why doesn’t some components work like the vintage verb and the cabinet room pro
    They make no changes in sound
    I need help

  • @RossCampbellGuitarist
    @RossCampbellGuitarist 13 лет назад

    @Bluedrake42 Was that just an excuse to mention that you have a $10,000 studio?

  • @Harrysound
    @Harrysound 11 лет назад

    maybe you have abad signal?
    Try double clicking the gate at the top to adjust for any signal noise.
    Never heard of a scarlett 2i4......

  • @vgmaster9
    @vgmaster9 13 лет назад

    Pardon my ignorance, but can more than one person use this at once, like a whole band?

  • @diasspeed
    @diasspeed 10 лет назад

    Is this good to use it in live situations? Lets say I connect my guitar to a laptop with this software and then straight to the PA. Can this work or is it better to use an good amp and mic?

    • @danieldelahanty6723
      @danieldelahanty6723 10 лет назад

      I know people who do that and ive heard it works pretty good.

    • @darkriff777
      @darkriff777 8 лет назад

      Buy a real amp for live stuff. It's a mission to set up your laptop with PA systems, just to get a loud sound.

  • @messengercrow
    @messengercrow 11 лет назад

    NI, how to connect the guitar to PC for a great quality? why don't you ever talk about that? Does it need an interface? What interface is compatible with GR5

  • @TheAssaschan
    @TheAssaschan 11 лет назад

    So it has a lot of guitar effects on here, but no actual guitar recordings, is that correct?

  • @nicethugbert
    @nicethugbert 11 лет назад

    Is it possible to usw this without mic simulations? Just room sound through "ears"?

  • @abstractlight1620
    @abstractlight1620 4 года назад

    is this the Hopes And Dreams guitar vst??

  • @fountane
    @fountane 12 лет назад

    Can anyone tell me how to get rid of the clean guitar sound I get underneath the distortion. I can hear the nice distortion sound but it's getting ruined by the clean sound underneath it that never goes away.

  • @stevo946
    @stevo946 13 лет назад

    @crisvstuper you record the audio and video separately, then put them together in a video editor.

  • @bHIPman
    @bHIPman 11 лет назад

    I have a Guitar Rig 3 and it's ok. I have no need to upgrade and i don't want to upgrade cause the sustain cannot even compare to my BOSS GT3 guitar processor.
    I mean, when i hit a note in Guitar Rig it lasts for a certain amount of time which is not long enough in my opinion. But when i'm playing through my BOSS GT3 that note lasts looong, which is awesome for metal/rock solos.
    Of course both can't be compared but just to give you an idea. I do like some effects in Guitar Rig though.

  • @gasytalenta6648
    @gasytalenta6648 12 лет назад

    student version is available in torrent version!

  • @daniva
    @daniva 4 года назад

    please update to a 6 version, you have the most decent cleans simulators, but compared to bias you are going down, you need to update the effects too, compared to others amp sim guitar rig is very musical not harsh sounding.. but you need to upgrade

  • @marvincosby7060
    @marvincosby7060 7 лет назад

    I can integrate it with my DAW? Does that include Reaper?

  • @OfficialAdamWest
    @OfficialAdamWest 8 лет назад +4

    So you created a VST of Joe Satriani?

  • @TRELOKAMPERI
    @TRELOKAMPERI 12 лет назад

    yes

  • @magicmike6961
    @magicmike6961 7 лет назад

    can you record with it?

  • @rucine
    @rucine 11 лет назад

    no it has a tapedeck button to record and loop on the fly

  • @ibinTZY
    @ibinTZY 11 лет назад

    its a stupid question but how to use it......i mean do we have to connect our guitar to da PC????....or dre is other way to do it?????

  • @h-dawg969
    @h-dawg969 4 года назад

    I have a question if any one has some insight.
    Say youve got all the tones you want and got your recording done, how do you then manage to emulate those same tones using amps n pedal when you are playing live? Do u just get as close as you can to the tone of your record?
    I cant imagine the misdion and cost it would be if trying to recreate same or similar sound whilst your with the band n playing live.
    & i expect fans wouldnt like it if theyte used to hearing your revord, but they go see u live n its the songs they know but with completely different tone....
    Probably an easy solution to a stupid question but ive never used anything like this before.....
    Looks like a sick product though so think I'll have to get it just for playing n recording stuff at home. Is it user friendly for a complete noob?

    • @scottreader7033
      @scottreader7033 4 года назад

      They have a free version with limited equipment, but it has a demo of lots of presets. I started using it today, and immediately ordered one of their interfaces which comes with the pro version free in UK (£79). But I need a new interface anyway, so a no brainier. Regarding live, I’m no expert, but I can’t see why you wouldn’t be able to use a laptop and interface to get this straight out to a pa?

  • @DJHeartFeelings
    @DJHeartFeelings 8 лет назад +1

    ist this a vst for a midi keyboard ore can i put my Guitar an play with that?

    • @B-DINO
      @B-DINO 8 лет назад

      will it work with a midi keyboard?

    • @fragment90a
      @fragment90a 8 лет назад

      Yes it will. You can integrate it in you Daw und input Midi sounds. But you need to give some virtual instrument (most likeley guitar) to the midi before add the signal to guitar rig

  • @DanieleTurani
    @DanieleTurani 11 лет назад

    maybe you have direct monitor enabled on your audio interface?

  • @petererhardt8420
    @petererhardt8420 8 лет назад

    Is Guitar Rig 5 in the Kontakt library or is it a separate NI entity?

    • @itschrisdecastro
      @itschrisdecastro 8 лет назад

      +Peter Erhardt Separate.
      If you want both, you might as well buy Komplete 10 and get more than just those 2 engines. Worth the $$. Komplete Ultimate is a Thou.

  • @tropixstarz2005
    @tropixstarz2005 Месяц назад

    HOW do i use this ? do i hook up the PC to my amp ? and plug my guitar into my PC ?

  • @Buoy2
    @Buoy2 13 лет назад

    @zab666 Vice versa imo. Except it's difficult to get a subtle overdrive effect without using an extra amp

  • @dregen77
    @dregen77 8 лет назад

    Junkyard are starting to get popular!?!? At last!!

  • @samuelcmercer
    @samuelcmercer 7 лет назад

    I keep trying to go to your website and it keeps giving me an error message. Is there something wrong at your end or my end?

  • @genjama
    @genjama 3 года назад

    I got an e-mail to download guitar rig 5 LE but the link just leads me to the reverb homepage. Upset that i cannot download it after spending 2 grand on an sg

  • @MakoEve
    @MakoEve 10 лет назад

    Can this be used to replace a guitar amplifier and a physical pedal board? Would it be possible to connect guitar-->audio interface--->computer. With outputs to monitors and use it for small room practice?

    • @joegragg64
      @joegragg64 10 лет назад

      Yes.

    • @davidsnakedoe7322
      @davidsnakedoe7322 10 лет назад

      I replaced guitar recording from amp thanks to Guitar Rig.
      If you learn well how to use it, you can build a monster sound thanks to this VST.

    • @rbagel55
      @rbagel55 10 лет назад

      John Jack Doe I use Acid Pro 7 to record. I have tried using Amplitube (Another PC based guitar rig) as my tone
      while I recorded with Acid 7. But I haven't had good results, system hangs or locks up. I use ASIO 4 All in both programs--any suggestions to my problom-is Guitar Rig Pro better?

  • @dcag76
    @dcag76 8 лет назад +1

    im new at this. so I buy the download for guitar 5. What other equipment do I need to purchase to connect the guitar to my computer, and computer to amp ect...?

    • @darkriff777
      @darkriff777 8 лет назад

      Buy yourself a Focusrite Scarlett 2i2 audio interface. It's the best entry/intermediate level audio interface for guitars and mics, at around $250 or so. (Don't buy a guitar link audio interface, those are pieces of shit). Connect your guitar cable into the Scarlett and that's it. If you want to record, get yourself Reaper or Studio One 3(DAW/Digital Audio Workstation). Alternatively, buy a Presonus Audiobox USB audio interface and you get Studio One Artist for free. That's it!

    • @tatzor
      @tatzor 8 лет назад

      You will probably need an external soundcard that supports this program. You won't need an amp since the amp is "inside" the program, all you need is headphones/speakers

    • @emfarhanr
      @emfarhanr 8 лет назад

      dcag76 You need audio interface, most youtube guitarist use focusrite audio interface to connect ur guitar to ur pc.. no need to install anything, just plug and play :D

    • @dcag76
      @dcag76 8 лет назад

      Thank you

    • @jacobjantz1124
      @jacobjantz1124 6 лет назад

      it def isn't plug and play wtf

  • @samuelsuarez9790
    @samuelsuarez9790 6 лет назад

    I have a problem when saving my tracks. I hit the Save button on the post tapedeck and then appears something like ''Sorry, the file couldn't be loaded'' what can I do?

  • @SandyHookFalseFlagOP
    @SandyHookFalseFlagOP 8 лет назад +3

    so if i have a question Native Instruments don't answer comments,, I see

  • @timbalandhits8
    @timbalandhits8 10 лет назад

    so is it really worth it? i got aplitube 3 and guitar rig5 also bias and revalver 4 they all have their momments is it worth it to upgrade 2500!!! to a axe fx 2 xl? really is it that much better? i cant find a comp axe fx 2 xl vs guitar rig 5 or amplitube 3 etc i personally love guitar rig 5 anf i got them all ( software any way)

    • @5urg3x
      @5urg3x 9 лет назад

      don candiani
      Depends what you're trying to do. AxeFX is in a league of it's own; if you buy one you'll probably never have to get anything else for the rest of your life...but keep in mind they're also extremely expensive and downright tricky to use...I've been working with computers since I was 6, learned applesoft basic when I was 9, and coming up with my own AxeFX effect chains and getting them to work with my MIDI controller took a ton of time...it was not easy to say the least. Guitar Rig / Amplitube / Etc are decent, but I've found that high gain stuff really does not sound all that good compared to the AxeFX or Kempers.

  • @alexanderloos2429
    @alexanderloos2429 10 лет назад

    Is there a "payable" Version of guitar rig Pro?

    • @teunputker
      @teunputker 9 лет назад

      Yeah, there's a program by native called: guitar rig 5 player.
      It's free but you'll have a lot less amps and stuff

  • @Maddog652
    @Maddog652 12 лет назад

    can you use a midi piano on guitar rig 5??

  • @santiagodeponce9390
    @santiagodeponce9390 6 лет назад

    Having problems with view....my screen is a 6x15 and it won’t configure to it....frustrating!!!!!

  • @jantzenbird9383
    @jantzenbird9383 10 лет назад

    Can you plug this into a real amp or no? If not what do you need to use this? Would I need to buy my own speakers?

  • @MargaretsLight
    @MargaretsLight 13 лет назад

    I like the first 6 comments., the sixth one was countered! haha!

  • @KingUDERZO
    @KingUDERZO 13 лет назад

    @MargaretsLight thats youtube :D

  • @FourtySven
    @FourtySven 11 лет назад

    does this run independently from kontakt 5 player? if so can it be run through kontakt 5?

  • @arkamitra14
    @arkamitra14 6 лет назад

    Can anyone help me out on this? Which one is the latest version - is it 5.2.0.2770? Or, 5.2.2.8? The official NI site, so far, is providing with the Guitar Rig Player 5.2.0.2770 version, but some of my friends are using 5.2.2.8.
    --
    How is that possible? KINDLY HELP ME GET THIS STRAIGHT. THANKS IN ADVANCE.

  • @RoofBeamsCarpenter
    @RoofBeamsCarpenter 7 лет назад

    can you use the Irig with this software?