Why Lucas is BAD in Brawl, and how he changed in Project M

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 авг 2024
  • Super Smash Bros Brawl Lucas is surprising very technical, but not a very good character...
    Here is how his move set completely changed in Project M/Project+
    Like, comment, and Subscribe!!!
    PATREON: / honestcontent
    REDDIT: / zachhonest
    Thank you to the people on Patreon!
    ---
    gnar
    Jose Rosario
    Trix
    Laserman2
    Bavilla Merritt Jr.
    DrinkingFood
    waffeln
    Vicksin
    Ampha
    Monnal
    Mitchell Kelly

Комментарии • 113

  • @kennethkay7226
    @kennethkay7226 2 года назад +318

    Lucas may have been bad in Brawl but he did something even more important when he joined the game. He introduced fans outside of Japan to Mother 3.

  • @lucrativelucas2655
    @lucrativelucas2655 2 года назад +60

    Lucas has always been some type of main of mine since brawl so I was so hyped that PM made him good, although he’s probably gonna be a secondary I still love him

    • @Cutzerella03
      @Cutzerella03 2 года назад

      Same but he is good in smash ultimate( he was already good since smash 4 but smash 4 Lucas feels weird) pm Lucas is awesome

    • @lucrativelucas2655
      @lucrativelucas2655 2 года назад +2

      @@Cutzerella03 ehh Ultimate Lucas has to compete with absolute cheese such as big ass hit-boxes, comeback mechanics that save character’s viability, and characters that have gimmicks, while the only real cheese he has is Up Smash invulnerability for 8 frames and PK Freeze

    • @Cutzerella03
      @Cutzerella03 2 года назад +2

      @@lucrativelucas2655 down smash is technically more of a cheese tool than freeze since it hits below platforms and gets bigger each multihit. You need more than just cheese in ultimate lol. I have been a Lucas main in ult as well as for it's entire life cycle and it feels way more playable than smash 4 lucas. It feels more like a functional brawl lucas compared to smash 4 cause more of his smash 4 nerfs got reverted and he has that wavebounce mixup floaty feel but has a quick frame 23 shorthop fastfall cause of his low jumps and engine buffs

  • @alexv0714
    @alexv0714 2 года назад +17

    Great video!
    One thing you didn't mention about Multimag is once you get the timing down on it, it will literally destroy a shield. It's insane shield pressure that either forces the opponent to drop shield and get hit, or eventually be shield poked. There is no way out, and he can just wavemag a safe distance away anyway. Super cracked character.

    • @Narqatix
      @Narqatix 10 месяцев назад

      magnet is really broken but you can buffer roll out :)

  • @SupaPuttyYT
    @SupaPuttyYT 2 года назад +75

    Despite being completely different in PM, Lucas and Ness still do have a couple similarities, like their neutral specials being moves they canonically use in their games and side specials that could counter one another

    • @The_SOB_II
      @The_SOB_II 2 года назад

      They also both have

    • @The_SOB_II
      @The_SOB_II 2 года назад

      .

    • @SupaPuttyYT
      @SupaPuttyYT 2 года назад +1

      i know Thunder and Magnet are still shared between the two

  • @Rhy2412TitanGamer
    @Rhy2412TitanGamer 2 года назад +19

    In singles his worst attribute was the 10 extra grab release frames, which negated his great buttons & range for his size.
    In doubles, Lucas was extremely dangerous with a partner who could heal him or enable footstool combos from his dthrow, which lead into dtilt jab locks across the stage.

  • @rakanelafrangi161
    @rakanelafrangi161 2 года назад +21

    Lucas had the most tech in brawl, funny he turned out so bad

    • @yabusamehoulen7636
      @yabusamehoulen7636 2 года назад +3

      This is the fault who Developed Lucas's Moves. İf this game were balanced then tier list doesn't Exists.
      But when Develeopers have their Favourite Character they re making their Favourites Strong usefully fast And adds Pioneer Attacks. İ think Lucas's Format Creator Hates Lucas probably. This is reason why Lucas had a Bad tier. But Lucas did nothing for Deserving that. That feels like giving Bad presents to who more deserve Most good Presents. BTW We all know that Lucas's Personal ability is Psychic. This power is Universal and having lots of ways to use. But they re İnsulted that and their toxic ideas makes Lucas Bad tier.

    • @tatertotboi
      @tatertotboi 2 года назад +5

      @@yabusamehoulen7636 the hell kinda drugs you on?

    • @yabusamehoulen7636
      @yabusamehoulen7636 2 года назад +3

      @@tatertotboi do we have a problem?

    • @yabusamehoulen7636
      @yabusamehoulen7636 2 года назад +3

      @@tatertotboi No i don't but seems like you re laughing and Kidding me right?

    • @yabusamehoulen7636
      @yabusamehoulen7636 2 года назад +3

      @@tatertotboi also i am pretty Healthier than you i stopped eat artifical Foods since 7 Years.

  • @LikelyHexoadine
    @LikelyHexoadine 2 года назад +12

    I actually enjoyed this video as I second mained lucas in brawl and sm4sh, and to see him in PM wants to make me play it even more! Once again, great video honest!

    • @alexv0714
      @alexv0714 2 года назад

      Definitely play him in PM. It's not easy but insanely rewarding. Check out Hyperflame and Narq.

  • @andrescube64
    @andrescube64 2 года назад +17

    I love the tech of throwing the PK Fire backwards and then magnet in the air backwards

  • @mushublaze
    @mushublaze Год назад +3

    starting off with Last Surprise hypes me up so much. can we like make Lucas an honorary Phantom Thief? cuz I didn't realize how nicely this theme fits with his viability rundown
    may I also just say your sound design is so nice, I could binge these videos back to back, they're so relaxing and informative

  • @tarhackle3503
    @tarhackle3503 2 года назад +7

    Love this! Thanks for looking into Brawl characters like this. Do you plan on doing this for Melee characters that are in Brawl as well, or will you just stick to having a Brawl section for characters introduced in that game? I'd love to see Sheik or Pokemon Trainer next too!

    • @anothenblue2630
      @anothenblue2630 2 года назад +2

      I feel like it's not generally worth it for Melee vets in Brawl because most of them can be summed up as "similar to Melee, but the engine no longer works, now they suck/are lame." For example, while Falcon did have some dumb changes like the knee no longer killing, he's not that different outside of Brawl's context. The problem is that Brawl doesn't allow real combos characters like him depended on and ground movement is a pipe dream if you're not Fox or Marth (they can't dashdance or wavedash, but they can walk and they walk *good*), so he just has nothing.
      On the other hand, someone like Marth is just an inherently good character like Meta Knight and the engine being broken didn't bother him since he's still a swordie and swordies are privileged by nature, he's just lame now because it's Brawl.

  • @theporkpiehatkid
    @theporkpiehatkid Год назад +6

    I swear pm lucas is my favorite fighting game character ever. Hands down

    • @Angelofo
      @Angelofo 10 месяцев назад

      DUDE SAME, i miss neon he was so fun to watch man

  • @xKyl3
    @xKyl3 2 года назад +6

    Great video! However I dont think saying "Lucas is better now because they made him taller than Ness" for 10 minutes and 13 seconds is a fair argument.

  • @ohmeohmicah
    @ohmeohmicah 3 месяца назад +1

    So he went from a character semi-clone to a significantly more modified clone that acts as a glass cannon rushdown... He got the Ken treatment. Also doesn't help that he's the blonde one and the character that he's a clone of is black-haired

  • @artemis-kinkyboikirby5539
    @artemis-kinkyboikirby5539 2 года назад +2

    'Risk upsetting every main of a character' every melee player when a mod comes out that ever so slightly nerfs their main

    • @ZachHonest
      @ZachHonest  2 года назад +1

      Falcon, Sheik and Marth were definitely buffed for the record

  • @Uberjunge
    @Uberjunge 2 года назад +4

    I would love to see PM lucas come to akaneia sometime. How do you feel about new chars in melee?

    • @Cutzerella03
      @Cutzerella03 2 года назад

      Why not ult Lucas in akaneia? Also yes pm Lucas would be cool but he doesn't have to be the same

    • @Uberjunge
      @Uberjunge 2 года назад

      @@Cutzerella03 i didn't play much ultimate, but i actually did enjoy lucas there too. I think those specials are cooler than what he got in PM. Idk anything about the lucas meta now, but i played him like a zoner, and i personally enjoy a more rush down style in melee. Mixing both versions together could be great, and im sure the akaneia team will do a great job if they try to add lucas

  • @LHSMeleeClub
    @LHSMeleeClub 2 года назад +2

    I like how you used footage from pm ex remix but I bet that confuses ppl lol

  • @FL-uj7cs
    @FL-uj7cs 5 месяцев назад

    Loving this shorter, more concise format for videos.

  • @ImCookieSparx
    @ImCookieSparx 2 года назад +1

    lucas has SO many unexplored tech in brawl, but the weird thing is he is just so slow and grabbable. i wish he was better. sure in utlimate he also has great tech, but in project m he's SO cool! especially his rushdown combos and down air!

  • @Zackylorin
    @Zackylorin 10 месяцев назад +1

    as a lucas main, rushdown lucas seems so fun

  • @pleaseexcusemydearauntsall4499
    @pleaseexcusemydearauntsall4499 2 года назад +1

    Can you do a mew2 melee one? Just modding melee and basing my changes based off your vids

  • @lostmedia404-notfound7
    @lostmedia404-notfound7 Год назад +1

    at this point, all characters that were "changed" in PM are basically rushdown

    • @ZachHonest
      @ZachHonest  Год назад

      ROB basically isn't.

    • @N12015
      @N12015 Год назад

      Expected from a mod who is essentially Melee 2.0 even to the most irrelevant details like charged smash attacks (From 1.4 to 1.41...... for no reason).

    • @Cosdamotto
      @Cosdamotto Год назад

      Basically yeah. I competed in PM events from 2012-2016 and honestly, was fun af. even DK and Bowser was very octane

  • @SammyBoiBeThicc08
    @SammyBoiBeThicc08 2 года назад +1

    the xenoblade chronicals X background music was appreciated lol

  • @user-uk1xq1cf6z
    @user-uk1xq1cf6z 3 месяца назад

    Fun fact: lucas in brawl has the only back air that can meteor smash

  • @Evixyn
    @Evixyn 2 года назад +1

    Do Lucario next has he was also give a 90% face lift.

  • @javianmonserrate8930
    @javianmonserrate8930 2 года назад

    Ness: Who are you
    Lucas: I'm your best friend

  • @gnardawgyt
    @gnardawgyt 2 года назад +1

    Lucas is so cool but I can't get my head around DJC, used to my spacies

  • @benbriefs798
    @benbriefs798 Год назад +1

    I loved playing Brawl, it was my first Smash game ever

  • @Guyro3278
    @Guyro3278 2 года назад +2

    Can you make a brawl p+ comparison video about Rob?

    • @ZachHonest
      @ZachHonest  2 года назад +4

      I'm thinking about Dedede in the future

    • @ninja1167.
      @ninja1167. 2 года назад

      @@ZachHonest I think a good character to do could be wolf, if you were interested there

  • @yabusamehoulen7636
    @yabusamehoulen7636 2 года назад +2

    İf that was in Lucas 's Hands he would be stronger than met knight 5 times and had a SSSSSSSSS+++++ Tier. But decision when belongs to stupid Developers so this bad Brawl Thing happened.

  • @C-531
    @C-531 2 года назад +1

    Do diddy Kong or olimar next

  • @zeta654
    @zeta654 2 месяца назад

    Seeing Cloud and Simon in Brawl feels wrong

  • @bone5108
    @bone5108 Год назад

    the music isnt loud enough

  • @KhunShawn
    @KhunShawn Год назад +1

    0:44 I stopped listening when the chorus dropped.

  • @yabusamehoulen7636
    @yabusamehoulen7636 2 года назад +4

    2:44 this is really Annoys me a lot other characters are easily dodge this and Their Recovery is doesn't do this Betray but this is why i hate Brawl Developers.

  • @ethanherzing652
    @ethanherzing652 Год назад

    What is the second song? I think it’s from xenoblade right?

  • @AspectCave
    @AspectCave 2 года назад

    great video as always :)

  • @Toeh2
    @Toeh2 Год назад +1

    Pink fresh was the goat or Lucas

  • @RedFlashdrive
    @RedFlashdrive Год назад +1

    I'm sorry but I hated PM Lucas so much...
    I tried to use and play him multiple times but I just did not like the changes they did to him. Sure he was a better character but he didn't really vibe with my play style..

    • @ZachHonest
      @ZachHonest  Год назад

      Try PM Ness. I liked Brawl Lucas a lot, and wasn't really good with PM Lucas. But PM Ness has some similarities to OG Lucas from Brawl.

  • @vossboss220
    @vossboss220 Год назад

    Ok smash geyser and pk blow aren't meant to be their own unique psi attacks they're just generic names given to different ways Lucas uses pk love in smash. I agree a bit better representation of the skill could be nice but I think up smash is fine the way it is since the animation is inspired by Lucas pulling a dragon needle and releasing tons of psi power

  • @AggiebabyEntertainment
    @AggiebabyEntertainment 2 года назад

    I mained lucas in brawl but the pm ver is my favorite

  • @blazeburst3833
    @blazeburst3833 Год назад

    Very good music choice

  • @tenkalion
    @tenkalion Год назад

    What's the song at 9:26 ?

  • @WitherVideos
    @WitherVideos Год назад

    Nice video!

  • @Skynetbear
    @Skynetbear 10 месяцев назад

    “No disrespect towards Brawl fans”
    10 seconds ago: “I’d rather watch paint dry than play this game”

  • @Banquet_
    @Banquet_ 2 года назад

    Lets go! Love this content

  • @MetatronsRevenge613
    @MetatronsRevenge613 Год назад

    Remove psi magnet, it is ugh, replace it with PSI Counter to be actually like Fox shine

  • @baldibasicsonscratchwow
    @baldibasicsonscratchwow Год назад

    Dude the games not called Smash Bros “Brawl”.
    It’s called Meta Knight: The game. /j

  • @TheDrinkingFood
    @TheDrinkingFood 2 года назад

    6:10 if i remember right pretty sure brawl doesnt have DJC?

    • @Cutzerella03
      @Cutzerella03 2 года назад

      Yes. There is zap jump tho. Brawl does have airdodge cancel tether tho and Ultimate Lucas has double jump cancel zair

  • @drcheerioshehehe
    @drcheerioshehehe 2 года назад

    me who mained lucas in brawl:

  • @CosmicDomo
    @CosmicDomo 2 года назад

    DOPE VIDEO

  • @samthesnowman666
    @samthesnowman666 Год назад

    to slow =x
    d

  • @gertabeelievurr666
    @gertabeelievurr666 7 месяцев назад

    I think lucas is better than ness (imo)🙂

  • @Ghee_Buttersnaps
    @Ghee_Buttersnaps 2 года назад +1

    Bababooey!

  • @araknair9605
    @araknair9605 Год назад

    neat

  • @Monhamd1000
    @Monhamd1000 2 года назад +3

    Oh yeah, Brawl's tier list is also as bad as Melee.

    • @SonicTheCutehog
      @SonicTheCutehog 2 года назад +3

      Expect that Brawl's tier list was ordered purely by how well each character did against Meta Knight because if how dominant he was.

    • @Monhamd1000
      @Monhamd1000 2 года назад +3

      @@SonicTheCutehog And everyone hated that.

    • @SonicTheCutehog
      @SonicTheCutehog 2 года назад +3

      @@Monhamd1000 Yeah, easily the worst balanced Smash game.

  • @RottenJerv
    @RottenJerv Год назад

    Of course Meta Knight is the Meta

  • @AggiebabyEntertainment
    @AggiebabyEntertainment 2 года назад

    PSO Music?! or am i deaf

  • @voided882
    @voided882 2 года назад +1

    music is WAY too high and has vocals. commentary is unable to be understood a lot