I work in quantum computing. My message to everyone is to learn mathematics. The news tries their best to explain quantum computing using words but you will feel that the explanation is never complete. That's because the full explanation can only be given in maths. Words and languages were developed to talk about the world of large objects that we experience. When physicists look at the atomic and subatomic level , they use mathematics, because words and language don't fully capture the behaviour of quantum mechanics. You need maths.
As much as I have issues with this government on focus towards startups, reasearch,etc,... I really appreciate recent developments of space policy and this quantum computing funding 👏👏
well 50 years back the previous government invested in ISRO,DRDO, AND nuclear technology! this government is doing a good job pushing technology forward
But later in these 50 years, the govts didn't learn from other nations to democratise the process. Countries like Israel had start-ups even before this term was coined.
@Kraken Thunder Britain, Norway, China are not suffering with socialist mindset, why India. India do not have democracy, but feudocracy. Change that and everything will get better.
19:55 I really appreciate the interviewer for the explanation of quantum entanglement and it puts a smile on my face when people talk about quantum physics and quantum computers
This is a really great step by the government. This technology is bound to be huge and totally game changing in the future and it is important to enter early in this. One more area where India entered quite early given that we got our independence in 1947 is Space research and that's the reason we are one of the few nations in the world to have achieved what we have achieved. I know the current generation these day is so much against Congress and Pandit Nehru, and would not deny that there would be some valid reasons for it, but to have a vision for space research in 1962 when India was surrounded by a million issues and widespread hunger and poverty, is really beyond commandable.
I am a nanotechnology researcher from Canada. If India really focuses on fabricating quantum chips and invest in the cleanroom infra, I might consider to come back.
@@varshilshah7593 I really want to but there is no cutting edge research or infra present in India in nanotech. All companies have their design centres in India but not R&D centres. Even IITs/IISc researchers don’t produce quality research. I will be wasting my youth! May be 10-20 years down the line when where will be a vibrant ecosystem.
Please increase funding for Central Universities of India, fill the faculty vacancies, upgrade the labs, and increase the number & amount of fellowships... itna toh bare minimum hai... baaki apni shraddha anusaar jo sarkaar de dey🙏🏻🇮🇳 Dr. Akhilesh Gupta should have allowed some junior with better science comm. skills here ... Ms. Basu 💜✨️
What should have been covered in this video is where are we in terms of developing this technology. What are the current major challenges and the foreseeable milestones that they are planning to achieve. What was covered was very broad but still better than nothing.
chip manufacturing quantum mechanics ka base nhi h halkat. Its like saying, GMC technology se pehle steel manufacturing ka base bna lo. Agar base bna bhi liya chip manufacturing ka 10 saal m, tab bhi India quantum computers m lagne wali chip ke market ko target nhi kar rhe.
@Kraken Thunder not just this , but also constant threats to our scientists and conspiracies to decapacitate our scientists and institutions just look at the geopolitics u will sense the enormous animosity the west harbours against our institutions like IIT the prime example
@Kraken Thunder quantum computers aren't a joke mera bhai. You need experts in that field which we don't have unlike China and Us . I think we had huge potential in chip manufacturing which we lost
Excellent topic and very well explained..I have one feedback for the team here…topics such as these need a bit more in terms of graphics or visualisation…people who understand such topics will get gripped onto this but some will lose interest if they can’t visualise…for example when he was explaining the photons released during electrons moving in an atom it can be visualised easily…such efforts will increase viewership…keep it up…from a regular listener
This is objectively not how quantum computing works. The bureaucrat didn't correct her, because he has no idea either. I hope the fund reaches the right scientists.
He is a senior advisor and can't even correctly explain superposition of electrons. And the assistant editor confusing audiance between parallel computing and quantum computing
As india becomes most populous country, we need a well educated youth, which can spend well. But despite education our workforce is being exploited by foreign and many indian companies itself.
While I admire the initiative and understand the budget allocated to this is insignificant compared to overall government spending, why is the government taking such initiatives? Classical computing offers enough computing power to realize Nehru's tech-solutionism. During the interview, Dr. Gupta mentioned we'll develop a market for this technology through collaborations. Shouldn't the government's scientific projects be driven by its own demand?
Wonderful Initiative! We have a long way to go and move faster if we gotta overtake other nations. But, this is clearly a step forward in the right direction.
Yes, I will appreciate the gesture of Indian Government towards Quantum. But if anybody who listens to Rajiv Malhotra ji, you would know, how far behind India is in his field. We've been crying for ages.
This is the next biggest step in science & technology after ISRO. I hope the allocated funds get utilized 100% with selfless attitude by all people involved without any corruption
looks a bit ambitious considering the current infrastructure being available and state of art idea which ought to be executed!! needs to be pursued on aggressive basis so that committed timelines are adhered to and policy and framework do play part in execution and budgets need to be properly adapted, in addition to futuristic perspective around research and innovation !! the DST and the other research centers so called Hubs need to up their game and improve a lot before claiming to front runners in cutting edge tech!!
God save this country when the “expert” in-charge of quantum computing does not even know base 2 (binary) arithmetic. Maybe we should get someone more competent?
I will make Sadguru and Nithyananada along with Deepak chopra as the heads for research as vast majority of Indians believe that these guys know more about QFT than the physicist from any university.
This is a great effort, but unfortunately India is behind the curve. China is decades ahead - they are both a quantum superpower and AI superpower. They already have QCs that are operational. One thing I dont agree here is that there are already "operational" quantum computers. IBM has a website where you can submit your program, and it will simulate inside IBM's QC. India does not have a proper high performance computing industry from what I know. US, Europe and CHina all have their own supercomputers and they compete with each other for the faster HPC. HPC should be developed from all fronts , not only QC among other critical technologies. It is late , but nevertheless an excellent effort. The best
Kudos to the government for investing in science....now if the journalist interviewing him didnt look so vacant we could have a lot more confidence in the future
WTF I know more than him and I am not even from this field haha😂 This is probably the worst explanation I have seen yet of the basics behind the science Also he seems to be a little better in his understanding compared to the infamous cloud computing upsc genius
Before China and other progress; India should Ex: Dr.Ramanujam theory..was abruptly stopped after his passing, sadly. SO, INTRODUCE THIS SUBJECT FROM SCHOOL SYLLABUS; COLLEGE AND PROFESSIONAL Quantum physics and maths. Decode the VEDAS. India with 666 million bright youth should foray in one and all aspects of Technology; Science; and of cousre Manufactuing. innovation, All High funda;
Don't know this person really an expert in this field or weak in explaining this...he was not confident and definitely not fully prepared either for interview on this topic....anchor was better explaining terms than this guy... Govt did not find any middle aged or young dynamic person to lead this mission...just learn from western leaders in this field....how they talk and this guy made us feel bored..
Government should get out of advanced physics and AI stuff. Let them improve funding to fundamental research at TIFR , CDAC and like. Full generic baat kar raha hai.
@@satinderpadda6264 let's be 100 years behind in technology then.....both things need to happen together.....we cannot do one thing at the expense of other.
Do you think the US and Europe is completely hunger free...if u think so, u r most innocent and uneducated....go to LA and see, how people are in ghettoes ...hunger free is goal for all nations and technology is means to achieve it and not the goal itself.
I am huge supporter of Indic knowledge and our unique culture etc. However, we are completely out of depth in modern science and technology. This guy has no grasp of quantum mechanics AT ALL. Pity. I am sure Aryabhata would have cried and cried listening to this nonsense.
I work in quantum computing. My message to everyone is to learn mathematics. The news tries their best to explain quantum computing using words but you will feel that the explanation is never complete. That's because the full explanation can only be given in maths. Words and languages were developed to talk about the world of large objects that we experience. When physicists look at the atomic and subatomic level , they use mathematics, because words and language don't fully capture the behaviour of quantum mechanics. You need maths.
This guy has completely butchered any explanation. And India is farthest of any country from quantum technology
you are right, same thing applies for AI as well
me studying the quantum computing at college this is the most simplified explanation of one of the most complex field.
Rahulji is one the founders of Quantum computing. I hope you study about him as well. Without him there would be no uncertainty principle.
As much as I have issues with this government on focus towards startups, reasearch,etc,... I really appreciate recent developments of space policy and this quantum computing funding 👏👏
well 50 years back the previous government invested in ISRO,DRDO, AND nuclear technology! this government is doing a good job pushing technology forward
But later in these 50 years, the govts didn't learn from other nations to democratise the process. Countries like Israel had start-ups even before this term was coined.
@Kraken Thunder Britain, Norway, China are not suffering with socialist mindset, why India. India do not have democracy, but feudocracy. Change that and everything will get better.
@@suseeln China is not suffering from socialist mindset 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@amrutkarsaurabh7398 How is China suffering.
19:55 I really appreciate the interviewer for the explanation of quantum entanglement and it puts a smile on my face when people talk about quantum physics and quantum computers
This is certainly a quantam jump for India.
This is a really great step by the government. This technology is bound to be huge and totally game changing in the future and it is important to enter early in this.
One more area where India entered quite early given that we got our independence in 1947 is Space research and that's the reason we are one of the few nations in the world to have achieved what we have achieved.
I know the current generation these day is so much against Congress and Pandit Nehru, and would not deny that there would be some valid reasons for it, but to have a vision for space research in 1962 when India was surrounded by a million issues and widespread hunger and poverty, is really beyond commandable.
I am a nanotechnology researcher from Canada. If India really focuses on fabricating quantum chips and invest in the cleanroom infra, I might consider to come back.
dont pay any attention to the tee ar ol above. They get 50 paise for this.
Would love to have you back.
You will have to because we would be the next power.
Please come back man 🙏
@@varshilshah7593 I really want to but there is no cutting edge research or infra present in India in nanotech. All companies have their design centres in India but not R&D centres. Even IITs/IISc researchers don’t produce quality research. I will be wasting my youth! May be 10-20 years down the line when where will be a vibrant ecosystem.
India need its own proprietary technology if we need to be self reliant and stay ahead in technologies. This is great start.
Quantum computing propreitary. Private companies like IBM has been on this for more than a decade.
Please increase funding for Central Universities of India, fill the faculty vacancies, upgrade the labs, and increase the number & amount of fellowships... itna toh bare minimum hai... baaki apni shraddha anusaar jo sarkaar de dey🙏🏻🇮🇳
Dr. Akhilesh Gupta should have allowed some junior with better science comm. skills here ... Ms. Basu 💜✨️
Increased Funding with the current setup is like throwing money down the drain
Quantam, Artificial Intelligence, Graphene Semiconductors, 3D printer
Please please never too late to start welcome to the future 🎉
What should have been covered in this video is where are we in terms of developing this technology. What are the current major challenges and the foreseeable milestones that they are planning to achieve. What was covered was very broad but still better than nothing.
Exactly!
Agree
Gentlemen of culture, eyes are focused on target.
Are bhai quantum mein jaane se pehle chip manufacturing toh start karo . Ek 6502 tak yaha nahi Banta .pehle ek base to banao phir tower banana
@Kraken Thunder We are much behind in Quantum race, Fusion race, Semiconductors race...
chip manufacturing quantum mechanics ka base nhi h halkat. Its like saying, GMC technology se pehle steel manufacturing ka base bna lo. Agar base bna bhi liya chip manufacturing ka 10 saal m, tab bhi India quantum computers m lagne wali chip ke market ko target nhi kar rhe.
@Kraken Thunder not just this , but also constant threats to our scientists and conspiracies to decapacitate our scientists and institutions just look at the geopolitics u will sense the enormous animosity the west harbours against our institutions like IIT the prime example
@Kraken Thunder quantum computers aren't a joke mera bhai. You need experts in that field which we don't have unlike China and Us . I think we had huge potential in chip manufacturing which we lost
@@mohitanand1844 so what to do? What u want them to do nothing?just sit nd watch?
Real science stuff.
Keep it up "Print".
Taking initiatives to develop an indigenous Quantum processor is highly laudable
Photonic energy is totally different and it is no way related to the Q bit. Q bit is spin dependent concept of electron.
Excellent topic and very well explained..I have one feedback for the team here…topics such as these need a bit more in terms of graphics or visualisation…people who understand such topics will get gripped onto this but some will lose interest if they can’t visualise…for example when he was explaining the photons released during electrons moving in an atom it can be visualised easily…such efforts will increase viewership…keep it up…from a regular listener
Thanks a lot for the feedback! Yes, we are constantly trying to make an effort to make science videos better ❤
I doubt if he is making any sense frankly. Maybe he knows quantum computing but the guy definitely didn’t explain it .
kudos for arranging this interview. These interviews will have more impact than political stuff.
This is objectively not how quantum computing works. The bureaucrat didn't correct her, because he has no idea either. I hope the fund reaches the right scientists.
Where are the scientists. The best and the brightest leave India.
The video is meant for general audience not only for quantum scientists.
The advising PM has zilch academic or hands on experience with relevant technology, so it’s doomed to fail.
Great initiative by government and scientifics, best wishes 🎉
He is a senior advisor and can't even correctly explain superposition of electrons.
And the assistant editor confusing audiance between parallel computing and quantum computing
Very good initiative must be executed properly and effectively
As india becomes most populous country, we need a well educated youth, which can spend well.
But despite education our workforce is being exploited by foreign and many indian companies itself.
While I admire the initiative and understand the budget allocated to this is insignificant compared to overall government spending, why is the government taking such initiatives? Classical computing offers enough computing power to realize Nehru's tech-solutionism. During the interview, Dr. Gupta mentioned we'll develop a market for this technology through collaborations. Shouldn't the government's scientific projects be driven by its own demand?
Wonderful Initiative! We have a long way to go and move faster if we gotta overtake other nations. But, this is clearly a step forward in the right direction.
❤️❤️need more such interactions. Great work Mohana.
Yes, I will appreciate the gesture of Indian Government towards Quantum. But if anybody who listens to Rajiv Malhotra ji, you would know, how far behind India is in his field. We've been crying for ages.
This is the next biggest step in science & technology after ISRO. I hope the allocated funds get utilized 100% with selfless attitude by all people involved without any corruption
11 in binary is 3 not 2 , sorry to point out
लाजवाब 🙏
OTT - Over the Top...kuch samajh mai nahi aaya 😢
Would recommend watching Quantum Computers explained by Cleo Abram and MKBHD if you want to dig a bit deep.
2 is 0010
The interviewer does a better job explaining the concepts. This guy puts me to sleep
He is a professor it's his job😂😂😂
Because he has made no contribution to the field and knows less than a bright teenager.
looks a bit ambitious considering the current infrastructure being available and state of art idea which ought to be executed!! needs to be pursued on aggressive basis so that committed timelines are adhered to and policy and framework do play part in execution and budgets need to be properly adapted, in addition to futuristic perspective around research and innovation !! the DST and the other research centers so called Hubs need to up their game and improve a lot before claiming to front runners in cutting edge tech!!
Is it so? Big or small??
He got 2 wrong in binary. It's 0010.
God save this country when the “expert” in-charge of quantum computing does not even know base 2 (binary) arithmetic. Maybe we should get someone more competent?
Don't won't to sound pessimistic but our country still can't manufacture or design high end chips
How are we going to be successful in quantam
🍻 Great Editing 🍻
What about super computer project?
Similar kind of project launched still we hardly seem results.
It will be only successful if bureaucrats do not line their pockets and misuse the fund
Amazing information... Thanks for the report! 👍🏻
Good
Very good initiative, but to be very honest Dr Gupta doesn't look upto date and expert on quantum technologies.
NTRO will be a major beneficiary of this.
Super stuff!
Will quantum computing r&d start with breaking lemon? If yes what will be it's super position 😜
I will make Sadguru and Nithyananada along with Deepak chopra as the heads for research as vast majority of Indians believe that these guys know more about QFT than the physicist from any university.
This guy doesn't sound too different. Extremely basic level of understanding.
@@mrgyani yes..please explain quantum physics to us mrgyani..i can clearly guess through your comment how science freak you are..
You should check out The Ranveer show with ISRO scientist.
🤣🤣🤣
This is a great effort, but unfortunately India is behind the curve. China is decades ahead - they are both a quantum superpower and AI superpower. They already have QCs that are operational. One thing I dont agree here is that there are already "operational" quantum computers. IBM has a website where you can submit your program, and it will simulate inside IBM's QC. India does not have a proper high performance computing industry from what I know. US, Europe and CHina all have their own supercomputers and they compete with each other for the faster HPC. HPC should be developed from all fronts , not only QC among other critical technologies. It is late , but nevertheless an excellent effort. The best
2 is 0010 not 0011
Not the best spokesman for the initiative. Jero Jero Vun Vun is 3 and not 2!
Men of culture.. We accidentally meet again.. 😇
Could have had better manner to question and answer. This looks like friendly chat
Kudos to the government for investing in science....now if the journalist interviewing him didnt look so vacant we could have a lot more confidence in the future
WTF I know more than him and I am not even from this field haha😂
This is probably the worst explanation I have seen yet of the basics behind the science
Also he seems to be a little better in his understanding compared to the infamous cloud computing upsc genius
Before China and other progress;
India should
Ex: Dr.Ramanujam theory..was abruptly stopped after his passing, sadly.
SO, INTRODUCE THIS SUBJECT FROM SCHOOL SYLLABUS; COLLEGE AND PROFESSIONAL
Quantum physics and maths.
Decode the VEDAS.
India with 666 million bright youth should foray in one and all aspects of
Technology;
Science;
and of cousre Manufactuing.
innovation,
All High funda;
Appreciate your effort but we need India's version of Neil deGrasse Tyson to explain these things to people.
What we get is Sadguru and Deepak chopra.
Need better expert to explain
I remember in 90s show on Doordarshan called Turning Point
@@rum81 that was a good show. I watched it everytime
Wow, hardcore physics in mainstream media... What is happening to India?
This isn't hardcore physics.. This is just hype talk, with very basic understanding of the subject.
@@mrgyani So, you are saying Dr. Akhilesh Gupta has a very basic understanding of the subject?
I got scared when I read Akhilesh 😂
Don't know this person really an expert in this field or weak in explaining this...he was not confident and definitely not fully prepared either for interview on this topic....anchor was better explaining terms than this guy... Govt did not find any middle aged or young dynamic person to lead this mission...just learn from western leaders in this field....how they talk and this guy made us feel bored..
Government should get out of advanced physics and AI stuff. Let them improve funding to fundamental research at TIFR , CDAC and like. Full generic baat kar raha hai.
😅😅 print kabse modi ki prasansa karne lagey 😅
Kya kya bol rahe ho uncle
Bro! first solve the problem of hunger and unemployment.
Are you a BBC reporter?
@@tvm73827 Bhakt 😂
@@satinderpadda6264 let's be 100 years behind in technology then.....both things need to happen together.....we cannot do one thing at the expense of other.
Do you think the US and Europe is completely hunger free...if u think so, u r most innocent and uneducated....go to LA and see, how people are in ghettoes ...hunger free is goal for all nations and technology is means to achieve it and not the goal itself.
People like u were ignored in 1950s when space research was talked about in India.
Thankfully.
Excellent Explanation
Sounds very SHADY, some one is pulling a fast one !!! Good Modiji , Adani could have done this for you...
Lol😂
3000cr loot
First improve R&D
The journalist should have studied physics better in school
After watching for 3 minutes, I lost interest in the video.
Wat about climate change actions 😂
@Kraken Thunder our world has to stop fossil fuels,coal by 2030 ,ban IEC engine, no more options
Should not the lady reporter be properly dressed.......🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️
Crop her right side😂😂
The only thing improper is your mind. What kind of “Dr” are you? A perverted one?
It's her choice how she wishes to dress don't need your validation or permission
@@Thallium983 Totally correct! Why is the Dr so concerned?
@@Thallium983 Very much yes , u may undress yourself also...is not this your constitutional right? No, rights are subject to reasonable restriction
I am huge supporter of Indic knowledge and our unique culture etc. However, we are completely out of depth in modern science and technology. This guy has no grasp of quantum mechanics AT ALL. Pity. I am sure Aryabhata would have cried and cried listening to this nonsense.