Message is simple , whatever middle class consumes for enjoyment , put tax right there . Its an atatck on middle class . Today its popcorn or old car . In future the list will keep on growing. Wake up folks
Why are you barking so much....Urban Middle Class is very much voting for vishwaguru and his cronies.....very happy with JSR and mandir masjid....so why cry now....enjoy becoming beggars and blame muslims for all the issues 😂
Bought Cement today, paid 28% gst. 10 lakh cement cost me 12.8 lakh! And you guys are crying about popcorn. I am happy atleast registering your own house does not attract gst if you build it on your own. Hope she does not get that idea before my construction completes.
The anchor keeps constantly interrupting as she is desperate for a commercial break. A program is meant to listen to experts not to finish this one & move to the next
The anchor needs to be a better listener before she starts running her mouth interrupting people. Why even call these guys to the panel if all you want to do is subtly force your ideologies by interrupting them and changing paths every step of the way? L for the anchor. W for the economist.
It is like East India Tax...My Grandfather let go property to to Govt who unable to pay property tax same trend continues now Car 28% , 18% and then 17% road tax ??
Everybody cheats on GST. Electrical, plumbing hardwares shops give no bill , charge almost GST rates, A small percent is passed on to these plumbers electricians and the rest is pocketed by these small traders. Black money being encouraged. Right!!?
@@TheKakarot_itachi Problem is not with paying tax. The problem is having such a complexity in the GST system like having 3 slabs for a single popcorn
Packaged food is dangerous sir whatever it is.. what are you even talking about... its far more dangerous then hygeine issues. Who are these ppl working in factories do they understand anything about hygeine. Common talk sense
GST is a tax applied to almost everything we use, including food, clothes, bread, healthcare, medicines, and insurance. Even basic ingredients are taxed under GST. Every year, new items are added to the list of taxable goods and services. GST was introduced with the idea of "One Nation, One Tax," to make taxes the same across all states. However, this goal has not been achieved. States have started charging extra taxes with different names, like user tax, service tax, fuel charges, and true-up charges. These extra taxes make the system different in every state, which goes against the idea of one common tax for the whole country. Every year, GST meetings are held to decide what new items to tax, adding to the financial burden on people. Along with GST, citizens also have to pay income tax, which has increased the cost of living significantly. Many people now wonder what benefits they are truly getting from the government in this situation. Brtish tax was less than present ta
In Multiplexed and Malls eat Buckets of Popcorn 🍿, recklessly without bothering about health forget about their pockets. They don't even know what tax they are paying, they want the BUCKETS well at any price 😢
Free house, free ration, free gas cylinder, free health benefits, free education, free tap water etc...just for vote bank enjoyed by family with 4 wives and 12 children to whom land is given by one political party and remaining everything is now given by another political party. 2 lakh crore looted by industrialists by mere less than 3 thousand people (politicians donation bank ?) Tax rate for new corporate in manufacturing sector is 15% (politicians donation bank?) but 2 to 3 crore actual middle class people paying tax for them the rate is 20% (biggest suffering class having one wife and one or two children).
Whole Indian market is flooded with adulteration, our parliamentarians are busy with doing all the nonsense debates, rather than caring about the health of common people. Basic needs are mostly adulterated.
When taxation comes every party is togather .. but blame is taken by FM . TOOR DAL If you sell in loose no tax .. if its cleaned and packed it attract 5% . So like all groceries are under 5% IF its cleaned and packed ... hygienic taxed ..un hygienic exempted from tax 😅
All food/edible articles should be charged at a uniform 5% or 12% tax rate and be done with it. Such micro management will lead to disaster in tax collection.
Country liquor, beedi all are cheaper meant for poor. Most of the hawkers selling their food on the roads. There is no water wash the plates just dip in the dirty water again and again. A sr person takes medical policy what percentage of policy actually spent to pay to hospital. GST 18%,25% to TPA ,25% insurance company wants.
media was ready with their arsenal for discussing gst on insurance... bringing petroleum products into gst ambit. but tai ne to popcorn ka googly de diya... discuss it with 5 panelists in prime time... who's got the game better?
GST Council has both Central government as well state government reps. Why this complicated tax structure on a simple Popcorn! Why can't one tax rate be applied on the Tax rate for Popcorn or just make it tax free since its an Agro product!
Issue is popcorn biz making more money's,, 130 to 200 rupees kg ,, we sell @ampc yard. Same think bought and sold for 100gram 300 to 400 rupees .. the malls are earning more money,, govt want a cut,, Now what happens is current price +gst,, the seller will not adjust the gst price on is current selling rate , it will be on buyer so the cost would be 300+gst, 400+gst...
The government including the opposition is not concerned about the middle class, salaried people, therefore the heavy taxation. When questioned they give lame excuses and lie to us.
@@odhdhd1543 even opposition is same.. They talk about more freebies than ruling one.. Either we will need to pay more taxes or state will go bankrupt... Which is happening in karnataka now..
GST is Hafta on organised sector where as patri wala is paying hafta to pvt sector. Thats why Self employment promotion is being don to collect hafta n salaried class is being reduced
Rude behaviour by the anchor. The experts are trying to discuss about taxation while she is trying to blame opposition parties. No experts here even brought up the government. And that annoying voice. This video deserves a thumps down.
Nirmala's hands prey i n on too poor children favourite popcorn.. Shameless... when Onion Price goes up, she said she did not use it.. we doubt weather she is a tax cutter or Axecutter ?
@TimesNow Please improve your level of journalism. Don't call 4 panelists if you don't have enough time to let even one of them respond properly. Its so insulting and disrespectful that you're constantly talking over them.
more than 75% of states are ruled by NDA, so blaming the opposition ruled state for the mismanaged GST meeting is the stupidest argument. In reality NDA is clueless about economic policy.
Tax is okay .government hospitals is it worth getting treated even ministers do not get treated . Roads are the worst .water is polluted .what is tax for 😂😂😂
This is called a popcorn diversion. Can anyone tell what we are being diverted from. And roadside food is it really not taxed if you know what I am pointing 😂 it is by ......we all know
Better to buy from shops and thelawalkas same with drinking water who supply to homes better to believe their quality instead of giving more money money where govt wants money by getting fssai licence fleecing Indian citizens tommorow gst on breathing air
What globally see ? Don’t Bullshit only idiots will have so many slabs and complicate. If you dare compare with the taxation of Singapore or UK and come out with a justification
Govt is so good at diverting attention. Instead of talking about health insurance and term insurance, everyone is talking pop corns. What a tragedy.
Worst FM ever!
You point Fm individuals make decisions for tax 😂😅😊
Message is simple , whatever middle class consumes for enjoyment , put tax right there . Its an atatck on middle class . Today its popcorn or old car . In future the list will keep on growing.
Wake up folks
Why are you barking so much....Urban Middle Class is very much voting for vishwaguru and his cronies.....very happy with JSR and mandir masjid....so why cry now....enjoy becoming beggars and blame muslims for all the issues 😂
Bought Cement today, paid 28% gst. 10 lakh cement cost me 12.8 lakh! And you guys are crying about popcorn. I am happy atleast registering your own house does not attract gst if you build it on your own. Hope she does not get that idea before my construction completes.
Soon, there will be another classification of GST over less salt, medium salt and regular salt, so total 18 slabs for single product popcorn
Salaried Middle class is being taxed without any consideration because they know we can't do anything. More ghan angry, I'm sad. Just sad.
The anchor keeps constantly interrupting as she is desperate for a commercial break. A program is meant to listen to experts not to finish this one & move to the next
@SanjaySharma-rh7bo
“The anchor keeps [...] move to the next”
===================
This ‘news’ organisation is a completely commercial organisation.
Stupid anchor
ANCHOR SHOULD BE A GOOD LISTENER
That anchor had no sense of timing-such a ridiculous and infuriating interruption!
The anchor needs to be a better listener before she starts running her mouth interrupting people. Why even call these guys to the panel if all you want to do is subtly force your ideologies by interrupting them and changing paths every step of the way?
L for the anchor. W for the economist.
@prajwals2793
“The anchor needs [...] W for the economist.”
======================
This is the style of functioning of Times Now.
This anchor is so annoying… even dont have the common sense atleast to finish the started sentence by the guest…
She is sick, needs some help
Godi anchor
It is like East India Tax...My Grandfather let go property to to Govt who unable to pay property tax same trend continues now Car 28% , 18% and then 17% road tax ??
ROAD side stalls are everywhere now. What taxes do they pay ?
Pls let the guest speak without interruption. Give them enough to speak . Very disrespectful behaviour.
Everybody cheats on GST.
Electrical, plumbing hardwares shops give no bill , charge almost GST rates,
A small percent is passed on to these plumbers electricians and the rest is pocketed by these small traders.
Black money being encouraged. Right!!?
Our Finance Minister is insensitive to the tax payer. She needs to go.
But you have voted for her boss time and time again...why barking now??? Enjoy the show and blame muslims for this also😂
Next is fart tax..more tax if it is carmel coated😅😅😅😅😅😅
This government does not want aam aadmi to get relief in anything. Taxing everything why.
someone buying flavoured popcorn in a cinema hall is wealthy enough to pay taxes
@@TheKakarot_itachi Problem is not with paying tax. The problem is having such a complexity in the GST system like having 3 slabs for a single popcorn
@@vigneshsunder1982Height of stupidity
There are many good features but some hiccups are there. Can we rename GST as good and stupid tax? The colonial mindset hasn't left us......
1 guna lagaan ×1 2 guna lagaan ×2 3 guna lagaan ×3 as follows
मिडिल क्लास वालों ITR FILE करना बंद करो तभी यह पूरा सिस्टम हिलेगा। ✅✅✅✅
Packaged food is dangerous sir whatever it is.. what are you even talking about... its far more dangerous then hygeine issues. Who are these ppl working in factories do they understand anything about hygeine. Common talk sense
GST is a tax applied to almost everything we use, including food, clothes, bread, healthcare, medicines, and insurance. Even basic ingredients are taxed under GST. Every year, new items are added to the list of taxable goods and services. GST was introduced with the idea of "One Nation, One Tax," to make taxes the same across all states. However, this goal has not been achieved. States have started charging extra taxes with different names, like user tax, service tax, fuel charges, and true-up charges. These extra taxes make the system different in every state, which goes against the idea of one common tax for the whole country.
Every year, GST meetings are held to decide what new items to tax, adding to the financial burden on people. Along with GST, citizens also have to pay income tax, which has increased the cost of living significantly. Many people now wonder what benefits they are truly getting from the government in this situation.
Brtish tax was less than present ta
Plain underwear 5%
With different colours 12%
with Graphics n designs 18%
Welcome to India🎉🎉
Popcorn is not the point government over-reach into people's lives is the problem....
Who is scared to bring back ballot paper ???
What a tragedy for the country. Talking popcorn...
Mam, pls let panelist complete the statement.
& lot of focus on opposition 😂😂
Already we see a Rs.1/- popcorn pack costs 700/- in a picture hall.
I don't understand who are these people who are behind this taxation policies, they have zero consideration for common people
@niara6
“I don't understand [...] for common people”
=======================
The ‘these people’ are Modi-Shah-Bisht & Co.
In Multiplexed and Malls eat Buckets of Popcorn 🍿, recklessly without bothering about health forget about their pockets. They don't even know what tax they are paying, they want the BUCKETS well at any price 😢
I am really surprised that as to how this Lady Seetha Nirmala has been appointed as finance minister. Just disgusting.
Worst FM of India taxing if it is packed 😂😂😂😂 , sold in AC showroom taxed,branded taxed 😂😂😂
Good argument..govt belives everyone has enough money to buy certain comodities and to squeeze max out of it such GST are levied..
Free house, free ration, free gas cylinder, free health benefits, free education, free tap water etc...just for vote bank enjoyed by family with 4 wives and 12 children to whom land is given by one political party and remaining everything is now given by another political party.
2 lakh crore looted by industrialists by mere less than 3 thousand people (politicians donation bank ?)
Tax rate for new corporate in manufacturing sector is 15% (politicians donation bank?) but 2 to 3 crore actual middle class people paying tax for them the rate is 20% (biggest suffering class having one wife and one or two children).
If centre can't control tax then this govt should live and handover the government to other
Some companies are making artificial food , not natural food
Who is named Tax Terorists in India ???
Whole Indian market is flooded with adulteration, our parliamentarians are busy with doing all the nonsense debates, rather than caring about the health of common people. Basic needs are mostly adulterated.
Foolish taxpayers are concerned about popcorn tax, when they should be concerned about loan write offs & unemployment 😅
now we know the true caliber / intensions of our govt.
"sir i would like to have pop corn with salt , spices , sugar coated caramelised and pre packed"
Govt - ☠
Doubting the govt, please fight elections and run the govt urself, Mr Sardana.
After sometime government will say you can't own a houses. Government will give 2 pairs dress, 1 pair shoes and monthly ration
I guess popcorn is now out of my menu
Anchor is seeking pro govt explanation and when doesn't she interrupts.
This anchor is trying to put all the blames on opposition.Why you are not asking Vishwa Guru modiji to interfere in such decisions...😅😅😅
No tax for food items. All food items should be accessible for poor to buy. Period
When taxation comes every party is togather .. but blame is taken by FM .
TOOR DAL If you sell in loose no tax .. if its cleaned and packed it attract 5% . So like all groceries are under 5% IF its cleaned and packed ... hygienic taxed ..un hygienic exempted from tax 😅
That is why no investment by big companies and Trump is saying he will increase tax
All food/edible articles should be charged at a uniform 5% or 12% tax rate and be done with it. Such micro management will lead to disaster in tax collection.
Country liquor, beedi all are cheaper meant for poor. Most of the hawkers selling their food on the roads. There is no water wash the plates just dip in the dirty water again and again.
A sr person takes medical policy what percentage of policy actually spent to pay to hospital. GST 18%,25% to TPA ,25% insurance company wants.
Despite a third term of the present government, India is working hard to go nowhere.
True ..unregulated food joints are not taxed
Y do thy collect tax if thy cant provide unadultrated food products😊
media was ready with their arsenal for discussing gst on insurance... bringing petroleum products into gst ambit. but tai ne to popcorn ka googly de diya... discuss it with 5 panelists in prime time...
who's got the game better?
Blame Breucracy to save politicians always take credit good work but Displeasure to officer
How much tax do we have to pay if popcorn and caramel are sold seperately....and then we can mix it 😮😮😮😮
All food products must comes under 3% expect liquor gutka tabacco goods. Must help poor & middle class of the country
Manufacturing cost is printed??
Tax on salti poop soon 18%😂😂
Okay nice to hear that it's kura karkat what policy makers want us to eat. Great
GST Council has both Central government as well state government reps. Why this complicated tax structure on a simple Popcorn! Why can't one tax rate be applied on the Tax rate for Popcorn or just make it tax free since its an Agro product!
Issue is popcorn biz making more money's,, 130 to 200 rupees kg ,, we sell @ampc yard. Same think bought and sold for 100gram 300 to 400 rupees .. the malls are earning more money,, govt want a cut,,
Now what happens is current price +gst,, the seller will not adjust the gst price on is current selling rate , it will be on buyer so the cost would be 300+gst, 400+gst...
The government including the opposition is not concerned about the middle class, salaried people, therefore the heavy taxation. When questioned they give lame excuses and lie to us.
You have voted for 🕉 nationalism so now enjoy the benefits also. Sacrifice for the majority 😅
@@odhdhd1543 even opposition is same.. They talk about more freebies than ruling one.. Either we will need to pay more taxes or state will go bankrupt... Which is happening in karnataka now..
Whenever the quantity of sales can be measured they jump like a tiger on its prey and tax them.
LOL she wants to put the blame on opposition for not stopping such provisions
The council should have made fuel under gst.
GST is Hafta on organised sector where as patri wala is paying hafta to pvt sector. Thats why Self employment promotion is being don to collect hafta n salaried class is being reduced
govt has no time to control adulteration, but full time for raising taxes for popcorn😂, different flavours with different tax in popcorn, wow
These are the reasons for inflation in food product
Election Commission / Commission Agent ???
Rude behaviour by the anchor. The experts are trying to discuss about taxation while she is trying to blame opposition parties. No experts here even brought up the government.
And that annoying voice. This video deserves a thumps down.
Nirmala's hands prey i n on too poor children favourite popcorn..
Shameless...
when Onion Price goes up,
she said she did not use it..
we doubt weather she is a tax cutter or Axecutter ?
@TimesNow Please improve your level of journalism. Don't call 4 panelists if you don't have enough time to let even one of them respond properly. Its so insulting and disrespectful that you're constantly talking over them.
Next year GST on marriage and having ...?
more than 75% of states are ruled by NDA, so blaming the opposition ruled state for the mismanaged GST meeting is the stupidest argument.
In reality NDA is clueless about economic policy.
But still you vote when they chant JSR and harass muslims....that time where does your logic go???
Times now is also a good media kya ?
Keep voting for them and cry like this..
after a weak: 18% gst on dotted condoms
UK jaisa service to do! Somalia jaisa nehi
Nirmal sitharaman priorities are completely wrong , middle class honest tax payer is getting crushed with high inflation and exorbitant price rise.
Tax is okay .government hospitals is it worth getting treated even ministers do not get treated . Roads are the worst .water is polluted .what is tax for 😂😂😂
Modi want to finish middle class family
Popcorn 🍿 tax😂😂
This is called a popcorn diversion. Can anyone tell what we are being diverted from.
And roadside food is it really not taxed if you know what I am pointing 😂 it is by ......we all know
Government will loose more tax from cinema goers as well as popcorn buyers in malls as people will stop going to movies and stop buying popcorn
02:00 questioning opposition for the rules made by government 😂
Anchoring seems to be pretty shitty... Not allowing anyone to speak.
Anchors should respect the commentators and stop talking over them / cut them during an argument. Height of rudeness.
Roadside stalls are increasing bcs og this
Anchor is asking questions to opposition party why there is tax in popcorn 😂😂😂😂😂
Godi media
Who will speak? Presenter has one second attention span and likes listening to own voice
Politics also 😅
Everything is being earned by gst council? Who is bringing these aggresive tax proposals...whom you are making idiots?
Better to buy from shops and thelawalkas same with drinking water who supply to homes better to believe their quality instead of giving more money money where govt wants money by getting fssai licence fleecing Indian citizens tommorow gst on breathing air
Media is bogus with these godi journalist.. justifying govt
Kind Request to Not Vote for BJP coming 2029 Election.... Don't Write your Frustrations here.....Put it in Action by Voting....
Sab Ka Saath ! Kis ka Vikaas?
OMG a talking frog!
What globally see ? Don’t Bullshit only idiots will have so many slabs and complicate. If you dare compare with the taxation of Singapore or UK and come out with a justification