It's very good - which bothers me. It bothers me a lot. And it's scary. It's actually a good song. But, this isn't HIM. It isn't Steven Wilson. It's AI. I can't imagine how artists like Wilson would feel to hear something like this. They've spent DECADES to build their craft, to hone their skills, to develop their talents, to create THEIR SOUND.... And AI can re-create it to such an extent that it may "cheat" them out of a creative future AND marr their history of talent, growth and development? It doesn't seem right to me.
Although it's very good, the song itself can't compete with the true heart of his music. And that's where most of his music comes from. Just my 2 cents but it does sound freakin' great.
I don't have problem with AI. If I like the song, I will listen to it. If I don't like it, I will not listen. It is important to know, which song is original (made by SW) and with one is AI produced. At the end of the story, it is important that SW gets money for his work.
FFS! Real fans would know this isn't an SW original but the casual listener would have no idea. That's pretty scary. But then again, AI is scary. The warnings sounded over the last decade or so were very real indeed.
Really nice job. But I think the Solitude vocals sound more like SW. Someone had asked you to do a video showing your process - any chance you're working on it? This whole subject of AI-created music is fascinating, and scary at the same time.
@@the_e_major Udio will use the info you give away in your video to block those artists, and then we won't be able to do it anymore. Best to keep that info private imo.
@@Basement-View I'm not completely sure but I think they can't do this even if they want to. The problem is that if they find a way to somehow block this hidden feature, the quality of all their songs drops drastically. This feature goes beyond Steven Wilson's music. My experience is telling me that it's possible to generate a huge number of songs from famous artists that are already out there using the platform.
@@the_e_major Couldn't they just block the specific tags you're using? I completely agree that since Udio was trained on artists, blocking those artists from the output ends up lowering the overall quality of the music generated. This is true for all AI like how text models get worse quickly the more moderation and blocks are thrown on them. But I've seen certain tag combinations trigger mod errors so I know Udio is at least trying to moderate and block some stuff, particularly whatever methods and jailbreaks bubble up to the surface via YT, discord, reddit etc. I just hope your tags are different enough from mine because I would be really disappointed to lose the ability to use SW's vocals.
Although it still sounds a bit artificial, it's already good. And it is only the beginning of these technologies. In 5 or 7 years our musical reality will change completely ...
I like this as much as anything he has done since Hand Cannot Erase. Will the AI Steven Wilson be going on tour anytime soon ?! I see that AI SW play a Les Paul too............
really boring. this sound like some really big trash that steven wilson wrote when he was wearing pampers and he don't even would like to publish it on z-side record collection
Give me the real Steven Wilson anytime. This is not in the same league. Keep your AI drivel.
Love you Steve Brilliant you are as you well already know,"Brilliant😊"
A very sad day for human expression.
It's very good - which bothers me. It bothers me a lot. And it's scary. It's actually a good song. But, this isn't HIM. It isn't Steven Wilson. It's AI.
I can't imagine how artists like Wilson would feel to hear something like this. They've spent DECADES to build their craft, to hone their skills, to develop their talents, to create THEIR SOUND.... And AI can re-create it to such an extent that it may "cheat" them out of a creative future AND marr their history of talent, growth and development?
It doesn't seem right to me.
Motif mimicry, a soulless veneer of SW.
Although it's very good, the song itself can't compete with the true heart of his music. And that's where most of his music comes from. Just my 2 cents but it does sound freakin' great.
I don't have problem with AI. If I like the song, I will listen to it. If I don't like it, I will not listen. It is important to know, which song is original (made by SW) and with one is AI produced. At the end of the story, it is important that SW gets money for his work.
I hate that I like it. This is very scary and disturbing
FFS! Real fans would know this isn't an SW original but the casual listener would have no idea. That's pretty scary. But then again, AI is scary. The warnings sounded over the last decade or so were very real indeed.
Really nice job. But I think the Solitude vocals sound more like SW.
Someone had asked you to do a video showing your process - any chance you're working on it? This whole subject of AI-created music is fascinating, and scary at the same time.
appreciate your opinion mate. Yes, I am in the process of making a video explaining how I get to certain artists.
@@the_e_major Udio will use the info you give away in your video to block those artists, and then we won't be able to do it anymore. Best to keep that info private imo.
@@Basement-View I'm not completely sure but I think they can't do this even if they want to. The problem is that if they find a way to somehow block this hidden feature, the quality of all their songs drops drastically. This feature goes beyond Steven Wilson's music. My experience is telling me that it's possible to generate a huge number of songs from famous artists that are already out there using the platform.
@@the_e_major Couldn't they just block the specific tags you're using? I completely agree that since Udio was trained on artists, blocking those artists from the output ends up lowering the overall quality of the music generated. This is true for all AI like how text models get worse quickly the more moderation and blocks are thrown on them. But I've seen certain tag combinations trigger mod errors so I know Udio is at least trying to moderate and block some stuff, particularly whatever methods and jailbreaks bubble up to the surface via YT, discord, reddit etc. I just hope your tags are different enough from mine because I would be really disappointed to lose the ability to use SW's vocals.
Increíble, lo peor es que la canción está buena ☹
That's a NOPE.
This is incredible...
Although it still sounds a bit artificial, it's already good. And it is only the beginning of these technologies. In 5 or 7 years our musical reality will change completely ...
i'm worry and sad !😟
Damn this is awesome
I'm sorry but this is awful, there's no realness to be found here.
The funny part is SW was saying he was having a hard time telling the difference between his voice and this one....
Excellent.
I like this as much as anything he has done since Hand Cannot Erase. Will the AI Steven Wilson be going on tour anytime soon ?! I see that AI SW play a Les Paul too............
really boring. this sound like some really big trash that steven wilson wrote when he was wearing pampers and he don't even would like to publish it on z-side record collection
Ai ist
it's very "Blackfield"
Ok tier I see better
😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊