Khan Sir Vs Pankaj Sir | Who is Right ?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 ноя 2023
- Hello Friends ,In this shorts video ,we have talked about The controversy between @khangsresearchcentre1685 and @PhysicsbyPankajSir. This controversy was created by the famous electricity misconception.We have tried to explain who is right between them and how the physics works behind each logics.
#physics #khansirmotivation #physicsisfun
#science #electronic #physicsshorts
Iss par full video available hai ,
Dekhne ke liye logo ke neeche click kijiye
Ya phir channel par visit kijiye.❤
Rajkumar Bhai sahi kaha or ye jo video bana rahe h inko hi samjh nhi aa raha h ki dono sir ne kya kya samjhaya h. Ye dono sir ke beech cumpere kar rahe h jabki unhone kya kaha h ek ek sabd acche se sune to samjhege. Berojgari 😂
@@prabhakarjhariya badhiya 😂
Aaiye kabhi tuition lene !!
@@SMarteduteria bhai tumbhi achhe knowledge ki bat bataye ho magar controversy ka Karan kuch or he full video sahi se dekho....?
ja ke physics pdlo only reel se gyan nahi milata jo video bana raha vo sahi hai pankaj sir bhi sahi hai@@RajuKumar-ol5wn
@@RajuKumar-ol5wnohh 😅 God that's why education is important plz aap thoda 9vi kakhya ka physics dekhe taar ki lambai se tab fark padega jabki potential difference ho switch off hone par potential difference zero ho jayega toh kya ghanta current flow karega isliye power (vi) bhi zero hoga aur jab power hi zero hoga to kayeka bill samajh me aaya kya ji
Jab education ko leke controversy hota he tab samajh jana desh age badh raha he😌
Edit:-8K wow😲
और जब इस गलती को मानने से टीचर इनकार कर दे तो लगता है कि देश अभी आगे नहीं बढ़ रहा है अभी भी कुछ कमी है
🔥🔥🔥
@@VRshort7 absolutely
*bihar
@@VRshort7kisi ko samjh nahi aa raha ki Khan sir apni galti kyo nahi man rahe
Kya unhe is controversy k bare me malum ro hai na ?
Pankaj sir is right...Khan sir bhi ensaan hai galtiya ensaan se hi hote hai...
Pankaj sir janawar ha😂
😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣
Kbhi chhu ke dekhana fej vala pata chal jayega
Beta aap narsri class me baitho ye baat tere smjh me nahi aayegi tu baccha hai abhi. lekin tujhe bta hi deta hu taaki 10, 20 saal baad tu jab padega to tere smjh aa jaayega.
Jab tak earth nahi milega tak tak phase bhi kuch nahi kar sakta.
Ex :- her pakshi phase wire per hi baithta hai unko current nahi lagta jab tak vo earth wali wire se touch nahi hote.
Note :- pehle phase ki spelling dekho google se vo thoda detail me bta dega aapko.
Isko kehte hai asli controversy, on educational basis , maza isme hi aata hai
ज्ञान वृद्धि हेतु प्रतिस्पर्धा होना अतिआवश्यक है🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🚩🚩
To jo insan conform nahi h vo kyu controversy ker raha h
Par ye dharm ka kachra apne paas rakho
How is resistance infinite😢😢😢😢
@@XAMINGOnly
अप निहायत ही अभागे मनुष्य हो,
जो धर्म को कचरा कहते हो🇮🇳🙏🙏🚩🚩🇮🇳
@@lubeenamm5469Because air acts acts as insulator
Pankaj sir shi hai🔥🔥🔥
Yes !!
Khan sir kichre subject ka teacher ha
❤
@@sahebGamming180😂chuo kar be kutte nahin pata hain tu bhokta kyu hian
@@SMarteduteria bhai khan se se bhi kabhi kabhi galati ho jati h wo v insan ha na ..❤
I am a wireman , Pankaj sir is Right ✅
I am Electronic
I am english but you are wrong
😂
@@SMarteduteria are bhari mistake hogaya sir I am Electrition
@@SMarteduteriabhaiya mujhe lagta Hai aapka infinite resistance manna galat hai kyuki waha par koi resistance hai hi nhi or hame pata hai ohms law is not applicable in case where there is no resistance also i=v/r relation is only mathematical ,if i=0 does not means resistance is infinite ,
Pls clear my doubt 🙏
Aap dono log mere liye आदरणीय aur पूज्यनीय है😊😊sir.
How is resistance infinite
@@lubeenamm5469because air a bad conductor. There was a gap, so circuit was incomplete, so current couldn't flow that's why, the resistance is infinity♾️.
V=IR, I♾️1/R
I=0, R=♾️.
Hope it helps..
Khan sir India ki no.1 teacher h
Par galti unse bhi ho sakti h
isliye Pankaj sir ki Baat sahi h
Usko galti nhi bolte bhai, usko knowledge me kami bolte h 😂
How is resistance infinite
@@generalvideo832100% right
Pankaj sir special physics k h na,,,,to vo jyada jante h,,,khan sir koi physics k teacher nhi h,,,,,,
Glti hoti to man lete video delet krwa k okat dikha di
@@lubeenamm5469bcs we cant measure it how much is it
जितना मुझे पता था खान सर तो बहुत अच्छे हैं ।
पर फिर भी खुद भी गलती होते हुए भी पंकज सर के चैनल पर strike करवा दिया 😂।
Khan sir khali wah wahi lutna chahta h
Tum log chutiya ho ya chaman chutiya ,salo Khan sir ke paas itna Khali fokt ka time nhi ki youtubro ki strike de salo strike to unke team ka kaam hai ab team wale thodi Khan sir ko har bar batayenge ki aaj in youtubro ko strike mara 😅
Khan sir ek bari hasti hai isliye agar unse galti hue bhi hai to pankaj sir ji unhe presonaly bolna chahiye tha publicly sidhe Khan sir par aabaj nahi uthana chahiye tha.
@@brainmasterfacts8637 achha 😅
Simpathy gain karne k liye aap majdur ka example doge.
😂
@@brainmasterfacts8637और हमने गलत बात सीखी वो?
Just clarify you wire k andar current hote hain bas flow nahi hota , agar doubt hai to dono wire ko jod k dekho
And anything/infinity = not defined, it's not 0
Current hote hain , lekin nahi hote 😂
Ye kaise statement hai ,
Current ka matlb kya hota hai ?
school jao. Phirse
Yes it's Right because conduction of electrons continues to earth through our body this is called earthing.
We feel current 😮
I am a fan of Khan sir but pankaj sir is right here...
Great fan I was.......but I now hate him, the way he talk shameful for a teacher
Khan sir is geography and world politics teacher ,
To phir phisycs padha hi kyo rahe hn
@@brilliantfactforgenius7427 kyuki pagal ho chuka hai
to physics me gyan kyo pel rahe hain
बेवकूफ वो gs के teacher हैँ जिसमे genral science भी आता है
@@Priyamvad_Priyadarshiyes
Un wires ko socket ke potential pe laane ke liye thoda sa current flow hoga jab tak wires socket ke potential pe na ae. Resistance infinite nhi hota bohot high hota hai to leakage current flow hota hai.
Khan sir ko bolo general knowledge pe dhyan do 😊
Koi bhi teacher jyada famous ho jaye to iska matlab ye nhi ki wo kabhi galat nhi ho sakta mera manna hai ki is mamle mein khan sir galat hai😂😂😂😂😂
Current flow hota h bhaai..
Lekin ye 12 physics ka syllabus mein nhi h.
@@sourodipbanerjeeexactly... Charge agar bhut high ho toh karega wo air kei dielectric value ko overcame kar legaaa
@@user-jy6rs2hj8i That can happen even at 1v… There will be some electrons flowing through the wire so you don’t even need high voltage…
9th ka physics padle chutiye
@@sourodipbanerjee to agar hum sirf 1 hi wire ko pakrae tab kyun current lagta hai kyunk tab bhi circuit close nahi hota
Khan sir - ruk Puri RUclips ko copyright bhejta hu....😢😂😂😂😂
😂
Khan sir is a egoist man
@@haiderabbas4541uska sirf pakistan pakistan kar ke content chalta hai. Aur khud ko hi Sir bana diya hai sabke liye😂
Current ko lambi duri per le jaane ke liye voltage badhaya jata hai iske liye ham trangister ka upyog karte Hain kyunki lambi duri me current ka loss hota hai khan sir is right❤ 11k to 220/440
If I = V/R
And R is ∞.
In this video
I = V/∞
So, I = 0.
But if we change the formula like
R = V/I
And I = 0 then R will be Undefined (not infinity).
If we say I is Undefined then the problem will be solved.
यही होता है जब लोग किसी की लाख अच्छी बातो को छोड़ कर एक गलती को पकड़ के जज करने लगते है आपने वीडियो में सही बताया है दोनो गुरु हमारे लिए आदरणीय है और हमे इनका सम्मान करना चाइए ❤
ना की किसी एक गलती को लेके तमाशा 🙂
😀❤️❤️ shukriya
Bhai baat to shi h pr pankaj sir k channel pr strike karwa dena ye kon si aadarniye waali baat hui
@@jitenderhtsaini6050right 😅
Bhai glti hoti hai tho usko manna chayie na ki channel par skrike dena chayie
Tamasha nahi ise tark vitark , manthan ya healthy debate kahte hain. Jis se baccho ki knowledge badhegi means fayda hi hoga. Gali to do nahi kisi ne kisi ko jo samman kam hua kisi ek ka bhi😊
में एक इलेक्ट्रीशियन हो और इस वीडियो में सही बताया गया है की खान सर गलत है
❤️❤️
😂😂😂😂😂
जब वायर में करंट है तो करंट फ्लो कर रहा है अगर नहीं कर रहा तो मीटर में रीडिंग नहीं आता है lekin reading a raha hai to Khan sar sahi hai mein jo cover Kiya jata hai kisi chij Ko bachane ke liye Kiya jata hai jab aap open karenge to current to flow ho gai
@@PujaKumari-gh1bjto kya wo formula galat hai 😂
@@PujaKumari-gh1bj metre me reading nahi aati hai , switch band rakhne par
Khan sir is also right it depends on condition that the power will ionised the atmosphere or not , example lighting in air
That happens when potential differences is very very high like in case of hertz experiment
Khan sir is right - current ko apne destination per jaane ke liye yah pata karna hoga ki circuit pura hai ya nahin, current ki vajah se- jab wire me ek electron kam ho jaaye to tu khud ke loop mein ghumta rahata hai aur vate karta hai circuit complete hone ka tab jakar uska ek electron mil jata hai
Potential difference and current are different things
Ye physics ka law hai koi politics nahi hai jo khan sir apne app ko sahi bole.
Khan sir is wrong...
Bhai unhone apne aap ko sahi bola hi nhiii, unse glti hui hai bs
Aise mindset mat rakha kro boss
Galti insano se hi hoti hai
Physics में khan sir कई बार गलती करते हैं मैंने भी notice किया है।
bhai dono sir sahi hai current flow bhi hota hai aur nhi bhi ❤❤
@@Calmscape39tumhe tab nhi pta hai kuch pankaj sir ne jab ek video me bola ki Khan sir ne galat btaya hai to😂😂😂 Khan sir ne pankaj sir ke channel PE strike marwa Diya tha taki unka channel delete ho Jaye😂😂 Jake pankaj sir ke channel PE video dekh lo 😂😂.
Pankaj sir recpect button 😊
बहस इस बात पर है कि अगर तार की लंबाई जितनी ज्यादा होगी उतनी करंट लॉस होगी और ये तब होगी जब तार सर्किट मे होगा सिर्फ तार मे करंट प्रवाह करेंगे तो लोड ज़ीरो होगा करेंट पर कोई असर नहीं पड़ेगा जैसे ही तार को सर्किट मे लाएंगे यानी कोई उपकरण को जलाएंगे तो धारा का ज्यादा क्षति होगी .
पंकज सर की बात सही है .
Dono sir sahi h, Khan sir experience aur halat k hisab se aur Pankaj sir Physics k hisab se,🙏🙏
Me khud electrician hun
And i know open circuits me current flow nhi hoga
jab tak "R" nahi milta
Pankaj sir is right me
Hota hain current flow open circuit mein bhi. But its a topic of advanced physics
Kaise nhi hoga current flow wire tak testor se check karke dekho , bich me kuchh nhi h matlab circuit complete nhi hua but wire ke end Tak current to aaega n
@@ytsiddharthkumar Bhai kya bak ra tester me resistance ni hota kya? Jese hi tester touch karega to current flow hoga ni to open rehne pr ni hoga simple concept h bhai
Wire ka internal resistance knha gya?😂 V=IR POWER LOSS TO HOGA PR METER ME SHOW NHI KREGA
@@pathansultan7336Abe wapas Jaan ka raasta tu dega
Correct Pankaj sir is right
Bilkul galat maine ye try Kiya h aur switch on krte hi aag lagne wali thi uske bad maine chappal bhi khai thi gharwalo ki
Khan sir shi keh rhe h🥲
Khan sir ghalat bol rahe hain
Ohms law is valid for only ohmic circuits ya ideal circuits... bhai agr resistance h wire ne to current ka power loss hoga(P = i^2 r ) but agr ideal wire with 0 resistance h to ( P = vi) lgta h , mtlb current ka kch to loss hoga
Bina load ke current flow nhi hoga unless voltage kafi high na ho.
Jab tak wo air ka dielectric na tod de
More than 21kv
Increase the voltage, and the air itself will act as a medium to complete the circuit. (Electric Arc)
No need to physically touch the wire to complete the circuit now.
The red wire has it's electrons oscillating since it's the live ac wire but yellow one has no current in it, so in a way both teachers are correct since one wire has 220V potential while other is at 0V but when they are shorted then both will carry huge amount of current!
wire ke dono taraf potential difference create hojayega, and isi ke wajah se ek short time keliye current flow hoga but not in conventional manner like ek wire se dusre wire me same electron flow kre, aisa nhi hoga, instead dono wires par negative polarity wale charges aajayenge or iska probability kaafi kam hai ki dusre wire pr aaya hua charge first wire se he aaya ho, so technically we can't really say ki current flow hua, but haan charges jarur flow hoga from the external system, and hence current leake karte rhega and power loss hota rhega thoda thoda karke
Leakege current
Current sirf bhut short time k lie flow hoga and phir zero ho jaaega as in RC circuit because
Ise ham capacitor k jaise treat kr skte h kyuki capacitor ki plates k beech m bhi space hota h and we know that capacitor allows AC but blocks DC
Pankaj sir sahi hai ❤❤
Un do points ke beech me electrical potential difference create ho gya hai... Jisko hum voltage kehte hai..
Matlab ke JAB vo points connect honge to current flow hoga .. jab tak connect nahi hai tab tak koi current nahi flow hoga...
Controversy nhi hoti kush, dono sahi hain bs alag nzriya rkh rhe hain
In reality, current hogi.
1. Jb switch on krenge tb
Jo galat padheye uska support karna galat h
Pankaj sir shi h
Actually current and voltage are to different things...
When u connect wire in socket then voltage available wire but current start flowing when load is connected to wire..
Absolutely correct 💯
Khan ji ko padhna hoga pankaj sir se😂😂
Actually देखा जाए तो दोनों ही सही है, quantum entanglement ka इस्तमाल करे तो और भले ही दोनों wire दूर दूर है पर कुछ करेंट हमेशा लीक करेगा जो नोटिस कर पाना मुश्किल है और 1 से current loss हो रहा है तो दूसरा रिसिव कर ही रहा होगा
Bachpan me is baat ko lekar me aur mere dost ke bich ladai hua tha. aur dekho me sahi tha 😂
अगर वायर की लंबाई बढ़ा दी मुंबई से दिल्ली तक तब करंट खत्म होगा कि 220 वोल्टेज वाला😂😂😂
😂😂😂
Ho skta h it's true electricity house m jb Bijli jata h to big amount m jata h because of transistors ghr m hr jgh jata h wha s to again power ko low kiya jata h because of resistors, pir area wise transformer m jata h wo again High kr dega current and distribution ho jaega meters m simple 😅
Topic hai current flow hoga ya nahi. Current hai ispe kisi ko doubt nahi 😊
lets understand this way
jo bijli ki wire transformer sai khambu pai jati hai aur agr hum sub sai akhri walai khambai pai jayai jaha circuit complete nhi hai lakin waha b dono wires mai potential difference hoga yai toh air resistance hai. Agr hum cathode ray tube ko dekhe phir............
Khan sir: agar lag raha ho current nahi hai to pakad ke dekh lo😂
Bro tune supply cut krke touch kra hai n ye dono wire ko wrna shyd zinda nhi hota ? 😂😂
Haan Bhai. , sirf example tha samjhaane ke liye
Toh bhai phele practicaly check kr switch on krke tab manenge hum
Agar switch on bhi hota to bhi marega nhi yaar tension na lo, kyuki alternate current phase change karta rehta hai 50 times per second me, To agar wo pakdega bhi to bhi pakad ke rakh nhi payega, chhodna hi padega.
@@Shashwatabhai ek bar check karna please
@@student...12345 Are Bhai, wo automatically bahat time ho jata hai, Jab line rehta hai or hamlog kaam karte hai aur kahin se ground aa jayega to maar dega. But hm, pakad kar rakh nhi paoge, chhodna to padega aur tum chhod hi doge subject to conditions that RMS voltage aur simple AC voltage 240V se jyada na ho.
Again AC voltage, DC nhi bol rha, wo to tum chhod hi nhi paoge wo ek zero-phase-change voltage hai.
Bhai tumhari baat sahi h but ham infinite resistance kese measure kese krenge😅 or single wire pakdane par ham current lgta h agr hm dusra wire na pkde tb bhi iska reason kya h fir😊
Agr ap single wire ko touch karke earth ke direct contact me na ho to apko current nahi lagega ... ha aur agar ap wire ko touch karke earth ke contact me ho to earth current (charge ) apne andar leleti hai tab you act as a wire ....
@@awareparmeshwar4415correct 👍
When Earth is connected ground aa jayega or circuit completes, to shock to lagega bhaiya.
Dono bhi sahi hai, yeh do wire ek bahut chota capacitor banata hai, isliye bohut Kam current flow hoga. Hame Pata hai ki capacitor se sifir ac flow ho sakhta hai, par current bahut Kam hoga jo ki negligible hai agar dc hota toh koi current flow nhi hoga. Students should respect both teacher, all you want is growth of india so if someone have some doubts it should be solved and right education should be given to understand how beautiful the nature is 😊. Aur ek aur chiz capacitor se jo current flow hota use ham reactive current ya reactive power bolte hai aur yeh current ka charge goverment nhi leti hai. Active current vo hota hai jo resistive load hota hai. Correct me if I an wrong 😅
😂😂 controversy bhi kaafi bade topic pe karr re 😂😅 mujhe laga hoga topic Advance classical mechanics se 😂😂
😂
@@SMarteduteria
Bro
Aisa ho sakta hai
Air ke through v current pass hoti hai
Tabhi toh spark se leke thunder ⚡ tak dekhne ko milta hai
Khan sir is absolutely right
@@Aryan_Vermabhai thunder production mai charge ka magnitude hadd se jada hota hai isliye discharge dikhta hai par agar wires ke through negligible hoga
@@bhavya5617
Wires me current negligible hota toh koi machine kaam hi nahi karta
@@bhavya5617
220 V ka toh supply hamare ghar me hi aata hai
Transformers me 440 V se leke 11,000 V tk ka current hota hai
Toh negligible kaha se ho gaya
I'm not student but pankaj sir is good in physics
Current can flow in case there is suitable atmosphere between the two wires. For eg. Lightning the current flows because there is suitable atmosphere between the clouds and metal rod at ground
Transient time mai current flow hota hai.. steady state time me nahi hota.. matlab kuch nano seconds keliye flow hoga jabtak dusra open end wire same potential me nahi aajata..
Current High voltage ka hota to easily flow kar lega like jab lighting hota hai to current earth par girta hai bhale bich mai air hai fir bhe current pass kar leta hai
@@downtoskydekho hum current ke bare mai bata rahe the ghar mai 220 aata hai or bake industry mai 440 or 1100 volt aata hai or eak baat mere ghar par to 440 aata hai tumhare ghar par kya aata hai wo tum jano
@@downtosky tumse aacha he physics pdhe hai tabhe bata rahe hai current ka voltage change karo apne aap tumhe bhe pta chal jaye ga
@@downtosky electrostatic current rahe to wo wire se flow bhe nhi kar sakta ish hesab se dono he teacher galt hua
@@PriyaSingh-lr4onyou are right lighting current kafi hi high voltage ka hota hai so wo air ke dielectric strength se flow kr deta hai but first stroke of lighting always ek shortes resistance path ko follow krne ki kosis krta hai aur iski liye bijli unche ped ya tower pr girti hai sur tum jo baat kr rhe ho wo second stroke ki baat kr rhe ho bhut lambi theory hai but in short wo khi pe bhi gir skti hai land ho ya tower aur uska voltage highest hota hai aur us se bachne ke liye koi protection nhi bna hai (aur second thing current bhi usi tarah tb hi flow karva jb air ka dielectric strength se jada ho aur hamare ghar aur near substation ki voltage bhi air ke dielectric strength se km hoti hai so current nhi flow hoga as a open circuit behave karega)
करेंट फ्लो होगा.... लेकिन करेंट की वैल्यू बहुत कम होगी....कारण यह है कि हवा में आयन होते हैं और हवा के माध्यम से करेंट बहुत कम मात्रा में फ्लो होगा...... उदाहरण के लिए हवा में खुली रखी बैटरी काफी समय बाद बिना किसी इस्तेमाल के ही डिस्चार्ज हो जाती है....
One can always mistakes... best is to acknowledge...
Pankaj Sir is right bec open wires mein extension box ko attach karein aur bulb jalane per circuit complete hoga.
क्योंकि हवा में नमी की मात्रा मौजूद होती है और उनमें कुछ अम्लीय मात्रक भी होते हैं इसलिए हवा में भी बहुत ही कम मात्रा में लेकिन करंट फ्लो अर्थात धारा का प्रवाह होता है अतः खान सर सही है
Hawa me nami se bahut Kam Matra me current flow hoga. Is logic se Khan sir sahi Hain par utni Matra me jitni Matra me current flow hoga😅😅
@@vikasverma_1 bro sahi bola tumne 😁
Ye tum genral science k hisab se upar upar se keh sakte ho... actually electron jump karega ya nahi vo dielectric strength pe nirbhar karta hai, and corona discharge ko leakage currents kehte hai.
Don't think about what he is saying
Think about why is he saying....😮
Dono hi apne jagah shi ho skte h because high voltage se hum air ko bhi ionise Kara ke usme current flow Kara skte h , jab high open voltage air me jaega through short distances too electric arc ka generation hoskta h
Agar acche sa iss question ko dekha Jaye toh conclusion kuch aisa dekhega When the switch is in the 'ON' position, the circuit from the positive terminal of the battery to the negative terminal is complete. The circuit is then said to be closed and the current flows throughout the circuit instantly.
Since this is AC current, current will flow but much less.
Two sirs are right here. But if you think carefully, Khan sir is right. You may not know the law of transformer. If this current were high voltage and the two were very close to each other, you would see the current flow with your own eyes. Press the switch of the shock gun or press the switch of the electric gun to light the stove and the electricity will move, due to which the purple light will flash, which you will hold and the electricity will flow through your body.
High voltage ki baat hi nhi ho rahi yahan
Ise ham capacitor k jaise treat kr skte h kyuki capacitor ki plates k beech m bhi space hota h and we know that capacitor allows AC but blocks DC
*पागल मत बनो वहाँ तार की लंबाई की बात हो रही थी।*
Chacha kaha rahte hai aap
Confusion hai to wire touch karke confusion door krlo 😂
Wire touch karne ki vaje sehi to circuit complete hota hea bhai 😂😂😂
Tu to science ka student nehi hea ye to pakka hua or agar he bhi to ratta wala ho tum
Aapki ye baat bohot acchi lagi
Ki aone aadar kensath khan sir ko galat bataya
Agar phase aur neutral ki coil bna kr pass layi jaye to bina touch hue bhi current flow kr jaye ka
Her koi her cheez me parfect nhi ho sakta Pankaj sir right hai Khan sir ne Jo bola tha wo shayad unki kahi na kahi bhool ho gyi hai
Jab science leke padhai hi nahi toh galat bolega hi. Pankaj sir correct ❤
12 science se kiya hai khan sir
Ohm's law converted in to ohem's law 😂😂
Both are right because the current tends to zero but not zero👍
Pankaj sie ne practically btaya hai.
in case of phase wire current is always present but in case of Neutral wire have no current available but it's one type of return path of current so phase wire need to complete circuit, if you touch without any protection so you got shock
How can the current present ?
@@SMarteduteriaare, inko pata hi nhi ki current is due to the flow of electron. Open wire me electrons flow hi nhi hoga.
bro here khan sir is also right but it depend on the situation becouse here the lenght of wire create capacitance as the lenght increaces large number of parralell capacitance form due to current leakage and over all create a good capacitance and we know i = v/Xc and here Xc is impedance due to capacitance which is equal to 1/ωc so here capcitance is inversly proportional to Xc and Xc is inversly proportional to current so overall when lenght of wire increases current also develop even in oven circuit but the current is so small
Yes ,it depends.
But ,Khan sir said in that situation where Voltage is our home voltage
@@SMarteduteria ye bhi sahi hai socket ke idhar jo voltage hai wahi voltage wire ke tip pe milega. Currunt bohot kam hoga but flow karega kunki ye AC hai jisme resistance nahi total inductance dalna padega formula me. V=ZI naki V=RI
@@vidyadharpatil6683but as we know current flow from higher potential to lower so here the resistance of air is very high approx 21kv so there is no lower potential to flow of electrons so current doesn't flow and about imaginary capacitors it only happens in long distance transmission system having distance more than 200km so in this situation there is no flow of current until a less resistive path is offered for eg human body or some conductor
@@sunnysonker5380 No, wire lenght doesn't matter capacitance and inductance are products of magnetic and electric field interaction, in long wires only difference is loss is noticeable, in short wire loss is there but very small. And for the higher and lower potential thing, in AC current these higher and lower potential exchage sides that's why it is "ulternating current" and only in case of ulternating current the non ohomic behavior of the resistor comes to play, means we not only consider resistance but total impedance of the circuit. And like no perfect blackbody or perfect elastic material is not reality in physics same case is for resistor perfect ohomic resistor is not real where it only has resistance.
@@vidyadharpatil6683 As an engineer we know that very small changes can be neglected so aproxx zero current will flow so second one was right
Basically the answer is yes.. current will flow, but adding infinite resistor is a condition right?
Khan Sir is a good motivator and Pankaj Sir is Good teacher that's the difference ❤
This wasn't real controversy, controversy was about MCB and place where should MCB need to be installed
Yes , you are also correct. Please watch my full video on this to understand.
Mcb kahin bhi lagao circuit open hai ya close. Ye matter krta hai. Jab minimum length wire ki use ki jaye
Pankaj sir भले यहां सही हो ,
ये बात केवल low voltage और कम दूरी पर ही सही है
लेकिन अगर transmissin लाइन की बात करोगे तो वहां high voltage होता है वहां corona , inductance, capacitance के कारण power loss होगा।
इसीलिए 11kv, 33kv भेजा जाता है ताकि पावर loss हो तब भी हमे राउंड figure 10 kv , और 30kv मिले।
Sawal bijli bill ka hai khan sir galat hai aur use ghamand bhi khud ko currect krne ke bajaye usne strike dalwa di
@@Dripster2तो भाई तुम कर लेना घमंड पहले हो तो जाओ घमंड करने लायक 😂
Aisa nhi h ji lo load pr transmission line m bhi current nhi flow hota h
Transmission line me load hamesha laga rehta h
Pankaj sir is right... Current always needs a cycle to flow.. when circuit is closed, current will flow
ρ= RA/L
Every conductor has it's own resistance so a less amount of current will flow.
मेरे हिसाब से दोनों अपने अपने जगह सही हैं... खान सर बोले थे कि अगर मीटर से ज्यादा दूर लोड होगा तो बिजली बिल ज्यादा आएगा जो कि सही है अगर हम पतले वायर का उपयोग करते हैं और ज्यादा दूर मे लोड होता है तो वोल्टेज काम हो जाता है वायर रेजिस्टेंस की वजह से और अगर हम वहीँ stabilizer से लोड चलाएंगे तो सैम लोड पर ज्यादा मीटर मे बिल आएगा....
Nikal
@@Businessislovemu se supari Nikal ke baat KR re baba 🤓
Bhai Khan sir humanities based subject ke mahagyaani hai pankaj sir science based subjects jaise physics aur chem ke legend hai
to ho sakta hai Khan sir se galti se mistake ho gayi hogi
pankaj sir bahut mast teacher hai physics ke
High voltage pe current flow karega kyuki air dielectric hai wo high potential pe conductor behave karta hai is liye jab thunderstorm or electric poles me spark dikta hai
Bro simple h wire ka bhi kuch resistance hota hai wire ke end tak cureent ayega hum touch krenge toh circuit complete ho jayega hume current lagega
Hello Bhai I am Vivek , friend of "nilesh" ,you are doing a great job 👍 keep it up and focus on your academics also
Shukriya Bhai 😃 !! Nice to see you here.
Thanks for your appreciation ❤️❤️
😀
@@nileshsharma5278 ❤️❤️
@@nileshsharma5278 tum kon ho bhai mere aur Mukesh k beech kyu aa rhe ho ,bhut marunga chadi se
@@vivekanand9692😂
Bina load ke current flow nahi hoga jisse nato to line loss hoga or na hi voltage drop hoga or ye bhi ek baat hai ki bina potential defrence ke circiut mai current flow nahi hota
Education ko lekar controversy is very good. Means people are progressing
Is prakar to V = IR hota hai aur
R=infinite hai to V= I*infinite , iska matlab Voltage infinite hoga 😂😂😂
Voltage doesn't depend on resistance it's a constant,still Khan sir galat hai 😂
If you divide anything with infinite then it's value is 0
Circuit me jab current hi nahi hai to kahe ki i?
Isaka matalab jab tak ham apne Ghar me current use nhi karte tab tak current powerhouse tak hi rahata hai 😅
😂right
Ha babu power house tak pol tak kyo ki current ke lia electron ka flow jaruri h but circuit complete nhi hoga to electron flow kaise hoga . Tumhe kya lagta ha jaha tak tar h waha tak current h to eska mtlb waha tak electron flow ker rha but waha aa ker electron ja kaha rha h aaise to wire ke sare electron us end per aa ker ruk jayenge samjhe .
Aur ager phir bhi tumhe lagta h ki waha tak current h to bus ek wire ko pakdo aur niche pair ko jamin se hta to taki circuit complete n ho tab dekho light nhi marega .
Inke mutabik Powerhouse Tak bhi nahi current kahi nahi rehta
Open circuit me bhi ac current oscillate hota hai flow hota hai bhai continuously wire positive negative me change hota rahta hai oscillating magnetic field oscillating current produce karta jai
My question is.. when you touch the live wire without touching the neutral wire or the ground, why does it shock you if current doesn't flow?
Bhai ye dono sahi hai apne jagah pe. Agar potential difference kamm hai tb air electricity conduct nhi karayegi lekin agar potential difference bahut jyada hai tb air ionize hoke electricity flow karayega. Jaisa ki lightning ya welding me hota hai.
Perfect
😀
Khan sir is right जब एक व्यक्ति सफ़लता पाने लगता हैं तो उसका पैर पीछे खीचने वाले बहुत लोग आ जाते हैं।
Abe teri shakl dekh ke lg toh nhi rha tujhe physics ka P bhi aatahoga. Bss Khan sir ka name leke cool bn rha hai tu
Education me controversy hona jaruri hai 😊😊
It is tending to infinity not infinity. So both are correct
Khan sir ka chemistry bhi galti h
Right
Once i did this and the wire blasted like atom bomb
😂😂😂
😂😂
Both answers are right. Depends on the context. If participating in competitive exams then current will not flow. If you want to design precision machine then current will flow.
When the voltage is higher then current also travel in air you can experiment with a high voltage circuit
Are bhai khan sir bulb &fan me lage taar ke bare me bol rahe the. .. o toh closed hota h na
Khan sir bhi sahi h uss hisab se
खान सर सही है, क्योंकि मैंने अपने इन्वेटर बैट्री को चालू करके सभी वल्ब को बंद रखा फिर भी बैट्री डाउन हुई।
Battery to bina wire ke dukan main bhi down hojayegi..
Ghadi ka cell bhi rakha rakha khatam ho jayega..
School jao beta...
Every battery will discharge naturally..
Yaha topic transformer se ghar tak aane wali bijli ka ho raha hai aur tu battery ki baat kar raha hai😂😂😂
Battery to bina wire ke dukan main bhi down hojayegi..
Ghadi ka cell bhi rakha rakha khatam ho jayega..
School jao beta...
Every battery will discharge naturally..
Yaha topic transformer se ghar tak aane wali bijli ka ho raha hai aur tu battery ki baat kar raha hai😂😂😂
Battery to bina wire ke dukan main bhi down hojayegi..
Ghadi ka cell bhi rakha rakha khatam ho jayega..
School jao beta...
Every battery will discharge naturally..
Yaha topic transformer se ghar tak aane wali bijli ka ho raha hai aur tu battery ki baat kar raha hai😂😂😂
@ankulyadav7415 Abe laure chutiya hai kyaa pahle Jaa kar padh fir comment karna saale jahil