"There are countless stars in my heart, there's one star that shines painfully. I don't want to grab it but I don't want it to go out." This line really got to me. They don't want to talk about Jonghyun because it's too painful, but they're going to do it anyway because they want his legacy to live on and they want to make sure he isn't forgotten. This whole period is so painful. There's a hole that Jjong left behind--it their presence, in their sound, in the way they interact with each other. I just . . . hurt so much for them. But I'm so proud of them for coming back so soon. I will always love them, and I'm supporting them now even though it's hard. We're all healing, and we will all make it through this. Right now, for me at least, it's time to cry, and to remember, and to love. 5hinee forever
We don't know that this song is certainly about Jjong. But the lyrics drop so many hints: - Like you mentioned, they don't want to talk about Jjong explicitly because it's too painful - The way they single themselves out as (I) and the (You) is a star - "I'm the only one hurting, thought I might seem fine" - "There are countless stars in my heart. There's one star that shines painfully" (In Jjong's memorial clip for the GDA, he was told that he was the star that shined the brightest in the sky) I personally think that the song holds strong references about Jjong, his suffering, and his painful way of saying goodbye
Yes if u base on the lyrics of their new songs it's pointed out one person and what are their true feelings towards him...if shawol is still hurting how much more with them 😭😭😭 Keep moving forward to all of you.jonghun oppa is still looking and proud for all you've done 🙏🏼🙏🏼and we sure he smile brightly above ... A smile full of happiness a real smile for sure 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
The first is. And it’s beautiful. But the second “annyeong” verse is actually sung by Minho..I think this video got some of the vocal attributions wrong by accident !
MISSELO27 no, we do not know. it was not a real romantic relationship. Love can be platonic,,, unless they clearly state we will not know please dont assume.
MISSELO27 either way, you should not assume. Key has not clearly stated "i was in a relationship with jonghyun" so please do not assume. Yes its possible but unless he says, dont say "bUt hE wAs"
this song says so much... we all know they're still hurting inside, but they've gathered enough strength and courage to get through this comeback. we love you so much shinee ❤
I am a Blink and Jisoo recommended this song, and suddenly, i literally had goosebumps by their voices and lyrics of this song. There is so much emotions through it that it makes waver your heart. 😭❤❤❤❤
It's about letting go or being paralyzed by the pain permanently. It's a choice you have to make if your going to have any life at all. Unfortunately I know exactly what their feeling and experiencing due to something that occurred in my own life not to long ago. Which I won't discuss here because as they said so aptly, "My feelings are not for display." But their is a terrible sense of doing something wrong, and of guilt for letting them go. Like your deserting them out of selfishness not necessity. Until you understand the difference between abandoning someone.....and setting them free. And I am still baffled at how someone who, for all intents and purposes is in essence a stranger to my life, could have so deep and devastating an affect on it. I am 5 months later still heart broken. And I fear I will stay this way for a very long time to come. Until I'm strong enough to set myself free. Which for now.....I'm not. Strength and Honor.
Christo Benno I can relate and I think I understand what you're saying. Jonghyun wasn't even my favorite member of SHINee but his vocal power in the group, general incredible character and influence is undeniable. I wish Korean fans and by extension Korean society would be a little more accommodating and forgiving of a person's personal struggles. I feel like especially celebrities have to always project an image of pure model behavior which really is inhuman. This is true in many countries but especially Korea even has dedicated antifans. I too am deeply affected by his sudden passing like you even now. I cannot even look at his face without tearing up, that such a beautiful soul decided to leave rather than having the conditions needed in order to truly be happy and thrive. This whole time I've thought if only he didn't feel he had to hide himself.
Truly well said. And your right , Korea has the horrible distinction of being #1 in suicide. How terrible that when my daughter called me at work to tell me the sad news my first reaction was "Honey are you sure you don't mean Onew?" The way he was treated after his unfortunate go around was truly sickening. I've been clean and sober for 38 years,( and I'm dating myself here lol), and the poor guy has to APOLOGIZE for having a drinking problem. My God I shudder when I remember the things I did when I drank. All he did was stagger around blind drunk and grab somebodies leg in a drunken stupor. Then they are accused of trying to make a buck off his death because they did a concert? When a large part of the reason was to give the FANS a chance to grieve with them. A friend of mine once told me " No matter how often you see sick, it's still stunning." He was right. I can't tell you how many times I've thought "I wish I would of had just 10 minutes alone with that kid to talk to him, and more importantly, to listen. Everyone needs someone to listen to their story, and to HEAR what their saying. Not just right it off with "Just hang tough you'll be fine." Really? Maybe not, maybe you won't be. Maybe you'll be so deep into yourself, so consumed by the pain and the darkness, that the only way out is from the outside. For someone to care enough to reach in and offer you their hand and a way back to the light. Unfortunately for him, and for all of us, that didn't happen. We all lost, most off all him. He's gone now, forever. And we all must find our own way in which to absorb this shocking and terrible loss, and to address the attending grief that inevitably follows such an unexpected loss. Thanks for your time. And for sharing your story, however brief with me. Always a pleasure to speak with someone who articulates his thoughts and feelings so well in such brief verse. (Unlike me lol). Strength and Honor.
Fan: What is one song that you're recently listening to? Jisoo: SHINee sunbaenim's 'You & I', the lyrics are very beautiful. It is a song that comforts you at the end of a tiring day ❤❤❤ She's right!
Key is SO GOOD! Sneaky bias-wreaker! I feel like he has really stood out in the "Story of Light" EPs. I can't help but think he is working hard for Jonghyun and the other members.
One of my favorite songs from the album. It was beautifully written. Key did an amazing job with the lyrics. When I hear this song I think of them saying goodbye to the brother that they have lost. I truly believe this was written for Jonghyun.
I'm not shinee fan. But one of my best friend is shawol. I can remember how she struggle as fan in those bad days. Even I still can't believe that happened. But anyway Shawols stay strong. As carat I wish you luck. This song brings back memories of SEVENTEEN's song smile flower. Lyrics are so painful but really really beautiful.
My bestfriend is also a shawol. She went on a long hiattus because of studies but when she went back to fangirling, thats the time the news about jonghyun came. She was so depressed that time and I can feel her pain too. Shes finally recovering now and keeps on supporting shinee. Fighting shawols, please stay together with the boys. Love from an ahgase. 💚
Kibum, my dear, you did justice! Bravo.... wow, the lyrics hit right at my heart. I felt the heartache... We as SHAWOLS go through pain with you all.. I personally still am grieving 😪😪😪😪😭😭😭😭
Does anyone understand these lines? "There are countless stars in my heart, there's one star that shines painfully. I don't want to grab it but I don't want it to go out." Does it mean... there are many people who he keeps in his heart/relationship he holds dearly, with the one that is painful being Jonghyun. He doesn't want to hold Jonghyun back from being in peace but yet he can't just let him go as well... I don't know, it just struck me really suddenly... thank you for the translation! We international shawols really appreciate this.
I am not a Shawol and got into K-pop after his passing. I actually found this song on a crack video, but I'm so glad I found it. The song makes me feel so close to him and I can feel Shinee's pain. I have been going through tough times and this song always helps to comfort me
Jonghyun ah, you listening? we still miss you hun! We always will and I've finally learnt that it's okay... it's okay to feel this way, when I laugh, when I smile, when I frown, and when I cry thinking of you and those precious and beautiful moments. It's not something try to forget or ignore or avoid, it's something we should treasure.
I love Good Evening but this is actually my favorite song on this new EP. Keybum, you really outdid yourself with this song. It’s so bittersweet and I can’t stop listening to it
I am really so touched by this song....KEYBUMMIE u have written a perfect MASTERPIECE......I LOVE IT TO D CORE❤❇❇.....it's tooo hard for my heart...I kinda feel tat he wrote dis remembering JONGHYUN in his mind...nd I some wat feel dis s for jonghyun......maybe I am wrong but tats wat I felt...I am kinda lyk so emotional listening to it😢
I cannot describe enough how much this song means to me. After 2 years im stil listening to it on REPEAT, i love it soo much. I listen to it when im happy, sad... it just brings me so much comfort for some reason. The lyrics are beautiful and the melody/instrumentals are chefs kis
when i watched the interview key said, they read the comment about knet bash them make a concert after jonghyun case in april if im not mistaken is for marketing, and they said that comment is really hurt .. then when i read again this lyrics.. for the whole song is not for jonghyun only.. its about themselves that knet bash.. you know what i mean right ?? im not good in english .. but seriously this song about themselve-bad comment-jonghyun case-concert in april ..... actually this song is so deep .. "my feelings arent for decoration " "i'll let you go easy,don't think that you're stepping on" and one lyric for shawol " i know that you're being honest when you wish me well"
Babywol here and when I heard this song, tears just flowed. Even though I haven't know them that too long, I felt the pain in the song. Emotions does transcend music. It's interesting too because whenever shawols comment they miss Jjong I couldn't empathize but when I heard this song made me feel how important he is in Shinee, not that I thought of him any less. Im actually watching Hello Baby, and I couldnt help how I wished I stan them early on when I was stanning suju at the time TT
it is difficult for us, that we did not know him in person, that we did not feel his breath on our skin and the sound of his heartbeats. It's damn complicated for us that we did not look in his eyes, that we did not smell his skin. I can not imagine how difficult it is for them, for his mother and for his sister. Life is unjust and turns difficult moments into tragedies. But I want to hope that there is a reason for all this, a very precise design, and that these four boys find a reason to accept all this immense, implacable and inexhaustible pain.
Honestly it feels really weird to listen to old shinee songs. When I hear jonghyuns voice it still feels like he’s alive, like the fact that’s he’s gone is really weird for me. It’s only when I listen to songs without him that it really sets in I guess.
now that i know key wrote this song and read the translation, i love this song even more now. the melody was already moving but knowing the lyrics, i will listen to this over and over with a fuller heart
I just heard this song today. Thank you for the upload with English Subtitles. To me it shows the whole world know how much they truly love and miss JONGHYUN 😔😔😔. This is IMO. Lovely, soft and soothing song. NICELY done. Thank you so much. 👏👏💝💝🌹🌹
I went here to listen to the song because of BP Jisoo, she's currently listening to this song, which according to her is a good song to listen after a tiring day. But after hearing this, it instantly strikes my heart. What a heartfelt song. I feel like I'm crying. 😞😞😞
The lyrics of this song really comes from his heart. We heard you, Kibum. We will do well to cheer you all up as we continue our lives. We’ll continually cherish the days that we had with jjong, but we’ll try our best to live like normal like you guys.
Amazing song really love it its so heart touching key saying bye hurt me so bad i really miss jonghyun oppa but i think its time to let go for his sake and ours we should help our member to stay strong and keep doing the best job this dosnt mean we forget our bling bling his olways in our heart like a shining star we will never forget you 😢😢😢😢
Am I the only one that gets the vibes of a sad melody in an Indian movie, from this song?? Especially the song 'kaise mujhe tum milgayi' from Gajini!! Any fellow Indian Shawols?? I dunno if it's the BGM, or their voices that give a soothing homely feeling? 😢 Even though the lyrics will haunt you, Even though the meanings those words take up in your imagination hurt you, Even though the melody sinks your heart to your feet, When you know that it's your only pain killer, you cannot avoid it. When you realize that it's your only drug, you'll want it more. This song is that drug. Why is it that I feel d need to listen to this every night, n ball my eyes out n fall asleep in tears?? 😫😫 I miss him.... Kibummie did such a wonderful job with the lyrics. And leave it to 5HINee to give life to words...
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
I am really sorry but I think I did wrong translation of second last line.. 😭😭I really wanted to do best for shinee fans.. 😫
Thank you for translating the song it’s my favorite of the album , lyrics are melancholic and soft
It's great enough! Thank U
Kreetika Omg its fine
Us shawols really appreciate the effort. Thank you for translating this beautiful song.
thank you so much for the video!!! can't express how thankful i am for a shawol like you 💕💓💞💝💘💖💗💕💓💞💝💖💘
"There are countless stars in my heart, there's one star that shines painfully. I don't want to grab it but I don't want it to go out."
This line really got to me. They don't want to talk about Jonghyun because it's too painful, but they're going to do it anyway because they want his legacy to live on and they want to make sure he isn't forgotten.
This whole period is so painful. There's a hole that Jjong left behind--it their presence, in their sound, in the way they interact with each other. I just . . . hurt so much for them. But I'm so proud of them for coming back so soon. I will always love them, and I'm supporting them now even though it's hard. We're all healing, and we will all make it through this. Right now, for me at least, it's time to cry, and to remember, and to love. 5hinee forever
ThatCrazyBookWyrm
This is the line that captured my eyes too
ThatCrazyBookWyrm 0
How do y'all know it's about Jjong
We don't know that this song is certainly about Jjong. But the lyrics drop so many hints:
- Like you mentioned, they don't want to talk about Jjong explicitly because it's too painful
- The way they single themselves out as (I) and the (You) is a star
- "I'm the only one hurting, thought I might seem fine"
- "There are countless stars in my heart. There's one star that shines painfully" (In Jjong's memorial clip for the GDA, he was told that he was the star that shined the brightest in the sky)
I personally think that the song holds strong references about Jjong, his suffering, and his painful way of saying goodbye
Yes if u base on the lyrics of their new songs it's pointed out one person and what are their true feelings towards him...if shawol is still hurting how much more with them 😭😭😭
Keep moving forward to all of you.jonghun oppa is still looking and proud for all you've done 🙏🏼🙏🏼and we sure he smile brightly above ...
A smile full of happiness a real smile for sure 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
Key singing ‘annyeong’ has me sobbing 😭
littlwnder woman saaame
The first is. And it’s beautiful. But the second “annyeong” verse is actually sung by Minho..I think this video got some of the vocal attributions wrong by accident !
“Goodbye to the love from my younger days,I’m letting you go bye bye bye” KEY
Baby Sali Is it what Im thinking? omg
Do you all think that “love from my younger days meaning that he was had relationship with one of shinee members?”
@MISSEL027 how did you know? Jongkey was real?
MISSELO27 no, we do not know. it was not a real romantic relationship. Love can be platonic,,, unless they clearly state we will not know please dont assume.
MISSELO27 either way, you should not assume. Key has not clearly stated "i was in a relationship with jonghyun" so please do not assume. Yes its possible but unless he says, dont say "bUt hE wAs"
This is such a beautiful song with beautifully written lyrics by Kibum! I can’t help but think of our Jonghyun when listening to this.♥️
Kpopfangirl Kee Same! When I first heard, i just knew I felt something related to Jonghyun.
When I hear this song I feel so sad because of jonghyun
jimin kookie it’s true! Jonghyun mentioned how he liked the word 안녕 so it’s not a coincidence that this is the songs title.
Caelstrom 😢 I miss Jjong too. I hope you’ll feel comforted by it some day.
Kpopfangirl Kee yes i think too
this song says so much... we all know they're still hurting inside, but they've gathered enough strength and courage to get through this comeback. we love you so much shinee ❤
i heard voice of jonghyun in taemin sometimes in onew ..
Especially in 2:53 until the end of the song..
Same 😣😣😣😣😣😣
"im letting you go bye bye bye" "even though my heart is aching" kibum really put thought into these lyrics ❤
I am a Blink and Jisoo recommended this song, and suddenly, i literally had goosebumps by their voices and lyrics of this song. There is so much emotions through it that it makes waver your heart. 😭❤❤❤❤
Omgg! Where can I watch the video??
@jennyCoverLyrics That has meanings behind these words and Key from shinee who had wrote that song
안녕- hello/goodbye jonghyun’s favourite word as it has opposite meanings.
well now i’m crying
This song NEVER get's easier to listen to
this is such a well written song
I don't know why but this feels so heartbreaking in a beautiful way. Thank you Jisoo for introducing me to Shinee💞
How could someone dislike this song ??? This is truly a gem . Such a soulful song kimbum nailed it
This song wrecked me. I think it is about him letting go of Jonghyun. The pain is palpable.
It's about letting go or being paralyzed by the pain permanently. It's a choice you have to make if your going to have any life at all. Unfortunately I know exactly what their feeling and experiencing due to something that occurred in my own life not to long ago. Which I won't discuss here because as they said so aptly, "My feelings are not for display." But their is a terrible sense of doing something wrong, and of guilt for letting them go. Like your deserting them out of selfishness not necessity. Until you understand the difference between abandoning someone.....and setting them free. And I am still baffled at how someone who, for all intents and purposes is in essence a stranger to my life, could have so deep and devastating an affect on it. I am 5 months later still heart broken. And I fear I will stay this way for a very long time to come. Until I'm strong enough to set myself free. Which for now.....I'm not. Strength and Honor.
Christo Benno I can relate and I think I understand what you're saying. Jonghyun wasn't even my favorite member of SHINee but his vocal power in the group, general incredible character and influence is undeniable. I wish Korean fans and by extension Korean society would be a little more accommodating and forgiving of a person's personal struggles. I feel like especially celebrities have to always project an image of pure model behavior which really is inhuman. This is true in many countries but especially Korea even has dedicated antifans. I too am deeply affected by his sudden passing like you even now. I cannot even look at his face without tearing up, that such a beautiful soul decided to leave rather than having the conditions needed in order to truly be happy and thrive. This whole time I've thought if only he didn't feel he had to hide himself.
Truly well said. And your right , Korea has the horrible distinction of being #1 in suicide. How terrible that when my daughter called me at work to tell me the sad news my first reaction was "Honey are you sure you don't mean Onew?" The way he was treated after his unfortunate go around was truly sickening. I've been clean and sober for 38 years,( and I'm dating myself here lol), and the poor guy has to APOLOGIZE for having a drinking problem. My God I shudder when I remember the things I did when I drank. All he did was stagger around blind drunk and grab somebodies leg in a drunken stupor. Then they are accused of trying to make a buck off his death because they did a concert? When a large part of the reason was to give the FANS a chance to grieve with them. A friend of mine once told me " No matter how often you see sick, it's still stunning." He was right. I can't tell you how many times I've thought "I wish I would of had just 10 minutes alone with that kid to talk to him, and more importantly, to listen. Everyone needs someone to listen to their story, and to HEAR what their saying. Not just right it off with "Just hang tough you'll be fine." Really? Maybe not, maybe you won't be. Maybe you'll be so deep into yourself, so consumed by the pain and the darkness, that the only way out is from the outside. For someone to care enough to reach in and offer you their hand and a way back to the light. Unfortunately for him, and for all of us, that didn't happen. We all lost, most off all him. He's gone now, forever. And we all must find our own way in which to absorb this shocking and terrible loss, and to address the attending grief that inevitably follows such an unexpected loss. Thanks for your time. And for sharing your story, however brief with me. Always a pleasure to speak with someone who articulates his thoughts and feelings so well in such brief verse. (Unlike me lol). Strength and Honor.
Fan: What is one song that you're recently listening to?
Jisoo: SHINee sunbaenim's 'You & I', the lyrics are very beautiful. It is a song that comforts you at the end of a tiring day
❤❤❤ She's right!
Key is SO GOOD! Sneaky bias-wreaker! I feel like he has really stood out in the "Story of Light" EPs. I can't help but think he is working hard for Jonghyun and the other members.
The meaning of this is song really making me speechless.
Kibum you rlly are a genius
It's so good
I'll listen it forever thank you for the hard working I love you
One of my favorite songs from the album. It was beautifully written. Key did an amazing job with the lyrics. When I hear this song I think of them saying goodbye to the brother that they have lost. I truly believe this was written for Jonghyun.
Onew always sings so good but he took his awesomeness to the next level in this song
We had no time to say goodbye but this song is for you our shining star. We miss you.
@Liza Johnson ik this was a 1year ago but jonghyun
I'm not shinee fan. But one of my best friend is shawol. I can remember how she struggle as fan in those bad days. Even I still can't believe that happened. But anyway Shawols stay strong. As carat I wish you luck. This song brings back memories of SEVENTEEN's song smile flower. Lyrics are so painful but really really beautiful.
I'm a Shawol and Carat and thanks for your comment!!!
My bestfriend is also a shawol. She went on a long hiattus because of studies but when she went back to fangirling, thats the time the news about jonghyun came. She was so depressed that time and I can feel her pain too. Shes finally recovering now and keeps on supporting shinee. Fighting shawols, please stay together with the boys. Love from an ahgase. 💚
I'm Shawol and Carat and yes Smile Flower is beautiful too and thanks
아플땐 아프다 말하고 모든이에게 같은맘을 기대하면 상처만 깊어져 내게 다가오는 감정들이 혼란들이 시간이 해결해 주리라는걸 믿고 용기를 내봐야지 내일은 오늘 같지 않음을 기다려보며 하루 하루를 견딜뿐 ....기억되는것 만이라도 소중하게 품어야해
Wow. Taemin's part at 1:11....I actually thought it was Jonghyun for a second...
Youngjae's Eyesmile yes i though too
Youngjae's Eyesmile Yes Taemin kinda sounds like him there
Same
Same and I felt it so much at 1: 19
Kibum, my dear, you did justice! Bravo.... wow, the lyrics hit right at my heart. I felt the heartache... We as SHAWOLS go through pain with you all.. I personally still am grieving 😪😪😪😪😭😭😭😭
Does anyone understand these lines? "There are countless stars in my heart, there's one star that shines painfully. I don't want to grab it but I don't want it to go out." Does it mean... there are many people who he keeps in his heart/relationship he holds dearly, with the one that is painful being Jonghyun. He doesn't want to hold Jonghyun back from being in peace but yet he can't just let him go as well... I don't know, it just struck me really suddenly... thank you for the translation! We international shawols really appreciate this.
Kibum 💕💕💕 this is such a wonderful song. The melody, your voices, the lyrics 💕💕💕 We love you Kibum 💕 And we will always love Shinee 💕💕💕
I am not a Shawol and got into K-pop after his passing. I actually found this song on a crack video, but I'm so glad I found it. The song makes me feel so close to him and I can feel Shinee's pain. I have been going through tough times and this song always helps to comfort me
Jonghyun ah, you listening? we still miss you hun! We always will and I've finally learnt that it's okay... it's okay to feel this way, when I laugh, when I smile, when I frown, and when I cry thinking of you and those precious and beautiful moments. It's not something try to forget or ignore or avoid, it's something we should treasure.
"you & I" : reference to "U&I" by jonghyun.
"Annyeong, annyeong" : reference to "elevator" by jonghyun.
It's definitely about jonghyun.
I love Good Evening but this is actually my favorite song on this new EP. Keybum, you really outdid yourself with this song. It’s so bittersweet and I can’t stop listening to it
I am really so touched by this song....KEYBUMMIE u have written a perfect MASTERPIECE......I LOVE IT TO D CORE❤❇❇.....it's tooo hard for my heart...I kinda feel tat he wrote dis remembering JONGHYUN in his mind...nd I some wat feel dis s for jonghyun......maybe I am wrong but tats wat I felt...I am kinda lyk so emotional listening to it😢
Me too
safiya 100M for RDD and LUCIFER literally fills me up with emotions of sadness immediately
I cannot describe enough how much this song means to me. After 2 years im stil listening to it on REPEAT, i love it soo much. I listen to it when im happy, sad... it just brings me so much comfort for some reason. The lyrics are beautiful and the melody/instrumentals are chefs kis
So beautiful! This makes me realise SHINee is a genre in itself! ❤️
I cried reading the translation... It's beautiful and painful at the same time.
The song is so beautiful but I can’t help but be upset listening to it
Goodbye my love from younger days~ I’m letting you go-Key Jongkey forever ❤️
Idk why my eyes are crying right now~ You did a great job Bummie~ stay strong...thanks for uploading this video! You are amazing!
when i watched the interview key said, they read the comment about knet bash them make a concert after jonghyun case in april if im not mistaken is for marketing, and they said that comment is really hurt .. then when i read again this lyrics.. for the whole song is not for jonghyun only.. its about themselves that knet bash.. you know what i mean right ?? im not good in english .. but seriously this song about themselve-bad comment-jonghyun case-concert in april ..... actually this song is so deep .. "my feelings arent for decoration " "i'll let you go easy,don't think that you're stepping on" and one lyric for shawol " i know that you're being honest when you wish me well"
Babywol here and when I heard this song, tears just flowed. Even though I haven't know them that too long, I felt the pain in the song. Emotions does transcend music. It's interesting too because whenever shawols comment they miss Jjong I couldn't empathize but when I heard this song made me feel how important he is in Shinee, not that I thought of him any less. Im actually watching Hello Baby, and I couldnt help how I wished I stan them early on when I was stanning suju at the time TT
Let me give you a hug! 🥺❤️
OMG Jisoo has a nice taste
this song is heaven
im kindly have a peace in my heart 😍😫
it is difficult for us, that we did not know him in person, that we did not feel his breath on our skin and the sound of his heartbeats. It's damn complicated for us that we did not look in his eyes, that we did not smell his skin. I can not imagine how difficult it is for them, for his mother and for his sister. Life is unjust and turns difficult moments into tragedies. But I want to hope that there is a reason for all this, a very precise design, and that these four boys find a reason to accept all this immense, implacable and inexhaustible pain.
샤이니 노래는 아무도 못따라간다 ㅠㅠ💞
Amazing song, beautiful voices. I lov ONEW VOICE♡♡♡. SHINEE ♡♡♡ LOV YOU. I LOVE it
this song is so beautiful that makes me cry
너무 좋다..샤이니 댄스음악도 발라드도 최고야..
Honestly it feels really weird to listen to old shinee songs. When I hear jonghyuns voice it still feels like he’s alive, like the fact that’s he’s gone is really weird for me. It’s only when I listen to songs without him that it really sets in I guess.
I like their voices. They warm and soothe. After this song Ken's voice started to like me even more. I did not notice this before.
Kibum's voice omg>>>>>>>>
this song gives me chills
bangtan life It makes me cry...
i know right. it reminds me of jonghyun.
I love the lyrics to this, one of my fav songs on the album thanks for the translations 💛
Their harmonization at the end is so beautiful ...
"My feelings are not for decoration" my favorite line
If hoshi recommends this then i must listen. THIS IS AMAZING
I just sat on my phone and this accidentally played. Now it's my favorite song 😁
now that i know key wrote this song and read the translation, i love this song even more now. the melody was already moving but knowing the lyrics, i will listen to this over and over with a fuller heart
I just heard this song today. Thank you for the upload with English Subtitles.
To me it shows the whole world know how much they truly love and miss JONGHYUN 😔😔😔. This is IMO. Lovely, soft and soothing song. NICELY done. Thank you so much. 👏👏💝💝🌹🌹
Love the lyrics and the way they sing it.....so calm and lovely
i am so hurt but shinee never fail t amazed me my 5hinee love you
I went here to listen to the song because of BP Jisoo, she's currently listening to this song, which according to her is a good song to listen after a tiring day. But after hearing this, it instantly strikes my heart. What a heartfelt song. I feel like I'm crying. 😞😞😞
OMG me Too 😂😂
Thank you for this translation! This song is heartbreakingly beautiful.
💎💎💎💎💎
This beautiful perfect song will be more great within our angel voice.. miss you so much jjong 😭😭😭
Onew voice amazing♡ good ㅜㅜ
Woooww shinee mind blowing outstanding beautiful lovely song 🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭❤️❤️❤️❤️
“There are countless starts in my heart, there’s one star that shines painfully”
ok bye T-T
이노래 들으니까 종현이 생각난다...영원히 5HINee. 종현아 많이 보고 싶다. 그곳에서 편히 푹 쉬고... 수고했어. 사랑해.
1:34 아프게 빛나는 나란 별 하나 가 아니라 아프게 빛난 너란 별 입니다.
그리고 2:13 에는 아프지 않은건 너야 괜찮아 보이겠지만
"There are countless stars on my heart, there's ONE STAR that shines painfully"
I cried TT thank you for translating
thank you so much for the lyrics 💗 it must've been difficult, it was quite emotional for me .
원래 5명이였던 자리가 4명으로 줄었다고 느껴지니까 진짜 울컥하다.. 이 노래도 뭔가 그 아이를 생각하며 부른 게 느껴지는 데.. 진짜 울컥하다.. 미안해, 진작 몰라줘서.. 알아줬으면 그나마 조금 1%라도 희망이 있었겠지..? 미안해.. 그리고 행복해..
The lyrics of this song really comes from his heart. We heard you, Kibum. We will do well to cheer you all up as we continue our lives. We’ll continually cherish the days that we had with jjong, but we’ll try our best to live like normal like you guys.
this songs takes alot of me
"My feelings aren't for decoration"
진짜...노래 너무 좋아.....ㅠㅜㅠㅜㅠㅜ
Fighting my babies I'm always here for all of u
its a really pretty song that keeps me coming back but end up crying
As a Minho stan I am satisfied by the amount of times I hear his voice in this song
this song has made my cry every time i’ve heard it
My favorite song on the album ♥️ Love you SHINee world ♥️
This song made me cry. I couldn’t even listen to it whole because i wanted to stop crying. The story behind this song is too sad to not cry tbh
i don't think anyone can..especially not the first few times you hear it
Gosh, this song is so beautiful. It makes you feel so emotional even if you don't understand what's the song about. Love it very much. 👍
아프지 않은건 너야. 아프지 않았으면 하는건 내 바람이야. 괜찮아 보이겠지만, 나는 쉽지 않아. 아프게 빛나는 너란 별, 잡고싶지는 않지만 꺼지길 바라지 않아. 내 맘이 아려도 편히 널 보내줄게, 우릴 밟고 간단 생각 마. 이제는 보내 안녕:)
This song is so so so so good !
샤이니노래는 언제나. 최고야
okay kibum loved jjong
they all loved eachother so much
MISSELO27 thats true
MISSELO27 how do you know that? I’m not being a crazy fan or smt. I’m curious
@@NAU442 omg now I’m crying
오늘 눈 오는데 이 노래 들으니 너무 좋다 사랑해 샤이니
Such a beautiful song ♡
Amazing song really love it its so heart touching key saying bye hurt me so bad i really miss jonghyun oppa but i think its time to let go for his sake and ours we should help our member to stay strong and keep doing the best job this dosnt mean we forget our bling bling his olways in our heart like a shining star we will never forget you 😢😢😢😢
Oh my god the lyrics.... im getting emotional 😢💔
•.•.•.•.•.•.•.•.•.•.•.•.•.•.•.•.•.•.•.•.•.•.•.•.•.•
「Edit: thanks for this video ♥️」
The LYRICS THEIR VOICES Hits Straight to my Heart
jinki oppa💕you sing very well
This song makes my heart cry...
Am I the only one that gets the vibes of a sad melody in an Indian movie, from this song?? Especially the song 'kaise mujhe tum milgayi' from Gajini!! Any fellow Indian Shawols??
I dunno if it's the BGM, or their voices that give a soothing homely feeling? 😢
Even though the lyrics will haunt you,
Even though the meanings those words take up in your imagination hurt you,
Even though the melody sinks your heart to your feet,
When you know that it's your only pain killer, you cannot avoid it.
When you realize that it's your only drug, you'll want it more.
This song is that drug. Why is it that I feel d need to listen to this every night, n ball my eyes out n fall asleep in tears?? 😫😫
I miss him....
Kibummie did such a wonderful job with the lyrics. And leave it to 5HINee to give life to words...
I'm a indian shawol
The meaning behind this song is so sad..shinee forever..
I fell in love with lyrics of this song.
1:10 Gosh Taemin sounds just like Jjong ❤️such a beautiful song for him. Absolutely pure
진짜 이 노래가 내 최애곡임.....ㅠ
1:55 when I first heard this part I fell in love. What a beautiful song Kibum