people really need to understand that shinee's line up was insane. Key and Taemin were not even in the vocal line and they are better than literally EVERY and I mean EVERY main male vocalist outside of exo. Minho could be an extraordinary lead vocalist in jyp or yg. the notes that key supported and hitted in this performance are literally insane especially for a male vocalist. and I am not even going to start with jinki and jjong because we will be here until the morning. Shinee remains undoubtedly the only male kpop group I can think of that all of their members have the ability to sing
@@camswu I was about to comment this, I’m a Cassiopeia and Shawol, and I completely agree that all of the members of DBSK (as 5) and SHINee can sing VERY GOOD. Also, all of them are SOLOISTS.
this is a live performance who uses so little backtrack and we can really hear their naked voices and they nailed. no wonder why Lee Soo Man is so confident to debut SHINee cause they can rock the stage with bare voices and talent.
I don't think I'll ever see another K-Pop song that is this huge and sweeping and yet so controlled (in choreography and vocal performance!). A song like this could so easily become a clusterfuck. With the tight turns and poses in the choreography so the way they coordinate their voices in the chorus. One wrong move could screw everything here up but Shinee is in control every second of this song. They know exactly what they're doing and what everyone else is doing as well. This is teamwork. This is what K-Pop should be all the time
@@ygstan8143 It's real ;-) He said he loved to trick people into mistaking him for a girl only to cough immediately after and watch their confused faces :D
Jjong's high notes and grunts though ♥ and his arms *drools* anyway, SHINee never disappointed me with their live performances. Most groups, when performing live, their voice isn't this strong and powerful. But SHINee, despite the tiring choreography, they still perform excellently. Vocals and choreo on point. The singers can dance, and the dancers can sing. Bruh, I'm proud to be a Shawol. I just wish that they will have more fans. SHINee fighting!
@@ihsan2837 no he didnt... no SM artist 'trained' another SM artist. They were trained by yoo young jin and other external coaches. Sure he might have helped with some cord connection and worked with him occasionally but he certainly did not train him himself and chen was already at a pretty high level when he came to sm. Same goes for him training Taemin, he did not. Onew and him gave Taemin pointers, but you can't call that "Training" someoen
This ladies and gentlemen is the standard for kpop. You can head Taemin going a bit off key in one like so it’s defo live. Everyone should aspire to perform like this.
No one can beat SHINee power and amazing live vocals like every member are amazing. Their dance is super hard and exhausting (believe me I used to dance to their songs and when I sang the song I sounded like sh*t). They are so amazing!!!
I loooove their outfits! Can we just take a moment to really look at each of them and appreciate them: Jonghyun is wearing colorful patterned top AND pants. Military boots. vest. and a freaking cleopatra necklace or whatever. and an extra necklace under it which is gold. Minho is wearing a big poofy shirt. a vest with a big sparkly thing on the front that looks like a necklace. there is some shoulder stuff going on. Is that latex? pluss an actual sparkly necklace with crystals. Taemin is wearing a sparkly tassel vest made out of plastic? his top has a chiffon trail at the back. and his PANTS wow they have like holes in the sides all the way up. and of course he is wearing like three necklaces. long hair and some of it is up in a little bun. Key is wearing a dress shirt with a vest with pattern in sequin or glitter in all kinds of colours. gold spike tooth necklace. and omg is he wearing a broach? yeah he is wearing a huge bejeweled scorpio broach! His hair long blonde bangs and green on the side under. and oh do I see nailpolish? Shorts adorned with silver channel logos? with tights underneath. Onew is wearing freaking ecstasy or acid nyon colored shirt. Vest with holes on the sides and a trail on the back. Some rope necklace or whtever that is and dangly red and gold necklace. looks like he also has a broach. on his shoulder. omg its a bird. he has a bird on his shoulder XD or is it a squirrel? Idk it's just as funny XD long swoopy hair to the side and the most harem harem pants ever. Amazing
yall heard Jonghyun? ma boi really said "this is live bish" ! They were dancing with all their might and yall gotta peep Jinki too. He was flipping his hair everywhere lmaoo
I wish I was a shawol during these times but I was too young 😭💟 I was a baby when they debuted with replay, but at least I can appreciate them now :) ✨
I got to know them since 2018 but damn when I started to explore them more and more gosh I was blown away They were sooo sooo ahead in time They are beyond kpop or any tag And they still maintain that standard Shinee=YOU CAN'T COMPARE/YOU CAN'T COMPETE WITH
This will always be my favorite song from them 🙏❤️ Thank you Jonghyun for these wonderful years with you ❤️ You will always be in Shawol's heart ❤️ May Rest In Peace 😔🙏❤️
I thought my bias would be taemin but when I got into them more, I realized I really like the other members too and I can't pick one now, so I guess I'm ot5 biased!
This makes my heart so full I have seen this so many times and I keep screaming and hyping them up even though they can’t hear me they just bring me so much happiness I’m so grateful for them
They were way ahead of time. No hate to anyone but couldn't help saying it Shinee faced something so huge and even after that they came back very strongly and they never used it as an excuse to be successful The kpop industry scenario might have changed or the criteria of everything might have changed but im proud of them for always trying to come back and always staying away from trashy race I respect them so much for being the same legendary shinee And yes i feel bad that they don't get the recognition and success they deserve but no matter what I will always be a shawol even I'm the last shawol in the universe and I will always wish for their happiness and success They are the best 👌 Their work shows it And there're a difference in art and trend and shinee represents that till today Also I feel shinee is not just kpop anymore I mean they are really unique and maybe that's why they are not so much hyped up like the trending ones I mean I have never found a single shinee song which would be just a trendy generic one All their albums are art They are not like the ones to follow stereotypes They are actually the most talented, consistent and unique artists not only in the kpop industry but in the whole world No matter what at the end of the day..I always find my way back to them... They are the ones I listen to when I'm cooking, walking, sleeping... They hit different
May Taemin's long hair never EVER come back. That said, I recently fell in love with this song even though I've always known it existed by wow this live was so amazing. They're such strong live singers it's insane.
Mariam Issa Yeah he said that on multiple occasions. But the main reason I hated it was because the extensions were so poorly done. You could see the natural curve of his actual hair and then it strangely transitioned to the bone straight hair. It wasn't uniform most of the time and it was just so bad. And it didn't flatter him.
I miss those REAL LIVE on music bank and ingikaeo that 2nd Gen did... There was camera and technic rehearsal but idols, at that time, always perform live.
Shinee is king of pop korea..for shinee be strong without jonghyun..r.i.p to jonghyun oppa.ur we angel..ur voice is so beautiful & vocal is vry powerfull..go shinee go..
Man, Sherlock still gives me feels man.... Has to be my favorite era. I was freaking spazzing!! Lawd knows I do not spazz, but Sherlock does it every time!!!
oh my gosh.. all of shinee's songs have difficult choreography.. i mean, who can sing while dancing to this?? you can see how fired up they are while performing. You can see them catching their breath. I love SHINEE!!! 💗💗💗
This is the type of Performance and Song that will never Get OLD I could srsly listen to it a million times and never get bored of the Most incredible Choreo Made in Kpop dance It's Brilliant and SHINee Executes it With Perfection Every Stage every time!!! That's Sheer Excellence That's SHINEE 🙌🏻 💋😍🎵🔥💎
Noone could catch the Shinee about live performance and talent but nowadays k.a.r.d is also good at live. Love shinee forever (my first favourite kpop band)
it's crazy they are able to sing ANYTHING with this coreography. it just goes to show how good they are. forever my favouite band ♥ i am so proud of them all.
Back here in 2020 watching this and OMG, I had forgotten that Taemin had long hair here.. i thought it was only during the Lucifer era haha.. he looks so different here with the last of his more girly image & sleeveless shirts.. Wish he would dress up like that again just for fun:)
I vividly remember watching this performance on a live stream when it was airing - it was such a momentous song and time, it just blew me away and I remember everyone being in awe. 5HINee forever
![[SUB] The first ever ⟪HARD⟫ performance by SHINee on TV as a whole #SHINEE](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6RycjP37IW8/mqdefault.jpg)
![[SUB] The first ever ⟪HARD⟫ performance by SHINee on TV as a whole #SHINEE](/img/tr.png)
![[4K/공간음향] 샤이니 - 셜록, HARD, Lucifer, 링딩동 (현장중계 풀버전) / SHINEE](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bKn-CVh7D2o/mqdefault.jpg)
people really need to understand that shinee's line up was insane. Key and Taemin were not even in the vocal line and they are better than literally EVERY and I mean EVERY main male vocalist outside of exo. Minho could be an extraordinary lead vocalist in jyp or yg. the notes that key supported and hitted in this performance are literally insane especially for a male vocalist. and I am not even going to start with jinki and jjong because we will be here until the morning. Shinee remains undoubtedly the only male kpop group I can think of that all of their members have the ability to sing
go watch DBSK sing acapella, they are old but they were good
@@camswu I was about to comment this, I’m a Cassiopeia and Shawol, and I completely agree that all of the members of DBSK (as 5) and SHINee can sing VERY GOOD. Also, all of them are SOLOISTS.
cuz SM, despite how horribly they treat their idols, actually gives a shit about vocal training.
Although they’re not as Popular I think Bap’s Vocalists Daehyon and Youngjae are very slept on
Jinhwhan from Ikon too is just as good
Go watch Han Jisung with Felix and Hyunjin "As I Told You l 2022 KBS Song Festival Ep 3"
this is a live performance who uses so little backtrack and we can really hear their naked voices and they nailed. no wonder why Lee Soo Man is so confident to debut SHINee cause they can rock the stage with bare voices and talent.
I don't think I'll ever see another K-Pop song that is this huge and sweeping and yet so controlled (in choreography and vocal performance!). A song like this could so easily become a clusterfuck. With the tight turns and poses in the choreography so the way they coordinate their voices in the chorus. One wrong move could screw everything here up but Shinee is in control every second of this song. They know exactly what they're doing and what everyone else is doing as well. This is teamwork. This is what K-Pop should be all the time
SHINee also said this is the era where the strong teamwork started
They literally look like 5 fingers in one hand
SHINee IS Kpop!
Shinee standard
i agree with you 100%
Every single time I see Jonghyun arms in this live I die srsly ;-;
OMFG DONT EVEN GET ME STARTED. I'm literally dead right now. And his growl towards the end. This was way too much for me.
Isaac Grenore samer here 😂😥❤
Very hot!
It’s his 30th birthday today. That’s crazy
me too and i dont even like men lmao
2024 still it's a Shinee world ❤
저만 계속보는거 아닐텐데 한국인 있나요?
셜록은 진짜 레전드곡 이예요
Am i the only one who came back here just to see Taemin's long hair again? 😂😂😂
angelrayne121 and his leg too
angelrayne121 its that real hair or wig ?
@@ygstan8143 It's real ;-)
He said he loved to trick people into mistaking him for a girl only to cough immediately after and watch their confused faces :D
@@ygstan8143 it's extensions
2020...i still love this craziness called my ult kpop band SHINee!
Jjong's high notes and grunts though ♥ and his arms *drools*
anyway, SHINee never disappointed me with their live performances. Most groups, when performing live, their voice isn't this strong and powerful. But SHINee, despite the tiring choreography, they still perform excellently. Vocals and choreo on point. The singers can dance, and the dancers can sing. Bruh, I'm proud to be a Shawol. I just wish that they will have more fans. SHINee fighting!
Minho: SHINee's back... SHINee's back... SHINee back... PACK PACK PACK PACK PACK!
theres no other group like shinee
they are legends forreal
Jonghyun is so good at singing. He is definitely ranked as one of the best Kpop singers, along with Chen and Kyuhyun
And taeyeon. Jonghyun trained Chen btw
@@ihsan2837 no he didnt... no SM artist 'trained' another SM artist. They were trained by yoo young jin and other external coaches. Sure he might have helped with some cord connection and worked with him occasionally but he certainly did not train him himself and chen was already at a pretty high level when he came to sm. Same goes for him training Taemin, he did not. Onew and him gave Taemin pointers, but you can't call that "Training" someoen
let’s appreciate jonghyuns, and honestly everyone’s ability to sing so well with this kind of choreo
셜록은 아이돌 역사상 레전드 곡
3:38
them: spread their legs
camera_ DRAMATICALLY ZOOMS IN ON THEIR CROTCHES
어째서 한국인이 없는겁니까?
띵곡인데 거기다가 안무까지 겁나 간지
2020년 5월 보고갑니다.
This ladies and gentlemen is the standard for kpop. You can head Taemin going a bit off key in one like so it’s defo live. Everyone should aspire to perform like this.
Taemin's long hair and style. He killed it. Total star.
Wow. Jonghyun really got muscles. I've seen him when he didn't have muscles and I see him in this performance. He looks WOW!
No one can beat SHINee power and amazing live vocals like every member are amazing. Their dance is super hard and exhausting (believe me I used to dance to their songs and when I sang the song I sounded like sh*t). They are so amazing!!!
Shinee vocals no joke the mics are ON
They're indeed the king of live performance. With that tight choreo, they can sing stable with soo little backtrack!
I loooove their outfits! Can we just take a moment to really look at each of them and appreciate them:
Jonghyun is wearing colorful patterned top AND pants. Military boots. vest. and a freaking cleopatra necklace or whatever. and an extra necklace under it which is gold.
Minho is wearing a big poofy shirt. a vest with a big sparkly thing on the front that looks like a necklace. there is some shoulder stuff going on. Is that latex? pluss an actual sparkly necklace with crystals.
Taemin is wearing a sparkly tassel vest made out of plastic? his top has a chiffon trail at the back. and his PANTS wow they have like holes in the sides all the way up. and of course he is wearing like three necklaces. long hair and some of it is up in a little bun.
Key is wearing a dress shirt with a vest with pattern in sequin or glitter in all kinds of colours. gold spike tooth necklace. and omg is he wearing a broach? yeah he is wearing a huge bejeweled scorpio broach! His hair long blonde bangs and green on the side under. and oh do I see nailpolish? Shorts adorned with silver channel logos? with tights underneath.
Onew is wearing freaking ecstasy or acid nyon colored shirt. Vest with holes on the sides and a trail on the back. Some rope necklace or whtever that is and dangly red and gold necklace. looks like he also has a broach. on his shoulder. omg its a bird. he has a bird on his shoulder XD or is it a squirrel? Idk it's just as funny XD long swoopy hair to the side and the most harem harem pants ever.
Amazing
I love their outfits...its out of d world yet very attractive...they pull it off really well!
라이브 퍼포먼스 와 지금보니 정말 대단하다ㄷㄷ
you did well, jonghyun.
I don't see a lot of people talking about Jinki's hairstyle like why??????? He looks so good 😩😩😩😩
Don't know group but the long hair I like I grew up in 60s -70- long hair was a big thing also lime the rock groups ♡♡♡ memories
2016 and I still listen SOY UN DORITO at 2:03
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA OH MY GOD I CAN LISTEN TO IT TOO XD
Raiza Gonçalves Same in 2017 😂
WAT DOES IT MEAN IN ENGLISH?
TheTableCloth FromTheEXOMonsterMV it means I am a Dorito
2020 it still sounds like that to me
yall heard Jonghyun? ma boi really said "this is live bish" ! They were dancing with all their might and yall gotta peep Jinki too. He was flipping his hair everywhere lmaoo
24년 7월에 보고 갑니다
놀뭐에 나와서 예전 무대도 보고가요😂
I wish I was a shawol during these times but I was too young 😭💟 I was a baby when they debuted with replay, but at least I can appreciate them now :) ✨
I miss Jong's angelic high note and his spirit and dedication I miss everything about him why did he have to go so soon 😭😭💛
I got to know them since 2018 but damn when I started to explore them more and more gosh I was blown away
They were sooo sooo ahead in time
They are beyond kpop or any tag
And they still maintain that standard
Shinee=YOU CAN'T COMPARE/YOU CAN'T COMPETE WITH
라이브 진짜... 미쳤다
@@petrucciful Live
@@petrucciful Live
@@a_dot_in_space Live
I'm amazed with SM's maknae at that time. They're extremely talented. Kyuhyun,Henry,Seohyun,Krystal,Taemin. Maknae domination😂
2023❤ I love Onew’s hairstyle
진기 머리랑 의상 너무 잘어울린다ㅠㅠ
I always come back to this video because of Jjong's arms...
I feel like shinee just doesn't get enough credit for this one and evil
i'm shock nobody's talking about taemin's pants.
dude, i was gonna talk 'bout it, seriously tho xD
I'll talk !! They're awesome 😍 looks like teen anime bad boy .....in the making
This will always be my favorite song from them 🙏❤️
Thank you Jonghyun for these wonderful years with you ❤️ You will always be in Shawol's heart ❤️ May Rest In Peace 😔🙏❤️
DUDE 1:59
STOP
WE CAN'T BREATHE JONGHYUN!
와 완전 라이브..대단하네
who else loved taemin rocking long hair? :3
i miss his long hair.
Koo Kai Yeah it really suited him!
I'm in love with this hair style 💕
Kaiden McNulty seriously ME 😘👍
Always.long hair taemin was🔥🔥🔥
I love how the oppas show their backs every single time Minho says "Shinee's Back!". #amazing #rockingit 😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁
I love taemin with long hair I wish it came back☺😊😀😁☺😀☺😊😀☺😍😍😍😍😍
omg Taemin's looking so awesome with dem long hair
how can they sing and dance dynamically at the same time?
why do they sound so amazing live
this is such an intense choreography yet they are so incredibly stable especially jonghyun.
their vocals really were IT and like idk they rlly just still are better than most artists
저춤을. 추면서 라이브를 겁나잘하면서 대존잘
SHINee made this song with their performances. Remember being blown away by their live performances
I thought my bias would be taemin but when I got into them more, I realized I really like the other members too and I can't pick one now, so I guess I'm ot5 biased!
옛날엔 셜록 옷 느낌이 그냥 대충 서구쪽? 느낌이겠거니 하고 봤는데 지금 보니까 묘하게 보헤미안 스타일? 느낌이 있네
...무슨 조합이짘ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
this performance and song are so insanely good
This makes my heart so full I have seen this so many times and I keep screaming and hyping them up even though they can’t hear me they just bring me so much happiness I’m so grateful for them
3:00 did anyone else heard jjong??
yes 😂😂
i was like
"JJong, staph pls, we all know that your voice is awesome" 😂😂
I live for this Jinki
다 잘하는데 진짜 종현이는 목이 터져라 부르는구나..
love to hear the fans cheering their name follow their step
babyikonic melodyelf Shawol fan chant is always amazing. Each time I hear them, I tear up a little. Lol
Taemin is fucking gorgeous. Amen.
요즘 아이돌들 보고 배워라 진짜.,,,,소속사도....... 열심히 연습해서 데뷔한 애들을 왜 립싱크를 시키는 거지ㅋㅋ.. 가수가 노래부르는 것보다 퍼포먼스가 더 중요한가 ㅋㅋ.....아,,이건 샤이니라서 가능한 건가,, 레전드
Jonghyun's biceps got me distracted. I can hear everyone singing live and on point. I need to rewatch the performance and focus. Hahaha!
came back to clean my ears please never allow anyone to sing any shinee songs outside of shinee
와 이걸 라이브로 하네 다시봐도 대단
Esta canción es tan difícil vocalmente hablando y aún la estabilidad es sorprendente y Kibum, estoy sin palabras. Todos reyes.
They were way ahead of time.
No hate to anyone but couldn't help saying it
Shinee faced something so huge and even after that they came back very strongly and they never used it as an excuse to be successful
The kpop industry scenario might have changed or the criteria of everything might have changed but im proud of them for always trying to come back and always staying away from trashy race
I respect them so much for being the same legendary shinee
And yes i feel bad that they don't get the recognition and success they deserve but no matter what I will always be a shawol even I'm the last shawol in the universe and I will always wish for their happiness and success
They are the best 👌
Their work shows it
And there're a difference in art and trend and shinee represents that till today
Also I feel shinee is not just kpop anymore
I mean they are really unique and maybe that's why they are not so much hyped up like the trending ones
I mean I have never found a single shinee song which would be just a trendy generic one
All their albums are art They are not like the ones to follow stereotypes
They are actually the most talented, consistent and unique artists not only in the kpop industry but in the whole world
No matter what at the end of the day..I always find my way back to them...
They are the ones I listen to when I'm cooking, walking, sleeping...
They hit different
Holy fuc how are they singing this live while dancing like THAT?! I could barely talk while walking sometimes HAHHAHAHAHAH
May Taemin's long hair never EVER come back. That said, I recently fell in love with this song even though I've always known it existed by wow this live was so amazing. They're such strong live singers it's insane.
same I wish it comes back cuz tbh his new hair look sucks
Mariam Issa Never again. No no no. No Sherlock hair ever ever again. XD
Why? People are saying that he hated to be compared with girls that's why he cut his hair I think that's true Ashley Collier
Mariam Issa Yeah he said that on multiple occasions. But the main reason I hated it was because the extensions were so poorly done. You could see the natural curve of his actual hair and then it strangely transitioned to the bone straight hair. It wasn't uniform most of the time and it was just so bad. And it didn't flatter him.
About his long hair coming back...
I miss those REAL LIVE on music bank and ingikaeo that 2nd Gen did... There was camera and technic rehearsal but idols, at that time, always perform live.
The girlies just do not sing live like this anymore!!
Shinee is king of pop korea..for shinee be strong without jonghyun..r.i.p to jonghyun oppa.ur we angel..ur voice is so beautiful & vocal is vry powerfull..go shinee go..
The fee SM payed for the choreographer was SUPER WORTH IT !
Man, Sherlock still gives me feels man.... Has to be my favorite era. I was freaking spazzing!! Lawd knows I do not spazz, but Sherlock does it every time!!!
One word "Legendary"..
oh my gosh.. all of shinee's songs have difficult choreography.. i mean, who can sing while dancing to this?? you can see how fired up they are while performing. You can see them catching their breath. I love SHINEE!!! 💗💗💗
TAEMIN'S HAIR😍😍😍
Minho starts shinee is back back pack pack pack😂 still love them❤
Onew's smirk 😍
omg 3:37 gets me every time i just think they look so hot when they do that leg dance move haha XD
jjong's muscle 👁👄👁
Jonghyun said the mic on lmao
This is the type of Performance and Song that will never Get OLD I could srsly listen to it a million times and never get bored of the Most incredible Choreo Made in Kpop dance It's Brilliant and SHINee Executes it With Perfection Every Stage every time!!! That's Sheer Excellence That's SHINEE 🙌🏻 💋😍🎵🔥💎
taemin is really cool here
역대 최고의 곡.. 셜록 컴백무대 12년이 지났지만 그때의 충격은 아직도 잊을수가 없다..
Music will never be what it was at this time. Talent mattered. You couldn’t be just pretty.
Noone could catch the Shinee about live performance and talent but nowadays k.a.r.d is also good at live. Love shinee forever (my first favourite kpop band)
it's crazy they are able to sing ANYTHING with this coreography. it just goes to show how good they are. forever my favouite band ♥ i am so proud of them all.
Can we talk about the actual choreography and skill and stamina it takes to perform this. Like what...
2:18 is so fuckimg random amd im loving it
넋놓고 보고있다 문득 의상이 눈에 하나씩 들어오는데....의상 뭐냐ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Those fanchants/screams..🙌😫😍
That shirt and that hair on Taemin is a yes
God this is still so legendary.
Key's hair with his FREEZE 🤩🤩🥰🥰
love key's jacket rocking pride colours :D
Back here in 2020 watching this and OMG, I had forgotten that Taemin had long hair here.. i thought it was only during the Lucifer era haha.. he looks so different here with the last of his more girly image & sleeveless shirts.. Wish he would dress up like that again just for fun:)
이렇게 라이브할 수 있는 남돌 샤이니말고 몇팀이나 있을까?
todavía soy un dorito!!! best performers ever!!
어머.. 샤이니에게 이런 시절이 있었군요. 살짝 놀랐지만.. 다 너무 잘 생겼군요
I vividly remember watching this performance on a live stream when it was airing - it was such a momentous song and time, it just blew me away and I remember everyone being in awe. 5HINee forever