Again thank you for testing out another router kit. This helps those who are watching their pennies make a choice. I always look forward to your videos as well as Rex and Mr Sellers. Thank you for sharing your knowledge with us.
Some thoughts after completing mine - installing the threaded studs sucks. Instead of using your drill chuck, you can use the knob cap nuts to drive the studs. - I managed to cut the "upstand" at the wrong angle, twice. The instructions on Paul's site are not that clear on how the blank should be oriented when marking 50 degrees. - I drilled the hole for the depth adjuster in the wrong place! But I was able to easily reposition it by filling in the hole with a dowel. - all of the studs are the same length, but the ones for the clamp bar are excessively long. Would be a nicer kit if they were just the right length. - it's easy to misalign the studs for the clamp such that it won't go on. A round file will remedy this. - I used a second, smaller forstner bit to make the iron hole into a pear shape. This greatly improved visibility and didn't seem to have downside. All that being said, my finished plane works great. I have a metal router plane with a very narrow blade, so it will be nice to have a big one and a small one.
Like some others, I have the kit in my shop somehwere - gradually climing the list of my projects to be done. I very much like the simplicity of Paul's design.
Thanks for the tip on using a hammer to adjust the angle of the screw. I could advance the blade, but it would bind when retracting. A couple of nice whacks with a nylon hammer to adjust the angle just a smidgen and now advancing and retracting the blade is very smooth.
Love Paul’s builds watched him do this a few years ago before kits were thought of and I did build my own router which looked nothing like his but worked amazingly well even made a fence for mine.
I decided to go with this kit rather that Rex's because it was so much cheaper for somebody outside of the US... Thanks for the build video, with Paul's and yours, I'll be all set to build it soon.
Please make an episode comparing different router plane builds from different kit makers and your assessment of their ease of build and use, pros and cons. Thank you for the video.
Nice! I got my kit a few weeks ago. It is always helpful to see different approaches to building. What I like is you can experiment and if it doesn't work just remove the HW and try again.
A very nice plane kit. Yes, you did make one before. It was nice too. I only recently learned about router planes. I don't know why I never knew about them because they are very useful. I have one now and love it. I may get this kit just because you make it look so fun to build. Thank you for sharing. Have a great day and stay safe.🙂🙂
Yes, please do a comparison video. I want to build one, but I can't afford to buy every company/ RUclipsr that comes out with their own designs. I love your deep dives. Keep up the great job.
First world problem? See what is available. Pick three or four good prospects. Pick one and build it. Real simple. But you'd rather try to burden someone else for your fleeting gratification. You'll also have to sit for the weeks of gathering materials, plans, making ,filming, editing and posting. Odds are, you won't make like a thousand other things you got excited about, then forgot to turn to the next titillating excitement to, in turn, forget about. While the maker bears all the costs and you contributed nothing. I had little runny nose kids, making a litany of I wannas. Loved them and ignored most of it. Unlike you, they grew up. God bless. Godd day.
Definitely agree on the comparison, and then talk difference with a Stanley 71 type. What would work best on which type of work, best for a beginner, reason to still want a Stanley, etc.
I'm just in the middle of making a router plane using a method you had used previously with a micro adjustment knob. But good to see you trying out Paul's kit 👍
Thanks James. I’ve got my kit ready to go, your overview has given the confidence to just get it done. Please do a comparison video. Can’t have too many router planes , surely?
I would certainly enjoy a video comparing the various router kits. The one thing I like about the Paul Sellers version is that he teaches how to make it with stuff you can buy at the hardware store, or you can buy his kit. I also like that his videos are out, so you can see what tools and skills are necessary before buying the kit.
I like this better than the other guy's 🤫 I use ipe for a lot of my tools and jigs. There's a kind of secure feeling I get knowing it's so stable and solid.
nice kit, good build. It occurred to me your trouble driving in those screws might have more to do with your formidable wood choice. Mighty pretty, but still mighty.
Very nice build! I made one myself right when the Paul Sellers video came out, but I have to say that I don't really like using it. I got a Stanley router shortly after which leaves a nicer finish, and it's somehow harder to adjust than my old chisel and wedge I was using before (based on Rex Krueger's old video). That said, it's still a pretty tool and I also kind of cobbled sizes together, as it was easier to find parts in English than metric sizes. Having everything in a kit is probably gonna make a nicer plane!
"we use crude tools to fashion better tools, and then our better tools to fashion more precise tools, and so on. each minor refinement is a step in the process, and all of the steps must be taken." -Chairman Yang
I really want to make a router plane, but there are so many options out there. Please make a comparison video. Usability is an important factor, but cost is going to be the deciding factor.
Hey, I have one of those! :P It was a lot of fun to build and it actually works... Plus while using it I can dream of having 1% of Paul Sellers' skill! :)
I hate using power drill to drive screws and bolts in woodworking. I find the control you get with a ratchet or a brace completely eliminates splitting if you judged the predrilled holes wrong.
Have one of these kits in my todo pile, definitely interested in the comparison video. Also would like to hear your personal preferences for what wood species to use for these types of projects.
I have been thinking of buying a router kit just not sure which one would be (not necessarily best) most fun for my skill level. I also often wonder if, other than being self made, can a kit plane keep up with a production plane like a 71 or 71 1/2.
Great job. Would love to see your comparison of the Sellars design (which I built last year) against Rex Krueger's (which I plan to build my own version of) and an old Stanley/Record.
Hi James, Thanks for posting this build video to provide some alternate strategies to build. I just placed an order for the kit as I wanted to experience building a router (though I already have a veritas one that works exceptionally well). I have a couple of questions with respect to this router and build: 1. I see that normally the router blades are bevel up (veritas, stanley etc.) but this one is bevel down. Is that going to make any difference? especially considering routers are mostly intended to be used across grain. 2. The retainer bar that sits on the top of the blade, with those 2 thumb nuts, is it supposed to pinch tight against the blade or is it just meant to make sure the blade doesn't fall off or come loose? The reason I am asking is because I wanted to be sure if the blade is supposed to sit flush within the groove or should I make sure the blade is slightly proud so that the retainer bar can pinch tight against it. Thanks!
The bevel angle is bevel down on this one, but in function it is the same as the veritas with the bent bevel as the cutting angle is close to the same. The blade should be slightly proud. the bar holds it in place.
Well, I wonder how well the maple will stick or stay glued to the Ipe. That wood has a LOT of oil/resin in it, and most of the time, people will wipe it with acetone before gluing, but, I would expect the oil to seep back in and the glue joint to fail eventually. Now, this got me thinking that I have some Ipe 4 by 4s, and was thinking about making hand planes...... Hmmmm.....
@@WoodByWrightHowTo Hmm, might have to try it. I do have a lot of Ipe around from some house projects. It does hold up really well for outdoor furniture here in the Pacific NW. Have some ironwood and lignum too....
A contrast between Paul's and Rex's might be interesting
Ditto
I would like to see the comparison!
I think that is comming!
James Wright and Paul Sellers coming together is oh so sweet. Thanks!
Again thank you for testing out another router kit. This helps those who are watching their pennies make a choice. I always look forward to your videos as well as Rex and Mr Sellers. Thank you for sharing your knowledge with us.
🤔Your the reason I now have a "Wood Working Tools" playlist!🤷😁
Some thoughts after completing mine
- installing the threaded studs sucks. Instead of using your drill chuck, you can use the knob cap nuts to drive the studs.
- I managed to cut the "upstand" at the wrong angle, twice. The instructions on Paul's site are not that clear on how the blank should be oriented when marking 50 degrees.
- I drilled the hole for the depth adjuster in the wrong place! But I was able to easily reposition it by filling in the hole with a dowel.
- all of the studs are the same length, but the ones for the clamp bar are excessively long. Would be a nicer kit if they were just the right length.
- it's easy to misalign the studs for the clamp such that it won't go on. A round file will remedy this.
- I used a second, smaller forstner bit to make the iron hole into a pear shape. This greatly improved visibility and didn't seem to have downside.
All that being said, my finished plane works great. I have a metal router plane with a very narrow blade, so it will be nice to have a big one and a small one.
This is great. Had to check my copy of the plans, as I thought the angle was higher; they show it as 50 degrees.
Like some others, I have the kit in my shop somehwere - gradually climing the list of my projects to be done. I very much like the simplicity of Paul's design.
Thanks for all your time and effort.
When I built mine I drilled opening I drilled it 45°, same as iron angle. Gave me a better view.
Thanks for the tip on using a hammer to adjust the angle of the screw. I could advance the blade, but it would bind when retracting. A couple of nice whacks with a nylon hammer to adjust the angle just a smidgen and now advancing and retracting the blade is very smooth.
I have build Paul Sellers router plane . It was very enjoyable process!! I made it from white oak, the knobs are from beech and applied Shellac.
Love Paul’s builds watched him do this a few years ago before kits were thought of and I did build my own router which looked nothing like his but worked amazingly well even made a fence for mine.
I decided to go with this kit rather that Rex's because it was so much cheaper for somebody outside of the US... Thanks for the build video, with Paul's and yours, I'll be all set to build it soon.
Please make an episode comparing different router plane builds from different kit makers and your assessment of their ease of build and use, pros and cons. Thank you for the video.
I enjoyed making this kit and highly recommend it.
Nice! I got my kit a few weeks ago. It is always helpful to see different approaches to building. What I like is you can experiment and if it doesn't work just remove the HW and try again.
Agree on the knobs. I put the knobs on mine and don’t use them and prefer just gripping the body.
Yes, please make a comparison video. Thanks!
Nice job. I'd definitely be interested in a comparison in use.
As usual, excellent video. Please do a follow up comparing the various router planes. Thanks, James!
Great! Finished mine yesterday. I also did not add the knobs. Bought two types of knobs but when I tested I found that without them is better for me.
The same. For wooden body planes I rarely put knobs on them. They're great for metal bodies where it's too thin to grab.
Looks good, the natural curve of the epay looks great
Good to see you again later again!
I've had my kit still in the box for a few weeks and haven't made time to build it out..... great job, beautiful work, James.
I see your using a Lake Erie tool works knife, I just received mine. Absolutely love this knife.
Love to see your comparison of all the different kits: how they are to build and how they work...
Thank you. I'm trying to source the hardware parts here in the US. More to follow...
Any luck yet?!
A very nice plane kit. Yes, you did make one before. It was nice too. I only recently learned about router planes. I don't know why I never knew about them because they are very useful. I have one now and love it. I may get this kit just because you make it look so fun to build. Thank you for sharing. Have a great day and stay safe.🙂🙂
Yes, please do a comparison video. I want to build one, but I can't afford to buy every company/ RUclipsr that comes out with their own designs. I love your deep dives. Keep up the great job.
First world problem? See what is available. Pick three or four good prospects. Pick one and build it. Real simple. But you'd rather try to burden someone else for your fleeting gratification. You'll also have to sit for the weeks of gathering materials, plans, making ,filming, editing and posting. Odds are, you won't make like a thousand other things you got excited about, then forgot to turn to the next titillating excitement to, in turn, forget about. While the maker bears all the costs and you contributed nothing. I had little runny nose kids, making a litany of I wannas. Loved them and ignored most of it. Unlike you, they grew up. God bless. Godd day.
So sounds unth kful for. WhF hS been given you, freely.
Speaking as a retired EE, you have a delightful selection of t-shirts!
Definitely agree on the comparison, and then talk difference with a Stanley 71 type. What would work best on which type of work, best for a beginner, reason to still want a Stanley, etc.
I'm just in the middle of making a router plane using a method you had used previously with a micro adjustment knob. But good to see you trying out Paul's kit 👍
Thanks James. I’ve got my kit ready to go, your overview has given the confidence to just get it done.
Please do a comparison video. Can’t have too many router planes , surely?
James! You have more router planes than fingers now. Keep up the good content buddy.
Seeing a comparison would be nice. I made a router plane based on one of your videos and it is one of my favorite tools to use.
I would certainly enjoy a video comparing the various router kits. The one thing I like about the Paul Sellers version is that he teaches how to make it with stuff you can buy at the hardware store, or you can buy his kit. I also like that his videos are out, so you can see what tools and skills are necessary before buying the kit.
Yes, I'd like to see a comparison in use.
I would love to see the comparison of the different router planes. Include manufactured ones.
Thanks for the great video, would love to see you do the comparison video including both shop made, restored and new router planes.
Hmm I think that space next to the hole is perfect to write "Linksys"
I made mine using Beech. Love it 🙂
I like this better than the other guy's 🤫 I use ipe for a lot of my tools and jigs. There's a kind of secure feeling I get knowing it's so stable and solid.
Thank you for another fun yet info filled video
Thanks for a short and succinct video on the build
Really beautiful work, James! It looks fantastic! 😃
Stay safe there with your family! 🖖😊
a video to compare most of them will be great!
Great video love to see how you went about making this Router Plane. I’ve purchased this kit also can’t wait to get started on it
nice kit, good build. It occurred to me your trouble driving in those screws might have more to do with your formidable wood choice. Mighty pretty, but still mighty.
Channel engagement!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I would like to see a comparison of router planes.
I have to agree regarding the drill chuck: I'd kind of rather not let the chuck jaws bite into the threads, but as you said, to each their own.
Nice kit. Looks pretty simple to build too.
YRTi has a great version that combines a carriage and traditional plane design. Just one more type of router for you to build and compare😊
Fantastic work. Thanks for sharing.
A pro and con would be great 👍
Comparison video please. So many good options.
I own this kit and keep putting off making it, so this is helpful.
Making this triangular piece is definitely the hardest bit
I’d appreciate a video comparing some of the different styles you made. I’m planning on making one for myself soon
As always wonderful video! I would like to see a comparison.
👍 nice video. A comparison between kits would be good.
Very nice build! I made one myself right when the Paul Sellers video came out, but I have to say that I don't really like using it. I got a Stanley router shortly after which leaves a nicer finish, and it's somehow harder to adjust than my old chisel and wedge I was using before (based on Rex Krueger's old video). That said, it's still a pretty tool and I also kind of cobbled sizes together, as it was easier to find parts in English than metric sizes. Having everything in a kit is probably gonna make a nicer plane!
Thanks James
Hi James, The router came out looking great. nice.
Your edit style keep the program moving. It would be nice if other Makers would pick up that style…
At 6:27 I was wondering why you were using a potato as screw wax... had to rewatch to confirm that it is not a potato.
I'd love to see a comparison vid comparing different kits.
"we use crude tools to fashion better tools, and then our better tools to
fashion more precise tools, and so on. each minor refinement is a
step in the process, and all of the steps must be taken." -Chairman Yang
I would love to see the Pro’s and Con’s video
Knurled nuts 🤔🧐🤗
I really want to make a router plane, but there are so many options out there. Please make a comparison video. Usability is an important factor, but cost is going to be the deciding factor.
Great job!
Hey, I have one of those! :P It was a lot of fun to build and it actually works... Plus while using it I can dream of having 1% of Paul Sellers' skill! :)
Nice project.
Great videos! I enjoy the voiceover instruction. Not to be snide, but I do appreciate a nice pair of knobs. (Oops!)
I’d like the comparison, please.
Thanks mate. That was great.
I plugged my cable into ny router and planed my way through the either
I hate using power drill to drive screws and bolts in woodworking. I find the control you get with a ratchet or a brace completely eliminates splitting if you judged the predrilled holes wrong.
I am usually in the same boat, but for this one I was following the instructions.
Have one of these kits in my todo pile, definitely interested in the comparison video. Also would like to hear your personal preferences for what wood species to use for these types of projects.
I'd like to see the comparison.
Actually thinking about buying/making this as an alt to my Stanley.
Cool kit
I built one awhile back, but I never could get it working right. Maybe I will try to rebuild it at some point.
the rex one is pretty good to replicate
but this one seems easier for the tools i have to make thanks
Thanks for sharing.
I have been thinking of buying a router kit just not sure which one would be (not necessarily best) most fun for my skill level. I also often wonder if, other than being self made, can a kit plane keep up with a production plane like a 71 or 71 1/2.
Now that is plane yummy, not bacon butty yummy but yummy never the less. Off to the kitchen I guess, then maybe the workshop.
Thanks. God bless.
Great job. Would love to see your comparison of the Sellars design (which I built last year) against Rex Krueger's (which I plan to build my own version of) and an old Stanley/Record.
Snide remark.
(I like the vid)
Nice job as always. Do you plan to add any carved decoration to the plan in the future?
I like ole wright
Hi James, Thanks for posting this build video to provide some alternate strategies to build. I just placed an order for the kit as I wanted to experience building a router (though I already have a veritas one that works exceptionally well). I have a couple of questions with respect to this router and build:
1. I see that normally the router blades are bevel up (veritas, stanley etc.) but this one is bevel down. Is that going to make any difference? especially considering routers are mostly intended to be used across grain.
2. The retainer bar that sits on the top of the blade, with those 2 thumb nuts, is it supposed to pinch tight against the blade or is it just meant to make sure the blade doesn't fall off or come loose? The reason I am asking is because I wanted to be sure if the blade is supposed to sit flush within the groove or should I make sure the blade is slightly proud so that the retainer bar can pinch tight against it.
Thanks!
The bevel angle is bevel down on this one, but in function it is the same as the veritas with the bent bevel as the cutting angle is close to the same.
The blade should be slightly proud. the bar holds it in place.
I would also like to see the comparison video. Maybe your top 5?
here you go. ruclips.net/video/7ZJLrF2TGB4/видео.html
I'd like to see that router vs router vs router vs router vs router vs router video
I found mine tended to dig in because the iron is too steep. I made one with the typical “L” shaped iron and it works much better.
Interesting..... 😊, thanks.
Beautiful pieces of wood.
RIP to all the sharp edges on your tools, lol.
I bought this one
Well, I wonder how well the maple will stick or stay glued to the Ipe. That wood has a LOT of oil/resin in it, and most of the time, people will wipe it with acetone before gluing, but, I would expect the oil to seep back in and the glue joint to fail eventually. Now, this got me thinking that I have some Ipe 4 by 4s, and was thinking about making hand planes...... Hmmmm.....
the oily wood and glue problem is an old myth. Yes there is a bit more oil but not enough to cause an issue.
@@WoodByWrightHowTo Hmm, might have to try it. I do have a lot of Ipe around from some house projects. It does hold up really well for outdoor furniture here in the Pacific NW. Have some ironwood and lignum too....