Turkey Moves Toward BRICS; Germany and France Delusional; NATO Faces Major Issues | Jacques Baud
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 сен 2024
- Jacques Baud is a former member of Swiss strategic intelligence, a specialist in Eastern European countries and head of United Nations peace operations doctrine. He was engaged in negotiations with top Russian military and intelligence officials right after the fall of the USSR. Within NATO, he participated in programs in Ukraine and in particular during the Maidan revolution in 2014.
Baud's Books: www.amazon.com...
The USA and Europe impose an embargo on NATO member Turkey. They cooperate with groups that carry out terrorist acts against Turkey in Syria and feed PKK supporters. Turkey has patience, no matter how loyal it is to NATO, do not test its patience. The West and NATO will suffer from this
NATO membership protects Turkey against NATO and NATO countries. At the same time, Turkey's membership in NATO protects Turkey against Russia. But that doesn't mean that Turkey agrees with NATO on all points. Since the failed coup attempt, initiated by the USA, Turkey knows that it cannot rely on NATO. Turkey acts according to the motto, keep friends close but keep enemies even closer.
NATO countries supports terrorist groups that attacks to Türkiye. They let terrorist groups does propaganda on their streets. NATO protects shit. We don't trust NATO. We trust ourselves. It was mistake join to NATO.
Tf are you talkin about😂 even if Turkiye leaves nato no one will do or can do anything. And Russia won’t do nothing against Turkiye
Perfetto
@@memo-cv2zd Why should Turkiye leave NATO? Turkiye could practice the Islamic doctrine of Taqiya (Holy Lying) and be both part of the NATO alliance, BRIC alliance, and even be militarily ally of Russia and China. Eventually, Islam will abolish NATO
A very good comment. Yes, USA planned the failed coup against Erdogan and the mastermind behind Fethullah Gulen is George Soros and his Open Society Foundation. Turkiye motto is always to keep "friends" close but "enemies" (of EU and NATO) will be closer just to threaten NATO
West wants/needs a guard dog but they have forgotten one significant reality: a Gray Wolf cannot be tamed into a guard (or a lap) dog.
Turkiye does not required to be pro-Western, Turkiye does not need to be pro-Eastern...
Turkiye is and needs to be pro-Turkiye ONLY!
menwhile turkey begging to join EU for the last 20 yeras like a begger on the streets and for the last years is begging to join bricsturkey is not a gray wolf but a hungry puppet beggin everyone for some food and some attentionbeggers will always be beggers and not wolfs
Which is impossible...
shall i remind you that turkey was begging usa for planes?that even now still begging to receive those planes?or shall i remind you that you wanted the approval and help of usa in syria?you tink that you are a wolf?hahah you are not even a kitty.foryears you say you dont need nato and that you will leave but you dont dare to do it cause you know that in 6 months you will loos half of turkey.you ar ebgging to join EU,you are begging to join BRICS alhough you are energy slaves from russia.face the reality you are not great you are beggers
Turkiye itself is already east, that is, Asia. It is not the southern wing of NATO, it is the southern wing of Russia. Russia is too Turkiye's northern flank. The western flank of China and Pakistan is the northern flank of Iran. 80 years ago, Stalin made a mistake, but Europe's puppet master failed to capitalize on it. By not accepting Turkiye into the European Union and supporting terrorist organisations, he made his aim clear and lost. The third world war will be fought between these 5 countries and the rest of the world, and at the end of this war there will be no place left called the world.
@@paradoksparadoks6299 Why is it impossible for Turkiye to be pro-Turkiye? Turkiye loves itself and glorfies its "race". Turks love ethnocentrism, ultra nationalism and racism. Turks hate Armenians.
No acceptance to the European Union issues with purchasing of US jets being punished for choosing to buy the Russian S400 Air defense systems and many other challenges.joining BRICS will be a more profitable option for that beautiful country. It should make the move.
Agreed. World is tired of sanctions due to Dollarization and single banking system . We need alternatives for everyone.
Admit to yourself that the WEST carries out a coup in Turkey using NATO elements every 10 years! Then REMEMBER that the people saved ERDOĞAN in the last coup attempt! Your problem is not Erdoğan, but the fact that the Turkish people know you very well!
@ardxa4259 İyi de ne istediniz devermedik diyen Nato değildi.Bence Nato dan falan daha fazla bizim kendi politikalarımız darbede etkili oldu.Canavarı besledik büyüttük
Col Baud commets are always a pleasure. Thanks Nima 🎉
I really enjoy Jacques contribution to the discussion, especially his insights into the thinking and behavior of the EU and NATO. He doesn't just regurgitate the same arguments over and over but instead digs deeper down the rabbit hole. Good stuff.
Nima, I really enjoy your interview style. Very honest and simple. Like a discussion between friends at a coffee shop. Keep up the great work. Eric Bossé Montréal
WOW, best guests + intelligent questions
I never miss a show
🙏
Thank you
Jacques Baud👌👍
Another interesting and enlightening discussion from Mr. Baud. I imagine Turkiye will do what is in its best interest, and President Erdogan seems to play his cards very close to his chest. The recent movement towards BRICS is encouraging from the perspective of future multipolarity and freedom from the stranglehold of the US dollar and political system. Let's wait and see!
Great discussion as always.
I am so grateful for your stable of great men.🙏❤️🥛 The content is so dense I listen to it several times.👂👂
Col Baud is the best guest. Other guests are the same on most shows about geopolitics. You host almost the same people as Judge Napolitano and The Duran.
What Jacques notes about Turkey’s EU membership is true, but it goes further than that. Turkey spent decades passing reforms, including most of Erdogan’s first decade in power. Then, Sarkozy stood up in 2008 and said France would veto Turkish membership, which meant Turkey started to understand that in Europe Islamophobia is a powerful force that will be exploited by politicians for electoral benefit and will ensure that Turkey’s EU membership hopes would never be materialised. After that is when the backsliding on reforms started. And after a long deliberation Turkey has realised its future is in the east, not in the west. Just like Russia has now turned to the east.
Also, Turkey would hardly be accepted into the EU, because Turkey is a fairly large country by European standards and it has some sovereignty. The main countries in the EU do not need potential competitors, they only need vassals who will supply them with cheap labor.
@@morfeicheg
To be honest, and it pains me to say this as a European, the biggest obstacle to Turkey joining the EU was that 80 million mostly non-white Muslims would get freedom of movement across the EU. That would never be accepted by the populist right, and was a key factor in why Sarkozy declared France would veto Turkish membership to stave off a challenge from Le Pen. And that bogeyman was employed by Boris Johnson (ironically of Turkish descent) and Farage in pushing through Brexit, who lied by claiming Britain as an EU member could not stop Turkish membership (despite having the same veto that France has).
the only benefit to try to enter EU is the move, the cleaning up of reforms you badly needed, a breathing space for the citizens That is before the whims and absurdities of the Commission. Before the unnecessary privatisations.To force some decisions and changes, even debates. The danger is the admin. gets a taste of mandating (in the name of Bruxelles) whatever some in power profit from.
So to be wise and quit timely.
And in any case never join the €zone.
@@kardy12Do you ever read, hear statements from Turkey politicians.public persons, etc.?
Comment sound like brainwashed wh.... guilty narrative. Also, I guess that your country is not been occupied by Ottomans couple centuries. In other case you will be more careful with such inclusive comments.
@@aleksandarbabic766
Aah, and you are of course the ultimate arbiter of what is or what isn’t “brainwashed”. Sorry, but it is a fact that Sarkozy’s motivation for publicly stating he would veto Turkish membership of the EU was to a significant extent a move to ward off a challenge from Le Pen’s National Front by stealing a march on riding on the coat tails of Islamophobia. And it’s a fact that Boris Johnson and Nigel Farage lied about the U.K. being unable to stop Turkey joining the EU despite it having a veto just like France and rode on the coat tails of xenophobia and giant posters of non-white Muslim immigrants “flooding” Britain.
“How Did You Go Bankrupt?” “Two Ways. Gradually and Then Suddenly.” - Ernest Hemingway’s novel, ‘The Sun Also Rises’
I'm afraid to say that the EU & NATO may cease to exist after this is all said and done, thanks to their participation for helping Joebama Buyden's war in Project Ukraine which will ultimately cause their end as well.
Not sure why you bring Obama into this - he had the sense of putting breaks on providing weapons to Ukraine, realising that Russia had escalatory dominance.
@@kardy12 Because he is from the same gang as the current Biden administration. Project Ukraine began in 2013, when Obama was president of the US.
@@kardy12Really?
How about to think again.
@@aleksandarbabic766
If you choose to live in la-la land, that is your prerogative.
@@kardy12 Obama was in charge from 2008 to 2016.
All s#it in Ukr was done under his regime.
So..maybe I live in la la land... But what is with you?
Brain dead or what ?
I would like to explain one more thing. Which country in Europe really has an army? Greece? a complete puppet state, colonised by the USA, living off the resources of Europe. Germany? colonised by the USA since it lost the 2nd world war, and although its administration knows this, its people are unaware of this, it has a uniform but it is empty inside. france? a country whose army has rotted in the last 40 years because of its reliance on nuclear weapons, unable to even fix its own internal chaos. italy? yes, there is something, but it is self-sufficient. maybe. spain? the only self-sufficient country in europe. Turkey is not a European country, neither because of its territory nor its religion. It does not have the kinship of the old European kingdoms, that is the real reason. Russia is playing a game with the USA, people are dying, but neither of them cares. they are nothing but partners who appear to be enemies. nato is neither the army of the USA nor of Europe. nato is a special army that protects the interests of the money barons. countries that cannot understand this will disappear over time. in a possible war, it would be very normal for turkey to leave the nato or declare neutrality. because who you are really fighting for and for what purpose is important here. It is clear that Turkey has no intention of being a pawn in the plan of the giants.
nowhere in western media is it even casually mentioned Turkey will likely join BRICS - it’s probably in their best interest to keep playing both sides but they could really become a leader of that part of the world being the most strategically positioned of all
It's normal that they don't mention it. Because the West does not want Turkey to join BRICs.
Western MSM just misinforms and lies ..
I've just discovered your work M Alkhorshid and I appreciate very much your respect for the guest.
Good forTurkiye,
Turkiye has been waiting for the last 30 40 years to join the EU which is not going to happen and it's Nato member always gets sanctions by Nato members and the US I'll say stuff the West go to the east there's nothing for you in the west Turkiye .
let the EU beg you to coming💪
EU will never beg Turkey for anything. And if NATO is such a drag for you, you should leave. No-one is forcing you to stay.
@@Oil2024 Without Turkiye, you are not safe...
@@Oil2024soon leaving this satanic evangelic group
nato and europe need to Türkiye, but Türkiye do not need nato and europe. 🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷
Correct.
As time goes on, Turkiye will be the 4th biggest power in the world in coming years
Russia China
Turkiye USA
This is ridiculous. Turkey makes %50 of export to Europe. And %80 of high value export to Europe. So Turkey can be bankrupted in 2 years if Turkey can't sell anything to Europe. Turkey can't sell anything to China or BRICKS countries. And Turkey sell Russia vegetables fruits and textile and import gas and oil which creates negative balance in trade. So even China is needing the juicy European and American market.
Also in NATO the only power is USA. Except USA all other countries can be replaced. As a Turk sometimes it is funny to read no sense Turkish propaganda.
Macronized Is a good joke!
Macron is worse than Zelensky . Both zelensky & macron are BIG 🤡🐀
Please, no more references to "extreme" right or "hard" right. Do these positions even exist these days. The warmonger "neo cons" who in fact are truly "extreme", sound in contrast as innocent as newborn babes.
Hungary may leave too.
eu and usa seeing turkey as enemy not ally. cuz of religion or culture or whatever but this it is.
Bu tarihten geliyor, çünkü Amerika diye bir millet veya ulus gerçekte yok, yapay bir devlet, daha doğrusu Avrupa'dan kaçıp yeni bir hayat ve gelecek kurmaya çalışan Avrupa'daki halkların karışımı, yani bir ulus veya millet değiller. İşte bu yüzden ulus devletlerden karşı nefret duyuyorlar, zaten Osmanlılar Avrupa devletleri ile yüzyıllardan beri savaşıyor, haçlı orduları v.s; İşte bu yüzden Türkiye'yi aralarında görmek istemiyorlar, ayrıca korkuyorlar da, rönesans ve reform fikirlerini ilk ortaya atan bilginler (İbn-Sina, Farabi)Türk bilginleri idi, ama osmanlı din bilginleri (şeyhülislam) kendi menfaatleri için bu fikirleri afaroz ettiler, ama bu fikirlerin gücünü avrupalı bilginler hemen farkedip reform ve rönesans'ı Avrupada uygulamaya koyuldular ve ileriye doğru büyük bir hamle yaptılar, burda geri kalan ve kaybeden Türkiye oldu.., işte bu ve benzeri sebeplerden dolayı Türkiye çok zaman kaybetti. Bu anlattıklarımı tarihten araştırabilirsiniz...
another interesting and insightful scenario analysis by the colonel...
NATO is deprived of an experienced, well-trained and well-equipped force of 9 corps
Nonsense.
@@kenklue467nato total -890.000 soldier
@@TURKOPOL46So? Bricks total?
@@TURKOPOL46 the bulk from Turkey
@@aleksandarbabic766The Turkish armed forces can operate jointly. 890,000 Turkish soldiers if bricks or bricks are added
Not Turkey, Türkiye
I will always call it by its proper name, Turkey.
@@johnbodman4504who cares what you do😂
@@johnbodman4504😂😂😂proper guy
Great!
Turkey just announced the largest tariff on china. Wow! Congratulations on turkey on supprting local workers! Stronger than even Eu tariff is huge!
Do you actually understand how tariffs work?
And then they announced that China will built an electric car factory in Turkey to bypass EU tariffs. Turks & Chinese must think EU people are stupid
Don't forget that Turkey has waited for 40 years to be integrated into the EU--but was refused! Turkey ,under the present government , is a loose actor ...and can change sides . There is no clear strategic direction....but is not a firm party.
Sure, I have heard, that if Turkey leaves Nato, Nato will fall . Bye Bye Nato.
you want that Turkey become a d0g like the other countries to join the eu.. delusional
You cannot integrate the Middle East into Europe. It is an oxymoron. Turkey fits better with the autocratic regimes . Erdogan is more like Putin than any Western leader
As a Turk, Türkiye should not join the EU right now, it would harm both parties. Türkiye should have joined the EU in the 2000s and the EU should not have supported terrorists in eastern Turkey under the name of freedom. Terrorists in the east killed more Kurds than Turks. These are not Kurdish warriors, they are just terrorists. The group trying to revolt in Turkey is the millions of Kurds who migrated from Northern Iraq to Turkey during the Iraq War. The West is currently experiencing ethnic chaos while masturbating for freedom. Indians and Arabs are two dangerous cultures.
Dostluklar samimi insanlarla, ticaret dürüst iş adamlarıyla yapılır. Avrupa birliği va ABD Türkiye’ye ne dostluk yaptı nede dürüst davranmadı. Türkiye batıdan hep ambargo ve tehtid aldı. Durumun sorumlusu batıdır.
We are not west also nor east , we are Turkiye , we have our own civilization so we should and must keep on moving our own way , besides except economics really nothing to take from west , an old lady .
Finally Turkey is in a mutually respected alliance
Maybe Tükiye would be more respected if it wasn't commiting war crimes all the time.
Not even talking about the corruption, the radicalization, supression of free speech and so on and so on.
If they would have fixed their problems, they would be in the EU long ago.
@close_all_tabs who wants to be in EU now anyway? Good thing Turkey decided to join BRICS as the sanctions of USA or threats of them will be eliminated in the future😅 as Azrahell have eyes on it as well.
@@close_all_tabsTurkiye is a Muslim Country and would NEVER have been allowed in, as we saw!
Turkiye was a useful " Ally", nothing more.
As for BRICS they will not 🚫 interfere in local/internal Turkish rule. Its people MUST change or decide on what they want.
In BRICS Turkiye will need to support the objectives .
@@bernaguvenc4029 Türkiye still wants to join EU. So does Ukraine, Georgia, North Macedonia, ... damn, even Serbia is trying.
Joining BRICS is just the second best, becoming China's little playball.
@@close_all_tabs So are you saying that the EU is a better option than BRICS??? Only delusional leaders want to be in the EU union, they are about to collapse together with their most superior USA idiots..
Strategy of war , why no experts on peace
Good question.
Thank you
2020 statistics for STEM graduates:
3.57m China
2.55m India
820k US
520k Russia
300k Indonesia
238k Brazil
221k Mexico
220k France
216k Germany
211k Iran
192k Japan
Data compiled by Statista
In other words, China graduated 4x more STEM graduates than the U.S. in 2020. It’s probable that the delta will keep growing.
Population China ~1.4 Billion, pop. USA 333 Million; China's STEM 'level' seems to be proportionate to size of population. edit: but how many US STEM graduates are US Citizens and will be employed in USA? China certainly has a huge "Talent Pool" in STEM graduates.
@@corvusduluthV2Less and less Chinese want to stay in US. Because they are treated almost like Japanese during WW2. Also, many back to mainland,not only because they are harassed, but because general climate in 'murica.
Use wrong pronounce... And you are canceled.
US already lose couple top scientist. Oh, by the way, do O need to mention that China have more money to invest in research and development.?
PS. STEAM in US and rest of world is not same. Do word DEI rong your bells 🎉
Many students in US are foreigners who return home after graduation.
@@karelnovak8818i don't care about USA
Enterprising East vs Warring West
Hello from Holland🌷
Thanks, a good analysis!
Türkiye 🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷
No way Turkey can join BRICS if it’s arming Ukraine. They WILL need to choose
Brics will not worry about such minor problems in order to benefit from Turkey's geopolitics and use the Black Sea effectively. BRICs, which has Turkey on its side, will disable NATO in the Black Sea and the Middle East.
You don't understand Brics. Brics has no military goals it is economic cooperation. Don't forget that enemies like Greece and Turkey are both in NATO.
I agree, Turkey will have to decide to clean up its act, if it wants to join BRICS. I also doubt that BRICS would admit a NATO member.
@@johnbodman4504It will also cause trouble for NATO and cracks the unipolar scheme, so it will be allowed.
@@dogacanalsancak2168 Yes you may be right, however it will have to get its troops out of Syria and stop arming Ukraine. I believe there will be further rules that will apply to Turkey, it will have to withdraw from aggressive action from any other country. BRICS+ is being set up as a non military organization, though I believe that may change when the US makes its move against China.
Not turkey türkiye bro
Evet !
Turkiye applied to European union first in 1963 since then they kept waiting due to Muslim population. Look at the member countries , none is Muslim country. We can say EU is a Christian community. EU came out with all bullshit excuse to not accept full membership. Of course Turkiye will shift the direction to East or better Union that helps economically. EU never liked Turkiye due to history and religious. I don't think Turkiye needs EU membership. Look at UK left the union and some other members are already considering to exit. What to discuss here anymore !!!!
I disagree EU is Christian because Erdogan has always stated Turkiye is a land of the Bible, and that Muslims are Christian people as Muslims accept Jesus as Christ and are circumcised like Jesus Christ. Muslims are Unitarian Christians who pray to God our Father (ALLAH) and reject praying to Jesus.
Nima
1st of all
TÜRKİYE not Turkey
2nd
the war is manipulated by us/uk, not Türkiye.
So why we should shed blood for those who avtually support the war, not want it to finish and support terrorist pkk against Türkiye?!
Nima always has hair supremacy
😏🙂
“It’s his mother’s muff”
-Tony Soprano
Unfortunately, I will not be accepted in Nima's "Hair-Manoy" bloc as I am completely bald!😢😢
Nimas, contata o Comandante Farinazzo, do Canal Arte da Guerra, seria legal vcs fazerem uma live juntos, ele assiste suas entrevistas, ele falou no Congresso essa semana sobre a defesa do Brasil. Seria muito bom vcs somarem forças, acho que ele vai ter um novo encontro lá na próxima semana.
Turkiye do rights cuz last 10 years nato pushed back and European alliance 50 years already waiting in door Turkiye also Turkish peoples no more wanted nato and Europe
*TURKİYE*
I disagree with Jacques in that Russia needs Türkiye to facilitate some way out of the Ukraine conflict - Russia has that conflict firmly under control - it will stop when Russia chooses it to stop.
Jacques also seems unaware that the Eu is also in terminal decline as a result of decades of neoliberalist economic policies inflicted from Brussels - a dysfunctional economic structure purposely designed to inflict austerity and division on Eu citizens by a general wage race to the bottom and a profit race to the top for the industrial states.
Through the sabotage of Nordstream by the US the French & German industrial engines of the Eurozone have been destroyed for generations - Eu member nations are in a recessionary spiral to depression.
Little wonder Türkiye choose a future in BRICS and sanction free multipolar trade.
All true.
NATO is a military union, BRICs is an economic union. it has nothing to do with it. Moreover, Türkiye is harmed by its NATO membership, it is very close to leaving NATO and establishing its own military union.
The best is to kick out of NATO evil
Ukraine conflict....
Turkey was mediator
In 2022 ... Just a short time after Russian Special military operation...
Nima 🌹
I think Turkey already passed the phase to rely on anyone
Turkiye is a long standing regional power
As a Turkish citizen, I really don’t think we have to be an EU member.
Turkish economy will be the biggest in Europe in coming years anyways
Nasıl olcak abi merakımdan soruyorum yanlış anlama
Good discussion. I wish people would stop using "extreme right". Its a mainstream media cope. These parties would be considered completely normal 20 years ago, in fact probably left wing mostly. They have just had enough of immigration.
"Extreme right" is actually nazis.
Even if a referendum is held to say that we should leave NATO and go to the side of Russia and China, you will see that you are indispensable
Europe needs to have Turkey in the alliance but can't have! Headache doesn't get worse than that.
No one will be down it's all political nonsense.
Extreme right or common sense?
france was always delusional.
You cannot compare the Chinese engineers with the European Engineers. I was a high level executive in a large US corporation. We hired Chinese Engineers for specific tasks but we knew they can only progress on the technical ladder. The European engineers are like swiss knives, no punt intended, many could rise to be VPs in many different departments. We even had a European engineer that became VP of marketing and another one who became VP of IT. With the Chinese this could never happen!
You can start by researching how popular electric cars produced by China are in the world market. Isn't it possible that bad Chinese engineers have come to your company? I'm Turk. You should also know that production cannot be made in the world market without China. Let's say you designed an electronic card, you will use many parts produced in China on that card. You can also find better quality and cheaper electronic products in China than European goods.
Turkey has never gotten any benefit from NATO. Just has gotten three time fascist army dictatorship government.because USA and NATO had supported them ..turkey must quite from NATO..
Turkiye must get out of NATO sooner is betetr, TURAN, Islamic Army is good choice
@@admiral20055 We dont want anything ISLAMIC.
@@admiral20055 What Islamic army! No such thing. You cannot do anything with Arabs under a religious dogma. Islam means Arabic Cultural Imperialism.
@@admiral20055Turkey is a secular country. Not an islamic one and their citizens are becoming more and more non-islamic every year. There is no way they would want a islamic alliance.
TURAN is possible for them though.
@@admiral20055what Islam. Everyday more people leaving Islam. CHP which is secular party will take over all Turkiye soon.
26:20 "You have this system of coercion between friends, when you start to coerce your friends because they don't think exactly like you, I think this is not a good sign. And probably if you have an opportunity... you can change your view, and probably join this group of countries". ~Jacques Baud.
You are wrong. The turks is closer to west than middle east. But in the end, we are non west ore asia. We belive in Atatürk ideologi and the todays goverment is like arabs
You got zero poor man😂
Russia will counter attack the attacker.
ADF... Extreme right??? More like centre right.(The old centre,and old right)AKA not crazy people 😇🤗🇸🇯
Nord Stream ? 🤔
whats germany's importance in nato again?? it'll take 5 years for germany to have an acceptable nato grade army - and that with a very good economy which it doesn't have today. even worse, it'll take a generation ot two to get german society to overcome the "impotent" mentality towards militirization- which the UK and US has been pouınding into germans' souls for decades..
Nato will collapse, EU will transform to a lose union with nations have more power to say and behave more independenly. Because the interest of east and west europe do not intersect as in east and west roman empire. They are culturally different as well.
"the Ukraine" ...
That's a dog whistle.
So Germany is facing a huge problem with thousands of Guest Workers from Turkey etc????
The "gastarbeiter" from Turkey were there fifty years ago
@@rosemaryspiota9836 77 years, exTLY ..
Germany has a huge problem with massive migration of extremists and terrorist in the name of human rights and freedom fighters the last 2 decades. Turks aren't a part of that, Turks have been there without problems for 75 years.
lot of money, that person doesn't have a vision that sees humans as intelligent in themselves, we have a big goal to run and catch the intelligence of the domestic animal that lives in the forest, free and commanded by global capitalism, the empire and ships and churches together.
will Turkey becomes a spoiler ..she has raised Chinese EVs 40% levy ?? 😂😂❤❤
TR has its own interests; and they are not same and equal to NATO's and the EU's.
BRICS is the natural partner.
nato total -890.000 soldier
Mostly Turkish.
@@oitzingerpeterTurkish Armed Forces is TÜRK.
Not just soldier but very important territory too...if Turkiye leaves Nato of course,which is never gonna happen anyway.
Maybe Nima can talk about his fake degree from a fake University from a fake country?
Türkiye is middle eastern country if you look from west. If you look from east it is a western country. Türkiye stands between both sides so we will never be truly western or truly eastern. When you try to put Türkiye in a block you will make a mistake.
Additionally it is a mistake to make sense of Turkish politics from your point of view. Variables are greatly different from the countries which are located east or west blocks
Looking at the current state of some European countries eg. France, UK, Germany, Belgium Turkey is more western country. Have you ever walked the streets of London, Berlin, Paris or Brussels it looks like Mogadishu.
Sorry, but AFD is not extrem right. This talking point is propagenda.
Don’t you know if you’re patriotic or democratic is the same as far right , 😂
Yep. Calling them extreme right is an understatement.
AfD is a bunch of fascists. Neo Naz*s. Nothing less.
liberals are right, afd is far right! be quiet and sit down that is the truth even if you don't like it!
Could be just a flowery speaks ?
@@bitsbobs8613 Distance from the left and the right should be 6 foot apart / or in front and behind .
Jacques gives the first sensible account of Turkey's strong allegiance to NATO and the west, despite the contempt it faces (often with reason) from that camp. Russia and Turkey are in a deadly embrace and Erdogan has successfully exploited this to Russia's disadvantage. However I think Jacques overestimates the strength of the bond between Russia and Turkey. In the last period, say a year or so, there has clearly been a distancing on Putin's part away from Erdogan. You could say Putin will no longer be 'played' by Erdogan. This coincides with US also being less receptive to Erdogan. Perhaps US and Russia don't need to compete for Turkey - despite this idea that Erdogan is a successful international player Turkey is really in a poor postion. Objectively it needs to go East but won't. Turkey is making conciatory noises to Russia but I think there is a real schism that won't be solved. If NATO were to attack Russia I don't think Turkey will sit on the fence but we'll see.
It has been 6 years since Turkey left NATO. We're just playing overtime
Turkey would not support or get involved in a NATO attack on Russia .
Such a poor comment. It has no touch with the reality, not at all. Turkiye will never sacrifice his sons and daughters for NATO if they attack Russia. Over the last 60 years NATO was behind all of the coups and coup attempts in Turkiye, and they have been supporting enemies of Turkiye in the region since 1980s. All these cost trillions of dollars of economic losses. After the last coup attempt in 2016, Turkish state and Turks know that NATO and the EU cannot be trusted. Today, let alone helping Turkiye ,NATO and the EU members openly support terrorist groups like PKK against Turkiye, despite they officially recognize PKK as a terrorist organization.
Your comment clearly demonstrates your lack of knowledge of Turkiye's geopolitical and economic significance. Open up the map and see where Turkiye is. First of all, Turkiye controls the entry to Black Sea from the Mediterranean Sea and entry to Mediterranean Sea from the Black Sea which is crucial in a war against Russia. Just remember WWi, how the Russian Empire crumbled, and Bolsheviks came to power when the French and the British Army were defeated in Dardanelles and they failed to help Russia. Second, many oil and natural gas pipelines pass through Turkiye. Most of the NG coming from the ME, Azerbaijan, Turkmenistan, Kazakhstan should pass through Turkiye. Third, Turkiye has a large sphere of influence. Through its historical and Turkic ties, it can reach states and people of Azerbaijan, Turkmenistan, Iran, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, Eastern Turkestan (in China), and many Turkic states in Russia such Chuvashia, Tatarstan, Bashkhurdistan, Yakutia, .... Also, through its historic and religious ties Turkiye has ties with many countries spanning from Morocco to Somalia, from Middle East to Caucasia, from ME to Balkans, from Caucasia to Central Asia, from Pakistan/Afghanistan to Bangladesh and then to Malaysia/Indonesa. Fourth, the Western countries have significant investments in Turkiye. Fifth, today Turkiye is an important gateway to Europe for immigrants. Today there are about 4-5 million refugees in Turkiye. They stay in Turkiye thanks to an agreement between the EU and Turkiye. Sixth, Turkiye has siginifcant reserves of boron and thorium which will be very important in energy production, military technologies, and material science in the future.
Turkiye has never naturally belonged to NATO and the EU.
Turkey will never move Brick.İf a Country a member of NATO this country never joın Brick.Erdogan uses thıs Issue .Turkey trouble in Economı crıses for thıs reason he wants to west to Turkey fınancıal assıstance.Erdogan also wants polıtıcal support from Turkey's allıes.For ısntance Human Rıghts and Refugee that ıs from Syrıa
Turkey is on Turkey side.
All other is secondary. This is not unique, all countries take care about his interests.
But there is one "little thingy". Turks want to reestablish Ottoman empire, Great Turkey, whatever you call it. Not just Sultan Erdogan, but majority of other politicians and public persons.
btw they don't look just on Europe, they also want to spread on entire Middle East. So.... Make your conclusion.
We just entertain the idea. It is not a logical idea to run after. I mean resurrection the Ottoman Empire in this age. It doesn’t make sense. Being a regional self sufficient power is the goal. Nothing more.
@@rccasual7525 When and where people are logical?
Geo Strategic lokation of Turkey is in same time bless and curse.
Every disruption in world situation can't avoid this region. So, Turkey are very important world factor per se. It's on Turkey which role they chose.
To be benefactor or....
Turkish people remibd me on Germans or English man's... On surface they sometimes talk about world peace but in essence they wish that days of *old glory * come back.
Not only politicians... Common people, just read comments on YT.
@@aleksandarbabic766 yes people are emotional mostly. But if you want ottomans back you need to conquer and hold east Europa and North Africa. Can anybody hold any land in this age? We cannot even hold a piece of island and call it ours. So this is just a romantic day dream of an empire nothing more.
But surely Türkiye has been bullied long enough, mostly by western countries so idea of a strong Türkiye is logical and it can be decorated with the past glories. What is wrong with that?
But if we are talking about influence, you are right. If I don’t expand then you will expand. That is natural.
What an insightful comment! From a primary school student learning geopolitics.Go on budy 😊
@@static7040 A da ti malo jedes lajne?
Tsssss kad krembil hoce da bude duhovit.
"Turkey is a peculiar member of Nato". 😂 Turkey is mainly peculiar because it always wants to be paid first.
The eastern flank of the nato will collapse
Turkey is as broke as South Africa 😅 Both are excellent briCs material 😂😂
TÜRKİYE
12th GDP(PPP) = 3.700 billion usd.
18th GDP(Nominal) = 1.150 billion usd. Only debtfull
You comment makes absolutely no sense. If you are saying these things intentionally that makes you a liar/troll. If you are saying these things due to lack of knowledge than it makes you ignorant which is better than being a liar.
Turkiye has lower debt-to-gdp ratio than any EU country. While Turkiye has a debt-to-gdp ratio about 35%, many EU countries have about 100% and more than 100% debt-to-gdp ratio. This has been the case for at least a decade. Could you explain how come a country whose debt is around 1/3 of its annual income can be qualified as broke, but countries whose annual income/production falls short of their debt are regarded as "not broke"? If you look at the household debt statistics, the situation is even worse. You can confirm this bitter truth from many open sources such as IMF, OECD, IBRD, ...
Interesting stuff.
Despite the guest was a former NATO colonel, so no big expectations. Brain is not there.
And his answer to Turkey positioning is clearly confused.
Too much CNN to use your tiny brain,😂
The former NATO colonel from the Swiss Army...
Are you even aware of your own stupidity?
he was not a NATO colonel. switzerland is not in NATO. he worked as a swiss army colonel (partnership f peace program) for NATO
@@patsickinger3885 he said so after some minutes in the interview.
And in the video description it's written that he participated in NATO activities in Ukraine, during Maidan events. A disgrace.
You are an arrogant and rude commenter.
Help these gentlemans to make a World richest man V. Putin to get more land , slaves, natural resourges. They are the Putins payroll are you supportin him for free. Ask money fot it.
You have chosen the wrong video. Didn't you bother to listen and even read his books?????
India needs to settle that border nonsense with China and Pakistan.
Draw a border line people and move on.
It's all unpopulated hills and empty space.
Bigger fish to Fry.
It's other way around
Pakistan and China need to settle their borders
Erdogan does not support Palestine. this guy is full of it.
his electorate does, so Erdogan is forced to go along.
Erdogan halted all trade with Israel
Türkiye is the country that provides the most aid to Palestine and today's news is that Hamas wants Turkiye to be a guarantor country check your fake sources 😂😂😂
@@anorthedge4422Most of my people support the Palestinian people.😮😂
@@TUR7777 Agreed.
🚀 Master Kim 🚀
Has 🇰🇵The Best
🚀Vaccine 🚀
to an International
Dis-ease so called
: 🎃.NATO.🎃.
🌀🧞🌀🧞🌀
isn't it pravda that Ukraine Become a Pia-no
keyboard for
NATO Composer
to play :
(zeL+en+sky) style Symphony of Necropolis, For:
Black Rock,💱
Black Stone,💱
Black Water,💱
In White House.
What a clowns.
Macronising! 😂
Omicron variant , more to point .
It’s a matter of scale: Swiss , suedes snd fins couldn’t resist the pressure of US / AIEPEC Davos club of maniacs. And lost their Neutrality.
As Turkey is much bigger another culture and religion and as the col. rightfully said their important geography geopolitical importance in the new world order of BRICS
Great guests . Nima you should have millions of views . Far more truthful than anything on mainstream lie and propaganda tv
U are awesome interviewer! I stopped watching Danny H. after he asked Richard Wolff for opinion about current state of dollar and told him several times that Richard only had 60 seconds because Danny wanted to dedicate 2nd half of that podcast to hear Danny talking.
As a Turk, I can say that I hope we leave NATO. We are embargoed in every field and NATO sees us as a second-class country. We are tired of the US's bilateral policy. A more equitable growth together with BRICS+ will benefit us. Losing Turkey, which is located in the middle of the world and provides an important intercontinental logistics opportunity, will put NATO in a difficult situation.
BRICS would make Turkish government and potentially even the future governments more oppressive and authoritarian. And why are you speaking for the country saying "we" in every sentence. You "as a Turk" is not the only perspective of Turks on this. My perspective is the opposite of yours. I don't want Turkey to be a country aligned with unprogressive countries like China and Russia. Reading your last sentence, it is easy to see you are just another troll bot because your intentions are not in favor of Turkey, they are simply anti-NATO. Russian propaganda in Turkey is so strong, I can even see it within my west-leaning friends and colleagues living in Turkey. For those of us Turks living abroad, there is a stark difference in perceptions of reality on this.
@@cemdursun Türk olduğumu biliyorsun Türkçe konuşsana. ABD nin ve Avrupa nın Türkiye ye ambargo uygulayıp ihtiyacı olan sistemleri vermemesinden memnuniyet mi duyuyorsun? ABD, İngiltere ve Fransa'nın Türkiye nin doğusunda Türklere karşı yapılanmış terör örgütünü desteklemesini doğru mu buluyorsun? Biz Türkler ve hükümetimiz bu durumdan rahatsızız senin fikrin seni ilgilendirir.
@@Alfonzo01 “biz turkler ve hukumetimiz” ilkokulda falansin sen herhalde pardon ustune geldiysem. Sana kolay gelsin kucuk adam. Hukumetcilik oynamaya devam
@@cemdursun Boş yapıyorsun Türkiye nin ne görüşte olduğunu öğrenmek istiyorsan Cumhurbaşkanını dinle
@@cemdursun Çin'e unprogressive dediğin anda devamını okumadım. Batı propagandası yiyen sensin kardeşim. Rejimlerin otoriter, demokratik olması öyle pat küt diye olucak şeyler değil. Benim de isteğim burjuvalıktan kapitalistlikten çok, daha halka yönelik yani sosyalist olunması. Çok kötü derecede kapitalist bir devletiz ve bunun sebebi özellikle Amerikanın NATO yu kullanarak 1960'lardan beri ülkemizde faşizm ve terörizmi kullanarak ''komünizme' karşı operasyonlar yürütmesi. Tabi onların gözünde en ufak sosyalistler bile komünistti. Eğer devrim olacaksa, rejim değişecekse bu bağımsızca gerçekleşmelidir. Batı ya da doğunun desteği, işbirliği ile değil. Hiçbirşeyden haberin yok diyemem ama kusura bakma Türkiyenin yakın tarihi hakkında pek bir fikrin yok. Basit bir ideoloji sempatizanısın. Batıda da bu sömürgeciliğin ( colonialism değil he sugar coated versiyonudur bu, daha doğrusu exploitism olur. Zaten haklı bir şekilde bizlerde 'kolonicilik' diye bir terim duyulmamıştır.) getirdiği zenginliklerle fonlanan bilimsel, sosyal olarak ilerlemiş ülkelerin başkalarına ait olan zenginliklerinden sen faydalanıyosun. Ne mutlu sana herkes iyi kazanıp iyi yaşamak ister, hakkıdır. Bunu sana anımsatmamın sebebi de şu an yaşadığın toprakların objektif gerçeklerin üstünü sisle kapatmasına izin vermemen gerektiğini sana göstermek. Yoksa neden orda yaşıyosun diye sormak haddime değil. Yaşa tabi.
İlkokul lafını kullanayım. Uhu uhu batı hoş uhu uhu doğu pis ve başka argüman sunmazsan naifsindir. E bilmemekte ayıp değil. Lakin bilmeden konuşursan senin yaptığın mı daha ayıp olur yoksa bilenlerin sana dalgavari bakması mı daha ayıp olur? Muhakemesini sana bırakıyorum.
When russia will take back Odessa and control the Black sea and so can easily reach the mediterraen . It's game over for UE
brics üyesi olursak biz TÜRKİYE olarak bu duruma izin veririz. Antlaşmalar ortada
You can't be part of brics if you apply sanctions on another member. Turkey will never be in brics if they keep the sanctions
i love it that BRICS are anti sanctions between members. The west has nothing but sanctions!
They are killing themselves.
Turkey can not be in BRICS while supplying weapons to Ukraine.
Russia invited to Turkiye for BRICS.Also China support to BRICS membership of Turkiye.
Guys , this is just economic union similar to G7. There's no harm to be part of the BRICS. This has no link to NATO. Japan is in G7 but not NATO member.
@@johnbodman4504Putin himself said “They would happily accept Turkey into BRICS if they wanted to apply” lol
What are you talking about?
🦃🦃💪💪
are u 🦃 or turkish?Which one?
Jacques Boud talks a lot of sense .
The European Union can be a very powerful power with Turkiye, but the USA, Russia and other sides does not want this.