Professor Explains History of China, Taiwan, and Hong Kong, Pre-2010 | Wondrium
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 авг 2024
- Want to stream more content like this… and 1,000’s of courses, documentaries & more?
👉 👉 Start Your Free Trial of Wondrium tinyurl.com/465dx65r 👈 👈
-------------------------------------------
Life under foreign rule by a massive empire isn't confined to ancient Egypt or the American colonies-today it's everyday life for over 30 million people in Hong Kong and Taiwan. Tensions are rising between China and its "lost territories," including riots and military occupational exercises. Steel your nerves-Taiwan's 2,000-year journey for independence may be coming to a head in our lifetimes.
This video is episode 44 from the series The Fall and Rise of China, presented by Richard Baum.
Learn more about China's history at wondrium.com/youtube
0:00 1997 Return of Hong Kong from British to Chinese
5:24 Joint Declaration on Hong Kong and Basic Law
8:52 Taiwan's Opposition to Reunification with China
12:41 Democratic Progressive Party Challenges Kuomintang
14:02 Lee Teng-hui Becomes Taiwan's First Native President
17:07 Teng-hui's Provocative Pro-Independence Speech
19:19 Chen Shui-bian Ends Kuomintang's Ruling Streak
20:49 George W. Bush Challenges Taiwanese Independence
23:42 Was Shui-bian's Assassination Attempt a Hoax?
27:22 Ma Ying-jeou Vows to Repair Relations with China
29:01 China's Relationship With Taiwan Improves
-------------------------------------------
Welcome to Wondrium on RUclips.
Here, you can enjoy a carefully curated selection of educational videos from our library of history and science series.
If you’ve ever wanted to travel back in time, wondered about the science of life, or dreamt of exploring the stars, then Wondrium will be your new favorite channel!
If you decide you’d like to learn more about what you love, check out the full experience at wondrium.com/RUclips
There, you’ll find in-depth answers to everything you’ve ever wondered, with mind-blowing surprises along the way.
Your brain is going to love this place!
-------------------------------------------
You can also read thousands of articles from the smartest experts in their fields at Wondrium Daily: www.WondriumDaily.com
And, of course, check us out on all of our social channels:
-Facebook: / wondrium
-Twitter: / wondrium
-Instagram: / wondrium
#China #HongKong #Taiwan
He starts out with an anachronism, talking about how the British took over Hong Kong, as though it were a thriving port city way back then. It was a fishing village with twelve families living there.
It’s also America’s national strategy to keep Taiwan independent from mainland China to help America maintain its controlling power of the area, which was originally for fighting against Soviet Union’s power expansion there. It’s America’s interest to have Taiwan separated from China.
Did he explain How
- Mogon, Rothschild, Ivy League universities got their first pot of gold from Opium trade?
- East India Company stole 45 Trillions from India by trains?
- US supported the Arab Dictator in drafting OPEC and use USD as the Petro Dollars?
- The Genocide of Natives Red Indians and Aboriginal people and the stealing of the entire continent of North America and South Pacific?
That’s why no country should trust the devil
@@kooklocklann9996 You mean no country should trust China? Well, I wouldn't go that far but certainly I agree that the Chinese Government is greedy and untrusworthy.
Never mind tge interests of the US , Taiwan really needs to tighten up those defenses and keep PRC out.
The commentator made a remark about the native Americans which he refered to as " Red Indians" ouch. One shouldn't say that. The American natived really don't appreciate this term. In any case the American natives have nothing to do with eithrt HK or Taiwan.
I'm also guessing the good man giving the lecture must have oroginally been presented a few years ago before Beijing crushed HK'S democracy.
@@morejoy5188 the American government are the one greedy and can never be trusted.
@@morejoy5188 China and hk, china have more democracy than americans. American democracy is fake. 🤣
This guy's voice is awesome. I hope he doe audiobooks
Sharing below written by a Malaysian RUclipsr:
I’m from Malaysia. China has traded with Malaysia for 2000 years. In those years, they had been the world’s biggest powers many times. Never once they sent troops to take our land. Admiral Zhenghe came to Malacca five times, in gigantic fleets, and a flagship eight times the size of Christopher Columbus’ flagship, Santa Maria. He could have seized Malacca easily, but he did not. In 1511, the Portuguese came. In 1642, the Dutch came. In the 18th century the British came. We were colonised by each, one after another.
When China wanted spices from India, they traded with the Indians. When they wanted gems, they traded with the Persian. They didn’t take lands. The only time China expanded beyond their current borders was in Yuan Dynasty, when Genghis and his descendants Ogedei Khan, Guyuk Khan & Kublai Khan concurred China, Mid Asia and Eastern Europe. But Yuan Dynasty, although being based in China, was a part of the Mongolian Empire.
Then came the Century of Humiliation. Britain smuggled opium into China to dope the population, a strategy to turn the trade deficit around, after the British could not find enough silver to pay the Qing Dynasty in their tea and porcelain trades. After the opium warehouses were burned down and ports were closed by the Chinese in ordered to curb opium, the British started the Opium War I, which China lost. Hong Kong was forced to be surrendered to the British in a peace talk (Nanjing Treaty). The British owned 90% of the opium market in China, during that time, Queen Victoria was the world’s biggest drug baron. The remaining 10% was owned by American merchants from Boston. Many of Boston’s institutions were built with profit from opium.
After 12 years of Nanjing Treaty, the West started getting really really greedy. The British wanted the Qing government:
1. To open the borders of China to allow goods coming in and out freely, and tax free.
2. Make opium legal in China.
Insane requests, Qing government said no. The British and French (with supports from the US), started Opium War II with China, which again, China lost. The Anglo-French military raided the Summer Palace, and threatened to burn down the Imperial Palace, the Qing government was forced to pay with ports, free business zones, 300,000 kilograms of silver and Kowloon was taken. Since then, China’s resources flew out freely through these business zones and ports. In the subsequent amendment to the treaties, Chinese people were sold overseas to serve as labor.
In 1900, China suffered attacks by the 8-National Alliance. These ,8-Robbers were: Empire of Japan, Russian Empire, British Empire (including India), France, USA, Germany, Italy and Austria-Hungary. Innocent Chinese civilians in Peking (Beijing now) were murdered, buildings were destroyed & women were raped. The Imperial Palace was raided, and treasures ended up in museums like the British Museum in London and the Louvre in Paris.
In late 1930s China was occupied by the Japanese in WWII. Millions of Chinese died during the occupancy. 300,000 Chinese died in Nanjing Massacre alone.
Mao brought China together again from the shambles. There were peace and unity for some time. But Mao’s later reign saw sufferings and deaths from famine and power struggles.
Then came Deng Xiao Ping and his infamous “black-cat and white-cat” story. His preference in pragmatism than ideologies has transformed China. This thinking allowed China to evolve all the time to adapt to the actual needs in the country, instead of rigidly bounded to ideologies. It also signified the death of Communism in actually practice in China. The current Socialism+Meritocracy+Market Economy model fits the Chinese like gloves, and it propels the uprise of China. Singapore has a similar model, and has been arguably more successful than Hong Kong, because Hong Kong being gateway to China, was riding on the economic boom in China, while Singapore had no one to gain from.
In just 30 years, the CPC have moved 800 millions of people out from poverty. The rate of growth is unprecedented in human history. They have built the biggest mobile network, by far the biggest high speed rail network in the world, and they have become a behemoth in infrastructure. They made a fishing village called Shenzhen into the world’s second largest technological centre after the Silicon Valley. They are growing into a technological power house. It has the most elaborate e-commerce and cashless payment system in the world. They have launched exploration to Mars. The Chinese are living a good life and China has become one of the safest countries in the world. The level of patriotism in the country has reached an unprecedented height.
For all of the achievements, the West has nothing good to say about it. China suffers from intense anti-China propagandas from the West. Western Media used the keyword “Communist” to instil fear and hatred towards China.
Everything China does is negatively reported.
They claimed China used slave labor in making iPhones. The truth was, Apple was the most profitable company in the world, it took most of the profit, leave some to Foxconn (a Taiwanese company) and little to the labor.
They claimed China was inhuman with one-child policy. At the same time, they accused China of polluting the earth with its huge population. The fact is the Chinese consume just 30% of energy per capita compared to the US.
They claimed China underwent ethnic cleansing in Xinjiang. The fact is China has a policy which priorities ethnic minorities. For a long time, the ethnic minorities were allowed to have two children and the majority Han only allowed one. The minorities are allowed a lower score for university intakes. There are 39,000 mosque in China, and 2100 in the US. China has about 3 times more mosque per muslim than the US.
When terrorist attacks happened in Xinjiang, China had two choices:
1. Re-educate the Uighur extremists before they turned terrorists.
2. Let them be, after they launch attacks and killed innocent people, bomb their homes.
China chose 1 to solve problem from the root and not to do killing. How the US solve terrorism? Fire missiles from battleships, drop bombs from the sky.
During the pandemic,
When China took extreme measures to lockdown the people, they were accused of being inhuman.
When China recovered swiftly because of the extreme measures, they were accused of lying about the actual numbers.
When China’s cases became so low that they could provide medical support to other countries, they were accused of politically motivated.
Western Media always have reasons to bash China.
Just like any country, there are irresponsible individuals from China which do bad and dirty things, but the China government overall has done very well. But I hear this comment over and over by people from the West: I like Chinese people, but the CPC is evil. What they really want is the Chinese to change the government, because the current one is too good.
Fortunately China is not a multi-party democratic country, otherwise the opposition party in China will be supported by notorious NGOs (Non-Government Organization) of the USA, like the NED (National Endowment for Democracy), to topple the ruling party. The US and the British couldn’t crack Mainland China, so they work on Hong Kong. Of all the ex-British colonial countries, only the Hong Kongers were offered BNOs by the British. Because the UK would like the Hong Kongers to think they are British citizens, not Chinese. A divide-and-conquer strategy, which they often used in Color Revolutions around the world.
They resort to low dirty tricks like detaining Huawei’s CFO & banning Huawei. They raised a silly trade war which benefits no one. Trade deficit always exist between a developing and a developed country. USA is like a luxury car seller who ask a farmer: why am I always buying your vegetables and you haven’t bought any of my cars?
When the Chinese were making socks for the world 30 years ago, the world let it be. But when Chinese started to make high technology products, like Huawei and DJI, it caused red-alert. Because when Western and Japanese products are equal to Chinese in technologies, they could never match the Chinese in prices. First world countries want China to continue in making socks. Instead of stepping up themselves, they want to pull China down.
The recent movement by the US against China has a very important background. When Libya, Iran, and China decided to ditch the US dollar in oil trades, Gaddafi’s was killed by the US, Iran was being sanctioned by the US, and now it’s China’s turn. The US has been printing money out of nothing. The only reason why the US Dollar is still widely accepted, is because it’s the only currency which oil is allowed to be traded with. The US has an agreement with Saudi that oil must be traded in US dollar ONLY. Without the petrol-dollar status, the US dollars will sink, and America will fall. Therefore anyone trying to disobey this order will be eliminated. China will soon use a gold-backed crypto-currency, the alarms in the White House go off like mad.
China’s achievement has been by hard work. Not by looting the world.
I have deep sympathy for China for all the suffering, but now I feel happy for them. China is not rising, they are going back to where they belong. Good luck China.
Informative. Thanks for you details.
Excellent comments and thank you for taking your time to share this. The same things can be said for cuba and the western media. All lies and propaganda. Don’t believe media. Cheers
A big piece of history
Very well said. For very long the west has suffered a deficit of well travelled and informed journalists. The few who have only tended to report stories that sell in their popular tabloids. With internet now, people are now able to see for themselves what Chinese people are all about.
Why do so many Asian people want to steer clear of China then... especially those in Taiwan and even Vietnam. Largely because China cares little about individual rights. Also... the map of China as is seen today is the result of centuries of conquest by the Han Chinese ... the western part of China was once populated NOT by the Han Chinese but Central Asian people... most of whom were Islamic. The Han Chinese Empire spread westward through conquest. The latest conquest was Tibet in 1958. The British had a ship based empire... the Han Chinese conquered on horseback.
Rest in peace Prof. Baum! Had the honor of attending his Chinese politics classes at UCLA. Best professor ever.
He's the most anti US propaganda ever. The hard opposite of the US political leadership
@Srika Redhouse to be fair there isnt jus one typical White Dude ..quite a broad statement of urz , he appears to have a depth of commitment to his studies that may differ from urz, Oh and nice racial slant sounds so PC but...
The Prof. failed to mention that, as a colony of the U.K., Chinese in Hong Kong had no ability to vote at all. Instead, he left the impression that there was an Assembly. So which was it? Could Hong Kong Chinese vote for the members of an Assembly while Hong Kong belonged to the U.K.? The Prof. also doesn't adequately describe the significance of economic relations between the P.R.C. (People's Republic of China) and Taiwan. He does point out with his mention of voting numbers of the people of Taiwan, that independence or belonging to the P.R.C. seems not to be the main concern of Taiwanese. Their concern seems to be whether there'll be prosperity or not.
Now if he did mention these, he’d be losing a whole lot of viewers wouldn’t he.
Because, as you say, independence from the communist Chinese jackboot, may not be the only concern for Taiwan. It is certainly a pinical concern, if you cannot see that, you're living in cloud coockoo land. A less than independent one!
His facts are more clearer than i could imagine. No BS or propaganda. Just at what it is. Great job.
He is full of bias.
Dr. Baum...you are really amazing. I hated lectures in college and graduate school...because you were not my prof. You move things along at the right pace and provide lots of interesting ideas and facts. Thank you! I am now one of your groupies. :)
he's been dead since late 2012. You can still watch and admire him, though.
corbeau I just realized that too.
Very fair and truthful presentations of the history.
VERY WELL PRESENTED! The endless American influence on all this politics was omitted, so I feel I got only part of the story.
This is how history should be written and interpreted. A neutral and impartial analysis without bias. No hypocritical double standards.... No doubt this informative analysis doesn't sit well with western mainstream views.....
Oo
You're nuts. This IS the western mainstream view.
@@alinazang6651 Not precise, it's correct to say that's western mainstream view but it's been sidelined as China to be the new demon to the west, and Taiwan will serve as a proxy of "democracy" so much so that's why this lecture has totally neglected Macao that has not such turmoil like we saw in HK that it has brought up as an attentive comparison in the beginning to mark such propagandic blow for it to be "mainstream".
@@alinazang6651 yeah. I was skeptical when he started talking about the lack of censorship and non intervention in Hong Kong. Is Hong Kong really so free and open?
The speech does not trace back to any earlier history of either HK or TW before the Opium War, unfortunately. On the other words, he still interprets and explains the history from an common western view to China.
@Alonso Spenser Nobody should pledge other people’s life in order to satisfy their proud
@@scottworthy5569 so please explain why Lincoln started the civil war. Obviously “pledge other people’s life in order to satisfy their proud”
这种教授西方一抓一大把，老殖民者了，高高在上看事情
@@philchang6416 - is the people of taiwan happy with their lives today ? , not under china rules .
@@privateconfidential7056 how do you know? I traveled to Taiwan and I heard the locals wanna reunion with Mainland China. They wanna rule by China instead of the recent government
Welcome to Taiwan 🇹🇼 and I think you will love the people there. Love from Taiwanese 🇹🇼
Fantastic factual analysis of Hong Kong and Taiwan, especially with the latter. Professor Baum has put together otherwise complex political dynamics in easy to follow language to reveal the historical evolvement of Hong Kong and Taiwan. I hope the good professor will elaborate more on Hong Kong, in light of the uprising and chaos since last year.
The chaos was provoked and incited by the USA.
@@mikemurray2027 By provoked do you mean by being an example of a free country that respects the rights of its people? You forgot to blame covid19 on the USA also.
@@wesleymatson9413 No, I don't. I mean that the USA was trying to stir up trouble in HK as a means of attacking China.
The USA has absolutely no business in HK or China.
he dead ...maybe a celestial update in the workz
@@mikemurray2027 Good Move right ? Gotta stop a Cancer before it Grows , ...start learning Mandarin , Cantonese is on the way out :(
This is very excellent presentation of modern Chinese history about Hong Kong and Taiwan. Thanks for the great job. I think students or viewers learn so much about the background behind the news.
This lecture is historically correct and unabiased to either party. Great history lecture rarely found in current media.
China always said this is the western bias no matter what !
Omission of macau in the conversation, does not a balanced view make.
@@WasLostButNowAmFound Glad you see it for what it is, too.
Nowadays, the world is changing so fast. Can anyone make a promise for anything will be staying the same for 50 years long? He did mentions the agreement between the governments of China and British but how about what is the situation today, especially when US and his lapdogs are jealous about China’s rising economy and can’t wait to tear China to pieces. What is China doing now is just to legislate the Security law to protect the country against being apart after more than a year riot and robbery in HK . You can easily find many videos posted online from HongKong about the riot happened last year and you will know how the majority people in HongKong think about which way is the best for them. Don’t just listen to the politicians. God bless HongKong, God bless China, and pray for world peace! Thank you🙏
There is a clearly bias in his message spreading hatred against China. ruclips.net/video/ZPYuGYLesx0/видео.html
This is good stuff. Thank you whoever posted this very informative video. I learned a lot. 😊
Thank you for your comment, Margaret. We are glad you enjoyed this video.
Never stop learning!
As a Chinese, the professor is very neutral I'v ever seen in RUclips!!! Here is a description in China Mainland: Since the Mainland-Taiwan's relationship is a continuing one from 1949 of the Civil War, however there is no any armistice agreement between the CPP and KMT, and that is the root reason why Taiwan is different with HongKong. This video suspend in 2008, hope more analysis for these years!
Taiwan is ranked the most democratic country in Asia by the Economist EIU. Furthermore, Taiwan's economic growth rates are higher than that of South Korea, Japan, and Singapore three years in a row. In fact, Taiwan's economic growth rate of 6.3% in 2021 is one of the highest numbers in last 30 years. One of the reasons that the CCP wants to invade Taiwan because Taiwan is a democratic, free, and prosperous country while China is an authoritarian state.
then why the Zhong Tian TV was banned by Taiwan government freely?
@@alanssshh The news channel of Zhong Tian TV is still broadcasting more than ten hours of news daily through RUclips, Facebook, Twitter, etc social medias. But they can not use public TV spectrum free of charge anymore because they used free public property to promote the KMT only, while the other TV news channels cover all political parties in a more balanced manner.
so Taiwan government banned Zhong Tian TV by the name of not liking DDP? how democratic in Taiwan? and you are proud about it.LOL
@@alanssshh Hi, poor communist Chinese, looks like you don't understand what is the democracy, freedom of speech and rule of law. FYI, Taiwan is also rated by a NGO, Freedom House, with a Freedom Index of 93 out of 100. Taiwan is one of the highest rated countries while China is rated with a very poor score of 9.
Furthermore, that news TV channel was conditionally renewed license 8 years ago by the KMT government with strict conditions of improvement on balanced news coverage as well as installing an independent outside expert monitoring the progress of improvement etc. But that news channel had done non of those improvements demanded by the independent committee Instituted by the Taiwan Congress.
I just discovered this channel. What a nice breeze to hear unbiased and factual lecture about HK/Taiwan history from an English speaking expert! As Chinese living in Canada, I am originally from Zhuhai by the way, a city you mentioned in your video :-) Your video definitely helps to fill in some gaps, eg. Dates and details of the events. I will for sure forward your video to many people here. People needs to understand the complicated past of these territories before they form an opinion or have a discussion with anyone. Education education education of history is the way to go in order to better understand our current world! Thank you so much for educating those who are willing to learn.
Thank you so much for your feedback, we are glad you enjoyed this lecture.
Thank you for enlightening us to know what is going on in China and Tiwan God bless you Man.
Straightforward facts without bias or nuances. Thank you, Professor!
the bias was subtle but research and experience was clearly Taiwan based. The depth in regards to China mainland perspective is very much in lacking. Humanizing the Taiwan perspective without actual experience or understanding of the mainland perspective...leads to this bias.
@@titusp9488 A fair observation. Thanks for pointing that out.
@@titusp9488 me hz
@@titusp9488 , “humanizing” Taiwan (or any country) is easy when set next to the CCP’s belligerence.
Hahaha...Western bias is promulgated through what is NOT said ...like Taiwan was returned to China in October 1945 and agreed by the Allies for Chinas contribution to defeating Japan. The Chinese people overthrew a puppet pro western government that did nothing to elevate the plight of poor Chinese. The west in its typical acts of duplicity to didn't want to honor that agreement since their puppet was no longer in power.
The professor said every Chinese name correctly, excellent mandarin pronunciation
Ben young Too bad his assessment of Hong Kong isn't as impeccable as his pronounciation.
@@kimberlynolin2100 and yours is correct? Lol
What a bunch of lies why don't you ask the people of Taiwan and Hong Kong if they want to be back with China. A resounding no
gregoryian123 the CCP sucks but the facts they are all Chinese and they were originally came from China.
yeah, suspiciously well 😁
It sounds absurd that the British negotiated for a package deal with Beijing when it no longer had any rights on Hong Kong and the surrounding territories. China is the landlord.
Don’t say that. White peoples is entitled to owe the world you see. According to them governments and news
Correction, whether you are a “believer or not”, the creator of this universe is the landlord. We are all ephemeral tenants in this physically, morally and intellectually limited terrestrial existence.
The people in HK were granted British Citizenship since they ARE subjects of the British Empire. In the same way that just because a landlord may own a building you are renting it does NOT mean the tenant has no rights! Landlords can not just evict a tenant nor violate their human and legal rights. As British citizens Britain would either have to accept millions of HK people as refugees fleeing Chinese dictatorship and socialist tyranny which would mean Britain would have a sudden problem dealing with refugees AND china would effectively have killed the Golden goose they wanted that was laying the best gold eggs in Asia! Thus both China and Britain negotiated to maintain the legal and democratic rights so that the Chinese Communists would not violate human rights nor subject HK British citizens to illegal arrests etc that would justify HK peoples being legitimately classed as refugees.
Anyone who knows any history about socialists should know they are liars and tyrants who can never be trusted to keep any promises, and Taiwan has seen how the de facto Chinese Emperor has reneged on all the promises made to HK's citizens...elections being rigged, pro-democracy politicians being blackmailed and intimidated not to stand against pro-CCP puppets, police becoming Gestapo to beat protestors, illegal arrests and secret 'extraditions' (kidnapping by the Chinese state of pro-rights/freedom activists) and wrongful jailing whether or not they are even charged and have a kangaroo court trials of any and all dissenters to the Communist oppression, and of course people just being made to disappear or commit suicide! That's why despite Chinese sanctions and military intimidation of Taiwan the Taiwanese are still willing to fight to the death to keep their democracy and liberty.
@@eddesa5134 people in HK most certainly WEREN’T given British citizenship. What they could apply for was British Oversea Citizenship. Which does not even grant the holder rights of abode in UK.
@@xsu-is7vq There was a debate prior to handover in 1997 about what to do. Both the UK and China feared the impact of having over 5 million Hong Kong people suddenly arrive in the UK (and most likely try to live in London which at that time only had a population between 3-4 million!) - it would leave China with a dead duck and Britain with a housing and welfare crisis; hence the negotiations to deter people from abandoning HK.
China would adopt a 'one country, two systems' approach promising to respect the democratic and legal rights which the HK people enjoyed that Chinese citizens do NOT, and Britain would not issue automatic full British citizenship rights but create hurdles: so people born and resident in Hong Kong before 1 July 1997 were able to register as a British national (overseas).
British overseas territories citizens from Hong Kong who did not register as British nationals (overseas) and had no other nationality or citizenship on 30 June 1997 became British overseas citizens automatically on 1 July 1997. They can hold a British passport and get consular assistance and protection from UK diplomatic posts but don't have an AUTOMATIC right to live or work in the UK, and are not considered a UK 'NATIONAL' by the European Union (EU). Once they get the BNO passport they and family members can apply for a BNO visa which DOES allow them to live, work and study in the UK! You can apply to stay for either 2.5 years or 5 years then extend the visa as many times as you want. After you’ve lived in the UK for 5 years, you can apply to live in the UK permanently. The point with the BNO visa is it stops a person being entitled to claim most of the welfare benefits which citizens would be entitled to.
www.gov.uk/british-national-overseas-bno-visa
Since China broke its promises and has been acting as a typical socialist tyranny Britain has done what it warned China it would do in such an event and that is allow HK citizens who were loyal British Empire subjects to come to Britain to escape the CCP tyranny.
www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/hong-kong-bno-passport-britain/2021/01/29/1d5b6f9e-620c-11eb-a177-7765f29a9524_story.html
You are brilliant! Your gentle, balanced and totally unbiased approach allows your knowledge to reach even those who would never question China's government. An amazing achievement (happening while I'm writing...)
Thank you!
This needs to be updated!
There is a point I disagree with.
The professor talks about 'ethnic' Taiwanese, but the Republic of China (Taiwan) is not independent. The ROC encompasses the whole of mainland China so the ethnic Taiwanese are the same as ethnic Californians - they are still part of the same country so not like ethnic Germans and Dutch.
There are not a single ethnic called “Taiwanese”. In Taiwan, people are also Han, Hui, Manchurian and others like in mainland China. The indigenous people have different ethnicities as well. Some mixed with people from mainland more and some less.
Taiwan and Penghu are leftover issues from World War II. See Treaty of San Francisco.
At the time, the U.S. government helped the Chinese Nationalist Party (Republic of China), which had been defeated in the Chinese Civil War, escape to Taiwan, which was then a Japanese colony. See Formosa betrayed.
After the Chinese Kuomintang came to Taiwan, it still maintained dictatorial rule, but moved towards democracy under pressure from the United States, and the Taiwanese entered the Republic of China to fight for their rights.
The Chinese who lost their privileges in Taiwan united with the People's Republic of China to steal Taiwan and Penghu.
@@user-oq1oc4qx4p Taiwan is a province of China.
@@irahoppe3632
In the Treaty of San Francisco, China did not obtain territorial sovereignty over Taiwan and Penghu.
@@user-oq1oc4qx4p The treaty is ambiguous. Just because the Americans say something does not make it a fact.
Japan gave up all rights, claims, etc over Taiwan. This suggests it reverted to what it was before Japan took possession.
It is like saying Japan took over Hawaii and incorporated it into the Japanese empire till it lost the war - then what? Does anyone seriously think its status would be unsure? There is no doubt it would be returned to the US.
The rest of the world, including the US, and except for a very few minor states, recognizes China and Taiwan as one nation.
In fact, if you look at a map of the ROC, it claims all of mainland China, and more.
The PRC has the seat at the UN, not the ROC.
Can’t wait until the next episode ! Thank you Professor !
Toi Cheung There is a clearly bias in his message spreading hatred against China. ruclips.net/video/ZPYuGYLesx0/видео.html
He is dead now - you idiote.
Watching this in light of current events is chilling. We're going to need a followup course on modern China/international relations.
J.A. Renau most people especially in America don’t know anything about ancient Asian Civilizations.
@@karendalsadik7119 Most people in America don't know their own history.
Kimberly Nolin so true!!!!
this video was uploaded recently. unless it was recorded quite awhile ago, it shows how rose-tinted his vision is when it comes to the ccp controlled china.
@@karendalsadik7119 we know that communism is horrible unlike most of americas youth that has been brain washed by pos lib america hating professors
To get an even better understanding of modern China, suggest reading/watching the views and opinions of the late Prime Minister of Singapore Mr Lee Kuan Yew. He's the only world leader to hv met with all generations of the Chinese leadership n visited China every year for 40 over years. It's unsurprising that leaders around the world sought his counsel on Asia on China including from the US where every president since Nixon has sought his advice about Asia and the world. You can also look up Kishore Mahbubani Dean of the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, a highly trusted aide of Lee Kuan Yew who was also ambassador to the UN
Yeah! At least not a white lecturer. I barely see any white person knows much about China or Asian history that much I mean barely we need Asians to speak for us
Only the Family has the in & out of China-Taiwan issue, not Lee Kuan Yew, and not Dr Baum ! Lee travelled to China numerous times knocking on the Family's doors but the door was never open for him although he's a descendent of the Family - 家里的后代......！
Mr Lee Kuan Yew, a Real Visionary was the Father of Singapore... No amount of money can bribe him...and that is why Singapore & its People Prosper very fast under his Leadership...No Corruption.
did he really explained history how HK became british colony in 19 century? Is there any reason Chinese have to accept Anglo-Saxon dominance ?!
Yeah, the reason is their big gun
@@user-qf9pw7fo3b Those guns are shrinking by the day.
Did he explain How Mogon, Rothschild, Ivy League universities got their first pot of gold from Opium trade?
Did he explain how East India Company stole 45 Trillions from India by trains?
@@yl128pang3 no he did not
@@davidmoss2576 now China should go and get land from England by force
I would consider myself a 'native Han Chinese Taiwanese' as my ancestors came from the mainland at least five generations ago (18xx) and like to share a few historical vital events that mark Taiwan as it is today.
(1) Indigenous people have been living in Taiwan since about 6ooo years ago. They originated from indigenous people from Southeast Asia, Oceania, and Madagascar.
(2) Discovery of Ilha Formosa: In 1542, some Portuguese sailors spotted the island and called it Ilha Formosa.
(3) Dutch Formosa 1624-1662: Dutch were in Taiwan for 38 years, and they started the documentation of Taiwan's history for the first time.
(4) Zhen Cheng Gong era: In 1662, the Ming dynasty general defeated the Dutch and established an exile regime in Taiwan to instaurate Ming dynasty back in China. Unfortunately, he died in Taiwan end of 1662 and never fulfilled his dream to go back to China.
(5) Ruling of Qing Dynasty in Taiwan: By 168x China's Qing dynasty established its administration in Taiwan. By then, there were many Han Chinese settlers in Taiwan. Most of them came from China's Fujian province (mainly from Quanzhou and Zhangzhou areas)
(6) Japanese rule: In 1895, the Qing dynasty lost the sino-Japan war to Japan and signed Taiwan off to Japan as a colony. During the Japanese colonization, Taiwanese underwent Japanese education, although most Han Taiwanese spoke Taiwanese dialect at home. In 1945 Japan gave Taiwan back to China under the Republic of China's rule. (R.O.C.)
(7) Taiwan, R.O.C. era: In 1949, R.O.C.'s Chiang Kai-shek retreated to Taiwan. With a few mismanagement incidents (e.g. hyperinflation in 1945, which lead to a revaluation of the 'old' Taiwan dollar to today's New Taiwan Dollar- N.T. dollar; as well as the 2.2.8 unrest in 1947)
I believe this mixed history makes Taiwan's political environment less centralized and more diversified than Mainland China.
If Taiwan wants to be separated, it will more focus on the native history. If Taiwan wants to be reunited, it will more focus on the history that connected to Mainland China. History is neutral, it's all about how you interpret it today, that's why Taiwanese's history education today is total different from 20 years ago, and that's the time when DPP came to power in 2000.
More diversity than mainland? Little boy
Taiwan and Penghu are leftover issues from World War II. See Treaty of San Francisco.
At the time, the U.S. government helped the Chinese Nationalist Party (Republic of China), which had been defeated in the Chinese Civil War, escape to Taiwan, which was then a Japanese colony. See Formosa betrayed.
After the Chinese Kuomintang came to Taiwan, it still maintained dictatorial rule, but moved towards democracy under pressure from the United States, and the Taiwanese entered the Republic of China to fight for their rights.
The Chinese who lost their privileges in Taiwan united with the People's Republic of China to steal Taiwan and Penghu.
Excellent. I feel more informed because of these type of lessons and how they are explained without the threat of bias ever being contemplated. History as it actually occurred, not told from one particular point of view. Priceless. Thank you.
We appreciate your feedback, Jeffrey, and are very happy to hear you're enjoying our lectures.
Thank you for being a fan.
he is an Axxho1e 💩
Did he explain How Mogon, Rothschild, Ivy League universities got their first pot of gold from Opium trade?
Did he explain how East India Company stole 45 Trillions from India by trains?
@@yl128pang3 he did not but what is your point of calling other such?
No, you are more misinformed.
Great lecture, thanks!
Thank you! Happy learning.
Best lecture I have ever heard about this topic!
Dated. Things have changed since President Tsai's landslide election
Sad.....
@@steveglaser44President Tsai is a sham and a shame with a fake degree from UK.
A very valuable lecture, conveying the truth of a history.
sadly no ... it only represent truth partially ...which is incomplete thus biased
Not the complete truth, without talking about the dirty role of Britain and United evil States.
Very good lecture, given in 2010 but still relevant today. Professor Baum reveals his deep knowledge of Chinese geopolitics. Thanks for posting.
It is relevant for anybody wanted to know the background but sadly they are all broken on July 1,2020 which anger the world.
he is an Axxho1e 💩
Did he explain How Mogon, Rothschild, Ivy League universities got their first pot of gold from Opium trade?
Did he explain how East India Company stole 45 Trillions from India by trains?
soon the last sacks of rice will fall in China
@@yl128pang3 Dr Baum did present the history of China, Hong Kong, and Taiwan fairly. An understand of how the "gold" the universities got is good but it is not the consequence of Opium war but the Siege of the International Legations, also known as the Eight-Nation Alliance or 八國聯軍 in chinese.
Thank you for the lecture!
A China study professor talking “zhuhai” in “Fujian” is like an American study professor talking about the rocket city of Houston in California. It reflects the quality and depth of his scholarship.
Great lecture! But things have been changing in Hong Kong since this was recorded. I wonder if there are/will be any updates to this course.
What has changed?
Very interesting history, I had no idea.
@@micah1754 where do we start? Plenty of news online as to what happened
@@justinkinkade2063 I need to go and do some reading. Any particularly good sources for a summary that you know of?
Post 1997 till today, Hong Kong has remained one of the most free territories around the world, ranking 3rd and well above USA. China has kept to its promise, “scrupulously” as described by the good professor. Current problems in Hong Kong are supported and agitated by Western powers in an effort to counter China.
The change is a series of reaction to the actions. Be reminded, Britain sought criminal charges on protestor trespass, block road. When thousands block main traffic, whole city centers for months, no gov will stand and watch... Plus, hundreds students stormed parliament 😱. Again, imagine hundreds loot West minster waving Russian flags, what MI6 would do??? We all knew what happened after Capitol Hill incident, looters were hunted one by one, military stationed inside for weeks... Smashing!
The history should be told like it was , no personal bias , salute to the Proffessor 👍🏻 , Good teacher definately has good students and follower Our future depends on it .
Thank you for your feedback, we appreciate it, oen.
How come. It is too bias
Good but OUTDATED short history. This is probably recorded in 2010; therefore, Important political events since 2010 are not covered. Many important events happened since 2010.
This series of 48 lectures was released somewhere between 2008 - 2010.
and don't forget tiamenan square where they killed students protesting gotta love the killer commies
@@christopherhand4836 Bonus Army likes your comment
@@christopherhand4836 thanks to the riots in HK last year, we own CCP a sorry for Tiananmen issue. CCP, well done!
@@christopherhand4836 Nobody was killed in Tianenmen. Elsewhere in Beijing, spontaneous fighting broke out between soldiers and people in which soldiers were also killed. Read the account by Graham Earnshaw, the only Western reporter who stayed in the square the whole night. All the others made up stories from their hotel rooms.
DR. Baum my respects to you , could listen to your lectures or lessons regardless of the topics ,you are a great educator.
Bless you Dr. Baum
Thank you for your comments, George! The late Dr. Baum was one of our top professors, and we are glad you got to enjoy his courses.
I just found out this site today. Overall, the lecture content is very informative and helpful. I was born in Taiwan, not affiliated with any political party and moved to Canada at age of 23 in 1974. I have no trouble with if Taiwn wants to be an independant country. Only one thing that I cannot agree with the DPP is that under her brain-washing policies, majorty of Taiwanese do not admit that their grand-parents even before them were originally caming from China. If you talk to Singaporian, at least a lots of them will admit yes, their ancestors were Chinese. Since DPP coming to power, the party has been applying a "soft" approach to seperate themselves from the Chinese root. I think this is a real cause of the problem that the DPP is trying to play with; as a result, to creat a tension beween the two sides.
Their actual roots are in the Philippines. Most people in Southern China are descendants of ancient Filipinos.
Various occupying forces especially the ones coming from Europe erased the regions identity. The ccp enjoys and benefited from the confusion so it continued the narrative of the European colonisers.
Taiwan and other southern states or provinces should recognise this and make their move to form alliances against the consuming insatiable monster.
The sooner the better.
@@xpro2009 Truth is truth, 98.5% of Taiwanese are Han ethnic Chinese
@@watson7042 According to the CCPs and it's wu mao.
@@xpro2009 China per se only have 90% Han Chinese, the proportion is even less than Taiwan's (98.5% or a little less if you like).
@@xpro2009 The irony is that Taiwan is even more ethnically Chinese than mainland China.
Thanks for the lecture. The story is correct but there were few factual and chronological mistakes.
"a few" and "few" mean completely different things. Placing a comma between "factual" and "and" makes a significant difference.
The Professor should start talking about the independent island of Formosa and how it later became Taiwan.
This what I want to know. Formosa has its own indigenous people and therefore this island is never a part of China.
@@Longtack55 ..Really ?...🤔...👈👈
@@paulwilliams3902
Nonsense.. my late parents from Taiwan, China. We are Chinese.
@@s546813 Taiwan is a independent country
I won't be surprised this Prof has been instrumental in influencing the political outcome of Hong Kong and Taiwan.
For many students at young age of around 20yo, when you paint a stream and craftily say it's a river, many of them will start to believe it's a river each time they see a stream.
Education is generally good but it can also destroy lives if the intention of the educator is evil. This is what we have been witnessing in Hong Kong and Taiwan.
YES YES YES
Rainbow Dance
Why do you mention HK and Taiwan in the same breath?
Are you saying they are part of the same country?
@Huawei is a criminal organization. " He is saying the both have similar issues with the repressive CCP police state"
But why mention Taiwan when it isn't controlled by 'the repressive CCP police state'? I've even had CCP drones admit that Taiwan isn't under the control of the CCP. The only reason to mention HK and Taiwan in the same breath, in my opinion, is as a warning to anyone foolish enough to think "1 country, 2 systems" could ever work under the leadership of the CCP.
What are your thoughts Hiaco?
The information about Taiwan-China relationship offered here is way outdated.
The situation has changed a lot for the last 6 years.
Indeed
academics usually lags behind several years to conduct studies thoroughly, things like research and data collection, which all takes time.
The contents are just a reflection of the status quo of that area, it does not require research or data collection, all it requires for one to get up-to-date info is paying attention to the world news headline.
I think this video was produced a long time ago. However, this post on youtube may have a bad misleading effect on the viewers.
@@tcdwu
What kind of world headline news would be a reliable source?
@@allenclw3361 unbiased newspaper not relying on institutional support stritly rely on their informative news
As an eyewitness to the 1997 Handover, I stood with a few million other HK people in the rain watching the fireworks and celebrating. At midnight, it was a huge street party. Of course, things have changed.
1997, watched tv from America, when the flag down, folded, a sense of sadness arose for Hong Kong, can't explain why I felt sad, 23 years later the answer revealed.
@@lichen2481 So you'd prefer to sell yourself to the west?
@@Morgue12free If you had to choose, you'd rather be China's whipping boy?
@@lichen2481 feel sad for HK being manipulated by US as a chess againt Mainland? IMAO
@@lichen2481 I watched from the UK
I grew up in HK
My sadness knows no depths now.
Awesome video! Great run down 👍
Thank you. The content is very informative and you have put it in a very interesting way.
Thanks so much for this. You are a great educator and thoughtful speaker.
Beautiful History narrated by the Very Highly experienced, intellectual, Professor.Commandable English vocabulary knowledge.
This guy is a communist puppet !
Never knew this was a lecture😅
Wow
Hahaha
Very very Good narration, clear smooth and nice vocal, comfortable to the ears.
My cousins in HK migrated to the US and Canada just before 1997. They were all back in HK within a few years and are still living in HK. Today
Excellent and in-depth
It is not in-depth when he explained about Taiwan. He should start talking from Formosa and how this independent island later became Taiwan.
GREAT !
COURSES!
The Joint Declaration and the Basic Law are completely tossed up with the replacement of the official start of One Country One System National Security Law.
More like Dictatorship Law - - from HK!!
At last n thanks God help Hong Kong to gain peace after that all the CIA go away n leaves Hong Kong alone too bad the pandemic had slow everything down.
Nice. I can understand clearly.
Excellent lecture
jwangxm388 There is a clearly bias in his message spreading hatred against China. ruclips.net/video/ZPYuGYLesx/видео.html
What a splendid lecture!
Objective and truthful presentation. Young people in Hong Kong should watch this.
From 2020, definitely not updated
If this knowledgeable professor is to be appointed national security adviser or Secretary of State to the Dump administration, I am gonna bet my life savings for our world to be more peaceful and harmonious.
Hong Kong changed tremendously since emperor Xi took power. Loads of regulatory control and brainwashing exercise were imposed to change their system
@@oasislin4587 greatest task is perhaps to change the housing policy. Stop compact housing by private developers.
This was posted in May, but it would be a REAL GOOD IDEA to say when it was recorded.
Escape Felicity clearly says 2010 in the notes
@@anon8095
Thanks I missed it
Still truth and facts do not change. Look up 'school for separatists' and CIA and NED 100 years ruclips.net/video/f9Q19QJpJ4s/видео.html
@@talkfacts100 Ah, the CIA....now you really bring up a topic very very important to be informed about (though very few are)👍🏼👍🏿👍🏾
@@rmp7400 that the ned does, what the cia couldnt do, is a well known cite and common knowledge. And yes really worth getting into this kind of topic. Gives another point of view from indoctrinating msm.
Common my brothers and sisters..let the Chinese decide. Eventually we will be in a family again. Hope the younger Taiwanese and Hong Kongnese won't fall to the European imperialist again.
By the way, I am a Taiwanese residing in Malaysia. My ancestors are from Fujian🙏❤️ No war between our brothers and sisters.. 💀🙏🙏
You obviously do not understand what China is like. Are you sure you’re not looking at the CCP through rose-colored lenses?
@@Goatzies Amen+ Mr Salleh is indeed looking through rose-hued lenses. The Communist Chinese decided to murder 80 million of their own in their initial power grab - and how many millions more were ripped out of their mothers' wombs by soldiers -;for being a female, or a second child for the parents...
Taiwanese participation on the world stage through global organizations and assisting other nations through diplomatic/trade ties is no sign of imperialism - it's a sign that Taiwan is an independent nation!
🇹🇼🇭🇰❤️🇦🇺🇺🇲🇪🇺🇺🇳🇮🇳
@@Goatzies well that history let the past be the past and just move on
@@USA50_ if Taiwan dares to claim a country, Mainland will take it over immediately
Splendid lecture and explanation. Very detailed, chronologic, and enlightening.
How ironic it is! The word of democracy came from the socialism, not capitalism. but right now, the counties of capitalism claimed that they have democracy, not the countries of socialism.
And the capitalists would be wrong.
Lol what? Democracy came from ancient Greece. Moreover democracy involves voting in elections. Are there elections in China? The problem is most Chinese don't know what the word means and mistranslate it as 民主. Adding the word "people's" to a bunch of titles doesn't make you a democracy lmao. How dumb are you?
@@smiley4669 bravo
Excellent lecture. All facts no political BS. Bravo.
Factual, clear and educational.
Hats Off for this educational masterpiece.
So informative .thank you Professor Dr. Baum.
Thank you so much
Wow, I really enjoy that piece, Very Educational and informative, Also very unbiased, I had to subscribe, 👍🏾👍🏾❤️
Taiwanese and HK ppl should have the right to speak for themselves.
As a Taiwanese myself, and learnt the actual history WITHOUT the CCP bias, the truth is Taiwan has never belonged to CCP, which is the Government is now trying to take over Taiwan.
This professor is obviously wrong in many points!!
@@veryhighyo
It's obvious that you only have the problem with CCP.
Historically, Taiwan was and is part of China.
Undeniably true.
M. how lol u probably read “the history “ provided by CCP to come to this. Who doesn’t know their best skill is twisting truth and making up propaganda. lol
veryhighyo I believe your current government is called Republic of China.
Indream Luo I believe British Columbia doesn’t belongs to UK nor Columbia.
Great video, very balanced and informative.
Thank you for your feedback, Karl, much appreciated.
My Oh My... what changes have occured since this was originally broadcast!
Obviously, not a recent lecture!! In fact 10 YEARS OLD
I see the triple 3. It’s a beer brand in Vietnam. Ever been there?
@@anonymousdonor8084 Not Yet, but I wanna go!
Kevin Brown sadly that’s a way off. I bet tourism won’t be available in Vietnam for another 6 months. When you can make it; I’d recommend North Vietnam . Much more interesting and scenic. The southern part is just dirty and congested; partiers paradise. If in for partying go to Pattaya in Thailand.
Factual, unbiased 👍 most important for young minds to not get brainwashed, before able to research independently n draw conclusion thereafter.
Wow....unbiased? 🤔 Please reassess your reaction in, maybe, 20 years.... (And please do not take any injections, that you may have at least the possibility of living that long.)🙏🏼❤
Normally, when a lease ends, the landlord can say: ciao baby, see you around.
And that was Pretty much the case here however some of Hong Kong was freehold , and China was keen not kill the goose that laid golden eggs so did a deal
And the lessor was Qing Dynasty, who were the actual owners, so should be returned to them. CCP never lawfully acquired HKG!
@@drthrottle Not Sure that the lease belongs to the Government rather than the country so I think that you are wrong there . But I thought at the time that maybe the British should have at least threatened to return it to the ROC
@@drthrottle When your house mortgage was sold to another bank, good luck saying to judge that you don't owe money to the new bank.
@@5888max ROC would love to take HK back only if it's physically possible. If possible, ROC wants the Taiwan island float to Hawaii. HK island cannot survive without New Territory and British can't possibly defend HK militarily nor willingly.
Watching today, Aug 2 2022. Nancy Pelosi just arrives in Taiwan.
This amazing lecture helps me understand what’s going on in the other side of the world.
Thank you!!
Just want to say, I think the title of this video is a bit misleading.
If you listen to his entire great course series: the fall and rise of China, you will realise that he covered the Qing Dynasty as well as the opium war. In fact, he provided accounts from both the Chinese and the British sides on their approaches at the conflict.
This video belongs to the later portion of his lectures.
Although there are parts that I do not entirely agree with, such as his evaluation of Deng xiaoping, I find the overall course to be fairly objective.
China is dictator
My two cents: assuming the Great Courses would like to foster further research into their various topics, I would suggest that you put the (1) traditional form of Chinese characters, (2) simplified form, and (3) pinyin onscreen whenever a lecture mentions a Chinese name/word.
Without any of these three, the viewers who do not already know Chinese are left without any concrete way to google that which they wish to research further.
This is necessary because transliterating Chinese words is notoriously difficult, yet without it non-Chinese speakers have no way at all to input a Chinese word into any search engine.
Thanks for the feedback! We're always happy to hear from our fans on how we could better serve them. Never stop learning!
The Great Courses Plus - Very gratifying to get a positive response. :) Greater than the Wall made of tamped earth or bricks, it is the difference in language that divide China and the west. A practical example: ‘Peking’ is a different search term than ‘Beijing’ yet both are referring to the city named 北京. If educators do not make a point of giving the different written forms, 99% of people outside of East Asia won’t even know to look for multiple keywords for the same name in Chinese. Hope that made sense....
The sacred symbol of the Fleur de Lys is not well represented by you, Monsieur.🙄
I had my doubt before watching the video, now i think its one of the best explain the situation. Real professor in deed ! 👍
Well said!
Fun fact, when Hong Kong was under UK’s watch, there was no democracy. After the handover , people start seeking for so call democracy. Though Taiwan was separated from the mainland, the constitution of Taiwan claims their territory including the mainland. For the Taiwan problem, unless PRC gives it up, otherwise war is inevitable.
Yes... but why did Hong Kong people feel safer with the British ? Because even if it was not a true democracy there was less state interference in people's lives... China will impose state rule and strict penalties for those who disagree. I live near the Chinese consulate in Vancouver... often there are protests there staged by people from Tibet, Taiwan or Hong Kong.
@@kevingoodwin5177 Congratulations, you live in the place with the most traitors in China.
Very neutral, non-biased and informative lecture. Thank you. of course more events have happened since then and an updated lecture will be something to look forward to.
china is a horrible communist country as are all communist countries
@@christopherhand4836 US Bombs while Communist China builds.
@@fleyua7176 USA is now colony of China, because China is expert at asymmetrical warfare. Just as deadly, but not as harmful to the environment.
@@rmp7400 Wow nice way to shield your country's human rights abuses.
He didn't mention that of the 2 million Chinese deposited in Taiwan, more than 1.5 million of them were Chinese soldiers... who still saw the Taiwanese as *Japanese*.
Very good point.
They are not viewed as Japanese but at most as collaborators. First as Japanese collaborators. Then, as Communist collaborators resulting in 228 incident.
My understanding was that Taiwanese aborigines had a close genetic relationship to the Japanese however recent studies in genetics show they have more in common with those tribes that occupied the far North East of Asia. Very interesting stuff. The Taiwanese aboriginal genes are also present in the New Zealand Maori as are the Melanesian genes.
@@ytterb917 do you know what "conscription" means?
@@audreyandlinCompany I know what is conscription. I am not saying Taiwaneses were collaborators. I am saying there had such a view among some soldiers in early days. In contrast, viewing Taiwanese as Japanese was rare.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I'M LOVING THIS LECTURE AND FIXATED ON THE BACKGROUND WHICH I RECOGNIZE. THEN SUDDENLY -- AH HA! -- I SEE THE LOGO FOR MY FAVORITE DVD CLASSES OF WHICH I HAVE (LITERALLY) THOUSANDS. ALMOST ALL LECTURES ARE TOP OF THE LINE, FAR SUPERIOR TO ANY PH.D CLASSES I TOOK AT UCLA. WISHING I HAD MAJORED IN THIS PROFESSOR'S FIELD, BECAUSE HE IS TEACHING ME THINGS I NEVER ONCE HEARD ABOUT.
VERY explanatory
Excellent!... thank you!!
very good lecture. Outlining the political evolution of both Hong Kong and Taiwan was tremendously helpful for me in understanding the ever present ongoing conflict between the PRC and the Republic of Taiwan on one hand and Hong Kong on the other hand.
Wow, this video needs an update!
Great information so fluently sir. Thank you very much.
Oh wow, I wanted to check his views on what's happening now but he's gone. RIP.
Josh Santiago he passed away?
@@karendalsadik7119 yeah he's departed.
As a third-generation Hong Kong Chinese, I am obliged to state that I feel the mainland has been extremely lenient and magnanimous toward Hong Kong for the past 23 years. I never had much fear for otherwise in 1997, and my prediction has been correct, as Hong Kong retains a high degree of autonomy beyond the expectation of many.
The West only listens to what they want to hear, but still thank you for your voice
same here.
Love how all the Chinese characters used for all the politicians names are in simplified characters instead of Traditional characters, which are the official script of Taiwan.
Thanks, one of the best educational videos about China and its islands...balance , no bias...
Very informative. The professors narrative have a ring of truth.
Professor Baum is an excellent orator and I appreciate this video being shared. However, considering what has been and currently is happening in Hong Kong, I think it is extremely important that it be stated clearly that this lecture is from 2010. The title of the video could be changed to reflect that, e.g. "Professor Explains History of China, Taiwan, and Hong Kong (2010)" or a title card and/or voice-over could be edited into the beginning of the video. I ask this because it was uploaded last year and may be viewed as a more current explanation of the situation. If this is possible, it would be greatly appreciated. Thank you.
Thank you for the astute observation. We've updated the title to reflect the fact that this video is indeed pre-2010. A lot has changed since then.
@@TheGreatCourses I wasn't sure I'd get a response, let alone one so quick! I appreciate you taking my comment into consideration and making that change, thank you!
To be honest. China was always like this. We’ve just finally wised-up. And it’s long overdue, I might add.
Part of the reason why Hong Kong wasn’t cracked down as hard when it was “returned” to China in 1997 was because it accounted for 20% of China’s financial industry. Back then, Hong Kong was a global financial hub for China. Today, that number is less than 5%, so the central government can finally do what it’s always wanted to do without fear of reprisal. Leaving Hong Kong alone was merely an act of practicality. Don’t ever mistake what China did out of the goodness of its heart. They are far more devious, and far more patient than anyone can ever imagine. I know this because I have Hongkonger friends whose families fled HK back in 1997. They knew this day was going to come, eventually.
@@Goatzies Yeah, I had put it on to listen to while doing other things and when he said that, I did a double take and had to check when it was made. That's why I asked them to put 2010 in the title. A lot has happened in the past 11 years but I still think the video is pretty informative.
An English professor explain the Chinese history !!!
Nice 💪
There are many Overseas Chinese whose first language is English. They are mostly in the top quadrant economically. Some are even Elitist. Although they retained the cultural links of the Chinese, many are pro-Western in their outlook just like the Taiwanese and Hong Kongese. Western education had taught them to be Independent thinkers. Since the advent of the Internet, many are pissed off by Western propaganda. They appreciate unbiased journalism in the English language. For them the anti-China propaganda is a real turn-off.
@@adamiskandar5107 yes you're right,at the beginning I'm also anti China,but now no more after seeing the western New so biased,.
Very excellent teacher! Great lessons and information! Thank you! I wish I could study more in your classes!
I used to be a regular subscriber to Great Courses and registered in many of their courses. After this lecture with the many important facts missing I changed my mind.
Hi Lar, if you can DM us with the facts you feel are missing and links to the peer reviewed evidence we can look at the course contents in house.
@@TheGreatCourses This lecture need to be updated to include the most important heppening in Hong Kong with the passing of the National Security Law which totally fued the international community on China.
@@SteepSix CCP People's Daily has been paying many western MSM and now the Great Course in further their propaganda network.
@@canman5060 everyone else has a similar law and HK can't? This is China's city not yours. Americans keep sticking their noses I. Other people's business claiming it's international. What a joke
cant say they r missing facts from after 2010 when the video clearly states its pre-2010.
How things have now changed. I remarked the differenceses from when I was in HK in the years after reunification and when I last visited around New Year 2019. Things have accelerated since even that time.
No things have not changed, you just are noticing more. The Chinese are master strategists, and the CCP link with the Israeli n.w.o.plans are very real. Take care....
things changed since 1997 to now. Who knew a fast moving society could change in more than 20 years time.
Thanks for the history,and the information.a