“I apologize for what happened” instead of “I apologize for what I did.” Insane man, so happy he was eliminated. I’m kind of upset they didn’t scold him further. If he tried that in Hell’s Kitchen, he would’ve come out crying.
@@azojedx Yeah, and made it blatantly obvious he only felt bad because he was caught lmao. I just pointed out the strange choice of vocabulary he chose to use, which tells us how shitty of a contender he is.
10:49 Don't be sorry for someone who tried to cheat He did put a tray with 4 ceramics in the blast chiller and did get only one ceramic out, not the complete tray That was absolut calculated
@@AlkaVirusjust a bunch of tards who get off spewing baseless hate, if he was trying to cheat he would have made it way less obvious and not in front of the cameras
@@AlkaVirus He probably gave himself way too little time to pull off the cheat. Remember: the one he took out failed. The normal course of action would have been to go back and grab one of his remaining 3. But he didn't. The girl tried out all her ceramics after they failed.
but what if in that little time to cook + the huge time stress he forgot where his 4 ceramics were and took were he thought it would be, i can say in a different profession experience, huge time stress can accrue/appear/create mistake/issue.
Apparently Tyler is a master manipulator. Puts a tray of 4 in, takes one from a tray of 3. Tries to play it off as an innocent mistake and somehow manages to fool people into believing him.
You do realize these shows are all staged right..... All contestants Produces TWO sets of plates for TASTING,,, ONE SET we never see the JUDGES TASTE AT EACH TABLE and the SECOND SET is the one they call the contestants out to bring to them for JUDGING... THIS JUDGING happens almost TWO HOURS after the challenge has ended when the contestants goes for a LUNCH break and the food has been standing on the tables to get cold, They come back from lunch and the judges has already decided who is leaving then they call out the random people to the podium with their dishes for so called tasting and judging which already happened at each contestants stand two hours prior. There is simply no way that this could happen in the order of events portrayed in the show other than it is staged and was told to do it for a little bit of DRAMA... I know this is the Master Chef channel and they will deny it but come on too many other master chef contestants has spilled the (baked)BEANS on how these shows work.
I am usually very suspicious but the way he went about it was extreeemely cartoon level dum. I think it's equally likely that the pressure and living conditions got to him and he blanked out. It would make more sense if he took the whole tray or picked it and then his own tray. Just one in total is strange. Especially when he already were careful with making 4 to have backups. Also with Joe as a judge and since this is the US show, I think they would definitely have some harsh words if it was truly intentional. Joe has blown up for way smaller offenses so it's strange that he's so calm. Plus everyone knows they are watched constantly. Dunno 50/50 here. In the end, the people on set has more context. I would think Joe would love a reason to make another angry Joe clip.
I worked at a chef training school once. During a practical exam, one of the students got a cleaner to go out and buy a pack of frozen french fries for the dish the student was preparing. Upon presentation, the french fries were too perfect to be hand cut. Needless to say, the student failed her exam.
I mean in 8th grade in home cooking class i didnt make my own tortilla bread and got a E ( pass where i live but just enough ) got my mum to write a A+ story about how the balance of the bread if slightly wrong Would make or break my whole dish and thereby didnt have the self confidence to make my own. Ended on a C i take that all week
So it wasn't an exam officer that noticed the literal bag of frech fries and deep frying it? Our exam had 3 officers... Also what does too perfect mean? Did she cut off the ends of the potato and sliced it on batons?
His lie is pathetic, you didn’t notice? Everybody put a tray inside and took the whole tray out, why would you take just too and leave a whole tray. He thought his back was enough to cover the camera but forgot so many. He’s not a “champ” just a dumb cheater
If he was trying to cheat, why would he have left the tray, the most obvious evidence? You tards assume everyone would cheat as obvious as you would if they were to do it
After the one he took out failed, he didn't go back to try out his remaining ones to see if they were better. WHich what anyone would have done. "Oh, it failed? Let's see if the other ones are better". But he knew his own 4 were failures and he couldn't also steal a 2nd one.
poeple are so susceptible to editing. He left four and took one from a tray of three. can't be a mistake. Not a 'true man', not a 'champ', no integrity. Thief and cheater.
First minute and a half of this video: Elizabeth = Don't YOU just hang around in your dining room almost peeing with anticipation that you're meeting a 14 year old cook and an American with an Italian accent. What a fake show. VERY American. and the way it's edited to make Jaimee look like an idiot and Tyler ... ! LAME lame lame. BUT; everything is OK. We are in the US of A. ANY crime is allowed so long as you turn around and say "Sorry" when you're caught red handed. Lame. and such a shame for the youngsters watching. What a SAD culture Americans have. fake show. fake apologies. ANYTHING to make money, and it stinks. So much like Gordon Ramsay. Fake.
That's called bias. You can see it a lot even outside masterchef. Girl cheats on bf. BF gets mad and crumble. People be like "I dont think she would cheat if he isnt doing anything bad."
You can call him whatever you want but only an idiot would waste his place at a worldwide competition that ones out of millions get to participate in for the sole purpose of stealing another competitor's dish that isn't even that good when he has his already ready
This is calculative. He can see his tray at the corner it's not like someone moved his tray and he mistook it as it's his. He must've have seen it that it doesn't look right so he took which looked right to him.
@@aurora_bae if you don’t like Tyler then you can take his elimination as being disqualified. That way his game doesn’t count. Same goes for Andrea in season 7. Along with all the contestants who withdrew: Gordon (s5) Dan (s6) and Mary Jayne (s11).
Lmao ig everything is fine as long as you cry and say youre sorry? Why even is everyone praising tyler for being a "champ" or a "true man". A real champ and a real man wouldnt even have plagiarized someone else's work.
I think the term real man doesn't make any sense. Man is a term for someone with male biological parts. Perhaps try saying mature or wise, lol? It's not really a gender thing man
Theres a chance it wouldn’t have. They didnt judge the one he stole, it may have been better than her other ones. And there was the other two people that made mistakes like the very dry veal and the other guy that wasnt happy with his dish too. And the thing is, theres almost no way he accidentally took one from a tray of three that wasnt even close to the tray of four he had. Especially because he didnt take the whole tray? If he thought it was his he wouldve taken the whole tray to try and find the best one. So my theory is the ones he made were probably not good and he knew that so thought stealing would be a better option.
why is he allowed to even say goodbye or put out his apron? he should be dishonorably kicked out. if you want to cheat, at least try not to get caught! what an idiot.....😂😂😂
Seems almost guaranteed that the show set up the scenario for the drama content. No way he didn't know he would get caught and everyone were far too nice to him afterwards.
I don't know many people who would destroy their character and integrity on a show available to billions of viewers internationally for the sake of "drama" on a show. If you have integrity, you have integrity, and it isn't for sale. Even if this were for "drama", that in itself shows lack of integrity. People of integrity don't choose to display themselves to be vile cheaters and thieves for the world to see so a TV show gets some "drama." It doesn't make sense. If it were a gag, he has signed an NDA and can't even defend himself afterwards. What kind of person of integrity would agree to that? (Edited because a word was missing.)
@@angeronal Have you ever watched a TV show? 😅People have been selling their dignity and/or integrity on TV for decades! I agree with Fred, this is 100% scripted for the sake of drama.
@@monologic_ You make a valid point. I haven't seen any television in over 35 years. I've never had Netflix or any other streaming service. I've also not watched a movie that has come out since probably the early 2000s. I occasionally watch these Masterchef episodes from a variety of countries, but rarely the US one. I clicked on the title because to me it sounded like someone snuck outside food in with the use of the word, "brought", and I was wondering how that would be possible. You are probably right and I am evidently just very out-of-touch. I guess I'm old school when it comes to integrity.
Well, there are many dumb criminals out there. Even meticulous killer thought they did the perfect crime but always forgot about CCTV. And the honorable judge didn't directly accuse him of any crime, so as a contestant not trying to create a scene is a perfect sense. Like if you're attending a court case and the judge announces that the accused is not guilty, you don't go around and scream you're guilty!! But having said that, yeah many of the reality shows have proven to be rigged, so who knows for sure. 😊
It also doesn’t make sense that Jamie didn’t ask anyone about it??? Maybe she’s just timid af but I would be screaming “WHO TOOK MY PANNA COTTA!?” immediately once I took in out the chiller😅
I mean, I have to give the show this. They are able to properly manipulate the audience to get a "discussion" going about if it was on purpose or a mistake. Thing is, neither makes sense. It was part of a script. If he wanted to cheat, then there is no reason to use the collapsed Panna Cotta. He had time to get another one, since the girl was trying at least two in less time (since he had to take it out before her). The same argument goes for it being an accident. So the question is: Why would he not take a second one after the first failed? Because they needed the original tray to be intact to have a dramatic showing. If you look at it, there isn't even a reason to make four Panna Cottas in the first place. One isn't even filled. But they needed him to make four, so that his tray would be unique. Because remember, the people in the studio don't have camera footage and they want to capture their responses which is why most will be left in the dark. It was probably not thought like this. The fact that the Panna Cotta collapsed wasn't part of the script, which is why these questions above arise. Originally, they thought both would present the same Panna Cotta and then the judges could act all detective like how the consistency and taste are way too similar. They had to change that part up when it collapsed. However, the point was always that they would pull the tray with four at the end as proof.
@@hollystiener16Right, so you are telling me, not only did he know his was bad, he also knew that hers tasted better, so much that it would be worth to keep a collapsed Panna Cotta and just not try one of his or steal another one? Again, this whole idea makes no sense.
@@hollystiener16 Right, since you know, the girl who took it after him had time to try two, he had only time for one. Makes total sense. Give me some of that copium. You realize that Panna Cotta isn't that hard right? Even if he thinks hers tasted better, which he had no reason to believe, a non collapsed one would still be overall better. But hey, if you want to, keep believing that shows like these tell you the truth.
You don't put a tray in and take out a single ramekin. Alexander was absolutely drawing attention for them to have an eye on him when he mentioned Tyler's name, he knew what he saw.
"For the very first time in master chef history, someone has brought us a dish they didn't cook" *Tyler nodding his head in agreement* "W-what do you mean chef?"
Oh poor thing apologizing for something that wasnt her fault in ANY way. I feel bad for her cuz honestly i mightve done the same. I hope she learns to stand her ground and that not everything is her fault.
In situations like this, people tend to deny the truth. But, man, Tyler accepted it like a true man. Truthfully, I wish there were many more people like him.
I don't wish there were more idiots who tries to cheat and can't even cheat properly and gets slapped in the face then accepts the punishment like a true "man" because their ego is bigger than the observable universe.
He was caught cheating and lying in 4K!! What was he was thinking will all the cameras on that set..🤣🤣🤣🤣 Dude's are in the bottom while Jamie's are on top. His bs apology won't cut it for he did not really admit sh*t and why he get Jamie's. The real reason is Tyler knows all 4 Panacotta he made ate trash, that's why he chose Jamie's best one. Which is a damn shame and felt sorry for Jamie that she feel the need to even apologize even she did no wrong on this one. I just wish Gordon did a Kitchen Knigjtmare speech on Tyler and show him the footage stealing Jamie's panacotta before giving him proper advice... The title of Thief, solely belongs to him in the entirety of this show.
I don't get it. Why are people saying it's scripted? Why would Tyler accept to do this even if this is a bit? Articles and news will be written about this online and Tyler will be shamed as long as he lived for being the first thief in Masterchef USA. That's not something to be proud of. So what kind of logic is this is scripted?
Man cheating in a cooking show? More like a drama that the show is set up every few seasons. 😂😂😂😂 Imagine your tray is at the bottom while you get one at the top to present to the judges.
Honestly so many things are going through their heads of what they did, what they're doing and what they're gonna do next, I completely understand he forgot which one was his
for some reason this video wasn't available in my country, so i pulled up the vpn.. best decision of my life i didn't expect this to almost make me cry, the ending with tyler was so wholesome
I think people are jumping on Tyler a little quickly here. Yes, there's evidence against him, but there are also several factors that point to this maybe being a genuine error that he did not mean to make. First of all, it's important to remember that MasterChef US is a reality show before all else. It profits from drama, feuds and what have you - that's why this entire season pushed the narrative of Leslie being a prick when in actuality, he's a wholesome man who is completely capable of getting along with others. Shows like these will sometimes even intentionally deprive contestants of sleep to ensure higher tensions, potentially resulting in larger blow-ups and/or incidents. I believe it is completely within the realm of possibility that Tyler simply hadn't been given enough sleep, and combined with the pressure of cooking on a timer, simply forgot where he placed his tray and how many ramekins were on it. As for why he only took one, perhaps he thought taking the entire tray would slow him down. Furthermore, if he really had been aware of his actions, there is then the question of why he didn't go back to try his own panna cotta after Jaimee's disintegrated. Although Graham stated that her panna cotta tasted good, Tyler couldn't have known that. Even if he had been short on time, surely it would have been worthwhile to try his own panna cotta? Would the judges not have preferred an intact but ungarnished panna cotta over one that had splattered all over the plate? Anyway, that's just my personal opinion. It's difficult to say with absolute objective certainty that Tyler knew what he was doing, and the possibility that he made an honest mistake is very much present. In the end, only Tyler himself knows the truth, and I hope he can live with it.
people always like to scream guilty its one of thoses hard to really tell if he cheated or simple made a mistake wasnt there not him nor do i know what type of person he is if he cheated he cheated if not well sadly he broke the rules and was kicked i spos we will never really no.
So why did he not try out his remaining attempts after the first one failed and not pick the entire tray in the first place? That's why he made 4 in the first place: to have backups. He didn't use his other ones as backup, that kinda indicates he cheated on purpose. Normal course of action: Grab entire tray, look at the results and go for the best looking one, and then for the 2nd best looking one if it failed.
@@Funkytrip73 I would say that one tactic is to leave your backups in the chiller to give them more time to set if they need it, you certainly don't have time to put them back. However the fact that he didn't go back means he most likely heard her commenting that one of hers was missing and figured it out. Alternately he didn't go back because she retrieved her tray and remaining ramekins and he didn't want to look suspicious pulling a tray with 4 ramekins out while already having used one. And of course the most likely reason, he knows he stole it and can't steal any more. So just to be clear I think he cheated on purpose I am simply stating that there are legitimate reasons to only take out one ramekin to start.
the kitchen is a very hectic place and I can’t even imagine how chaotic it is especially with Gordon and Joe watching. Tyler picking up a single ramekin at the last minute was understandable as he didn’t have the time to test all 4 so he just grabbed one and hoped it had set. Unfortunately it didn’t set and was also Jamie’s ramekin
- Wow bro, do you even realize how insulting that question is? It makes you look really bad, because you are basically making fun of someone who possibly has a speech disorder or perhaps some form of disability, your only potential saving grace would be that maybe you were not smart enough to figure that much out, because if you are smart enough, then it just means you're a real jerk.
@@auraa411 - Agreed, I already responded basically the same as you did, but apparently they deleted it so don't be surprised if your comment gets blocked as well, apparently calling people out for being insensitive jerks gets you blocked.
Everyone judging like their perfect & hasn’t made no mistakes in their life. He owned his dishonesty, didn’t dispute it, accepted it, apologised to the right people, showed his gratitude & walked away head held high A REAL MAN. Not many people would’ve held up like he did, thats a real man if anything. You can tell he earned everyone’s respect when he left, mine included.
You would fall easy prey to manipulators. The way he spoke, he tried to deflect and diminish his cheating in every breath. For example, "I apologize for what happened" instead of "I apologize for what I did". No, I'm not exaggerating, that choice of wording is deliberate, routinely used by politicians and other fraudsters. That man was sorry that he was CAUGHT, not for what he did...
@@icant8027 I DOUBT you’ve been a fully honest human being with no flaws or faults in your life but you feel the need to look down on a man who owns up to his & apologies. Wow. Shameful.
You don't know what her real voice is ha? In an interview she said she had been terribly bullied on school and even in this season she said it. One of her bullies hit her neck for a joke but the hit was hard that it damaged her voice to talk. The school did not take action because the boy is very rich. They said that Jamie should have defended it. But I mean how can the girl defend herself, she didn't had friends. On the 1st team challenge this season she was the last to pick and she said that's how it is always on school for her Poor girl actually hope that boy is doing terrible in life.
@@alliancecd nope. I don't recall that much but I think she was at least top 8. Also she later appears in all stats season. But she couldn't get the apron. The judges hope that they made the right decision by choosing someone over her but a few episodes later they literally said "I wish we took Jamie instead of him".
@Ruwinka - Oh my god how awful, so terrible that happened to her, but what is even more horrible and sad, and in my opinion, illegal, is that the school didn't do anything about because the family was rich? disgusting.
I really believe that Tyler forgot what shelf he put his tray inside the freezer and then when he went back to the freezer he mistakenly picked up Jaimes instead
@@_Lucary I don't know, I am usually very suspicious but the way he went about it was extreeemely cartoon level dum. I think it's equally likely that the pressure and living conditions got to him and he blanked out. It would make more sense if he took the whole tray or picked it and then his own tray. Just one in total is strange. Especially when he already were careful with making 4 to have backups. Also with Joe as a judge and since this is the US show, I think they would definitely have some harsh words if it was truly intentional. Plus everyone knows they are watched constantly. Dunno 50/50 here.
@ronlyon4645 all of them put a full Tay in then took their whole tray out. He's the only one who took 2 individually and not the whole tray. He knew what he was doing.
“I apologize for what happened” instead of “I apologize for what I did.” Insane man, so happy he was eliminated. I’m kind of upset they didn’t scold him further. If he tried that in Hell’s Kitchen, he would’ve come out crying.
And she was still so sweet to him
he still apologized bro
Apologize to whom? Himself? 😂@@azojedx
@@Casual-Netizen to HER.
@@azojedx Yeah, and made it blatantly obvious he only felt bad because he was caught lmao. I just pointed out the strange choice of vocabulary he chose to use, which tells us how shitty of a contender he is.
10:49
Don't be sorry for someone who tried to cheat
He did put a tray with 4 ceramics in the blast chiller and did get only one ceramic out, not the complete tray
That was absolut calculated
why would he not just exchange one with the ones in his tray and bring his whole tray out lol
@@AlkaVirusjust a bunch of tards who get off spewing baseless hate, if he was trying to cheat he would have made it way less obvious and not in front of the cameras
@@AlkaVirus He probably gave himself way too little time to pull off the cheat. Remember: the one he took out failed. The normal course of action would have been to go back and grab one of his remaining 3. But he didn't. The girl tried out all her ceramics after they failed.
but what if in that little time to cook + the huge time stress he forgot where his 4 ceramics were and took were he thought it would be, i can say in a different profession experience, huge time stress can accrue/appear/create mistake/issue.
@titanittitanit5612 But why would he only get one ceramic and not the complete tray?
Apparently Tyler is a master manipulator. Puts a tray of 4 in, takes one from a tray of 3. Tries to play it off as an innocent mistake and somehow manages to fool people into believing him.
@@ColinP-yo2mz I consider both Tyler and Andrea both disqualifications
It's not real, it's all scripted to create drama to get ratings.
I think, maybe, judges were told what happened, by the crew, but they didn't actually see it to tell if it was a genuine mistake or not.
You do realize these shows are all staged right..... All contestants Produces TWO sets of plates for TASTING,,, ONE SET we never see the JUDGES TASTE AT EACH TABLE and the SECOND SET is the one they call the contestants out to bring to them for JUDGING... THIS JUDGING happens almost TWO HOURS after the challenge has ended when the contestants goes for a LUNCH break and the food has been standing on the tables to get cold, They come back from lunch and the judges has already decided who is leaving then they call out the random people to the podium with their dishes for so called tasting and judging which already happened at each contestants stand two hours prior. There is simply no way that this could happen in the order of events portrayed in the show other than it is staged and was told to do it for a little bit of DRAMA... I know this is the Master Chef channel and they will deny it but come on too many other master chef contestants has spilled the (baked)BEANS on how these shows work.
I am usually very suspicious but the way he went about it was extreeemely cartoon level dum. I think it's equally likely that the pressure and living conditions got to him and he blanked out. It would make more sense if he took the whole tray or picked it and then his own tray. Just one in total is strange. Especially when he already were careful with making 4 to have backups. Also with Joe as a judge and since this is the US show, I think they would definitely have some harsh words if it was truly intentional. Joe has blown up for way smaller offenses so it's strange that he's so calm. Plus everyone knows they are watched constantly. Dunno 50/50 here. In the end, the people on set has more context. I would think Joe would love a reason to make another angry Joe clip.
I worked at a chef training school once. During a practical exam, one of the students got a cleaner to go out and buy a pack of frozen french fries for the dish the student was preparing. Upon presentation, the french fries were too perfect to be hand cut. Needless to say, the student failed her exam.
I mean in 8th grade in home cooking class i didnt make my own tortilla bread and got a E ( pass where i live but just enough ) got my mum to write a A+ story about how the balance of the bread if slightly wrong Would make or break my whole dish and thereby didnt have the self confidence to make my own. Ended on a C i take that all week
French fries?? Of all things!
So it wasn't an exam officer that noticed the literal bag of frech fries and deep frying it?
Our exam had 3 officers...
Also what does too perfect mean? Did she cut off the ends of the potato and sliced it on batons?
His lie is pathetic, you didn’t notice? Everybody put a tray inside and took the whole tray out, why would you take just too and leave a whole tray. He thought his back was enough to cover the camera but forgot so many. He’s not a “champ” just a dumb cheater
If he was trying to cheat, why would he have left the tray, the most obvious evidence? You tards assume everyone would cheat as obvious as you would if they were to do it
After the one he took out failed, he didn't go back to try out his remaining ones to see if they were better. WHich what anyone would have done. "Oh, it failed? Let's see if the other ones are better". But he knew his own 4 were failures and he couldn't also steal a 2nd one.
not to mention, the argument might have worked if her tray had 4.
Nah I think it was pressure
poeple are so susceptible to editing. He left four and took one from a tray of three. can't be a mistake. Not a 'true man', not a 'champ', no integrity. Thief and cheater.
@@ichinggoh I was more concerned about Jaimee rather than Tyler. She was one of the few girls with a short name in this season.
First minute and a half of this video: Elizabeth = Don't YOU just hang around in your dining room almost peeing with anticipation that you're meeting a 14 year old cook and an American with an Italian accent.
What a fake show. VERY American.
and the way it's edited to make Jaimee look like an idiot and Tyler ... ! LAME lame lame. BUT; everything is OK. We are in the US of A. ANY crime is allowed so long as you turn around and say "Sorry" when you're caught red handed. Lame. and such a shame for the youngsters watching. What a SAD culture Americans have.
fake show. fake apologies. ANYTHING to make money, and it stinks. So much like Gordon Ramsay. Fake.
That's called bias. You can see it a lot even outside masterchef.
Girl cheats on bf. BF gets mad and crumble. People be like "I dont think she would cheat if he isnt doing anything bad."
@@konaqua122 And thats called: You make NO sense. an't make head or tail of what you are trying to say. LOL.
You can call him whatever you want but only an idiot would waste his place at a worldwide competition that ones out of millions get to participate in for the sole purpose of stealing another competitor's dish that isn't even that good when he has his already ready
This is calculative. He can see his tray at the corner it's not like someone moved his tray and he mistook it as it's his. He must've have seen it that it doesn't look right so he took which looked right to him.
jamie is so sweet she apologised when she did nothing wrong
Tyler knew what he was doing. What a pathetic guy
@@aurora_bae if you don’t like Tyler then you can take his elimination as being disqualified. That way his game doesn’t count. Same goes for Andrea in season 7. Along with all the contestants who withdrew: Gordon (s5) Dan (s6) and Mary Jayne (s11).
Lmao ig everything is fine as long as you cry and say youre sorry? Why even is everyone praising tyler for being a "champ" or a "true man". A real champ and a real man wouldnt even have plagiarized someone else's work.
plagiarism means to copy. he stole not copied
I think the term real man doesn't make any sense. Man is a term for someone with male biological parts. Perhaps try saying mature or wise, lol? It's not really a gender thing man
Yea true
It's not plagiarism. He took the ramekin that he DIDN'T make
Ya and what kind of man makes panna cotta
He knew exactly what he did and refused to man up and admit it. Lying cheater takes no accountability. I’m glad he was exposed and thrown out.
Luca is such a golden retriever of a person.
i say this was set up by masterchef themselves. they probably just hired him to get out the next day lol.
This man gets it lol, some extra drama for people at home
@@EternalNero gotta be real, the americans make uninteresting things interesting.
funniest thing is he chose the one tray that even if he hadn't been caught cheating probably would have sent him home.
Theres a chance it wouldn’t have. They didnt judge the one he stole, it may have been better than her other ones. And there was the other two people that made mistakes like the very dry veal and the other guy that wasnt happy with his dish too.
And the thing is, theres almost no way he accidentally took one from a tray of three that wasnt even close to the tray of four he had. Especially because he didnt take the whole tray? If he thought it was his he wouldve taken the whole tray to try and find the best one. So my theory is the ones he made were probably not good and he knew that so thought stealing would be a better option.
@@Dragonn6667 true, but probably less chances then his own.
why is he allowed to even say goodbye or put out his apron? he should be dishonorably kicked out.
if you want to cheat, at least try not to get caught! what an idiot.....😂😂😂
That's not a mistake. That's scripted. As 99% of today's shows. 🙄
A convincing one regardless, that was fun
Seems almost guaranteed that the show set up the scenario for the drama content. No way he didn't know he would get caught and everyone were far too nice to him afterwards.
I don't know many people who would destroy their character and integrity on a show available to billions of viewers internationally for the sake of "drama" on a show. If you have integrity, you have integrity, and it isn't for sale.
Even if this were for "drama", that in itself shows lack of integrity. People of integrity don't choose to display themselves to be vile cheaters and thieves for the world to see so a TV show gets some "drama." It doesn't make sense. If it were a gag, he has signed an NDA and can't even defend himself afterwards. What kind of person of integrity would agree to that?
(Edited because a word was missing.)
@@angeronal Have you ever watched a TV show? 😅People have been selling their dignity and/or integrity on TV for decades! I agree with Fred, this is 100% scripted for the sake of drama.
@@monologic_ You make a valid point. I haven't seen any television in over 35 years. I've never had Netflix or any other streaming service. I've also not watched a movie that has come out since probably the early 2000s. I occasionally watch these Masterchef episodes from a variety of countries, but rarely the US one. I clicked on the title because to me it sounded like someone snuck outside food in with the use of the word, "brought", and I was wondering how that would be possible. You are probably right and I am evidently just very out-of-touch. I guess I'm old school when it comes to integrity.
Well, there are many dumb criminals out there. Even meticulous killer thought they did the perfect crime but always forgot about CCTV. And the honorable judge didn't directly accuse him of any crime, so as a contestant not trying to create a scene is a perfect sense. Like if you're attending a court case and the judge announces that the accused is not guilty, you don't go around and scream you're guilty!!
But having said that, yeah many of the reality shows have proven to be rigged, so who knows for sure. 😊
It also doesn’t make sense that Jamie didn’t ask anyone about it??? Maybe she’s just timid af but I would be screaming “WHO TOOK MY PANNA COTTA!?” immediately once I took in out the chiller😅
I mean, I have to give the show this. They are able to properly manipulate the audience to get a "discussion" going about if it was on purpose or a mistake. Thing is, neither makes sense. It was part of a script. If he wanted to cheat, then there is no reason to use the collapsed Panna Cotta. He had time to get another one, since the girl was trying at least two in less time (since he had to take it out before her). The same argument goes for it being an accident. So the question is: Why would he not take a second one after the first failed? Because they needed the original tray to be intact to have a dramatic showing.
If you look at it, there isn't even a reason to make four Panna Cottas in the first place. One isn't even filled. But they needed him to make four, so that his tray would be unique. Because remember, the people in the studio don't have camera footage and they want to capture their responses which is why most will be left in the dark.
It was probably not thought like this. The fact that the Panna Cotta collapsed wasn't part of the script, which is why these questions above arise. Originally, they thought both would present the same Panna Cotta and then the judges could act all detective like how the consistency and taste are way too similar. They had to change that part up when it collapsed. However, the point was always that they would pull the tray with four at the end as proof.
Hers tasted amazing and his probably did not
@@hollystiener16Right, so you are telling me, not only did he know his was bad, he also knew that hers tasted better, so much that it would be worth to keep a collapsed Panna Cotta and just not try one of his or steal another one? Again, this whole idea makes no sense.
@@Modie yes and he prob didn't have time to go back and get his, especially to risk getting caught
@@hollystiener16 Right, since you know, the girl who took it after him had time to try two, he had only time for one. Makes total sense.
Give me some of that copium. You realize that Panna Cotta isn't that hard right? Even if he thinks hers tasted better, which he had no reason to believe, a non collapsed one would still be overall better. But hey, if you want to, keep believing that shows like these tell you the truth.
You had me in the second sentence and lost me immediately afterwards. Way tldr
You don't put a tray in and take out a single ramekin. Alexander was absolutely drawing attention for them to have an eye on him when he mentioned Tyler's name, he knew what he saw.
2:20; 2:54; 3:40; 4:46; 4:53; 5:04; 5:21 "Penna codda" 🤣🤣🤣
3:22 "Penna Coada" 🤣🤣🤣
"For the very first time in master chef history, someone has brought us a dish they didn't cook"
*Tyler nodding his head in agreement* "W-what do you mean chef?"
The panna cotta is the message
nice reference 😭
The panna cotta is the friendships we (didn't) make on the way
Tyler chose the wrong panacotta 😂
I think it's staged. Nobody is THAT dumb to do it so openly with cameras around.
Its a surprise that gordon didnt yell at him 😂
Did Tyler get disqualified? Or did it just count as a normal elimination?
Technically he is disqualified. Because he (unintentionally) broke a rule.
@ well the wikipedia article won’t accept that for some reason.
I mean... no difference between the two. He just got eliminated on the spot.
@@theblackantonio then you can go edit the Wikipedia page
@@skyjewel4861 lol, "unintentionally"
I'm sorry, but you are very gullible.
Oh poor thing apologizing for something that wasnt her fault in ANY way. I feel bad for her cuz honestly i mightve done the same. I hope she learns to stand her ground and that not everything is her fault.
the good thing about a somewhat bad executed panna cotta is that it will still be tasty xD
He dumb he should’ve replaced the one he took with one of his 😂
Didnt you see it was all filmed? lol It would change one dumb decision for another and potentially look even worse
If he had done that, there would be more evidence against him and taking jamies intentionally
In situations like this, people tend to deny the truth. But, man, Tyler accepted it like a true man. Truthfully, I wish there were many more people like him.
When you're caught and the evidence is all against you, you really have no option. It's like the murderers in the dying minutes of each CSI episode.
He did go in circles around the fact that it wasn't an accident
I don't wish there were more idiots who tries to cheat and can't even cheat properly and gets slapped in the face then accepts the punishment like a true "man" because their ego is bigger than the observable universe.
@@Charsiupao Totally, yeah.
@@Maplaplaplapla yeah, but he did not know. He done it by mistake.
He was caught cheating and lying in 4K!! What was he was thinking will all the cameras on that set..🤣🤣🤣🤣
Dude's are in the bottom while Jamie's are on top. His bs apology won't cut it for he did not really admit sh*t and why he get Jamie's.
The real reason is Tyler knows all 4 Panacotta he made ate trash, that's why he chose Jamie's best one. Which is a damn shame and felt sorry for Jamie that she feel the need to even apologize even she did no wrong on this one.
I just wish Gordon did a Kitchen Knigjtmare speech on Tyler and show him the footage stealing Jamie's panacotta before giving him proper advice... The title of Thief, solely belongs to him in the entirety of this show.
Middle judge? What happened to him. Crazy different. Aura wise isn't the same.
Nono chef Ramsay hes just preparing pannacruda dont worry
I don't get it. Why are people saying it's scripted? Why would Tyler accept to do this even if this is a bit? Articles and news will be written about this online and Tyler will be shamed as long as he lived for being the first thief in Masterchef USA. That's not something to be proud of. So what kind of logic is this is scripted?
To do this when there is a kid there
Wow
he knew full well what he did
Man cheating in a cooking show? More like a drama that the show is set up every few seasons. 😂😂😂😂
Imagine your tray is at the bottom while you get one at the top to present to the judges.
he took only one he knew it wasn’t his
What season is this?
Season 5, episode 6. It’s in the description:)
I love masterchef world
Panna coatta? Why can't Americans just pronounce words as they were meant to be said?
that is how you say it in Italy
@@hollystiener16 it's not. It's puh-na, not pan-na. It's co-ta, not co-rrra. Americans won't even try to get foreign words right.
@@ref.erence yes because theyre ignorant. and also who cares omg
i was expecting steamed ham but alright
That was a twist...
Everyone is so cocky and mean and nasty. Except the youngest star.
❤
¿Esperaba que le diesen una medalla o algo? Menudo tramposo :V
Honestly so many things are going through their heads of what they did, what they're doing and what they're gonna do next, I completely understand he forgot which one was his
Always been my favourite winner Luca
Im feeling judgemental today so I'll just say that Courtney seems like a red flag made from synthetic fibers.
for some reason this video wasn't available in my country, so i pulled up the vpn.. best decision of my life
i didn't expect this to almost make me cry, the ending with tyler was so wholesome
He cheated. But accepted his punishment well.
wholesome? he lied and cheated
@@flowerpuff944 he cheated and still didn't admit it wasn't a mistake. that's not wholesome.
@@ref.erence I didn't say it was wholesome 😂😂😂
I think people are jumping on Tyler a little quickly here. Yes, there's evidence against him, but there are also several factors that point to this maybe being a genuine error that he did not mean to make. First of all, it's important to remember that MasterChef US is a reality show before all else. It profits from drama, feuds and what have you - that's why this entire season pushed the narrative of Leslie being a prick when in actuality, he's a wholesome man who is completely capable of getting along with others. Shows like these will sometimes even intentionally deprive contestants of sleep to ensure higher tensions, potentially resulting in larger blow-ups and/or incidents. I believe it is completely within the realm of possibility that Tyler simply hadn't been given enough sleep, and combined with the pressure of cooking on a timer, simply forgot where he placed his tray and how many ramekins were on it. As for why he only took one, perhaps he thought taking the entire tray would slow him down.
Furthermore, if he really had been aware of his actions, there is then the question of why he didn't go back to try his own panna cotta after Jaimee's disintegrated. Although Graham stated that her panna cotta tasted good, Tyler couldn't have known that. Even if he had been short on time, surely it would have been worthwhile to try his own panna cotta? Would the judges not have preferred an intact but ungarnished panna cotta over one that had splattered all over the plate?
Anyway, that's just my personal opinion. It's difficult to say with absolute objective certainty that Tyler knew what he was doing, and the possibility that he made an honest mistake is very much present. In the end, only Tyler himself knows the truth, and I hope he can live with it.
people always like to scream guilty its one of thoses hard to really tell if he cheated or simple made a mistake wasnt there not him nor do i know what type of person he is if he cheated he cheated if not well sadly he broke the rules and was kicked i spos we will never really no.
Didnt his own not work at all?
So why did he not try out his remaining attempts after the first one failed and not pick the entire tray in the first place? That's why he made 4 in the first place: to have backups. He didn't use his other ones as backup, that kinda indicates he cheated on purpose. Normal course of action: Grab entire tray, look at the results and go for the best looking one, and then for the 2nd best looking one if it failed.
Yeah, so he cheated
@@Funkytrip73 I would say that one tactic is to leave your backups in the chiller to give them more time to set if they need it, you certainly don't have time to put them back.
However the fact that he didn't go back means he most likely heard her commenting that one of hers was missing and figured it out.
Alternately he didn't go back because she retrieved her tray and remaining ramekins and he didn't want to look suspicious pulling a tray with 4 ramekins out while already having used one.
And of course the most likely reason, he knows he stole it and can't steal any more.
So just to be clear I think he cheated on purpose I am simply stating that there are legitimate reasons to only take out one ramekin to start.
Who is Elisabeth?
yes, yes of course everyone's on Tyler, I'm just here for this ->
11:37
Why does gordon sound like ai stutter?? Edit: like half of them are full of audio stutter! Meanwhile the music is completely clear
Welcome Lucia? Hmmmm
Staged? i think so.❤
damn, Tyler took it like a champ
u mean stole someone's dish? then yeah
@@Destiny7327 no, i meant the consequences of the accident
Couldn't even admit it in front of the judges. Yeah right.
It was a mistake he made and he apologized a lot because he TRULY didn't mean to do it.
@@mattng2761 :D:D sure he did not , how naive can u be
dharr man predicted this!!!!!!!!!!
The truth will set u Free...glad he say sorry 😔
I agree with you, except he didn't end up being honest. That was not a mistake and he knew it but couldn't admit it.
the kitchen is a very hectic place and I can’t even imagine how chaotic it is especially with Gordon and Joe watching. Tyler picking up a single ramekin at the last minute was understandable as he didn’t have the time to test all 4 so he just grabbed one and hoped it had set. Unfortunately it didn’t set and was also Jamie’s ramekin
I've got a bridge to sell to you as well. Very cheap.
Tyler was probably pressured in a hurry 😢
McDonald's here he comes if they'll take them I wouldn't! What a slime bucket!
No he absolutely cooked it! I believe him.
oh yeah after you saw him taking sth not his
3:47 Why is the lady who makes super hero suits talking like she's on slow internet?
- Wow bro, do you even realize how insulting that question is? It makes you look really bad, because you are basically making fun of someone who possibly has a speech disorder or perhaps some form of disability, your only potential saving grace would be that maybe you were not smart enough to figure that much out, because if you are smart enough, then it just means you're a real jerk.
Well honey, some people just have speech difficulties, your parents obviously didn't teach you how to be respectful, failed parenting
@@auraa411 - Agreed, I already responded basically the same as you did, but apparently they deleted it so don't be surprised if your comment gets blocked as well, apparently calling people out for being insensitive jerks gets you blocked.
Alex 🥹🥹🥹
Everyone judging like their perfect & hasn’t made no mistakes in their life. He owned his dishonesty, didn’t dispute it, accepted it, apologised to the right people, showed his gratitude & walked away head held high A REAL MAN. Not many people would’ve held up like he did, thats a real man if anything. You can tell he earned everyone’s respect when he left, mine included.
You serious right now?
You would fall easy prey to manipulators.
The way he spoke, he tried to deflect and diminish his cheating in every breath.
For example, "I apologize for what happened" instead of "I apologize for what I did". No, I'm not exaggerating, that choice of wording is deliberate, routinely used by politicians and other fraudsters. That man was sorry that he was CAUGHT, not for what he did...
@icant8027 In his life, you can cheat, steal or lie. So long as you "apologise" if you get caught, you're a real man. A true hero.
@@jameshenderson4876 well thats basically what he said i guesse. Maybe he does that in real life all the time who knows
@@icant8027 I DOUBT you’ve been a fully honest human being with no flaws or faults in your life but you feel the need to look down on a man who owns up to his & apologies. Wow. Shameful.
“She”
If you want the best tasting fries, dont just deep fry them, use Jaimee' vocal fry. Its so over the top your fries will burst in to flames.
Tyler looks incredibly australian.
Jaimee's voice is very weird and hilarious 😂. She sounds like a creaking door 😂
You don't know what her real voice is ha?
In an interview she said she had been terribly bullied on school and even in this season she said it.
One of her bullies hit her neck for a joke but the hit was hard that it damaged her voice to talk. The school did not take action because the boy is very rich. They said that Jamie should have defended it.
But I mean how can the girl defend herself, she didn't had friends.
On the 1st team challenge this season she was the last to pick and she said that's how it is always on school for her
Poor girl actually hope that boy is doing terrible in life.
@Ruwinka Did she win Masterchef?
@@alliancecd nope. I don't recall that much but I think she was at least top 8. Also she later appears in all stats season. But she couldn't get the apron. The judges hope that they made the right decision by choosing someone over her but a few episodes later they literally said "I wish we took Jamie instead of him".
@Ruwinka - Oh my god how awful, so terrible that happened to her, but what is even more horrible and sad, and in my opinion, illegal, is that the school didn't do anything about because the family was rich? disgusting.
I really believe that Tyler forgot what shelf he put his tray inside the freezer and then when he went back to the freezer he mistakenly picked up Jaimes instead
But he only took one instead of the entire tray
@@_Lucarytruly suspicious
@@_Lucary I don't know, I am usually very suspicious but the way he went about it was extreeemely cartoon level dum. I think it's equally likely that the pressure and living conditions got to him and he blanked out. It would make more sense if he took the whole tray or picked it and then his own tray. Just one in total is strange. Especially when he already were careful with making 4 to have backups. Also with Joe as a judge and since this is the US show, I think they would definitely have some harsh words if it was truly intentional. Plus everyone knows they are watched constantly. Dunno 50/50 here.
man with integrity, tyler.
Nor really. He cheated and he knows it. But he accepted his punishment well.
a man with integrity doesnt cheat in the first place
@@flowerpuff944 really? i thought he mistook it.
@ronlyon4645 all of them put a full Tay in then took their whole tray out. He's the only one who took 2 individually and not the whole tray. He knew what he was doing.
What’s wrong with her voice? She can’t speak properly
first
Nbc
I'm guessing that means nobody cares? I agree! Who cares? I can't stand childish remarks like that!
@@angeldark8812 "first" is childish af bro
Ey fwiw this "first" comment might've actually been made by a child
@@nadjanadezhda3405 watching MasterChef? That’s a childish remark in itself!
Cheater!!! 😜