still remember the 1st listened to this song i was crying :( such an emotional voice and this song was way damn touchin. cant believe its already been 9 years :((((
Joo pleaseee stay forever in JYP even not many people recognize you but for JYP stan you are the best singer for us.. we love you Joo! expecting to hear Joo, Jun. K, Changmin of 2AM and 15&.... pleaseeeee!
I LOVED THIS SONG ! I didn't kwon she was under JYP and now under woollim ! Can't wait to see her solo ! Her voice would match with woohyun's voice in my opinion ! I want a collaboration omg.
I agree with you. Actually I've liked her voice since I watch Dream High Season 1. Then she joined Woollim and now she comebacks with new song. I'm really excited.
+Dana R her, woohyun and lovelyz's jin as a vocal sub unit. i know she is having a come back, the teaser video looks good ! I really can't wait to see it. i love her voice
너무 뜨거워 싫어 너만 사랑하고 사랑하는 내가 싫어 바보 같이 슬픈 노래가 싫어 자꾸 아파하며 또 훌쩍거리다 결국 입을 막고 너를 불러 Oh Ah I`m so sorry 울지 말라면 다신 안 울게 오 제발 잡은 손을 놓지는 마 Ah I`m so sorry 여린 마음은 점점 멀어질 때 마다 새까맣게 타 들어가잖아 이 나쁜 남자야 넌 못된 남자야 한 사람만 너만 바라보고 사는 난 약한 여자야 착한 여자야 가면 어떡해 떠나면 어떡해 오 너무 차가워 싫어 다른 사람처럼 나를 바라보는 오 그 눈빛이 너무 싫어 Oh Ah I`m so sorry 니가 하라는 대로 다 할게 우리 다시 처음으로 돌아가자 Ah I`m so sorry 어린 나는 쉽게 구겨지고 결국 찢어져서 아파 이 나쁜 남자야 넌 못된 남자야 한 사람만 너만 바라보고 사는 난 약한 여자야 착한 여자야 가면 어떡해 떠나면 어떡해 자존심 상하고 속상하면 어때 너만 돌아와준다면 괜찮아 오늘도 난 니 집 앞에 서서 홀로 널 기다려 그래 너 밖에 모르는 바보인가 봐 난 정말 여자로 태어나서 단 하루만 살아봐 한 사람만 나만 바라보고 살아봐 나쁜 남자야 나쁜 바보야 가면 어떡해 떠나면 어떡해
Omg yes I finally remember her name after all these years and found this mv. I remember when I was just getting in kpop, I didnt love ballads. This was the song that changed my mind. I love this song!
Omg rediscovering this song after years... underrated af masterpiece. And damn chansung’s performance here was amazing🥺 wish I could see him get these roles in dramas
I hope Joo could comeback to stage again, she has a really beautiful voice And she shouldn't worry about her past rumor, a lot of other artists could overcome it. But if she's still enjoying musical, it's all her choice. Good luck Joo :D
Joo is doing musical now and she's cut her hair short. Time surely flies... This is my favorite song of her and this music video is one of my favorites too. JYP should plan a big a comeback for Joo, this girl's got something!
Ugh the end gets me every single time TT the mv is amasterpiece !!! Fightiing joo with ur new single ~~ ( i can't help but fangirl over channie HE LOOKS SOOO HOT *FANS SELF*)
This song I'll never forget. I remember when she sang it live for the first time. It represents a terrible relationship that I had with someone I loved, it was short, but it lasted many years at the same time. Seems like I've healed after all these years, I managed not to cry while watching this for the first time. Phew..
This is still her best song!!! Her new ballad is nice but this one, I don't know, I can't help but think is more powerful. She delivers this song with such emotion..... I've really liked this song since release and have come back multiple times over the years to listen to it. I just love this song so much!! I'm very happy to see Joo back!!!
노래가 처음 나왔을때가 중학생이였는데 그때 들어도 노래가 너무 좋았고 목소리도 정말 좋아서 매일 듣곤 했는데 뒤늦게나마 알려지게되서 마음한켠으론 아쉽고 다행이라 생각합니다 무대울렁증때문에 음악방송에 나오시면 너무 심각하게 목소리가 떨리셔서 방송출연을 못하게 된걸로 알고있습니다 다른 영상보시면 나오는데 정말 안타깝습니다 목소리도 좋으신데...
Había perdido esta canción, la escuche una vez allá por el año 2012 y me encantó, hoy 28 de diciembre 2023 lo volví a encontrar ❤ ADORO ESTA HERMOSA BALADA!!!
it's been what 3 years? and this song is still one of my favourite songs ever. i wish she comes back! She's featured on BTOB's new album too with Ilhoon (her bro!) Can't wait to hear it!
After watching this video and hearing the song I couldn't stop myself from crying. Wow, this song is amazing. I'm glad I found this song after listening Baek Yerin on Weekly Idol. I really liked it !!!!!
I heard this song at the time it was released. It was so emotional and impressive to me. I even forgot the song title but still remember the content in the clip. I searched this MV for a long time. And today I saw it. My feelings remain the same
she just so underrated T.T she has beautiful and unique vocal, even could reach high pitch. she nee mooooreeeee comeback until people recognize her, she deserves that fame.
OMG , I listened this song 4 years ago.. and now "Timeline " again listen.. and I new ,I rediscovered.. Chansung too this movie. wo wow wow ..Joo please Comeback..your voice perfect.. , Do not waste time and immediately turn..Fighting
I love everything about this. Joo sings with so much emotion and passion that this song will always hit you hard. And the video is so unlike the usual K-pop video. I love Joo and I really really wish she would get the recognition she deserves as soon as possible cause I'm so scared she'll leave this industry. She's amazing and if she leaves, it would be such a loss. She's got so much talent in her and I really wanna see more of it.
I didn't even knew that Joo is from JYP. She's amazing! Can't wait to see her on stage with Woollim's logo! Oh my goodness! This MV has a lot of messages that you can keep into your mind. 대박!
the thing i love about JOO is she not rushing to return to the music scene after debut she realize she need improvement,back to being aand went trainee which is very difficult, unlike many idols group rushing to debut and lack traing and talents , i really admire her , hope the hard work paid off , Joo deserve it
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
뮤비 참잘만듦 황찬성 연기오짐
이노래는 듣다보면 자연스럽게 뮤비까지 떠올라서 꼭 보러오게 됨. 진짜 황찬성 연기를 너무 잘해 ㅠㅠ 같잖다는 표정으로 비눗방울 뿌려줄때 내가 주도 아닌데 심장 짜갈라짐.
짜갈라짐ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅇㅈㅇㅈㅠㅠ뮤비에 과몰입 오지게 하게됨ㅎㅎ
헐 저두요....비눗방울 총 쏠때 몰입 쩔어요 황찬성 포마드머리에 표정때문에 더
우리집듣다가 찬성이가 집으로 가자고해서 따라가면 저꼴 나는건가요??ㅠㅠ
@@문보민-z3z 아앜ㅋㅋㅋㅋㄲㅋ연결성 오지네유
짜갈라졐ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ ㄹㅇ 이거 뮤비 보면 연기 다들 잘해서 내 맴이 다 아픔 ㅠㅠㅠ
주 표정 연기가 너무 간절하고 절실해서 슬프다
레알 핵명곡 나만알고싶은 가수인듯 ㅠㅠ 진짜 노래 진짲ㅎ다 ㅠㅠ 여러분 주 왜안뜨는지알려주실분 나쁜남자 꼭들으세요 이별노래로도 최고입니다 ㅠㅠ
삐 삐 진짜.... 핵인정.... ㅠㅠ 너무좋아요
초딩떄 봤는데 뮤비에서 나오는 몸짓이 웃겨서 기억 하는 .. 'ㅁ'
학교폭력때문에 못뜸
충분히뜬 노랜데 이건
남자때문에도ㅠㅠㅠ
황찬성때문에 보러왔다가 뮤비 자꾸 생각나서 하루에 한번씩 오는중····
지금 나와도 듣기좋은노래..
이때 찬성이형 연기 핵소름 ㄷㄷ
찬성이집 가는 분들 여기 꼭 오시길 ㅠ 주기적으루 뮤비 복습함
또 노래내주시면 좋겠다 여러 설이 돌았지만... 무대극복하시고 제발 노래내주셨으면 이런 노래 죽기전에 한번만 더들어보고싶다 8년이지났네벌써 나만아는노래가된건가 ㅜㅜ
명곡에 가사도 편곡도 좋고
뮤비도 감성 풍부하고 아주 많은 요소들이 가미된 명작입니다.
잘 감상했습니다.
라이브가 약하다는게 단점이지만 호소력 하나만큼은 정말 좋다..가끔 생각나면 예전 곡들을 쭉 찾아듣는데 지금도 좋네
숨은명곡임 애절한감정이 녹아든 보컬도 잘어울리고 묻힌게 아까운노래
와 찬성 미쳤다 2:37 부터 대비된 모습 나올 때 괜히 내 가슴이 사무침.. ㅠ 연기도 잘하고 10존잘 ㅠ ㅠ
그 뒤에 비누방울 총 꺼내니까 어이없단 듯이 웃는거도 미침 그냥 ㅈㄴㅈㄴ 미침 도란만
3:07 뭐 이거? 가소롭다는 표정도 맴찢ㅠㅠ
1
뮤비 지금 다시봐도 개잘만듬. 왠만한 영화 씹어먹는다
Still one of my favorite ballads in kpop. This truly deserves more views!! Such a beautiful song...
Who still watching this in 2019? This so is really good. I cried a little everytime I'm immersed in it
2020 thoo
I cry every time I listen to this song!
Yesss Chansung is so good at acting, I hated him 😭 and the song sounds so desperate too
2024
아름답던 비누방울이 연약할 것 같던 비누방울이 마지막에 폭탄처럼 변해있을 때.. 이야....
갑자기 생각나서 들으러 옴. 명곡이고 뮤비도 너무 좋음
비투비 일훈오빠가 속해있는 비투비 팬 멜로디에요! 일훈오빠 누나께서 주씨라 하셔서 찾아왔는데ㅜ노래를 너무 잘부르시네요ㅠ가족이 다..잘부르셔
I think this is actually one of the best ballads ever made.
The bubble gun was GENIUS
Agreed!
I agree!! Adds so many depths to this mv
@@noukie582 agreed. It makes this mv could be view from so many angles. The director is genius. It perfectly conveyed the broken heart of the girl.
황찬성 연기 왜케잘해? 그리고 뮤비 몰입감 대체뭐임? 미쳤는데????
엊그제 이트라이브(곡 작곡가)가 하는 말이, 노래 나왔을땐 차트 올킬했는데 라이브할 때마다 너무 긴장해서 점점 아쉬워졌다고 하네요. 그러다 안나오게된듯...이 노래 참 좋은데, 아쉬운 가수~ 이젠 달라졌기를~
진짜 띵곡이다 중학생때 많이들었는데..
황찬성 진짜 좀 과하게 잘생겼다;; 까만머리도 잘생겼는데 빨간머리일때 존나 귀엽고 쩌네...
황찬성 여기서 너무 멋지게나옴..
거의 10년전 치고 뮤비도 잘 만들고 연기들도 잘 했음 ㅎ
나..나쁜남자 연기하는 황찬성씨...너무잘생겨서 헤어나올수가없어요
이 노래는 뮤비까지 봐줘야 감상이 완벽해지는 느낌
This song is so good. I really wanted a Joo/Baek Ah Yeon collab. Imagine how amazing that would've been.
+Flourescent39 omg. That would've been amazing. I wish they were able to do that before Joo left for Woollim.
me too😍
Flourescent39 jimin park 15&
둘다 연기 쩔음
그 당시에도 진짜 좋아했던 노래고 뮤비 보고 찬성이 비주얼에 폭격당했었던...ㅠ찬성이 연기 너무 좋아ㅠ 이렇게 오랜 시간 지나서 봐도 여전히 노래 너무 좋고 뮤비 진짜 좋구나..잘 만들었다ㅠ
요 감성 ? 감정 너무 좋아용
@@공오공구-z5z 인정인정👍
still remember the 1st listened to this song i was crying :( such an emotional voice and this song was way damn touchin. cant believe its already been 9 years :((((
This song keeps coming back to my homepage for years now..
황찬성...와...할말 없게 만드네...제왑에서 얼굴만보고 데려갈만하다...
명곡이에요~ 2023년에도 들으러 오네요!ㅎㅎ
Joo pleaseee stay forever in JYP even not many people recognize you but for JYP stan you are the best singer for us.. we love you Joo! expecting to hear Joo, Jun. K, Changmin of 2AM and 15&.... pleaseeeee!
우리집때매 여기까지 왔는데 저만 이거 계속 보게되나요,,?찬성이 연기때매 계속 보게 되네요 미쳐따ㅠ
주 목소리는 언제
들어도 트랜디하네요💙
This song deserves more appreciation
2021 anyone? i miss JOO i hope she make another comeback like this song❤
아직도 듣는 노래.. 주의 목소리가 처절해서 좋다 찬성은 나쁜남자 역할에 잘어울림ㅋㅋㅋ 연기도 잘하고
I LOVED THIS SONG ! I didn't kwon she was under JYP and now under woollim ! Can't wait to see her solo !
Her voice would match with woohyun's voice in my opinion ! I want a collaboration omg.
I agree with you. Actually I've liked her voice since I watch Dream High Season 1. Then she joined Woollim and now she comebacks with new song. I'm really excited.
eh I mean I agree with you aboht collaboration with Woohyun. Maybe she will (when Woohyun debut as solo 😆😆😆)
+Dana R her, woohyun and lovelyz's jin as a vocal sub unit.
i know she is having a come back, the teaser video looks good ! I really can't wait to see it.
i love her voice
+Mélissa Ermacora ahaha maybe someday after woohyun realese his solo. And a lot Inspirit want Infinite V too. So maybe after that.
+Dana R i'm still waiting for infinite V too.. haha
we only can wait :)
Who ever wrote this song and directed this MV is a pure genius!
아직도 좋다ㅠㅜ
너무 뜨거워 싫어
너만 사랑하고 사랑하는 내가 싫어 바보 같이
슬픈 노래가 싫어
자꾸 아파하며 또 훌쩍거리다
결국 입을 막고 너를 불러 Oh
Ah I`m so sorry
울지 말라면 다신 안 울게
오 제발 잡은 손을 놓지는 마
Ah I`m so sorry
여린 마음은 점점 멀어질 때 마다
새까맣게 타 들어가잖아
이 나쁜 남자야 넌 못된 남자야
한 사람만 너만 바라보고 사는 난
약한 여자야 착한 여자야
가면 어떡해 떠나면 어떡해
오 너무 차가워 싫어
다른 사람처럼 나를 바라보는
오 그 눈빛이 너무 싫어 Oh
Ah I`m so sorry
니가 하라는 대로 다 할게
우리 다시 처음으로 돌아가자
Ah I`m so sorry
어린 나는 쉽게 구겨지고
결국 찢어져서 아파
이 나쁜 남자야 넌 못된 남자야
한 사람만 너만 바라보고 사는 난
약한 여자야 착한 여자야
가면 어떡해 떠나면 어떡해
자존심 상하고 속상하면 어때
너만 돌아와준다면 괜찮아
오늘도 난 니 집 앞에 서서 홀로 널 기다려
그래 너 밖에 모르는 바보인가 봐 난 정말
여자로 태어나서 단 하루만 살아봐
한 사람만 나만 바라보고 살아봐
나쁜 남자야 나쁜 바보야
가면 어떡해 떠나면 어떡해
감사합니다
고마워
주 노래 좋아했는데 아쉽다...
Omg yes I finally remember her name after all these years and found this mv. I remember when I was just getting in kpop, I didnt love ballads. This was the song that changed my mind. I love this song!
시간이 지나면 지나서 들을수록 너무좋아서 꼭 평생듣고싶어요
Omg rediscovering this song after years... underrated af masterpiece. And damn chansung’s performance here was amazing🥺 wish I could see him get these roles in dramas
I'll listen to this again in 2024. This is the saddest song that I always remember in 2011. Oh, Chansung, u r the baddest guy in the MV.
I hope Joo could comeback to stage again, she has a really beautiful voice
And she shouldn't worry about her past rumor, a lot of other artists could overcome it. But if she's still enjoying musical, it's all her choice. Good luck Joo :D
Shiro Neko what is the rumor?
Emily Park the usual iljin rumor
+Shiro Neko she's coming back!! under Woollim Entertainment!!
+Shiro Neko she's in woollim again! :D
+Shiro Neko She's back! Her new song is Cry & Blow.
옛날 감성이 느껴진다 이런노래도 이젠 추억이다 진짜
Joo is doing musical now and she's cut her hair short.
Time surely flies...
This is my favorite song of her and this music video is one of my favorites too. JYP should plan a big a comeback for Joo, this girl's got something!
her acting in this video is great!
뮤비가 너무 좋아
The best Melody and Suit with JOO Voice....her Voice so sadly...arrrgggghhhh i hope this song gonna Win at Music Chart....
와나 초딩때 이 노래 진짜 좋아했었는데ㅜㅜㅜ추억ㅜㅜ
뮤비 끝내주네요잉ㅎㄷㄷ
BOO your brother is very proud of you even if this song isn't brand new it's still great
주 노래중에 젤 좋음
아 이 노래였구나,,, 내가 초딩 때 들었던 노래가 이거였어,,,,
군대에서 처음봤는데 뮤비 너무 잘만들어서 다시보러옴ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Ugh the end gets me every single time TT the mv is amasterpiece !!! Fightiing joo with ur new single ~~ ( i can't help but fangirl over channie HE LOOKS SOOO HOT *FANS SELF*)
노래 좋아서 찾아 듣게됨
Why the view is so little ?
When I'm feel so down, I'll come to this mv.....
I really like her voice 😍
Joo fighting
2015 this song is still good
2damecuteUK 2017 and its still good
2019 and it's still good
2020 epidemic year it's still awesome!
Please JYP Joo need a comeback! i miss Joo
13 anos se passaram e essa música continua inesquecível. 🤍
헤어지고 듣기 딱 좋은곡이네.
가슴이 무너지는 기분임.
Rediscovering this song in 2020. This song was so underrated. It's so emotional and still relevant to this day!
Chansung ♡♡♡
Một bài hát khá hợp với thời tiết mưa se lạnh của mùa thu đông. Rất lâu rồi mới nghe lại. Nhớ những kí ức thời học trò
This song I'll never forget. I remember when she sang it live for the first time.
It represents a terrible relationship that I had with someone I loved, it was short, but it lasted many years at the same time.
Seems like I've healed after all these years, I managed not to cry while watching this for the first time. Phew..
Yeah, it is a great song
the way her sing this song, always make my tears flow without i realize..
She's sing like talking (full of deep feeling)
This is still her best song!!! Her new ballad is nice but this one, I don't know, I can't help but think is more powerful. She delivers this song with such emotion..... I've really liked this song since release and have come back multiple times over the years to listen to it. I just love this song so much!!
I'm very happy to see Joo back!!!
노래가 처음 나왔을때가 중학생이였는데 그때 들어도 노래가 너무 좋았고 목소리도 정말 좋아서 매일 듣곤 했는데 뒤늦게나마 알려지게되서 마음한켠으론 아쉽고 다행이라 생각합니다
무대울렁증때문에 음악방송에 나오시면 너무 심각하게 목소리가 떨리셔서 방송출연을 못하게 된걸로 알고있습니다 다른 영상보시면 나오는데 정말 안타깝습니다 목소리도 좋으신데...
THIS SONG WAS SO NICE!!!!!!!!
Omg her voice is so nice TT
She is a talented singer!!!!
Había perdido esta canción, la escuche una vez allá por el año 2012 y me encantó, hoy 28 de diciembre 2023 lo volví a encontrar ❤
ADORO ESTA HERMOSA BALADA!!!
2pm Changsung!!!!!!🥰😍💕
it's been what 3 years? and this song is still one of my favourite songs ever. i wish she comes back! She's featured on BTOB's new album too with Ilhoon (her bro!) Can't wait to hear it!
After watching this video and hearing the song I couldn't stop myself from crying. Wow, this song is amazing. I'm glad I found this song after listening Baek Yerin on Weekly Idol. I really liked it !!!!!
주~~~ 너가 승리자야!
이 댓글들을 봐!
너 팬이 상당해.!
물론 주 너가 힘들었단겄도 알아
하지만 Joo 바로 Yoo 아니 Joo 그래 그게 바로 너!! !
I heard this song at the time it was released. It was so emotional and impressive to me. I even forgot the song title but still remember the content in the clip. I searched this MV for a long time. And today I saw it. My feelings remain the same
she just so underrated T.T she has beautiful and unique vocal, even could reach high pitch. she nee mooooreeeee comeback until people recognize her, she deserves that fame.
황찬성 종오오오온나 잘생겼다::;;;;
OMG , I listened this song 4 years ago.. and now "Timeline " again listen.. and I new ,I rediscovered.. Chansung too this movie. wo wow wow ..Joo please Comeback..your voice perfect.. , Do not waste time and immediately turn..Fighting
I love how chill Chansung is with the fact she just kicked open the door and knocked down the other girl
I love everything about this. Joo sings with so much emotion and passion that this song will always hit you hard. And the video is so unlike the usual K-pop video. I love Joo and I really really wish she would get the recognition she deserves as soon as possible cause I'm so scared she'll leave this industry. She's amazing and if she leaves, it would be such a loss. She's got so much talent in her and I really wanna see more of it.
chansung 😍😍
Gosh she need to make a comeback......seriously.....I do miss her.......
1:35 와 씨 눈빛뭐냐 개존잘
울 일훈이에 누나분♡♡ 이노래 예전부터 되게 좋아했구 더 좋은 노래 많이 불러주시길
4 August 2020, i like this song so much. And i like she's voice too.
omg this song is freakn amazing !
and channie why so handsome
I didn't even knew that Joo is from JYP. She's amazing! Can't wait to see her on stage with Woollim's logo! Oh my goodness!
This MV has a lot of messages that you can keep into your mind. 대박!
I love her voice! shes so talented~
and chansung looks handsome =D
Joo come back pleaseeeeeeeeeee
the thing i love about JOO is she not rushing to return to the music scene after debut she realize she need improvement,back to being aand went trainee which is very difficult, unlike many idols group rushing to debut and lack traing and talents , i really admire her , hope the hard work paid off , Joo deserve it
Korean ballads are the best for sure !!!!!
OMG!
i love this mv chansung so smart and cute in the same time