썸네일만 봐도 진짜 프듀 메이크업이 거의 모두에게 레전드였다....강혜원 진짜 초롱초롱하게 예쁜데 초반에 어디서 기어세컨드 그런거 해서 반전이라고 인기 많아진걸로 알고있는데..거기다 헬바야때도 물론 노래가 뛰어난건 아니었지만 랩보단 노래담당이었는데 메인래퍼 하겠다고 먼저 나서서 하고..실력 전혀 없고 외모로만 뽑혔다기보단 이런것들을 좋게봐서 순위가 높지 않았나 싶네요 광배 지금은 표정도 많이 자연스러워지고 많이 늘었는데 다음 컴백도 기대되네요
@James Henry Smith definitely and when i watched produce48, it did happen. They showcased Minju and Hyewon improving and they get to debut Typical MNet
@@simdy12356 왕이런은 이쁘긴 했지만 은근히 캐릭터가 튄다거나 돋보이진 않았음. 그래서 막판에 인기가 조금씩 떨어지고 결정적으로 악편당해서 순위 폭락... 반면 강혜원은 실력적으론 왕이런보단 밑이어도 프듀 방영 내내 보여준 자신만의 캐릭터가 확실했기에 인기 떡상함. 왕이런은 예쁜애가 그냥 예쁜 모습으로 비춰졌기 때문에 비주얼 말고 딱히 다른 모습이 안보였지만 강혜원은 예쁜 비주얼과 상반된 반전 모습을 많이 보여줘서 기어세컨드, 미나미맘 등등 캐릭터가 많았음. 둘다 스타성이 없진 않지만 상대적으로 스타성이 더 돋보였던건 강혜원이었지
True but that is unfortunately normal in the kpop industry. They push them to improve and some even say that trainers (not frm pd48) are very harsh behind the scenes
OF COURSE HYE WON IMPROVED!!!! She learned how to rap well, and she worked on her shortocomings on dance and vocal!!She totally deserved to be part of IZONE with Minju!! Bye haters
as a singer, hyewon was actually not as bad as the editing makes her out to be. she sounded very quiet and at times unstable, but overall i have definitely heard worse performances from debuted idols. she improved her stability and projection, and you can tell she has a nice voice now. eventually, either way, she found a place in rapping and i think that was best. yes, the first stages in which she rapped sounded like it was a mistake to switch, but in the end she improved and, if she kept going with the training, she would actually be *very* good. her voice just really suits it imo.
Idk why but I see a lot of potential in the first girl In some moments of her performance she actually sounded good If she continues training she will sing well one day I'll be rooting for her, she doesn't deserve any type of hype but she doesn't deserve hate too -.-
Hyewon wasn’t bad here, Mnet was quite mean with pointing out her footsteps and bumping the mic. Sure, she was quite and a bit unstable, but I think her mic was kinda quiet too. Minjoo especially wasn’t bad! I thought she was good! Her mic was quiet as well, and I thought she was very professional at covering up her mistake. Of course, Mnet edits the judges to look bored. Rude.
@@오뜨-b2q ㅋㅋㅋ사쿠라는 아이돌짬덕에 끼라도 있는데 강혜원은 맨날 같은표정 끼도없고 ㅋㅋ 노래 춤 표정 다 핵못인데 f맞지 ㅋㅋㅋ 안준영이 미나미끼워서 그렇게까지 분량안줬으면 애초에 광탈했을 그리고 실질적으로 사쿠라 현재 졸라 노력해서 춤 잘춤... 노래도 비음 놓고 많이 나아졌고 표정 표현 풍부한걸로 해외팬들한테도 호평~강씨는 아직도 뻣뻣쓰 광배니 뭐니 캐릭터성이랑 얼굴외에 실질적으로 실력으로는 인정하는사람 읎죵
Minjoo (the second lady) wasn’t even THAT bad. In fact she’s... not good, but not bad at all. Voice is stable, not too weak too (though backtrack was heavy). Dance moves were well-executed for at least the first half of the song. What’s with the editing? :l
RUclips Account Yh I don’t like the editing either and the judges’ faces it’s like the worst performance they’ve ever seen and it’s not that bad. Minjoo is good and she can improve she was just really nervous😕😕
I know it's their job to judge them and be critical of what needs the criticism, but I could never to Hyewon. She looks so freakin sweet and truly pure, I couldn't say a single thing bad to her 🥺
i don’t even stan iz*one but i knew from the first time i saw hyewon in the boombayah team, she was someone special. she didn’t want to give up and wanted to help chowon and the others. she’s not the best, but she’s working hard !
That first girl hasn't had experience in dancing her voice is good but she needs to not be nervous on herself she needs to let it all out more and the second girl her dance is good but still a Little bit of development in both singing and dancing
Now these two became one of the important assets in the group. Well, all of them are but now they're the rappers who plays the guitar and both captivated viewers with their visuals.
woong's onion did listen to Hyewon live and yes I did listen to colours. I understand having a ‘weak’ member for eg. Sohye from iOi improved throughout the show, I didn’t see any improvement in hyewon
나또한 혜원이를 데뷔시킨 한사람이에요. 이 아이의 미래에 이날의 기억이 후회가아닌 인생의 가장 행복하고 아름다운날로 기억하며 살수있기를 바라신다면 처음마음처럼 끝까지 혜원이를 지켜주세요. 혜원이에게도 너무 특별한 프듀1화지만 저에게도 너무특별한 프듀1화 입니다. 혜원이란 아이를 알면서 인생에 행복 한스푼을 더하며 살고있거든요.
they were bad (especially hweyon, minju was alright) but what matters was their improvements now that they’ve debuted !! minju especially has grown so much and has become a true artist, she has a long way to go but her dancing/singing have improved rapidly and she even wrote a song on the bloomiz album ?? we know the lineup was rigged, but it’s nice to see that the girls have taken this and worked their hardest to prove themselves especially after the controversy
hyewon isnt that bad. I have to agree her voice is not that stable. but she can hit the notes perfectly. mnet evil editing is really rude to her and also minju,I think they were both nervous in that day, but they're great and they deserve to debut.
it's 2020 but I still love to watch this because I really believe Kang Hyewon's voice is beautiful. She just lacks in confidence and training but Her tone is really beautiful and soothing.
여기 나올 당시 혜원이는 경험만 쌓아보란 의미로.민주도 마찬가지로 소속사에서 내보냄. 당시 소속사에서 연습생들 따로 보컬 안무 연습도 없었던 ..그런 와중에 광배 덕력매력 폭발로 대인기.밍구리 애잔함으로 인기폭발! 광배의 지옥에서 돌아온 청순래퍼 보면.애가 얼마나 대단한지 알게 되고.밍구리 1000%에서 100000%로 빛남.결론은 지금 아이즈원 인기의 12날개 중 2날개로 절정의 인기 행진 중~~~ 이게 펙트!
Truth be told.. They both did not perform as bad as Mnet made it look like. Hyewon was timid, but her dance is ok. Minjoo.. Gosh.. She did great here. Mnet's editing skills leveled 10000000000. 🙄
Minju just lacks confidence, y'all haters better stop talking about her. She has improved so much. Her parts in their collab with gidle and itzy are amazing 😭 she's dangerous
몇가지만 알아두시죠 강혜원은 소속사를 여러번 옮기던 떠돌이 연습생이었고 마지막이었던 에잇디에서는 아이돌을 키워본적이 없어서 트레이닝을 제대로 받지 못한 채로 프듀에 나왔습니다 그리고 여기서 '못하면 왜 나와'라고 하시는 분들있을 까봐 얘기하는데 프듀에 나오는 조건에 실력은 없는 것으로 압니다 그래서 1화에서 등급을 매기고 그 등급 맞춤으로 트레이닝을 하는 것이죠 그리고 투표조건에 실력은 없었습니다 자기가 싫었으면 투표안하면 그만입니다 이미 데뷔한 가수들을 욕하지 말아주세요 님들말대로 못한다고 탈퇴한다고 해도 의지가 없다면서 욕했을 거잖아요 항상 악플 볼때마다 팬인 저도 힘든데 본인은 어떻겠습니까 비판과 비난은 구분해주세요 제발요
Compare Hyewon’s this stage to one of her Violeta stage. Ya’ll will see how much she has improved and worked hard. Even in the show she did her best to improve. We love our princess HYEWON💗
all these anti’s in the comments are... I think both of them did a good job, hyewon sounded good she just had some un-stable moments + her mic was quiet and mnet really did her wrong with the footsteps zoom, she just needed to work on her dancing which she did, and Minju did well it’s just that she was too nervous for stable vocals, not to mention how much movement the dance involved which doesn’t allow stable vocals.
yes, they are stunning, that does not mean it’s all they have, and there’s nothing wrong with being beautiful, grow up Anti’s (oh and you don’t need facial expressions to be an idol) + HYEWON ONLY TRAINED FOR 1 YEAR 😐.
I am so much proud of them. First of all, they both debuted, their skills had a huge improvement, specially in singing and dancing, and of course, they had tons of accomplishments achieved in their lives, and as a member of Iz*one.
Please dont hate minjoo shes simply nervous... shes actually very talented if you don’t believe me check out her stage with kriesha chu or her dance covers
I CAN SMELL THAT MINJOO WILL BE THE NEXT BAE JINYOUNG. LIKE THEY ARE NERVOUS ABD SCARED AT FIRST BUT IN THE END THEY GOT TO SHOW THE VIEWERS THEIR TALENTS
I told you guys! Minjoo can sing, rap and dance. She just needs to build her confidence. And look at her now, she is more confident and competitive! Minju let's debut! Knets, please vote for her.
people need to stop hating on hyewon . she's in iz*one already and doing fine so can people just accept it and move on ? hyewon will improve , i feel that she was probably not ready to debut honestly but she's improving , she will get better . and minju has improved greatly , look at 1000% . she did great . she's not "jUsT a vIsUaL , nO tAlEnT" .
Hyewon probably should’ve gotten a D at least. She did hit the E5 which is very high but she didn’t show much else so I would’ve given her D. Minju deserved a C for sure. Her vocals weren’t very good, but her dancing was on point. She’s just bad at dropping down.
how is this evil editing haha evil editing is a term you use when they twist the contestant's words with editing... this isnt evil editing it's literally just showing two girls who didnt do very well and didnt get good grades
Why do I have six subscribers Goes to prove that fans of Kpop will automatically assume good looking people are talentless . Didn’t you get that from this clip?
Let alone clicking like of not knowing exactly what their liking? We seriously need to decrease human population in this world, because we have too many dumb ass people! 😀😁😂
For hyewon, it isnt really bad at all like. Compare to the other contestants that actually off tune. I know she's not really talented but there's always an asset that wins the heart of the viewer. Not just her face but her personality. ❤️
![PRODUCE48 [1회] 첫 도전! 울림(러블리즈)과 WM(오마이걸)의 실력파 연습생!ㅣ울림김수윤, 권은비, 김소희, 김채원, WM이채연, 이승현, 조영인 180615 EP.1](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HmwgNRwp4JU/mqdefault.jpg)
![PRODUCE48 [1회] 첫 도전! 울림(러블리즈)과 WM(오마이걸)의 실력파 연습생!ㅣ울림김수윤, 권은비, 김소희, 김채원, WM이채연, 이승현, 조영인 180615 EP.1](/img/tr.png)
![[IZ*ONE 아이즈원] 실전 압축 원영듀스 # 1](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dP_afCPSgD8/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ENG sub] PRODUCE48 [10회] ♬Rumorㅣ′작곡가 대만족′ 국.슈(국프의 핫이슈) @콘셉트 평가 180817 EP.10](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Y5B9pxWa3Is/mqdefault.jpg)
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ENG sub] PRODUCE48 [2회] 등급 재평가 'F에서 진주를 찾은 것 같아요' 180622 EP.2](/img/1.gif)
썸네일만 봐도 진짜 프듀 메이크업이 거의 모두에게 레전드였다....강혜원 진짜 초롱초롱하게 예쁜데 초반에 어디서 기어세컨드 그런거 해서 반전이라고 인기 많아진걸로 알고있는데..거기다 헬바야때도 물론 노래가 뛰어난건 아니었지만 랩보단 노래담당이었는데 메인래퍼 하겠다고 먼저 나서서 하고..실력 전혀 없고 외모로만 뽑혔다기보단 이런것들을 좋게봐서 순위가 높지 않았나 싶네요 광배 지금은 표정도 많이 자연스러워지고 많이 늘었는데 다음 컴백도 기대되네요
김민주는 계속 볼수록 빠져드는 매력 있게 예쁜 스타일이고 강혜원은 그냥 보자마자 헉 소리나게 예쁜 스타일?
어쨌든 둘 다 존예
민주 진짜 개예쁘다 처음에는 왜이쁘다고 하는지 몰랐는데 지금보니깐 여신이네
은서 니보단 나을듯
@@우짤요-w5n ㅆㅇㅈ ㅋㅋㅋ 주제모르고 ㅈㄴ 씨부림
@@우짤요-w5n아이즈원 팬이긴 한데 민주는 연생이고 쟤는 일반인인데 왜 비교를 쳐하냐 애초에 비교상대가 안 되지
@@예연-y8x 지금은 노래노 늘고 음색도 쩔어ㅋ
보니까 댓삭튀했네,.ㅋㅋ 암것도 모르고 욕하지맙시다
강혜원 지금도 왕창 이쁘긴한데 저렇게 입고 화장한게 훨씬 이쁘다 아이즈원 스타일리스트 메이크업 아티스트 듣고 있나?
난 지금이 더 예쁜데...
컨셉에 맞춰야 돼서 그래요 그리고 아이즈원에서 화려한 스타일이 잘 어울리는 멤버들도 섞여있어서 강혜원 혼자만 잘 어울린다고 저렇게 평범하게 꾸며놓으면 오히려 또 욕 먹을걸요?
But who would thought that these two are rappers, pure innocent rapper on their comeback Violeta and they played the guitar on I really like you 😭💕💕
Ikr, they improved so much and became much more confident especially Minju 💕
Yes they both improved so much! Especially in Oneiric Diary! Minju got center and Hyewon is more confident than always
Hyewon's performance wasn't even that bad, Mnet evil edited her and the judges to the max
@James Henry Smith She’s the one who chose the song. No one forced her.
They probably wanted some drama by seeing the "F girl" improve and debut
This is Mnet, it's for the views
@James Henry Smith definitely and when i watched produce48, it did happen. They showcased Minju and Hyewon improving and they get to debut
Typical MNet
프듀에서는 얼굴만 이쁘고 잘생기면 실력F여도 다 데뷔했음 그러니 저 실력에도 얼굴믿고 보내는거지ㅇㅇ
@@simdy12356 이게 얼굴이쁘고는 좀 아니고
캐릭터가있어야댐
@@simdy12356 왕이런은 이쁘긴 했지만 은근히 캐릭터가 튄다거나 돋보이진 않았음. 그래서 막판에 인기가 조금씩 떨어지고 결정적으로 악편당해서 순위 폭락... 반면 강혜원은 실력적으론 왕이런보단 밑이어도 프듀 방영 내내 보여준 자신만의 캐릭터가 확실했기에 인기 떡상함. 왕이런은 예쁜애가 그냥 예쁜 모습으로 비춰졌기 때문에 비주얼 말고 딱히 다른 모습이 안보였지만 강혜원은 예쁜 비주얼과 상반된 반전 모습을 많이 보여줘서 기어세컨드, 미나미맘 등등 캐릭터가 많았음. 둘다 스타성이 없진 않지만 상대적으로 스타성이 더 돋보였던건 강혜원이었지
왕이런은 중국이라 런이미지
다 틀렷네 왕이런은 걍 주작으로 떨어졋지...ㅋㅋㅋ 떨어질 수없던 미모엿음
ㄴㄴㄴ 주작
솔직히 소속사별 평가 민주랑 사쿠라 비슷한것같은데 ㅜㅠㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ민주는 D 사쿠라는 A ... 솔직히 민주 저거 영상보니까 D까지도 아니더만
민주가 사쿠라보다 못했음. 근데 사쿠라도 확실히 A까지는 아니었음
@@이안-f8q 풀영상 보고오세용~!💕
신비비 엥 민주가 훨나음
신비비 이영상에선 못해보이는데 엠넷이올려준 풀영상보면 괜찮음
그니까요ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 배윤정이 나 한번만 믿어봐 이러고 A보냈더니 얼굴빨로 센터 차지하고 실력이 늘긴해도 민주처럼 확달라지는건 또 아님. 민주를 A로 보냈으면했는데...얼굴도 이쁘고 점점 실력이 늘어가면서 사쿠라의 두세배를 잘함.
ミンジュこの時に比べてすごく痩せて本当に綺麗になったと思う…スゴイなぁ
この時のカンちゃんのビジュアルが最高だと思う。
근데 신기한건 저 두분이 다 데뷔를 하셨다는겈ㅋ
@@hasunmozu 네! 충고감사합니다
@@띵동띵동복숭아누르지 부드럽게 받아주셔서 감사해요! 댓삭 할게요 저도 :)
김민주님은 순위조작이셨네요...
@@몰랑이-v5b 저기욬 얼반웍스는 혐의가 있는 소속사가 아니거든요 ㅎㅎ ㅈㄹ마세요
위즈원 김민주님 말하는건데 에잇디가 왜나오죠..
The way they criticize the idols infront of them is so heartbreaking If I was there I would burst out crying
True but that is unfortunately normal in the kpop industry. They push them to improve and some even say that trainers (not frm pd48) are very harsh behind the scenes
They need to have strong mentality.
It was great for them who can face the critique and learn from it
@David Kim Say that to some artists outside korea who came so far without it
Compared to what people behind screens could say- its quite incomparable...
@@MKahfi-bv1qw Not true, being kind is much more motivating lol. This is proven fact instead of overly harsh
when both of these suit the 'purity' image but ended up doing rap on the group battle lololol let's rise kim minjoo ang kang hyewon
And ended up as rapper in iz*one
They are rappers but not because they are good rappers, its because they cant sing
@@ViickyGar The fuck are you saying...
MINJU is a visual,vocalist and lead rapper...
While HYEWON is a vocalist and a rapper...
Are you deaf??
@@tiffanykaye1794 hyewon also visual and lead rapper
@@samu-ls6yu MINJU is the official visual FYI...
강혜원 F받았을때 전혀 예상하지못한 표정ㅋㅋ
그냥 표정이 저런것같은데 지가 뭔데 남의 표정을 보고 함부로 단정지음?
야옹 시발ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 지가뭔데래 ㅋㅋ 지혼자 열폭 오져ㅜㅜ
야옹 열폭은 니가 한 거 아님??ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 개읏경
ᅲ김민주처돌이 어딜봐서 저게 열폭임?ㅋㅋ 느그들 열폭 뜻 모르냐 진짜? 니년은 민주 개인팬 같은데 아이즈원 팬 아니네 ㅋㅋ 광배 표정으로 까이는 거 뭐라 했더니 그 사람한테 되려 지랄하는 꼬라지 ㅠ
luck un 이미친놈이 위에 개지랄헛소리한새끼한테 한 말인데 그새끼가 댓글 삭제한거임~ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 모르면 쌉치구~
To think both of them made debut
Lol especially hyewon. Im not sure if she improved through out the whole show xd. Minju did though, which i think why she deserves it a bit more
It's what she deserves
OF COURSE HYE WON IMPROVED!!!! She learned how to rap well, and she worked on her shortocomings on dance and vocal!!She totally deserved to be part of IZONE with Minju!! Bye haters
Somehow
smh
as a singer, hyewon was actually not as bad as the editing makes her out to be. she sounded very quiet and at times unstable, but overall i have definitely heard worse performances from debuted idols. she improved her stability and projection, and you can tell she has a nice voice now. eventually, either way, she found a place in rapping and i think that was best. yes, the first stages in which she rapped sounded like it was a mistake to switch, but in the end she improved and, if she kept going with the training, she would actually be *very* good. her voice just really suits it imo.
Idk why but I see a lot of potential in the first girl
In some moments of her performance she actually sounded good
If she continues training she will sing well one day
I'll be rooting for her, she doesn't deserve any type of hype but she doesn't deserve hate too -.-
and then..u right
trueeee
You're right! She's now a member of IZ*One!
Congratulations, all of you either became Hyewon-stans or biased with her
She deserves the hype for her personality, which is what rose her to the top as it emphasises the true beauty she is ♡
Hyewon wasn’t bad here, Mnet was quite mean with pointing out her footsteps and bumping the mic. Sure, she was quite and a bit unstable, but I think her mic was kinda quiet too.
Minjoo especially wasn’t bad! I thought she was good! Her mic was quiet as well, and I thought she was very professional at covering up her mistake. Of course, Mnet edits the judges to look bored. Rude.
I AGREE!
No it's just that Minjoo was nervous
@bangsat ye namanya aja bangsat, komentarnya pun pasti bangsat
@@jaljalayla4499 I agree all of your comment expect visual can be a talent , that's what I can't agree but nvm don't care about me lel
@@jaljalayla4499 dammm sry bro I didn't saw talented but I saw talent lmao sry man 😂😂
이때부터 민주 원픽이었던 내 안목ㅠ 칭찬해
사쿠라 보다가 왔는데 뭔차이인지 1도 모르겠네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅌ 사쿠라A면 애는 적어도 c~b임
강혜원 B
김민주 A
이렇게받아도 별논란 ㄴㄴ함 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@user-fx9tb1lr7w 사쿠라가 A면솔직히 강혜원은BC임
@@오뜨-b2q ㅋㅋㅋ사쿠라는 아이돌짬덕에 끼라도 있는데 강혜원은 맨날 같은표정 끼도없고 ㅋㅋ 노래 춤 표정 다 핵못인데 f맞지 ㅋㅋㅋ 안준영이 미나미끼워서 그렇게까지 분량안줬으면 애초에 광탈했을
그리고 실질적으로 사쿠라 현재 졸라 노력해서 춤 잘춤... 노래도 비음 놓고 많이 나아졌고 표정 표현 풍부한걸로 해외팬들한테도 호평~강씨는 아직도 뻣뻣쓰 광배니 뭐니 캐릭터성이랑 얼굴외에 실질적으로 실력으로는 인정하는사람 읎죵
@@nyamygood 저때말한건데 지금이 왜나옴;;
@@user-fx9tb1lr7w 사쿠라에 비해서라구요
김민주 지원자 쯔위 사나 다보인다.. 하늘의 비쥬얼
그러니까요 ㅋㅋ 비주얼로는 완죤 대박 ..
진짜 소속사에서 딱 얼굴만믿고 보낸듯
팩트ㄷ
뭐 안되도 배우시킨다는 마인드
다른 얘들은 정말 간절한 마음으로 하는데 저런자세로는 배우도 힘들듯
공감 얼굴믿고 노력1 연습1도안하고나온 실력임 장난하나..
김소혜도 되니까 걍 내보낸듯
1:56 からの清純なだけね。 Fです。 からのカンちゃんのきょとんとした顔がめっちゃ好き笑笑
Now that they debuted and had a comeback, we came so far, I'm so proud
Hyewon's audition really wasn't that bad at all, she even hit the high note right on the head and rarely went off tune....
Minjoo (the second lady) wasn’t even THAT bad. In fact she’s... not good, but not bad at all. Voice is stable, not too weak too (though backtrack was heavy). Dance moves were well-executed for at least the first half of the song. What’s with the editing? :l
RUclips Account Yh I don’t like the editing either and the judges’ faces it’s like the worst performance they’ve ever seen and it’s not that bad. Minjoo is good and she can improve she was just really nervous😕😕
RUclips Account
True. She just have a problem in her confidence I think and she should have sang louder.
Life is a bitch they lowered her mic
カンちゃん可愛いすぎやろ。
actually felt bad for these two, but its okay! they have lots of time to improve!
carat soup they are nervous minjoo is a great dancer
Siti Romlah what are you talking about?
Where can we watch?
Tricia Aviya watch what?
You should search her name KIM MIN JU AND KRISHA CHU
I know it's their job to judge them and be critical of what needs the criticism, but I could never to Hyewon. She looks so freakin sweet and truly pure, I couldn't say a single thing bad to her 🥺
thats called pretty privilege
i love hyewon but what is this comment😭 judge her on her talent, which she obviously has, not her looks
@@sieun5459 Someone took my comment WAY too seriously, I- 😭
강혜원 진짜 일본여배우 시바사키 코우 리즈시절 이랑 존똑 아니 더예쁨;;;
강혜원 등급받기전 표정이랑
배윤정이 F입니다 하고 났을때 표정나오는거
개귀여워 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ케
Its insane how they both debuted in the end tho :o
Cherry Allen it’s safe to say that they both worked hard, hyewon and minjoo hwaiting ✊🏻✨
Juri Takahashi should have debuted instead ..
@@georget9640 no
Insane??
Weren't the votes rigged?
2人ともこの頃と比べると実力ついたし垢抜けたなあ(；_；)
i don’t even stan iz*one but i knew from the first time i saw hyewon in the boombayah team, she was someone special. she didn’t want to give up and wanted to help chowon and the others. she’s not the best, but she’s working hard !
민주 잘췄는데ㅠㅠ 악편 개심했음
サムネのカンちゃん強すぎないか！！！！！！
That first girl hasn't had experience in dancing her voice is good but she needs to not be nervous on herself she needs to let it all out more and the second girl her dance is good but still a Little bit of development in both singing and dancing
Misimatoka Stanley Kim Minjoo can sing and dance. She's just so nervous and shy in front of the judges and produce48 members.
JIN IS PRETTIER THAN ME it's true I kind of had the feeling for her nerves I hope she ups her grades cause she needs to let it out more
Misimatoka Stanley let's just wait and support her all the way! HAHAHAHA
JIN IS PRETTIER THAN ME yeah of course
they have improved now and I'm so proud of them
i feel bad for hyewon.... she wasn’t that bad but she seemed super nervous
꧁༺ euph oria ༻꧂ ??? what the heck lol
꧁༺ euph oria ༻꧂ that was unnecessary. And also, it's actually 'you're'
꧁༺ euph oria ༻꧂ can you do better?
꧁༺ euph oria ༻꧂ haven’t heard of u :)
꧁༺ euph oria ༻꧂ good for you, me too
Now these two became one of the important assets in the group. Well, all of them are but now they're the rappers who plays the guitar and both captivated viewers with their visuals.
True. They break everything with their visual and rap skills!!
nomnon Momo Hirai rap skills....okay 😂
Maybe Minnu (I prefer her singing voice more tho)
But Hyewon....nvm
@@jujuukekeke7668 did u listen to their song 'airplane'? or maybe their past side track 'colors'? Well you're probably losing your taste
woong's onion did listen to Hyewon live and yes I did listen to colours. I understand having a ‘weak’ member for eg. Sohye from iOi improved throughout the show, I didn’t see any improvement in hyewon
@@jujuukekeke7668 well that's because of your lack of appreciation.
めちゃくちゃ可愛いかんちゃん
0:23 The best two shot ever in the history of Mnet
that girl in the thumbnail (on the right) looks like a mix of Sana and Jihyo? Am I the only one?
BoOmInNG sYStEM uP UP Ty TY tRAcKk sometimes she looks like tzuyu 😅
She's Kim Min Joo, btw. From urban works ent 😊 She was in Ikon's WYD MV and Kriesha Chu's Like Paradise MV
I love PockyJr More than Pepero ow I didnt know that, thanks for the information my friend
lol i used to think the same
i thought im the only one omg
Minju worked really hard and has improved a lot since produce 48♡
It's hard to forget hyewon's legendary visuals!
나또한 혜원이를 데뷔시킨 한사람이에요. 이 아이의 미래에 이날의 기억이 후회가아닌 인생의 가장 행복하고 아름다운날로 기억하며 살수있기를 바라신다면 처음마음처럼 끝까지 혜원이를 지켜주세요. 혜원이에게도 너무 특별한 프듀1화지만 저에게도 너무특별한 프듀1화 입니다. 혜원이란 아이를 알면서 인생에 행복 한스푼을 더하며 살고있거든요.
기어세컨드
Hyewon looks absolutely mortified because she also knows she isn't that good, but she tried her best and made debut
Hyewon said shes pure but now she takes every member in her harem
that one girl with the rainbow shirt looks like sana from twice
윤기민 She's Kim Minjoo. Please support her! 💞
and dahyun
I see Tzuyu.
oh wait you're right she looks like tzuyu not sana i confused them both
saw her audition she got a D i think
When trainees said minjoo looks like an actress. Yes, they're right.
Hyewon and Minju showing a significant progress on the debut show. So proud. I believe all the trainer also agree with me.
they were bad (especially hweyon, minju was alright) but what matters was their improvements now that they’ve debuted !! minju especially has grown so much and has become a true artist, she has a long way to go but her dancing/singing have improved rapidly and she even wrote a song on the bloomiz album ?? we know the lineup was rigged, but it’s nice to see that the girls have taken this and worked their hardest to prove themselves especially after the controversy
Thank you for this,but I hope you still support hyewon in being in iz one.Both hyewon and minju improved a ton :)
hyewon isnt that bad. I have to agree her voice is not that stable. but she can hit the notes perfectly. mnet evil editing is really rude to her and also minju,I think they were both nervous in that day, but they're great and they deserve to debut.
Kim minjoo is talented, sing, rap, dance and acting. And I believe she can do it. Fighting! 민민 😘👏🏼
1:55 청순만하다 ...ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
moon wild
What’s meen?🧐
@@in-if2umIt is that she is only pretty and is not good at singing and dancing
정우성 I see. Thank you 😊
The two of them debut. Daebak. The power of fans base is real.
it's 2020 but I still love to watch this because I really believe Kang Hyewon's voice is beautiful. She just lacks in confidence and training but Her tone is really beautiful and soothing.
Hyewon in Dreamlike... uuufff 😌😌👌🎵❤
여기 나올 당시 혜원이는 경험만 쌓아보란 의미로.민주도 마찬가지로 소속사에서 내보냄. 당시 소속사에서 연습생들 따로 보컬 안무 연습도 없었던 ..그런 와중에 광배 덕력매력 폭발로 대인기.밍구리 애잔함으로 인기폭발! 광배의 지옥에서 돌아온 청순래퍼 보면.애가 얼마나 대단한지 알게 되고.밍구리 1000%에서 100000%로 빛남.결론은 지금 아이즈원 인기의 12날개 중 2날개로 절정의 인기 행진 중~~~ 이게 펙트!
주작 이게 팩트
09_지우 응 현실은 인기 최고 ~ 방송사 섭외 난리 ~~ ㅋㅋ 이게 팩트 ~
@@전우치-g6x 인기좋든 어쨋든 주작은 맞잖음;;
09_지우 근데 어쩌라고 논점을 못 잡겠는데 🤷♀️
ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 뭔개소리야 그냥 준영이가 아무것도 모르는 이쁜애들 둘 데리고 꾸민 주작쇼지
Truth be told.. They both did not perform as bad as Mnet made it look like.
Hyewon was timid, but her dance is ok.
Minjoo.. Gosh.. She did great here.
Mnet's editing skills leveled 10000000000. 🙄
얼굴만 이쁘고 실력없으면 오히려 독인듯...'얼굴만 믿고 연습 안했구나 ..'이런 생각으로 비호감...
변진희 얼굴못생기고 실력도 없었으면 저자리조차 불가능
그나마 그란 말이 가능하겠죠
얼굴 별로고 실력도 별로면 바로 욕 오지게 박을듯
얼굴, 실력도 별로면 연습생 될수도 없을 듯...부자면 뭐...부자여도 성형하고 나올텐데...
아이즈원 데뷔함. 다들 쓋!
ㅋㅋㅋ이게 일부러 그럴까봐 성장스토리 만들어주는겁니다~ 실력안좋아도 데뷔할수있게
Minju just lacks confidence, y'all haters better stop talking about her. She has improved so much. Her parts in their collab with gidle and itzy are amazing 😭 she's dangerous
강혜원 예쁜 것도 예쁜데 자신감 넘치는 모습이 너무 귀엽고 사랑스러운 느낌ㅋㅋㅋㅋ그래서 못해도 밉지 않은뎈ㅋㅋㅋ
비글이 소파 찢어놓고 뭘잘못한지 모르는 그런느낌ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
몇가지만 알아두시죠
강혜원은 소속사를 여러번 옮기던 떠돌이 연습생이었고 마지막이었던 에잇디에서는 아이돌을 키워본적이 없어서 트레이닝을 제대로 받지 못한 채로 프듀에 나왔습니다
그리고 여기서 '못하면 왜 나와'라고 하시는 분들있을 까봐 얘기하는데 프듀에 나오는 조건에 실력은 없는 것으로 압니다
그래서 1화에서 등급을 매기고 그 등급 맞춤으로 트레이닝을 하는 것이죠
그리고 투표조건에 실력은 없었습니다
자기가 싫었으면 투표안하면 그만입니다
이미 데뷔한 가수들을 욕하지 말아주세요
님들말대로 못한다고 탈퇴한다고 해도 의지가 없다면서 욕했을 거잖아요
항상 악플 볼때마다 팬인 저도 힘든데 본인은 어떻겠습니까
비판과 비난은 구분해주세요 제발요
민주 데뷔하자!!!!!ㅜㅜㅜㅜ
숨은 성지가 있었네 시험 잘 찍게 해주세요
y'all hyewon became a rapper and she is doing pretty well so far!
カンちゃんやば可愛い😍❤️💕
Hyewon voice is so pure and soft the judge is so mean she improved alot minju too
얼굴만 이쁘다. 근데 노래못하면서 왜 하필이면 아이유 노래를..? 그 어려운걸ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
김꽃님
인정 대 공감
연예인들도 좀처럼 엄두를 못내는
곡을 자기자신을 모르고 있어 더
용감함
정확히 똑같은 말 하면서 내려왔는데 역시 사람 생각 다 비슷비슷하구나ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ그러게요 왜 하필 아이유 노래를...
김꽃님 자신이 해내보고 싶어서 도전한거죠 혜원이언니랑 관련된 사람으로서 기분않좋아요
마리네뜨{마가렛} 니 아는 언니를 오냐오냐 안해줘서 속상한건 알겠는데 대중이 보고 느끼는 주관적인 생각이야 ㅇㅋ? 내가 욕을 했니 뭘했니?
마리네뜨{마가렛} 아무리 해내고자 하는 도전 이라지만 아이유 노래는 좀 아니지않니~?ㅋ
Hyewon invented the concept of being pure and pretty
Compare Hyewon’s this stage to one of her Violeta stage. Ya’ll will see how much she has improved and worked hard. Even in the show she did her best to improve. We love our princess HYEWON💗
It’s prince
And it’s Kwangbae
@@pokecather325 I don't believe we shouĺd really assume that
혜원이는 이때가 젤 이쁨. 지금도 이쁘긴 한데 저때 진짜 이뻤음
all these anti’s in the comments are... I think both of them did a good job, hyewon sounded good she just had some un-stable moments + her mic was quiet and mnet really did her wrong with the footsteps zoom, she just needed to work on her dancing which she did, and Minju did well it’s just that she was too nervous for stable vocals, not to mention how much movement the dance involved which doesn’t allow stable vocals.
yes, they are stunning, that does not mean it’s all they have, and there’s nothing wrong with being beautiful, grow up Anti’s (oh and you don’t need facial expressions to be an idol) + HYEWON ONLY TRAINED FOR 1 YEAR 😐.
The minju is just unfortunate with a little lack of confidence, but she's really talented
I am so much proud of them. First of all, they both debuted, their skills had a huge improvement, specially in singing and dancing, and of course, they had tons of accomplishments achieved in their lives, and as a member of Iz*one.
0:44 hyewon melts my heart🧡
この2人ビジュやべえ
2人がまさか受かるとは初めて見た時思わなかった
どんどん魅力を発揮して気づけば推してた
Please dont hate minjoo shes simply nervous... shes actually very talented if you don’t believe me check out her stage with kriesha chu or her dance covers
본방때도 생각했는데 김민주 악편임... 풀영상 보면 나쁘지 않게 했는데 오히려 너무 이쁘니까 평가절하된듯
and now they're proving their worth in debuting. a big slap to everyone doubted them.
カンちゃんこんなに可愛いのに拭いきれない陰キャ感…姿勢かな
どっちもデビューするというね💗
Kim Minju has Jung Chaeyeon's vibe really
I CAN SMELL THAT MINJOO WILL BE THE NEXT BAE JINYOUNG. LIKE THEY ARE NERVOUS ABD SCARED AT FIRST BUT IN THE END THEY GOT TO SHOW THE VIEWERS THEIR TALENTS
이렇게 보면 3대 기획사는 괜히 3대가 아니라는 생각이든다.. 노래잘하고 춤도 잘추고 이쁘고 그냥 이쁘기만 해서는 안되는듯
They are not born talented, but K-Pop is about hardwork. If you are hardworking, you can make it.
... and beauty.
KANG HYEWON, I BELIEVE IN YOU 😍😍😍
She Bebuted bro
and she pays you back through her debut 👍🏻
괜잖아요 민민!!!! 화이팅 화이팅!!
I told you guys! Minjoo can sing, rap and dance. She just needs to build her confidence. And look at her now, she is more confident and competitive! Minju let's debut! Knets, please vote for her.
people need to stop hating on hyewon . she's in iz*one already and doing fine so can people just accept it and move on ? hyewon will improve , i feel that she was probably not ready to debut honestly but she's improving , she will get better . and minju has improved greatly , look at 1000% . she did great . she's not "jUsT a vIsUaL , nO tAlEnT" .
Hyewon probably should’ve gotten a D at least. She did hit the E5 which is very high but she didn’t show much else so I would’ve given her D.
Minju deserved a C for sure. Her vocals weren’t very good, but her dancing was on point. She’s just bad at dropping down.
You play brawl stars
Hyewoon become a rapper in this showw and she emprove alot
이..이쁘기만 햇구나....
했이겠지
안진주 그걸 몰라서 저렇게 썼을까 ㅋ
제주도에선 수박을된장에 찍어먹는대 그럼 왜 제대로 안 써 ㅋ
luck un 저렇게 쓰는 사람 꽤 있어요 ㅎㅎ
제주도에선 수박을된장에 찍어먹는대 그게 잘못인 걸 모르나? ㅋㅋ
they started from "just a visual" to "visual and talented" and got to the final lineup ! thank u 😍
Minju looks like Tzuyu and Hyewon looks so pure with that eyes so beautiful!
ミンジュ本当に綺麗
大好き😭😭
아이즈원 볼때마다 혜원님 진짜 예쁘다고 생각했었음..
how can i take produce48 seriously if i'm thinking that Lee Seung-Gi is Son Oh-Gong and Lee Hong-Gi is P.K HAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAH LMAO!
SAME
OMG same lol
glad to hear i'm not the only one! HAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Exactly 😂
HAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAHAAHA
So nice evil edit mnet
Zuramaru 。 exactly i bet u they are gonna that thing with Sohye and other girls who dont donso well
how is this evil editing haha evil editing is a term you use when they twist the contestant's words with editing... this isnt evil editing it's literally just showing two girls who didnt do very well and didnt get good grades
Why do I have six subscribers Goes to prove that fans of Kpop will automatically assume good looking people are talentless . Didn’t you get that from this clip?
Why do I have six subscribers
Ikr! These kids hears an intriguing words or phrase n immediately applies it, often too religiously. 😂
Let alone clicking like of not knowing exactly what their liking? We seriously need to decrease human population in this world, because we have too many dumb ass people! 😀😁😂
For hyewon, it isnt really bad at all like. Compare to the other contestants that actually off tune. I know she's not really talented but there's always an asset that wins the heart of the viewer. Not just her face but her personality. ❤️
혜원언니는 프로듀서분들이 얼굴만 보고 고른듯 혜원언니 근데 진짜 왤케 이쁘지...? 진짜🐶부럽
UWE Kim Minjoo 😍😍😍 Chu's are supporting you.
Frits Sebelleno who's Chuu? The Loona one?
Marthalena P R Crisha Chu
Im here 😆✋
Harrah Reima aaa. KRIESHA CHU :"3
Ry-ry Espinosa who r u?