Details of Israeli Raid - Hostages Held in Civilian Homes - Rumored US Involvement
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 сен 2024
- For uncensored, ad-free videos and detailed analysis check out my Substack at:
prestonstewart...
We have more details on the Israeli raid into Gaza yesterday that successfully rescued four hostages being held by Hamas. There has also been a flurry of information that we try to parse through as some of the allegations are serious. The hostages talk about being held in the homes of Palestinian civilians and there are suggestions that one of them may have been a former employee of Al Jazeera. There have also been folks claiming the US was directly involved in the operation, but at this point I’ve not seen any evidence to suggest that’s the case.
Twitter: / prestonstew_
TikTok: / prestonstew
Instagram: / prestonstew_
Contact: preston@warstories.co
People seem to be debating whether international law forbids hostage rescues from dense urban areas if it results in high collateral damage. If it does, then international law has been poorly written and needs reworking. Anything else encourages any insane group to kidnap civilians and drag them into well defended urban areas for immunity. Any law that gives immunity to abhorrent illegal behavior is a bad law.
"... During the rescue, they were surrounded by hundreds of armed men, with rpg's, various weapons, etc...". This is what Al Jazeera will call civilians, and make loud complaint to the UN. When they hear a helicopter, civilians all run toward the noise with weapons of war in hand.
Al Jazeera = Taqiyya (deceit, lying to the kaffir-infidels on propose to make them meek & passive)
The IDF canceled one Al Jazeera reporter who won't be reporting anymore.
just think abou thieves on 1948,
Yeah just a bunch of innocent civilians who just happened to be holding self defense weapons and running towards the gunfire, totally not combatants
@@rockygayung Do you really believe that old lie?
You are no longer a civilian if you are holding hostages at home!
May be they are threatened by hamas, forcing them to stay with hostages.
@@shakole5979to bad for them, at the bottom line it doesnt matter, they dont want to change the governing authority ska hamas creatures.
And you failed to even watch 5 minutes of the video. It was hamas guards, as he clearly said. They are terrorists. They would gladly use civilian homes to hide in.
@@shakole5979come on now that would mean Hamas is putting civilians in danger the news says they're helping the civilians not putting them in danger
@@shakole5979hamas paid them. Not forced. The guy was a reporter and member of Hamas's political arm.
This channel is too underrated, almost all other coverage either ignores the hostages, the Civilians or only gives surface level details.
something you forgot to mention. Noa was taking into hostage at photographer journalist house working for Al Jazeera. So the guy was reporting during the day, coming back at home keeping an hostage at home. Can we maybe start to rethink the Palestinian narrative? The number of causalities ?
Those numbers are corroborated by the IS though. If both sides are saying its about right its about right to accept those numbers.
@@Khronogi IS? Islamic state?
@@KhronogiWhat's IS?
One of the aspects of your presentations that I enjoy the most is that their titles NEVER turn out to be clickbait. What We see, is what we get from you. Thank you for all these facts, Preston.
Seen so many other channels who just lie to the viewers entirely, like “THE RUSSIAN ARMY IS ON THE BRINK OF COLLAPSE” Dude, I don’t need propaganda
I've been watching numerous media reports on this heroic rescue, and I have to say, the media and international organizations are OUTRAGED that Israel successfully rescued their citizens.
Yeah. The MSM and the UN don't like Israel, to say the least.
Of course they are. What did you expect? They have no integrity whatsoever.
No, every one is angry that idf exterminated 274 civilians during this operation.
You’re right and it’s incomprehensible to me.
@@pollsfriend it’s no wonder why an increasing number of people distrust the media
And supposedly these "innocent Palestinians are separate from hamas!" meanwhile holding hostages in their homes. Meanwhile, attacking the deceased on trucks as they come into Gaza after October 7th. No.
If the police raid your home are you suddenly a cop? The logic in these comments is nonexistent. Hamas is their government, it's who has the control. Theres not much room to fight back as a civilian if they say you have to have hostages in your home.
@@simplsquam Are you for real? If a terrorist invades my home and brings hostages into my house, then I get away as far as possible because I know that some very angry people will be on my doorstep soon. The fact that the Pal were fine with Hamas using their homes for 8 months to hold hostages says a lot about them. And don't tell me there was nowhere to go. Where there is a will there is a way.
@@friedrichrubinstein There is no where to go. It does not matter how much 'will' you have. No where in Gaza is safe, and that is a fact.
@@ZER0-- Just because you say "that is a fact" doesn't make it true. The IDF dropped more than 7 million lealets telling people where to evacuate to, and those zones are a lot safer than the zones that the IDF publicly declared to operate inside. But even if you think that the humanitarian zones aren't safer than the rest, anywhere in Gaza is safer than inside a house with active Hamas terrorists, and a house with Hamas terrorists is still safer than a house with Hamas terrorists AND ISRAELI HOSTAGES. How dumb do you have to be to think you will survive if Israel finds out there are hostages in your house?
The mental gymnastics these plebs have to think of to make a shred of backwards logic.. @@Joezaccai
Are we really supposed to believe that all casualties are innocent civilians?
If you ask Al Jazeera or left wing politicians, yes
All gazans are guilty
There are none at all. They support this
@@BlazedreptileGross. I hope you understand that rationale defends the 7th.
Preston referenced the Black Hawk Down movie scene. Noted that whenever there is an Israeli strike or bomb on Gaza, civilians and children are seeing running to the scene and not away from it which is disturbing, kind of likes zombies on a frenzy.
Noa argamani (the hostage) was held in the apartment where the father (a doctor) of the journalist from Aljazeera lived.
Not surprising imo.
RUclips deleted this whenever I posted it
Makes sense, wouldn't surprise me if RUclips was complicit in all of this too
@@snikrepak wtf? Dude the logic to make these leaps is astonishing.
Screen shotting this before it's plausibly censored
Source ( the one who spread 40 babies lies)
Civilians in Gaza helped Hamas hide Israeli hostages...I'm so shocked!!
Whodda thunk it!
@@patricity9355 Everyone who read the statements of the hostages released in November?
Common sense.
Israel holds Palestinian hostages in civilian prisons
Does the strip have 3A protections?
Do people understand that “hostages were well treated” is an oxymoron!
Unlike the thousands of Palestinians who have been arrested and held in prison without charge? And have not been treated well! Is that an oxymoron?
B'Tselem Israeli human rights organisation who have documented this abuse.
what do you mean? something like.... I take your kids from you.. hide them.. but hey. we kept them alive... so.. we are good people? lets not talk about the woman who was raped and killed then put on parade while her dead body is in back up a pick up truck... while yelling god is great. You will always find blood on the shores of islam... gross religion. some are good some are bad. re·li·gion -- the belief in and worship of a superhuman power or powers, especially a God or gods. sounds like science fiction but it's real
@@AbdulEssa-kp4vf more like ironic to think any of the situations is desirable for the people affected by
Lol, seriously. Would you rather have it be different?
Um no, That's not what an oxymoron is dear.
Leave it to Palestinians to take hostages and then complain when they get killed in the rescue operation.
The word “refugee camp” means nothing anymore. There are buildings with foundations. That’s a city. Not a camp
What’s the significance of focusing on the building type?
That's because Palestinians have a special "refugee" status just for them, that don't apply to other nations.
@@bccbaron12 refugee camp Isn't stone building, that stands there for decades. I thought it's obvious.
@@alexjiharev9770 Where did you learn that? I’ve never heard anything about refugee camps being defined by their building material and only lasting for a short time.
@@bccbaron12 Im happy for you. If someone runs for his life, when he stops, he put his camp and sits. If someone lives 20 years, has house, infostructure, its NOT refuge camp. Its village or town. In your logic all Israel is refugee camp, cause it built by jews, who Are refugee from all Muslim countries and from holocaust of Europe.
When you call Nusyirat a "refugee camp" you should keep in mind that this "camp" has existed for over 70 years, the people who live there were born there - they're not displaced refugees from recent fighting zones. This "camp" is a fully built neighborhood. It's not a makeshift tent camp. Even though Gaza was autonomous for about 20 years now, they had kept calling themselves refugees because they seek to "return" to Israel (even though they'd never lived in Israel).
TBF if you are kicked out of your home and you tell your descendants about your home that they should be able to have if they ever get back to it. Is that no different than israel returning to the area after a thousand years away?
The Arabs in Gaza who call themselves "refugees" need to call the neighborhood as "camps" in order to keep getting $ from the corrupt UNWRA. As for the return rubbish, that will never happen. It's like the Arabs in Gaza calling themselves "pals". No such people ever existed. They were created by the PLO and KGB in 1964. Arabs need to go home now. Gaza is now Jew Country!
The Palestinians are refugees waiting to return to Europe.
@@KhronogiYes, because of the Holocaust, and because of all of the Jews being kicked out from all of Africa and the Middle East after Israel was founded. They had no choice but to go to Israel. They've been ethnically cleansed from every Muslim majority country.
This is why it's important for Israel to survive. It's not important for Gazans not to live 10 miles away in Egypt (or Jordan, Lebanon, Syria, etc etc).
The motive for the Gazans to make war is religious extremism and racism, not a desire for social justice. They don't give a f about democracy, human rights, etc.
@@KhronogiNo one forced the Jordanians, Egyptians, Lebanese, and Syrians living in 1948 Israel to leave. They could have lived side by side as many Israeli Arabs still do.
They left because they started a war against the Holocaust survivors and lost that war. A mistake they continue to make.
Anti Israel propaganda crisis: Do we say "the hostages were well fed" or go with "there is no food in Gaza" ?
Israel propaganda crisis: Palestinians fed Israeli hostages even as their own children starved.
🎉❤
Both logic is out of the window here
The more sinister possibilty, is that Noa is in the first weeks of pregnency, due to rape..
So your complaint is they treated Israeli captives as humans, unlike the treatment of Palestinian captives in Israeli prisons.
I personally had no doubt about the involvement of regular gazans in the kidnapping and holding of hostages.
Hamas terrorists themselves released many vides showing just this happening the very same day the initial attack happened and hostages where being brought back as Palestinian civilians celebrated in the streets.
Is it because the last 105 released said they were sent to live with regular families that received extra food from Hamas and never saw a guard, and they were scared to leave only because the IDF killed the last few that tried?
@@criticalevent so much for Hamas's lies about how there is no food for anyone to eat
They could also force them and lie about the reason
@@xp8969 No one has ever said there's "no food". Morons.
IDF statement confirms that Noa was held hostage at this journalist home: " Following the completion of IDF and ISA examinations of reports on the subject, it can be confirmed that Abdallah Aljamal was an operative in the Hamas terrorist organization, who held the hostages Almog Meir Jan, Andrey Kozlov, and Shlomi Ziv captive in his family home in Nuseirat.
The hostages were held captive by Abdallah Aljamal and members of his family in their home. This is further evidence of the deliberate use of civilian homes and buildings by the Hamas terrorist organization to hold Israeli hostages captive in the Gaza Strip.
Israeli security forces will continue to make every effort to bring the hostages home."
Instead of IDF statement it should read “trust me bro” because the IDF has lied so many times before and have been caught red handed, it needs to be taken with a grain of salt
@@changmarvin idf is 80% true
And acnoladge when they were wrong
Not same for the other side that is 20% true and never acnoladge the lied or were wrong
@@lordlorian81wtf is acnoladge?
IDF is so good at propaganda that even Biden said he saw the pictures of 40 beheaded babies. “IDF said so” = not a reliable source.
@@TheMule1he meant acknowledge.
Why does Preston keep calling them civilians? It seems Preston does not know what a civilian is. Here is a clue, if they are firing an ak47 at you, or hiding hostages, they are not civilians.
According to Hamas everyone civilians
Look at the images of children being slaughtered. Are they not civilians to you?
If they have ak's and rpg's = No@@Am4rkble
@@HingalshDealer I agree with you there. But what about children between 0-3 years? Do you think they can use weapons? Many have been slaughtered and if you tell me your Instagram I can show you the footage verified by Western outlets.
@@Am4rkble0-3 year olds are walking in the street? No
It's crazy that one of the hostages were held in one of an Al Jazeera employee house
Well if anyone was killed or injured, that's the risk of having hostages in your house
Or in your 'country'.
@@PesSkeptCyn Is it also valid for Israelis?
How about if you lived on the first floor without knowing that there is hostages on the 4th floor and your family gets killed because of it ?
How do you justify that.
Why the need to b.. almost 90 buildings?!
Gigi & Bella Hadid father said when Jews were oppressed in Europe and their ship was denied entrance to UK, USA they head to Palestine. Palestinians open their hearts & homes to those refugees! His father took 2 families into his home for 2 years. When Haddid pregnant mother was about to deliver him, she went to his grandparents house. When she returned home her guests took over her house and wouldn't let her in. Palestinians then became the refugees in their own country !!!
How do you feel about Al Jazeera your source now? One of their employees housed the hostage.
Hamas chooses its words carefully. A prisoner is not the same thing as a hostage. All 4 of these hostages were partygoers who were snatched from a music festival. In what sense are they prisoners? They are not prisoners of war because they were not soldiers engaged in a war, they were civilians having a party, nor are they criminals arrested for a crime who were tried and sentenced. No, they are hostages, people taken into captivity as bargaining chips by a terrorist organisation which can't win a war against a sophisticated well-armed adversary, without playing dirty and committing war crimes. Once again, Hamas lies to cover up its own crimes.
The organization is absolutely using it to try to justify a war crime. I don't know where those partygoers were at the time so it might be some crazy technical argument to say they were trespassing on Palestinian territory or some argument, but it is very clear they were hostages.
@@Khronogi The partygoers were not in Gaza, they were near the Gaza border on the Israeli side. Hamas had to breach the fence at the border and fly across on motorized hang-gliders to get to where the music festival was.
6:42 HamAss projecting again calling the IDF NotZ's occupiers.
Hamas was funded by Israeeeeel as opposition to PLO. Israeeeel was built on terrorism and land theft.
also the prisoners israel is releasing are just some detainees who believed to have connection to hamas or have made some death threats towards Israelis, they are just detained, and not in prison
My guess is that the IDF did the raid to minimize innocent civilian injury and maximize Hamas casualties. The innocent are awake and can move away from gunfire and the terrorists move towards it making them easy to differentiate.
iv heard a rumor IDF struck 90+ building with air strikes. How the fuck one is minimizing civilian casualtys when he strikes 90+ buildings with air strikes just to raid two buildings. They dotn give a shit about civilians
Exactly. Soldiers are trained to prioritize targets from no threat to high threat. People running away are no threat. People running toward you with guns are high threat.
Hamas has played this game so long, it's transparent. It's never "we lost 270 fighters." It's always some foggy 270 "people".
You mean the same way they assessed the risk of the three Israeli hostages they killed even though they were speaking Hebrew and said they were hostages? Yeah I’d be doubtful of anything the “most moral army if the world” says
@@changmarvin Were you there? You know your story to be true? How?
@@slartybarfastb3648 I'm not on his side, but I do believe that the IDF confirmed the unfortunate friendly fire killing of the hostages. What @changmarvin can't wrap his head around is the fog and confusion of war causes these things to happen. As stated elsewhere, the IDF is the most scrutinized military in the world. If they bomb an ammo depo that is too close to civilians and it causes casualties, it's their fault. Everything is their fault. Ironically when the do do wrong, they admit it and investigate it and take action to correct it.
During the raid 49 million pregnant children were killed :(
Dont forget about the israeli 3000 hostages killed by the idf in the attack as-well
@@angelamir9060Israel is retarded putting their soldiers at risk instead of just negotiating a hostage deal.
Including 3 billion journalists 😢
Funny
@@cipherw0lf imagine supporting the Zionist dogs
Just a note that I wonder how Hamas is able to count the bodies so fast, on October 7th it took Israel almost two weeks two count all the bodies, it seems that Hamas knows the numbers in 12 hours (let alone the fact that Hamas counts his militants as civilians)
Just like in Al Ahli, until it was clear it wasn't an Israeli strike and then the number dropped by 90%
12 hours?
More like 12 minutes
The answer is simple. They know how many soldiers they have in the area and how many are lost.
Accurate initial counts of Israelis lost on Oct. 7 were being reported within hours of the attacks. Maybe you’re thinking of how long it took to ID each person and account for those taken hostage? Let me know if this helps or if I’m misunderstanding your comment.
@@ozyehuda What are you suggesting with your comment? It seems like initial loss counts for virtually any event are reported on in real time, and get updated as new info is collected
Why in the world is the u.s. sending aid to gaza in the first place. Makes no sense to be helping both sides.
That Hamas statement about the hostage rescue had about 79 negative adjectives per sentence. When someone sounds that bitter it almost makes them harder to believe them.
That statement almost made it sound like the hostages were there willingly. :)
So many buzzwords, they know what buys the ignorant masses
I love that hummus statement. The frustration. ah the frustration.
This is being commented on quite a bit on Reddit, basically *there are no civilians in Gaza*
I wonder how many of the Palastinian civilians were killed by Hamas>
probably many, it benefits them more then Israel
just after their attack? or since theyve been in control in Gaza? Because im sure that number is much higher
in radical islam if you aint dying for blood thirsty war demon-god allah you are doing the creed badly, human life has no meaning except being a slave of demon-god allah.
40,000
What do you think the significance of that info could be?
Why would "civilians" be housing hostages?
The Gaza health ministry is Hamas, and nobody can know that quickly how many people were killed or injured.
The publish list of killed by
Name age and ID numbers
@@mohmedelsayd6071 sure. And those can't be fabricated?
Nobody, not even the most advanced countries on earth (and Hamas is nowhere near that level) can know that quickly how many people died in the attack.
This reminds me of the Islamic Jihad missile that fell in an empty parking lot of a hospital in Gaza.
Lies.
@@mohmedelsayd6071 and half of these IDs aren’t even in a valid format
@@R0DBS the occupation state had access to all Palestine data throw co operation with plo in west bank.. thats how some Palestinians can have access to airport and work inside the occupation state and some can't.
Did you ever see videos of aid trucks coming into Gaza? A mob of hundreds surrounds them. Disguising the rescue mission that way would be a terrible idea. It was just a truck with furniture .
Too cozy -- Israel and the US always have a "COZY" EXCUSE TO COMMIT GENOCIDE!"
Thats what called element of surprise
@@cuttingman007it's called "perfidy" which is a wae crime.
@@cuttingman007called using hunger as a weapon
@@WriteInAaronBushnellhow is that? Using hunger as a weapon would be denying them aid if they don't do something for them. Don't be so melodramatic
If civlians guard hostages....like it or not.....they're not ONLY civilians anymore....
They WERENT. Did you watch the video? He clearly said they were hamas guards
@@simplsquamsome people just hear what they want to hear to try to defend the indefensible, the video creator even said on more than one occasion that they were guarded by Hamas militants and not civilians.
Are you saying that the 4 hostages were guarded by over 1000 civilians, in different building blocks, in a market, in the streets?
Dropped my phone yesterday and broke it. found an.old Amazon fire so I could catch up on your new video. I appreciate and look forward to.the.content you put out. The way you present the information is as non bias as it can be and I and I'm sure many others are very appreciative of the hard work you out into these videos for us. Than you and keep up the great work!
The term civilian should be replaced with subject being that's much more factual.
Taliban alone stopped USA UK NATO and Australia
on October 7th, tens of thousands of "innocent civilians" came in waves after Hamas carried out the incursion.
There is footage from the security cameras in towns hit, showing civilians coming by car and foot to take part after Hamas took over the towns.
Those "innocent civilians" were involved in kidnapping, r*ping, burning, looting, and had a bloody hand with Hamas in what happened.
They are the ones who kidnapped Noa, you can even see that when they took her in her kidnapping video they were civilians and mostly unarmed on bikes.
No innocent civilians, there are only Hamas and Hamas sympathizers who hide hostages in their homes.
Everybody in gaza knew who was held there! they are not innocent.
Multiple leaps of logic though. 1. Having support for a force does not make one support their every action. 2. Just because a group of people support something does not make everyone support that something.
Don't forget Taliban alone stopped USA UK NATO and Australia.
@@Khronogiyou missed an even more important point: were the people whose homes Hamas wanted to commandeer to use as a hostage helping spot opposed to that, what are were they supposed to do? They are faced with armed zealots who are not opposed to shooting any Palestinian civilian and then just counting him with the rest as martyred in their fight against Israel.
Any time a rescue of kidnap victims is carried out, there is danger to them. Israel knows this very well. And as well, they were criticized after the 1970s Entebbe rescue. I'd take the risk if I'd been stolen by terrorists, not that any have this choice.
Any idea of the name of the IDF soldier killed on that raid?
The obvious choice: negotiation! It seems israel does not know that word, it prefers barbarity.
@@martincohen155 Arnon Zamora plus some hostages.
Terrorists don't deserve negotiation@@galeriadesol948
@@galeriadesol948 You could not be more wrong. Israel left Gaza in 2005, left Lebanon in early 1980s. Has not gone to war despite constant missiles from both locations, all funded by Iran. You out of your mind? Heard perhaps, of the Oslo Accords, the Abraham Accords? Do your homework, babe.
the Hamass propaganda machine is certainly in fine shape. The reality is that Hamass is fully responsible for all the death there since they are the ones that kicked this off and are still holding hostages.
Those "hostages" should not have been in the occupied territories if they don't want to be in any harm way and as long they decide to be there they will always be a target
You’re actually an idiot for even claiming that it’s the civilians fault they are being targeted. There are rules to warfare for a reason, this is illegal and morally reprehensible thing that israel is doing. But comes as no surprise from a racist zionist settler state that practices apartheid.
@@aymenyahyaoui1771 Stop smoking crack, it's effecting your ability to think clearly. Israel is NOT occupied territory. It is a sovereign nation. Thus the crimes committed on 10/7 and the subsequent war that resulted from the brutal massacre and illegal taking of hostages are solely the fault of Hamas.
@@aymenyahyaoui1771 funny how the Israeli’s can find artifacts in their own language that are thousands of years old, and are shown as living there by other cultures as far back as the Bronze Age, but it somehow belongs to interlopers that arrived after the Romans.
@@aymenyahyaoui1771 No, that is a justification of a war crime.
There are no civilians in Gaza.
"oh but the Palestinians arent Hamas" HMS reminds me of a government: voted by its people, tries to eradicate Jewish people (see their constitution), fails miserably, and now they are losing Gaza fighting a futile war.
Friendly reminder that adolf hitler was elected into power too. Assuming all Palestinians are a part of hamas is wildly ignorant and an easy excuse for war crimes
@@simplsquam And the Germans lost 2 Million civilians when Adolf and his crowd were eradicated. Using Adolf as a comparison means that there is nothing wrong with the civilian casualties in Gaza.
what an excuse to justify killing of innocent people, so americans people are ligitimates target because they voted for their presidents (who killed millions of innocent people accros the world).
The only option during the elections where a corrupt government that failed in all their promises and Hamas, hamas only got 40% of the votes. So half of the population didn't vote and of the other half only 40% did. Back then hamas also got support from Israel until they realised they won't bow down to them like the other Palestinian authority did
@@RickTheDestroyer2 That is simply untrue. Israel tried very hard in 2006 to prevent Hamas from winning elections. In the lead-up to the elections, on 26 September 2005 Israel launched a campaign of arrests against PLC members. 450 members of Hamas were detained, mostly those involved in the 2006 PLC elections. During the elections, the Israeli authorities banned Hamas from holding election campaigns inside Jerusalem. Rallies and public meetings were prohibited. Palestinian candidates were allowed to campaign in East Jerusalem as long as they registered with Israeli police, but, a police spokesman noted, "Anyone who is a supporter of Hamas will not receive permission." The Israeli police arrested campaigners of Hamas and closed at least three Hamas election offices in East Jerusalem during the campaign. When it became evident that Hamas was set to win the elections anyway, Israel raised the issue with the United States. However, President George W. Bush made clear that the elections should go forward as scheduled.
Not may have been is an Al Jazeera reporter, and his father is a doctor and they all Hamas members
Your mum is a hamas member
Source( the one who spread 40 babies lie)
@@nisahmed9121 It's on Al Jazeera's website, why are you lying?
@@noamto Check your information because Aljazeera denied what you’re saying!
@@nisahmed9121 They can deny all they want, it's literally on their website. Do you need a link?
I think the best part about your channel is how you admit you are unsure, or there isnt enough evidence rather than picking a side. Holding evidence to this standard is what we all need to do to sift through an information war this dense, especially online. thank you for being able to admit this, many arent.
No clickbait no partisanship no BS… just facts. Thank you for giving us a superior perspective compared to any single mainstream media outlet
Innocent civilians that were keeping Israeli hostages at their homes!!! WTH?!!!!!! 😡
Thank you for the commentary.
That “journalist” held hostages in his family home
Great video as always, Preston! Unbiased and fact based, which can be hard to find regarding this conflict. 👏 👏 👏
Secondly thanks for doing such a great job on fact-checking and properly presenting things in a volatile period
Ok so reading between the lines the Palestinian population is complicit, now what? Hamas can’t be eliminated because it’s an ideology supported by the population. Where does this end? Where can we go from here even if all hostages are returned?
Likely the IDF has to finally do the policing they never did. Pretty much indeterminate occupation of Palestine why because Palestine will re-start building the terrorist Jihad army again over & over. Islam is like this, its in their dogma to be like a relentless death cult this is exactly what Mohammed wanted out of them sadly, he was also this awful if not worse.
Thank you Preston, and congrats on 700k subs you deserve a lot more.
Thanks a lot man!
Of course, Al Jazeera was particularly silent about the operation....
HL....i am a subscriber from India...i have always loved your videos.
Yesterday, a group of innocent pilgrims returning from a famous hindu shrine in north India, were brutally massacred by islamic terrorists, using american M-4s.
They shot at a bus carrying these pilgrims, killed the driver in the first spray of gunfire.
Even after the bus fell into a ravine, they continued to spray the vehicle indiscriminately with automatic fire.
A 2 year old child is a victim of this madness.
If you are a true american patriot....🙏🏻🙏🏻
Please raise this issue. And the issue of the US leaving arms around the globe after conflict ends.
Our government is telling us that it was done by foreign origin terrorists, but the weapons are right there in afghanistan.
You talking about this would mean a LOT to some of us.
I can't help but wonder are some "civies" in Gaza giving IDF any solid intel?
Yes, the Shabak unit is responsible for getting this type on intel
Definitely, it is not e every Palestinian that love hamas. Some do what they out of compulsion. I saw a video where a brother and his group killed his brother accusing him as an informant.
Correction to Preston: Where you say that it wouldn't be smart to use humanitarian vehicles alongside tanks if you want to sneak into enemy territory; Keep in mind that this video was taken after the truck was used in the mission. In other words, the tanks were there after the rescue event to provide cover for the truck. Hope that clears things up a bit.
200 civilians with guns were killed
I’m in total awe of the Israeli army.
ah so you like terrorists
Dude you make the most thorough and honest content. Bravo
Preston, you are a breath of fresh air in the insanity.
no words about the person holding Noa was a reporter?
Which ties right back to the fact that reporters were part of the invading force on October 7th.
Correction, seems he was holding the 3 men in his home, not Noa.
I made a joke yesterday on a different video saying the next news articles after we heard of the rescue would be that people were protesting Israel stealing Hamas' hostages as part of their genocide.
I was hoping I was being a bit hyperbole about the response. Turns out I was pretty on the money which is honestly very depressing.
BBC: "4 Israelies stayed in Gaza for 8 months & didnt pay rent." Hamas: we'll sue them
Which side has the greater right to life? A hostage or their captors and facilitators? Would the US really leave hostages in place if the potential existed for collateral casualties? Really.
"Palestinian" - this is KGB invention 1967.
Before they was "Arabic refugees from Egypt or Jordan"
Mostly they referred to themselves as southern syrians. but yes "palestinians" is a recent invention.
1964 invention
Israel 1948 invention
@@lt6731you’re off by a few thousand years bro
At least they didn't come from new York , UK and other places , at least they don't bring mercenaries to fight with them at least they don't bring Western weapons. At least they don't need mama America's milk
I'm not sure if this is proper to say, but maybe since Palestinians like to boycott anything Israeli, we should boycott Peoples Media Project.
Or maybe something more serious, like legal action.
"They're going to attack what they see as a military facility"
Why would you assume that? They tend to prefer attacking non-military targets.
Like hospitals and schools and kids.
Trying to stay balanced and trying to present perspectives from both sides on the information front of a war is incredibly challenging.Skepticism on the internet is generally lacking, but verifiable evidence equals credibility ( plus sources and their history)Thanks,Preston, for trying to thread the needle and building trust in your work.👍🤙
Can't wait for your factual and non biased updates, great job!
This video came up in the suggestions and I'm glad it did. Liked and subscribed.
Appreciate that, glad you’re here!
Really, if I were a hostage, I'd rather have Israelis try to rescue me than anyone else including the US.
"Trust me and i dont really belive in reporting that" well said sir there is to much of that going around
Why only Israel is giving explanations on its war strategies and results....Russia, Ukraine arent being questioned at all .... Israel will do whats necessary to protect her country 💪🇮🇱🙌✡️✌️😊💞
The rescue details are so goddamn bad ass, I expect major films to be made about it
Why are you quoting Gaza “health ministry”?
This time it seems a bit strange that they didn't report numbers of children and women killed. Hamas always presents this number first.
Most logical people run away from gunfight in a warzone...
So my intuition tells me that most of those killed were fighting age men trying to stop the Israelis.
What is going on in this video? How many times did you repeat that there is no evidence about obviously BS claims made on social media? I've rarely heard you mention a lack of evidence about claims made by Hamas, which are often even more outrageous. Instead, you've started including their quotes verbatim in every video, generally without push-back.
It's not an accusation. I just genuinely don't understand what the thinking behind it is.
Actually, I understand about the claims about Americans being involved, because that is like an attack more directly against you, so you feel a little bit defensive about it.
Why do u read their statements?
Seriously, don't spread their nonsense.
I agree and disagree, we need to hear other information outside of our own echo chambers. Preston’s audience isn’t influenced by their BS so I’d rather it be read here than mainstream media.
Due diligence and an intellectual capacity that allows him to critically think, thus enabling him to parse information without being persuaded by a facile arguement. How are you going to aggregate data without consuming all of it? Additionally, if you're only viewing one side... how are you getting the whole picture?
I'm not trying to be a dick, but what was the point of your post? Don't you want to know what your perceived opposition is thinking?
Why bother reading any statements at that point? Would you rather be told what to think about an organization via the opposing side of an ongoing war?
What other alternative do you suggest than straight from the horses mouth. It’s truly not problematic at all and should be done more so by other journalists.
@@alphaq1548 This channel is more based then what you get brainwashed from YT shorts.
Israel have the right to rescue their peoples, and if Palestinians willing to sacrifice themselves they are not civilians they are Hamas if they are dead I don’t blame Israel not at all
What I don't understand is why Hamas would risk placing hostages in areas like refugee centers. Don't they know this might increase the risk of civilian casualties?
Hahaha.
You probably think Humus fights for Palestinians.
They're Qatari proxy group
They don't care. They know the world values civilians and don't want them killed. But for them it makes no difference the sacrifice is for a higher cause. These people are evil
Go watch Hamas interview with BBC(I think) the interviewer ask him why Hamas builds tunnels under civilian houses etc he said so IDF won't bomb them.
You get the point they don't care about civilians heck the more they lose civilians they better is for them in the international news.
Yes they know that is an increased risk, and they do it because when those civilians end up as casualties they can use that for propaganda purposes.
Hamas wants civilian casualties. They don’t care about death, and they are highly skilled at manipulating world opinion due to casualties even though they are responsible for those casualties.
in a civilian home? wouldn't surprise me one little bit. There's usually no difference between Hamas and the so called civilian.
News saying 3 hostages killed as well as 4 hostages rescued?
There was a second clip of the box truck being escorted by APCs and tanks. There was also a video of a different van with ladders going up to the second floor of one of the buildings.
awesome content preston!
Thanks a lot!
This rescue is one hell of a story, with so many moving parts, and I'd bet that eventually it's going to inspire a Hollywood movie.
Imagine if the Police in New York was called to rescue hostages in a bank and decides that the whole neighborhood is complicit! IDF training!!!
Well you just know some Navy SEAL needs to write a book about this and make a film….
But it’s the civilians that let their homes be used by Hamas! There are very few innocent civilians in Gaza
How many innocent civilians would you say there are?
A very good and clear report , THX!
I admire Preston for how he manages to keep a straight face as he reads out Hamas's (rambling) talking points, etc.😁
Whats that tells you about the so called Palestine civilians?
What civilians?
The same thing it says that they readily accept the governance of humus and actively support humus.
Won't somebody think of the entirely innocent future jihadis ? Oh the humanity !!!
The number of bleeding heart, scat for brains first world denizens that have been captured by social cyber warfare and now support this murderous culture is highly concerning.
That there's only civilians left in Gaza?
😂☠️😂☠️😂@@criticalevent "civillians" 😂☠️😂
The same thing it says that they readily accept the governance of humus and actively support humus.
Won't somebody think of the entirely innocent future jihadis ? Oh the humanity !!!
The number of bleeding heart, scat for brains first world denizens that have been captured by social cyber warfare and now support this murderous culture is highly concerning.
Wait, are we seriously being lectured to by HAMAS on "complex war crimes'? Is this what they are taught in the UNWRA/HAMAS schools?
Thanks for the coverage ❤
Soldiers are in tunnels, and after this operation, unfortunately all were moved to underground.
Preston I respect that you want to remain neutral. With that said, why does it matter if the pier is being used to bring in humanitary aid and also save hostages? If they are going to attack the pier, they are only herding the people they were elected to protect. Feel free to discuss how any enemy combat that fires upon troops makes everybody around them valid targets. Everybody knows they were going to turn against the United States eventually I don’t know why you just can’t call terrorist a terrorist. While I appreciate that you are fairly new at this, when in the history of warfare has decided who was attacked required to defend their actions when trying to save their citizens who are admittedly being held, tortured, and killed daily?
Be more like Spencer call it as it is without fear of having the hamasniks turn on you.
I personally would like to say sorry for the loss of innocent civilians who were used by Hamas as human shields m, but I don’t think that the Israeli army has done anything wrong since the Palestinian civilians knew about the hostages being held in their residence yet they were quiet instead!
Remember that the Israeli army kept saying that they would not fight if their hostages were left to their families, but the Hamas didn’t mind thinking they had the last day in the conflict.
You can’t fight the blacksmith who could use any of his work tools to hurl at you. Iranian government is misleading your citizens in Gaza and Rafah, so don’t take orders from the Iranian government if you’re not their citizens.
You don’t harass the leopard in a cave when you find it there or the consequences are worse than you ever thought of!
Of course AJ was involved
Thank you Preston for giving us something to think about and the apparent options for both sides during this operation. Your interpretation and analysis is extremely valuable to me. Thank you.
Just the facts Maam
Arnon 💔
If you want more hostages to be rescued you should not share this info ...
How are they civilians if they're holding hostages. If Preston was a prisoner in Irag would his captors be civilians. They aren't Npcs in Fallout they were terrorists. Women can be terrorists and even children.