A Ratio of Two Radicals | Problem 480

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 янв 2025

Комментарии •

  • @MichaelRothwell1
    @MichaelRothwell1 8 дней назад

    In the 2nd method, you need to be careful when applying the rule √(z/w)=√z/√w, because it doesn't always hold in the world of complex numbers, assuming (as you do) that √z represents the principal square root.
    For example, taking z=1 and w=-1, we get √(z/w)=√(1/-1)=√(-1)=i
    but √z/√w=√1/√(-1)=1/i=-i,
    so in fact √(1/-1)=-√1/√(-1)
    To see what's going on here, it helps to use polar form.
    We have z=1=cis 0, w=-1=cis π (using the principal arguments).
    So z/w=1/-1=cis 0/cis π=cis(-π).
    Taking principal square roots,
    √z=cis(0/2)=cis 0, √w=cis(π/2),
    so √z/√w=cis(0-π/2)=cis(-π/2)
    On the other hand,
    √(z/w)=√cis(-π)=cis(-π/2)
    and all seems to be fine.
    But wait! cis(-π) is not written using its principal argument (-π is just outside the allowed range -π

  • @scottleung9587
    @scottleung9587 11 дней назад

    My method was setting the expression equal to a+bi and squaring both sides to get rid of the radical. Then I took the complex conjugate, and from there I got the two square roots of 2i, which are 1+i and -1-i.

    • @aplusbi
      @aplusbi  10 дней назад +1

      You are good! 😍

  • @prakrit1280
    @prakrit1280 11 дней назад +1

    Sir, little bit actually,
    sqrt(3 + 4i)
    = sqrt(4 - 1 + 4i)
    = sqrt(2² + i² + 2×2×i)
    = (2 + i)
    and not (1 + 2i) 🥹
    sqrt(-8 + 6i) / sqrt(3 + 4i)
    = (1 + 3i) / (2 + i)
    = (1 + 3i)(2 - i) / (2 + i)(2 - i)
    = (2 - i + 6i + 3) / 5
    = (5 + 5i) / 5
    = (1 + i)😊

  • @kevinmadden1645
    @kevinmadden1645 11 дней назад +1

    Continue! Sqrt(2i) equals 1+I and -1-i.

    • @mcwulf25
      @mcwulf25 11 дней назад

      That square root sign is single valued, which is why he said "principle value".
      Frankly, that sign should be banned as it causes lots of confusion when dealing with higher power roots.

    • @kevinmadden1645
      @kevinmadden1645 11 дней назад

      @mcwulf25 Why is 1+I the principal( not principle) square root of 2i? Both 1+I and -1-i equal 2i when squared.

    • @mcwulf25
      @mcwulf25 11 дней назад

      @kevinmadden1645 You can only have one! If it was a real number, say 4, both 2 and -2 squared are solutions. But by convention, 2 is the principal root. Which is why we put "+/-" before the square root sign if we mean both. I don't know who decided that the solution with the positive real value is the principal root but Syber said that was the convention he was following.

  • @andyiswonderful
    @andyiswonderful 11 дней назад

    I got 2i.

  • @black_eagle
    @black_eagle 11 дней назад +1

    Your method seems too complicated.
    Write expression as x = sqrt(2(3i-4)/(3+4i))
    Notice that 3 + 4i = 1/i * (3i - 4).
    So x = sqrt(2/(1/i) = sqrt(2i) = sqrt(2) * sqrt(i)
    Simplify sqrt(i) using i = e^i(pi/2 + 2n*pi) => i^1/2 = e^i(pi/4 + n*pi) = e^i*pi/4 * e^i*n*pi = sqrt(2)/2 * (1+ i) * (-1)^n
    So x = (1+ i) * (-1)^n = 1+i or -1-i.

  • @mcwulf25
    @mcwulf25 11 дней назад

    Not seen the video yet but I notice the modulus of the numerator is 10 and the denominator is 5.

    • @mcwulf25
      @mcwulf25 11 дней назад

      When I continue: Take out sqrt(2) and the fraction becomes (-4+3i)/(3+4i)
      Now multiply top and btm by -i to get
      Sqrt (-2/i) sqrt,(3+4i)/sqrt(3+4i)
      = sqrt(2i)
      = (1+i)
      Similar to method 2.

  • @DJ.Nihad6174
    @DJ.Nihad6174 11 дней назад +2

    2i or not 2i😂😂😂

    • @aplusbi
      @aplusbi  10 дней назад

      I got u! 😁

  • @ruud9767
    @ruud9767 11 дней назад

    rewrite as √( (numer) / (denom) )
    numer = -8+6i
    denom = 3+4i
    note that numer = 2i * denom (or do the division)
    almost donre. The answer = √(2i)

  • @key_board_x
    @key_board_x 11 дней назад

    = (- 8 + 6i)/(3 + 4i)
    = 2.(- 4 + 3i).(3 - 4i)/[(3 + 4i).(3 - 4i)]
    = 2.(- 12 + 16i + 9i - 12i²)/[9 - 16i²] → where: i² = - 1
    = 2.(- 12 + 25i + 12)/[9 + 16]
    = 2.(25i)/[25]
    = 2i
    = [√(- 8 + 6i)] / [√(3 + 4i)]
    = √[(- 8 + 6i) / (3 + 4i)]
    = √(2i)