I didn't even notice that Xiaoting's mic fell off, until someone in twitter revealed it. Dude she handled it well, very nice. I miss c-group btw, they became much closer to each other than they already were because of the mistreatment that they experienced in that show, no one's there for them other than themselves. C-group deserves better, I love them.
The girl with long black hair that sang most of the parts seems like she was given notes that were too high, a low register would maybe fit better, but she sang on pitch especially at the end. I admire that she kept going and did her best with what she had. The girl with ginger hair is the strongest in my opinion. The rap was really good, especially in another language than her native one. I'd like to see her continue further.
The girl who did most of the singing and highnotes is really good actually! Her tone is amazing. It’s unfortunate she cracked but she was carrying the song’s vocal parts the most and cracking happens sometimes but that doesn’t mean she sounds bad because I think she seems like she’s going to be known for her main vocal capabilities imo. And ofc the girl with red hair was amazing and her facial expressions are great!!
@@sunnymira Hai mira... tommy Hwang here... meet you here too... Yeah she my #1 pick.... HuangXingQiao.... iam be her fans since 2years ago... i love her japanese single.... Iam be deep husky voice FANS which unique vocal type in kpop industry... for example StayC J
Shen Xiaoting reminds me of Kim Sejeong. She is a talented all around trainee who was also kind enough to team up with a whole bunch of unpopular trainees. Please support this kind Queen!
they're not unpopular, basically you can't say much abt their popularity bc it's only the first ep, they're just lower ranking trainee in terms of skill (ranked from their first signal performance and i guess other performance too before this)
@@paiget8570 yep because if xiaoting will choose a team she will definitely choose the powerful one so that she can have more attention than she had now
Shows like this just remind me that not everyone can be a star - there are so many people that can dance and sing well but personality/star quality is equally important!!!
which is why i love how sunmi said she is going to look for aura and presence. people seriously underestimate how important presence is on stage if you want to be a top idol
@@anee7558 i agree. Also Sunmi might not be the best dancer or singing. But she has the aura and star quality. Which is why she is the most successful WG soloist right now
At first I doubted Yeseo's choice to take Xingqiao in her cell but in this performance, she did well despite her mistakes (missed dance move and voice crack). She has this aura on her. And watching her Fiesta performance really showed me how she improved a lot in a short span of time. I hope she'll get better and better.
the girl in beige, yo if she improves her vocal in this survival show, she’d be a legit main vocal material. i can see her vocals be stable in the future
I dont know. She started so bad. She was out of tune most of the times, shaky vocals, the song is clearly out of her comfortable range. Though yes her vocal color is really good.
Appreciate this comment, some stray love to spread virus comment to each trainee like they were in prison or bullied other, this is a survival show that trainee comes to learn to become an idol, some had talent, some didn’t, mostly those hate comment are on foreign trainees…fk shet I hate it when they knew nth and feeling like a coach or judge to those.
She gave most of the lines to her other members, so that they can shine and show more of their potential. If I was the center of (C,K or J Group) I would choose to have the most lines but that's not the case of Xiaoting, she's also so humble, kind and I can see how she genuinely care to her members. She was singing so stable , gave that rap and gave that clean and elegant dance but she wasn't even trying hard 👐👐👐😭😭😭 Vote for Shen Xiaoting!!!
@@whitefox7369 Pls watch this link : ruclips.net/video/nceJvcJp3XY/видео.html It is not Xiaoting fault that she is so talented lol, she's not good with high parts, but she is stable with low parts, good in rapping, a very great dancer and she has that center "aura",she helped her other members do their parts it is not her fault if they did not slayed
@@whitefox7369 Are you new to kpop? In a group it consists of roles, Shen Xiaoting role was a leader and main dancer so yeah😒 it's just hard talking to people who haven't done their research lol
@@ivanahmaeaclo5330 I frankly wished she gave less parts to vivi Chen . The ponytail girl one. She's so pretty even in youth with you but her singing is a little shaky even there . 😢 And it really shows here
Right, I guess Xiaoting is the only who can rap in her group that's why she got the less lines anyways looking forward on her improvements she already has the talent.
I can see Xiaoting as the leader the way she took care of here teammates. She deserves to debut. She slayed this performance, I hope the three centers stay as a cell so they can debut together.
The main vocal has potential with enough practice, I hope she continues to grow and practice her abilities she will be a good vocalist if she does. I can also see that she lacks some stamina and other members too except for the rapper. I'll be cheering on them and hope that they became more talented
they still did a decent job despite the language barrier and the fact that they're singing while dancing,,, there's a lot to improve and that's what's the show is all about,,,, jiayou
The one with orange hair can really perform.I think the other girls should've practice more,specially singing in stable. But who knows, maybe these girls suddenly improve.And the thing I really like to compliment is they sang live.
The division of parts is distributed poorly or it's just her who can sing high notes. Being an idol, singing while dancing is a must. They will need more practice and I hope they grow. Cheer up !!!
They didn't do that bad though. Rumor is a hard song to sing live because of how many body-rolls it has in it's choreo, but all the girls managed to sing all the lines even if they were unstable often (except for queen Xiaoting✨). Their stage presence is also good, I'm actually impressed ngl. Most idols can't even sing live anyways, so I'd say these girls are reasonably talented enough to make it
@@mariunfabregas7533 and also the girls who sing eunbi part its has good job for the highnote and i love her voice sm, i think her highnote it's quite crack just because she has many line and its actually high :(
Now knowing that Mnet chose the song and parts for them, I don’t think Huang Xingqiao did that bad considering her lack of dance experience. With more training to become more stable while dancing she has so much potential.
it's sad how ruowei didn't have many lines because she seems very talented and could've really shown her talents on that stage !! and she's so underrated, my girl deserves more recognition !
Only just noticed around 1:47 xiaoting's mic falls off, but she effortlessly manoeuvres it out of the way. I wonder if they didn't make such a big deal out of it because no one noticed from how effortlessly she handled it :o
@@chi5065 That will happening to every deep husky singer when someone forced them must singing in highpitch ... out of their vocal range... This song not give Justice for HuangXingQiao Beautiful deep husky voice....
@@tommyhwang936 tbh I also think so, I think if she raps it'll sound cool for her voice since you know it's husky. Plus the Opening part, she could nail those
I am starting to like Huang Xing Qiao (girl with the long black hair) because when she messed up she still had her head up the whole time! Even if shes not the best, Hwaiting! Jiayou!
the way they edited it really made it seem like xingqiao had weak vocals but she's actually an amazing singer, it was just doing it while dancing that affected it. towards the end she killed it especially at 1:02 and the chorus line after + she has so many other vids online!
Xiaoting and Xingqiao are really good. Xiaoting in rapping and Xingqiao in singing. Both are tall and pretty and charismatic. When you see them perform you can't help smiling. They have only 9 days apart in their birthdays. Please vote for Xiaoting and Xingqiao as well as Yurina. Debut the 99l tall trio.
xioating's Korean pronunciation sounds almost fluent. she's stable too. rooting for her. and i hope they'll give xing qiao a chance. she has the voice, just needs a suitable range and not high pitched. i hope we'll get to see her vocals development in this show. looking forward for her performance
@@tommyhwang936 Ziyin already had thousands of fans behind him. Ruowei didn't get screentime, only her performance were shown which they only talked about Shen Xiaoting and Chen Hsinwei.
You can't blame them, the original team chosen for this song was so perfect that people wanted them to debut together. Even izone could not out shadow the original
honestly the main vocalist in this group did a great job considering a) there are many high notes in this song and they're all difficult and b) her voice is quite deep, so the notes could've been a bit out of her range. xiaoting also did a great job as the rapper.
"Deep voiced singers shouldn't be main vocalists," Huang Xing Qiao: "screw that, I'll be whatever I want!" Her voice is quite stable actually, but some may think it's weird bc we don't know many deep voiced main vocalists. As a mezzo soprano myself I can understand what it's like. We need more mezzo sopranos as main vocalists actually, not only rappers or 'no line club'.
ruclips.net/video/Lypml4kmGX4/видео.html ruclips.net/video/RpwY7EUxX_4/видео.html For you guys want listern her beautiful husky voice.... 1 of that video her live singing.... another one her japanese song which she produce that song by herself
Xingqiao the dark horse. don't forget to vote for her. She's so idol material same as Xiaoting. Both have great personality, and can do any concept. Both of them are knetz fav. for a reason. International fans should choose wisely. KPOP isn't just swag/badass music. Idols have to be ace of all trades. Attractive Visual☑️ Attitude☑️ Stage Presence☑️ Variety show skills☑️ Versatile(any concept)☑️
@@kaeya9148 so bad you say? Yes I caught some moments she danced ahead of the beat but Xingqiao is still a dark horse, put her with Xiaoting in a group and you'll get a main dancer and lead vocalist with overflowing visuals, there's nothing wrong with her attitude I mean, we cannot see anyone's true colors through just pixels but its just contagious the way she laughs in a serious moment, and c'mon give her a break I'm sure almost half of the entire population does that
You should remember that original Rumor from PD48 has 3 vocalists singing ,but this time only huang xing qiao plays the main vocal and she never sings with dance in front of the stage. I think she is one of the most potential members in C group.
Surprisingly, the main rapper of this group seems to be the most stable one, along with the best vocal technique among them as well, and seems to be a decent dancer too. There is a big gap in terms of skills within this team.
she's main position is dance but yes she can raps that good and you can also see other video of her vocals was totally amazing, support shen xiaoting she's an all rounder 😼
@@wiz_lime i agree. rumor is a good choice for xiaoting and an okay choice for that other rapper, but it's a really bad choice for their two vocalists, both because of the song and the choreography. they should've just picked something safer
@@iwatchyoutube3511 well i haven't watched the episode yet, when i posted this comment, this is only the first time I've seen her. it's also a very short video and mose of the time they're showing another member or the judges' faces so i didn't get a good look at her dance
the way i hated this performance at first (tho i loved xiaoting's parts) lol... now i love it... i mean i love xiaoting and xingqiao slayed here.. definitely c-group picks
@@MsFated dude, it's a personal preference. i already said i hated it but i'm now accepting it as if she's slayed her coz i started to appreciate her efforts of singing while dancing for someone who has never done it before. again, it's not the same slayage as well as other people but it's a slayage xingqiao level...
@@MsFated i think you've misunderstood me lol. i already said i hated it at first. second, i only said she slayed it on 'xingqiao level' coz she's on a league of her own (i consider her background on singing while dancing since she didnt specifically trained for it). lastly, why are you so bothered with me saying she slayed?? coz like our opinions on these performances can be subjective you know lmao 😂 i'm aware how bad the performance was, as what i've said "i hated it at first"
despite the mistakes, it wasn’t horrible. i think they did good. i honestly really like the girl with the cream colored shirts singing. there were mistakes but i enjoyed it. she does have a nice voice. with a little bit more vocal training, she would definitely do a lot better. the other girls also did pretty well! orange haired girl really caught my eye, her rap was amazing. the other two also did well. the girl with the ponytail could use a bit more training but she does have potential! the other girl with the long black hair also caught my eye with her vocals. it wasn’t bad tbh, i liked it! i’m rooting for these girls!! (i don’t know any of their names so i tried to describe them best as i could)
@@MsFated 1:51 u will notice her mouth close faster than voice....it mean no live vocal.... She lorina/HuangXingQiao can sing live very good.... So i think it just Mnet Plan to manipulated audience to think XingQiao cant sing
The girl on beige is actually my fave in this grup like gurl if her vocals are warmed up and she practices for a stable voice she would be a force to be wrekend with
i barely noticed her in Chuang because she was eliminated so early and there was barely any clips of her but in 999 she's like a star, i couldn't even take my eyes off her
The girl in the gold top actually did quite well with all those high notes. With the proper vocal training she could become really stable as her vocal tone is already really nice
0:25 was not even a choreo mistake but they made it look like a mistake. it's like a cheat way to ensure xingqiao's voice won't go shaky after the chest pumps, overall she did good and this might sound controversial but her high note sounded better than eunbi's (except the baby)
Oohh now i think about it, good observation tho. I've been contemplating alot & recheck this video now & then, you and i have the same braincell on Xingqiao on 0.25. Xingqiao's high note definitely sold me to her on this entire season.
I give these girls props. As a person who loves rumor a lot, I understand that this song is difficult and the high notes are HIGH. My girl Kwon Eunbi and the pd48 girls really set a standard for this song. I applaud these girls for doing their best, and I hope they continue to improve. They have loads of potential!
@@Ryan-kx1wz 노래는 발음문제가 아니라 그냥 발성문제인데요? 언어랑 상관없음. 춤은 제 생각엔 별로? 못하진 않지만 그렇게 잘하지도 않은것같고... 물론 저도 프로 아니라서 전문 평가 못하지만요.. 근데 이번 회에는 중국보다 일본 참가자들이 더 잘하고 눈에 띈거같네요
![[1회] '각 그룹 1위의 자존심' K/C/J 1위 유닛 무대 모음집 @플래닛 탐색전Girls Planet 999 [ENG]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/osv2RGQ0Stg/mqdefault.jpg)
![[1회] '각 그룹 1위의 자존심' K/C/J 1위 유닛 무대 모음집 @플래닛 탐색전Girls Planet 999 [ENG]](/img/tr.png)
![[1회] J그룹 ‘크리스탈 걸즈’ ♬FANCY_TWICE @플래닛 탐색전Girls Planet 999 | Mnet 210806 방송 [ENG]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/lyLyYjKr_c4/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ENG sub] PRODUCE48 [10회] ♬Rumorㅣ′작곡가 대만족′ 국.슈(국프의 핫이슈) @콘셉트 평가 180817 EP.10](/img/1.gif)
No wonder Shen Xiaoting is the number 1 in C-group. She carry this performance.
Which one is she? The one who cover Yena rap part?
@@wanieyaziey9894 she one with brown hair
@@wanieyaziey9894 yes 0:38
@@ayaaaww Knew it she stand out for me
@@bluemoon1794 alright thanks 😊
xiaoting has grown so much in such a little amount of time. she was always so talented but today she was mind blowing. the destined center for sure
miss her sm :((
@@mthsyiaa she literally made it into the final lineup?😭
@@miguelrom4170 YES
Yeah but sadly she's not the center. A center that we wouldn't have 😢
@@EL-or1ec we all know kcj1 are the real centers
I didn't even notice that Xiaoting's mic fell off, until someone in twitter revealed it. Dude she handled it well, very nice. I miss c-group btw, they became much closer to each other than they already were because of the mistreatment that they experienced in that show, no one's there for them other than themselves. C-group deserves better, I love them.
Time stamp?
@@dzuhhh 1:48
xiaoting doing chowons rap part is insane. she carried the whole group and ate the performance up, she needs to debut immediately.
chowon from lightsum or another chowon?
@@prettyerim6000 yes she is in lightsum now .
@@Moon-nv3nu yes, i know but I didn't know if was chowon from lightsum o another chowon
Ikr
@@prettyerim6000 chowon from lightsum
The girl with long black hair that sang most of the parts seems like she was given notes that were too high, a low register would maybe fit better, but she sang on pitch especially at the end. I admire that she kept going and did her best with what she had. The girl with ginger hair is the strongest in my opinion. The rap was really good, especially in another language than her native one. I'd like to see her continue further.
Yes she's Huang Xing Qiao shes a soloist my number 1 pick. Her voice is too deep and low in her many songs.
@@wiz_lime i love her deep voice sm, she's one of my pick too!! I hope she will more practice and go to final >
@@radjarachmadsyah5679 me too
the ginger hair girl is c group's center shen xiaoting!!
ruclips.net/video/RpwY7EUxX_4/видео.html
This huangxingqiao vocal if u want know her true voice
can we talk about how much hsin wei has improved?😭😭 i’m so proud of her
She done every mission well.
yes vivi is talented even since her in youthwithyou2
I miss her
Hsin Wei reminds of Hyewon
Xuo rowei did will her rap here
The one who did chowon's rap is the best by far
shen xiaoting :)
Exactly!!
She’s the c group center!
TRUEEEE
Agreed
The girl who did most of the singing and highnotes is really good actually! Her tone is amazing. It’s unfortunate she cracked but she was carrying the song’s vocal parts the most and cracking happens sometimes but that doesn’t mean she sounds bad because I think she seems like she’s going to be known for her main vocal capabilities imo. And ofc the girl with red hair was amazing and her facial expressions are great!!
She's Huang Xing Qiao shes a soloist. A powerful vocalist with low and deep voice.
Yes i actually am most interested in her cz her voice is the type i usually like
This should be due to dancing. Believe with more practice she will learn how to control her breath while dancing heavily.
@@wiz_lime Yess her deep vocals are amazing but she also can go high! I love her tone a lot!!
@@sunnymira
Hai mira... tommy Hwang here... meet you here too...
Yeah she my #1 pick.... HuangXingQiao.... iam be her fans since 2years ago... i love her japanese single....
Iam be deep husky voice FANS which unique vocal type in kpop industry... for example StayC J
Seems like everyone forgot that Xiaoting can rap too. This is what a center should be. All rounder artist. So proud of you babe 😘
Shen Xiaoting reminds me of Kim Sejeong. She is a talented all around trainee who was also kind enough to team up with a whole bunch of unpopular trainees. Please support this kind Queen!
they're not unpopular, basically you can't say much abt their popularity bc it's only the first ep, they're just lower ranking trainee in terms of skill (ranked from their first signal performance and i guess other performance too before this)
I think the one that resembles more to Sejong is Kim Dayeon the korean center, she's also from the same agency as her hahaha
@@victonxvixxxveriveryfanboy3887 ahh Dayeon is from Jellyfish?
Mnet chose the teams, not the girls’ themselves! keep that in mind
@@paiget8570 yep because if xiaoting will choose a team she will definitely choose the powerful one so that she can have more attention than she had now
Shows like this just remind me that not everyone can be a star - there are so many people that can dance and sing well but personality/star quality is equally important!!!
hahahaaahaha
which is why i love how sunmi said she is going to look for aura and presence. people seriously underestimate how important presence is on stage if you want to be a top idol
@@anee7558 i agree. Also Sunmi might not be the best dancer or singing. But she has the aura and star quality. Which is why she is the most successful WG soloist right now
True!!!
But here we see that even sing And dance at the same time is BIG deal) Not just look pretty. The one who only got look could be models or RUclipsrs
At first I doubted Yeseo's choice to take Xingqiao in her cell but in this performance, she did well despite her mistakes (missed dance move and voice crack). She has this aura on her. And watching her Fiesta performance really showed me how she improved a lot in a short span of time. I hope she'll get better and better.
this song was too high for her. she has more of a low husky voice like Jisoo (BP) but less huskier.
yes i love her! she is one of my top picks
@@rosesnrosie4878
Deep soul voice like Xingqiao will show their best potential when sing ballad song
the girl in beige, yo if she improves her vocal in this survival show, she’d be a legit main vocal material. i can see her vocals be stable in the future
Who?
yes her voice is beautiful , but her lack of vocal skill kinda hide that ( i would say)
And she's damn pretty
Thank you omg she did'nt deserve this she carried the whole song
I dont know. She started so bad. She was out of tune most of the times, shaky vocals, the song is clearly out of her comfortable range. Though yes her vocal color is really good.
This shows that you can't judge an idol that undergoes training and say that they're not talented. You never know unless you walk into their shoes.
Appreciate this comment, some stray love to spread virus comment to each trainee like they were in prison or bullied other, this is a survival show that trainee comes to learn to become an idol, some had talent, some didn’t, mostly those hate comment are on foreign trainees…fk shet I hate it when they knew nth and feeling like a coach or judge to those.
She gave most of the lines to her other members, so that they can shine and show more of their potential. If I was the center of (C,K or J Group) I would choose to have the most lines but that's not the case of Xiaoting, she's also so humble, kind and I can see how she genuinely care to her members.
She was singing so stable , gave that rap and gave that clean and elegant dance but she wasn't even trying hard 👐👐👐😭😭😭
Vote for Shen Xiaoting!!!
@@whitefox7369 Pls watch this link : ruclips.net/video/nceJvcJp3XY/видео.html
It is not Xiaoting fault that she is so talented lol, she's not good with high parts, but she is stable with low parts, good in rapping, a very great dancer and she has that center "aura",she helped her other members do their parts it is not her fault if they did not slayed
@@whitefox7369 Are you new to kpop? In a group it consists of roles, Shen Xiaoting role was a leader and main dancer so yeah😒 it's just hard talking to people who haven't done their research lol
@@ivanahmaeaclo5330 I frankly wished she gave less parts to vivi Chen . The ponytail girl one. She's so pretty even in youth with you but her singing is a little shaky even there . 😢 And it really shows here
@@whitefox7369 @1:45 she can clearly hit high notes though, it's still in her range.
Right, I guess Xiaoting is the only who can rap in her group that's why she got the less lines anyways looking forward on her improvements she already has the talent.
I can see Xiaoting as the leader the way she took care of here teammates. She deserves to debut. She slayed this performance, I hope the three centers stay as a cell so they can debut together.
Xiaoting is must debut. I’m throwing hands if she doesn’t
Which one is xiaoting?
@@ewseekhelp she is the one with orange/light brown hair
@@ewseekhelp 0:36
agree
same😭😭😭
The main vocal has potential with enough practice, I hope she continues to grow and practice her abilities she will be a good vocalist if she does. I can also see that she lacks some stamina and other members too except for the rapper. I'll be cheering on them and hope that they became more talented
She's actually more well known for her deeper vocals :( idk why they chose this song
Shen Xiaoting is really out here, proving to everyone that SHE is the C-Group's center, well done! 😭💗
they still did a decent job despite the language barrier and the fact that they're singing while dancing,,, there's a lot to improve and that's what's the show is all about,,,, jiayou
True..
language barrier? I thought all of the members are from c group...
ah yes I checked it again, they're all chinese so I don't think there's language barrier?
@@yooh1785 language barrier meaning they have to sing in korean which is foreign to them i guess
@@yooh1785 language barrier for them to sing in korean
シンチャオまじで原石だと思う
よくイェソ見つけたよなwwwスゴすぎる🥺
My girl Xiaoting really gave us EVERYTHING!!!!! She EMBODIED this performance and was soo freaking stable!!!
She's a strong vocalist with low and deep voice.
Xaoting is a mood changer. ghorrrl the mentors get hyped on her part
선샤오팅 진짜 압도적이다
저 33위 빼고는 나머지 둘도 씨그룹 평균보단 나음
예나 대신 땜빵도 되겠는데.
오래봐서그런가
두꺼비같음 ㅎㅎ
@@보필보필-j7r 누가욤?
@@보필보필-j7r 움..웨이가 두꺼비라뇨..ㅋㅋ진짜 실화.. 아이돌상이아니고 중국 배우상이라그래요
The one with orange hair can really perform.I think the other girls should've practice more,specially singing in stable. But who knows, maybe these girls suddenly improve.And the thing I really like to compliment is they sang live.
her name is Shen Xiaoting! 🤍
she yess queen xiaotingg
She looks like IU and Bae Suzy altogether 😍
she is c group's center shen xiaoting!!
You like to compliment that they sang live? Every single group in this first round did 😂 But yeah ofc its still an important thing to mention
The division of parts is distributed poorly or it's just her who can sing high notes. Being an idol, singing while dancing is a must. They will need more practice and I hope they grow. Cheer up !!!
Yeah, and this is actually a hard song
They didn't do that bad though. Rumor is a hard song to sing live because of how many body-rolls it has in it's choreo, but all the girls managed to sing all the lines even if they were unstable often (except for queen Xiaoting✨). Their stage presence is also good, I'm actually impressed ngl. Most idols can't even sing live anyways, so I'd say these girls are reasonably talented enough to make it
@@mariunfabregas7533 and also the girls who sing eunbi part its has good job for the highnote and i love her voice sm, i think her highnote it's quite crack just because she has many line and its actually high :(
Xingqiao can actually sing really well T-T, it's just that her voice doesn't really match the song, and she isn't stable while singing
@@mariunfabregas7533 true but it kinda just doesn't hit as hard as the contestants who did it in Produce 48 :/
Now knowing that Mnet chose the song and parts for them, I don’t think Huang Xingqiao did that bad considering her lack of dance experience. With more training to become more stable while dancing she has so much potential.
xiaoting’s performance is even more shocking when you realize she’s not rapping in her native language
@Kpop lover I know that. why are you pressed.
@@bluegyrl75 who pressed tho?
션샤오팅 진짜 춤이랑 보컬 제일 안정적이고 튄다
다른애들이 못해서 그런건가 .. 저 밝은 탈머도 너무 잘어울려 ..
it's sad how ruowei didn't have many lines because she seems very talented and could've really shown her talents on that stage !! and she's so underrated, my girl deserves more recognition !
비주얼은 미쳤다 진짜
Only just noticed around 1:47 xiaoting's mic falls off, but she effortlessly manoeuvres it out of the way. I wonder if they didn't make such a big deal out of it because no one noticed from how effortlessly she handled it :o
True 😳
coming back here to say how much Huang Xing Qiao has improved and cant wait to see more of her💖
How did you knoww🤔
@@xingqiaofairy6620 I see you everywhere HAHAHAHA, glad to see there's someone who really supports this precious girl
@@_kagura2173 yes she's my top 1
@@_kagura2173 me too :v
I promote all her live vocal video everywhere
@@tommyhwang936 that's nice, let's all root for her, I'll check out the vids you post
Xiaoting is absolutely amazing. Holy sh**. She needs to be a soloist after this.
XINGQIAO literally sing half of the song, so proud of her
ファンシンチャオめっちゃダンスもボーカルも上達してるし
これ見て選んだイェソもすごすぎる
Their main vocalist is working so hard. They'll get better with more practice. They're not bad
ruclips.net/video/Lypml4kmGX4/видео.html
This their main vocalist do live singing
Can I ask the name of their main vocal here?
It sounds like her throat will hurt later
@@chi5065
That will happening to every deep husky singer when someone forced them must singing in highpitch ... out of their vocal range...
This song not give Justice for HuangXingQiao Beautiful deep husky voice....
@@tommyhwang936 tbh I also think so, I think if she raps it'll sound cool for her voice since you know it's husky. Plus the Opening part, she could nail those
I am starting to like Huang Xing Qiao (girl with the long black hair) because when she messed up she still had her head up the whole time! Even if shes not the best, Hwaiting! Jiayou!
the way they edited it really made it seem like xingqiao had weak vocals but she's actually an amazing singer, it was just doing it while dancing that affected it. towards the end she killed it especially at 1:02 and the chorus line after + she has so many other vids online!
its hard to pull Kwon Eunbi's high note on this song😨
yep you only know how hard it is when you see people failing...
Yeah I miss Iz*One
Yess it was even hard for her, just imagine for someone with much less vocal training 🙌
i miss eunbi 😭😭💀 she's going solo this month it's fine but still
Only eunbi and yuri give justice to that high note
xiaoting's aura and her gaze she's really the perfect center 😭
Xiaoting and Xingqiao are really good. Xiaoting in rapping and Xingqiao in singing. Both are tall and pretty and charismatic. When you see them perform you can't help smiling. They have only 9 days apart in their birthdays. Please vote for Xiaoting and Xingqiao as well as Yurina. Debut the 99l tall trio.
But XingQiao is underrated ☹️
C26 definetly have potential. Trust me, we will see her growth.
1:31, xingqiao really did great here tbh
yes
This group is full of visuals
sure,so many Chinese idols are visuals
xioating's Korean pronunciation sounds almost fluent. she's stable too. rooting for her.
and i hope they'll give xing qiao a chance. she has the voice, just needs a suitable range and not high pitched. i hope we'll get to see her vocals development in this show. looking forward for her performance
The girl with orange hair has a really beautiful voice and also she's has a strong dance 😭😭💞💖💕💓🥺
shen xiaoting
@@crystalorbit5767 tnx
xingqiao and hsinwei didn’t even do that bad mnet is literally crazy omfg
xiaoting carried her team she never disappoints
The other girls need to practice more but xiaoting on the other hand is way more stable and eye catching
Yess
who is she?
@@millaray610 the one with orange/brownish hair
I like Xiaoting's personality! She's totally a leader-material.
The fact that Huang Xingqiao got this popular with her screentime in Fiesta, makes me feel sad for Xu Ruowei. Girl didn't get any screentime at all.
Compared with xuziyin... ruowei still appear in ep.1....
Xuziyin no screentime... her performance cut by mnet in ep.1
@@tommyhwang936 Ziyin already had thousands of fans behind him. Ruowei didn't get screentime, only her performance were shown which they only talked about Shen Xiaoting and Chen Hsinwei.
다떠나서 중국 아이돌 연습생 한국에 아이돌로 들이기전에 중국으로 런안하겠다는거랑 동북공정에 동의하는 글을 절대 안올리겠다는 계약서좀 썼으면... 하도 많이 데여서...
계약 어길시 시진핑 마오 개개끼 3창하고
[유튭 틱톡 박제 필수로]
중국으로 추방하면 지킬듯.
인체의 신비는 당하고싶지 않을테니
그러게요 그런거 다 하면서 한국에서 돈 벌어먹겠다고하면 안되죠 모순!
인체의신비당할텐데 그걸어케하노
계약서 써도 백퍼 튈 듯, 스엠처럼 대기업이랑 계약서써도 전부 튀는데... 애초에 동북공정하려고 온 애들 같음
The girl with color orange(?) Hair color carry this performance her stage presence and rap dance👍👏 she's now one of my pick💙
if i'm not wrong she's the center for c-group in O.O.O
same.
Her name is shen xiaoting
Her name is Shen Xiaoting 🤍
Shen xiaoting domination
You can't blame them, the original team chosen for this song was so perfect that people wanted them to debut together. Even izone could not out shadow the original
honestly the main vocalist in this group did a great job considering a) there are many high notes in this song and they're all difficult and b) her voice is quite deep, so the notes could've been a bit out of her range. xiaoting also did a great job as the rapper.
ruclips.net/video/RpwY7EUxX_4/видео.html
HuangXingQiao vocal
yes, considering pd48 had 3 vocalist there...meanwhile here she sang literally all
Shen Xiaoting carried this performance
Literary the high note on this performance can't get out of my head. It is so beautiful!
From this moment I knew Shen Xiaoting will debut. And she did. So proud of you girl.
"Deep voiced singers shouldn't be main vocalists,"
Huang Xing Qiao: "screw that, I'll be whatever I want!"
Her voice is quite stable actually, but some may think it's weird bc we don't know many deep voiced main vocalists. As a mezzo soprano myself I can understand what it's like. We need more mezzo sopranos as main vocalists actually, not only rappers or 'no line club'.
Shes ma Fav from this group
yeahh i wanna see more deep toned main vocalist in kpop
Her voice is kinda unusual in kpop but sound pleasing to my ears😗
ruclips.net/video/Lypml4kmGX4/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/RpwY7EUxX_4/видео.html
For you guys want listern her beautiful husky voice....
1 of that video her live singing.... another one her japanese song which she produce that song by herself
@@starrbitz1229 rosé has a deep voice
Xingqiao the dark horse. don't forget to vote for her. She's so idol material same as Xiaoting. Both have great personality, and can do any concept. Both of them are knetz fav. for a reason. International fans should choose wisely. KPOP isn't just swag/badass music. Idols have to be ace of all trades. Attractive Visual☑️ Attitude☑️ Stage Presence☑️ Variety show skills☑️ Versatile(any concept)☑️
i hope she makes it. she's my pick since day1. I'm kind of worried in her rank during the interim that was released
True.
She did so bad in utopia lmaooo yeseo believed in her and still hasnt improved ☠️
@@kaeya9148 so bad you say? Yes I caught some moments she danced ahead of the beat but Xingqiao is still a dark horse, put her with Xiaoting in a group and you'll get a main dancer and lead vocalist with overflowing visuals, there's nothing wrong with her attitude I mean, we cannot see anyone's true colors through just pixels but its just contagious the way she laughs in a serious moment, and c'mon give her a break I'm sure almost half of the entire population does that
xingqiao does not deserve to debut she needs to first fix her attitude
I CANT BELIEVE XIAOTING SINGLEHANDEDLY CARRIED THIS WHOLE TEAM
The brown haired girl stole the show!
She's the c group center Shen Xiaoting!
シャオティンちゃんはさすがとしか言えない！
シンチャオちゃんはキーが高くて得意な音域じゃなかったんだろうな。
歌上手くてスタイル抜群だからうまくいってほしい。
The way Shen Xiaoting really carried this entire performance
You should remember that original Rumor from PD48 has 3 vocalists singing ,but this time only huang xing qiao plays the main vocal and she never sings with dance in front of the stage. I think she is one of the most potential members in C group.
True true
Xiaoting's is passionate, she would really be a great leader and rapper, as well as a major dancer.
Surprisingly, the main rapper of this group seems to be the most stable one, along with the best vocal technique among them as well, and seems to be a decent dancer too. There is a big gap in terms of skills within this team.
I dont know who picked this song its a wrong choice. Huang Xing Qiao their main vocalist is a powerful vocalist with low and deep voice.
she's main position is dance but yes she can raps that good and you can also see other video of her vocals was totally amazing, support shen xiaoting she's an all rounder 😼
@@wiz_lime i agree. rumor is a good choice for xiaoting and an okay choice for that other rapper, but it's a really bad choice for their two vocalists, both because of the song and the choreography. they should've just picked something safer
She’s not just a “decent” dancer. She has won many dancing competitions, as said of u watched the whole ep
@@iwatchyoutube3511 well i haven't watched the episode yet, when i posted this comment, this is only the first time I've seen her. it's also a very short video and mose of the time they're showing another member or the judges' faces so i didn't get a good look at her dance
xiaoting best center, a performer, a leader
the way i hated this performance at first (tho i loved xiaoting's parts) lol... now i love it... i mean i love xiaoting and xingqiao slayed here.. definitely c-group picks
I can’t stand ppl like you. Xingqiao slayed here? You got to be fucking kidding me. This was her worse In the show. She did better in fiesta
@@MsFated dude, it's a personal preference. i already said i hated it but i'm now accepting it as if she's slayed her coz i started to appreciate her efforts of singing while dancing for someone who has never done it before. again, it's not the same slayage as well as other people but it's a slayage xingqiao level...
@@user-burp low standards you have if you think she slayed this performance 🤣
@@MsFated i think you've misunderstood me lol. i already said i hated it at first. second, i only said she slayed it on 'xingqiao level' coz she's on a league of her own (i consider her background on singing while dancing since she didnt specifically trained for it). lastly, why are you so bothered with me saying she slayed?? coz like our opinions on these performances can be subjective you know lmao 😂 i'm aware how bad the performance was, as what i've said "i hated it at first"
But seriously Eunbi's high note in Rumor is really hard to pull off 😵
Jo yuri pull it better
Chowon did it the best, both rap amd high note.
This is about Eunbi.
both wrong. rumor is eunbi's song. NO ONE can do it better than her
@@cutepongki go make a different comment or something
time flies so fast, our iz*one baby has become senior to them and covering their song🥺
despite the mistakes, it wasn’t horrible. i think they did good. i honestly really like the girl with the cream colored shirts singing. there were mistakes but i enjoyed it. she does have a nice voice. with a little bit more vocal training, she would definitely do a lot better. the other girls also did pretty well! orange haired girl really caught my eye, her rap was amazing. the other two also did well. the girl with the ponytail could use a bit more training but she does have potential! the other girl with the long black hair also caught my eye with her vocals. it wasn’t bad tbh, i liked it! i’m rooting for these girls!! (i don’t know any of their names so i tried to describe them best as i could)
Cream colour shirt vocal video
ruclips.net/video/RpwY7EUxX_4/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/Lypml4kmGX4/видео.html
@@tommyhwang936 thank you!! i appreciate it :)
I mean it is horrible just not HORRIBLE.
I wouldn’t call this good at all
@@MsFated it's not that bad there were worse performances I would give this a 6/10
@@MsFated 1:51 u will notice her mouth close faster than voice....it mean no live vocal....
She lorina/HuangXingQiao can sing live very good....
So i think it just Mnet Plan to manipulated audience to think XingQiao cant sing
Xiaoting really caught my eye, she’s now one of my main picks!
The girl on beige is actually my fave in this grup like gurl if her vocals are warmed up and she practices for a stable voice she would be a force to be wrekend with
My number 1 pick
you’ve made it xiaoting ❤️ i’m so proud of you
i can see Huang XingQiao improving. She's got the voice but needs vocal lessons and def dance lessons.
If she made it and debut I believe she will learn a lot🥺 please vote for her
@@goldentabby1030 i'm voting for her everyday
@@johnjerahkenalmasa9346 thank you for supporting herrr❤️😊
@@xingqiaofairy6620 yes all the time!!! been supporting her since day1! let's do our best!!!
@@goldentabby1030 Can you please where can we vote?
okay but the girl whos voice cracked has lots of potential. i really like her vocal tone ❤️
He's Huang Xing Qiao shes a soloist my number 1 pick. She's a powerful vocalist with low and deep voice.
i barely noticed her in Chuang because she was eliminated so early and there was barely any clips of her but in 999 she's like a star, i couldn't even take my eyes off her
She was in Chuang too?? I can't believe I missed her
@@IloveADVENTURE123 yes she was, however she was eliminated the first round
She was chosen for an IMPROV dance battle yet was eliminated so early. She is one of my earliest picks. I was so disappointed in chuang 2020 lol.
Actually, most main dancer material in chuang were eliminated early that's why compared to ywy to that time, chuang felt so lacking
Chuang was so dirty to dancers yeah didn’t watch after 2 episodes
okay BUT XingQiao's voice is so beautiful!! Xiaoting's aura and stage presence is so good!! gonna root for them~
Xiaoting stage presence is really strong
I hate how the editors continuously replayed and zeroed in on the mistakes . They didn’t do this with a lot of the other demo stage .
Xiaoting has such a beautiful dance line! Definitely Main Dancer Material!
The girl in the gold top actually did quite well with all those high notes. With the proper vocal training she could become really stable as her vocal tone is already really nice
She solo singer & song producer...
Never believe 100% what mnet show to you in GirlPlanet 999
xingqiao you're the best
Xiaoting killed the performance.😍
XIAOTANG KNEW THEYLL GOING TO BE GRADED INDIVIDUALLY
help 😭😭😭
we don’t know but she lead her team well
xiaoting lol, she perform with a big gap rank trainees, even the pony tail hair girl is #33
Her name is Xiaoting but she reminds me of Sejeong. A talented all around girl who is also kind to unpopular trainees. Please support this kind Queen!
they did good! Huang Xing Qiao's vocals are great, voice cracks are normal so that's okay! AND CAN I JUST SAY I'M IN LOVE WITH XIAOTING
AM I THE ONLY ONE WHO LOVES THE MAIN VOCAL'S CONGESTED BUT FULL AND POWERFUL VOICE? YES SHE MAY HAVE CRACKED BUT HET VOICE WAS SO GOOD FOR ME
Her voice is deep and low thats why this doesn't suit her.
FINALLY I FIND PEOPLE WHO ALSO LIKE HER VOICE, idk her deep voice its soooo 😩✊💖💗❤
FINALLY SOMEONE WHO LIKES GER VOICE LIKE ME
i love her voice too omg
@@kandrai ruclips.net/video/efn4htThQlw/видео.html
Xiaoting 😍😍
비주얼이랑 피지컬은 4명다 탑티어네
That rapper carried the whole team
이걸 리액션 해주는 다른 분들 너무 대단하신 것 같다
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 중공x 약칠 당햇으니까
진짜 존나 이해가 안되는게 한국연습생들도 데뷔 못 하는 판에 남의 나라까지 끌고 와야함? 중국 일본 다 피차 서로 좋은 감정 가진 것도 아닌데 존나 엠넷 이해 안 되네 그냥 관심 안 주는게 답인가
엠넷의 관심사는 한국연습생이 데뷔하든말든.... 중국자본을 이용해서 방송만들고 중국과 일본에 다시 되 팔아서 돈벌면 그만...
저번 프듀48때 중국이 자기들만 빼고 한국일본오디션하니깐 배아파서 이번에 큰 투자를한듯
그건 ㅇㅈ… 왜 굳이 한국까지 와서 아이돌이 하고싶지 ..? 자기 나라서 하면 됐는데….
그럼 니가 기획사 사장되서 한국인들 데뷔시키든가 ㅋㅋ
Xiaoting carried the whole performance. But I really hope the show will help the other girls improve, they're cute !
shen xiaoting saved her group
huang xing qiao say hi
0:25 was not even a choreo mistake but they made it look like a mistake. it's like a cheat way to ensure xingqiao's voice won't go shaky after the chest pumps, overall she did good and this might sound controversial but her high note sounded better than eunbi's (except the baby)
Oohh now i think about it, good observation tho. I've been contemplating alot & recheck this video now & then, you and i have the same braincell on Xingqiao on 0.25. Xingqiao's high note definitely sold me to her on this entire season.
I give these girls props. As a person who loves rumor a lot, I understand that this song is difficult and the high notes are HIGH. My girl Kwon Eunbi and the pd48 girls really set a standard for this song. I applaud these girls for doing their best, and I hope they continue to improve. They have loads of potential!
Yes only eunbi can slay this w/ pwer vocal
Xiaoting ate it up fr like her voice is so stable and her charisma is overflowing
who is she:(?
@@millaray610 the one with brown/ orange hair
Xiaoting always got first place or second.. But now it was to be voted and she got the last second place I'm crying.
사실상 배우 모델하고 싶은데 아이돌을 과정이나 수단으로 생각해서 지원한 애들같음.
비쥬얼과 실력의 차이에서 오는 괴리감이 큼.
근데 제 눈에만 잘하는것같나요? 노래는 외국인이니 어쩔수없어도 춤은 제가 본 참가자중 젤 잘한거같은데
@@Ryan-kx1wz 노래는 외국인 감안하더라도 못해서ㅠ 발음은 좋은데 기본발성자체가 노래전혀 안해본것같은... 춤만 잘추는거면 댄서를 지원해야겠죠
ruclips.net/video/RpwY7EUxX_4/видео.html
@@Ryan-kx1wz 노래는 발음문제가 아니라 그냥 발성문제인데요? 언어랑 상관없음. 춤은 제 생각엔 별로? 못하진 않지만 그렇게 잘하지도 않은것같고... 물론 저도 프로 아니라서 전문 평가 못하지만요.. 근데 이번 회에는 중국보다 일본 참가자들이 더 잘하고 눈에 띈거같네요
@@myungweollie 그냥 내 개인적인 생각일뿐인데 음악평론가마냥 우루루 몰려와서 답글다는건 뭐임? 답글들 그만다셈