as an oboist, i played principle on this with my youth orchestra in carnegie hall and i can honest to god say that it was one of the greatest most beautiful moments of my life
00:00 Introduction 00:17 Theme (Eb) 00:51 Variation 1 (Eb) 01:27 Variation 2 (Eb) 02:01 Variation 3 (Eb) 02:45 Variation 4 (c) 03:40 Variation 5 (D) 04:13 Variation 6 (g) 04:55 Variation 7 (C) 05:13 Variation 8 (Eb) 06:21 Variation 9 (Eb) 08:12 Variation 10 - Finale (Eb) 09:02 Coda It's a bit unusual for this movement to be theme and variations, given that the last (as well as the first) movement of a symphony is usually in sonata form.
Indeed. Though not unheard of, I think Haydn has some symphonies that end with a Theme and Variations movement. And if you look at sonata structure pieces(so, concertos, piano sonatas, etc.) as a whole, a Theme and Variations ending is not that unusual. Indeed, I see roughly this frequency of forms for ending movements of sonata structure pieces: 1) Tie between Sonata Form and Rondo(Earlier pieces(Mozart and earlier) tend towards Rondo while later pieces(Beethoven and beyond) tend towards Sonata Form) 2) Minuet and Trio (Early Mozart especially) 3) Theme and Variations 4) Other less common ones to end with like Fugue(Haydn Symphony no. 3), Binary Form, etc.
Actually in his day it got mixed reviews, but that just means he was a great experimenter and ahead of his time and half his audience was stuck in their ways! Of course it's a masterpiece today, but in his day many people found it too heavy, deep, and complicated. "Hard on the ear."
Stephen, I cannot tell you how many times I’ve watch this video. Now I’m going to send this to my brothers and sisters for Father’s Day. We lost my dad in Feb. 2018. He adored Beethoven. I’m the only other classical music lover in my large family. I’m going to send your video, because I think the visual helps you hear the music better. I think it’s easier listening to a 10 minute video with graphics like you used here. And I think this is one of Beethoven’s most playful pieces. So thank you for providing a gift I can give my family to remember our Dad.❤️
I'm so happy that you decided to do Eroica! I had wanted to request it, but I read your FAQ, so instead I've been watching your channel with eager hopefulness, knowing that I'd enjoy whatever you posted, even if it wasn't Eroica.
*_Beautiful! Kinda makes me want to walk the walk of atonement in game of thrones but instead of it being a shameful walk It would be a royal walk towards the throne xd_*
MOZ-Bachthoveen-ART Some of my videos have millions of views. Here are the ones with over five million views apiece: Debussy, Clair de lune (piano music) Bach, Toccata and Fugue in D minor, organ Beethoven, Symphony 7, Allegretto, mvt 2 Chopin, Nocturne, opus 27 #2, piano solo Bach, Air ("on the G string", string orchestra)
smalin Right. These videos are very popular. Those pieces are also among the most popular. But you did better work with the Goldberg Variations imp, but those doesn't gets millions of view because not a lot of people doesn't like or even know about the Goldberg Variation. The graphic is not the sole component, the big part of it is still the music. The visual part is to complement the listening experience. I actually didn't watch your videos of the Goldberg Variations as often until I actually like the music and seek for your videos to enhance my experience. I'm just saying, your work of the Goldberg Variations deserve more views, and the music deserves more views, but it's up to the listeners to decide if they like the music or not.
I was shocked when i heard this movement was considered lesser than the first two. I thought this was the cornerstone of the piece, Beethoven turning to learned techniques and doing so brilliantly.
Para los que tienen buen oido : Este maravilloso cuarto movimiento esta basado en dos sonidos : Mi bemol y Si bemol . El gran genio los transforma en un torrente sin fin de ideas sonoras con agudas armonias y como siempre una rica orquestacion . Tengo la version para piano y cuando llego al climax del TUTTI me llena una gan emocion . Le preguntaron a Beethoven antes de la novena cual era su sinfonia preferida y respondio inmediatamente : Heroica . Y la quinta ? le preguntaron , no,no Heroica respondio . Estoy de acuerdo con el gran genio de Bonn ......
Yo antes no era muy amante de La Heróica, pero luego de escuchar esta Magistral Interpretación del Cuarto Movimiento, pasó a ser una de mis Sinfonías Favoritas.
I had a thought about this symphony last night: In my view the symphony can almost be seen as a musical outline of Beethoven's entire life or, less specifically, of the general development of the romantic hero. The first movement is Beethoven's early period, or alternatively the 'Virtuoso' period; The second movement, the funeral march, is Beethoven's despair in Heiligenstadt as the crisis of his deafness emerges; the scherzo is Beethoven's gathering resolution, it is the penultimate moment of _intimation_ before the creative outburst, and there is a sense that tremendous forces are amassing together; the first 395 bars of the final movement (i.e. everything up until 9:02 in this video) form the middle period, a period of rapid creative activity, a furious emanation of the energy that accumulated in the preceding scherzo movement (alternatively, this first half of the finale contains the 'Appassionata' and 'Invasion' periods); the section in the finale consisting of bars 396 to 430 (from 9:02 to 10:54 in this video) is an ominous portent of the ensuing years of incubation and unproductivity; But then, in the concluding bars of the finale, there is a prophecy: the wheel will turn again, and a final surge of glory will issue forth in the form of Beethoven's late period, or the period of 'Sublimation.'
I agree with much of this. The ominous section before the finale though is, in my humble opinion, Beethoven not letting the listener get through the symphony without having been reminded of the anguish he was going through in his life at the time. Then Beethoven says "ok enough"... back to the symphony... So it was a very very very personal stamp in a symphony that was in itself a personal stamp.
Thank you Smalin for this upload :). Just want to say, that i like the moment at the end especially : from 9:30 to 10:55. There is a minor theme,that i like in this movement :)
The part at 10:20 was sampled as a backtrack to a rap song my brother listens to. I was listening to it and I immediately recognized it. I have no knowledge of the name of the song
@@karsadkarsad www.whosampled.com/sample/18110/Atmosphere-1597-Ludwig-Van-Beethoven-Finale%3A-Allegro-Molto/ I love this website, it really is very helpful^^
Thank you. The first two opening bars of this (the world's greatest symphony) is Beethoven saying here I am. He is announcing himself to the world. It is exceptional.
I think if you were told you could only save one Beethoven piece, this movement would be a good candidate. Amazing how it manages to be gargantuan and sublime, yet also silly and whimsical at the same time.
Stephen - I love this! I’m going to show it to my dad, who is very sick in the hospital. He adores Beethoven, and especially the Eroica symphony. I think he’ll get a kick out of “seeing“ the music. Thanks again. I know my dad, Jack, would want to say thanks also.
BTW, I did an alternate version of the score for the third movement, in which there is a separate "staff" for each group of instruments (strings, winds, brass): ruclips.net/video/nBPWgX6v3UQ/видео.html
6:10 on.. Imagine someone seeing the ocean for the first time after living away from the ocean their whole life. This is, musically, Beethoven taking us on his journey to a new musical landscape, and seeing it for the first time. A new world!
This song makes me think of MLB baseball. Every piece of the song has a feeling to some piece of baseball. 0:04-0:17 Play Ball! 0:17-0:52 Training 0:52-2:00 Going to a Baseball Game 2:00-2:36 MLB Melody 2:36-3:40 Starting Lineups 3:40-4:13 MLB Melody (when tracking another game) 4:13-4:55 Strikeouts 4:55-5:03 MLB Melody (after a break) 5:03-5:13 Call to the Bullpen! 5:13-5:37 Game Review 5:37-6:21 Mid-Season Play, All-Star Break 6:21-7:22 MLB Melody (after the All-Star Break) 7:22-9:02 August Baseball 9:02-10:20 Greatest Legends in MLB History 10:20-10:55 MLB Playoffs 10:55-11:54 World Series
I highly recommend listening to Osmo Vanska with the Minnesota Orchestra! Except for some very minor clipping the recording is absolutely superb. All the instruments are so beautifullly mixed in, while still having a unified sound as a whole. The reverb is also just ideal. Enough to give a lushious and full tone, but not too much, so that it makes everything sound blurred and some instruments aren't distinguishable anymore (as with a lot of recordings of this piece). Much better sounding than even some of the most renowned recordings like Karajans imo. Not to mention how good the interpretation itself is :D
Wow. After watching that scroll my eyes are all wonky. It looks like my computer is still moving. It's beautiful to be able to see what you are listening to.
hallo smalin, vou make a great job. I am a lover of beethoven since 40 years, but never I could see the structure of the music so visible as in your video. Go along. Thanks and forgett my awfull englich.
Así como hago llamados en pro de otras causas, así hago un llamado a escuchar las grandes obras de la Música Clásica y en éste caso "ver" la música que también es posible gracias a smalin. ¡¡Disfruten y vean!!
Here's an idea, maybe you could do an animation of this movement the same way you did with Mozart's Jupiter finale (Richard Atkinson has a fabulous video on the finale of Eroica). There alot of motivic connections and i think this version, while exampling Beethoven's excellence in harmony, looses it contrapuntal "weight". I know, i should "request" or "underwrite" but i am both a child and dirt broke. I will as soon as i possibly can. Sorry if this doesn't make any sense my, dyslexia is strong in the morning
In this coloring method, twelve hues equally spaced around the color wheel are assigned to the twelve pitches on the circle of fifths. There’s no way to make the palette “richer” while preserving this relationship. See www.musanim.com/HarmonicColoring/ for more background on this.
¿Quien es smalin? Esa era para mi una gran interrogante, pero me fuì a Google que todo lo sabe y allì me encuentro con que es una persona de renombre y logros acadèmicos notables. Sus videos son realmente notables ya que a mi la mùsica clàsica me gusta mucho, tanto, que no solo oirla, sino verla tambièn y hete que aquì està. Este video me gusta en especial por que es el movimiento màs bello, bueno, todo es hermoso, de la 3ra. Sinfonìa Heròca. Gracias, es y serà un placer oir y ver. Gracias samalin.
Yes, you have correctly identified me. My personal web site is stephenmalinowski.com, and the website for the Music Animation Machine project is musanim.com ... Please feel free to contact me if you have questions.
smalin De verdad que me he sentido dichoso de recibir respuesta tan inmediata de una persona tan importante. yo solo soy un diletante que realmente disfruto con la mùsica clàsica aunque mis conocimientos en ella son muy, muy cortos. Solo me gusta y ya y eso desde mi niñèz, pero con èstos video se han hecho realidad mis sueños : Ver la mùsica. No tengo palabras para agradecer su dedicaciòn en la realizaciòn de sus videos. Gracias mil, de verdad. Sorry for no write in English, but my english is short and bad.
jose rey angel hernandez cruz It's okay, Google translate makes it all good. I am happy to give you this pleasure and satisfaction. Please help me share my work.
Kolby Villanueva Hey, if you wanna hear REAL Beethoven's "Erotica" you should try listening his ariette "Der Kuss" it's erotic poem, really, it's cool:-)
I wrote software. You can read about the project at my website. This page in particular might answer your question: www.musanim.com/ProductionNotes/synchronization.html
Listen to Osmo Vänska's interpretation with the Minnesota Orchestra. The whole thing is incredible, but this passage is so damn powerful, yet controlled! You can just hear the hero struggle against fate and overcome it like Beethoven did when he wrote this masterpiece of a Symphony that changed all of music!
@@pcgamingftw5694 Osmo’s interpretation is one of my absolute favorites! He’s so controlled and clinical, yet he can lay it down pretty good when it comes to powerful passages like that. His Beethoven cycle is my reference of sorts. There are more elegant cycles (Wand’s is amazing), more lively ones (Chailly’s), but overall Vanska is consistently outstanding and flawless.
COMO SE HACE LA MUSICA SINFONICA.LA CLAVE ES SU desarrollo,como lo es en la vida misma y en una flor.La música no es como la pintura, que se aprecia su belleza, prácticamente en el acto, no es asi, en la música sinfónica que precisa de un desarrollo lo más intenso posible, al objeto de disfrazar,de difuminar en lo máximo posible, la tónica, es decr, el motivo,tema,semilla, frase del inicio de la sinfonía, que pueden ser 3-4 notas como sucede en esta sinfonía y en la 5 sinf. de Sibelius que son unas notas que deberán ser desarrolladas, como un recién nacido,bebe,niño, joven adolescente. maduro...ec.A a excepción de estas pocas notas iniciales, vendrá el tema, luego el desarrollo y posteriormente la reexposición.ESTE ESQUEMA QUE ES el de la sonata, TAMBIÉN podrá variar algo con el tiempo, añadiendo un nuevo movimiento y poco más, salvo en la música del período1950 en adelante.COMO HACE EL COMPOSITOR PARA DESARROLARLA. en otra ocasión se indicará.
![Mozart - Symphony No. 25 in G minor, K. 183 [complete]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/rNeirjA65Dk/mqdefault.jpg)
as an oboist, i played principle on this with my youth orchestra in carnegie hall and i can honest to god say that it was one of the greatest most beautiful moments of my life
10:54 one of my favorite parts
Me too always
It always makes me so happy to hear the theme return at 8:12. It being augmented is somewhere between silly and grandiose.
You mean prolonged?
@@ClassicalPower well it's augmented because it's the same notes at 2:00 but longer value
@@starchythepotato2877 Okok yes I wasn't sure what you meant!
00:00 Introduction
00:17 Theme (Eb)
00:51 Variation 1 (Eb)
01:27 Variation 2 (Eb)
02:01 Variation 3 (Eb)
02:45 Variation 4 (c)
03:40 Variation 5 (D)
04:13 Variation 6 (g)
04:55 Variation 7 (C)
05:13 Variation 8 (Eb)
06:21 Variation 9 (Eb)
08:12 Variation 10 - Finale (Eb)
09:02 Coda
It's a bit unusual for this movement to be theme and variations, given that the last (as well as the first) movement of a symphony is usually in sonata form.
Indeed. Though not unheard of, I think Haydn has some symphonies that end with a Theme and Variations movement. And if you look at sonata structure pieces(so, concertos, piano sonatas, etc.) as a whole, a Theme and Variations ending is not that unusual. Indeed, I see roughly this frequency of forms for ending movements of sonata structure pieces:
1) Tie between Sonata Form and Rondo(Earlier pieces(Mozart and earlier) tend towards Rondo while later pieces(Beethoven and beyond) tend towards Sonata Form)
2) Minuet and Trio (Early Mozart especially)
3) Theme and Variations
4) Other less common ones to end with like Fugue(Haydn Symphony no. 3), Binary Form, etc.
2 flutes: Ellipse
2 oboes: Inverted ellipse (star)
2 clarinets: Octagon
2 bassoons: Inverted ellipse (star)
3 horns: Rectangle
2 trumpets: Rectangle
Timpani: Rectangle
Strings: Rhombus
This must have been mind blowing to have first heard this because it still is
Yep. It was ground-breaking.
+smalin I was listening to u r videos since I was 3 I am 7/2
@@KATTACEO So 3 1/2 (at the time?) or 7 1/2? Either way, I can forgive the ambiguous fraction notation? :)
Actually in his day it got mixed reviews, but that just means he was a great experimenter and ahead of his time and half his audience was stuck in their ways! Of course it's a masterpiece today, but in his day many people found it too heavy, deep, and complicated. "Hard on the ear."
@@andrewb.7613 There is a film on the reception of the Eroica (BBC's Eroica) which goes into the contemporary reaction to the work.
Stephen, I cannot tell you how many times I’ve watch this video. Now I’m going to send this to my brothers and sisters for Father’s Day. We lost my dad in Feb. 2018. He adored Beethoven. I’m the only other classical music lover in my large family. I’m going to send your video, because I think the visual helps you hear the music better. I think it’s easier listening to a 10 minute video with graphics like you used here. And I think this is one of Beethoven’s most playful pieces. So thank you for providing a gift I can give my family to remember our Dad.❤️
8:12 I love this part♥️
Same
Transcendent self-possession and self-discovery by the greatest of all artists...
10:55 - The End : The most monumental part of this movement.
This parts is GOATED
Every second of this masterpiece is absolutely breathtaking
4:12 is euphoric
It's the most badass bit in the whole symphony
This is becoming my favorite piece of all time, particularly this 4th movement Thank you so much for the digital images!
Same here brother
One of the best codas out of not only Beethoven's symphonies, but also any piece out there!
Arguably the most uplifting and powerful pieces of Music ever written.
Love the fugato that starts at 2:45
mee toooo
This one at 5:13 is my favorite.
I'm so happy that you decided to do Eroica! I had wanted to request it, but I read your FAQ, so instead I've been watching your channel with eager hopefulness, knowing that I'd enjoy whatever you posted, even if it wasn't Eroica.
I hope to do all the Beethoven symphonies eventually.
The 4th movement is gorgeous, thank you so much
08:11 - 09:03 best part of all
5:59 My favorite part in the entire movement. That moment is foreshadowed by 5:31 (I think, i may be overanalysing)
I agree with you, its my second favorite part after the finale
I’ve “listened” to this music many times, but never “heard” it before I saw it here today!
This symphony really speaks for itself!
*_I discovered this piece for the first time today even though I have admired beethovens 9th symphony since I was 13 in 2014_*
Did you never realize that it was called the 9th because there were 8 more before it?
Well I knew it as Ode to Joy so...
The part that starts at 4:13 I always called “elephant music”.
*_Beautiful! Kinda makes me want to walk the walk of atonement in game of thrones but instead of it being a shameful walk It would be a royal walk towards the throne xd_*
My favourite Beethoven symphony, and my favourite RUclips channel.
Here is my new response: please help me share my videos.
smalin If only people were more interested in music like this, your videos would get millions hits.
MOZ-Bachthoveen-ART
Some of my videos have millions of views.
Here are the ones with over five million views apiece:
Debussy, Clair de lune (piano music)
Bach, Toccata and Fugue in D minor, organ
Beethoven, Symphony 7, Allegretto, mvt 2
Chopin, Nocturne, opus 27 #2, piano solo
Bach, Air ("on the G string", string orchestra)
smalin Right. These videos are very popular. Those pieces are also among the most popular. But you did better work with the Goldberg Variations imp, but those doesn't gets millions of view because not a lot of people doesn't like or even know about the Goldberg Variation. The graphic is not the sole component, the big part of it is still the music. The visual part is to complement the listening experience. I actually didn't watch your videos of the Goldberg Variations as often until I actually like the music and seek for your videos to enhance my experience. I'm just saying, your work of the Goldberg Variations deserve more views, and the music deserves more views, but it's up to the listeners to decide if they like the music or not.
smalin I'm also using your videos to learn the Goldberg Variations. It's so much more fun and easier than reading the music sheet :)
This is amazing.
I wish Beethoven could see this..
Wait until you see my latest video (uploading now) --- a new version of his Große Fuge.
These videos (The Eroica) have been a lovely addition to my Christmas vacation. Thank you.
This is my favorite movement of the symphony.
This is my favorite movement of any symphony.
+goldenoldiesPete Same!!
Mine too!
I'm hooked !!
"My God its... It's like a dam bursting!"
I know the reference xD
I was shocked when i heard this movement was considered lesser than the first two. I thought this was the cornerstone of the piece, Beethoven turning to learned techniques and doing so brilliantly.
Para los que tienen buen oido : Este maravilloso cuarto movimiento esta basado en dos sonidos : Mi bemol y Si bemol . El gran genio los transforma en un torrente sin fin de ideas sonoras con agudas armonias y como siempre una rica orquestacion . Tengo la version para piano y cuando llego al climax del TUTTI me llena una gan emocion . Le preguntaron a Beethoven antes de la novena cual era su sinfonia preferida y respondio inmediatamente : Heroica . Y la quinta ? le preguntaron , no,no Heroica respondio . Estoy de acuerdo con el gran genio de Bonn ......
Excelente Apreciación.
Yo antes no era muy amante de La Heróica, pero luego de escuchar esta Magistral Interpretación del Cuarto Movimiento, pasó a ser una de mis Sinfonías Favoritas.
I had a thought about this symphony last night: In my view the symphony can almost be seen as a musical outline of Beethoven's entire life or, less specifically, of the general development of the romantic hero. The first movement is Beethoven's early period, or alternatively the 'Virtuoso' period; The second movement, the funeral march, is Beethoven's despair in Heiligenstadt as the crisis of his deafness emerges; the scherzo is Beethoven's gathering resolution, it is the penultimate moment of _intimation_ before the creative outburst, and there is a sense that tremendous forces are amassing together; the first 395 bars of the final movement (i.e. everything up until 9:02 in this video) form the middle period, a period of rapid creative activity, a furious emanation of the energy that accumulated in the preceding scherzo movement (alternatively, this first half of the finale contains the 'Appassionata' and 'Invasion' periods); the section in the finale consisting of bars 396 to 430 (from 9:02 to 10:54 in this video) is an ominous portent of the ensuing years of incubation and unproductivity; But then, in the concluding bars of the finale, there is a prophecy: the wheel will turn again, and a final surge of glory will issue forth in the form of Beethoven's late period, or the period of 'Sublimation.'
I agree with much of this. The ominous section before the finale though is, in my humble opinion, Beethoven not letting the listener get through the symphony without having been reminded of the anguish he was going through in his life at the time. Then Beethoven says "ok enough"... back to the symphony... So it was a very very very personal stamp in a symphony that was in itself a personal stamp.
Thank you! This is great to watch and see how the music is constructed.
6:20. Stop. And listen.
Thank you Smalin for this upload :). Just want to say, that i like the moment at the end especially : from 9:30 to 10:55. There is a minor theme,that i like in this movement :)
The part at 10:20 was sampled as a backtrack to a rap song my brother listens to. I was listening to it and I immediately recognized it. I have no knowledge of the name of the song
Could you pl tell me which song?
@@karsadkarsad www.whosampled.com/sample/18110/Atmosphere-1597-Ludwig-Van-Beethoven-Finale%3A-Allegro-Molto/ I love this website, it really is very helpful^^
1597 by Atmosphere
Thank you. The first two opening bars of this (the world's greatest symphony) is Beethoven saying here I am. He is announcing himself to the world. It is exceptional.
I think if you were told you could only save one Beethoven piece, this movement would be a good candidate. Amazing how it manages to be gargantuan and sublime, yet also silly and whimsical at the same time.
Stephen - I love this! I’m going to show it to my dad, who is very sick in the hospital. He adores Beethoven, and especially the Eroica symphony. I think he’ll get a kick out of “seeing“ the music. Thanks again. I know my dad, Jack, would want to say thanks also.
BTW, I did an alternate version of the score for the third movement, in which there is a separate "staff" for each group of instruments (strings, winds, brass): ruclips.net/video/nBPWgX6v3UQ/видео.html
I love this music, and I love the graphics. Well done!
¡Gracias! Cuanto más lo miro y más lo escucho, más lo disfruto. The more I listen to it, the more I enjoy it. Great job!!
6:10 on.. Imagine someone seeing the ocean for the first time after living away from the ocean their whole life. This is, musically, Beethoven taking us on his journey to a new musical landscape, and seeing it for the first time. A new world!
This song makes me think of MLB baseball. Every piece of the song has a feeling to some piece of baseball.
0:04-0:17 Play Ball!
0:17-0:52 Training
0:52-2:00 Going to a Baseball Game
2:00-2:36 MLB Melody
2:36-3:40 Starting Lineups
3:40-4:13 MLB Melody (when tracking another game)
4:13-4:55 Strikeouts
4:55-5:03 MLB Melody (after a break)
5:03-5:13 Call to the Bullpen!
5:13-5:37 Game Review
5:37-6:21 Mid-Season Play, All-Star Break
6:21-7:22 MLB Melody (after the All-Star Break)
7:22-9:02 August Baseball
9:02-10:20 Greatest Legends in MLB History
10:20-10:55 MLB Playoffs
10:55-11:54 World Series
Simply amazing.
The best rendition of this I have heard. don`t ever remove it!
I highly recommend listening to Osmo Vanska with the Minnesota Orchestra! Except for some very minor clipping the recording is absolutely superb. All the instruments are so beautifullly mixed in, while still having a unified sound as a whole. The reverb is also just ideal. Enough to give a lushious and full tone, but not too much, so that it makes everything sound blurred and some instruments aren't distinguishable anymore (as with a lot of recordings of this piece). Much better sounding than even some of the most renowned recordings like Karajans imo. Not to mention how good the interpretation itself is :D
Well done, Stephen Malinowski! Thank you.
En la complejidad de una sinfonía como la 3º de Beethoven, se puede apreciar tu gran trabajo, Smalin. Muchas Gracias.
This a lovely Beethoven piece to discover and enjoy as it is virtually ignored in the 'Classical media'...
The Pizzicato Strings at the start is so perfect
Of my god, that rediculus finale. Very good work.
4:13 in my opinion is the best part
This is an absolutely FAB visual. Amazing work!!!!
You might want to check out some of my more recent videos: ruclips.net/video/LXPIIz3YTmc/видео.html
FANTASTIC!
I'd like you to know that I enjoy the effort you put in on making your videos.
Here is my new response: please help me share my videos.
Wow. After watching that scroll my eyes are all wonky. It looks like my computer is still moving. It's beautiful to be able to see what you are listening to.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motion_aftereffect
Magnificent!
So many videos lately... ah!
Not today sir I'm sorry
The segment from 6:20 to 9:02 is just about one of my all-time favorite chunks of music by anyone. It's just so damn sexy!
Movement 1 - The Great deads of a persons lifie
Movement 2 - His death and funeral
Movement 3 - Resolution or realase
Movement 4 - The leagacy
hallo smalin,
vou make a great job. I am a lover of beethoven since 40 years, but never I could see the structure of the music so visible as in your video. Go along. Thanks and forgett my awfull englich.
You're welcome!
there are so many brilliant parts of this movement but for me the best is 2:45 - 3:40
10:55 OMG that scared me off!
I get chills every time I hear that part
0:17-0:47 Pavlov the dog got his bone stolen by a duck
(Baby Beethoven reference from baby Einstein)
da 8:12 a 9:02 corni formidabili!
I got dizzy.
everything is moving sideways now.
@_@
You are not alone! It happens to the best of us!
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motion_aftereffect
Evelynn Whitebridge Hey i know you from amino!!!
:O)!
as B himself said* so well: 'the Crescendos don't go all the way"!
Dylan 100 % Agree / Mind Blowing
Tür best of all movements
This is amazing! What are your thoughts on his piano variations of the same theme?
Así como hago llamados en pro de otras causas, así hago un llamado a escuchar las grandes obras de la Música Clásica y en éste caso "ver" la música que también es posible gracias a smalin. ¡¡Disfruten y vean!!
Exellent
Here's an idea, maybe you could do an animation of this movement the same way you did with Mozart's Jupiter finale (Richard Atkinson has a fabulous video on the finale of Eroica). There alot of motivic connections and i think this version, while exampling Beethoven's excellence in harmony, looses it contrapuntal "weight".
I know, i should "request" or "underwrite" but i am both a child and dirt broke. I will as soon as i possibly can.
Sorry if this doesn't make any sense my, dyslexia is strong in the morning
I made this video before I developed those techniques. Maybe someday I will revisit it.
i'm learning the third movement right now
08:11 - 09:03 best part
IV. Finale. Allegro molto - Poco andante - Presto
So sad the way people are actually enjoying this while I'm absolutely terrified, stressing how im going to learn all about this piece for my test!😭😭😭
2:10 looks like the text on the enchanting table in minecraft
the final part gets intenser to intenser
love the visuals, a slightly richer palette might make an even better experience, or not... worth the experiment IMO
In this coloring method, twelve hues equally spaced around the color wheel are assigned to the twelve pitches on the circle of fifths. There’s no way to make the palette “richer” while preserving this relationship. See www.musanim.com/HarmonicColoring/ for more background on this.
10:55 :D
¿Quien es smalin? Esa era para mi una gran interrogante, pero me fuì a Google que todo lo sabe y allì me encuentro con que es una persona de renombre y logros acadèmicos notables. Sus videos son realmente notables ya que a mi la mùsica clàsica me gusta mucho, tanto, que no solo oirla, sino verla tambièn y hete que aquì està. Este video me gusta en especial por que es el movimiento màs bello, bueno, todo es hermoso, de la 3ra. Sinfonìa Heròca. Gracias, es y serà un placer oir y ver. Gracias samalin.
Yes, you have correctly identified me. My personal web site is stephenmalinowski.com, and the website for the Music Animation Machine project is musanim.com ... Please feel free to contact me if you have questions.
smalin De verdad que me he sentido dichoso de recibir respuesta tan inmediata de una persona tan importante. yo solo soy un diletante que realmente disfruto con la mùsica clàsica aunque mis conocimientos en ella son muy, muy cortos. Solo me gusta y ya y eso desde mi niñèz, pero con èstos video se han hecho realidad mis sueños : Ver la mùsica. No tengo palabras para agradecer su dedicaciòn en la realizaciòn de sus videos. Gracias mil, de verdad. Sorry for no write in English, but my english is short and bad.
jose rey angel hernandez cruz
It's okay, Google translate makes it all good. I am happy to give you this pleasure and satisfaction. Please help me share my work.
smalin Off course, I put your videos in my Facebook page and send it to all my friends. Tank's and Happy New Year.
Ah, Eroicaaa...
Erotica.
Kolby Villanueva Hey, if you wanna hear REAL Beethoven's "Erotica" you should try listening his ariette "Der Kuss" it's erotic poem, really, it's cool:-)
6:13 any LoZ fan hear something familiar?
2:01 Beethoven's ballet, The Creatures Of Prometheus.
so satisfying
Cool graphics.
I also have finale, how do I do this?
See www.musanim.com/HowTo/
@@smalin ah, I see. Thank you.
4:13 to 4:53 is 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
0:17 is my personal favorite
Agreed
I don’t really like classical music but this song is good.👍
I love all these videos, thanks for making! How did you make them?
I wrote software. You can read about the project at my website. This page in particular might answer your question: www.musanim.com/ProductionNotes/synchronization.html
Cool, I'll check it out, thanks!
4:12
Listen to Osmo Vänska's interpretation with the Minnesota Orchestra. The whole thing is incredible, but this passage is so damn powerful, yet controlled! You can just hear the hero struggle against fate and overcome it like Beethoven did when he wrote this masterpiece of a Symphony that changed all of music!
Great final movement Eroic
@@pcgamingftw5694 Osmo’s interpretation is one of my absolute favorites! He’s so controlled and clinical, yet he can lay it down pretty good when it comes to powerful passages like that. His Beethoven cycle is my reference of sorts. There are more elegant cycles (Wand’s is amazing), more lively ones (Chailly’s), but overall Vanska is consistently outstanding and flawless.
If you put it at .5, that is what our concert speed is currently at
i can put this when on our school radio if theres a parade😊
Please upload
8:12 and 10:56 napoleon at the zenit of power.
COMO SE HACE LA MUSICA SINFONICA.LA CLAVE ES SU desarrollo,como lo es en la vida misma y en una flor.La música no es como la pintura, que se aprecia su belleza, prácticamente en el acto, no es asi, en la música sinfónica que precisa de un desarrollo lo más intenso posible, al objeto de disfrazar,de difuminar en lo máximo posible, la tónica, es decr, el motivo,tema,semilla, frase del inicio de la sinfonía, que pueden ser 3-4 notas como sucede en esta sinfonía y en la 5 sinf. de Sibelius que son unas notas que deberán ser desarrolladas, como un recién nacido,bebe,niño, joven adolescente. maduro...ec.A a excepción de estas pocas notas iniciales, vendrá el tema, luego el desarrollo y posteriormente la reexposición.ESTE ESQUEMA QUE ES el de la sonata, TAMBIÉN podrá variar algo con el tiempo, añadiendo un nuevo movimiento y poco más, salvo en la música del período1950 en adelante.COMO HACE EL COMPOSITOR PARA DESARROLARLA. en otra ocasión se indicará.
How do you do these visual videos with the music? It's so interesting to watch it go exactly to the music like a dance. A Beethoven ballet!
I wrote software to do it.
does someone have the time for the Poco Andante?
never mind! it starts somewhere around 6:21
Heard in Baby Beethoven
same dude
Same here man
mi sol, mi ré, fa la, fa mi...
4:15 is great