To be honest I really touched... At first I thought EXO would stop the Chinese versions of songs after some time but this proved me wrong. I'm really happy that EXO never stopped singing in Chinese and even though the Korean members doesn't know Chinese they would learn it for us. Thank you EXO for your hard work! WE ARE ONE!!! EXO FIGHTING!!!💕💕💕
If only people watched EXO-M more. All these EXO-K M/V's with millions of views, while Exo M has only a few Million and even less sometimes. It makes me sad.
Next time, SM should give the talented Lay more lines. 1. Because he has a very beautiful voice (and a lot of dancing skills) 2. He is chinese, therefore he should sing more in the chinese version! I love you YiXing!!!! Will always support you!!!
actually....i am not sure if you know about Lay's clotting disorder. Before he joined exo he actually had a vocal surgery and had a major bleeding. Lay prefered singing than dancing but because of the surgery he couldn't sing that much and therefore he decided to focus on dancing.....
LAY BEGINNING THIS SONG WOW VERY NICEU CHANYEOL NEXT OMAIGAD BAEEEEKKKKK SO BAEEE SUHO OH SO SWEET MY CHENCHEN UGH OMG THAT VOICE O.O MINSEOK WHUT WHUT WHUT *hyperventilates* D.O MY HONEY VOICED MAN JONGIN AREN'T YOU COLD?! SEHUNNIE I STILL LAUGH WITH THAT SPACE SCENE I CAN'T OMFG RIP ME.
Go and look up the meaning of the song (search "whale astronauts poem" or something like that) and click on iheardyoulikekpop and then scroll down till you find the post about the possible meaning of this song. I promise you you won't be laughing at Sehun or the whale anymore once you're done reading it.
Omfg why is this so sad? I miss Lu, Tao, and Kris... This melody is so beautiful and nostalgic, it makes me remember their first winter album, ''Miracles in December'', even when there was no miracle for EXO in 2014, let's keep supporting them forever EXO-L's!
Usually there is a bigger like in the Chinese version when it comes to Ballads like Baby Don't Cry but it got more noticeable when Miracles in December came and they loved the ballad with Chen, Luhan and Baekhyun
Jenifer Triminio Yeah, for me Luhan and Chen voice are so beautiful together, that's why "what is love" chinese version is one of my favourite songs of all the time :c I miss Luhan voice so much, but not alone, with Chen
The whale concept was derived from the a whale called Alice aka ‘The Loneliest Whale in the World’, who is an unidentified whale species, being the only whale emitting a call at 52-hertz.Even any of his kind hear him, he doesn't stop singing. The astronaut concept was derived from the story of the astronaut who spent 48 minutes in his spaceship and coming back saying that those 48 minutes were the longest and most loneliest of mankind. This Mv tells us how they were about to separate in hard times, how they thought about giving up, how they missed old times, but when two lonely,.astronaut and whale find each other, members getting ONE again, there is also a poem about astronaut and whale meeting in space. Astronaut shows the way of ocean to whale to find his home again. One of this symbol is Exo-L and other is Exo. Exo-L rescued them from separating, didn't let them give up. And Exo ll always sing for Exo-L even we hear, or not.
I was so happy because I heard our precious Yixing's voice at the very beginning then he also sang a small part at the middle and I was like that's it?! I didn't even hear his voice in the Korean version yet, he has very short lines here, he deserved more parts here because he's the one who's Chinese, if you want our unicorn to stay, treat him nicely, fair and square.
Xiumin Sehun also got one line each video. even less than Lay. Staying or not should not depend on lines given. He is missing all EXO activities other than what he likes. You should ask who is actually treating whom bad. Lay is treating EXO like shit
+Hola Mosi well, not starting a fight tho, He's not treating EXO like sht, SME also tells him to do solo activities to promote EXO in China. He cares for the members. And yes, Xiumin and Sehun got very short lines but the fact that he's Chinese and got short lines is not fair.
SME never wanted him to go by himself to China and do everything just for himself. It is very against SME's direction and the fact that he even missed Japan dome concerts for debut was seriously criticized by SME and Japanese fans alike. He is so selfish and irresponsible. I wouldnt mind him leaving.
+Hola Mosi srsly, SME wanted him to promote in China, for EXO to gain more fans and popularity there! And are you even a real fan? Because if you are, you wouldn't want any of them to leave. And EXO won't sLAY without LAY.
DONT GET ME WRONG I MISS ALL 3 OF THE EX MEMBERS BUT LUHAN'S VOICE ALWAYS SOUNDS TO GORGEOUS WITH THESE KINDS OF SONGS IMAGINE HIS SOFT VOICE SINGING THIS I AM RIOTING
Wow Kai's part actually fcked me up really bad This whole song wrecked me up really bad but holy shit I still can't get over Kai's part wtf they have wonderful voices!
I think SM should let Lay showing up more in each mv; his shots are far less than other members, it is really unfair. T_T Lay is worth being paid attention to.
to CEO Kim, thank you for clarifying some things regarding Lay personal studio and solo activities in China. to all members of EXO, thank you for supporting Lay
Wow, their pronounciations improve a lot. I can finally understand them without reading on the lyrics. CY surprised me, didn't expect him to be this good. DO on the other hand is practically a native. Lay, you are
Everytime they release new songs of Chinese verson, their pronounciation of Mardarin become better. This time I can listen almost every word and understand without reading the lyrics! I'm so proud of my boys
1-MAMA 86 m 2-Power 84m 3-History 84m 4-Lucky one 70m 5-Miracles in December 52m 6-Universe 44m 7-Sing for you 38m 8-What is love 36m 9-For life 27m 10-Electric kiss 26m 11-Coming over 8m 12- Dancing king 55 m 13- Light saber 20 m
GUYS!! The whale doesn't represent former members at all. It represent EXO members and the astronaut represent US, EXO-Ls. This is talking about the 52 hertz whale called Alice or "The loneliest Whale of the world" and the Astronaut (Michael something I think..) who spend 48 mins in his spaceship and who came back saying that It was the longest and loneliest 48 min in the world. If you still can get It, there's also a poem about an astronaut who met a whale that was lost and he show her how to go back home. We are the astronaut who helped EXO (the whale) to be one and not give up, so they will sing for us (title, sing for you) even if we don't Hear them (52 hertz whale) bc we saved them. I hope you understand.
+кιм мιиѕєσк lιттlє вασzι ("Nada ktaibe") heh heh BTS made a song called whalien 52 and its based on this lol anyways what you said is actually really clever.
Sasha Xiong Yes I know, I'm an ARMY too xD But the meaning of the whale in my theory of “Sing for you” even though it's the loneliest whale in the world too, the meaning isn't same at all
+tegoshin RIght! I get so upset because when you look up any EXO song, only the Korean version comes up. I enjoy both versions but I prefer the Chinese version because I speak a little. I just wish the chinese versions would get more appreciation.
My own opinion: First, Popularity and achievements are from their fans. You streamed their songs multiple times, watched their mvs and buy their albums. Meanwhile, we don't care about any of that. Yes, we do care about our faves achievements and we do try to make them win by voting but not to the point that we're going to waste our time watching the same my for an hour or so. They don't force us too. They remind us that we have a life aside from them. Second, recognition is also based on popularity. My faves get recognised because of their talents. Their vocals, their sense of style, their versatile acting, their dance styles. They have a life beside shitloads of comebacks and our faves can stand alone without the help of their members. For example: EXO Baekhyun could be BYUN BAEKHYUN as a soloist, as an actor, a luxury brand ambassador. And I'm proud to say that this is what EXO taught us. We didn't have so many views in an my bcs they always remind us that we should focus on ourselves first or study first than watching their ig lives, them who always tell us to buy foods instead of alburns, and most especially having their own unique talent in their solo activities with us making us all proud as EXO-LS
Why do Chinese version of Exo songs are so underrated? The Korean version has around 1,800,000 views and this only has almost 500,000? In my opinion, this sounds better than the Korean version, and Chen's lines slayed, as well as Sehun and Lay!
Dear Yixing, please bear in your mind that you are precious and you have done nothing wrong to either the EXO members nor EXO-Ls so please stop saying you're sorry. Also please take care of yourself and know that we, EXO-Ls will never forget you and we love you so much.
I got the biggest smile on my face when Kai started dancing (like always) but then I got sad when Chanyeol and Suho were fighting, then I went to happy again when the camera cut to Kai and now I am an emotional rollarcoaster
作詞：周煒傑 作曲：Matthew Tishler/Felicia Barton/Aaron Benward 我指尖吉他的節拍 染上寂寞的純白 今天要把未完的故事說完 心事堆積成了雪 哼成歌對你思念 你能否聽見 I'll sing for you 可能太畏懼失敗 說不出對你的愛 深怕表白, 你會消失人海 我終於鼓起勇氣 坦白這一秘密 就算你不在意 I'll sing for you The way you cry the way you smile 你入鏡的畫面刻在我腦海 想說的愛, 說不出的愛 若現在我告白 就請你聆聽 I'll sing for you sing for you sing for you 多想得到你微笑答案 請別笑我太無趣 我的世界只有你 其實我不像別人灑脫 當你慢慢靠近我 多想要擁你入懷 融化這季節 零下的孤單 The way you cry the way you smile 你入鏡的畫面刻在我腦海 轉身只會總留下遺憾 都怪我不勇敢 請遙遠聆聽 I’ll Sing for you Sing for you 你會有天明白我的愛 感謝命運的奇跡 引我來遇見你 你是我最美奇跡 可能在今夜後 我又變成懦弱的我 所以今天一定要對你說出口 請用心去聆聽 The way you cry the way you smile 你入鏡的畫面 刻在我腦海 想說的愛, 說不出的愛 若現在說出來 這一刻對你說 只想你聆聽 I’ll Sing for you, Sing for you 只想你聆聽 I’ll Sing for you
I'm not gonna lie, I stopped supporting exo after luhan left the group. I'm not even an exo-l anymore and I don't know if I could call myself an exo-l since I stop being there for them. But everytime I see their mv out, I can't help myself but click it. And the fact that I'm able to differentiate their voices made me remember how much I loved them
Meaning you love EXO, but you were there only for Luhan, not the meaning of being an EXO-L, you know... I know that you left EXO for that reason but what about before... It was only for Luhan... But see what you've missed? Sorry if it looks too offensive... I just can't help but feel bad, everyone is so different... It's hard to accept anything...
+JAJA Lu I know your feel tho. The moment I found out about Exo, just after Tao became my bias.... he left... but I didn't stop supporting them. I support all of them. Exo need us. But yeah Luhan ... I guess you were Luhan biased , It's hard to aceept every thing like Meow Meow said #9InMyEyesBut12InMyHeart
Hearing every exo songs one by one...after every song I feel like this song song would be my favorite one...but when I hear the next one..all the songs are my favorite..they enter deep into my heart....
I wish some EXOLs will stop bringing the ones who left back, don't get me wrong, i still support KrisHan (not Tao, personal reasons) but i don't think it's right to keep mentioning them that much in every EXO comeback. This is EXO now💗, you guys should move on already and also it would be great if you'll stop comparing Lay's voice to Luhan's, they don't sound the same and tbvh it's kinda annoying to read comments like that. You are remembering Luhan through Lay's voice? That sounds wrong in many ways. Yixing is Yixing and Han is Han so stop comparing them. Gorgeous MV😿👌💕🐳.
THANK YOU for writing it, my thoughts were just the same. For me Yixing's voice is so unique, I don't understand how people hear Luhan in that voice. And the past should be left in the past, let's look forward now for a wonderful future with 9 precious boys that we have.
i used to not support Tao too, for some reasons. but after all i realized he's innocent. i really feeled guilty. maybe u should read tge truth , and watch some interviews !
CAN PEOPLE STOP MENTIONING LAY WITH LUHAN? I have nothing against luhan, but people keep saying that Lay's voice sounds like Luhan! I can't believe people are saying that they want luhan to sing it instead of lay. Not only I think Lay has a very unique voice that is different from Luhan's (Maybe only real fans could tell), but it's just wrong to mention ex members everywhere. Lay being the only chinese member left is not recieving the respect he deserves. If you ACTUALLY miss Luhan he has so many solo promotions even a non fan know about, I know people are sad that kris tao and luhan left but we're supposed to be happy about exo's comeback and excited about the members but everyone's talking about the ex members instead of people who stayed with exo...
+Kim-Jung KimySeok I heard the similarity when I first became an exo fan but I know they are completely different now so I don't get why they keep bringing up them. It's like when people kept saying tao kept sounding like kris when rapping. Lay is Lay and Tao is Tao.
I just have one question. How does that girl manage to dump 10 guys that are all my babies? I can barely say "no" to fangirling over them. BUT SHE MANAGES TO SAY, "I'm breaking up with her" I wanna applause her for having that courage and bravery. But at the same time she's like evil for doing that.
It’s the 2nd year in a row for EXO-Ls without an winter special album… at least we will get a song from Baek tomorrow. But I really miss the winter special. Also because Universe got me into EXO 🥺🥺❤️❤️
GO GO LAY!!!! LAY FIGHTING!!!! WO AI NI ZHANG YIXING!!
+EunLoveForever wo ai ni* "ni men" means u all
+Ying Girl refer
+EunLoveForever Just "wo ai ni" is enough :)
aww hahaha thanks guys.. sorry.edited done. :)
Wo ai ni Yixing ge :3
I respect Lay even more each day... :) He's not my bias, but I fully support him. GO BOY! S[LAY] them all!!!
he is not my bias , but he is perfect and sweet ♡ uri Lay ♡
same, he's not my bias, but he's my husband hahahaha (srry)
same,but he is my bias
He is my one beautiful bias and thank all of you guys for supporting this beautiful hearted hardworking Unicorn 🙏
+Nidya F Huang same
Damn...does EXO EVER have a happy Christmas?
They're jamming with Dear Santa
right... they r always crying every time they realize a song.... 😞😞
I wanted to cry when i listen to this
+Snooopid P hahahaha
i don't think so
Lay's voice is gift from above
To be honest I really touched... At first I thought EXO would stop the Chinese versions of songs after some time but this proved me wrong. I'm really happy that EXO never stopped singing in Chinese and even though the Korean members doesn't know Chinese they would learn it for us. Thank you EXO for your hard work! WE ARE ONE!!! EXO FIGHTING!!!💕💕💕
I'm* sorry got to excited😅
same 😮😍
If only people watched EXO-M more. All these EXO-K M/V's with millions of views, while Exo M has only a few Million and even less sometimes. It makes me sad.
Next time, SM should give the talented Lay more lines.
1. Because he has a very beautiful voice (and a lot of dancing skills)
2. He is chinese, therefore he should sing more in the chinese version!
I love you YiXing!!!! Will always support you!!!
+UnicornLene Desu i'm agreed with you. they should give Lay more lines. :D.
+UnicornLene Desu yesss. i love his voice
+Sugarbabii27 I agree~ Have you heard his solo songs?! If not, I recommend you all to listen too "One Person". His vocal, omg!!!!
actually....i am not sure if you know about Lay's clotting disorder. Before he joined exo he actually had a vocal surgery and had a major bleeding. Lay prefered singing than dancing but because of the surgery he couldn't sing that much and therefore he decided to focus on dancing.....
+pinyao Lu I know about his coagulation disorder, but I don't think it's therefore. I'm pretty sure.
Thank You SM for giving Suho more lines, his voice is so sweet and this song allow him to showcase it.
i know ritee xD his voice really suit this song >< and on the snow also, suho sings really welll >\\\
Xiumin too
And in the other songs too! he has more lines than his usual two
Ambar J I know I heard it I was so happy that end up crying.
he wort it
中文發音真的唱得太棒了!!!!!!!!!! 大家的中文都進步得好快!!!!!
Chen's voice is so amazing
just as usual . he's the best
+shaymaa qassim exactly: )
chen is wonderful!!!!!
+LibraButterfly1 not just his voice... He is completely amazing.
+frantastique chenmi(≧∇≦)/
I didn't expect my Lay to begin the song--
*I am dead*
ikr same lol Lay sLAYing
+Chanyeol Erin hahahah
Oh no!!! You're dead? Which means
... YOUR GHOST IS THE COMMENTER!!! *Paranoid*
+adriana dann wow didnt know he began the song thanks this sounds better than the korean version
+adriana dann why??
SM SEHUNS VOICE IS SO BEAUTIFUL PLEASE DONT HIDE THIS FROM US! WE REALLY APPRECIATE HIS VOICE SO PLEASE LET SEHUN SING MORE!
Sehun is trying his hard to learn Chinese .
Besides I think he will get more line in chinese ver. But I can even find him…:(
+游啊游, 魚兒in galaxy can't…
+yoongi bear when did he sing? i didn't quite hear his voice
Ziyan Zhang
1:34 i think!
+yoongi bear no 1:34 is kai's voice !!
sehun's vioce is 1:25
Lay's voice reminds me of orange soda somehow. So warm, nice and fresh at the same time....
LAY BEGINNING THIS SONG WOW VERY NICEU
CHANYEOL NEXT OMAIGAD
BAEEEEKKKKK SO BAEEE
SUHO OH SO SWEET
MY CHENCHEN UGH OMG THAT VOICE
O.O MINSEOK WHUT WHUT WHUT *hyperventilates*
D.O MY HONEY VOICED MAN
JONGIN AREN'T YOU COLD?!
SEHUNNIE I STILL LAUGH WITH THAT SPACE SCENE I CAN'T OMFG
RIP ME.
SOMEBODY NEEDS TO DO SOMETHING ABOUT THAT SUHO X CHANYEOL THANG. SERIOUSLY FIGHT GOALS.
+장미차 fight goals 😂exactly 😂👏
Go and look up the meaning of the song (search "whale astronauts poem" or something like that) and click on iheardyoulikekpop and then scroll down till you find the post about the possible meaning of this song. I promise you you won't be laughing at Sehun or the whale anymore once you're done reading it.
+Manon Jann I saw that post before watching the videos and I can't help but cry waterfalls right now D'x
Manon Jann Thank you for the tip!! I'll definitely check that out!!
Omfg why is this so sad? I miss Lu, Tao, and Kris...
This melody is so beautiful and nostalgic, it makes me remember their first winter album, ''Miracles in December'', even when there was no miracle for EXO in 2014, let's keep supporting them forever EXO-L's!
indeed..this song is soo emotional..i cried.. i miss them.. i miss them
Miss them too
I miss them too😿💔
+Tickle my Minhoe MISS THEM AS MUCH AS HELL .... :'( :'( FIGHTING FOR OT12 TILL THE END !!!!
Chinese versions always underrated gaaad, i'm the only who love more exo songs with Chinese versions? xD
you are not alone xD
I like their mellow songs in Chinese more :')
i always prefer chinese version more... i'm jongin stan btw
Usually there is a bigger like in the Chinese version when it comes to Ballads like Baby Don't Cry but it got more noticeable when Miracles in December came and they loved the ballad with Chen, Luhan and Baekhyun
Jenifer Triminio Yeah, for me Luhan and Chen voice are so beautiful together, that's why "what is love" chinese version is one of my favourite songs of all the time :c I miss Luhan voice so much, but not alone, with Chen
This sounds so much better than the korean version.
ikr!
Monique both sound good
Don't compare the same song from a same group
Just different language nothing else😒
@@laureakaashisrana9852 I actually chinese versions/language are powerful when it comes to this genres
好了一点就可以吗很喜茶
The whale concept was derived from the a whale called Alice aka ‘The Loneliest Whale in the World’, who is an unidentified whale species, being the only whale emitting a call at 52-hertz.Even any of his kind hear him, he doesn't stop singing. The astronaut concept was derived from the story of the astronaut who spent 48 minutes in his spaceship and coming back saying that those 48 minutes were the longest and most loneliest of mankind. This Mv tells us how they were about to separate in hard times, how they thought about giving up, how they missed old times, but when two lonely,.astronaut and whale find each other, members getting ONE again, there is also a poem about astronaut and whale meeting in space. Astronaut shows the way of ocean to whale to find his home again. One of this symbol is Exo-L and other is Exo. Exo-L rescued them from separating, didn't let them give up. And Exo ll always sing for Exo-L even we hear, or not.
👌🏽
Your theory is the best among what I have read so far
+LOL ikr
Idk why but your comment made me cry :(
+LOL aah thank you 🙏😊
to be honest as a suyeol fan this mv has allowed me to rest in peace
+plumsweet me too..i'm suyeol shipper lol
my qianxi!!! Omggg
I'm Suyeol Shipper!!
It's so rare to see tf fans on a EXO MV OMG
+Selena Zheng tf boys are so cute! even tho not a fan
omg i was so scared there wouldn't be a chinese version HALLELUJAH
I know right?? I'm so happy ;_;
When I listen to this song. I miss EXO 12 members....
+Izayoi Sakamaki yeah me too ):
Same;-; i always cry when i listen to this;;;;
me too..;w;
same(T ^ T)
3:54 a rare photo of me and sehun.
+ellie yip (elliexpika) lol
+ellie yip (elliexpika) WHALE hello there
+ellie yip (elliexpika) he even sang for you ;)
+EXO Forever that was sweet :)
iam sooo jealous. lucky u
Minseok sounded so beautiful when he sang!! GIVE HIM MORE LINES PLEASE
Where's his line ?
+Meiily BBL the last line of the first time they sing the chorus
ikr
+Meiily BBL 1:30 is Xiumin~
Thank u ! You're right, his voice is so beautiful ! He really deserves more lines ! (And sorry for my bad english)
I was so happy because I heard our precious Yixing's voice at the very beginning then he also sang a small part at the middle and I was like that's it?! I didn't even hear his voice in the Korean version yet, he has very short lines here, he deserved more parts here because he's the one who's Chinese, if you want our unicorn to stay, treat him nicely, fair and square.
He has only like 1 line in the Korean vers..
Xiumin Sehun also got one line each video. even less than Lay. Staying or not should not depend on lines given. He is missing all EXO activities other than what he likes. You should ask who is actually treating whom bad. Lay is treating EXO like shit
+Hola Mosi well, not starting a fight tho, He's not treating EXO like sht, SME also tells him to do solo activities to promote EXO in China. He cares for the members. And yes, Xiumin and Sehun got very short lines but the fact that he's Chinese and got short lines is not fair.
SME never wanted him to go by himself to China and do everything just for himself. It is very against SME's direction and the fact that he even missed Japan dome concerts for debut was seriously criticized by SME and Japanese fans alike. He is so selfish and irresponsible. I wouldnt mind him leaving.
+Hola Mosi srsly, SME wanted him to promote in China, for EXO to gain more fans and popularity there! And are you even a real fan? Because if you are, you wouldn't want any of them to leave. And EXO won't sLAY without LAY.
Yixing's voice melt me
DONT GET ME WRONG I MISS ALL 3 OF THE EX MEMBERS BUT LUHAN'S VOICE ALWAYS SOUNDS TO GORGEOUS WITH THESE KINDS OF SONGS IMAGINE HIS SOFT VOICE SINGING THIS I AM RIOTING
as a Luhan biased, I FEEL YOU 😭
+Annaliese Bain BUT ALSO BE HAPPY FOR HIM AND EXO BOTH ARE SO SUCCESSFUL BE HAPPY I'LL SING FOR YOUU lol
+Kim Minseok OF COURSE I'M HAPPY FOR MY LOVE HE IS HAPPY AND HEALTHY NOW MY BOY :'^))
Wow
Kai's part actually fcked me up really bad
This whole song wrecked me up really bad but holy shit I still can't get over Kai's part wtf they have wonderful voices!
OMG I KNOWWW! ❤️😍
Kai is kind of an all rounder isn't he? He can rap, he can sing, AND HE CAN SURE AS HELL DANCE!!!!
Amen sister. Kai is just perfect
Agree!! It didn't just amaze me how great his voice is but also his Chinese pronunciation too. Perfect❤︎
Am I the only one who think a beaten up Chanyeol looks absolutely gorgeous?
definitely ha
Same
hahahahaha hell yeah 😉❤❤
I wish it was not true but he looks frickin sexy
+Mahnoor Amjad too damn georgeous
exo chinese winter songs always hit different 😭😭 THE WAY YOU CRY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
chen✨lay✨xiumin✨
bir Türk korecan
+MISS A AND IC korecan demeyelim de sadece SMstan'ım ^^
+Aysegul Yesilyurt I love this comment. You make me cry. Chen Lay Xiumin
+Aysegul Yesilyurt o.k
Unnie love you all girls
Lay's voice is perfection
Their diction is really perfect for this song. I never like their Chinese versions due to their pronunciation, but this song really prove me wrong.
me too
Agree!
Ikr? I think it's also because it's a slower song, I applaud their improvements. So proud haha
i am so agree wif u!!!
i am so agree wif u!!!
LAY YiXing 's voice is really sweet. Support him!!!
'icing for yooouuu'
lool
Mah gawd dat wuz such a coincidence
made my day lol
so happy I saw this!
每一次一唱到 the way you cry 開始，我就有种雞皮疙瘩的感覺，很感動的一首歌，真的很好聽，非常適合在夜晚，一個人熄了燈靜靜地聆聽。
每次聽到那裡淚就飆了QQ
+JXjiajia 他們中文真的進步好多啊...聽著聽著默默就哭了...
+Joyce Chen 我也是
I think SM should let Lay showing up more in each mv; his shots are far less than other members, it is really unfair. T_T
Lay is worth being paid attention to.
to CEO Kim, thank you for clarifying some things regarding Lay personal studio and solo activities in China. to all members of EXO, thank you for supporting Lay
Wow, their pronounciations improve a lot. I can finally understand them without reading on the lyrics. CY surprised me, didn't expect him to be this good. DO on the other hand is practically a native. Lay, you are
Everytime they release new songs of Chinese verson, their pronounciation of Mardarin become better. This time I can listen almost every word and understand without reading the lyrics! I'm so proud of my boys
*pronunciation
I wish I can read and understand Mandarin 😓🌸
Kylie A just learn it like sehun kkk he'd improved a lot:)
I love Yixing's voice
2023 and i still want exo to release more chinese versions of their songs. praying for a winter album with chinese track.
I like to listen to their winter songs to fall asleep❤ 特别安心
1-MAMA 86 m
2-Power 84m
3-History 84m
4-Lucky one 70m
5-Miracles in December 52m
6-Universe 44m
7-Sing for you 38m
8-What is love 36m
9-For life 27m
10-Electric kiss 26m
11-Coming over 8m
12- Dancing king 55 m
13- Light saber 20 m
GUYS!! The whale doesn't represent former members at all. It represent EXO members and the astronaut represent US, EXO-Ls. This is talking about the 52 hertz whale called Alice or "The loneliest Whale of the world" and the Astronaut (Michael something I think..) who spend 48 mins in his spaceship and who came back saying that It was the longest and loneliest 48 min in the world. If you still can get It, there's also a poem about an astronaut who met a whale that was lost and he show her how to go back home. We are the astronaut who helped EXO (the whale) to be one and not give up, so they will sing for us (title, sing for you) even if we don't Hear them (52 hertz whale) bc we saved them. I hope you understand.
These are just assumptions right? Cause it's not confirmed by SM or EXO.
+Claudia Oviedo This is just a theory
+кιм мιиѕєσк lιттlє вασzι ("Nada ktaibe") It part connects with the poem, as the song is about being alone and heartbroken.
+кιм мιиѕєσк lιттlє вασzι ("Nada ktaibe") heh heh BTS made a song called whalien 52 and its based on this lol anyways what you said is actually really clever.
Sasha Xiong Yes I know, I'm an ARMY too xD But the meaning of the whale in my theory of “Sing for you” even though it's the loneliest whale in the world too, the meaning isn't same at all
In the middle of 2023 I still hear it and it makes me cry
Lay's voice is so beautiful and he has improved his singing a lot.keep going better and better. always love you,yixing.
Did anyone cried while watching both MVs???
me 😭😭
+Ain Arianie u r not alone!!!😂😂
+Delin Woo . i think there will have tsunami soon because our cry 😭😭😂
+Delin Woo *tears 😂
*sniffles* Yup
This song will never not be dreamy
Lay's Voice at the start is just so soft and sweet I almost fell asleep listening to it.
English version too please ;d
Agreed!
YAAAAS
agree 1000%
omg yesssss
yeah pls
STARLIGHT here to support EXO :
same VIXX
I'm ELF and Support EXO^^
Thank you 😘❤️
thanks💖
Thank you so much dear :)
+Anna Cheonsa thank youuu♥♥♥
Same as me !! I'm ELF too
One and only kpop band in the world forever exo-l
the way you cry .. the way you smile 😢😩
The feels the feels this song is my song for EXO m.... the loving memory of exo M
ya, me too
Yixing's and Luhan's voices are really so similar my heart flipped flopped while imagining Luhan in this Mv. Its so sad x 100 I love Exo❤️
i love lay i feel like he is so sweet
Lay is perfection! I love the mandarin versions bc I get to hear Lay's voice more!!! Fighting Exo love it!!!!! And DO I love you!!!!!
Those people who are not clicking this version should be regretting that they missed this beautiful version & also more lines for lay LOL
hahaha true! Lay at the beginning tho T·T
+vivi potatoes If you look up Exo sing for you, the chinese version doesn't even come T^T
And the meaning of lyrics.. Both versions are excellent but Chinese ver killed me
+tegoshin RIght! I get so upset because when you look up any EXO song, only the Korean version comes up. I enjoy both versions but I prefer the Chinese version because I speak a little. I just wish the chinese versions would get more appreciation.
+tegoshin I agree. It doesn't move. Its great tho
My own opinion:
First, Popularity and achievements are from their fans. You streamed their songs multiple times, watched their mvs and buy their albums. Meanwhile, we don't care about any of that. Yes, we do care about our faves achievements and we do try to make them win by voting but not to the point that we're going to waste our time watching the same my for an hour or so. They don't force us too. They remind us that we have a life aside from them.
Second, recognition is also based on popularity. My faves get recognised because of their talents. Their vocals, their sense of style, their versatile acting, their dance styles. They have a life beside shitloads of comebacks and our faves can stand alone without the help of their members. For example: EXO Baekhyun could be BYUN BAEKHYUN as a soloist, as an actor, a luxury brand ambassador.
And I'm proud to say that this is what EXO taught us. We didn't have so many views in an my bcs they always remind us that we should focus on ourselves first or study first than watching their ig lives, them who always tell us to buy foods instead of alburns, and most especially having their own unique talent in their solo activities with us making us all proud as EXO-LS
EXO songs will be playing on the moon in 2024^^
*The galaxy represents Kris*
*Fighting represents Tao*
*Basketball represents Luhan*
*Plus they lost a lot*
#SingForYou
Love you EXO! 😊
kris represents raper lol
Okay, I'm gonna cry now. I didn't expect my journey as a Baby EXO-L would have more tears than not. 😭
Why do Chinese version of Exo songs are so underrated? The Korean version has around 1,800,000 views and this only has almost 500,000? In my opinion, this sounds better than the Korean version, and Chen's lines slayed, as well as Sehun and Lay!
yixing voice makes me smile...
EXO GO!
Please continue to support Exo and Lay even though he have his individual schedule in China.
first I had Jungkook and Suga fighting
NOW SUHO AND CHANYEOL?! so many 'fights' between members 😂
ikr
Yes .. ;-;
+Hannia St Call me sadist for liking them, because the fighting scenes are so... touching.
Yes ;-; My heart hurts.
Yeshhh its so sad
Dear Yixing, please bear in your mind that you are precious and you have done nothing wrong to either the EXO members nor EXO-Ls so please stop saying you're sorry. Also please take care of yourself and know that we, EXO-Ls will never forget you and we love you so much.
This is so beautiful and sad, I love it!! Chanyeol's voice just killed me, so perfect!!!
it"s 2023 and I still miss EXO-M 😢
Can I just say chen's pronunciation has improved so much~~ chenchennnnnnnnn ~~~
I got the biggest smile on my face when Kai started dancing (like always) but then I got sad when Chanyeol and Suho were fighting, then I went to happy again when the camera cut to Kai and now I am an emotional rollarcoaster
needs more lay. please! better yet the whole song as his solo. it suits his voice so well!
They're just so unbelievably talented, I love them so much
Sing For You (为你而唱)'s Chinese lyrics is so much better than before!!!!!!!!!!!
Mr.周煒杰, Thank you for the beautiful lyrics!!
Exo makes me so soft, awww.
Chen ' s sound is amazing 😍😍😍😍
Lay just sLAYed this song. My bias didn't let anyone down. Lay, Exo, FIGHTING!!! (Lay and Chanyeol biased)
作詞：周煒傑 作曲：Matthew Tishler/Felicia Barton/Aaron Benward
我指尖吉他的節拍 染上寂寞的純白
今天要把未完的故事說完
心事堆積成了雪 哼成歌對你思念
你能否聽見
I'll sing for you
可能太畏懼失敗 說不出對你的愛
深怕表白, 你會消失人海
我終於鼓起勇氣 坦白這一秘密
就算你不在意
I'll sing for you
The way you cry the way you smile
你入鏡的畫面刻在我腦海
想說的愛, 說不出的愛
若現在我告白 就請你聆聽
I'll sing for you sing for you
sing for you
多想得到你微笑答案
請別笑我太無趣 我的世界只有你
其實我不像別人灑脫
當你慢慢靠近我 多想要擁你入懷
融化這季節 零下的孤單
The way you cry the way you smile
你入鏡的畫面刻在我腦海
轉身只會總留下遺憾
都怪我不勇敢 請遙遠聆聽
I’ll Sing for you
Sing for you
你會有天明白我的愛
感謝命運的奇跡 引我來遇見你
你是我最美奇跡
可能在今夜後 我又變成懦弱的我
所以今天一定要對你說出口
請用心去聆聽
The way you cry the way you smile
你入鏡的畫面 刻在我腦海
想說的愛, 說不出的愛
若現在說出來 這一刻對你說
只想你聆聽
I’ll Sing for you, Sing for you
只想你聆聽
I’ll Sing for you
You're still singing to us and I'm still listening to you
I'm not gonna lie, I stopped supporting exo after luhan left the group. I'm not even an exo-l anymore and I don't know if I could call myself an exo-l since I stop being there for them. But everytime I see their mv out, I can't help myself but click it. And the fact that I'm able to differentiate their voices made me remember how much I loved them
Meaning you love EXO, but you were there only for Luhan, not the meaning of being an EXO-L, you know... I know that you left EXO for that reason but what about before... It was only for Luhan... But see what you've missed? Sorry if it looks too offensive... I just can't help but feel bad, everyone is so different... It's hard to accept anything...
+JAJA Lu I know your feel tho. The moment I found out about Exo, just after Tao became my bias.... he left...
but I didn't stop supporting them. I support all of them. Exo need us. But yeah Luhan ... I guess you were Luhan biased , It's hard to aceept every thing like Meow Meow said #9InMyEyesBut12InMyHeart
***** Lay? I hope he doesn't leave Exo ;_; He's such a kind soul. If he leaves, I won't know what to with SM ...
SOO...are you gonna support EXO now...or just gonna leave?
I feel the same way 😂
🥹🥹第一次听，第一次看MV的時候，我還是个初中生。晃眼這麼多年過去了，還是很好聽啊🤗🥺
🥺💗💗
such a sad song! i miss kris and luhan :(
and tao ;(
i miss ot12
me too.
And before I watch this MV I've watch a lot of KrisYoel OPV. OMG and then Exo's show time make me cry again
#tao :c
LAY张艺兴,加油!!!!虽然只有你一个华人的队员在EXO不过你都坚持那么久了,我们都希望你不要放弃。EXO,WE ARE ONE!!!!!LAY加油!FIGHTING!GAMBATEH!!!
😭
It made me cry a little bit harder than the Korean version. I need my daily dose of Yixing. I want him back, well and ready to be his best.
HAPPY EXOL DAY!
layyyyyyyyyyyyyy needs more lines
Xingie He sings so good lmao
Hearing every exo songs one by one...after every song I feel like this song song would be my favorite one...but when I hear the next one..all the songs are my favorite..they enter deep into my heart....
I wish some EXOLs will stop bringing the ones who left back, don't get me wrong, i still support KrisHan (not Tao, personal reasons) but i don't think it's right to keep mentioning them that much in every EXO comeback. This is EXO now💗, you guys should move on already and also it would be great if you'll stop comparing Lay's voice to Luhan's, they don't sound the same and tbvh it's kinda annoying to read comments like that. You are remembering Luhan through Lay's voice? That sounds wrong in many ways. Yixing is Yixing and Han is Han so stop comparing them.
Gorgeous MV😿👌💕🐳.
Awh :( why not support tao?
THANK YOU for writing it, my thoughts were just the same. For me Yixing's voice is so unique, I don't understand how people hear Luhan in that voice. And the past should be left in the past, let's look forward now for a wonderful future with 9 precious boys that we have.
+LadyLu0620 I agree with you 100% I think you are my soulmate ;D (Even about Tao lol)
i used to not support Tao too, for some reasons. but after all i realized he's innocent. i really feeled guilty. maybe u should read tge truth , and watch some interviews !
+LadyLu0620 thank you so much for posting this! i agree 100%: lets love the exo we have and just enjoy their awesomeness!!! EXO Fighting!
I couldn't stop listening to this song again and again! beautiful melodies, beautiful lyrics, beautiful voices! I'm so touched!
falling in love with Lay's voice.................
This song remind me a little of Little Things by 1D.... So right now I'm sobbing so hard and missing Kris, Luhan, Tao and Zayn 😭😭😭♥️
I like your comment, you are so right :( I miss them 4 too
1D :/ Good but Exo The Best 💞
+Alison Eusebi sameeee :(((
All EXO-L miss them
I feel you btw ... zayn 💔💔
这次的词比前几次的好多了 也不用看字幕就听懂
他们抒情歌的歌词都比较好 快歌你懂的。。
吉他的聲音真的好喜歡
更能清楚聽到每個成員的歌聲
大發！！
Chen lay xiumin fightingggggg!!!
CAN PEOPLE STOP MENTIONING LAY WITH LUHAN? I have nothing against luhan, but people keep saying that Lay's voice sounds like Luhan! I can't believe people are saying that they want luhan to sing it instead of lay. Not only I think Lay has a very unique voice that is different from Luhan's (Maybe only real fans could tell), but it's just wrong to mention ex members everywhere. Lay being the only chinese member left is not recieving the respect he deserves. If you ACTUALLY miss Luhan he has so many solo promotions even a non fan know about, I know people are sad that kris tao and luhan left but we're supposed to be happy about exo's comeback and excited about the members but everyone's talking about the ex members instead of people who stayed with exo...
ikr i.don't really similarities in Lay and Lu's voices... maybe is just me..
+Kim-Jung KimySeok I heard the similarity when I first became an exo fan but I know they are completely different now so I don't get why they keep bringing up them. It's like when people kept saying tao kept sounding like kris when rapping. Lay is Lay and Tao is Tao.
I totally agree with you Lay's voice sounds extremely unique from the others
+mimi fu THANK YOU!!!
+mimi fu maybe because they're new fan ??? because Lay's tone is a little bit lighter than Luhan, if they hear closer they can tell them apart
I just have one question.
How does that girl manage to dump 10 guys that are all my babies?
I can barely say "no" to fangirling over them.
BUT SHE MANAGES TO SAY, "I'm breaking up with her"
I wanna applause her for having that courage and bravery. But at the same time she's like evil for doing that.
seriously no matter how many times i see your pic is AMAZING!!
Kim-Jung KimySeok THANK YOU XiuXiu is yours right?
Learn to Google *cries in the corner silently*
+Tammy 인피니트 (Lᴏʀᴅ Dᴀʀᴋɴᴇss) Yup! Xiumin is bae~~
Kim-Jung KimySeok Chanyeol is mine, lol jk. But XiuMin is a cute baozi.
sehun's voice melted my heart!
wow lay voice 😭
can i know when is lay part?
+hui min In the beginning
the first one
+hui min also 2.56-3.04 :)
the members' Chinese pronunciation rlly improved a lot omg
It’s the 2nd year in a row for EXO-Ls without an winter special album… at least we will get a song from Baek tomorrow.
But I really miss the winter special. Also because Universe got me into EXO 🥺🥺❤️❤️
Chennn the way you cry and the way so smile. Ilove them all