Комментарии •

  • @bakakafka4428
    @bakakafka4428 23 дня назад +13

    There's plenty of money left in the pockets of the grifters and their sponsors. All Labour have to do is get it instead of taking on the role of grifters.

  • @johnturner5252
    @johnturner5252 23 дня назад +29

    That won't happen with Labour or any Government that has a P.M. who prefers Davos to Westminster. Expecially when it is rumoured that Blair could be the next to head the W.E.F.

    • @RobinHarris-nf4yv
      @RobinHarris-nf4yv 23 дня назад +6

      Boring conspiracist nonsense.
      And Starmer doesn’t prefer Davos to Westminster
      Grow up

    • @mmcc5846
      @mmcc5846 23 дня назад

      You grow up kid starver is a Zionist and a genocide lover he publicly admitted it ​@@RobinHarris-nf4yv

    • @davestevenson9080
      @davestevenson9080 23 дня назад

      @@RobinHarris-nf4yv Starmer is a member of the trilateral commision, WEF young global leaders, Fabian Society, and London Liberal Synagogue. Wake up lol, none of these things are conspiracy - they are open fact.

    • @EldenLordOrvik7790
      @EldenLordOrvik7790 23 дня назад +8

      ⁠@@RobinHarris-nf4yv Jan 19th 2023 - on “the News Agents” podcast, he was asked which he preferred - Davos or Westminster, and he said Davos because Westminster is “too constrained”.
      Why lie? All you had to do was look it up.

    • @pausereflect5911
      @pausereflect5911 23 дня назад

      The UK Government is already subservient to other interests that are not Good for the country. Someone says it's conspiracy. I think not.

  • @johnhorgan9295
    @johnhorgan9295 23 дня назад +11

    Remember PFI were going to get more of the same, a Privatized NHS.

  • @theotherandrew5540
    @theotherandrew5540 23 дня назад +9

    Let’s start with returning workers rights for collective action, and making zero hours contracts and fire& rehire illegal.

    • @Towertrips
      @Towertrips 23 дня назад +1

      And watch unemployment soar

    • @nigelmckay5915
      @nigelmckay5915 23 дня назад +1

      Yep. It worked well in California, Newsome introduced a $20 hour minimum wage and 60% of shops shut

    • @keithparker1346
      @keithparker1346 22 дня назад +1

      Labour couldn't even do the thing about making it illegal for your employer to contact you outside of work hours...they backtracked on that

    • @Towertrips
      @Towertrips 22 дня назад

      @@keithparker1346 it’s called work, that’s a four letter word to most lefties

    • @georgepeel1484
      @georgepeel1484 22 дня назад

      @@Towertrips Hogwash.

  • @michaelmayo3127
    @michaelmayo3127 23 дня назад +28

    Labour should dump the whole of the UK's anti Trade Union legislation in the waist bin.

    • @paulgibbons2320
      @paulgibbons2320 23 дня назад

      It can't realistically do that.

    • @Minimmalmythicist
      @Minimmalmythicist 23 дня назад +4

      @@paulgibbons2320 It could very easily, it´s one change that wouldn´t cost a penny. Indeed, the Spanish left coalition government did just this. They repealed the laws making it harder to strike.

    • @Towertrips
      @Towertrips 23 дня назад

      @@Minimmalmythicist how do strikes make the country more competitive? Unions encourage lazy workers

    • @paullarne
      @paullarne 23 дня назад +2

      Back to the 70s with crippling strikes etc. NO.

    • @paulgibbons2320
      @paulgibbons2320 23 дня назад +2

      @michaelmayo3127 it's strange that Cons have never developed their own union structure.
      To let the opposing party have a strangle hold really is like dropping your trousers.

  • @marcchrys
    @marcchrys 23 дня назад +9

    Starmer's Labour has willingly allowed its hands to be tied by corporate power, billionaire moguls and Blairite ghouls from the past :-(

  • @yodab.at1746
    @yodab.at1746 23 дня назад +7

    Tax the holders of the wealth assets! The people who own the debts, the infrastructure, the buildings don't pay tax due to having accounts and living status abroad. They should pay. Otherwise they're just stealing from us.

  • @ianlayton6949
    @ianlayton6949 22 дня назад +6

    Ban foxhunting.
    They've had 20 years of self policing, yet the modern use of drones by hunt sabs has shown the ongoing breaches of hunting with hounds law.
    They've had their chance, taken the piss, so shut them down.
    Also bring in Scots law across the UK to better protect endangered species (especially raptors)
    And increase UK national parks in terms of both area and quality to meet international minimum standards.
    Niche stuff - but it could be delivered by DEFRA in short order with little cost.

  • @anthonysteel6877
    @anthonysteel6877 22 дня назад +4

    De-criminalising drug use would involve no cost,save money on policing,courts,prison,probation etc,and could even produce revenue by licensing and taxing the drug industry.

  • @BazPar150
    @BazPar150 23 дня назад +7

    We can always hope. Tackling poverty should be number one priority and removing the two child benefit cap a must.

    • @witlesswonderthe2nd883
      @witlesswonderthe2nd883 23 дня назад +2

      No simple tax code changes would be easier and more cost effective, just by raising the tax band to 20-25 k a year earnings before you pay tax would put money directly into peoples pockets.
      Will never happen though because that gives people more control over their own lives and earnings.
      All governments love the back and forth of form filling to show the public who is boss, plus it creates well paid none jobs with gold plated pensions.

    • @davidclark1545
      @davidclark1545 23 дня назад

      @@witlesswonderthe2nd883never understood why we have two departments, one to tax tax from you and another to give you tax credits back. Just change the bloody tax codes and get rid of half of them.

    • @kevinwells768
      @kevinwells768 23 дня назад

      @@witlesswonderthe2nd883 ...what gold-plated pension would that be? And how would you make up the loss of tax take up to £25k without impacting public services?

    • @keithparker1346
      @keithparker1346 22 дня назад

      ​@@witlesswonderthe2nd883fine and dandy if you're working but what about people who are not?

    • @user-xu5vl5th9n
      @user-xu5vl5th9n 22 дня назад

      Global warming is the number one moral cause for Starmer. It is an "emergency". Poverty will have to play second fiddle, despite the fact it is a real global emergency with people dying right now. Which is unfortunate because proposed actions on the former are likely a catastrophe for the latter, not to mention the fact that more people die from cold weather and deaths from extreme weather have fallen enormously.

  • @229andymon
    @229andymon 23 дня назад +18

    When Labour won't even acknowledge the inherent and gross unfairness of *how* they gained their massive majority far less plan to do anything about it, I reckon it's not being cynical to doubt their capacity to do what Murphy is suggesting.

    • @InnuendoXP
      @InnuendoXP 23 дня назад

      Well you look at how much of their base support they lost pursuing this strategy & how watered down their policies had to become, I doubt Labour 'wants' this state of affairs for achieving power for power's sake.
      But I don't see why they'd draw doubt to the legitimacy of their mandate to govern as soon as they're elected either, the media would have a day.

    • @RobinHarris-nf4yv
      @RobinHarris-nf4yv 23 дня назад +1

      Nothing unfair about Labours win.
      Labour got more votes in 412 constituencies

    • @timwoodger7896
      @timwoodger7896 23 дня назад

      Reform gave labour the chance to get into power, thank Farage because before he entered the race the Tory’s still could have held them off and I’m sure they could have created a coalition.

    • @modularmorne
      @modularmorne 23 дня назад +1

      ​@@RobinHarris-nf4yv problem is first past the post, 59% of voters actually voted and labour got 34% of the vote share yet they get 63% of seats in parliment. First past the post is a joke

    • @scoates9910
      @scoates9910 23 дня назад

      Like the Tories did when they got their sizable majority under that clown ? Couldn't care less, labour are now in charge now and that bunch of wasters are history.

  • @CecilEtienne
    @CecilEtienne 22 дня назад +1

    Labour is now the New conservative party and conservative Government. Labour has completely lost its way and will never be the same again.

  • @gordonmackenzie4512
    @gordonmackenzie4512 23 дня назад +11

    Having been interested in politics for many years, I’ve always listened and compared. Westminster governments seem unable to consider looking outwards, at other Countries, to see how things are done differently and possibly better.

    • @Minimmalmythicist
      @Minimmalmythicist 23 дня назад +1

      Politics tends to happen in a mental bubble in most countries, people are not used to critically thinking in that way. Things that seem "far left" in one country are taken as normal in another.

    • @adenwellsmith6908
      @adenwellsmith6908 23 дня назад +1

      NHS. Research Beveridge and Bismarck systems to see why the NHS needs to go.

    • @shaun906
      @shaun906 23 дня назад +2

      they do? Gordon brown toured the world explaining how to use QE to reliquidate banks after 2008. you are told what they want you to hear. in the Tories case its 'government is rubbish, fend for yourself', so i can see why you believe what you do.

    • @adenwellsmith6908
      @adenwellsmith6908 23 дня назад

      @@shaun906 Brown was lying.
      The bank bail out was the SLS. Special liquidity scheme. They made a 35 bn profit on that.
      QE is different. The actual mechanism is the APF Asset Purchase Faciltity. It's a private company, which, for a change, means you can see the accounts.
      So what have they done with the money? You look at the balance sheet to see what they have done. It's all Gilts. They have lent the money to the state, the state has increased the debts. No bank debt involved.

    • @Minimmalmythicist
      @Minimmalmythicist 23 дня назад

      @@adenwellsmith6908 there´s no evidence that the NHS needs to go, the NHS is better than the German system in some ways, worse in others, but even if the German system was theoretically better, it would cost a tonne of money to move to a German style system and wouldn´t be worth it.

  • @oldishandwoke-ish1181
    @oldishandwoke-ish1181 19 дней назад +1

    There's plenty of money, but it's sitting in offshore tax havens.

  • @jameslochridge4265
    @jameslochridge4265 22 дня назад +3

    Labour now is no different from the Tories.

    • @keithhooper6123
      @keithhooper6123 22 дня назад

      W.E.F. controlled.Labour will continue to destroy the country.

  • @paulgibbons2320
    @paulgibbons2320 23 дня назад +7

    We desperately need fair rent controls.
    They had the debate and changed the law so tennants can have a pet instead 😂
    I don't think our parlintarians who are 80% landlords ever seriously considered rent controls. Do you ? 😂

    • @user-xu5vl5th9n
      @user-xu5vl5th9n 22 дня назад

      Labour promised to abolish section 21 "no fault" evictions from "day one". How's that working out for y'all?

    • @Mike-lb1hx
      @Mike-lb1hx 22 дня назад +2

      rent controls are just shooting the messenger, the current level of immigration (1.2 million) the UK needs to build 500k houses per annum for them alone based on average occupancy levels per property. This is on top of the needs of the rest of the population at a guess 250k so a total of 750k per annum. This level of building is impossible.

    • @paulgibbons2320
      @paulgibbons2320 22 дня назад

      @@Mike-lb1hx yup
      This is a different issue.
      Blair returned the magna Carter and serfdom via the back door.
      The rich living on the backs of the poor.

  • @brendanlea3605
    @brendanlea3605 23 дня назад +7

    We can always hope.

  • @BrianFace182
    @BrianFace182 22 дня назад +2

    One big caveat is they don't want to make things better. It's a government of managed decline.

  • @Anti-Peaceforcepolice
    @Anti-Peaceforcepolice 20 дней назад

    Sadly, the newly elected UK prime minister is on record as saying that he prefers the policies of Davos and the WEF to those of Westminster.

  • @mad4surfing2
    @mad4surfing2 22 дня назад +1

    Just to confirm, I will be watching the series, go knows we need the solutions!

  • @Sgwaos
    @Sgwaos 19 дней назад

    This is a great idea, and I like your suggestions which I've been watching - thank you very much! 🙏

  • @duncanpoundcake
    @duncanpoundcake 23 дня назад +5

    But they won't.

    • @adenwellsmith6908
      @adenwellsmith6908 23 дня назад +1

      More debt, more debt, more debt.
      Asset strip the workers even more.
      Import more poverty
      Hide the numbers.
      Politicians to loot more personally.

  • @PaddyWV
    @PaddyWV 21 день назад

    Amuses me that a Universal Basic Income could slash the wasteful jobs at the DWP. They could be transferred to HMRC where they could chase the real criminals.

  • @cliffordhammond01
    @cliffordhammond01 20 дней назад

    Labour couldn't change the bedding on the bed. They are all corrupt and belong in prison

  • @Minimmalmythicist
    @Minimmalmythicist 23 дня назад +3

    I think that the "mainstream" parties in the UK are gripped by austerity mania, they can´t think about problems any other way.
    To give the new government their due, one thing I think they will be better at than the Tories is day-to-day running of government departments, but that´s not enough to sort out the big structural problems the UK has.
    There are plenty of decent policies we could implement that wouldn´t cost the government a lot as you say, i.e Corbyn´s policy of requiring companies to give their workers shares and seats on the board of directors is a great one. Another good policy would be to give workers protection from unfair dismissal after 6 months instead of two years. I think it´s utterly ludicrous to think that any employer needs two years to decide whether or not someone is competent enough to do the job.

  • @clivebroadhead4381
    @clivebroadhead4381 21 день назад

    Since the Thatcher Government not just wages, but the terms and conditions of workers have been eroded. Final salary pensions are not available to blue collar workers and youngsters leaving school and university. In addition, some graduates have huge loans and the nationalised industries are owned in most part by foreig nationalised industries and pension funds.

  • @roymillsjnr5172
    @roymillsjnr5172 23 дня назад +3

    Agree Richard , 🙌

  • @clivebroadhead4381
    @clivebroadhead4381 22 дня назад

    It may be true to say there is no money, but if not it's very convenient argument for inaction. After the war the country was bankrupt, however, it was not used as an eexcuse to do nothing!

  • @morturn
    @morturn 23 дня назад

    perfect, thank you

  • @SkyEcho7
    @SkyEcho7 23 дня назад +1

    Social Tariff on all utilities would cost £millions but it would save £billions in health & social consequences.

  • @alansdorsetfossils4028
    @alansdorsetfossils4028 22 дня назад

    I believe zero hour contracts are in their sights probably soon.

  • @kevinwells768
    @kevinwells768 23 дня назад

    Think I can guess one or two of the topics (clean up corruption in WC1 perhaps?), but look forward to seeing the series.

  • @stuartriches2551
    @stuartriches2551 22 дня назад

    Lets hope Labour are watching

  • @Srindal4657
    @Srindal4657 21 день назад

    I think i see what you mean, while i have concerns for labour, i also hope they will improve peoples lives. They now have the power. Lets hope they use it properly. But i wont get my hopes higher than that.

  • @anllpp
    @anllpp 22 дня назад

    ❤ Hopefully

  • @neilsmith154
    @neilsmith154 21 день назад

    Ok do everything you want but only one thing. No wealth tax. All other options on the table. Do you have anything else?

  • @JonnyWebster78
    @JonnyWebster78 20 дней назад

    2 days. This already hasn't aged well.

  • @user-wo6qn3vf9n
    @user-wo6qn3vf9n 22 дня назад

    As soon a Labour got in here is all the Unions announcing industry action. Typical, people have such short memories. Welcome to the 1970s.

    • @Redf322
      @Redf322 21 день назад

      So there was not hundreds of people on strike recently under the Tories?

    • @user-wo6qn3vf9n
      @user-wo6qn3vf9n 21 день назад

      Yes, but got nowhere. The Labour Party will give into them. I never mentioned the Tories.

  • @stevenwilliamson6236
    @stevenwilliamson6236 23 дня назад +1

    When you say change, do you mean improve?

  • @MarjorieStoker-oj8fh
    @MarjorieStoker-oj8fh 22 дня назад

    😢

  • @brucemacdougall6121
    @brucemacdougall6121 22 дня назад

    Under Starmer?

  • @GeorgesDupont-do8pe
    @GeorgesDupont-do8pe 22 дня назад

    We might get a pound of carrots 🙂

  • @dennismccarthy7032
    @dennismccarthy7032 23 дня назад

  • @monkeysausageclub
    @monkeysausageclub 22 дня назад +3

    Ohh they most certainly are going to change the country. Alas it will not be for the better.

  • @ashjitsu
    @ashjitsu 23 дня назад

    They will definitely change it 😂😂

  • @gj55223
    @gj55223 23 дня назад +3

    The closing muzak is a terrible idea.

  • @user-ke8gx4zc9s
    @user-ke8gx4zc9s 22 дня назад

    Changing the UK by changing our constitution is a bad idea. Labour is looking to "progress" through the dilution of British culture and the installation of hard left policy. The reason we are in such a bad place is due to Labour. The changes they have made have been, mostly to the detriment of Britain, not for the better. It was Gordon Brown who essentially contributed to the banking crash in 2007 which plunged us all into austerity. Austerity, which they then spent 10 years blaming everyone else for. All of that, along with the PFI deals. Most people have forgotten how bad Labour were. And that is how Labour win, they rely on people with short memories and those who don't understand what they are doing in the background.

    • @jamesbarbour8400
      @jamesbarbour8400 22 дня назад

      It was actually the selling of so called Sub Prime Mortgages (giving mortgages to people who had no real chance of paying them back, due to their low paid jobs and hence less disposable income), that initiated the 2008 financial crisis in America, courtesy of Lehman Brothers.
      Much as I despise both Gordon Brown and Rishi Sunak, the 2008 financial collapse had nothing whatsoever to do with them.

  • @mrspanman1045
    @mrspanman1045 21 день назад

    I bet you £10 they don't.

  • @cinemaipswich4636
    @cinemaipswich4636 23 дня назад

    Even though Labour has the Trade Unions at its heart, they will help the farmers, food makers, and manufacturers first. The only way that the UK can trade with the EU, is to enter into the common market and the custom's union. They need not join the political union. All it takes is the safety of food, goods and products that businesses already understand. Get trade working with the EU. They have the best universal standards that have never been rejected by the rest of the world.

    • @Redf322
      @Redf322 23 дня назад

      We have kept most EU standards as we need them to trade with EU, and as you say most of the world. The nearest to what you are saying is the EEA. But free movement of goods requires free movement of people. Some people on here don’t like that. Farage said he would never take us out of the Single market and Customs union.

    • @keithparker1346
      @keithparker1346 22 дня назад

      The common markets long gone

  • @RobinHarris-nf4yv
    @RobinHarris-nf4yv 23 дня назад +1

    Hi Richard, I look forward to seeing your positive series of videos.
    I get so tired of Owen Jones, Novara etc just producing the same old stuff moaning about Labour, it just creates divisive echo chambers.
    Labour have just taken on James Timpson as minister of state for prisons.
    He will want to to look at rehabilitation rather than imprisonment
    That’s a positive change.
    Labour want to look at the Canadian model,of massive childcare subsidies….Canada have worked out it’s possible to make childcare very cheap and the increase in parents working brings in more revenue than childcare costs.
    Labour want to negotiate reduced trade barriers with EU, esp on agri foods.
    These are all ways to make positive change without huge cost
    As I said Richard, why don’t you reach out to Phil Moorhouse or Van man talks or others.
    We really need the left like you Richard to engage with a broader spectrum….you may not agree with Phils support of Labour, but you could both use your knowledge to create really interesting content.

    • @Redf322
      @Redf322 23 дня назад

      It isn’t his support of labour people don’t agree with it is his constant punching left.

    • @RobinHarris-nf4yv
      @RobinHarris-nf4yv 23 дня назад

      @@Redf322 Phil Moorhouse is the left

    • @abody499
      @abody499 23 дня назад

      "divisive echo chambers" - yeah those are 3 words that always signal a level 1 dweller, and especially "divisive". whenever I see or hear that word, I know it's being used by someone with no concept of the difference between an arse and an elbow

    • @keithparker1346
      @keithparker1346 22 дня назад

      Van Man is a political dunce ffs

  • @DeeCee-nb6ev
    @DeeCee-nb6ev 23 дня назад

    Reign in the restrictive free speech legislation. Cancel hate speech legislation against belief systems or at least make fact and truth overrule belief.

    • @abody499
      @abody499 23 дня назад

      it would be ok if people like you understood what the concepts of fact and truth actually mean

    • @DeeCee-nb6ev
      @DeeCee-nb6ev 22 дня назад

      @@abody499 who are these people like me?

    • @abody499
      @abody499 22 дня назад

      people who use a veil of free speech rhetoric to conceal prejudice and superficial exclusive identity politics agendas. please explain the concepts of fact and truth that are referred to.

    • @user-xu5vl5th9n
      @user-xu5vl5th9n 22 дня назад

      @@abody499 Facts and truth like men becoming women and vice versa. It is the people living in their own post-truth bubble who want crackdowns on free speech.

  • @Guitar6ty
    @Guitar6ty 23 дня назад +7

    In the 1980s labour despite having huge union following did nothing to stop the outsourcing of most of our industry. They also did nothing to stop the Poll Tax for people who were made unemployed. They thought it was fine that some one who had millions paid the same amount of poll tax as the newly unemployed. Teaching our children that they can be any rainbow colour they want to be is a crime against humanity.

    • @davestevenson9080
      @davestevenson9080 23 дня назад

      And when blair came in he started the invasion of britain which is the source of most of our problems today such as housing costs, energy bills, inflation. Have never understood how the left have this huge blind spot when it comes to immigration despite being more sensible everywhere else

    • @cliffhughes6010
      @cliffhughes6010 23 дня назад +2

      I don't regard New Labour as Labour.

    • @radiosnail
      @radiosnail 23 дня назад +5

      Labour were in Opposition. What did you expect them to do?

    • @shaun906
      @shaun906 23 дня назад

      you do know once a party has a majority its impossible to "stop" the government? unless they have rebels? 3 line whips ring a bell? that why this super majority was BS, i guess you sucked in all the bs?

  • @captnoplan3926
    @captnoplan3926 22 дня назад +1

    You bashed Labour in previous videos and I was ready to unsubscribe, since we should be lucky that the Tories are finally out and you bashed them before they've even moved in yet so to speak.
    So thank you for trying to take a more positive approach.
    Could Labour take a page or two out of the 'Deficit Myth' book, which argues that you can kick start the economy again without relying on tax payers money?

  • @cliffward2400
    @cliffward2400 23 дня назад +1

    Rather than protecting those in precarious situations, the minimum wage was instrumental in driving down living standards. Not all change was positive.

  • @adenwellsmith6908
    @adenwellsmith6908 23 дня назад +2

    Change the minimum tax code on migrants to break even. 38,500 a year.

    • @witlesswonderthe2nd883
      @witlesswonderthe2nd883 23 дня назад +1

      Needs to be nearer 80k with the dependents they’re allowed, even then at that they’d still be a drain

    • @Redf322
      @Redf322 23 дня назад

      They are not a drain its small monies relatively. You are being dog whistled.

    • @adenwellsmith6908
      @adenwellsmith6908 23 дня назад

      @@Redf322 so how about a compromise? You say they aren’t a drain. That means none will be affected by a minimum tax code of 38.5k and a no welfare policy

    • @user-mj5bl5dy1b
      @user-mj5bl5dy1b 23 дня назад

      Skilled workers are needed ..Many companies need these workers Raising the tax won't help the UK

    • @adenwellsmith6908
      @adenwellsmith6908 23 дня назад

      @@user-mj5bl5dy1b So skilled workers. Workers who generate more tax than they cost.
      Otherwise you are just acting like a plantation owner who says, who will pick our cotton? You mean we have to PAY workers?
      38,500 for each adult economic migrant, a minimum tax.
      Skilled workers of course earn more than that so aren't affected.
      it's the unskilled and the non working migrants who then have a decision to make.
      Implementation is easy. NI register contains the details. A simple DB query, and the letters/emails go out to employees. The money rolls in next month.
      Next, all economic migrants should have to fill out an annual tax form. We then send the demands out for any short fall.
      So its a compromise. You say they are skilled high wage earning migrants. The change won't affect them will it?
      But I know its the opposite. The only people who object are those with that plantation owner mentality.

  • @selvamthiagarajan8152
    @selvamthiagarajan8152 22 дня назад

    I know where exactly you are going with this change with no cost pitch. You want to about gender altogether , gender is fluid, women have penis, pregnant person, they, them that sort of cultural shift at no cost.

  • @hettyindyscot18
    @hettyindyscot18 22 дня назад +1

    Labour should make real 'change', just ditch 'subsidy junkie' Scotland, more cash in England's pocket. Can't fathom why they don't seem keen to do that. 🤔 Got any spare 'change' please SIR!

  • @maaziy_ghaziyIYI
    @maaziy_ghaziyIYI 22 дня назад

    Labour need to change its stance on Israel and Palestine. Would you advocate for ceasefire and Palestinian statehood?!

    • @keithparker1346
      @keithparker1346 22 дня назад

      We could you know even stop arming and sending our RAF to help Israel

  • @johnwarren9112
    @johnwarren9112 23 дня назад +1

    Change it for the worst 😕🐍🐍🐍

  • @Painey66
    @Painey66 23 дня назад +1

    Labour will not be around much longer

  • @fiction8909
    @fiction8909 23 дня назад

    The minimum wage was an absolute disaster for those of us who were young and struggling when it came it - it pushed wages down considerably, and we could see it happen before our eyes. Before, you'd go into a job centre and there'd be a range of pay and competition - if they were serious they had to pay up. Suddenly everything was stuck at the (too low) national minimum wage, and there was no variation or choice if that was your only option. Employers gave everyone the same blank answer - "it's the minimum wage", end of conversation. Worse, it created a huge illegal pay market, where people paying cash in hand for off-the-books jobs (off the employers' books i mean) were always paying less than it, whereas previously they didn't really know what to pay. Peoples wages in markets went down and down, not just in 'real terms' but simply down - by the time you counted in the 'unpaid' hours people were working for four pounds an hour. A minimum wage either has to be at a reasonable level, which of course it never is. But tbh, i had sympathy with employers too who needed flexibility to get their business off the ground, sometimes times are tough and you have to drop a wage, some times it's good you can pay more. The minimum wage was and is a straitjacket. (And then there's National Insurance, where hope you do a video on that - because nothing, absolutely nothing, is more of a handicap to starting new businesses, or getting a small job, than that. Introduced as a Lloyd George slight-of-hand to get it through, now just a lead weight on everybody).

    • @abody499
      @abody499 23 дня назад +1

      "it pushed wages down" - no it didnt, capitalism did

    • @Redf322
      @Redf322 21 день назад

      @@abody499exactly thats why they were struggling.

    • @fiction8909
      @fiction8909 16 дней назад

      @@abody499 Easy to say from your armchair, but those of us who needed the money got less of it thanks to another poorly thought out and executed Labour plan. I'm all for dismantling capitalism, but if you do it by making the poor poorer while muttering glib memes you're not really winning.

    • @abody499
      @abody499 16 дней назад

      sierra hotel uniform tango the foxtrot uniform charlie kilo uniform papa yamkee oscar uniform bravo uniform mike bravo lima india november golf foxtrot oscar oscar lima.

  • @Th3_Gael
    @Th3_Gael 21 день назад

    Minimum wage wasnt a benefit.
    It has consistently outpaced the natural market wage growth.
    People like to talk about raising the floor because it makes them feel good.
    Raising the floor might seem like youre lifting people up, but in actuallity minimum wage is a net, a net more find themselves caught in and yet more feel drawing ever closer.
    I worked in electronics 30 years ago. It used to pay roughly 2.5x what a shelf stacker would earn, now the difference at tech level is about 8k. Its not worth the additional education and years of training to earn 8k more.
    Many on building sites and other industries not doing piece work are in the same boat; their wages barely rise year on year while the net draws ever closer

    • @Th3_Gael
      @Th3_Gael 21 день назад

      Thought I'd add another thing.
      Remember the days where someone who had done badly at school or possibly dropped out could get a job sweeping the floor, and if they showed enough interest, and enough grit they could land an apprenticeship.
      Minimum wage took that away. It now costs too much to take someone on to do a menial job the skilled workers should be doing themselves anyway
      Talk to people your own age or older and ask how many used to get their break that way

  • @hughcaskey9542
    @hughcaskey9542 22 дня назад

    Think you need to move to another planet

  • @darek795
    @darek795 23 дня назад +2

    Immigration topic seems to be forbidden for Labour. They want to promote LGBT instead of dealing with immigration.

  • @SureshkumarShaih
    @SureshkumarShaih 22 дня назад +1

    Hallelujah!!!! The daily jesus devotional has been a huge part of my transformation, God is good 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻was owning a loan of $47,000 to the bank for my son's brain surgery (David), Now I'm no longer in debt after I invested $8,000 and got my payout of $270,500 every months,God bless Christy Fiore 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸..

    • @IbrahimFilipe
      @IbrahimFilipe 22 дня назад

      Hello!! how do you make such monthly, I’m a born Christian and sometimes I feel so down of myself 😭 because of low finance but I still believe God

    • @KingsleyFoska
      @KingsleyFoska 22 дня назад

      Thanks to my co-worker (Carson ) who suggested Ms Christy Fiore

    • @FarnellCannaday
      @FarnellCannaday 22 дня назад

      After I raised up to 525k trading with her I bought a new House and a car here in the states🇺🇸🇺🇸 also paid for my son's surgery….Glory to God, shalom.

    • @SimplotElbie
      @SimplotElbie 22 дня назад

      She's a licensed broker here in the states🇺🇸 and finance advisor.

    • @DegeorgeGoswami
      @DegeorgeGoswami 22 дня назад

      I've always wanted to be involved for a long time but the volatility in the price has been very confusing to me. Although I have watched a lot of RUclips videos about it but I still find it hard to understand

  • @davidfoster2006
    @davidfoster2006 23 дня назад

    Not paying equal pay for women, bankrupted the Birmingham Labour Party run council, so not always an accurate commentary by you.