This is an interesting comparison. My gut would say T Mac; for longevity I will reluctantly give Carmelo that edge. If only T Mac didn't have lower back issues.
T-Macs game looks better, matter of fact, arguably the best LOOKING game ever. But 39% FG is horrible. I'm going with Melo who was stronger, can back u down and doesn't get hurt like TMac
Tmac can do the exact same thing what you just said plus his numbers were better in a defensive oriented league Tmac dropping 36+ ppg with all this spacing he has
@ when you say better numbers, what do you mean? cuz if you go loook at his percentages they were not better and melo played in the same league during his prime, limited spacing and 2 legit bigs on the block and everyone played defense
@@MMCGIRTH12 well at least you admitting that it's not purely a bball decision for you bc I watched them both in their prime and it's no doubt Tmac is better. Happy Holidays bro
Tmac was the most talented player in the early and mid 00s. I feel like his personality let him down he was just way to chill. Kobe would shoot 7 for 27 and then blame his teammates and next game, everybody playing better defense even though Kobe shot them out the previous game. He would cry to management and than boom heres Odom, heres Gasol
Stop hyping T Mac. He was a choke artist. His 4th quarter stats will shock you! Its MISERABLE! Great as a higlight player, but never hit big shots in big moments or when his team needed him. How does that make you 1 of the "greatest" scorers??! 😒 fanboys smh
Have to give it to TMac
Mac and it’s a no brainer.
Melo for me and he was a better post up player. Better player it's open but better scorer Melo
Tmac plus he had to do more fr in Toronto and Orlando he was the PG and matched up with opposing teams best wing player TMAC was a DAWG boy was cold 🥶
This is wild to even compare. TMAC ALLLLLL THE FUCKIN WAY 💯💯💯💯💯💯💯
Tmac for me easy
Plus a much better playmaker
T Mac
Mac all day
If we're talking total offense I'd go with Mac because of his play making ability
Exactly. T Mac better pull up J on the break, passer, rim attacker.
This is an interesting comparison. My gut would say T Mac; for longevity I will reluctantly give Carmelo that edge. If only T Mac didn't have lower back issues.
Tmac and its easy for me!!!! Tmac is same league as KD as a scorer.
T mac
T-Macs game looks better, matter of fact, arguably the best LOOKING game ever. But 39% FG is horrible. I'm going with Melo who was stronger, can back u down and doesn't get hurt like TMac
I’m going wit Melo, soon as he stepped in the league was up there wit bron and was more successful
Melo
To me only thing Tracy got on MELO is his defense scoring wise MELO was just as good💯
Definitely Tmac, but Melo ain't far behind
Mac. He had some better physical tools and was more cerebral with his game.
Tmac and it’s not even close considering tmac could pass also
Melo when he was still explosive
Tmac easy
Melo for me. Bigger body, took more contact, didnt mind post play. That along with the shooting touch from anywhere
Its T Mac
Real ones know it’s Melo
Nah it’s Tmac
I got Mac as better offensively overall but I’m taking melo. The consistency efficiency and effect on the game is slightly more to me
Melo his midrange and pullup was MJ Kobe level and he had a better post game but Tmac was probably a better finisher
Tmac. No comparison. Athletic af. Clutch… could shoot And he played defense.
Melo, in Denver was a problem more physical. Tracy had more athleticism but his injury slowed him down. Melo shot the 3 ball better too
Put them both in todays game, melo is the better player can play the 3 or 4 and grab rebounds shoot finish and can carry a team better
Tmac can do the exact same thing what you just said plus his numbers were better in a defensive oriented league
Tmac dropping 36+ ppg with all this spacing he has
@ when you say better numbers, what do you mean? cuz if you go loook at his percentages they were not better and melo played in the same league during his prime, limited spacing and 2 legit bigs on the block and everyone played defense
Melo Tracy McGrady had years where he put up higher numbers, but his usage rate was also way higher
Because he had Gordon giricek, drew gooden pat garrity and Andrew declerq as teammates in orlando
You could just give Melo the ball and walk to the other end #sweatergod
Melo because t Mac is even worse than melo in the playoffs
Tmac not even a Top 75 player all time. Melo top 10 All Time Scoring
Tmac def top 75, that list is a lie
@ show me some proof. cause Carmelo definitely on there
@@MMCGIRTH12 just watch the highlights Tmac all around just better. Going off of list just gets you caught up in biasness and politics
@ Well i’m going off politics my brother. Tmac had bad Knees. Never made it out first round. Had a couple good years. I don’t see him over Melo imo
@@MMCGIRTH12 well at least you admitting that it's not purely a bball decision for you bc I watched them both in their prime and it's no doubt Tmac is better. Happy Holidays bro
Tmac was the most talented player in the early and mid 00s. I feel like his personality let him down he was just way to chill. Kobe would shoot 7 for 27 and then blame his teammates and next game, everybody playing better defense even though Kobe shot them out the previous game. He would cry to management and than boom heres Odom, heres Gasol
Melo is not in Tmac or KD's class as a scorer
Stop hyping T Mac. He was a choke artist. His 4th quarter stats will shock you! Its MISERABLE! Great as a higlight player, but never hit big shots in big moments or when his team needed him. How does that make you 1 of the "greatest" scorers??! 😒 fanboys smh
Facts
T Mac