"It's not starting from an idea. Not starting even from the expression of the same feeling nor an exposition of the same idea but rather simply being together in the same place at the same time and leaving space around each art so that neither art has to glue itself to a particular . . ." John Cage
I love how wonderfully adventurous, and flexible they are in their approach to their art, and life. They seem like truly joyful, and fulfilled human beings.
I was attending the renowned Cooper Union School for the Advancemnt of Art and Architecture in New York City and one evening took in a performance at Lincoln Center in the late 60's. Before the show began, on a warm summer evening, I was waiting in the elegant plaza, enjoying the breeze as well as the sophisticated crowd. All at once there I was standing in front of Cunningham and Cage, and I knew exactly who they were. Well dressed and tall...they both gave me a delightful nod. Admittedly in those salad days I was a cute young man...and I think they figured so, as well. I returned the nod and shyly moved on. Were it today, I would have approached and engaged then in a lively conversation.
For those of you who didn't know, these two were romantically involved at this time. Not that it particularly matters, but interesting piece of background knowledge
@speedskis777 they seem to me to be speaking quite plainly and clearly about their working processes, which i find refreshing, especially considering how difficult their work can seem. to know the specific roots and bases of their practices is illuminating to me. mine is just one perspective, but maybe watch the interview again and reconsider their what they are saying about their approaches, or perhaps take a look at the i ching, for example. idk, maybe it just isn't for everyone.
@beatlesmack9 Mr Cage wrote quite a bit of wonderful "straight" music for strings and piano. His compositions in the more classical style are very lovely and beautiful.
Does anyone know if there was ever a joint interview between Cage , Cunningham and Rauschenberg. Perhaps about Aeon or something in relation to their collaborations?
@beatlesmack9 Whether what he composes is music or something else is a separate question ----- he certainly composed, that is, put things together ---- instructions involved in the production of sounds. Cage even said himself that if one has trouble referring to what he is composing as music one can call it something else.
@SnapshotsMusic No. He wasn't. Although Zappa did say something along the lines of finding John Cage's work more interesting to read and how it was written rather than how it actually sounded.
A valid opinion on an artform is not predicated on knowing the difference between right and write, or even the omission of punctuation, zaneisthemaster. I am not agreeing with this opinion, just not judging it on usage of language. Maybe you misinterpreted the meaning of the phrase "he didn't right music". Cage certainly did turn music or sound on it's ass for us to consider.
- "The difference between ear and eye system is you can hear behind them" 0.0 After 5 secs - "it's true" Why words like that spoken from them are so different than from a kindergarten child?
Great conversation ... Merce is Harpo Marx with a towering intellect..... Merce came here in 83 and the Arts Assembly / Cultural Council had to apologize to the backward arts community here that 'next time we'll use real music." At his lecture at Jacksonville Univ. I asked his influence on performance art ( then real hot ). Merce emphatically but gently answered me " I Do Dances" ... The dance students in attendance had no idea who he was and could only ask inane questions about 'making it ' in the dance world..... he was very patient and gracious to these imbeciles.
john cage is a charlatan whose success can be attributed to his charisma and wit, but not to his talent nor ability as a composer. love listening to his interviews, far more than his "music".
+AliIKarimi I'm glad you like his interviews, but I don't agree with your criticism of his talents and composing ability. Perhaps you should judge a discipline or artistic expression you understand. Maybe instead of labeling him a "charlatan" you could just state that you don't understand his art. I AM pleased that he elicited a reaction from you, which possibly was his intent.
That woman is so lucky to have had the chance to talk with both of these men.
Thank you, Walker Art Center!!!!!!
She's great. She's Interested in their answers, free of ego, and never jumps in if things are not rattling along.
"It's not starting from an idea. Not starting even from the expression of the same feeling nor an exposition of the same idea but rather simply being together in the same place at the same time and leaving space around each art so that neither art has to glue itself to a particular . . ." John Cage
ok
Holly -- yes - Indeterminancy and calligraphy . chance and space. Form IS content .
2:33 for those wondering
Iv been struggeling to write an essay on these 2 for a couple of days now. This interview has been a massive help. thanks.
They are absolutely brilliant.
wonderful conversation
I love how wonderfully adventurous, and flexible they are in their approach to their art, and life. They seem like truly joyful, and fulfilled human beings.
I love both their laughters.
Me too. The photos of their laughters are awesome :)
Excellent class on the creative process: very inspirational.
I was attending the renowned Cooper Union School for the Advancemnt of Art and Architecture in New York City and one evening took in a performance at Lincoln Center in the late 60's. Before the show began, on a warm summer evening, I was waiting in the elegant plaza, enjoying the breeze as well as the sophisticated crowd. All at once there I was standing in front of Cunningham and Cage, and I knew exactly who they were. Well dressed and tall...they both gave me a delightful nod. Admittedly in those salad days I was a cute young man...and I think they figured so, as well. I returned the nod and shyly moved on. Were it today, I would have approached and engaged then in a lively conversation.
Beautiful calculated people thinking before they speak.
So unlike many today.
Totally agreed
Agreed!
I just want to hug them both
great interview! Thank you, Walker Art Center!
In life, find someone who looks at you the way these two look at each other.
They are both such brilliant and loving people :)
Cage's voice is so relazing. I wish someone just took interview clips of him and made an asmr video.
two Masters!!!! this is a good class!
thank you verry much for this video !! great !!!!
very nice video, thank you!
I met them both Charming
what wonderful collaborators and lovers
Doors opened listening to this itw #thankyou
For those of you who didn't know, these two were romantically involved at this time. Not that it particularly matters, but interesting piece of background knowledge
What
I thought they were a couple until the end of their lives, they certainly behave like people that love and respect each other.
Very goooood♥️♥️❤️
Bert and Ernie.
@speedskis777 they seem to me to be speaking quite plainly and clearly about their working processes, which i find refreshing, especially considering how difficult their work can seem. to know the specific roots and bases of their practices is illuminating to me. mine is just one perspective, but maybe watch the interview again and reconsider their what they are saying about their approaches, or perhaps take a look at the i ching, for example. idk, maybe it just isn't for everyone.
this is most deficient from all ways.thank you.
Brilliant
@beatlesmack9
Mr Cage wrote quite a bit of wonderful "straight" music for strings and piano. His compositions in the more classical style are very lovely and beautiful.
listen to Cage playing Morton Feldman.The backround noise from coughing to car honking is emiinent.
I would have gave an arm to meet them back then...
a creative thinker
que artistas tan geniales
Genteel gentlemen. Geniuses.
Does anyone know if there was ever a joint interview between Cage , Cunningham and Rauschenberg. Perhaps about Aeon or something in relation to their collaborations?
I wondered the same thing. I find this discussion to be incredibly important. Would love to see more group interviews!
Surely the chance traffic and strange noises in the background are no mistake, or are they…hmm.
where can i see these performances? does any one know?
Who is the interviewer?
yo mamma
I was going to ask the same thing.
I hope it was intentional...it sounds fantastic... like the weather...
@beatlesmack9 Whether what he composes is music or something else is a separate question ----- he certainly composed, that is, put things together ---- instructions involved in the production of sounds. Cage even said himself that if one has trouble referring to what he is composing as music one can call it something else.
@SnapshotsMusic No. He wasn't. Although Zappa did say something along the lines of finding John Cage's work more interesting to read and how it was written rather than how it actually sounded.
That’s how I think about Zappa’s music. LOL
i'm sure John would have loved that.
A valid opinion on an artform is not predicated on knowing the difference between right and write, or even the omission of punctuation,
zaneisthemaster. I am not agreeing with this opinion, just not judging it on usage of language. Maybe you misinterpreted the meaning of the phrase "he didn't right music". Cage certainly did turn music or sound on it's ass for us to consider.
Hello, may anybody tell me which is the book that Cage pronounce at minute 26:20 please?.
Thank you very much in advance.
Ana.
Lankavatara Sutra for anyone wondering :)
@@AttitudeCastle Thank you! 😊👏🏻
- "The difference between ear and eye system is you can hear behind them"
0.0 After 5 secs
- "it's true"
Why words like that spoken from them are so different than from a kindergarten child?
Chance can be translated so differently if we want to keep their definition of chance straight
@beatlesmack9
music IS sound, sound IS music...
best regards... :)
Hello everybody. Any idea where to get this on DVD??// to buy it?
Please help.
Great conversation ... Merce is Harpo Marx with a towering intellect..... Merce came here in 83 and the Arts Assembly / Cultural Council had to apologize to the backward arts community here that 'next time we'll use real music." At his lecture at Jacksonville Univ. I asked his influence on performance art ( then real hot ). Merce emphatically but gently answered me " I Do Dances" ... The dance students in attendance had no idea who he was and could only ask inane questions about 'making it ' in the dance world..... he was very patient and gracious to these imbeciles.
Who the fuck's idea was it to sit awkwardly in the center of a large gymnasium next to a busy road.
Have you heard John Cage talk about traffic?
this is a realy good interview
if you are a fan of joh cage you have to hear
gabriel williams - time travel in music
@Consciousish Favorite comment of 2011.
@beatlesmack9 compose, from latin componere, com - together; ponere - to put. a composer is someone who puts together.
I'd like to know the woman's name. Maybe I missed it.
Virgil Thomson, composer and writer, said John Cage had 'no ear'. Was he right?
Yes.
no. To take one example, try the String Quartet in Four Parts. It's delightful.
merce looks like an elf
21:45
@sleepytimejesse I think it was intentional.
@beatlesmack9 i dont feel you should have a valid opinion because you dont know the difference between right and write
Probably it was Cage's idea, you know, for staying close to the noise.
Matt Bullock was here
Probably Johnny Cage.
@sleepytimejesse Yeah, really. Plus the reporter seems either inexperienced or simply awkward.
one dislike
how stupid !
We're so open minded, our brains have fallen to the ground.
the skull is not the mind
I don't feel John Cage can rightly be called a composer because he didn't right music, but sound, and they are not the same
interestingly enough, john cage said the same thing at one point, preferring to be called an inventor rather than a composer.
@@jameskong3894 Oh yes, you’re right! I forget about that comment he made. Interesting!
In addition to the graphic scores and chance procedure pieces he composed many more traditional scores
@@jameskong3894 i think Schoenberg allegedly made this comment about Cage.
john cage is a charlatan whose success can be attributed to his charisma and wit, but not to his talent nor ability as a composer. love listening to his interviews, far more than his "music".
I wouldn't call him a charlatan, but I also wouldn't call him an artist.
AliIKarimi you obviously did not listen to him- he clearly outlined a project that dealt with time and cited tradition from India as an impetus.
+AliIKarimi I'm glad you like his interviews, but I don't agree with your criticism of his talents and composing ability. Perhaps you should judge a discipline or artistic expression you understand. Maybe instead of labeling him a "charlatan" you could just state that you don't understand his art. I AM pleased that he elicited a reaction from you, which possibly was his intent.
You, on the other hand, are just someone who comments on You Tube videos.
charaltan? in which sense?
@beatlesmack9
music IS sound, sound IS music...
best regards... :)