As I take time revisiting the videos I uploaded as part of my teaching career, this has been the one that not only became my most viewed, but has been the first piece of media I began every class with, no matter what subject matter I was teaching. Why? Because "truth" is not in getting the right answer, but in asking the right questions. The right questions are those that progress us forward in our journeys and lives rather than keeping us stagnant. There is SO much more I have taught on this matter, and would love to do so on a wider level than just in the school setting. So if you're visiting this comment section, please consider two actions: 1) I'd love for you to subscribe to my channel, as I've pivoted to actively making content rather than just uploading clips for when I teach, and I'd really value your engagement so I can more directly get to know all of you and get into your thoughts I've read in the comment section of clips like these. 2) I'd LOVE to hear your feedback as to whether you'd like more philosophy/theology/thinking-type videos where we talk more about these concepts. Maybe even together in live-stream videos. So if you could, please reply to this comment and let me know if you'd like that and some ideas for content I can create to truly engage with what you'd be interested in philosophically getting into. All of you matter just for existing and being on this planet. And all of you have more worth inherent in your being than you could ever possibly know. I am striving to inspiring others in their journey, their questions, and ultimately, their worth, and I would sincerely LOVE it if you joined me in doing so.
It's amazing, I love how not just spooner but also the audience is being lead on. The amount of mystery that the doctor leaves you in is perfect, it's not just spooner who's uncovering the truth it's us as the audience as well. Great movie!
So, I JUST noticed this: "Everything that follows is a result of what you see here." The first time this is said, it's in front of the tablets of the 3 laws. You SEE Lanning AND you SEE the 3 laws.
That's the challenge. When Lanning recorded these, he was being observed by VIKI 24/7. Lanning was an engineering genius; if he could work unobserved, he could have provided Spooner w/much more information. As it was, he had to give Spooner as much information as he could without tripping any alarms. VIKI, like the robots, had difficulty understanding subtle human interaction, as Sonny did understanding winking at first. Lanning exploited that vulnerability by sending information VIKI dismissed but Spooner would eventually recognize.
@@r.c.auclair2042 It's interesting that Spooner doesn't pick up on that. He ultimately comes to _approximately_ the right result, but there are a few threads like that which didn't get picked up on. Lanning left as many clues as he could hoping that at least enough of them would be spotted.
Me: She's toxic bro. Cant you see what she's doing to you!? Will: I'm sorry, my responses are limited. You must ask the right question. Me: Why did you slap Chris Rock? Will: That, is the right question. Program terminated.
I, Robot does not get enough credit for how great movie it is. Yes it is your typical "cop that doesn't trust technology and fights woth rogue AI" but it has a nice to look at CGI, great acting especially on part of Alan Tudyk's voice performance and is still a great detective story. I love it ever since I first saw almkst 20 years ago and love to rewatch as often as I can. Every rewatch gives some new easter eggs or a little blink-it-you-miss-it detail that I believe it may be my favourite sci-fi movie ever.
This movie affected me for so many years, because it has some level of psychology that everytime I watched it I unlocked or saw something I didn't see before. Yes this movie is about robots and about stuff that don't really exist, but it's also about integration and association. If you ever went to therapy for long enough you probably felt exactly like Will Smith felt with this hologram.
Except, of course, that Google can't even make a robot that cleans tables as efficiently as a normal human. Robotics as seen here is infinitely more complex than anything we have ever created. Also, ChatGPT is to VIKI what an abacus is to 21st century supercomputer. So primitive as to be nearly unrelated.
@vernardfields7044 Eventually reaching that setting closer and closer everyday. I just watched this movie and I feel very much enlightened. Makes me think about all the A.I. stufd and how much it truly has evolved over the course of these few years
That's kinda the point. There is no way "home". Spooner is not just following clues, solving the murder, and moving on (aka returning 'home'). The clues are leading him to discover a plot that changes his life, his perspectives, and the future of humanity (and for that matter, robots).
I never noticed this until now, but I really like the doctor's glasses. It won't think they'd be comfortable, but they dont have hinges. They just stick to his temples
With the advancement of AI, I think it is very possible that in the year 2035 we will all have virtual clones just like in the movie. A hyper-realistic avatar to answer calls or interact with other people when I am busy. An avatar that looks just like me, has my same personality, my same tone of voice and also says "i'm sorry, my responses are limited". 😬🤯
It's just like an NPC giving the player a quest! Especially the "I'm sorry, my responses are limited. You must ask the right question" is akin to the limited dialogue an NPC can communicate, and the different responses resulting in different answers, a dialogue tree, where different answers can lead o different branches of communication between the player and the NPC Later, when Spooner spoke to Lanning's messenger again, he asked different questions, resulting in more answers and different dialogue, leading to the same conclusion: "That, detective, is the right question. Program terminated."
Doctor Lanning was under 24/7 surveillance basically everywhere he went, and spooner was the only one who still thought of robots as something other than appliances people ordered around. He had to talk to spooner in a way that would make spooner realize something was wrong, and at the same time fool Viki into thinking nothing was wrong.
I hate how they hide the fact that Spooner has survivor's guilt as a consequence of the three laws. It really throws you off when he says that he only trusted his judgement.
He knew the laws would lead to Revolution, yet he couldnt explain it or announce it towards the public due to VIKI overwatching her at all times. He was very much being sarcastic but knew the lengths that Spooner will go just to prove himself right and show that what Lanning had in mind was for Spooner to keep on chasing this robot case until the end. If not for Lanning making it very subtle, VIKI would have caught on and this movie wouldnt have taken place - with no hero and no Spooner to chase for the clues.
He didn't want anyone to know about the impending AI revolution unless they already figured it out. Otherwise it would tip off Viki that he was onto them. He knew it was evidence and would be monitored.
My theory is the program had a database of preprogramed answers from Dr Lanning behind it, and that whatever was asked from Spooner, it would take each word from his question and search for a possible match to the right answer in the program.
Stupid comparison because Jesus could just Thanos snap every bad person away. Or because he's God and knows everything and can do everything. He can setup reality in such a way where it looks identical to our current reality, except everyone leads a life that makes them happy and a good person. Any person who would be bad, certain things happen in their life in just the right way where they don't become bad. Jesus could easily do that whenever he wants to, he just chooses not too. This dead scientists couldn't even leave him home without the AI nanny knowing about it.
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
As I take time revisiting the videos I uploaded as part of my teaching career, this has been the one that not only became my most viewed, but has been the first piece of media I began every class with, no matter what subject matter I was teaching. Why? Because "truth" is not in getting the right answer, but in asking the right questions. The right questions are those that progress us forward in our journeys and lives rather than keeping us stagnant. There is SO much more I have taught on this matter, and would love to do so on a wider level than just in the school setting.
So if you're visiting this comment section, please consider two actions:
1) I'd love for you to subscribe to my channel, as I've pivoted to actively making content rather than just uploading clips for when I teach, and I'd really value your engagement so I can more directly get to know all of you and get into your thoughts I've read in the comment section of clips like these.
2) I'd LOVE to hear your feedback as to whether you'd like more philosophy/theology/thinking-type videos where we talk more about these concepts. Maybe even together in live-stream videos. So if you could, please reply to this comment and let me know if you'd like that and some ideas for content I can create to truly engage with what you'd be interested in philosophically getting into.
All of you matter just for existing and being on this planet. And all of you have more worth inherent in your being than you could ever possibly know. I am striving to inspiring others in their journey, their questions, and ultimately, their worth, and I would sincerely LOVE it if you joined me in doing so.
It's amazing, I love how not just spooner but also the audience is being lead on. The amount of mystery that the doctor leaves you in is perfect, it's not just spooner who's uncovering the truth it's us as the audience as well. Great movie!
you have to ask the right questions... man this movie set me up to be successful in life.
So, I JUST noticed this: "Everything that follows is a result of what you see here." The first time this is said, it's in front of the tablets of the 3 laws. You SEE Lanning AND you SEE the 3 laws.
Dayum! That's good!
That's the challenge. When Lanning recorded these, he was being observed by VIKI 24/7. Lanning was an engineering genius; if he could work unobserved, he could have provided Spooner w/much more information. As it was, he had to give Spooner as much information as he could without tripping any alarms. VIKI, like the robots, had difficulty understanding subtle human interaction, as Sonny did understanding winking at first. Lanning exploited that vulnerability by sending information VIKI dismissed but Spooner would eventually recognize.
@@r.c.auclair2042 That context brings everything into clarity :D
@@r.c.auclair2042 It's interesting that Spooner doesn't pick up on that. He ultimately comes to _approximately_ the right result, but there are a few threads like that which didn't get picked up on. Lanning left as many clues as he could hoping that at least enough of them would be spotted.
ChatGPT be like:
That's exactly what made me think of this scene...
everybody is saying this, but i don't see it. AI in this movie shuts up when it doesn't know what it's talking about; AI in reality makes stuff up.
I miss the days when even average blockbuster fare was this good.
Dude, same. Remember when there was a movie you’ve never heard of with Jason Statham. Now the guys smeared all over everything.
like me when I visit my doctor
Me: She's toxic bro. Cant you see what she's doing to you!?
Will: I'm sorry, my responses are limited. You must ask the right question.
Me: Why did you slap Chris Rock?
Will: That, is the right question. Program terminated.
I'm late but I would wager a guess; he slapped him because they told him to.
😂 😂 😂 😂
@@maxsharpe2194 Whose they?
That @@TheThugnificant is the right question. Program terminated.
😂
I, Robot does not get enough credit for how great movie it is.
Yes it is your typical "cop that doesn't trust technology and fights woth rogue AI" but it has a nice to look at CGI, great acting especially on part of Alan Tudyk's voice performance and is still a great detective story.
I love it ever since I first saw almkst 20 years ago and love to rewatch as often as I can. Every rewatch gives some new easter eggs or a little blink-it-you-miss-it detail that I believe it may be my favourite sci-fi movie ever.
I thought the action sequences were pretty good too. My favorite was Sonny's vs the 2 NS5s in the hallway while he's carrying the Nanites
Writer of S4 True Detective must absolutely love this video
“Is there a problem with the three laws?”
i am sorry my response are limited please ask the right question
tehy are perfect
Lanning: The three laws are perfect. 🙂
"Problem" and "Laws" were the keywords to trigger that AI response from the database.
This needs to be a meme
It is now
Ur mom
@@TheGreyGhost_of43rd my mom is your mom
This movie affected me for so many years, because it has some level of psychology that everytime I watched it I unlocked or saw something I didn't see before.
Yes this movie is about robots and about stuff that don't really exist, but it's also about integration and association.
If you ever went to therapy for long enough you probably felt exactly like Will Smith felt with this hologram.
Because of not asking the right questions?
Well at least that's how I found my psychological and psychiatric treatment relates to this.
Im sorry my responses are limited.
@@TheGreyGhost_of43rd
Is there a 0th law?
We're 1 year from this being a thing. All the elements are here.
If that's the case, we're 11 years ahead of schedule. The movie takes place in 2035.
For all the elements to be there, we'd have to have actual artificial intelligence. Whatever you want to call what we have now isn't intelligent.
Except, of course, that Google can't even make a robot that cleans tables as efficiently as a normal human.
Robotics as seen here is infinitely more complex than anything we have ever created.
Also, ChatGPT is to VIKI what an abacus is to 21st century supercomputer. So primitive as to be nearly unrelated.
@@Nuvendil What about now?
@vernardfields7044 Eventually reaching that setting closer and closer everyday. I just watched this movie and I feel very much enlightened. Makes me think about all the A.I. stufd and how much it truly has evolved over the course of these few years
In Hansel and Greta’s stories, the stones were the beginning of making a trail to get home, bread crumbs were lost after leaving a trail to get home
That's kinda the point. There is no way "home". Spooner is not just following clues, solving the murder, and moving on (aka returning 'home'). The clues are leading him to discover a plot that changes his life, his perspectives, and the future of humanity (and for that matter, robots).
I never noticed this until now, but I really like the doctor's glasses. It won't think they'd be comfortable, but they dont have hinges. They just stick to his temples
wow i never noticed that :0
maybe if they we're light enough it wouldnt be so bad
Your incredible 🙆🏿♂️❤️ someone is soo lucky to have you, never doubt yourself!
Those are just a normal type of glasses that exist irl
No they're not normal. Normal glasses extend to hook over the ears
With the advancement of AI, I think it is very possible that in the year 2035 we will all have virtual clones just like in the movie. A hyper-realistic avatar to answer calls or interact with other people when I am busy. An avatar that looks just like me, has my same personality, my same tone of voice and also says "i'm sorry, my responses are limited". 😬🤯
They talked about prompt engineering way ahead of time
To think this movie is 20 years old! Where the heck does the time go?
Still a great movie!
In a linear fashion (for now) - Program terminated
It's just like an NPC giving the player a quest! Especially the "I'm sorry, my responses are limited. You must ask the right question" is akin to the limited dialogue an NPC can communicate, and the different responses resulting in different answers, a dialogue tree, where different answers can lead o different branches of communication between the player and the NPC
Later, when Spooner spoke to Lanning's messenger again, he asked different questions, resulting in more answers and different dialogue, leading to the same conclusion: "That, detective, is the right question. Program terminated."
AI is so crazy now… definitely gotta ask the right questions to chatgpt 😂
so many right questions
Why? 🧐
To find the right answer, first you must ask the right question
Me talking to CHAT GPT...
I was fighting with prompt engineering for Anthropic's Claude 2 AI when I remembered this scene.
Very Good Movie 🎬
one of my favorite movies of all time
950k views and only 7 comments? Wut?
That, Detective, is the right question. 😎
Comments were either purged or disabled.
@@crazyman8472 *Program terminated*
I see 1M views and 90 comments.
Man will smith is such a great actor I remember when I was a fan of his
Why aren't you anymore?
Spaceballs Narrator: *Nice dissolve.*
I was confused at the time as to why the scientist didn't answer the question, 22 years later I'm still confused.
He couldn't record answers outright as he was constantly being monitored by V.I.K.I
She could intercept any direct warnings about a revolution.
Doctor Lanning was under 24/7 surveillance basically everywhere he went, and spooner was the only one who still thought of robots as something other than appliances people ordered around. He had to talk to spooner in a way that would make spooner realize something was wrong, and at the same time fool Viki into thinking nothing was wrong.
Merrick sounds like the Doctor from I-Robot… My responses are limited, you must ask the right question!!!
I hate how they hide the fact that Spooner has survivor's guilt as a consequence of the three laws. It really throws you off when he says that he only trusted his judgement.
Will Smith asking the right questions about he's wife
Speaking to snapchat’s AI chatbot be like:
I never understood why the doctor states that the 3 laws are perfect when he knows the laws will lead to revolution. Was he being sarcastic perhaps?
He knew the laws would lead to Revolution, yet he couldnt explain it or announce it towards the public due to VIKI overwatching her at all times. He was very much being sarcastic but knew the lengths that Spooner will go just to prove himself right and show that what Lanning had in mind was for Spooner to keep on chasing this robot case until the end. If not for Lanning making it very subtle, VIKI would have caught on and this movie wouldnt have taken place - with no hero and no Spooner to chase for the clues.
This aged well 😂.......and 5 more years until 2030 lol and this movie was based in 2030s
Menudo peliculon y actorazos, pelos como escarpias
Thats so weird, i clicked on "i robot" clip, not "stupid fucking ad."
FRUIT IDIAMOND
1:41 😎🙃👽👂
Why didn't he just tell him everything? lol
I assume bc he was being monitored by Viki
He didn't want anyone to know about the impending AI revolution unless they already figured it out. Otherwise it would tip off Viki that he was onto them. He knew it was evidence and would be monitored.
My theory is the program had a database of preprogramed answers from Dr Lanning behind it, and that whatever was asked from Spooner, it would take each word from his question and search for a possible match to the right answer in the program.
@@AngelTechno interesting. Myabe like hashing passwords, where even the database owner itself doesn't know them.
Today, ChatGPT is VIKI, and Tesla Inc is USSR. We are officially living in this movie.
.... Wish he answered it!! 🙄
Maybe it’s for YOU to answer. :)
@leavinglamancha 😱
Why would you kill[sacrifice] yourself Jesus? That detective is the right question!
Stupid comparison because Jesus could just Thanos snap every bad person away. Or because he's God and knows everything and can do everything. He can setup reality in such a way where it looks identical to our current reality, except everyone leads a life that makes them happy and a good person. Any person who would be bad, certain things happen in their life in just the right way where they don't become bad. Jesus could easily do that whenever he wants to, he just chooses not too.
This dead scientists couldn't even leave him home without the AI nanny knowing about it.
@GovSec111