Replacing Bright

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 12 июн 2024
  • So I removed some of my readings that had bright in them from my channel. This is a replacement using Shaw.
    I wrote it. The link is here: scp-wiki.wikidot.com/dr-shaw-...
    Buy my stuff here: scpstore.org/collections/dr-c...
    Support me via Patreon here: / dcimmerian
    Check out the community discord here: / discord
    Check me out on the tweeters: / dcimmerian
    This work is licensed creative commons 4.0 attribution/share alike.
    All SCP wiki works are licensed creative commons 3.0 attribution/share alike.
    The image of Doctor Cimmerian was created by Perelka_L.
    Channel art was created by TheVolgun
    Thumbnail image of Doctor Cimmerian was commissioned from Lord Bung.
  • РазвлеченияРазвлечения

Комментарии • 174

  • @HumanThePerson
    @HumanThePerson Год назад +211

    I am optimistic about how long this Fandom will survive. The very least is more than a decade if we don't encounter a huge scandal or controversy. What do you guys think?

    • @Drawoon
      @Drawoon Год назад +21

      Yeah, me too. There's a number of widely recognised scps keeping interest going, and people will keep wanting to make scp content for a good while I think.

    • @Marcharound
      @Marcharound Год назад +9

      Knock. On. Wood.

    • @Shadows_Of_Yhtyll
      @Shadows_Of_Yhtyll Год назад +27

      I mean, we've already lasted more than a decade, we've been going strong for roughly 16 years now, i don't think we're going anywhere anytime soon.

    • @hannahfanning9585
      @hannahfanning9585 Год назад +10

      I mean we've already encountered a number of scandals and controversies and we're still here, so I feel rather confident.

    • @randomcookieboy
      @randomcookieboy Год назад +5

      ...You do know this fandom has already existed for over a decade, right?

  • @Alex_Off-Beat
    @Alex_Off-Beat Год назад +168

    The fact that we already have a Dr. Rights and a Dr. Light makes this way more difficult than it has to be... 🤣

    • @beywheelzhater8930
      @beywheelzhater8930 Год назад +31

      Get read for Dr. Fight, former head of the SPC organization

    • @maddiesmenagerie8853
      @maddiesmenagerie8853 Год назад +5

      Dr. Yikes

    • @see4881
      @see4881 Год назад +13

      Dr. White starring heisenberg

    • @beywheelzhater8930
      @beywheelzhater8930 Год назад +7

      Dr. Goodnight, first ever person to sleep through a containment breach featuring multiple critical risk keter class anomalies

    • @Blastertronus
      @Blastertronus Год назад +5

      Dr. Blight, Atom Blight.

  • @MegaTang1234
    @MegaTang1234 Год назад +140

    RUclips and fan art are now the only proof a "Dr.Bright" existed.

    • @lazybones8962
      @lazybones8962 Год назад +29

      Yeah just youtube channels, fanart, older fanmade stories about or including him, new discussion from people who just haven't seen the news yet
      Okay maybe a little bit more

    • @something1600
      @something1600 Год назад +13

      Dr what? Never heard of him.

    • @emil1842
      @emil1842 Год назад +10

      No. There were just some authors that decided to change his name. There are still 100 plus articles on the site that include Dr Bright.

    • @capitanonox5159
      @capitanonox5159 Год назад +10

      Plus, some International Branches have openly refused to replace him.

  • @Mah-Boi
    @Mah-Boi Год назад +40

    Dr. Shaw is the same as Dr. Bright. So I don't see why people are saying Dr. Shaw is new.

    • @silent_stalker3687
      @silent_stalker3687 Год назад +12

      I’m confused
      Shaw was just made a few weeks ago so…

    • @spicytrashpanda
      @spicytrashpanda Год назад +21

      ​@@silent_stalker3687 yeah, you're watching Bright get 1984'd in real time.

    • @silent_stalker3687
      @silent_stalker3687 Год назад +10

      @@spicytrashpanda I just checked the wiki
      Who’s Bright?

    • @Mah-Boi
      @Mah-Boi Год назад +11

      @@silent_stalker3687 Oh it's just the name for Shaw before the event that shall not be named.

    • @zabianreubens4989
      @zabianreubens4989 Год назад +23

      @@silent_stalker3687 Dr bright was a character of whom was a self insert from a person who recently had been caught grooming children was renamed to dr shaw by many people who wrote stories involving him (mainly kaktus and Cimerian) to disassociate the two from eachother

  • @clauday6467
    @clauday6467 Год назад +35

    Now we can't make bright puns sadly

    • @clauday6467
      @clauday6467 Год назад +35

      I feel shawry for the character

    • @Ginjue
      @Ginjue Год назад +15

      ​@Clauday That's the spirit! Let's go Dr.Shawty!

    • @TheBearInTheChair
      @TheBearInTheChair Год назад +15

      Dr. Shaw has got a Bright future ahead of him

    • @tourmaverse
      @tourmaverse Год назад +8

      You never shaw that coming. ;)
      Ayyy?

    • @thousandsofclowns
      @thousandsofclowns Год назад +10

      This is just like that one book. Brighteen-eighty-four.

  • @wombat9793
    @wombat9793 Год назад +121

    I am quite fond of this new Shaw character

    • @something1600
      @something1600 Год назад +4

      Are they an immortal?

    • @emosquiddy5388
      @emosquiddy5388 Год назад +7

      >alternate universe where George Bernard Shaw is Dr. Bright

  • @GrubbsandWyrm
    @GrubbsandWyrm Год назад +39

    Don't need to kill baby Hitler. Just teach him how to be a good artist later so he doesn't flunk out of art school and has a better career path.

    • @thenexus8384
      @thenexus8384 Год назад +4

      He was a good artist

    • @GrubbsandWyrm
      @GrubbsandWyrm Год назад +2

      @thenexus8384 he could paint an entire apartment in one day! Two coats!

    • @thenexus8384
      @thenexus8384 Год назад

      @@GrubbsandWyrm ?

    • @salicaguillotines
      @salicaguillotines Год назад +8

      ​@@GrubbsandWyrm to think that he wouldn't have done all that stuff in WWII if he was allowed to go to art school and learned how to paint murals instead. To shame.

    • @thanotosomega
      @thanotosomega Год назад +5

      JK Rowling has taught us success in the arts does nothing to stifle hate, the only difference would have been people complaining about separating the art from the artist after the Holocaust

  • @whg_brianferguson
    @whg_brianferguson Год назад +26

    Y'know what? I respect the middle ground

  • @DianaHatter
    @DianaHatter Год назад +62

    Just noticed and learnt what happened with Bright, damn man

    • @hordelord4759
      @hordelord4759 Год назад +4

      what happened?

    • @nomnomgoblin8901
      @nomnomgoblin8901 Год назад +33

      @@hordelord4759 the IRL Dr. Bright decided to be an asshat, so instead of scrubbing the fictional Bright from the universe they're renaming them Shaw.

    • @hordelord4759
      @hordelord4759 Год назад +7

      @@nomnomgoblin8901 So Dr bright is no longer cannon?

    • @bryansalva8944
      @bryansalva8944 Год назад

      @@hordelord4759 #[REDACTED].) Dr. Bright is no longer allowed to be part of any other dimensional or pataphysical level where the Foundation is present.

    • @salicaguillotines
      @salicaguillotines Год назад +22

      ​@@hordelord4759 yes and no
      There's no one canon per say since there are so many timelines in SCP. You ou can say that in this case that Dr. Bright doesn't exist in Cimmerian's canon but Dr. Shaw does. :)

  • @theokkali467
    @theokkali467 Год назад +68

    ELIAS IS BETTER! He has more charm! and personality!

    • @youngelink4200
      @youngelink4200 Год назад +5

      not to mention there's also Dr Rights & Dr Light, so there's a bit more distinction from those characters name wise

  • @uglyweirdo1389
    @uglyweirdo1389 Год назад +33

    I love this. This is as least as good as with the other guy. The community needs what you've done with this to move on in a healthy way.
    It feels different in ways I can't seem to pinpoint. I and hopefully we could benefit quite a lot from hearing the two side by side and by the same person.
    I'm schizoeffective and it's getting harder to make sense. I apologize for sense that didn't make.
    Thank you for mypillskickedin

  • @abe-danger
    @abe-danger Год назад +17

    I still think the original ones should be archived under the "bright" files

  • @autobotCRSHR
    @autobotCRSHR Год назад +11

    So... Elias Shaw is going to be the new Jack Bright? Interesting...

  • @Detah_
    @Detah_ Год назад +6

    honestly the character of doctor bright is fucking hilarious and I hope we can separate the art from the artist. I still think deleting the list of things doctor bright is not allowed to do was wrong. What he did was horrible but still

  • @thefemboyslayer
    @thefemboyslayer Год назад +10

    Removing Bright over what the author did is a big circus act. All in the name of the protection of the readership.

  • @maxmatthews2463
    @maxmatthews2463 Год назад

    The council suggest not researching any 001 info.

  • @riphopfer5816
    @riphopfer5816 Год назад +9

    This was delight. Absolutely cracking, man; laughed mi arse off. I like most of your work, Cimmerian, but I think humour is your strongest suit. That’s just one man’s opinion, but I was once (20 years ago) a published short fiction author, having even published (NOT self-published) a collection. Your dialogue reminds me a bit of a blend of Douglas Adams and Todd McEwen, both of whom I respect highly-especially for the cadence of their dialogue. I HOPE this video isn’t demonetised; this is the kind of content of which RUclips needs MORE. To punish a grown adult writer for using adult language in his original work is ABSURDLY limiting, stifling, and antithetical to the spirit of creativity. Quality writing is rapidly becoming a lost art form, so I stand behind any effort to encourage it. That’s one of the reasons I feel strongly about SCP: It helps to make writers out of people who may never otherwise try their hand at the craft. It gets them accustomed to-first-writing in a structured manner, just as one might when writing a formal essay, and-second-learning to riff on that that structure to create ever more creative pieces.
    Anyroad, nice word, Doc. Hope you’re doing well, mate. Cheers!

  • @lunareclipse2401
    @lunareclipse2401 Год назад +76

    i think shaw is better so far. he's already much funnier

  • @loveyasine
    @loveyasine Год назад +9

    DR SHAW SWEEPSSSSSS

  • @cinnabunz1532
    @cinnabunz1532 Год назад +1

    I'm already eager too see more with this new character.

  • @noodles2459
    @noodles2459 Год назад +3

    This reminds me of the "are we the baddies skit"

  • @PTran-bv4tw
    @PTran-bv4tw Год назад +1

    THOSE "SWANN ENTITIES", DAMN!

    • @PTran-bv4tw
      @PTran-bv4tw Год назад +1

      Honestly, I still miss Bright. Of course I know what he did and he deserve to take back what he has done. But... something to me can not be replaced in memory. It's like discharge something that's very important and memorable to you...

  • @jabulinatheseal1406
    @jabulinatheseal1406 10 месяцев назад

    1:40 writing and delivery is hilarious here

  • @delfox1761
    @delfox1761 Год назад

    I'm glad it has come back!

  • @SamanthaVimes
    @SamanthaVimes Год назад

    I guess they need to have the next one take a ticket.

  • @Aftern00nTeaTime
    @Aftern00nTeaTime 11 месяцев назад

    In my opinion I think Dr. Elias Shaw has more potential to become a different character than a mere replacement, for example there was someone mentioning giving him a death journal where he writes his current death, kinda give him a unique personality in my opinion.

  • @duhmitryov
    @duhmitryov Год назад +4

    Still a classic.

  • @something1600
    @something1600 Год назад +1

    At least they have a chance to poison Stalin.

  • @angelcruz4870
    @angelcruz4870 Год назад +4

    lmao after i knew about those things, me and some fellow Redditors decided to make fanarts of Elias, we decided to give him a new appearance to make this even more effective.
    due to a lot of the old fan arts of the guy with green eyes, ginger/red hair, black glasses, green turtleneck and a modern lab coat still being affiliated with the previous name, we made him look much older and have different features. we changed his eye color to -bright- yellow, we made him have the same lab coat as Gears, but he puts the collar up kinda like Dracula's cape. we also made his hair a wavy black, and have these scars/tattoos on the left side of his face that looks kinda like cracks on his skin (maybe because of his connection to Able).
    he no longer wears glasses and some also redesigned his 963 (now 0963) to make it even more effective. they made it to have a more Aztec imagery with a yellow gem on the middle instead of the usual starburst pattern and red gem. i still like the old design tho, but that's just me lol, maybe because i made a replica of it and is currently wearing it rn. yes i wont die wearing this dont worry.
    please guys, make fanarts of him more, to those artists that's reading this comment. im also an artist so i decided to contribute, and you can too. you can look his name up on Google to see our depictions of as reference, and please make him hot. ty.

    • @CoolF41lur3
      @CoolF41lur3 10 месяцев назад +1

      Do you have a link where you upload your art? I want to see the necklace despite dr brights creator being a freak, I hope you changed the irl necklace design too, right?

  • @noodles2459
    @noodles2459 Год назад

    This would make a great skit

  • @notmebeingme461
    @notmebeingme461 Год назад +5

    A race to kill Hitler, noice.

  • @tourmaverse
    @tourmaverse Год назад +4

    I do like the name Elias.😅

  • @valcanoman1829
    @valcanoman1829 Месяц назад

    I love Dr. Jack Bright in the SCP Wiki and the SCP fandom because of his amazing goofy personality and stories but all good things have to come to an end for his author of the wiki who has absolutely abuse his admin powers to groom minors who is kicked out and have his author character avatar replaced by a different character who is like him in the same way.

  • @siilverREAL
    @siilverREAL Год назад +3

    how the fuck am i, unable to handle change due to mental illness, handling the name change better than everyone who complains its "literally 1984" 💀💀💀

  • @thejokerz9751
    @thejokerz9751 Год назад +1

    I agree with your decision

  • @electrobob992
    @electrobob992 6 месяцев назад

    Dr. Shaw could still work, without changing much of the original fictional character.
    For example he could have used an SCP to try to prevent his immortality, but it took his words a bit more literally.
    Like he asked "Make it so I, Dr. Jack Bright never touched SCP 963"
    But it just changed his name permanently, and makes it so no one can utter his name even himself. *Their heads explode, and those aside from himself will suffer memory loss if they survive.*
    Then add to his madness and have him using random names every time he gets a new body. Some standard, other outrageously hilarious.
    Of course have any entry mentioning his old name bring replaced with [REDACTED]

  • @Scarlet_Emperor
    @Scarlet_Emperor Год назад +10

    So Dr Shaw is gonna be a different character than Dr Bright or the same?

    • @moustrout1299
      @moustrout1299 Год назад +12

      same character just different name.

    • @Scarlet_Emperor
      @Scarlet_Emperor Год назад +5

      @@moustrout1299 Alright. Thanks for notifying

    • @TheBearInTheChair
      @TheBearInTheChair Год назад +7

      Honestly, it's a different character similar stories

    • @zabianreubens4989
      @zabianreubens4989 Год назад +14

      Technical different character same premises Same immortality Same wacky shenanigans BUT THIS TIME WITHOUT THE CHILD GROOMING! WAS QUITE THE DEAL

    • @Scarlet_Emperor
      @Scarlet_Emperor Год назад

      @@TheBearInTheChair Oh? So what makes him different than Dr Bright?

  • @crowemagnum1337
    @crowemagnum1337 Год назад

    Loved it.

  • @mopar1969ful
    @mopar1969ful Год назад +9

    I'm not going to lie, I've never really been a fan of the Dr Bright list, nor a fan of a lot of the usage of Dr Bright in general
    I love when he's portrayed as a serious scientist that can also be a bit of an eccentric (bordering on a little bit of mania), but more often than not I see him portrayed as the Foundation equivalent of Deadpool. And that just never really feels to me like it fits well at the SCP Foundation

  • @something1600
    @something1600 Год назад

    Is Shaw a flesh monster in When Day Breaks?

  • @Callsign_Saxon
    @Callsign_Saxon Год назад

    Okay I'm a bit out of the loop. What happend with Dr. Bright?

    • @TheBearInTheChair
      @TheBearInTheChair Год назад

      The original writer (theduckman) used Dr. Bright's name as a persona while being a complete degenerate, grooming, cyber bullying, etc etc....

    • @Callsign_Saxon
      @Callsign_Saxon Год назад

      @@TheBearInTheChair feck, that ain't right... cheers for letting me know

  • @Emberfist
    @Emberfist Год назад +3

    Elias is better in pretty much every way

  • @zabianreubens4989
    @zabianreubens4989 Год назад

    Better idea Dr kite

    • @jexmarro9
      @jexmarro9 Год назад

      Naaa people will claim that racist

  • @something1600
    @something1600 Год назад

    Is Dr Shaw also immortal?

  • @fallenstriker5472
    @fallenstriker5472 Год назад +1

    Idk man

  • @SpacePatrollerLaser
    @SpacePatrollerLaser Год назад

    Now you're Shan off. Whasn't that job assign to MTF Iota 8: code name "Hogan's Heroes"?

  • @metroprime6947
    @metroprime6947 Год назад +8

    Understand why you replaced him still don't like it

  • @sal6695
    @sal6695 Год назад +24

    I get that bright is a scumbag but i am NOT in favor of Damnatio Memoriae. Bright was a part of the foundation, a big one, and that cannot and should not be undone. The man himself didn't write the vast majority of the works about his character anyway

    • @immanuii
      @immanuii Год назад +1

      Yes, and that's why people aren't removing the character from their stories, but replacing him with another character that is exactly the same as the original one besides his name.
      Nothing is lost here. The character still is and will be a part of the foundation, the only thing that will happen is the character people love will be disassociated from the real horrible person. There's no reason to complain about this change so long as you're not a fan of the real life person (not a lot of people are, hopefully), or you're particularly fond of the name (people will get over it).

  • @something1600
    @something1600 Год назад +1

    For some reason I thought Shaw was a woman for some reason.

    • @CalvinNoire
      @CalvinNoire 11 месяцев назад

      Elias sounds like a girl name but I've never seen anyone who has that name so who am I to judge, what do you think?

  • @makaronzserem2062
    @makaronzserem2062 Год назад +6

    Maybe we should just replace all the SCP old guard and move on?

    • @jexmarro9
      @jexmarro9 Год назад +2

      Hell yeah, just yeet it all into the shitter and start clean 👍🏻

  • @SodaPopBarbecue
    @SodaPopBarbecue Год назад +8

    4chan will bitch, because they still feel entitled to influence on the Wiki.
    Ignore anyone who's complaining:They're either kids from content farms or 4chan demanding to be handed the keys to the wiki.

    • @salicaguillotines
      @salicaguillotines Год назад

      Now 4Chan is crying over how they're apparently "1984" the character and how that's all made up. Have they ran out of copium? They can cry harder!

    • @clauday6467
      @clauday6467 Год назад +2

      Tbh the scp wiki is also pretty cringe for letting this happen for so long this past few years

    • @advanced2431
      @advanced2431 Год назад +8

      I hope people realize that the only reason SCP exists in the first place is because of 4chan.

  • @_Mr.Black_
    @_Mr.Black_ Год назад +18

    Replacing bright with shaw is just like replacing fuck with frick, or shit with shoot. We all know what it means. We're adults here we don't need to do this

    • @TheBearInTheChair
      @TheBearInTheChair Год назад +5

      It doesn't change much, you're right about that, but the good Lord knows I've been through similar editing issues connected to some scandalous events that I played a hand in breaking up and I've had to leave behind those endeavors knowing that most my final contributions ended up on the draft room floor.
      Still doesn't make the Brights any less canon, a lot of material is out in the wild, I'm sure some writers will still try to submit works with them in it to be ethically weighted on the quality of the entries and filed appropriately.
      This is the moral choice in my honest opinion, however the ultimate fates of Dr. Shaw and Dr. Bright remains to be seen. What we do from now on out defines us as a community, the duckman will get his comeuppance just my opposite number number did, I just think we shouldn't be okay with completely 1984ing the character's story.

  • @meaghancampbell8109
    @meaghancampbell8109 Год назад +14

    You guys are doing a lot more as a writing franchise to mend fences and to not hurt people who have been victimized way better then other notable fantasy gernes (HARRY POTTER!!!!)

    • @uglyweirdo1389
      @uglyweirdo1389 Год назад +5

      Rowling writes fascist propaganda and openly endorses hate groups. The fandom tries to distance its optics from the name of its author. They still enthusiastically spread and defend it.
      Bright is a mo and completely erases his name from everything and replaces it to preserve his victims and the wonderful work of people who used the character under false pretenses.
      DR. C and the rest of the community that can are to help people.
      We are nothing like the HP fandom.

    • @meaghancampbell8109
      @meaghancampbell8109 Год назад +6

      @UglyWeirdo that's what I'm saying...I mean this franchise is so much smaller with such fewer resources and cares for its fans so much more...it's frankly amazing.

    • @uglyweirdo1389
      @uglyweirdo1389 Год назад +4

      @@meaghancampbell8109 I suppose my point was they aren't doing anything at all and your phrasing implied they were. I probably a misinterpreted. Lemme retry.
      This is way more effort and care than a more public and accountable fandom doing this same thing. Like how Paizo is acknowledging and working to change the horrible.
      Antipsychotics hitting like a truck that maybe makes no sense. I like this and so do you. We're cool.

    • @salicaguillotines
      @salicaguillotines Год назад +2

      It's really refreshing for the community to come together like this!

    • @meaghancampbell8109
      @meaghancampbell8109 Год назад +1

      @UglyWeirdo dude I'm working my backshift and I'm in the middle of moving so I'm overtired so I'm nor wording things good
      ..are we cool yet....lol

  • @SRWOtaku
    @SRWOtaku Год назад +16

    Eilas Shaw.... doesn't has the same impact as Jack Bright....
    Cimmerian, this feels.... wrong....

    • @GustavoRubio
      @GustavoRubio Год назад +10

      Give it time

    • @clauday6467
      @clauday6467 Год назад +2

      @@GustavoRubio I hope time will fix it

    • @Marcharound
      @Marcharound Год назад +13

      It’s just a matter of being used to Bright. Just like we did Bright, we’ll get adjusted to Shaw soon enough. Only a matter of time.

    • @SRWOtaku
      @SRWOtaku Год назад +3

      @@GustavoRubio but what if, despite trying to give it time, it still feels wrong? What then?

    • @spicytrashpanda
      @spicytrashpanda Год назад +5

      ​@@SRWOtaku then it means you're a free thinker. What you're experiencing is the side effects of a long cherished character getting 1984'd in real time. It's rough the first time, but your senses will dull with time.

  • @tarbamichaelwijesunderajr
    @tarbamichaelwijesunderajr Год назад +1

    Dr Cimmerian Help!!! How To Replace The SMG4 Djkaktus