this is why you shouldn't include "SM copying......" in videos like these, when all these years it's HYBE ang almost the whole K-pop industry that's always copying them
[Note]: The update about Taemin’s album isn’t meant to bring in any unnecessary hate towards him. With that said, I’m just discussing what netizens have been talking about recently. Although I personally understand that concepts can be recycled, redone, and so on, this update is simply about how fans of HYBE reacted when Taemin’s teaser was dropped. I shared both perspectives to the issue, but I definitely should have explained a bit more in Taemin’s defence. That didn’t even cross my mind at the time of filming, as I was simply covering the issue broadly. But now that I’ve seen even more details, I acknowledge that I could have presented the topic a bit better. Also in the title I stated, “SM copies BTS’s V?” and I wanted to emphasize that this isn’t a standalone statement. I added a question mark so that I could go into it more in the video. Saying “SM copies BTS’ V” would stand as a statement and a fact if it were worded that way. I left it more open-ended with the question format and let the viewers thing what they wanted. Again, I should have presented some more details in Taemin’s defence and I sincerely apologize if that hurt anyone. I hope this clears some things up✨
Did anyone missing the point here? V's latest album is produced by NJ's creative director-Min Hee Jin. She was from SM. I saw a lot of concepts earlier made within SM are being used or recycled. MHJ seemed to popularized these SM's concepts even after she left SM. Why is it hard to understand now. Concepts can be recycled! Nothing is wrong with that. What went wrong is when Hybe stan coming at SM stan accusing bunch of SM idols copying their idols. Like wth, you guys didnt even exist yet when SM came up with these concepts back then for FX, Shine or even the earlier gen from SM. Learn the kpop history ppl. Kpop fans nowdays are bunch of crazy kids who like to create wars with other fandoms. Hey Hybe stan, your idols didnt invent anything! Your idols just popularize or recycle existing concepts which exist long time ago. Get real
What do you mean? Taemin simply followed the style SHINee had been doing for years. If it’s similar to V’s album, then it means V copied SHINee’s concept. Or you can blame the former SM producer that worked on V’s album for transferring their concepts. Please get more details and facts before you do reports like this
Hi there! I never said Taemin copied V. These reports are not my own thoughts. I’m just reporting on what others are talking about from an outside perspective. Of course, Taemin himself has nothing to do with this. It’s definitely on the staff/producers. I understand where you’re coming from completely, but I’m just covering what others are discussing. I personally don’t think it’s plagiarism, since Shinee has always had concepts like this for years. But to remain unbiased, I refrain from sharing my own thoughts and just report from the outside. I hope this makes sense✨
@@kdramanotes I understand that you’re just presenting information on what is going on without putting your own personal opinion. I’m just saying, if you want to ask people what they think, then they should be presented with the full information. That’s where reporting work comes in. There’s some extent of investigation that you’re required to do, so that when people see your news, they see the holistic picture and they’re not jumping into the wrong conclusions based on the minimal information presented. As you have presented views of Armys talking about the plagiarism, you could have also presented views of Shawols debunking it, and let the viewers decide which side makes more sense to them. That’s a better approach. I hope you understand where I’m coming from
@@siriusk9769 I did add some brief tweets covering the other perspective, but I could have definitely gone more into it. My apologies for that. I will keep this in mind moving forward. I’m not a professional journalist by any means, and I’m still picking up on ways to present things as properly as I can. This comment helps a lot, thank you so much✨
It was definitely a new carats asking silly questions like that.
I feel so sorry for Beomhan..
this is why you shouldn't include "SM copying......" in videos like these, when all these years it's HYBE ang almost the whole K-pop industry that's always copying them
[Note]: The update about Taemin’s album isn’t meant to bring in any unnecessary hate towards him. With that said, I’m just discussing what netizens have been talking about recently. Although I personally understand that concepts can be recycled, redone, and so on, this update is simply about how fans of HYBE reacted when Taemin’s teaser was dropped. I shared both perspectives to the issue, but I definitely should have explained a bit more in Taemin’s defence. That didn’t even cross my mind at the time of filming, as I was simply covering the issue broadly. But now that I’ve seen even more details, I acknowledge that I could have presented the topic a bit better. Also in the title I stated, “SM copies BTS’s V?” and I wanted to emphasize that this isn’t a standalone statement. I added a question mark so that I could go into it more in the video. Saying “SM copies BTS’ V” would stand as a statement and a fact if it were worded that way. I left it more open-ended with the question format and let the viewers thing what they wanted. Again, I should have presented some more details in Taemin’s defence and I sincerely apologize if that hurt anyone. I hope this clears some things up✨
Did anyone missing the point here? V's latest album is produced by NJ's creative director-Min Hee Jin. She was from SM. I saw a lot of concepts earlier made within SM are being used or recycled. MHJ seemed to popularized these SM's concepts even after she left SM. Why is it hard to understand now. Concepts can be recycled! Nothing is wrong with that. What went wrong is when Hybe stan coming at SM stan accusing bunch of SM idols copying their idols. Like wth, you guys didnt even exist yet when SM came up with these concepts back then for FX, Shine or even the earlier gen from SM. Learn the kpop history ppl. Kpop fans nowdays are bunch of crazy kids who like to create wars with other fandoms. Hey Hybe stan, your idols didnt invent anything! Your idols just popularize or recycle existing concepts which exist long time ago. Get real
Great points, thank you for sharing!
@@kdramanotes you're welcome 🥰
Thank you for your hard work. I always love your videos and the way they're made ! 💖
I also love your commentary too, you sound so cool ! Keep it up ✨
Thank you so much!! I really appreciate the kind words🤍
What do you mean? Taemin simply followed the style SHINee had been doing for years. If it’s similar to V’s album, then it means V copied SHINee’s concept. Or you can blame the former SM producer that worked on V’s album for transferring their concepts. Please get more details and facts before you do reports like this
Hi there! I never said Taemin copied V. These reports are not my own thoughts. I’m just reporting on what others are talking about from an outside perspective. Of course, Taemin himself has nothing to do with this. It’s definitely on the staff/producers. I understand where you’re coming from completely, but I’m just covering what others are discussing. I personally don’t think it’s plagiarism, since Shinee has always had concepts like this for years. But to remain unbiased, I refrain from sharing my own thoughts and just report from the outside. I hope this makes sense✨
@@kdramanotes I understand that you’re just presenting information on what is going on without putting your own personal opinion. I’m just saying, if you want to ask people what they think, then they should be presented with the full information. That’s where reporting work comes in. There’s some extent of investigation that you’re required to do, so that when people see your news, they see the holistic picture and they’re not jumping into the wrong conclusions based on the minimal information presented. As you have presented views of Armys talking about the plagiarism, you could have also presented views of Shawols debunking it, and let the viewers decide which side makes more sense to them. That’s a better approach. I hope you understand where I’m coming from
@@siriusk9769 I did add some brief tweets covering the other perspective, but I could have definitely gone more into it. My apologies for that. I will keep this in mind moving forward. I’m not a professional journalist by any means, and I’m still picking up on ways to present things as properly as I can. This comment helps a lot, thank you so much✨
@@kdramanotes Thanks for being understanding and accommodating 🤗