East German Guards at the Neue Wache and Soviet March "Comrades, Let's March Bravely"
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 апр 2022
- The tradition of guards stationed at the Neue Wache is a long standing German tradition that has spanned over 80 years, under multiple different regimes. From the Reichswehr, to the Wehrmacht, to the Volksarmee and finally today's Bundeswehr.
This goosestep looks more closely related to the Wehrmacht era because the late 1970’s (to 1989) East German Neue Wache drill march is much slower and the legs kick much higher.
early era? the hand doesnt move as high as late era. I personally take this drill the best verion, the hand tidened but doesnt wave as high as in soviet drills, and of course the goose step is absolutely amazing.
by hand tidened I mean not forming a blade shape
@@Jasminsamb dude he means the steps not the hand. The goosestep is still german but the shoulder swing is definitely soviet style.
and, the nva parade formation uses soviet style (a tight square line without people carrying swords in the far right row) with a prussian goose step(the feet are lifted first before walking, unlike the soviets where the feet have to take a step as far as possible)
even though the hands are soviet style (first row formation when nva carries daggers(?) when they haven't done a salute (I don't know what's the name) to the honecker
f:goose step nva is getting lower every year
I'm not sure I recalled this correctly but there was speak of abolishing the Prussian style marching and going full Soviet but the German military leaders said that the German march music was too fast for Soviet/Russian style marches.
That's how to do it, excellent drill, and very well trained soldiers. The last German army with style.
Definitely the essence of German military tradition on display.
Good thing that shithole "country" has been terminated. For ever.
Absolutely. The Bundeswehr is a yawn fest with drill being the least of their problems. Self-Defeat and Self-Hatred never does yield positive results.
Love to see these old videos. Everyone is so well-dressed and thin.
Nun ja, die hatten ja nichts.
I remember watching that ceremony back in 1970 god it makes one feel old
It must take lots of practice to hold that rifle almost completely vertically without dropping it while marching
Bruh how have i found you memelord ho chi meme
Frage lieber nicht. Was wir geübt haben.
And at the end your kneese are broken.
@@janvanholten7592 Bullshit
@@janvanholten7592 Yeah. I did some time in the British RAF reserves and was always told explicitly not to stamp hard as it would fuck your knees and ankles.
These helemts are brilliant.i bought one from croatia for 1,20€ but shipping was 25€ .still worth everypenny
How did you find one like that? What website did you use?
Ugly ass helmets
what site did you buy it from?
Ebay
@@estonianchauvinistk.s.p3864 привет, может ты меня будешь недолюбливать.
но ты говоришь по русский ?
Remember seeing this in 1988. I was mightily impressed by the whole thing
That's awesome! How did the military band sound? Do you remember?
@@MaximusandHistory awww I wish there had been the military band. We got to the Neu Wache just prior to the guard changing. We went inside to take a look.
Then outside they marched along from inside a big old building, and conducted the guard change.
Their build & the smartness of their uniforms were what really impressed me. The precision of their drill was impeccable. And I distinctly remember thinking(as just a wee lad) are these the type of men we will have to fight 🤣 It wasn’t a confident thought
@@anthonywalsh7613 I've had so many former NATO soldiers leave comments on my videos explaining how they were somewhat distraught by the precision of the NVA and that they would have to potentially fight them in a theoretical war.
What's interesting is that NATO rated the NVA as the most combat ready, well trained and disciplined army in the entire Warsaw Pact!
@@MaximusandHistory interesting that mate.
When you see it close up it brings it home much more.
Plus we were issued with information (pamphlets) explaining the capabilities
I remember watching them changing the guard here back in 1986 when I was in the RAF and we visited East Berlin.
Thank you for leaving a comment!
I get many comments on my videos from former NATO & Warsaw pact soldiers, its very surreal as I was born a decade after the Cold War ended!
Thank you for the great video.
This is really old? Not even construction of the Palast der Republik!
Thank you so much for sharing.
They did march bravely.
that Goosestep MEANS BUSSINESS!!
Brüder zur Sonne, zur Freiheit
Brüder in Zechen und Gruben /;=)
@@frankcoala5890 based
Es gibt keine Brüder...nur Gegner ! Mache was besser als andere und schon hast du Feinde !
THE BEST VERSION OF GERMANY
A Germany without freedom, killing those who wanted to leave it and ready to serve one of thé bloodiest dictatures in history ? No thanks !
Ehhhhh
@Sanctus Paulus 1962 lol they were one of the world's most developed nations in terms of HDI.
Nazi Germany hold my beer
worst version 🚮
Ich war als Ernst Thälmann Pionier Mal vor Ort. Unsere Klasse wurde ein Mal in den Palast der Republik eingeladen. Dabei haben wir auch den Wachwechsel mit angesehen.Der Stechschritt ist preußisch. Die Russen versuchen ihn zu übernehmen. Er passte aber nicht zu ihrer Marschmusik. Also ließ man's seien. Denn Preußischen Gloria auf dem roten Platz zu spielen, wäre wohl nicht so gut angekommen.
А сейчас Германия подстилка сша. У немцев ничего нет, они зависят что им скажут из за сша.
Hi
@@ernstthalmann4306 Tag
Preußens Gloria wurde schon auf dem Roten Platz gespielt, von der Bundeswehr.
@@chrisyuriy4410 ja jetzt. Aber nicht während der Zeit des Kalten Krieges.
There is not any soviet march!
The 1st is "Präsentiermarsch der Nationalen Volksarmee", composed by Alfred Pechau, the 2nd is "Brüder, zur Sonne, zur Freiheit", the German adaptation of a Russian song of 1895/96:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Br%C3%BCder,_zur_Sonne,_zur_Freiheit_(Brothers,_to_the_Sun,_to_Freedom)
The 2nd tune is copied from Comrades Let’s March Bravely
War der Präsentiermarsch nicht etwas zu schnell?
@@uliquast1422 Ich meine: nein.
Gerade für den Präsentiermarsch der NVA gibt es bei RUclips zahllose Beispiele; bei Veranstaltungen, mit grünem Hintergrund mit Erwähnung aller Instrumente im Zentralen Musikchorps und beim Historischen Platzkonzert zur 750-Jahr-Feier 1987.
Perfection ❤👍 with burder zur sonne zur freiheit... 😊
can i use this video for my intro?
Yes, just give credit
Regardless this peculiar change of guard, it would be interesting for me to know if there is any book related to military aestethics.
Ich wünsche mir diese Zeit zurück.
Wir hatten wenig Sorgen.
Viel Ärgerliches, aber wenig Sorgen, schon gar keine Furcht vor der Zukunft. Und heute? Sorgen , Ängste und gewolltes Desaster. " Zeitenwende". Als entscheiden Zeiten....
Militar balet. Art.
Magnifique Armée Populaire Nationale de la D.D.R. !
❤❤
Это последняя прусия,нет сейчас ФРГ,дух нетот
Brüder zur Sonne, zur Freiheit.🕊
do you have the full version of this film?
No, sorry!
what a pity
Как всегда чётко
Uber alles!
Uber? This taxi service didn't exist back then!
Гитлеры приходят и уходят, а германский народ остаётся, как говорил товарищ Сталин.
Its greatt
Jesus, that would hurt the shit out of my shins.
Hmm where have I seen this before
....i'am sorry, it's the original "Wachablösung" like in 1943...in front of " Reichskanzlei"
better than german now
its true!
💯%
❤️❤️❤️
🌹🌹🌹
So beautiful! The dear feeling about GDR is back.
Yeah,i miss those stazi terrorists.
I love 🇻🇳 🇻🇳
Love from America
Socialism will win!
Bravo bravo!!!
Смело товарищи в ногу ,духом окрепнем в борьбе ,в царство свободы дорогу ,грудью проложим себе.
А реализация? Да..такой хоккей нам не нужен...)))
@@volterosein3956 песня написана еще в те времена, когда даже крушение царизма было неосуществимо. Никто не предполагал, что спустя 100 лет даже режим Коли Тряпкина будет казаться мягким и либеральным в сравнении с последующими.
Так что ничего удивительно, что дорогу так и не проложили.
The early NVA uniforms with closed collars are better than the later uniform with open collars.
I agree, the open collar was a ditch from tradition!
1984/85 hat man den Kragen auch geschlossen getragen ! Es war der Winterbefehl !@@MaximusandHistory
Those Germans sure love their marching.
Those were no Germans, those were puppets of socialism
@@agorazontas5894 and the west is the puppet of capitalism
@@agorazontas5894The real Germany is already dead.
I prefer the GDR when it comes to the military, both the GDR and the FRG were puppets of the great powers, but at least the GDR kept the German military tradition.
@@weitnerscheckanberden4405 Yes, the German values and military traditions, that led Germany into 2 World Wars, antisemitism and the Holocaust. Congrats! May I call you a revanchist?
@@agorazontas5894world war 1 was caused by the death of an Austrian arch duke, has nothing to do with Germany's traditions. Idk what are you yapping about
„Soviet march“
Gose steps is a Prussian military tradition.
Please change that.
I think you misunderstood the title, as the military band is performing a Soviet march, which was called "Comrades, Let's March Bravely", it was performed during the Russian Civil War. I know they are using the Prussian Goose Step, hope I cleared up the confusion.
La classe.
Any one watched the Indian/Pakistani change over guards at the border .Boy can they high kick .
Эхх..Геополитика.. Хорошо нас так Запад на*бал с не расширением НАТО на восток....
Верно, НАТО не будет расширяться на восток. Вы не обязаны верить всему, что говорит ваш лидер Путин!
They are marching like current Russian honor guard
Soviet soul
Not Russia ...Prussia County...Germany you Dork !
Name of the march?
portal potato woman
Real question is where does the changing of the guard take place now that it was moved away from the Neue Wache
It might come as heartbreaking news to you, but they didn't move it anywhere, and that's because the changing of the guard ceremony is no longer a thing since 1990!
The Bundeswehr does not continue the tradition of the Großer Wachaufzug unfortunately.
@@MaximusandHistory Thank you for this information.
I personally visited the Neue Wache in 2019 and I knew the Chancellor still places a wreath to the victims but was not aware that the Wachaufzug ceremony was discontinued.
@@ernestkhalimov1007 They still send guards on state visits, but yeah, sadly this tradition has been discontinued.
@@MaximusandHistory Duly noted
PREUßEN ADE , LEIDER !!!!!!!! C.
GLÜCKLICHERWEISE IST DER DRECK WEG!!!
GUYS. Enjoy this footage..........because........... this is the LAST you will see of a "REAL GERMAN ARMY"...........................
nope, this is not the ''real german army''
@@Kalashnikov413 yes its the last real german army , you like it or not but that's true
@muhammadmughnihalimmughni8687 but this ain't the proper and original Prussian goose step
@muhammadmughnihalimmughni8687 The original Prussian goose step never reached 45 degree angle though
В мультфильме ,,Снежная Королёва,, ,так охрана короля печатала шаг.
Да здравствует верное традиционное братство Вьетнам - Советский Союз - Российская Федерация!
1988
I remember seeing the DDR Army marching in Berlin in 1976, with some swiss friends, all at the age of 21 to 23 years old. We spoke all french and as we said they look like the Nazi Wehtmacht, some east germans looked at us with realy unfriendly faces,
They marched in the German military fasion,which goes back well before the Nazis came to power.
The GDR brainwashing narrative were , the Nazis were elimininated, what was false
Celebrating miltary parades and rituals were and are fashistoid
OWN FAULT.we can understand france.
Serious question, do current East Germans want independence from the west or is that just a meme. Cause I seriously can’t tell any more
probably there are some brainwashed(by soviets) east germans want it
@@borakaraca9788 but I have some mates who were born a decade after and they were born in what used to be east Germany and they joke about it all the time. It’s gone on so long that I if I ask them if they actually want it or not then il just be embarrassed. I’ve never met their parents as they are still in Germany so I don’t know if they had an effect on them. On another note funnily enough I’m learning German at Uni and my “study budy” is a Pole who’s indifferent to the Soviets. He was born in a soviet built hospital, taught in a soviet built school, played sports in soviet era sport facilities. He didn’t care much for politics, only what the effect is on the people and from photos he had seen prior to the Soviets, he wouldn’t be in a foreign university today as there was nothing in the area to give him opportunities, there wasn’t even a local school.
No, even majority of them favour reunification back in 80s. Only hardcore communist loyal to Soviet did, ordinary Germans did not. This is easy to understand for those Communist because when Germany reunify, they will be put on trial and would not have a place in a new society. I dont even know such meme exist on Internet
@@kiennguyenanh8498 I asked them and they said that their feelings are similar to the discontent the north of Britain has for the south of Britain.
@@proleterriert8075 You need to know that their country had been divided for 40 years with nearly no interaction. The alien and distant feeling can be understand. This feeling even stronger when the wall was built. Same thing happened to North and South Germany during Reformationu
Can anyone spot John Cleese?
1:04 name?
Brüder zur Sonne, zur Freiheit.
what year this is ?
Not sure, mostly likely 1970's.
@@MaximusandHistory Probably the early 70's. The soldiers are still wearing their collared uniforms.
Men noemt dit ' de ganzen pas'. Ik ken geen enkele gans die zo loopt?
Geweldig! Jullie Nederlanders hebben echt gevoel voor humor! Heel sympathiek!
A comunist country with Prussian traditions. I wish the comunist in my country to have the discipline and respect for the traditions that the GDR use to have. Why the communist in other countries are destructive to national history and traditions ?
Because communism requires tearing down of traditions because traditions are seen as oppressive in Marxist ideology.
Internationalism
So similar to the regime that totally did not exist from 1930 or whatever to 1945
@Sanctus Paulus 1962 It is a joke, when you're in denial of something on the internet that you clearly and everyone clearly know what happened/what existed/..., you say "I totally didn't do this/that"
It is also similar to the Reichswehr of the German Republic of Weimar, so what? It's just German/Prussian traditions that despite the kind of the regime that at any time rules over the German Reich, the traditions were followed (excluding the most un-german state, the Federal Republic of Germany)
Old DDR ARMY!
Jawohl!!!!!!❤
Мы помним и любим вас, восточные немцы. Простите нас за предательство Горбачева. Мы обязательно исправим эту ошибку и снова будем вместе как братские народы
Они обижены на нас!!!
@@user-sp7lb2mk6u всё поправимо. Было бы желание
Какой друг использовал танки и солдат, чтобы расстреливать и подавлять немецкий народ в 1953 году, когда они хотели свергнуть советское марионеточное государство и хотели воссоединения. Арестовывали и отправляли немцев, не желавших иметь ничего общего с коммунистическим режимом, в спецлагеря и Сибирь. Так много для дружбы.
@@kiennguyenanh8498 ну так спроси самих немцев, что там за провокация была в 1953 году. А Сибирь это страшилки 👻 для западной пропаганды
For brotherhood an peace for everyone.
Смело товарищи в НОГУ ( советская песня )...да и в ТЕМУ
Ммм...
Вот странно, вроде, слово "либерал" негативную окраску имеет для большинства россиян, а непонятно почему?
Вроде такие приятные милые люди, с такими замечательными идеями...
Would they really have fought against their west german brothers ?
They were so brainwashed, they would have done it
Yeah, brainwashed Sure. Forced to read kapital and state and revolution, truly the peak of communist brainwashing. Ever thought that maybe the West germans were brainwashed into fighting for the capitalists?
@@agorazontas5894 can i ask something what is it whit the west and east fighting and i DONT! think they would no matter how much they get brainwashed fight against their own friends familys etc!
Genau hinschauen, so etwas werden Wir nie Wiedersehen.
Zum Glück
真正的人民军队！
Не умерщвляли психологически немцев в ГДР в элементах присущих им генетически!!!
Just like the Leibstandarte outside the Reichkanzlei. Super.
Super? 🤮🤮🤮
@@agorazontas5894 What's your problem??
@@mariafrost1762 My problem is the fact of remembrance on Leibstandarte by East German military, the militarism of GDR regime, history falsification of GDR regime and the glorification of GDR.
@@agorazontas5894 Nobody was referring to the GDR or National Socialism.
The comment was on the fact that they resemble the Leibstandarte who used to change the guard like these GDR soldiers......and they look good and are very smart.....that was all.
My comments were nothing to do with ideologies. They just look good, that's it.
@@mariafrost1762 Stalin would be so proud of you... Blind, deaf, mute and... SILLY!
Строевой такой же как у солдат вермахта .
Das war so gewollt
ruclips.net/video/mE46CHiQjyg/видео.html The same here in 1974.
Que parecido por la forma de desfilar a la Alemania nazi
Así era el cambio de guardia en la cancillería de Hitler. Busca los videos aca mismo. Ellos mantuvieron la tradición mientras que Alemania Federal la sepulto.
1989.. Game Over ☝️🍷
wow
🤮🤮🤮
Dear God, this is no sovjet marsh, you morron!
👍👍👍👍👍❤
🤮🤮🤮
@@agorazontas5894😐
The helmets look really stupid!
Ostdeutschland ist das beste Deutschland
Na klar - von Westdeutschland mit Billionen Euro wieder aufgebaut!
From all the versions of the Präsentiermarsch der NVA, this has got to be the worst xD
It‘s just way too fast and too loud…
i think this is sped up
Probably has more to do with the poor acoustics of the street than anything. Also when it’s only 2 bars of something played like this it’s often pretty bad. May 9 parade the band always sounds terrible because it’s just pausing the band every 250’ the minister of defense stops to review a unit lol
@@Usmodlover yeah makes sense
This is due to the poor audio quality, in real life the performance would sound great.
Maybe we can have a goose step march-past with Germans, Chileans and North Koreans?
Of course! But without Germans
@@agorazontas5894 It would be incomplete without the Germans.
Because they are the best at it.
@@KillerofWestoids The FRG did well by disclaiming militarism, military traditions and rituals. Them are the roots of 2 WW, fascism, antisemitism and holocaust. Prussian traditions should be exstinct forever.
East Germany will rise again.
It rose in 1990 ;)
No it wont you stupid fool.
NVA Ostalgie. Eric Honecker. Berlin wall. Peter Fechter. Stand off Berlin 28 Oct 1961. Ostalgie
Ironic that the Nazis also used this music.
Really? Pretty sure that's a commie song originating in Russia
Rotes Preußen
Wehrmacht, die zweite...
ja - und schon wieder einen Krieg verloren...!
Ja syn trudowoga naroda pod krasne znamia staju , wintowku biore bojewoju i rodinie kljatwu daju.
All.now impotent
Das ist nicht der Soviet Marsch. Das ist immer noch Original wie in den 30iger Jahren bei den Nazi's.
This has nothing with Soviet to do. This is a german marsh like in the 1930. Die Nazi's did the Ex Step too and I did too when I was in the NVA 1988 to 1990.
Stimmt…der einzige Unterschied ist, dass die braunen Faschisten rot wurden…
Das ist richtig!
I remember in September 1989,then DDR leader Eric Honnecker flew to Peking seeking for help from communist China.
At that time then Chinese communist Supreme leader "Deng Xiaopong" greeted Honnecker and promised to provide financial help to East Germany, China was very difficult at that time but Deng still attempted to help a remote communist brother. But soon after a few days after that trip when Honnecker was fired by the party and Krenz taken over, DDR fallen suddenly in October and the rest of the history we all known....
If Honnecker seek help from China two months earlier, the DDR could be saved.
It was that Gorbachev, the traitor leaded to all the tragedies in Eastern Europe and Russia, he betrayed DDR !
The SED is at fault for industry mismanagement, spying on the own people and to see every critic as an attack. The people had already enough before Gorbachev came for a visit. The alternative history would have been a civil war.
GDR would fall regardless if Chinese helped or not. Their socialist economy would not be able generate enough taxes to support all the social programmes and inefficient industry.
Sicherlich Preußische Tradition .Aber die Märsche und Melodien sind anders .,,Brüder zur Sonne zur Freiheit "!
Schade! zum Schlechteren verändern
Nicht zum schlechteren sondern zum Besseren!! 🤦♂🤮
ruclips.net/video/Z4oBgzYHM_w/видео.html ¡Viva Alemania del Este! ¡Larga Vida! ¡Hacia Adelante Alemania del Este! ¡Hacia Adelante! ¡Siempre y para siempre! ✨🙏❤️
Fashist
That's what zPutin dreaming about.
We Will revive the soviet union and then - ddr! Не беспокойся
@@aluminiumchloride8614 это тебе беспокоиться надо, попадешь под кукан
Those helmets look so wack
What is on top of their heads😂
Ponemceni slovania a ako im to hrabalo v hlave ked sa bili do prs aky su nadradena nemecka rasa.a berlin mesto kde sa narodela drahoslava a jej syn svaty vaclav tade sa orehanal
holas asi lo hace mi pais ruclips.net/video/0pF637fSzv4/видео.html
Silly comment! Is your country responsible for 2 worldwars and holocaust?
STFU!!!
Say what you like about the evils of the DDR, they had excellent foot and rifle drill.
"muh evils of DDR" im sorry but the 57% of east germans who wasnt the DDR back would disagree
НИШТЯГК!!!
❤️❤️🇧🇬🙏❤️🇩🇪
🤮🤮🤮
Ja ja die russenknechte
2023 German : american servant
And now they are American servants
@@SergeyAlexandrovofficial Maybe, but we are FREE!!
@@redacted7060 If you think so, but we are FREE!!!
@@wernerdaedalus9463 not for long, when Ukraine runs out of manpower you would be sent there, the french already did under American command
W la stasi