@@AndreyRubtsovRU Maybe if you live in some kind of fantasy world where everyone who holds a certain position or job is perfectly competent or adequate. But if you live in the real world, you should know it happens all the time. Even in the classical music world, this is certainly not a new phenomenon.
You are effectively saying the Latvian National Symphony Orchestra is a 'nothing' orchestra. Which of course perfectly fine to have such an opinion. You're entitled to it. I don't think it's nothing, though. And if people are paying, that's another proof of something...
I saw Tarmo conduct live at the BBC Proms and he did an EXCELLENT job. It was the best concert of my life! All the people hating on him are just jealous…
I'm Latvian, have heard him in multiple concerts live - conducting Mahler Second and Strauss symphonic works, I can confirm, that his charisma and energy on stage is fascinating and inspiring; of course, he is extremely young, but still with enormous potential, talent and love towards the music!
wow harsh comments below. Well, I saw him conducting Sibelius 1st and I think he did a Great job. Wish him best luck in music, lets be supportive to each other instead of all negative comments.
I just saw him conduct Bruckner's 9th Symphony and Sibelius' Violin Concerto for the Hong Kong Philharmonic last week. He was fantastic!! I believe we will keep hearing about Tarmo for years to come. Best of luck to this young, talented man!
All these cynical comments. If you'd seen this guy conduct live you'd have a different opinion. He is phenomenal. Embittered RUclips boomers who feel they missed out on a succesful career in music are not going to change that simple fact.
Another example of unnecessary hype in the “classical” music world. He needs to develop without this nonsense which ultimately can have a negative effect.
Estoy de acuerdo con usted. El chico se ve muy "sintonizado" o mejor, obsesionado con Wagner. Es muy temprano para centrar desde ya su carrera en un solo compositor o en un estilo. El muchacho debe desarrollarse, madurar artísticamente y con el paso del tiempo fijar sus metas estilísticas y estéticas. Ojalá no madure biche, como decimos en Colombia y termine estropeando su carrera. Sería una lástima.
@@germanmedicis625En cambio en Italia decimos que la madre de los idiotas siempre está embarazada. Probablemente también la madre de los fracasados y frustrados.
It'll be fascinating to see if he becomes an important figure in music. What I've heard shows he plays music very fast, very crisp, and very precisely - which doesn't work with everything. Best wishes from Vermont 🍁
I cannot judge him until i see one of his concerts. I really liked Makela and his concerts though. Curious to see his future as well. And as for people who think young conductors are always bad, remember that all the old conductors we know started when they were young. Eg dudamel stated at 18, karajan at 21, etc. And there was a lot of hype around them during there time too. So yeah.
he should conduct bellini and rossini before doing wagner because belcanto singing is important in wagner, i bet nobody taught him that in music school.
Well it's not a surprise that a Finnish conductor was exposed to Wagner more than Italian opera. But it sounds like he will focus on opera conducting in the future, so he will get to know other repertoires, too.
@@papagen00 Peltokoski continued his music studies at the Sibelius Academy, where his conducting instructors included Sakari Oramo, before leaving the institution without a degree. -- from Wikipedia
О, в его возрасте я тоже любил размахивать карандашом в такт пластинке с Вагнером! Как показывает ролик, сейчас возможностей для "игры в дирижёра" намного больше!
@@DWClassicalMusic Vielen Dank für Ihre Antwort! Leider kann ich kein Englisch. Ich denke, dass die moderne Computertechnologie es einem ermöglicht, jeden Text in jeder Sprache zu lesen. Ich hoffe auch, Sie sprechen Deutsch?
Поразительно, что теперь можно указывать человеку, на каком языке он должен писать комментарий. Это недостойно уровня общественной вещательной организации. Любой комментарий, господа, есть внимание к вашей компании, уделённое ей время и в конечном результате - источник вашего успеха и дохода. Если вы впредь будете столь избирательны, то на ваше место придет другая организация, которая любит людей, а не пытается учить всех, как нужно жить. Спасибо!
This is a child trying and failing to do adult work. What can an immature, callow youth bring to Mahler 9? Or Beethoven 6? Or Bruckner 8, without mugging, aping and acting on the podium? The worst part of it are all the supposed “adults” in arts administration who propel this idiocy and try to make real musicians - those who are compelled to participate in this farce - pretend he is the second coming of Von Karajan? A child has no insights into music brought and earned by living life and experiencing the full range of emotion which is then brought to the score and to rehearsal. A child has tantrums which masquerade as behaviors which make a mockery of the art. This fraud belongs in high school, not in front of professional musicians.
Age has nothing to do with it whatsoever. Maestro Arturo Toscanini started conducting "by mistake" as he was 16 years old, but he'd already played for and learned from Giuseppe Verdi. Music nowadays has become nothing more than a business, and this young guy is nothing but one more product. Hopefully he'll realize it sooner than later.
A talented young conductor indeed. If I might say, his comments have a bit of arrogance toward his fellow players: "I do my thing and musicians are professionals. I know the music. I can conduct...That's what I do. I hope they (referring to the orchestra players) do their best as well, if they don't then I might say a few words". A conductor without his orchestra can't do or show anything.
Tarmo, may I suggest to you the idea of “Soli DEO Gloria”, Glory to God alone? You’ll find those words on the manuscripts of JS Bach; certainly he believed in giving God ALL the glory &, as a matter of fact, looked forward to the day he would meet his Lord & Savior Jesus the Christ. Unfortunately, the composers you admire - such as Richard Wagner - were devoid of this faith & our world is much the worse for it; case in point, Hitler’s admiration for his antisemitism & his convoluted idea of who Christ was - & look what that brought to our world.
Why are they hyping this kid?? Does anyone at DW actually know anything about music or conducting? This is average conducting at best; any competent conservatory conductor would do a similar job
2:24 "I know music. I can conduct."
That's such a cocky comment. Especially coming from a boy who has proven absolutely nothing so far.
Errrrm. He won the big job, though?
@@AndreyRubtsovRU Yes he did, but that has nothing to do with the quality of his music making.
@@MisterPathetique that. is. quite. a. statement.
@@AndreyRubtsovRU Maybe if you live in some kind of fantasy world where everyone who holds a certain position or job is perfectly competent or adequate. But if you live in the real world, you should know it happens all the time. Even in the classical music world, this is certainly not a new phenomenon.
You are effectively saying the Latvian National Symphony Orchestra is a 'nothing' orchestra. Which of course perfectly fine to have such an opinion. You're entitled to it. I don't think it's nothing, though. And if people are paying, that's another proof of something...
I saw Tarmo conduct live at the BBC Proms and he did an EXCELLENT job. It was the best concert of my life! All the people hating on him are just jealous…
Ikr 🫨 how can they say that
Felicitaciones
@madeleine_andrea Frrrr he seems like a good conductor
(Also hiiiiii 😁)
I'm Latvian, have heard him in multiple concerts live - conducting Mahler Second and Strauss symphonic works, I can confirm, that his charisma and energy on stage is fascinating and inspiring; of course, he is extremely young, but still with enormous potential, talent and love towards the music!
wow harsh comments below. Well, I saw him conducting Sibelius 1st and I think he did a Great job. Wish him best luck in music, lets be supportive to each other instead of all negative comments.
Yeah people are jealous. I saw him conduct Beethoven's 9th on New Year's Eve 23/24. Best concert of my life.
I just saw him conduct Bruckner's 9th Symphony and Sibelius' Violin Concerto for the Hong Kong Philharmonic last week. He was fantastic!! I believe we will keep hearing about Tarmo for years to come. Best of luck to this young, talented man!
All these cynical comments. If you'd seen this guy conduct live you'd have a different opinion. He is phenomenal. Embittered RUclips boomers who feel they missed out on a succesful career in music are not going to change that simple fact.
I couldn’t agree more!!
Another example of unnecessary hype in the “classical” music world. He needs to develop without this nonsense which ultimately can have a negative effect.
Estoy de acuerdo con usted. El chico se ve muy "sintonizado" o mejor, obsesionado con Wagner. Es muy temprano para centrar desde ya su carrera en un solo compositor o en un estilo. El muchacho debe desarrollarse, madurar artísticamente y con el paso del tiempo fijar sus metas estilísticas y estéticas. Ojalá no madure biche, como decimos en Colombia y termine estropeando su carrera. Sería una lástima.
They are called "Maestri" way before they have grown hair on their balls.
@@germanmedicis625En cambio en Italia decimos que la madre de los idiotas siempre está embarazada. Probablemente también la madre de los fracasados y frustrados.
Agree
@@novageriothe world is crowded with frustrated people 😂
It'll be fascinating to see if he becomes an important figure in music. What I've heard shows he plays music very fast, very crisp, and very precisely - which doesn't work with everything.
Best wishes from Vermont 🍁
we need new genius composers, not conductors.
Not aware they are mutually exclusive. Mahler managed just fine.
@@ferguszade5594 well, how many mahlers are there today?
This is only a short video clip and I have never worked with this young man. But what I see and hear here makes me very sceptical.
“I do my thing, the musicians are professionals.” Quite right! They don’t need you, child.
Well, musicians of the fine orchestra seem to think otherwise, clearly?
I'm a musician of a "fine orchestra". He's ridiculously full of himself, everyone of my colleagues agrees.
@@shobarschhmm slamming him publicly on social media doesn’t sound very professional!
Wasn't my first choice either but people are mindlessly praising him as a genius and I thought I'd share what musicians actually think of him.
@@shobarsch one of my professors at music college knows people that have worked with him and they all think he has a massive ego
I really question this. Who is pushing this silliness?
Recording companies
showing the world with your amazing talent huh!!! hope to see you and witness your performanc someday,,,,proud to say i also came from Saulon clan.
We're glad you enjoyed it. Make sure to follow us for the latest uploads!
Congratulations!!! : )
I cannot judge him until i see one of his concerts. I really liked Makela and his concerts though. Curious to see his future as well.
And as for people who think young conductors are always bad, remember that all the old conductors we know started when they were young. Eg dudamel stated at 18, karajan at 21, etc.
And there was a lot of hype around them during there time too. So yeah.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts on the matter with us and our community.
You have been blessed, go on!🎉🎉❤❤❤
he should conduct bellini and rossini before doing wagner because belcanto singing is important in wagner, i bet nobody taught him that in music school.
Well it's not a surprise that a Finnish conductor was exposed to Wagner more than Italian opera. But it sounds like he will focus on opera conducting in the future, so he will get to know other repertoires, too.
He didn't even finish the school
@@zyc4582 you mean he didn't finnish school
@@papagen00 Peltokoski continued his music studies at the Sibelius Academy, where his conducting instructors included Sakari Oramo, before leaving the institution without a degree. -- from Wikipedia
He probably has never bothered to listen to Norma or Lucia due to his never ending wagner rampage😂
Seems weird thinking that Esa-Pekka Salonen is now he grand old man of Finnish conductors
The faces of the musicians at 1:35 😂😂😂😂😂
Thats just how every musician looks during rehearsals tbh 😭
haha glad I'm not the only one who noticed that
😂😂🤣🤣
О, в его возрасте я тоже любил размахивать карандашом в такт пластинке с Вагнером! Как показывает ролик, сейчас возможностей для "игры в дирижёра" намного больше!
Thank you for your comment. If possible, please comment in English next time so that more people can follow the discussion. All the best!
@@DWClassicalMusic Vielen Dank für Ihre Antwort! Leider kann ich kein Englisch. Ich denke, dass die moderne Computertechnologie es einem ermöglicht, jeden Text in jeder Sprache zu lesen. Ich hoffe auch, Sie sprechen Deutsch?
Google translator works fine..
Поразительно, что теперь можно указывать человеку, на каком языке он должен писать комментарий. Это недостойно уровня общественной вещательной организации. Любой комментарий, господа, есть внимание к вашей компании, уделённое ей время и в конечном результате - источник вашего успеха и дохода. Если вы впредь будете столь избирательны, то на ваше место придет другая организация, которая любит людей, а не пытается учить всех, как нужно жить. Спасибо!
@@БорисШалагінов Exactly lol
His precise, clean, smooth interpretation bores me to death. Just like any other major conductor nowadays, maybe other than Barenboim.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts on the interpretation with us and our community.
This is a child trying and failing to do adult work. What can an immature, callow youth bring to Mahler 9? Or Beethoven 6? Or Bruckner 8, without mugging, aping and acting on the podium? The worst part of it are all the supposed “adults” in arts administration who propel this idiocy and try to make real musicians - those who are compelled to participate in this farce - pretend he is the second coming of Von Karajan? A child has no insights into music brought and earned by living life and experiencing the full range of emotion which is then brought to the score and to rehearsal. A child has tantrums which masquerade as behaviors which make a mockery of the art. This fraud belongs in high school, not in front of professional musicians.
Age has nothing to do with it whatsoever. Maestro Arturo Toscanini started conducting "by mistake" as he was 16 years old, but he'd already played for and learned from Giuseppe Verdi.
Music nowadays has become nothing more than a business, and this young guy is nothing but one more product. Hopefully he'll realize it sooner than later.
Thanks for sharing your opinion on the matter.
Yet another moderately talented conductor being pushed way beyond his real abilities. A Ken Doll. Like Makela.
Удачного звездного пути🎉🎉🎉🎉
Thank you for your comment. If possible, please comment in English next time so that more people can follow the discussion. All the best!
Seemingly very unpleasant young boy. I would not like to work with him
A talented young conductor indeed. If I might say, his comments have a bit of arrogance toward his fellow players: "I do my thing and musicians are professionals. I know the music. I can conduct...That's what I do. I hope they (referring to the orchestra players) do their best as well, if they don't then I might say a few words". A conductor without his orchestra can't do or show anything.
I am very sceptical of his new appointment with HK Philharmonic.
Tarmo, may I suggest to you the idea of “Soli DEO Gloria”, Glory to God alone? You’ll find those words on the manuscripts of JS Bach; certainly he believed in giving God ALL the glory &, as a matter of fact, looked forward to the day he would meet his Lord & Savior Jesus the Christ. Unfortunately, the composers you admire - such as Richard Wagner - were devoid of this faith & our world is much the worse for it; case in point, Hitler’s admiration for his antisemitism & his convoluted idea of who Christ was - & look what that brought to our world.
Tarmo Peltokoski...Is there any chance that this guy is of North-Macedonian descent?
This is high on cringe
❤❤❤ ❤❤❤ ❤❤❤ ❤❤ excelente ! [ Lovely cat ... grooming .. in the video tol! ]
Industry plant...?
lots of jealousy in the comments
Fr…
Oh joy…here we go again
Incredible talent !!!!
A very talented young lady.......!
He's a man. Can't you hear and see?
Peltokoski is a talented young MAN .......!
That’s just rude
LADY?!
Why are they hyping this kid?? Does anyone at DW actually know anything about music or conducting? This is average conducting at best; any competent conservatory conductor would do a similar job
Thanks for sharing your opinion with us and our community.
The Music Elon Musk
Brilliantly said. This is a child being forced into the mold of an adult, and failing.
He conduct my Orchestra and is was very normal. Nothing special.
He is a sensational conductor
Totaler Blödsinn😮😮😮
I and Wagner was simply made for each others…world-on-demand mode😉
Edward Yudenich (Uzbekistan)
Youngest Conductor (2005~)
What nonsense. Next…
oh God not another one. Move over Klaus...
Just because you can wave arms in front of professional musicians doesn’t make you a good conducting.
He's neither the youngest nor a star.
Ew, Wagner
Mai scambiare ol virtuosismo per arte...
Oh joy…here we go again