too high pitched in the p48 version. it's such a weird thing because the theme and visuals, clothing, etc. fit the live but again kind of... doesn't feel sultry? because of the vocals. this demo sounds like the better song by far
@@elijahjohnson5146 the voices itself of p48 are really high - doesnt meant they sing high. Perfect for cutesy concepts. But as you can hear, the girl singing here has a way deeper base tone in her voice. Even though they sing the same notes it doesn't mean it sounds the same.
it's probably because the trainees who actually suit this song was eliminated lmao. but i still love the pd48 ver. they all did very well despite everything.
jihun stan True that! If only the producer kept Chowon as their main vocal the sultry vibe they wanted might be there. I would rather had Eunbi as the center and sub vocal 1. They are lacking on the rap part actually eunbi failed to delivered the rap part fiercely. If only Go Wujin wouldn’t be the one who got eliminated things would go different.
@@minditris9229 A lot of teenagers can pull that off, it's just that most Korean girls were taught being cute is the most important thing ever. So they never learned to be anything else.
The song is not high-pitched. The thing is a main vocal guides the song, and if the main vocal has a sweet voice like Eunbi, it sounds too soft. That's why Chowon's voice was more impactful in the chorus.
I think this is the reason why they gave the rap to Chowon, because the rap needs a strong voice, maybe EUNBI rap will sound soft specially live. But I still love their version all of them.
@@Moon-nv3nu yes, but they weren't right when they said that the rap was the main part of the song. The chorus is, and that's why they should have prioritized it. Knowing mnet, that part could have been scripted. Just see what they did to the snake team in gp999.
Of course the rap parts aren't gonna be good, it's a demo song after all. I know Jiyeon's a better rapper than that so she probably just didn't have enough time to learn the parts fully.
If I am gonna change something from this it would only be the one to sing the high note in bridge. I think CLC Seunghee could make it sound fuller til that end note. Other than that, it's perfect.
Unpopular opinion but I like the rap here muuuuch more. They were just shouting in the PD48 version... especially the rapper with dark hair and pink highlights.. my ears kinda died listening to her...
넌 Toxic 파고들어 내 맘을 어지럽게 해 난 다시 빠져들어 아무것도 할 수 없게 돼 Oh Na na na 너의 눈이 마주친 순간 다른 말은 안 듣게 돼 너를 믿고 싶게 돼 다른 얘기들은 모조리 다 불태워줘 겁도 없이 달려가는 날 막진 말아줘 쓸데없이 떠다니는 소문 소문 소문 난 귀를 막고 너 하나만 믿어 믿어 믿어 Boy 이제부턴 어떻게 너를 봐야 되는지 말해줘 네 진심을 보여줘 Baby 멈출 수 없는 내 맘 네게 줘도 되는지 말해줘 모두 괜찮을 거라고 그렇게 말해봐 Rumor Rumor Rumor Gossip Gossip Gossip Rumor Rumor Rumor 날 사랑한다고 그렇게 말해봐 Rumor Rumor Rumor Gossip Gossip Gossip Rumor Rumor Rumor 모두 괜찮을 거라고 그렇게 말해봐 들리는 얘기들 믿고 싶지는 않지만 대체 왜 난 지금 네 전활 피하고 있는지 사랑은 Da ra ta ta ta 달콤한 거짓말 내 눈을 바라 봐 너땜에 힘들어 하는 날 Baby 거부할 수 없게 넌 나를 흔들어 듣고 싶지 않은 소리가 날 건드려 왜 속상하게 넌 날 불쌍하게 만들어 이곳 저곳 하나같이 모두 맘에 안 들어 솔직하게 말해줘 내 눈을 보며 말해줘 어찌할 수 없이 빠져버린 날 제발 그만 날 피하지만 말고 모두 괜찮을 거라고 그렇게 말해봐 Rumor Rumor Rumor Gossip Gossip Gossip Rumor Rumor Rumor 날 사랑한다고 그렇게 말해봐 Rumor Rumor Rumor Gossip Gossip Gossip Rumor Rumor Rumor 모두 괜찮을 거라고 그렇게 말해봐 Love is blind Now I'm blind Love is blind Now I'm blind 쉴 틈 없이 말해봐 어떤 말도 들을 수 없게 네 안에 갇혀 숨이 멎어도 이제부턴 어떻게 너를 봐야 되는지 말해줘 네 진심을 보여줘 Baby 멈출 수 없는 내 맘 네게 줘도 되는지 말해줘 모두 괜찮을 거라고 그렇게 말해봐 Rumor Rumor Rumor Gossip Gossip Gossip Rumor Rumor Rumor 날 사랑한다고 그렇게 말해봐 Rumor Rumor Rumor Gossip Gossip Gossip Rumor Rumor Rumor 모두 괜찮을 거라고 그렇게 말해봐
After years i came back lol its a pity that they eliminated the real rapper or else Chowon might have been the main vocal, Eunbi or Sian as sub vocal 1 and 2, Go Yujin main rapper
why are gidle fans claiming the rapping is soyeons when its literally not, that literally sounds nothing like soyeon. and also soyeon did not write the song tf did yall get that from? eden produced and wrote the song, soyeon had nothing to do with it. lucy is the one rapping and singing all herself. ik some neverlands are going to be triggered and come at me, so go ahead : DD wheres the proof that soyeon is the one rapping? soyeons rap tone is really not that unique so i can see why people are confused on whether whos rapping. ITS ALL LUCY
is it me or no one is commentinf about how sae fits the parts? It may be high pitched but Idk. Especially the second verse, she looks and sounds like a cute yandere.
Can I ask for clarification purposes? I have alot of question for this son since this is my all tiem favorite song 1. Did soyeon of (g)idle participated in creating this song or only eden(from cube too) and megatone? 2. Did soyeon or any member of g idle sang the demo apart from lucy? 3. Why g idle are rumored to be parto f this song cause I want eden to give g idle a song with the sme genre as rumor :( g idle would kill this song :(
ongniel_trash | lmao i dont even argue with you 😂 you could just be a lil bit kinder dont you think?ruined the song?lmao what a joke.if it ruined the song,then u go sing it.
the pd48 version and this one has different vibes despite being the same song.. its like pd48 ver is insisting for someone to listen while this is pleading..
Also known as Jiyeon... She was a member of BigHit/Source Music's collab group called GLAM. however the group disbanded shortly after Jiyeon/Lucy got arrested from a scandal. Now she's solo
![[Produce48] 루시(LUCY) - Rumor](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LDE3tAyfdvA/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Produce48] 루시(LUCY) - Rumor](/img/tr.png)
![MALE VERSION | Nation's Hot Issue - Rumor [PRODUCE 48]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mLy4YLWcmJs/mqdefault.jpg)
OMG! THANKS FOR 68K VIEWS AND 1,6K LIKES
2:30 thinking that jiyeon cried on glam because she couldn't do high notes. It's so amazing how she grow up vocally.
ngl even though the produce48 version is catchy
this sounds more like a legitimate song, the vocal tones are just too high in produce48 version imo
I love Rumor so much I just listen to the demo, the pd48 version, and the izone version XD
陈嘉鸿 SAMe sksjKSJSKSJSK
I wish all the version were on spotify sksk
AAAAAAGH SAME
陈嘉鸿 same
@@mmh2168 I think you can make local files on Spotify to make songs that are not on spotify available on spotify for yourself.
the demo sounds satisfying
Guys, this is all Lucy, there is no Soyeon okay Lucy just keeps changing her voice to make it seem full ok
Ikr real neverland shouldn't confuse. Clearly its not soyeon's voice
Sian is born for this
too high pitched in the p48 version. it's such a weird thing because the theme and visuals, clothing, etc. fit the live but again kind of... doesn't feel sultry? because of the vocals. this demo sounds like the better song by far
even the trainers said that
Kaname Aoyama How is too high pitched when the key is the exact same here ?
@@elijahjohnson5146 the voices itself of p48 are really high - doesnt meant they sing high. Perfect for cutesy concepts. But as you can hear, the girl singing here has a way deeper base tone in her voice. Even though they sing the same notes it doesn't mean it sounds the same.
it's probably because the trainees who actually suit this song was eliminated lmao. but i still love the pd48 ver. they all did very well despite everything.
jihun stan True that! If only the producer kept Chowon as their main vocal the sultry vibe they wanted might be there. I would rather had Eunbi as the center and sub vocal 1. They are lacking on the rap part actually eunbi failed to delivered the rap part fiercely. If only Go Wujin wouldn’t be the one who got eliminated things would go different.
As much as I love the rumour team, this is so much better. Their version is way too high pitched to pull off the message and feel of the song.
No wonder it didn't win.
Chloie Asajar wrong. It’s all about concepts. Most of the audience like cute concepts
true this should've been a bad ass moment
That's what happens when you give a song like Rumor to a bunch of teenagers, not saying they can't pull it off but it won't have the same mature vibe.
@@minditris9229 A lot of teenagers can pull that off, it's just that most Korean girls were taught being cute is the most important thing ever. So they never learned to be anything else.
If y'all are confused about who Lucy from Glam is, her real name is Jiyeon and that's what she went by in Glam
Anyways, I love this version so much
Glam as in BigHit's Glam?!
@@nadanazeer2266 yup
@MaMa DeW yup
@@nadanazeer2266 wait i though SourceMusic created Glam... Maybe they collabed...
isn't glam like- ?? is she one of the non-controversial members?
I like more this version! Thank for this amazing video! Congratulations!
Oh damn this version sounds so much better!
After all this time the demo version is still superior
I need 1 hour loop of this version
The only parts where this is worse than the final song is Chowon's part. Chowon slayed so hard.
@hello what do you mean?
@@ae-Michael he means Chowon did better than the rap part here
Both of the raps were pretty shit, I wouldn't say either one was better. Probably cause they forced thel to scream rap and that's never a good idea.
Chowon's rap was not good at this point, she was screaming.
Rumour is my favourite song from the concept evaluation
Whoever sings that first line DAMN UR VOICE IS PRETTY!!!!
It's all Lucy. Lol
@@minshubay6740 so, the voice from 1:41-1:45 belongs to her and not Yena's?
@@eririnakai2709 yes. In demo version.
Sian is meant for the song
The song is not high-pitched. The thing is a main vocal guides the song, and if the main vocal has a sweet voice like Eunbi, it sounds too soft. That's why Chowon's voice was more impactful in the chorus.
I think this is the reason why they gave the rap to Chowon, because the rap needs a strong voice, maybe EUNBI rap will sound soft specially live. But I still love their version all of them.
@@Moon-nv3nu yes, but they weren't right when they said that the rap was the main part of the song. The chorus is, and that's why they should have prioritized it. Knowing mnet, that part could have been scripted. Just see what they did to the snake team in gp999.
LYRICS:
Neon toxic pagodeuleo
Nae maeumeul eojileobge hae
Dasi ppajyeodeuleo
Amugeosdo hal su eobsge dwae
(Ooh, na na na) neoui nuni majuchin sungan
Daleun maleun andeutge dwae
Neoleul midgo sipge dwae
Daleun yaegideuleun mojoli da bultaewo jwo
Geobdo eobsii dallyeoganeun naleul magji malajwo
Sseuldeeobsi tteodanineun somun somun somun
Na gwileul maggo neohanaman mideo mideo mideo boy
Ijebuteo eotteohge neoleul bwayadoeneunji malhaejwo
Ne jinsimeul boyeojwo baby
Meomchulsu eobsneun nae maeum nege jwodo doeneunji malhaejwo
Modu gwaenchanheul geolago geuleohge malhaebwa
Rumor, rumor, rumor
Gossip, gossip, gossip
Rumor, rumor, rumor
Nal saranghandago geureoke malhaebwa
Rumor, rumor, rumor
Gossip, gossip, gossip
Rumor, rumor, rumor
Modu gwaenchaneul georago geureoke malhaebwa
Deullineun yaegideul mitgo sipjineun anchiman
Daeche wae nan jigeum ne jeonhwal pihago inneunji
Sarangeun da ra ta ta ta
Dalkomhan geotji ma-a-al
Nae nuneul bara bwa-a-a
Neottaeme himdeureo haneun nal baby
Geobuhal su eopge neon nareul heundeureo
Deutgo sipji aneun soriga nal geondeuryeo
Wae soksanghage neon nal bulssanghage mandeureo
Igon jeogon hanagachi modu mame an deureo
Soljikage malhaejwo nae nuneul bomyeo malhaejwo
Eojjihal su eopsi ppajyeobeorin nal
Jebal geuman nal pihajiman malgo
Modu gwaenchaneul georago geureoke malhaebwa
Rumor, rumor, rumor
Gossip, gossip, gossip
Rumor, rumor, rumor
Nal saranghandago geureoke malhaebwa
Rumor, rumor, rumor
Gossip, gossip, gossip
Rumor, rumor, rumor
Modu gwaenchaneul georago geureoke malhaebwa
Love is blind, now I'm blind
Love is blind, now I'm blind
Swil teum eopsi malhaebwa eotteon maldo deureul su eopge
Ne ane gatyeo sumi meojeodo
Ijebuteo eotteohge neoleul bwayadoeneunji malhaejwo
Ne jinsimeul boyeojwo baby
Meomchulsu eobsneun nae maeum nege jwodo doeneunji malhaejwo
Modu gwaenchanheul geolago geuleohge malhaebwa
Rumor, rumor, rumor
Gossip, gossip, gossip
Rumor, rumor, rumor
Nal saranghandago geureoke malhaebwa
Rumor, rumor, rumor
Gossip, gossip, gossip
Rumor, rumor, rumor
Modu gwaenchaneul georago geureoke malhaebwa
Of course the rap parts aren't gonna be good, it's a demo song after all. I know Jiyeon's a better rapper than that so she probably just didn't have enough time to learn the parts fully.
Omg been waiting for this thank youuuuu
2018년아 다시 돌아와주면 안되겠니... 후회없는 1년을 보낼게 제발
Eunbi can't sing like Lucy. It's too high and I think just Chowon and Sian suit ❤
Lucy
I dont like the rap here but i think the vocals r better than the pd48 version
Yes I’m agree with you
Would have been better if Sian was the main vocal
@@Kameroro2 i do think sian fits the lead vocal chowon should have been the main
Yuris husky voice would’ve fit well
chiesaki yuri wasnt in the team though
Come here again after listening to the pd48 ver... this ver is the best even after 4 years...
Lucy I'm so proud of you Queen keep it up 💛
If I am gonna change something from this it would only be the one to sing the high note in bridge. I think CLC Seunghee could make it sound fuller til that end note. Other than that, it's perfect.
Jiyeon from GLAM is Lucy, by the way!
Unpopular opinion but I like the rap here muuuuch more. They were just shouting in the PD48 version... especially the rapper with dark hair and pink highlights.. my ears kinda died listening to her...
She was 15 and was forced to rap as there were two rapping parts and they only had one rapper on the team.
Same honestly. Rap parts sounds so much better when it's in deeper pitch. Especially if you're screaming it, it ain't gonna sound good.
넌 Toxic 파고들어
내 맘을 어지럽게 해
난 다시 빠져들어
아무것도 할 수 없게 돼
Oh Na na na
너의 눈이 마주친 순간
다른 말은 안 듣게 돼
너를 믿고 싶게 돼
다른 얘기들은 모조리 다 불태워줘
겁도 없이 달려가는 날 막진 말아줘
쓸데없이 떠다니는 소문 소문 소문
난 귀를 막고 너 하나만 믿어 믿어 믿어 Boy
이제부턴 어떻게 너를 봐야 되는지
말해줘 네 진심을 보여줘 Baby
멈출 수 없는 내 맘 네게 줘도 되는지
말해줘 모두 괜찮을 거라고
그렇게 말해봐
Rumor Rumor Rumor
Gossip Gossip Gossip
Rumor Rumor Rumor
날 사랑한다고
그렇게 말해봐
Rumor Rumor Rumor
Gossip Gossip Gossip
Rumor Rumor Rumor
모두 괜찮을 거라고
그렇게 말해봐
들리는 얘기들 믿고 싶지는 않지만
대체 왜 난 지금 네 전활 피하고 있는지
사랑은 Da ra ta ta ta
달콤한 거짓말
내 눈을 바라 봐
너땜에 힘들어 하는 날 Baby
거부할 수 없게 넌 나를 흔들어
듣고 싶지 않은 소리가 날 건드려
왜 속상하게 넌 날 불쌍하게 만들어
이곳 저곳 하나같이 모두 맘에 안 들어
솔직하게 말해줘
내 눈을 보며 말해줘
어찌할 수 없이 빠져버린 날
제발 그만 날 피하지만 말고
모두 괜찮을 거라고
그렇게 말해봐
Rumor Rumor Rumor
Gossip Gossip Gossip
Rumor Rumor Rumor
날 사랑한다고
그렇게 말해봐
Rumor Rumor Rumor
Gossip Gossip Gossip
Rumor Rumor Rumor
모두 괜찮을 거라고
그렇게 말해봐
Love is blind
Now I'm blind
Love is blind
Now I'm blind
쉴 틈 없이 말해봐
어떤 말도 들을 수 없게
네 안에 갇혀
숨이 멎어도
이제부턴 어떻게
너를 봐야 되는지 말해줘
네 진심을 보여줘 Baby
멈출 수 없는 내 맘
네게 줘도 되는지
말해줘
모두 괜찮을 거라고
그렇게 말해봐
Rumor Rumor Rumor
Gossip Gossip Gossip
Rumor Rumor Rumor
날 사랑한다고
그렇게 말해봐
Rumor Rumor Rumor
Gossip Gossip Gossip
Rumor Rumor Rumor
모두 괜찮을 거라고
그렇게 말해봐
i love lucy sm i'm so proud of her ):
Honestly I wish that the I am demo is out
Damn, loved her in glam. 😔
Lucy my queen my idol
Xing qiao from girls planet 999 sang well if we consider this version
After years i came back lol its a pity that they eliminated the real rapper or else Chowon might have been the main vocal, Eunbi or Sian as sub vocal 1 and 2, Go Yujin main rapper
Go yujin center not main rapper
i feel like this version suited the lyrics more than the produce 48 version lmao
just saying tho
Lucy doctor for singing.
Who sang this version , I hear a lot of familiar voices ...
@@JW-ck9gr You can also hear Soyeon from (G)idle
SugarIly when?
@@Emilia-ll3ii yeah
@@Emilia-ll3ii i heard she wrote the lyrics.. But im not sure thats actually her voice? Could still be Lucy as backing track with lowered volume.
It’s definitely not soyeon
Who sang this version?!?!
Lucy
@@huhuhuhurricanestreamwow7937 I hear more voices
Din Callada wait really???
@@dayanaraocampo9075 yes she collaborated with Dean
Where is she now?
Can you please upload the full demo of all PD48 6concepts songs please
if u guys didn't know she's a member of glam (the girl group from bighit)
I'm just knowing the one who sing this ver is the former GLAM member ....
where can i download this?
Download in description in this video ruclips.net/video/3VbEbd9X2wU/видео.html
Don't forget to SUBSCRIBE!
please approve my request
@@HidaSone please request
Can someone kindly please send me this version if they have it?
why are gidle fans claiming the rapping is soyeons when its literally not, that literally sounds nothing like soyeon. and also soyeon did not write the song tf did yall get that from? eden produced and wrote the song, soyeon had nothing to do with it. lucy is the one rapping and singing all herself. ik some neverlands are going to be triggered and come at me, so go ahead : DD wheres the proof that soyeon is the one rapping? soyeons rap tone is really not that unique so i can see why people are confused on whether whos rapping. ITS ALL LUCY
is it me or no one is commentinf about how sae fits the parts? It may be high pitched but Idk. Especially the second verse, she looks and sounds like a cute yandere.
Wow!!
lumor lumor lumor.....
que voz boa... mal acreditei q ela canta tudo
Yujin suits this song
Can I ask for clarification purposes? I have alot of question for this son since this is my all tiem favorite song
1. Did soyeon of (g)idle participated in creating this song or only eden(from cube too) and megatone?
2. Did soyeon or any member of g idle sang the demo apart from lucy?
3. Why g idle are rumored to be parto f this song cause I want eden to give g idle a song with the sme genre as rumor :( g idle would kill this song :(
Eden, Megaton and Score produced this song. Soyeon wasn't involved.
1:36 I bet that’s Soyeon. I love gidle, I know that voice
@@Wania-qw6yo its not her
Anna ramdial you don’t know that
oof That’s not someone for sure
❤️❤️❤️
BigHit needs to debut a girl group man it would end all girl groups I NEED YOU TO DEBUT A GG BIGHIT!
they did, Lucy from Glam was from Bighit, but they disbanded after a scandal
@ibighit l my notifs said: "ibighit replied: Ikr" and i was honestly so confused like why is bighit here and why is it saying ikr
@@demontitania x2
Nah, their big bg doesnt even have enough talent to compare to rookie bgs.
stan loona which rookie boygroups are you talking about?
Eargasm
im sad i just found this now but i love it so much 💕
Why do i hear hwasa’s voice in the beginning?
Thank God there's no "love is brind, now I'm brind". Can't say enough how much I hate that part
ongniel_trash love is blind*
Sae sang "Love is brind", that's why I hate that. Don't correct me if you don't even understand what I mean, thank you.
ongniel_trash | such a small mistake such a big fuss.tsk.
Such small mistake ruined the song. If you like it them go listen to it then, why do you have to argue with me?
ongniel_trash | lmao i dont even argue with you 😂 you could just be a lil bit kinder dont you think?ruined the song?lmao what a joke.if it ruined the song,then u go sing it.
the pd48 version and this one has different vibes despite being the same song.. its like pd48 ver is insisting for someone to listen while this is pleading..
I miss Lucy
아래 뭐가 하나 트랙이 더 깔렸네
Pd48 ver. Is still better for me...
Kayaknya izone harus nyanyiin lagu ini deh, pake OT 12
Demo > PD48 OT5 > IZ*ONE OT12
this voices seams like hwasa,soyeon,jihyo and jeongyeon in diferent times
no I AM? )):
demo better than produce 48 trainnee
WAIT IS THAT SOYEON IN 1:38 & 1:46? That is how soyeon raps (her style is like that). if not, well she really sounds like soyeon.
kard ?
NARA TUZAKI no
Lucy from GLAM (bighit ent.) (disbanded)
park ji yeon from glam... but righ now she called LUCY
Who's Lucy?
A former Member of GLAM, A Disbanded Girl Group of BigHit Ent.
Can i know who is the singer of this demo ?
Lucy
I thought jiyeon from glam sang the demo???
Dyodoleu She did
Did i just heard Jeon Soyeon - G IDLE in Bridge and Final Chorus ??? Nani
Nope
Imagine of hwasa perfomed this
I thought that Hwasa sang this ;-;
But would be perfect
who's lucy?
Member of GLAM
Also known as Jiyeon... She was a member of BigHit/Source Music's collab group called GLAM. however the group disbanded shortly after Jiyeon/Lucy got arrested from a scandal. Now she's solo
@@ava1002 if I am correct dahee was the one who got arrested ?and that's why the disbanded
Rainbow 05 Yes it was dahee not Jiyeon
Who sing this song before produce 101
Lucy
@@syawalzptra6454 tq
Is it bibi?
No. It's Lucy she used to be part of glam
Sorry, who is Lucy? Is she from a girl group?
No, Lucy is member of girl group GLAM
강 실기 Yes she is Jiyeon from glam
Is Lucy active as an idol or what?
Lucy is idol she's from girl group GLAM
Well, am I the singer? Uuuh
Who sang this demo tho?
huda zainal Lucy from GLAM
G IDLE Jeon Soyeon
Soyeon or lucy eh? Hehe
Lucy, it's in the description
@@nurull.6 lucy
g
Is it true that Soyeon ( (G) -IDLE ) wrote this song?
She helped
@@Wania-qw6yo nope
oof stop lying
idk but ahn yujin would fit this song really good
I picture (G)-Idle singing this song.
Omg the rap sounds terrible here... Other than that this is much better.
This just doesn’t sound right, idk..... I think the Pd48 and Izone versions are better than this.
Its because you were used with produce version lol