GIANT Crassula Bonsai (Beware Dramatic Pruning!)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 ноя 2024
  • ХоббиХобби

Комментарии • 228

  • @MontanaBonsai
    @MontanaBonsai 2 года назад +61

    I cant get over how aggressive and confident you are in your cuts. Bravo.

    • @Nepali_Bonsai_Bamrukh
      @Nepali_Bonsai_Bamrukh 2 года назад

      😹

    • @Watcher4187
      @Watcher4187 2 года назад +6

      You can beat the crap out of Jade plants and their cuttings root incredibly easy. I've got a bunch of them at home and have butchered them like this. They just keep right on kicking along, no problem.

    • @TheresaPowers
      @TheresaPowers 2 года назад

      @@Watcher4187 that was not a Jade plant

    • @capnspicy5565
      @capnspicy5565 2 года назад +2

      @@TheresaPowers If that's not a jade then what is it? Portulacaria Afra? Lol

    • @kadincetanner5080
      @kadincetanner5080 2 года назад

      SMALL SHRUB TRIMMING

  • @realrohitdebnath
    @realrohitdebnath 2 года назад +36

    I live in India. I've a Portulacaria afra. It's highly manageable and easy to work with. Highly recommended for beginners and pros.

    • @CoryandStuff
      @CoryandStuff 2 года назад +10

      Came here to say this. He is definitely talking about a Portulacaria Afra near the beginning.
      It’s easy to confuse portulacaria afra a for jades (crassula ovata) because they can be called “dwarf jades” even though they aren’t actually a jade / crassula.

    • @peterchan3100
      @peterchan3100 2 года назад +6

      @@CoryandStuff --You are absolutely right - the jade I worked on in NOT - Portulacaria afra so this tree does not take to wiring at all. Very difficult species to use for bonsai. The P afra is a better one to use.

    • @HoldToChrist
      @HoldToChrist Год назад +1

      Just got a Portulacaria afra!

    • @lynnshirley
      @lynnshirley 9 месяцев назад

      I thought that too
      @@CoryandStuff

  • @TheBonsaiZone
    @TheBonsaiZone 2 года назад +13

    Such a wonderful old tree!

  • @sonjamae
    @sonjamae 2 года назад +23

    The one tallest branch left now seems very bare, it'll be interesting to see what this ends up looking like when new growth starts up. And also excited to see how the cuttings fare

    • @fabulously695
      @fabulously695 2 года назад +4

      Crassula Ovata is surprisingly vigorous and resilient, as long as its warm and not over or under watered, you can remove every growing tip and leaf, and it'll still backbud and carry on growing. If they're overwatered, they rot, if they're underwatered, they tend to drop limbs to conserve water

  • @tambou5022
    @tambou5022 7 месяцев назад

    I will remember these 2 words from now on when pruning, " BE BOLD". thank you for that.

  • @RosarioCostanzo
    @RosarioCostanzo 2 года назад +3

    Years ago, I used to steal Portulacaria and jade leaves from my neighborhood and now I have really an army of succulent!! I have so many cuttings that I will arrange a forest! They are generous plants, perfect for bonsai and if you walk around nurseries, you can find a lot of big material relatively cheap

  • @1BergerVongSchlauigkeitHer
    @1BergerVongSchlauigkeitHer 2 года назад +19

    The South African one is Dwarf or Elephant Jade - Portulacaria afra. Different from Jade and with edible leaves.

    • @ImNotAProfessional
      @ImNotAProfessional 2 года назад +2

      Oh wow i didnt know they had edible leaves.
      Im not going to try one just in case 😂😂

    • @CoryandStuff
      @CoryandStuff 2 года назад +5

      @@ImNotAProfessional Completely safe to eat portulacaria afra leaves, but crassula leaves are not safe.
      Portuacaria afra leaves kinda taste like an apple to me.

  • @xxalxxllxx
    @xxalxxllxx 2 года назад +11

    Love to see the process. Thanks for including us, Peter. 🌱

  • @russmaleartist
    @russmaleartist 2 года назад +2

    Should be a very interesting experiment . . . so, I look forward to seeing which media will work the best,
    Peter. I know you enjoy these experiments as well as sharing them with us. I have been following you on RUclips for many years now, and I still find your videos fresh, interesting and no in the least boring. So, bring on the challenges and experiments . . . I love to watch the "Master at work with his craft!"

  • @pegjames188
    @pegjames188 2 года назад +2

    I found when decorating behind a cupboard a pruning I’d dropped growing quite happily in the fluff build up and rooted into the carpet.

  • @Jenny-fk3ke
    @Jenny-fk3ke 2 года назад +18

    so glad for this video - I’ve been waiting ages to see you work on a crassula bonsai. I have a young jade tree which is about 2cm thick at the base and I recently wired the trunk into a curve without any problems. In my experience if the branch is supple enough, and you’re careful, it should be ok to wire without breaking.

  • @jeffncompany
    @jeffncompany Год назад +1

    first time I've seen a video from Peter dedicated to a succulent! and what a crassula ovata it was! massive!

  • @serg10xm.69
    @serg10xm.69 2 года назад +3

    I love that you made a video of these, they are very beginner friendly.

  • @liwoszarchaeologist
    @liwoszarchaeologist 2 года назад +3

    Bonsai mix is great for rooting succulents, because for both good drainage is the goal. Perlite and volcanic gravel help a lot, and so does keeping the soil very shallow. A good rule of thumb for Crassula and Kalanchoe is to wait for the plant/cutting to tell you it's thirsty before watering. Portulacaria afra on the other hand struggle with taking up enough water until they root, so with those mist them frequently.

  • @Stettafire
    @Stettafire 2 года назад +17

    My experience with these plants and similar to it (these tree succulent things, jades and others like it) is that directly after pruning they always look odd but they quickly bud agian and look amazing. There is always that moment of regret but you gotta trust the process and trust the pruning.
    Even the thick cuttings I'd attempt to root, but then again Im a home grower so I don't worry about the upkeep getting too much.
    They do need watering but very rarely. I water mine once every few weeks, but only like a little splash from a glass. If you are in high humidity (I suppose like a greenhouse) then it's probably fine. But in a central heating house the air is much dryer.
    Also tropical succulents require higher humidity and more water then desert succulents, so there is some caution to be taken there.

  • @oneshotllaw2158
    @oneshotllaw2158 2 года назад +5

    Thanks for doing a video on jade trees very interesting.. got a tree that I inherited from my grandmother still going strong .. take care and have a great day

  • @ulrikek359
    @ulrikek359 Год назад +1

    I also experimented: in water they form the best roots and also it is the fastes way. After a couple weeks and some waterchanges you can put them into a cactus-mix

  • @TheHadesShade
    @TheHadesShade 2 года назад +10

    Very curious to see how the crassula will look in a few months!

  • @walterwjr947
    @walterwjr947 2 года назад +1

    Thank you.... 🙏 😔 🙏
    Dr. Chan it is a great honor to be allowed to participate in your research. I look forward to the end results, but it will be interesting as we peek into the pot from time to time. You are very brave with your cuts. You just seem to know where.
    Enjoy the season of the harvest.
    🙏 🖖 🙏

  • @catibree1
    @catibree1 2 года назад +5

    My heart nearly stopped when he cut off so many branches . Especially the larger one.. But, since he is the master of bonsai, I guess he knows what and what not to do.. I will be anxiously awaiting the new growth on the mother plant, and also the cuttings.

    • @tambou5022
      @tambou5022 7 месяцев назад

      Remember his 2 words, " BE BOLD".

  • @daljitsrkg
    @daljitsrkg 2 года назад +13

    Hi heron! Thanks for the amazing videos. I have learned so much from you ❤️

  • @Pearlygatefarm
    @Pearlygatefarm Год назад

    The crunch as the succers came out was a delicious sound

  • @WilliamAiken
    @WilliamAiken 6 месяцев назад +6

    4:48 the "Oh My God" is hilarious! I love a great bonsai design he does so effortlessly - that's what 30+ years of experience does!

  • @jakicatancabelic9436
    @jakicatancabelic9436 2 года назад +1

    Yes indeed Josh "Oh my God!"-still wonderful result. Thank you Mr. Chan.

  • @granthawkins9142
    @granthawkins9142 6 месяцев назад

    Man my heart just about stopped when he sawed off that big limb. But I saw exactly what effect it had I'm inspired

  • @BonsaiKiwa
    @BonsaiKiwa 2 года назад

    GIANT Crassula Bonsai, this is a very good bonsai sir, the character is amazing

  • @mikew9499
    @mikew9499 2 года назад +5

    Thank you for sharing your thoughts and wisdom on bonsai.

  • @johnberry1107
    @johnberry1107 Год назад

    Lovely plant story. New to southern most CA USA from the northeast I am converting to cactus & succulents outdoors. Unbelievable ability to come back from neglect. Thank you.

  • @Kalithrasis
    @Kalithrasis 2 года назад +6

    They can take less than 10C in winter, but cold tolerance depends on climate and also soil. Where I live they're frequently grown outdoors and in pots without much care and experience 0 to -2C a few times each winter. This climate is also much like their native climate which is summer dry, winter wet. Growing in a heavy, wet, and clayey soil is likely going to cause root rot, but in sand they're pretty tough as nails.

    • @fabulously695
      @fabulously695 2 года назад +1

      agreed, I leave mine outside in an unheated lean to, in winter it is often between 1-5C,

    • @JacobFirlotte
      @JacobFirlotte 2 года назад

      Where’s that?

    • @onLYbyM
      @onLYbyM 10 месяцев назад

      same here
      sometimes 0 C.. no problem..
      been out for 2years..
      a young plant too.

  • @barryauguste9734
    @barryauguste9734 Год назад +2

    I can't wait to see the update. Bonsai are are constant reminder of how short and fragile our lives are. If only we had more time to be with them..... thank you sir.

  • @MTPatriot1787
    @MTPatriot1787 Год назад +1

    Fantastic as always. Thank you for your continued sharing of your knowledge Peter. It is much appreciated.

  • @johncreet1254
    @johncreet1254 2 года назад +2

    These are amazing plants; really easy to propagate from cuttings and easy to prune. I had one that belonged to my grandmother in the 1970s that I inherited. It wasn't in great shape but I took a cutting that grew into a huge specimen with a trunk that must have been more than 18 ins in circumference. Unfortunately I watered it a little too much one winter a couple of years ago and the whole thing rotted. Fortunately I took some cuttings which are now growing well.

  • @kerriefearby9542
    @kerriefearby9542 2 года назад +1

    My son had sold his house and the new owners didn't wand the very old and very large Crassula ovata which was growing in the garden. So I carefully cut it into manageable "trees" and transported to my place where I immediately potted these cutting's into buckets of my succulent mix. Some of the big cuttings had thick trunks up to 12cm in diameter. Within no time they all developed roots. Since that time I have bonsaied them and taken hundreds of cuttings during the shaping process. Best, most forgiving plant ever.

    • @Wolfy459.
      @Wolfy459. 2 месяца назад

      How thick was the trunk? Mine is (i hope not was!) 6 inches. I have rot where the trunk and all branches were! what do I do?? I don't want to kill it!

  • @growclipbonsaiforseniors1951
    @growclipbonsaiforseniors1951 2 года назад +2

    I like Torpedo sand to use in rooting. Excellent video.

  • @shivangnisharma9448
    @shivangnisharma9448 2 года назад +2

    I have the variety you mentioned, it was discarded by neighbour, tall ungainly, around that time I discovered you & air layering, now I have 2, both look excellent (even if I praise myself) . I wish I could send their pictures . The variety you showed here doesn’t tolerate very high temperatures too, mine have always rotted in summer

    • @naphom
      @naphom 2 года назад

      I live in Durban, South Africa. Summer temperatures are often in the 30's (Celcius) and all the Crassula Ovatas I've seen seem to enjoy it. I have a few that get direct sunlight for 12 hours per day and they are doing very well. I suspect the high humidity helps a lot.

    • @shivangnisharma9448
      @shivangnisharma9448 2 года назад

      @@naphom thanks, what growing medium are they planted in? This year I’ve switched to cinder let’s hope it works , will know only by august 23

    • @naphom
      @naphom 2 года назад

      @@shivangnisharma9448 - uhm.... just soil. Nothing specific or specialized. It's inside one of the concrete blocks used to retain soil, so it was backfilled with whatever was available. .

  • @nillysbonsai9636
    @nillysbonsai9636 2 года назад +2

    Them cuttings alone are decent plants! Nothing lost with that aggressive prune :D

  • @convoyconvoyconvoy
    @convoyconvoyconvoy 2 года назад +1

    must be the season for trimming jades, as a i brutalised all of mine today and yesterday, i also prefer the dwarf jade over the money tree, as its quicker to rebound from trims too

  • @MadAboutCichlids
    @MadAboutCichlids 2 года назад +2

    The ones you seen in India are most likely portulacaria afra, they're very popular for bonsai there.

  • @BonsaiCornwall
    @BonsaiCornwall 2 года назад +4

    Dramatic pruning? I’m in 💚

  • @vktesla
    @vktesla 2 года назад +1

    "its the trunks thats most important. In bonsai you are trying to make tree like images....and trees have trunks" - Little piece of gold everyday from the great master splinter

  • @chrismurphy2769
    @chrismurphy2769 Месяц назад

    Best quote: 8:54
    "Teaching you how to make cuttings out of crassula would be like teaching grandmother to suck eggs." LOL!

  • @jeffsers624
    @jeffsers624 2 года назад +2

    What works best for me for that particular family of succulents is to leave them out for a week or so after cutting to let the cut end callous. Then stick them in cactus/succulent soil.

  • @jsnstamper
    @jsnstamper 2 года назад +1

    I just trimmed mine yesterday because we have to bring it in for winter. We call it a jade, I think it’s the same variety you have there....keep it up guys

  • @astounded
    @astounded 2 года назад +1

    Mr. Chan- Thank you for sharing the value and beauty of an "ordinary" plant. Even something as common as C. ovata, when tended throughout the years, can become something extraordinary. The story of its journey only makes its presence all the more beautiful and inspiring. Can there really be such a thing as a "common" plant?

  • @waynehiorns6688
    @waynehiorns6688 2 года назад +1

    Absolutely brilliant I watched many of your vids & little is more & bite the bullet is the way to go, love too get my hands on that large cutting lol
    Regards
    Wayne
    Keep up the good work

  • @Sandraa021
    @Sandraa021 8 месяцев назад

    would love to se an update on this! I Have just started to take an interest in bonsai and have a jade plant. This looked extreme, but I trust the process and would love to se the result this far! :D

  • @christmassnow3465
    @christmassnow3465 Год назад +1

    The other species with the smaller leaves is not actually a Crassula. It is Portulacaria Afra which is classified in the Didieraceae family and previously in the Portulacaceae family.

  • @Teresa-ih4sn
    @Teresa-ih4sn 2 года назад +2

    Wonderfully informative video! Thank you Sir Peter!!

  • @4shore325
    @4shore325 2 года назад +1

    Definitely not for the faint of heart! lol I have a large jade that I should do something similar but am chicken. It's not even for a bonsai but just maintenance. I see the branches that are being pulled down and a couple that are crossing another but I have not gotten up the courage to go in and cut away. After this video, maybe I will be able to do a couple of the branches. I was holding my breath as he was cutting, I'm surprised he hasn't hurt himself cutting so fast. I'm sure he has a vision in his mind as he's cutting but, wow, so fast! Great video.

  • @deedahl2866
    @deedahl2866 2 года назад +1

    I need to see if you have a video on the different types of yews. I have LOTS of cuttings from different ones. Hick's (red berries). Podacarpus. Densiformis media (something). And spreading ones too. Some have short leaves and others are longer leaves. Seems they get broken a lot during transportation so that creates an opportunity for me to get cuttings.

  • @therisingofroninbonsai
    @therisingofroninbonsai 2 года назад +3

    Wacaouwww.....giant crassula bonsai....jade !!!!

  • @chrisrose323
    @chrisrose323 2 года назад +1

    Ohh you showed us this long ago when you showed us your exersize room. Cool to see it again

  • @nickgillespie8234
    @nickgillespie8234 Год назад +3

    Any updates?

  • @egoebonsai37
    @egoebonsai37 2 года назад +1

    Giant Crassula Bonsai is wonderful n beautiful Bonsai
    Good job Sir 👍🏽

  • @terriejohnston8801
    @terriejohnston8801 2 года назад

    I'm halfway thru tbe video...
    ALL the cuttings...WHOA! I'D love to watch this Dude, @ his propagation techniques. To JUST STICK in sand!?! Lol.
    Hoping some propagating b4 video is over. Ive tried SO many ways w so many succulents. YEAHhhh, he's showing us....

  • @diytwoincollege7079
    @diytwoincollege7079 Месяц назад

    Would love to see the tree and the cuttings today.

  • @arunshetty6406
    @arunshetty6406 4 месяца назад +1

    Is there a follow up video of this ? As the video was posted a year ago I am curious what all the pruning had done to the plant ?

  • @MekhetM
    @MekhetM 2 года назад +2

    Trying to grow my own crassula from leaves, I left one lying around but it just rotted. Next I will try with water too :)

    • @lisaskidgel-yn1oj
      @lisaskidgel-yn1oj 5 месяцев назад

      Mine always rot too. No matter what I try or don’t try.

  • @jsnstamper
    @jsnstamper 2 года назад +1

    I did wire it with a rubber coated aluminum wire for a couple of years with minimal marks left when I removed it yesterday

  • @robbybobby64
    @robbybobby64 2 года назад

    They grew from single leaves that fell on the soil. I have one that is 25 years old now. I love it.

  • @MidniteSan
    @MidniteSan 2 года назад +1

    Thx for sharing Peter....

  • @3sechsund80er
    @3sechsund80er 2 года назад +3

    Don’t fully agree on the minimum viable temperature. I keep them outside until temperatures drop below 5 C at night. They are doing fine.

  • @naphom
    @naphom 2 года назад

    I believe it is Crasula Sarcocaulis you are referring to. I have two growing in the soil in my garden.

  • @jude1515
    @jude1515 10 месяцев назад

    Interesting story. I can’t wait to start creating bonsais.

  • @adinacosma4861
    @adinacosma4861 8 месяцев назад

    Good morning Mr. Chan. I'm wondering if I should seal the big cuts or not. Usually I'm not sealing only the conifers. Thank you for the video.

  • @mayarada2059
    @mayarada2059 2 года назад

    Absolutely beautiful fantastic Money plant to have it , my favourite plant and always feel happy to have it .

  • @PatriciaAnnGriggs
    @PatriciaAnnGriggs 2 года назад +2

    I really really Love this video

  • @kittyiam2206
    @kittyiam2206 2 года назад +1

    Is this the same as a jade plant? It looks like it. Thank you for the video!

  • @annabelcleare138
    @annabelcleare138 Год назад +1

    This is amazing! Please can we have an update?

  • @mikec3820
    @mikec3820 2 года назад +2

    there is a afra crassula? news to me. im a jade and portulacaria nut too lol thansk peter! beautiful ol jade you have here sr

    • @Robert-ij9ih
      @Robert-ij9ih 2 года назад

      ruclips.net/video/euBeKLZYDEM/видео.html

  • @rsa420
    @rsa420 2 года назад +1

    They are so awesome I have recently added some to my collection. I have always wanted one. We call them jade or money trees, they are treated with alot of respect and mysticism. I was told its bad luck to buy one for ones self hence why it took so long till I got one gifted too me. I have grown loads of clones from the leaves alone

    • @rsa420
      @rsa420 2 года назад

      I am in South Africa and mine look just the same as the one in the video, I might be getting a few other species later in the year.

  • @desiTravelerOfficial
    @desiTravelerOfficial 2 года назад

    Excellent video..I am really impressed with the size and history of this tree. Mr. Chan. I developed interest in Bonsai long ago by reading your books :) good to find your chanel. I am from India we are not able to grow this C. ovata in north india as it succumbs to heat in summers... that is why you see a lot of Portulacaria afra Bonsai in India... as PA is more heat tolerant...

  • @h.b.1421
    @h.b.1421 2 года назад +2

    Hallo Peter, it may have been Crassula sarcocaulis which has really fine leaves (less than a cm or 2 fifth of an inch) and it is quite frost hardy. I keep them outside all winter (I usually have really moderate temperatures here) if the temperatures don't fall below freezing too much (I read that it can tolerate up to -12° C or 10° F, but haven't been able to test this), you have to be careful though. I have a few of them grown from cuttings which very easily start new roots. One can keep these inside, but then you need to take care that the plant has enough moisture in the air, otherwise the leaves shrivel up.
    On the other hand Crassula sarcocaulis can have lots of beautiful little red to white flowers.
    And I can verify that the leaves of the Crassula ovata (as shown in your video) grow new plants. One of the few of these I have at home lost a leave and I placed it into a pot and it grew to a few cms this year. Slower than using a cutting though.

  • @HommeTerre
    @HommeTerre 2 года назад +2

    I bet on bonsai substrate with akadama ; second position for sand 🤔 the water poses a problem of rehabilitation then towards a mixed substrate... but why not the experience is interesting and enriching. 💕 Thank you so much for this spectacular new video ✨

  • @johnpugh5867
    @johnpugh5867 2 года назад +1

    You can wire if yo let dry out so it limps and use heavy wire you can shape even large branches give it a try

  • @Alexia.C.S
    @Alexia.C.S 2 года назад +1

    I'd love to have one of those cuttings! 🥺

  • @NFSCfan
    @NFSCfan 6 месяцев назад

    That random egg yolk just chillin.

  • @almac2598
    @almac2598 2 года назад

    Thanks Peter. A big plant.

  • @Wolfy459.
    @Wolfy459. 2 месяца назад

    Hi Peter, thanks for the lesson. I just did a massive trunk cut on my 38 year old jade! What should I put on the cut to prevent rotting? I have a bad case here and I hope I didn't kill it!!!!
    Please HELP!

  • @tomzifertomzifer6944
    @tomzifertomzifer6944 2 года назад

    That thing is going to make new buds all over

  • @weakleaderwbbd8378
    @weakleaderwbbd8378 2 года назад +1

    Hi, what type of soil you use for that type of plant?

  • @ryantranter8206
    @ryantranter8206 2 года назад

    I was wondering where you did the cuttings? Is that a new building you have had built? It looks very empty for one of your greenhouse/pollytunnels lol
    Thanks for another great video Peter 😁😁😁😁

  • @pezpythons1532
    @pezpythons1532 4 месяца назад

    I started one from a single leaf in 1999 when I was 5 years old, at school. it is now 25 years old and it's trunk is the size of my arm 👍

  • @earthladyadventures5018
    @earthladyadventures5018 Год назад

    I can’t wait to see the results

  • @t3dwards13
    @t3dwards13 2 года назад +1

    Phew... I thought he was going to chop down the whole trunk.
    That would have been tragically dramatic. Lol

  • @soonzach4017
    @soonzach4017 Год назад

    As always love your beautiful job 👍

  • @kingstar2256
    @kingstar2256 2 года назад

    thank you so much! i will give this a try

  • @Jacob-yb6bv
    @Jacob-yb6bv 2 года назад +2

    Fine down to 5 degrees C. Keep dry in winter.

  • @narusawatd.9966
    @narusawatd.9966 Год назад

    Do you need to prune the roots? Or how should I go about containing it. I have a 16yo jade and it is starting to outgrow my pot

  • @9daywonda
    @9daywonda 2 года назад +1

    Unusual specimen for a bonsai.

  • @barbarafazio549
    @barbarafazio549 2 года назад +1

    Do you put a sealer on the cut?

  • @ELLE-qi5nj
    @ELLE-qi5nj Год назад +1

    Oooh magnifique 🌺

  • @princekareem
    @princekareem Год назад

    I have two of these, 15 years or so old and not sure what to do with them. Maybe some bonsai experiments 😃

  • @franzwagner7370
    @franzwagner7370 2 года назад

    Very nice again! Anybody knows what he means with "sharp sand"?

  • @paolomh113
    @paolomh113 2 года назад

    Hi, could you comment about that hexagonal pot? The u.

  • @crizcroz
    @crizcroz 3 месяца назад

    I keep mine outside until the first frost (northern Sweden so in september-october) and they have never rot.

  • @simjam1980
    @simjam1980 Год назад

    Is it normal for the leaves to shrivel up on cuttings when letting the cut marks seal before potting.?

  • @maxkopfraum
    @maxkopfraum Год назад

    What an amazing plant.

  • @Bigninjon
    @Bigninjon 2 года назад +2

    Love the warning!! Lol

  • @yadigarklckaya5989
    @yadigarklckaya5989 6 месяцев назад

    He knows what he does👍🏻👏🏻🌹