Why Your History Textbooks Are Full of Lies - Historian Sandeep Balakrishna
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 сен 2024
- Watch The Full Episode Here: • Fiery Debate - Truth A...
Check out BeerBiceps SkillHouse's Podcasting 101 Course - bbsh.in/bb-yt-...
Follow BeerBiceps SkillHouse's Social Media Handles:
RUclips : / @beerbicepsskillhouse
Instagram : / beerbiceps_skillhouse
Website : bbsh.in/trscli...
For any other queries EMAIL: support@beerbicepsskillhouse.com
In case of any payment-related issues, kindly write to support@tagmango.com
Follow Sandeep Balakrishna's Social Media Handles:-
Facebook: / thedharmadispatch
RUclips: / @dharmadispatch
X: / dharmadispatch
Also on Substack: thedharmadispa...
Check out my Mind Performance app: Level SuperMind
Android - lvl.fit/androi...
Ios - lvl.fit/iosdow...
Join the Level Community Here:
linktr.ee/leve...
✅ Subscribe To Our Other RUclips Channels:-
BeerBiceps (English Channel):
/ beerbicepsofficial
Ranveer Allahbadia (Hindi Channel):
/ ranveerallahbadia
TRS Clips हिंदी (Hindi Podcast Highlights):
/ @theranveershowhindi
Best Of TRS :
/ @bestoftrs
Best Of TRS Hindi :
/ @bestoftrshindi
RAAAZ By BigBrainCo :
/ @raaazofficial
RAAAZ Clips :
/ @raaazclips
BigBrain Plus :
/ @bigbrain_plus
Link to our blog: beerbiceps.com/
Welcome back to another episode of The Ranveer Show. Today, we welcome Sandeep Balakrishna. He is a writer and author specializing in Indian history and culture. He is also a former IT professional with a successful career in major multinational corporations. He is the founder and editor of The Dharma Dispatch, an online journal dedicated to Indian civilization, culture, and history. Additionally, he is a contributing editor of the Prekshaa Journal, focusing on Indian culture and philosophy.
In this episode, we will discuss the history of India that is never taught in schools. We talked about the truth of our education system, the new education policy, how certain parts of history are portrayed in our textbooks, and much more. We will also discuss the impact of Islamic invasion on the relation of Hindus and Muslims of India.
This was an amazing conversation with Sandeep Balakrishna where we debated on various topics and had an in-depth discussion on Indian history. I hope you will like this conversation and do not forget to share your thoughts in the comments.
#indianhistory #islamicinvasion
--
INSTAGRAM : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
FACEBOOK : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TWITTER : @beerbicepsguy
/ beerbicepsguy
WHATSAPP: BeerBiceps
whatsapp.com/c...
LINKEDIN : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TELEGRAM: @beerbicepsguy
t.me/beerbicep...
SNAPCHAT: @beerbicepsguy
----------------------------------------------
About :
TRS Clips is a collection of SHORT CLIPS from The Ranveer Show podcast. Enjoy our latest knowledge-fueled videos from the BeerBiceps team. Every conversation on #TheRanveerShow is intellectual, deep & progressive. We cover everyone from entrepreneurs to Bollywood film stars to even athletes.
Today, The Ranveer Show or TRS - Happiness Through Curiosity. A show where we host the world's greatest success stories and try digging out their secrets to success. Every conversation is an EXTREME learning experience for the viewer.
![Eminem - Fuel (Shady Edition) feat. Westside Boogie & GRIP [Official Audio]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/k1OquBida9s/mqdefault.jpg)
Ranveer should do solo shows... he's so eager to tell what the young generation knows about everything
Yeah totally 👍 he has all kinds of friends and lot of views to tell and surely he's oversimplified version for his 3year old viwer 😂
@@sayonkumarbiswas3886 he doesn't want to get his muslim viewers offended .😆
@@PrimeBoy-u3g but he's Muslim viewer are his three south Bombay friends 😂🙏
Listen to him ranveer. you are interrupting too much.
Yeah, even I found it odd. Sir is a historian for a reason...unse behas karna, is so not right
He has become secular now.
He always does
@@Anon12375😂
He is just scared..this is all something centric people suffer from. They want to be politically correct.
Ranveer NALANDA is only 1 out of 12 University we had .
Bhai I request you , plz Let the guest speak , u can keep 20% of time for giving your own opinions and rest for the guest and not otherwise .
bhai bhai yehi main likhne wala tha, and one thing you just have to stop giving examples of movies man. movies are not considered as a criteria here
Ranveer is bollywood inspired liberandu
@@99.keshavudhaneI think he's a Pappu supporter.
Respect for guest he is very intelligent
Rana Pratap is actually shown as rebel even in the wiki, my textbook, and many other websites
Fortunately the new generation is slowly and steady coming to the truth.
Sandeep sir is a 100% right about Maharana Pratap and rajputs. They were portrayed as bigoted and arrogant in isce history book
I think there are 2 sides to the Rajput princes - on the one hadn they were a group of people who retained some martial culture/disciplines. On the other hand they failed to work together to defeat Islamic invaders and furthermore some allied WITH the invaders.
LOL, Ranveer referring SLB to create 'awareness' about Allauddin Khilji. Bollywood is not history they are part of the problem and not the solution. Ranveer should stop glorifying Bollywood
Ranveer y u so apologetic abt ur culture, v will not teach hate, facts themselves wud b so bitter u wud have nuthn but hate against such perpetuators
Chatrapati shivaji maharaj ki jai ❤🚩🚩
Maharana Pratap singh sisodiya ji ki jai ⚔️🗿🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
As he said "People will not accept the truth even if truth is standing in front of him"
Bro, the guest is historian not you. So plz raise your doubts but dont debate and argue
I agree totally with the guest
Feedback for you Ranveer : 1. Let your guest/s speak, don't waste the viewers time by interrupting so much. 2. Don't be scared while your guests are instilling awareness in Bharat-ians. Let the viewers draw their own conclusions as to whether they like/dislike what the Islamic & Christian invaders did to Bharatvarsh. It is pretty clear with the current situation in Bharat, the followers of islam are plotting to destroy the Bharat/Hindus again ! So burying your face in the sand while this happens won't help anyone.
He wants to become Gandhi and work for the mythical hindu-muslim unity. We need ppl like JSD. Ranveer has become woke.
In the 90 s , we also were also taught that these heroes were rebels. They wer heroes cuz they had a spine to defend their motherland. So, people who go to others countries n become tyrants can never be liked, people who love these outsiders tyrants can never be liked...if anyone has a problem with it...they ll have to live their own negativity
Our First Education Minister was ________________
Maulana Abul Kalam Azad
A very knowledgeable person, who set up UGC Aiims IIT ...
A very knowledgeable person, who set up UGC Aiims IITs....
@@nh6999 mene bas naam pucha tha😂
@@nirmalmunda4651 Maine bhi hint diya tha. So that u do some research and not just follow WhatsApp university.🤔😂
Hii bro love from Bhagyanagar!!!❤️❤️❤️
😂🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Ajj india ka itna bura haal hone ke piche.. India ka education system resposible hain.. Jo ki british ne lagu kiya tha.. Aur usse pehele mughal ne humare temeple barbaad kiye he the.. Jaha gurukul mein bharat ki bachho ki shiksha hoti thi.. Iss desh aur hindu civilizaion ko pichle hazaro sall se toda jaa raha hain...aur abb hum kehen ko azad hain.. Per bharat mein jyda tar logo ka colonial mindset hain..kyu ki yaha ke log.. Ajj bhi imforamation ko apne brain mein feed karne ko education samjte hain... Ajj bhi rattu popato ko glorify kiya jata hain.. Ajj bhi bachhon ko.. School mein crtical thinking kaisi ki jati hain.. Skill kaisi developed ki jati hain.. Different career path kaise hote inn sab kuch knowledge nahi hain.. Indian mein logo sirf engineer, doctor, Ca.. Sirf yahi carrers dikhte hain.. Aur iske liye bhi bacho ko ratana padta hain
Maharana Pratap and also our SIKH GURUs....can there b bigger sacrifices? Sri GTB , hari singh nalwa, maharaja Ranjit Singh, .....never forget their sacrifices n never forgive mullaz
Marathas?
There are many Rajputs ....when nobody dared to fight Mughals....they fought straight one -one.....
Rajputs fought when Mughal was at its peak....Sikhs & maratha expanded when Mughals were out....
Sickh history of sacrifice for Hindus is false and full of propaganda. Don't believe it.
@@anoopsingh-iq1oeSickhs never fought Mughals. They were anti-Hindu and anti-Bharat.
Marathas fought the Mughals when they were the peak of their power.
Hope they get reformed soon✌️😑
Ranveer is also from the indoctrination generation... So am I, I am afraid.
Ranveer Statement "I hope the new education policy does not instill Hate" This is same thing Islamist and Khangressis are saying to Executed Kashmiri Pandits. Don't Tell the world how you were butchered as it will spread Hate. Don't Speak the Truth.
That lies filled by coward Congress for votebank...
Ok, if muslims feel hurt, bad things of muslim invaders may not be mentioned, but greatness of Indian rulers and indians shud be highlighted a lot in history text books.
Ranveer, please don't show ignorance and poor knowledge in history despite several podcasts with several famous Historians. And, the beggest joke is reffrring Wikimedia. Please understand the truth. Don't lose the respect to your show.
Pls mention some truths in summary, you are mentioning...how can we understand what you are referring to
Wikipedia is the biggest propaganda tool
Agree
Let the guy talk stop your imposition of 'secularism'
Ranveer - TRS is a good platform but imho you should please listen more to the fellow pros who come on your show and should you wish to do your own talking, please do a solo show. Challenging learned guests like this when you know so little is a very painful experience!
Maharana Pratap: Mewar's Rebel King by Brishti Bandyopadhyay | Goodreads.
Those interested in real history should read Swatantyaveer Savarkar's book on 6 Golden pages of Indian History.
"Nalanda" is real life version of "Ohara" in One Piece.
Good to see people who watch onepiece ..even watch beerbiceps😂
Maharana pratap never lose any war
Right
Read history
Haldighati was indecisive even according to contemporary Mughal accounts. He eventually captured all territories apart from Chittor. This he was able to achieve with limited manpower and funds even after his father and uncles lost most of Mewar to Mughals and Gujarat Sulatanate.
He is 100 per true
Man why did Sandeep Balakrishna even care to sit through this. They host is just so ungracious. Let the guest speak.
Aurangazeb used to refer Shivaji Maharaj as Mountain rat that is the wording , this person twisted the statement atleast thats what I read in school back in 90s , yes lot of whitewashing of history happened because in the dawn of independence india saw lot of communal violence so then rulers thought of downplaying Islamic atrocities so next generations will live in harmony but I feel they should have presented facts as is , vote Bank stmt is absurd till Indira Gandhi era over overwhelming majority of Hindus are with Congress and literally there is no strong opposition , during independence moment INC was referred as hindu party
history 's purpose is not nation building or catering to anyone's feelings.
I was educated in CBSE and we NEVER saw Maharana Pratap as a rebel against Akbar. They were just mentioned as kings of different kingdoms who fought against each other. I agree with Ranveer on this. We should just stop politicizing history - this is done a LOT in India and we need to stop. We need to read history for what it is, simple. We don't need to whitewash history and at the same time no need to over-glorify anyone.
I UNDERSTOOD THIS LONG BACK WHEN I HAD A MEME PAGE ON FB AND USED TO INTERACT WITH RANDOM PEOPLE ALL ACROSS THE GLOBE
Ranveer please stop trying to appease a certain section ..the guest is spitting facts..we love you but this time you are way to much full of your self.....
Bhai bolne diya kar yaar, har cheez me expert nahi bana jaata, kisi wajah sey wo expert hai.
Stop interrupting ranveer...
Shut up and listen and let us listen too...
The obsession people have for the Mughals era is crazy . Ranveer bro I have seen how u turn I made u see the recent government it’s doesn’t show how Hindu u are but how opportunistic u are . RSS was pro Hindu even then even now . But many mushroom Hindus have grown recently
And deny all the atrocities committed by your community. Al Takiyya all the way.
RSS came about in response to a threat and you know what that threat is.
@@sricrRSS is useless. Hindu Mahasabha is a real Hindu organization.
Can we leave bjp rss and Muslims out of this discussion … yes atrocities happened as it happened anywhere in the world when someone comes to conquer your country .. we should accept and now move on .. just like Germans did after world war 2 … present Hindus and Muslims need to accept the past and move on ..
@@dorisdey998 That is the problem. Muslims are not ready to accept that their ancestor committed atrocity. Germans has accepted the mistake and a law that nobody can deny holocaust. To move on, one must first accept the past.
the problem is it the hate/violence is religiously sanctioned. and that cannot be changed till qayamat. read the Quran or follow ex-muslims.
@@dorisdey998 We will move on when museums are built and muslims are educated on how their hindu ancestors were tortured. no more brushing under the carpet.
0:51 muh ki baat chin li bhai 😂❤
Ranveer, i admire many of your qualities, but please please stop trying to 'moderate' and 'centralize' everything. For a change, just listen to the expert. If he hadn't insisted about the 1974-2000 history books clarification on Maharana Pratap, you would have stayed in your 'moderate' cocoon that 'no no no, our books never called him a rebel'. Well, now you know.
Agree
Kudos TRS for introducing cues on the side screen of the glossary/analogy
Ranver either be in right or left don't say social and secular things
What next will Ranveer have an opinion on? Nuclear physics? Just as eager to hear that
I dont know what kind of history they read.....
Maharana Pratap as put by Ranveer rightly was anything but downplayed in our history book .
Also history is a factual narration and students of 10 th arent doing phd in their subject.
We need broader sweep on topics .
I hv read about Chola Pallavas pratiharas not in 10 th standard but in lower years.
Kitabein padhni nhin hoti h aur aise chomu aa jaate hn sense of false pride instill karke apni kitab bechne.
Shameless.
Jay maharana 🚩🚩🚩
Plz should not try to become expert and give chance to yr guest to speak
Congress changed our history books
90s kids know how we got scammed in our history textbooks
It needs an unbiased approach as anticipated in AI use cases.
I studied the same in the text books when I was in school
Some of the things in history books which are taught are merely stories which has not actually happened rather than history. But, Modi government which people call a bold government has done very very little to correct it .
Hi Ranveer, you know in this video I have been confused many times for that,are you taking an interview ? or giving your interview ?
If you called so much proficient guest for the subject then why you interrupting him with your opinions, let him speak...we will hear you some other day 😂
Maharana Pratap❤
Maharana Pratap Never Lost Win Two Battle Of Haldighati And Battle Of Dewair Refrence Omendra Ratnu Book Maharana The Thousand Year War For Dharma
Yes all our textbooks are lies this man knows everything as he had played gta with jhangir
To jisne likhi usne gta khela tha? Kuch bhi matlab
You should bring people from left wing as well as right wing. And let them give their opinion. Only ask questions. Don't try to simplify things. The viewers are not dumb. Let the guests talk the way they want. Instead of being centrist, this will be right way.
Saar saar plx teach real history saar ..saar maharana pratap great saar he was 10 ft tall saaar ....shivaji ruled whole world saaar😭😭😭😭😭😭
Tu pitega kisi din 😅
No, he is lying. As a historian I have read about Maharana Pratap. He was not mentioned as rebellious. I have no idea how did this gentleman came up with this absurd theory
Bro books have their edition, he tells about before 2000 editions
I agree 💯
Ranveer should have patience, we are here to listen his opinions, kindly not yours. Please let him finish his points. Be silent when he was talking, like you were conversing with central ministers on your podcast.
Yay..first to comment n view
Congress k kuchh logo ka drama 😂😂😂
Bhai tuhi pura podcast bol le.
change karao saari books aur nahin to mass bunk karo ,national bunk karo, poore desh ke bachche school mat jao fir kisko padhyenge ye
Ranveer is so innocent and is in denial mode and an secular apologist .😂
Haan Bhai, history books mein jhooth hain. Asli sacchai wala history toh RSS Wale, bjp Wale bolte Hain. Aise logon ke wajah se Aaj kal kuch dumb log kuch bhi anap sanap bakte rehte hain.
❤
History is dependent on the person who wrote it if he wanted to show a character brutal or wrong he could do that, and I think we should not follow a single book for this we should 😅😅😅have collected various resources and various scholars not some money consuming vote banks increaseing lol…
Asper the sangism india still not indipendant.... British not ruled in india....😀
Sir thank you so much for this precious information but plz i request you to take Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj 's name with honor it's not Shivaji you must say Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj... respect our heros and specialy heroes like Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj & Maharana Pratap ji is like a god for us so plz. As a maharashtrian i request you to take care of Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj not a Shivaji...
Congress Govt disrespected Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj in our old History books . Please tell them first.
Keep Quiet it is TRS😂 Bro where is your listening skills with weird faces.
EGO is the Enemy
This happens when you study from crafted boards and not state board
Book: Eminent Historians ❤
In your zeal to bring Hindu Muslim unity please broaden your research. The moderate Muslim majority is irrelevant as they refuse to condemn Muslim agression and terrorism. By citing people like Abhijeet Chawda who are pseudo scholars you are missing out on the expertise of people like Sandeep Balakrishna. As viewers we wish to hear more from the guest rather than you.
Just because he's a historian doesn't mean you have to believe whatever he's saying.. he sounds biased and he's just saying some things out from his opinion and imagination...
Great war is coming and you have a significant role to play ranveer don't be secular ka 14, we must have United front this time or Bharat will fall again and there will not be any British interfarence
He is not a historian he is only a sangh propoagandist. Fake one
Bhai dusre jo bhi bolne de
This guy is so ignorant. May be hater should be the right word
Please halp me i am kalki
Please find my guider lord parashuram my name is Alen kumar
Bro help me to tell people that earth is flat ,sun and moon is revolving the earth. Bro help me to tell that halala is sacred practice tell by our god😂😂
Stop being a clown ranveer you can do better in 12 minutes of clip 50% of words are spoken by him let the guest speak mate.
WhatsApp university professors are correct.😂
If sandeeo is historian i am einstein
Arey host stop your useless excitement sometimes in such crucial topics 😢
Ranveer doing monologue here 🥱
I hate
I love your video idea