Discussing The "Tibet Issue" With A Chinese Celeb - Are We Told Different Truths?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 13 дек 2024

Комментарии • 962

  • @tsee_dorj
    @tsee_dorj Месяц назад +223

    Tibet had its own culture, language, religion, and history. The Chinese communists had always wanted to annex it. On October 7, 1950, the PLA walked into Tibet. Tibet is Tibet not China

    • @edwardhuang3751
      @edwardhuang3751 Месяц назад

      By that logic the US shouldn’t even exist.

    • @zxa875
      @zxa875 Месяц назад +5

      same logic, so let Sikkim\Arunachal\Khalistan\ Kashmir\Ladak\Northeast independent, Indians merged these place without peace.

    • @Vijai-Vpandian
      @Vijai-Vpandian Месяц назад +12

      @@zxa875 India is a subcontinent and it is democracy not like single party system of China.

    • @DifferentNazariya
      @DifferentNazariya Месяц назад

      @@zxa875 Not sure whether you’re high or uneducated! Go read about how China attacked and outcasted Tibetian head to propagate its own agenda. China is still irritated by Dalai Lama and his visits near India-China border. Comparing that to Indian merger is outrageous.

    • @sauravgogoi4535
      @sauravgogoi4535 Месяц назад +8

      @@zxa875 Tibet had its own Government and Government is overthrown by Chinese govt. But Khalistani(Canadian terrorist), Kashmiri(Pakistani) Terrorist, Northeast insurgency or Ladakh had no government. So do not compare Chinese with Indian situation.

  • @JampaTashi-l8e
    @JampaTashi-l8e Месяц назад +137

    Tibet is not part of China

    • @RajuBoro-mk9xx
      @RajuBoro-mk9xx Месяц назад

      China superpower

    • @Don_Junior105
      @Don_Junior105 Месяц назад +1

      Tibet has been a part of China longer than North East India has been a part of India.

    • @Rsingh-babhan..v
      @Rsingh-babhan..v 24 дня назад +2

      ​@@Don_Junior105 tibet people live in india after they are ruined after attack of china
      North east always part of bharat and people of their fell proud as an Indian

    • @imnikshay
      @imnikshay 24 дня назад +1

      @@Don_Junior105so thats why tibetian had to fly to india with dalai lama monks ??

  • @tenzinyoungduyoungdu2231
    @tenzinyoungduyoungdu2231 Месяц назад +375

    Tibet was never part of China ..

  • @abhishekkatoch6189
    @abhishekkatoch6189 Месяц назад +100

    She gives Misguided and wrong information

  • @ShrikrishnaThakur
    @ShrikrishnaThakur Месяц назад +277

    She sounds like a Chinese propaganda person and the possibility is Ranveer was the target to promote the soft Chinese propaganda in India through her.

    • @zikoza4829
      @zikoza4829 Месяц назад +11

      What propaganda...she shows her communication skills, even india have separatist issue like khalistan, kashmir, northeast .every country does

    • @Abhinav-m4o
      @Abhinav-m4o Месяц назад +16

      ​@@zikoza4829khalistan is in canada

    • @micheal6803
      @micheal6803 Месяц назад +11

      Heard about honey trapping 😂,well she got em

    • @sauravgogoi4535
      @sauravgogoi4535 Месяц назад +14

      @@zikoza4829 Tibet had its own Government and Government is overthrown by Chinese govt. But Khalistani(Canadian terrorist), Kashmiri Terrorist(Pakistani Terrorist), Northeast insurgency had no government. So do not compare Chinese with Indian situation.

    • @satplm3011
      @satplm3011 Месяц назад +1

      I know you only like palki sharma

  • @Fly_Adventure
    @Fly_Adventure Месяц назад +145

    I don't understand why you asking this question to her ??? she don't know anything about real Tibet History !!

    • @jan-pk6un
      @jan-pk6un Месяц назад +3

      True .she should read the history well before commenting on Tibet issue .

    • @buchungnyerpatsang9310
      @buchungnyerpatsang9310 Месяц назад

      Paid channel,FREE TIBET.

    • @dolmanorkey2342
      @dolmanorkey2342 Месяц назад

      It’s true that they don’t know about Tibet as they learn from their schools false history which is made by Chinese government. They really don’t have access even for free press or social media. May be she will learn from this Podcast the truth. Thank you Ranveer for bringing up this topic. She will definitely learn a lot later. So my Tibetans please do write more of the truth rather giving bad comments as not only she but many people will know the truth . So share your stories . He is really trying his best to make her understand the truth. He explained well to her .

    • @RvVx7
      @RvVx7 Месяц назад

      Yeah he shouldn't give such tough topics 😂

    • @m.k5391
      @m.k5391 Месяц назад

      Views

  • @gourabsaha8577
    @gourabsaha8577 Месяц назад +81

    Tibet was a bigger nation than China at one point. Tibet is now illegally occupied by China.

    • @aliciazhang1ty
      @aliciazhang1ty Месяц назад +4

      No it never was.

    • @Sweetsugardaddy
      @Sweetsugardaddy Месяц назад +5

      ​@@aliciazhang1tygo and learn history buddy

    • @theawesomeman9821
      @theawesomeman9821 Месяц назад +5

      you could say the same thing about India annexing Hyderabad and Nagaland against their own will.

    • @Lotusflower888
      @Lotusflower888 Месяц назад +1

      and also kashmir ladakh

    • @Yontengrg-o7z
      @Yontengrg-o7z Месяц назад +1

      @@Sweetsugardaddy that person is chinese agent, last name zhang

  • @tseringNyima-x3l
    @tseringNyima-x3l Месяц назад +178

    Tibet is independent country before 1959. China occupied my country.

    • @zxa875
      @zxa875 Месяц назад +3

      look at the map printed befor 1959, no one recognize tibet is independent

    • @tenz5812
      @tenz5812 Месяц назад +10

      Tibet was an independent nation before China occupied the Tibet. The Tibetan has their own unique culture, language, and culture that differs from China mainland and has never been a part of mainland China.

    • @小明-r4h
      @小明-r4h Месяц назад +2

      @tenz5812 like what you said,Indian should be divided into hundreds parts ,because every part have different languages 、history and cultures.and before England come to Indian ,they were different countries and even they have different colors of skin

    • @Bhishek_sahu_br01
      @Bhishek_sahu_br01 Месяц назад

      ​@@zxa875usa will make u understand what was??😂

    • @Bhishek_sahu_br01
      @Bhishek_sahu_br01 Месяц назад

      ​@@小明-r4hbut the people accept I'm Indian what he'll the skin colour is btt btt in case of tibbetian they don't say I'm chinese without pressure 😂😂

  • @lobsangtsering5651
    @lobsangtsering5651 Месяц назад +107

    Tibet was a free country once but China occupied my home country and we had to leave my own country

    • @小明-r4h
      @小明-r4h Месяц назад

      @小明-r4h
      2分钟前
      No ,Tibet is never a independent country !Ok ,please tell me who or which country treated Tibet as a independent country in history ?

    • @RaviRanjan-fr2bt
      @RaviRanjan-fr2bt Месяц назад +9

      ​@@小明-r4hI just want to know curiosity...Are you the AI Robot or the human manually working from Beijing? 😅😂

    • @dlm2003
      @dlm2003 Месяц назад +1

      @@小明-r4homg tsktsk

    • @tsee_dorj
      @tsee_dorj Месяц назад +4

      @@小明-r4hbullying small countries shame on China

    • @tibetanchineseofchina
      @tibetanchineseofchina Месяц назад

      @lobsangtsering5651, Tibet is a part of the People's Republic of China. It is an autonomous region of the People's Republic of China. Tibetan culture and Buddhism are part of Chinese culture. -- Public statement from The 14th Dalai Lama, March 15, 2005

  • @RahulKar-j7t
    @RahulKar-j7t Месяц назад +175

    Asked her if she is allowed to criticize government 😂😂😂

    • @shortswithyoutube4995
      @shortswithyoutube4995 Месяц назад +7

      Yes bro it is propaganda based video

    • @letsexplore9633
      @letsexplore9633 Месяц назад +11

      There is freedom of speech in China but after the speech,freedom is not guaranteed.😂😂😂😂😅

    • @tashitara
      @tashitara Месяц назад

      @@letsexplore9633😂

    • @lifenrose9972
      @lifenrose9972 Месяц назад

      She can. Chinese can criticise the govt.

    • @Sandwich_supremacy
      @Sandwich_supremacy 5 дней назад

      ​@@lifenrose9972jack ma have other thoughts 😂

  • @kungawangjor1478
    @kungawangjor1478 Месяц назад +46

    The way she explained "Tibet is part of china" is like " Pizza is Chowmin because chowmin has vegetables😂
    Logic left her mind 🤭

  • @dickyichonzom2686
    @dickyichonzom2686 Месяц назад +83

    I am Tibetan born in India and my parent were born in Tibet . Till now they are not granted visa to Tibet by Chinese embassy. Yes Tibetan kids in Tibet are forced to learn Chinese language .

    • @小明-r4h
      @小明-r4h Месяц назад +5

      That is good !You are Indian now and for ever ,only Tibetan in China can call themselves Tibetan. You are Indian tibetan ,but finally you are Indian . Your indian should try your best to learn indian language and English ,that is good for having a bright future in India . And Tibetan in China are Chinese ,they should learn Chinese language ,it’s good for having a bright future in China .

    • @Lotusflower888
      @Lotusflower888 Месяц назад

      Hehe so you only learn tibetan in india🤨😬

    • @TIBETANVIKING-lw8oc
      @TIBETANVIKING-lw8oc Месяц назад +4

      @@小明-r4h Tibet has been an independent nation since ancient time, and it has never been a part of China anywhere in its history. It was only in 1949, that the communist China forcefully occupied Tibet, and unleashed its draconian rule in the region. If the statehood of Tibet is to be set as a precondition to talk about Tibet, then the communist regime should go hiding behind the bushes of the Great walls.
      Since the time of the first King of Tibet, Nyatri Tsanpo [around 400 BCE]2, some 43 kings had ruled Tibet till the middle of 9th century CE. It was followed by Sakya Lamas, Phagdrupas, Rinpungs, Tsangpas and the Dalai Lamas till 1959, the year when China took full control over Tibet. In all these years, Tibet had maintained varied relationships of war, peace, and accommodation with its immediate neighbors: India, China, Mongolia and Nepal. How much China may want to distort, the fact is as early as 7th century, Tang Emperor Taitsung had to kowtow before the might of King Srongtsan Gampo and offer his daughter Princess Wencheng Kungchu’s hand to the Tibetan king.
      In 763 CE, during the reign of King Trisrong Deutsan, Tibetan troops captured the Chinese capital Changan, present day Xian, and installed the friendly prince Chengchung as the new Emperor. During King Trirelpachen’s period, a peace treaty was concluded between Tibet and China in 821 CE in which it was proclaimed, “Tibetans shall be happy in Tibet, and Chinese in China. Both shall not intrude into other’s territory”. These events were inscribed on the stone pillars [Tib: rdo ring] erected in the Chinese city of Changan, Tibetan capital Lhasa and the border Gungu Meru. The pillars in Lhasa stand witness to these historical facts.
      Later, in the 13th century, like some other countries, both Tibet and China also came under the influence of the Mongolian empire. But China was ruled directly by Mongol emperors under Yuan dynasty [1279-1368]. Tibet enjoyed great autonomy under Priest-patron [Tib: chos yon] relationship between the Mongol Emperors and the Sakya Lamas. However, Tibet later shook off the Mongolian influence in 1350, while China became free only in 1368. Therefore, the Chinese assertion that China inherited Tibet from Mongolian Yuan dynasty does not hold any ground.
      During the reign of the Dalai Lamas starting from the mid 17th century, Mongol, China and Nepal influenced Tibet occasionally, but nothing amounted to the loss of Tibetan independence. When Tibet realized the “Great Game” of British and Russian Empire, His Holiness the 13th Dalai Lama declared Tibetan independence on 13th February 1913

    • @YAYATIBETANVLOGS185
      @YAYATIBETANVLOGS185 Месяц назад +1

      Yes but right v r Tibetan people

    • @sarvesh704
      @sarvesh704 Месяц назад

      @@小明-r4h Tibetan do not become Chinese just because Chinese Communist party occupied it. One day communist party rule will be over and Tibet will be free.

  • @pondakpa6557
    @pondakpa6557 Месяц назад +16

    I need a podcast with Tibetan leadership to make clarity.

  • @Jackhoney10
    @Jackhoney10 Месяц назад +142

    Tibetan people can't keep a photo of his holiness The 14th Dalia Lama in Tibet, is this freedom?

    • @tenzinyangchen5921
      @tenzinyangchen5921 Месяц назад +5

      Exactly

    • @小明-r4h
      @小明-r4h Месяц назад +1

      That is true in Tibet !Every nation can’t allow the people to hold the separatist’s picture ,right ?

    • @tenzinyeshi5160
      @tenzinyeshi5160 Месяц назад +7

      Exactly if China think tibet as a family then why they don’t allow tibetan people to kept picture of our spiritual leader inside Tibet . In any journal or in any news our spiritual leader never had spoken bad word to China in fact he speaks of neighborhood brotherhood with China. He is very compassionate that he is still waiting when China will be honest to themselves.
      Talking about the girl above in the video she said she don’t want to speak in the topic in which she is not expert . So she can only see that people in Tibet live their lives to survive doing business , going school , celebrating festival , greeting each other , welcoming tourist , ofcourse people have to live they have to survive . so you saw what you want to see . People in Tibet in the capital area mostly younger generation they are very much dependent on the Chinese government what they can provide weather in an education service or health service or their career . If feel people who are old ages mostly have the feeling of being freedom in religion and language. So said that they can’t keep their spiritual leader picture or their own flag .
      If you love us allow us our flag and picture of our spiritual leader picture in Tibet . After that you say we are family I will not say anything .
      Tuesdays China allows many tourist to visit Tibet why not before why we can see vlog in Tibet on RUclips. Why not before . So much confident that they waiting for a next generation to portrait .

    • @Yontengrg-o7z
      @Yontengrg-o7z Месяц назад +1

      @@tenzinyeshi5160 are you writing essay???

    • @tenzinyeshi5160
      @tenzinyeshi5160 Месяц назад

      @@Yontengrg-o7z thank you for the time you gave to read my comment

  • @JampaTashi-l8e
    @JampaTashi-l8e Месяц назад +118

    Tibet is Independent Country before 1959

    • @小明-r4h
      @小明-r4h Месяц назад +1

      But there are no countries treat Tibet as a independent country before or after 1959.

    • @小明-r4h
      @小明-r4h Месяц назад

      No ,Tibet is never a independent country !Ok ,please tell me who or which country treated Tibet as a independent country in history ?

    • @shortswithyoutube4995
      @shortswithyoutube4995 Месяц назад

      ​@@小明-r4h in chusul agreement tibet india china sign agreement chusul you can search in internet

    • @shortswithyoutube4995
      @shortswithyoutube4995 Месяц назад +6

      Tibet is free country before 1959

    • @小明-r4h
      @小明-r4h Месяц назад

      Every Dailai Lama was appointed by the central government of China ,including the 14th Dalai Lama!14th Dalai Lama once was the Vice Chairman of the National People's Congress of the People's Republic of China。This is 100% truth !

  • @tenzinpassang2991
    @tenzinpassang2991 Месяц назад +65

    Freetibet 💯

    • @zxa875
      @zxa875 Месяц назад +2

      Free Sikkim\Arunachal\Khalistan\ Kashmir\Ladak\Northeast.

    • @Don_Junior105
      @Don_Junior105 Месяц назад

      Arunachal Pradesh was Southern Tibet. When is India freeing that? Both India and China are occupying Tibet.

  • @namgozardo
    @namgozardo Месяц назад +43

    I am Tibetan who born in Tibet grow up in Tibet ,we Tibetan never felt Tibet was part of China,Tibet was independent country before 1959 but china occupied Tibet in 1959 .

    • @Atheist-Libertarian
      @Atheist-Libertarian Месяц назад

      Yes.
      Most people know that.
      Unfortunately that girl is either consciously speaking like an agent of CCP,
      Or even worse if is brainwashed by CCP, then she would believe all those things

    • @cariopuppetmaster
      @cariopuppetmaster Месяц назад

      Ok but your opinion doesn't matter to those that have power

  • @bluesky590
    @bluesky590 Месяц назад +66

    She should comment on tibet like that otherwise she would be in jail when she back to China 😅

  • @lobsangtsering5651
    @lobsangtsering5651 Месяц назад +45

    Bro you should have shown her some videos evidence of how China captured my country Tibet

    • @ultronic_004
      @ultronic_004 Месяц назад +6

      Indians with tibetians🙌🏻💙

  • @invin1988
    @invin1988 Месяц назад +39

    Tibet was not always part of China. It is not just religion that separates China and Tibet. China attacked and annexed Tibet in 1951.

    • @小明-r4h
      @小明-r4h Месяц назад

      14th Dalai Lama will not agree with you ,once he was Vice Chairman of the National People's Congress of the People's Republic of China. This is 100% truth ,everyone can google it on internet !

    • @tibetanchineseofchina
      @tibetanchineseofchina Месяц назад

      June 23, 2003
      The Indian side recognizes that the Tibet Autonomous Region is part of the territory of the People's Republic of China and reiterates that it does not allow Tibetans to engage in anti-China political activities in India.

    • @lvjinbin28
      @lvjinbin28 Месяц назад

      even Taiwan still claim Tibet in ROC constitution, so you should try Forward Policy again haha

  • @tenKAI11
    @tenKAI11 Месяц назад +14

    There is a difference between giving free education and forcing more than a million Tibetan kids to put in Chinese boarding school

  • @Thupten78
    @Thupten78 Месяц назад +22

    Mongolia is not a china, and Tibet is not a china. She claims her as a mongol Chinese which is non existence unless she is mix of mongol and Chinese. If she is mongol descendent then she is mongol. Mongolia is divided into two countries namely inner and outer mongol. Inner mongol is with China like Tibet which is under China after its invasion in 1959. I think you are asking questions to someone who is famous in China and such person can never speak truth due to many reasons. Tibetan kids are forced to learn Chinese not Tibetan. Thank you Ranveer for bringing up Tibetan issues. You can tell she is one hundred percent Chinese representation. Tibetan doesn’t hate Chinese people, it’s the CCP government who invaded Tibet. Indian government should know better Communist Chinese government from the suffering of Tibetan people. When China first entered Tibet as a beggar, and then as a helper and as a developer. They have built roads and bridges and finally through roads and bridges Chinese Army came with guns, tanks and bombs and turned Tibet upside down. Being friendly with Chinese may benefits Indian government temporarily but eventually Indian government will be paralyzed by CCP. It’s time take strong stance against China before it’s too late if someone believes in patriotism and India as a great Nation. Jai India, Jai Tibet

    • @N12534-f
      @N12534-f Месяц назад

      Then why does Dalai Lama say he only wants autonomy not independence,if Tibetan leader himself is not taking a strong stance then how can others take?

    • @Thupten78
      @Thupten78 Месяц назад

      @@N12534-f if Tibetan exiles government fight for independence Tibet how would Indian government react or respond to us. Not only India, what will be world’s perspective and treatment towards us. World leaders are strongly influenced by CCP at this century and they have been labeling us a separatist group even though we don’t claim for independent Tibet. If we fight for Independent Tibet then they will destroy us under the name of terrorist. Right now at this moment it’s only the matter of survival of Tibetan civilization and its culture. Autonomy is all about survival of our people and its cultural and identity which is based on Buddhism that was originated from Nalanda, India.

    • @tibetanchineseofchina
      @tibetanchineseofchina Месяц назад

      Mongol is ethnicity, Chinse is nationality, like Han Chinese, Han is ethnicity, Chinese is nationality. Chinese can be considered as ethnicity of all 56 groups.

    • @Thupten78
      @Thupten78 Месяц назад

      @ Great Gangis Khan invaded not only china but reached faraway countries. His name is still popular and no one can deny it. Still one part of Mongolia is Independent. Mongolia that went under CCP is under CCP at this point but it cannot take away that fact of Mongolia being a great free Nation. Your are brainwashed by CCP propaganda and I don’t blame you. I hope this answered your question. Thanks

  • @tseringchodon4266
    @tseringchodon4266 Месяц назад +24

    She is not the right person to potcast. Your show might countdown. Also she doesn’t possess any experience in any field. Nor an expert. So sad for this show.

  • @ten695
    @ten695 Месяц назад +21

    Ranvir Atleast you should invite some other knowledgeable person for this interview regarding Tibet issue.. ofcourse her answer will be in 5:38 Chinese favour . Chinese citizen themselve don’t have right to freedom to speak against their govt..

    • @kellydolma3809
      @kellydolma3809 Месяц назад +2

      Exactly

    • @dfgh-ke8ch
      @dfgh-ke8ch 8 дней назад

      why would any sane Chinese citizen will support separatism of their own country? Will any Indian citizen who loves his/her nation allow Khalistan or some northeast ethnicities to gain independence?

  • @basernishant
    @basernishant Месяц назад +62

    Obviously she will talk in favour of china. She can even says pakistan is part of china.😂

  • @tenzindakpa1080
    @tenzindakpa1080 Месяц назад +21

    Why don’t you interview the professor Hon Shiang Lau, he is a Han Chinese living in USA. He challenged that Tibet was never a part of China since antiquity. You have to listen to both side so that the real fact about Tibet can be judged by public specially Indian public directly linked. Indian border dispute with China will never be solved unless the Tibet unresolved dispute will be solved.

    • @QuantumNinja1.9
      @QuantumNinja1.9 Месяц назад

      True, he was meek in this podcast. Probably compromised

  • @JampaTashi-l8e
    @JampaTashi-l8e Месяц назад +24

    After 1959 Chinese Occupied our Country...Free Tibet

    • @小明-r4h
      @小明-r4h Месяц назад +1

      @小明-r4h
      2分钟前
      No ,Tibet is never a independent country !Ok ,please tell me who or which country treated Tibet as a independent country in history ?

    • @shortswithyoutube4995
      @shortswithyoutube4995 Месяц назад +3

      ​@@小明-r4h go comment in your internet not here tibet is free country 🤬

    • @小明-r4h
      @小明-r4h Месяц назад

      14th Dalai Lama once was the Vice Chairman of the National People's Congress of the People's Republic of China。This is 100% truth !Please google it !

  • @Arunh9-pw7lp
    @Arunh9-pw7lp Месяц назад +45

    She looks trained to speak on politics.

    • @satplm3011
      @satplm3011 Месяц назад +3

      Like palki sharma?

    • @Arunh9-pw7lp
      @Arunh9-pw7lp Месяц назад +2

      @@satplm3011 Palki Sharma is journalist. She’s obviously trained to speak about anything & everything. She however is a celebrity & a common Chinese girl. We know where her words are coming from.

    • @satplm3011
      @satplm3011 Месяц назад +1

      @Arunh9-pw7lp so your common girl and celebrity always speaks against india and modi??? Supports khalistan? Supports china? Supports pakistan?? Supports north east independence??

    • @Arunh9-pw7lp
      @Arunh9-pw7lp Месяц назад +1

      @@satplm3011 I just said she looks trained to speak on politics just like Palki. Palki is openly political while she claims to be “common girl”. You know what i am saying but it’s not your fault. You’ve got a job of a keyboard warrior so you’ve to speak anyway but i have no such pressure.

    • @samriddhabasu8764
      @samriddhabasu8764 Месяц назад

      ​@@satplm3011 why are you getting excited my friend, she believes that her government is good, just like I believe our central leadership is good compared to the previous leaderships, she believes her government is giving equal respect to everyone, and she might be oblivious of the fact that PLA have committed mass atrocities on mongolia and tibet, and the way china keeps in it's education, hiding the facts about it's own oppression, it is quite obvious that she will be speaking for the government

  • @subekchathapa576
    @subekchathapa576 Месяц назад +79

    The most useless podcast miss guiding and miss educating young Indians

    • @crazycreator1891
      @crazycreator1891 Месяц назад

      Are you tibetian brother.

    • @tarunpal3852
      @tarunpal3852 Месяц назад +1

      Absolutely.

    • @tenzang5830
      @tenzang5830 Месяц назад +1

      @@crazycreator1891 I don’t think tht guy is Tibetan .. I can sense by the writing..

  • @tjangchup654
    @tjangchup654 Месяц назад +34

    Trying to be logical without facts. Chinese took Tibet in 1959 and it’s on record and you are saying we never know the truth. 🤦🏻‍♀️ Oh bhai maro mujhe maro! By hearing that I have ZERO Credibility with whatever she says.

    • @zxa875
      @zxa875 Месяц назад +1

      Sikkim\Arunachal\Khalistan\ Kashmir\Ladak\Northeast are not a part of india.

    • @JanmejayaDas9
      @JanmejayaDas9 Месяц назад +3

      @@zxa875 nice joke

    • @shiishinchiu6636
      @shiishinchiu6636 Месяц назад +1

      Tibet is recognized as part of China by both the United Nations and India. If India were to withdraw its recognition, it could lead to significant issues.

    • @tjangchup654
      @tjangchup654 Месяц назад +1

      @@shiishinchiu6636 Oh dear, It doesn't change the fact that China took over Tibet by killing thousands of Tibetans, destroying so many temples and monasteries that she said “appreciated” of and even Dalai lama’s picture is restricted for Tibetans in Tibet to pray. And Oh dear, first you have to be good to India on the border. Apparently, India has a problem with that.

    • @shiishinchiu6636
      @shiishinchiu6636 Месяц назад

      @@tjangchup654 Before China took over in the 1950s Tibet was a society under "feudal serfdom," asserting that approximately 95% of the population were serfs with little to no rights. They highlight severe conditions where serfs were treated as property and subjected to exploitation and oppression, often with no basic human rights.

  • @biswanathmahapatra8441
    @biswanathmahapatra8441 Месяц назад +45

    Tibet was never part of Chinese civilisation historically….

    • @aliciazhang1ty
      @aliciazhang1ty Месяц назад +2

      China controlled Tibet at certain points of time. including Qing dynasty.

    • @aliciazhang1ty
      @aliciazhang1ty Месяц назад

      Northeast was never part of india. Free north east.

    • @biswanathmahapatra8441
      @biswanathmahapatra8441 Месяц назад +5

      @@aliciazhang1ty i said , from civilisation point of view, Not politically……
      Politically, even India had ruled over Indonesia once.. does that mean its part of Indian civilisation?..no right.. they r culturally different.. similarly Tibet is different from China…

    • @aliciazhang1ty
      @aliciazhang1ty Месяц назад

      @@biswanathmahapatra8441 How is Tibet different than rest of China?

    • @Yontengrg-o7z
      @Yontengrg-o7z Месяц назад +1

      @@aliciazhang1ty very different, tibetans only have 2 families which are bhutanese and himalayan people of nepal(sherpa,gurung,tamang,hyolmo)

  • @DechenWangmo816
    @DechenWangmo816 Месяц назад +15

    Dear....one of our neighbours went to Tibet few months ago... they told us that...there's few monastery....but no monks in there...
    I didn't ask more...coz I know everything was changed...
    I have one favour for you ...if you don't mind...
    Please do research and read about our history...🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
    I know whole Chinese are not bad...but some of them are fucking bad...but I don't have ill feelings towards you guys...
    "TRUTH ALWAYS PREVAILS"

  • @mangalamsingh8909
    @mangalamsingh8909 Месяц назад +14

    Tibet is not the part of china , they will say one day India is also part of china like they say about arunachal pradesh (part of India), look at her face she knows she is telling the lie or she doesn't know but she want to stand with her lack of knowledge , and protect her government doing.

  • @Lharden77
    @Lharden77 Месяц назад +12

    U haven’t seen those poor Chinese who are suffering in hunger ur govt shows only bright side not those dark sides

    • @tseringlhamo4896
      @tseringlhamo4896 Месяц назад

      Yeah that’s why there own country people comes out to other countries and protest for there rights. She have zero knowledge on her own country. Plus how come she can talk about my country TIBET.

  • @sangmoshakya117
    @sangmoshakya117 Месяц назад +20

    Tibet is Never a part of China lady. And thank you brother talking about Tibet. Love you more. ❤❤❤

    • @shortswithyoutube4995
      @shortswithyoutube4995 Месяц назад +3

      Yes tibet is free country

    • @RajuBoro-mk9xx
      @RajuBoro-mk9xx Месяц назад +1

      ​@@shortswithyoutube4995 Jammu and Kashmir, north east

    • @shiishinchiu6636
      @shiishinchiu6636 Месяц назад

      India was also not a country before the British put it together. 😂

    • @dragonwukong9
      @dragonwukong9 Месяц назад

      Tibet was always part of china ❤❤

  • @ngawangwangmo-oz3dz
    @ngawangwangmo-oz3dz Месяц назад +5

    Tibet was a free country before 1959

  • @Jamesyarphel
    @Jamesyarphel Месяц назад +14

    Why you invite only one person? What are you trying to convey the message here? If you want to understand the issue then bring both party here and debate

  • @rishabhsingh9976
    @rishabhsingh9976 Месяц назад +13

    you can never justify your invasion and illegally occupied in the name of development and facilities

  • @tenzin4665
    @tenzin4665 Месяц назад +35

    Tibet is not part of china it’s a separate country.
    We have our own language, and traditions.
    China occupied Tibet since 1959.
    FREE TIBET💪

    • @小明-r4h
      @小明-r4h Месяц назад +1

      @小明-r4h
      2分钟前
      No ,Tibet is never a independent country !Ok ,please tell me who or which country treated Tibet as a independent country in history ?

    • @Yontengrg-o7z
      @Yontengrg-o7z Месяц назад

      @@小明-r4h he/she is telling truth, chinese occupied tibet in 1959

    • @Yontengrg-o7z
      @Yontengrg-o7z Месяц назад

      @@小明-r4h you are chinese agent

    • @小明-r4h
      @小明-r4h Месяц назад

      14th Dalai Lama once was the Vice Chairman of the National People's Congress of the People's Republic of China。This is 100% truth !Please google it !

    • @dragonwukong9
      @dragonwukong9 Месяц назад

      Hawaii was never part OF THE USA FREE HAWAII!! 💪

  • @deckyitsomo3476
    @deckyitsomo3476 Месяц назад +11

    Tibet was never part of china

  • @OBChold
    @OBChold Месяц назад +10

    Thank you trs , I am Tibetan

    • @induchopra3014
      @induchopra3014 Месяц назад +2

      Tibetans are not Chinese. They are not communist or areligious

  • @tenzinsemsang2217
    @tenzinsemsang2217 Месяц назад +12

    Tibet isn’t the part of china
    It’s a different country but Chinese communist forcefully conquered Tibet
    Free Tibet free human rights

    • @lvjinbin28
      @lvjinbin28 Месяц назад +1

      even Taiwan still claim Tibet in ROC constitution, so you should try Forward Policy again haha

    • @cariopuppetmaster
      @cariopuppetmaster Месяц назад

      If it's a different country why do they use Chinese passports?

  • @NgawangThinley-o4d
    @NgawangThinley-o4d Месяц назад +13

    Sorry .100% Tibet is Not Part of china

    • @cariopuppetmaster
      @cariopuppetmaster Месяц назад

      Except it is. So what passport does the average Lhasa man travel under? If it's not a part of China why do they use Chinese passports?

  • @gourabsaha8577
    @gourabsaha8577 Месяц назад +9

    She has been taught to say this.

  • @Bookaholic_
    @Bookaholic_ Месяц назад +20

    No it's not a part of China ...you invaded it in the 1960s

    • @zxa875
      @zxa875 Месяц назад +2

      Sikkim\Arunachal\Khalistan\ Kashmir\Ladak\Northeast are not a part of india.

    • @shiishinchiu6636
      @shiishinchiu6636 Месяц назад +1

      Read a book.

    • @Bookaholic_
      @Bookaholic_ Месяц назад

      @@shiishinchiu6636 I've read plenty but obviously i avoided the Chinese propaganda books

    • @shiishinchiu6636
      @shiishinchiu6636 Месяц назад +1

      @@Bookaholic_ Did you read about the Tang, Yuan and the Qing with regards to Tibet?

    • @cariopuppetmaster
      @cariopuppetmaster Месяц назад

      Then it is a part of China. Also pretty convient you are forgetting about the Qing huh.

  • @saileshdurgam4825
    @saileshdurgam4825 Месяц назад +9

    Nice burning questions asked by ranveer ,she got provoked 😅

  • @shivnegi6614
    @shivnegi6614 Месяц назад +19

    She is chinese propaganda spokesperson

    • @satplm3011
      @satplm3011 Месяц назад +2

      Like palki sharma?

  • @shivaputra_krishna_IIT
    @shivaputra_krishna_IIT Месяц назад +1

    She is so confident that in future, people will be learning Mandarin along with English

  • @Ugyxnm
    @Ugyxnm Месяц назад +7

    Tibet was a free and independent country. It’s fully invaded by China communists party. Since from 1959 Mao’s regime killed millions of our Innocent Tibetans. Still today China is completely trying to destroy our culture and language too. We Tibetans will never give up. One world, one dream. Free Tibet. Bhoe Gyalo✊🏼✊🏼✊🏼

  • @sonamyangzom-wh1xp
    @sonamyangzom-wh1xp Месяц назад +5

    There were thousands and thousands of gigantic and massive ancient Monasteries, which were all demolished by CCP and massacred thousands of high spiritual masters, monks and Nuns 😢😢😢

  • @tenzinpehor7126
    @tenzinpehor7126 Месяц назад +4

    Tibet was a independent and separate country and will be an independent country. Long live his holiness the dalai lama.

  • @chimedorjee1974
    @chimedorjee1974 Месяц назад +12

    Tibet is not part of china 🙏🙏🙏

  • @tenzinchoekey1100
    @tenzinchoekey1100 Месяц назад +9

    Tibet is never part of China

  • @tenzindakpa1080
    @tenzindakpa1080 Месяц назад +6

    India never had border with China before 1959.

    • @cariopuppetmaster
      @cariopuppetmaster Месяц назад

      British India had border agreements with China so no you are wrong

  • @FUTURITYlko
    @FUTURITYlko Месяц назад +14

    Worst talk show episode, she doesn't know anything and tshe is applying Chinese narrative

  • @YOGIM32
    @YOGIM32 Месяц назад +11

    Should have asked about tianamen square

  • @tenzin_tsering
    @tenzin_tsering Месяц назад +4

    Thanks for all the good questions. Free Tibet.

  • @Tenzin1675
    @Tenzin1675 Месяц назад +2

    Tibet is not a part of China… we have our own culture and language traditions..

  • @tenzindakpa1080
    @tenzindakpa1080 Месяц назад +4

    There is a book called Tibet Brief 2020 authored by Michael Van Walt Van Praag. He challenged all the claims of Chinese government over Tibet published in their book called white paper. I hope you must be aware of all this book.

  • @ranaaksham739
    @ranaaksham739 Месяц назад +3

    I just heard one thing from this podcast that Chinese know nothing about there country and they just love each other 😂

  • @nawangthinlay2792
    @nawangthinlay2792 Месяц назад +6

    I feel pity to her when she says she is Mongolia and yet Chinese. Mongolia Chinese and Tibetans are totally different countries. Although she is beautiful in looks yet has very poor idea of historical facts . Better dive deep into history of Tibet and Mongolia. Truth is truth.

    • @lvjinbin28
      @lvjinbin28 Месяц назад

      The Yuan Dynasty ruled Tibet, Was the Yuan Dynasty a dynasty in China or a dynasty in Mongolia?

  • @tenzinlekphel1453
    @tenzinlekphel1453 Месяц назад +1

    Mary’s story reflects a perspective shaped by the Chinese government's narratives, a common outcome of strict government control over information in China. Many in China grow up with state-approved versions of history and culture, often missing the voices of those affected, like Tibetans who still struggle for basic freedoms. It’s essential to recognize how information is often filtered to align with the government’s viewpoint, especially around sensitive topics like Tibet.

  • @karmachoden4906
    @karmachoden4906 Месяц назад +11

    home work is must...

  • @tenzindakpa1080
    @tenzindakpa1080 Месяц назад +4

    Professor HON-SHIAN Lau is a Chinese professor who wrote a book on Tibetan history based Chinese official documents. Why he wrote this book because of his curiosity to know the fact about Tibet that why Chinese government always saying that Tibet is the part of china. There is absolutely not necessary to claim that Tibet is a part of china but the historical fact does not allowed china to claim over Tibet. That is the reason why the Chinese government altering the old Tibetan history.

    • @shiishinchiu6636
      @shiishinchiu6636 Месяц назад

      Tibet belongs to China from the Tang Dynasty.

  • @subekchathapa576
    @subekchathapa576 Месяц назад +15

    Haha she knows everything why the heck in this world she is here in India because of them Chinese his holiness Dalai Lama is not able to return his home his kingdom

    • @hmmmm9174
      @hmmmm9174 Месяц назад

      Dalai Lama was funded by CIA. Indian people too ready to shill for cia backed enemies in India who fool them

  • @momnjayden3043
    @momnjayden3043 Месяц назад +2

    The fact this lady pointing out that china has built Tibets infrastructure in a more immaculate way everything is beautiful in terms of education
    Health etc but the fact remains that they colonised Tibet and never gave its freedom!its a sensitive topic and holds immense sentiments for Tibetan people!!

  • @lobsangtenzin9169
    @lobsangtenzin9169 Месяц назад +3

    Invite Tenzin Tsundue to hear Tibetan perspective.. be fair

  • @tenzindolkar8062
    @tenzindolkar8062 Месяц назад +9

    Wat celeb- lack of knowledge. She is just scared en nerveus to answer the truth…. Bla bla bla by the way Ranveer-correction here…80percent Tibetaans in tibet not China….

  • @tenzintsering912
    @tenzintsering912 Месяц назад +5

    Next time If u got any chance podcast with a Chinese people you should ask them why Chinese want to destroy Tibetan language, religion and culture. Why Tibetan children get separated from their parents and force to learn Chinese languages. Why They remove Tibetan language from the schools. Why His Holiness the Dalai Lama photo is banned in Tibet???????

  • @tenzang5830
    @tenzang5830 Месяц назад +3

    China is so powerful and greedy that they literally changed the name of the country Tibet to Himalaya world in one of the museum in France, name is musée guimet, Paris. How they can control and put pressure on that museum to change the country name ? Wah .. that too in free country like France .. so shameful act. Museum is to keep the fact, studied, and displayed to the public and not to modify or to change. So sad …

  • @kalsangtashi3040
    @kalsangtashi3040 Месяц назад +6

    Look at the face of this girl, whatever she is saying, it is clearly visible from her face that she is lying.

  • @ngasang77
    @ngasang77 Месяц назад +8

    @TRS Clips Tibet was never or will be part of china historically. please ask her abt human rights in Tibet, seeing Tibet from chinese eye and Tibetan eye is very two different side stories. 😔 Free Tibet

  • @ptsering5990
    @ptsering5990 Месяц назад +2

    Thank you TRS Clip. Namaste.
    Tashi Delek.

  • @tenzingtravelvlog3845
    @tenzingtravelvlog3845 Месяц назад +7

    How tibet become part of china if you look at tibet history tibet kingdom and china kingdom are different for centuries

    • @zxa875
      @zxa875 Месяц назад +1

      Sikkim\Arunachal\Khalistan\ Kashmir\Ladak\Northeast are not a part of india.

    • @TIBETANVIKING-lw8oc
      @TIBETANVIKING-lw8oc Месяц назад

      @@zxa875 Tibet has been an independent nation since ancient time, and it has never been a part of China anywhere in its history. It was only in 1949, that the communist China forcefully occupied Tibet, and unleashed its draconian rule in the region. If the statehood of Tibet is to be set as a precondition to talk about Tibet, then the communist regime should go hiding behind the bushes of the Great walls.
      Since the time of the first King of Tibet, Nyatri Tsanpo [around 400 BCE]2, some 43 kings had ruled Tibet till the middle of 9th century CE. It was followed by Sakya Lamas, Phagdrupas, Rinpungs, Tsangpas and the Dalai Lamas till 1959, the year when China took full control over Tibet. In all these years, Tibet had maintained varied relationships of war, peace, and accommodation with its immediate neighbors: India, China, Mongolia and Nepal. How much China may want to distort, the fact is as early as 7th century, Tang Emperor Taitsung had to kowtow before the might of King Srongtsan Gampo and offer his daughter Princess Wencheng Kungchu’s hand to the Tibetan king.
      In 763 CE, during the reign of King Trisrong Deutsan, Tibetan troops captured the Chinese capital Changan, present day Xian, and installed the friendly prince Chengchung as the new Emperor. During King Trirelpachen’s period, a peace treaty was concluded between Tibet and China in 821 CE in which it was proclaimed, “Tibetans shall be happy in Tibet, and Chinese in China. Both shall not intrude into other’s territory”. These events were inscribed on the stone pillars [Tib: rdo ring] erected in the Chinese city of Changan, Tibetan capital Lhasa and the border Gungu Meru. The pillars in Lhasa stand witness to these historical facts.
      Later, in the 13th century, like some other countries, both Tibet and China also came under the influence of the Mongolian empire. But China was ruled directly by Mongol emperors under Yuan dynasty [1279-1368]. Tibet enjoyed great autonomy under Priest-patron [Tib: chos yon] relationship between the Mongol Emperors and the Sakya Lamas. However, Tibet later shook off the Mongolian influence in 1350, while China became free only in 1368. Therefore, the Chinese assertion that China inherited Tibet from Mongolian Yuan dynasty does not hold any ground.
      During the reign of the Dalai Lamas starting from the mid 17th century, Mongol, China and Nepal influenced Tibet occasionally, but nothing amounted to the loss of Tibetan independence. When Tibet realized the “Great Game” of British and Russian Empire, His Holiness the 13th Dalai Lama declared Tibetan independence on 13th February 1913

  • @Tibetan-Channel
    @Tibetan-Channel Месяц назад +1

    Do not disrespect the show host Ranveer. He is generally a pro Tibet.

  • @Nobullshitok
    @Nobullshitok Месяц назад +5

    Asked about Arunachal, ladakh and Aksai

  • @Rosehan1251
    @Rosehan1251 Месяц назад +2

    If you ask her is India part of Pakistan, she would say yes.

  • @anujsubba6722
    @anujsubba6722 Месяц назад +4

    Waste of time calling her we could literally see that she is favoring Chinese Government

  • @Sondhon
    @Sondhon Месяц назад +1

    I am here in india from 1994 to till now I late my whole family in Tibet. .. She can't tell true as she go back china. I know well about the truth of china and policy. .. I haven't got chance go to school at that time. ... Nowadays schooling is in city in Tibet but no opportunity to learning Tibetan language. .. But in village school are close as they teaching more Tibetan language. She not true as she wants to go back to the china. So she get problem. So I try to go back to Tibet in 2009 but in Nepali and china border they saying if I go back Tibet you put jail for 8 to 15 years punished of 50000yan I can't go there in Tibet... But anyway thanks brother. .you support us .. God bless you. .. ❤❤❤❤ jai hind and jai Tibet. ... 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

  • @youcanatalkwithnaved9744
    @youcanatalkwithnaved9744 Месяц назад +8

    Chinese tying to use propaganda

  • @M_Rewa81
    @M_Rewa81 Месяц назад +1

    Oh, Ranveer, brilliant choice-asking the occupier for insights on Tibet! Because, of course, no one knows Tibet better than the ones trying to rewrite its history. We are not Chinese, Period.

  • @tseringlhamo4964
    @tseringlhamo4964 Месяц назад +5

    Tibet is never part of China ….

  • @leipajangkhuu
    @leipajangkhuu Месяц назад

    Local Tibetans loved every Tourists like you.

  • @tashitsomo6595
    @tashitsomo6595 Месяц назад +3

    Tibet is not part of china....we have different language,religion,and culture...

  • @genji-gaming
    @genji-gaming Месяц назад +2

    This lady didn't use to call the Dalai Lama instead Leader in the whole podcast. If she does......! You know that truth!

  • @Peggy-d3g
    @Peggy-d3g Месяц назад +5

    I don't think she knows the fact correctly👎 Tiibet is a independent country and never a part of China.

  • @Urproblemursnotmine
    @Urproblemursnotmine Месяц назад

    Thank you so so much Ranveer for bringing up Tibet Issue on Your Podcast, which means a lot, huge respect to you and your team

  • @dadak84
    @dadak84 Месяц назад +3

    Misinformation not required, don't talk on matters you know nothing about. These are serious matter and nothing casual.

  • @atibetanspirit230
    @atibetanspirit230 Месяц назад +2

    Please invite Tenzin Tsundue to your podcast. You can have a good intellectual discussion.

  • @ChoeGrg
    @ChoeGrg Месяц назад +3

    You should have ask here what happen in 1959 what we have gone through

  • @ChoedonKarma
    @ChoedonKarma Месяц назад +4

    Tibet is never part of china..

  • @OMKARKULKARNIorkul1991
    @OMKARKULKARNIorkul1991 Месяц назад +3

    Ranveer fall in Chinese honeytrap!
    She portraying more CPC polit beauro communique mouthpiece.
    She doing soft propaganda nothing else.

  • @tenzang5830
    @tenzang5830 Месяц назад +2

    Ok if so … let’s try herself by saying Free Tibet with one banner in her hand in market or in open air. She will know the results and btw, why Dalai Lama portrait is not allowed in Tibet, not even in house ? Why thousands of cctv in Lhasa, capital city of Tibet and also in Potala palace ? Why my sister is not allowed to visit other countries ? Why she is not alligible to get a passport in first place ? Why destruction many of monasteries, why Tibetan subject is not included in schools when we are Tibetan, why Chinese police took my brother in custody just sending 1 picture of Dalai Lama through WeChat, how did they know in 5 mins ? Madam.. so many things are going on around you only thing u r not noticing as u r in your comfort zone. Thank you ranveer sir for asking tht lady atleast .. Free Tibet .. please support our cause…

  • @ABCDTRUTH
    @ABCDTRUTH Месяц назад +6

    This is same as discussing "India Issue" with a Pakistani celeb!!! rubbish

  • @kirundagale7623
    @kirundagale7623 Месяц назад +2

    India aslo have free education up to 10th standard 😂

  • @shortswithyoutube4995
    @shortswithyoutube4995 Месяц назад +3

    Tibet is free country have you ever seen how much genocides is done don't be ridiculous

  • @choekinyimakarmatsang7520
    @choekinyimakarmatsang7520 Месяц назад +1

    Thank you . 1959 invention , millions lost life , 2 lakes Tibetan went to refugees leaving all theirs belonging. 2 lakes people can’t lie together. That’s impossible 😂

  • @pemamasih5329
    @pemamasih5329 Месяц назад +12

    Tibet is not part of China for your kind information senseless girl, right now in Tibet,Chinese force to Stop Tibetan children to learn their own language Tibetan and shut down the school,since 1959 Chinese captured our motherland Tibet don't you know that it's just a bullshit crap , please don't say you have told and heard first collect and research all the information about Tibet and how Tibetan people live in exile since 1959 .as a anchor that's not acceptable

    • @zxa875
      @zxa875 Месяц назад +2

      same logic, Sikkim\Arunachal\Khalistan\ Kashmir\Ladak\Northeast are not a part of india.

    • @sauravgogoi4535
      @sauravgogoi4535 Месяц назад +1

      @@zxa875 I am an Indigenous Northeastern and we were never Invaded by India. We were always an Integral Part of India.

    • @Yashikca
      @Yashikca Месяц назад +2

      @@zxa875 you have no reason to comment on

  • @stanzinphunchok5748
    @stanzinphunchok5748 Месяц назад

    She has very general answers for all the questions which are almost similar and this shows that she lacks information. She is not the right person to ask about it.

  • @himalayagno.1386
    @himalayagno.1386 Месяц назад +3

    only one nation in all asia that is china. 😅😅😅