An explanation here for those unaware: current Titanic research has theorized that the Propior Deo version of Nearer, My God to Thee was actually played by the ship’s musicians. There are three versions of the hymn’s tune: the Anglican “Horbury” version (played in A Night to Remember), the American “Bethany” version (played in Titanic 1997), and the “Propior Deo” version, used by Methodists. As Wallace Hartley, the band’s leader, was a Methodist and was reported to have said that the “Propior Deo” version was the song he’d play before he died, the current belief is that this version would be what he would have played. Also, this question inevitably opens the can of worms of “well, did the band actually play Nearer, My God to Thee, or is it just pious legend?” which is still hotly debated by Titanic enthusiasts to this day. Such a question cannot be answered here with any certainty, so I will stop short of there.
@@fallingcrane1986 hello fellow enthusiast. Yes it's exactly that. The idea of the last song being Nearer my God to Thee or Autumn has been debated since the inquiries I guess, and we still haven't got an answer. I'd propose the theory both were played that night in a certain order.
@@ralphrichard8431 It is her attention to the details, the mechanics of and timing of the sinking's, all recorded with great angles that makes her the flag ship of this genre of videos.
One idea for a video, you could sink a ship, but have a camera at the bottom of the lake recording as the ship hits the bottom, that would be cool to see what it does.
Idea: Cardbordia 12 :THE SINKING OF CARDBOARD ESTONIA Edit: the Estonia/Estline is a tragic ship sinking. It was on a cruise from Sweden to Estonia in the baltic sea. The ferry loaded cars in the car compatment. Early morning the opening to the compartment flooded with water then it broke off because the waves causing to much presure which caused it to capsize Edit 2: Wrong words Edit 3: wrong episode
I was just wishing that someone or something would take me out of my bad life, and there you are. i need cardboardia... war in the Ukraine? f--k that , i wanna watch cardboardships sink
Easily your most detailed one yet. 1:03 just killed me watching the Carboardians running for their lives.
LOL
"Gentlemen, it has been a privilege playing with you tonight."
Id play my violin
Your production of Cardboardtanic was phenomenally well done and detailed. Job well done on the accuracy of the sinking and all the small details.
1:27 this is the most tragic scene
True :’(
yeah
And we thought it couldn't get any better
The lights and everything just make it an INCREDIBLY detailed ship! You can even see the people! You definitely get a sub from me.
I'm addicted to these videos haha
I like so much the fact you used the accurate version of Nearer my God to Thee, not the one from the movie.
Согласен
An explanation here for those unaware: current Titanic research has theorized that the Propior Deo version of Nearer, My God to Thee was actually played by the ship’s musicians.
There are three versions of the hymn’s tune: the Anglican “Horbury” version (played in A Night to Remember), the American “Bethany” version (played in Titanic 1997), and the “Propior Deo” version, used by Methodists.
As Wallace Hartley, the band’s leader, was a Methodist and was reported to have said that the “Propior Deo” version was the song he’d play before he died, the current belief is that this version would be what he would have played.
Also, this question inevitably opens the can of worms of “well, did the band actually play Nearer, My God to Thee, or is it just pious legend?” which is still hotly debated by Titanic enthusiasts to this day. Such a question cannot be answered here with any certainty, so I will stop short of there.
@@fallingcrane1986 hello fellow enthusiast.
Yes it's exactly that. The idea of the last song being Nearer my God to Thee or Autumn has been debated since the inquiries I guess, and we still haven't got an answer. I'd propose the theory both were played that night in a certain order.
Wow ! love the details !
I’ve been waiting for this. You’ve made me so happy.
I love how the cardboardtanic was accurate but missed a few things, besides that, im happy you used the correct version of NMGTT.
Incredible attention to ineterior. I can see effort of drawing stilizes walls etc
Chloe, I'd like to say you've gone a bit overboard on this one.... but I won't, the productions costs are right on par with the quality of the work!
I think she did a great job on the detailing one the interior and exterior of the ship
@@ralphrichard8431 It is her attention to the details, the mechanics of and timing of the sinking's, all recorded with great angles that makes her the flag ship of this genre of videos.
All l can say is that this wasn’t made in five minutes, very well done and appreciated.
Gentlemen it’s been a privilege playing with you tonight. Amazing work keep it up 👍
Keep up the good work love your vide
I meant to say vids
Excellent video!
I like the band members, Larry, Mo and Curly. 😉
I don't know if it's Ukraine or what but this got me in the feels. God bless the souls aboard RMS Titanic. Peace to my friends at this channel. xoxo.
It was british
My heart can't just go on after seeing this it's going to stop!
Wow, lots of work on the scenery. Nice job. 👍🏻
This is amazingly well detailed you need to make more like this
What memories, thanks bro, you always make my day
Legend!!
This was my favorite video
One idea for a video, you could sink a ship, but have a camera at the bottom of the lake recording as the ship hits the bottom, that would be cool to see what it does.
Gentlemen, It’s been an honour and a pleasure….
beautiful
disfruto desde chile estas entretenidas imagenes felicitaciones por la producción!!!. Me alegra mucho tu ingenio
I love how it’s so detailed
I all really liked the video but I want to give the video 1000 more likes! This is the only Quality content.
Magnifique!
I’ll never forget the spider that died in the original video.
Rip to him, the spider in first class died
Love it!
I love this
Amazing! So cool
This is great work!
IT looks good!!!
awesome!
Did you make separate builds for the interior or were they on the ship? I can’t comprehend that you MADE this like holy cow
Nice music
i need a tutorial on how to make cardboard ships like this lol
Alright I very good at this stuff maybe I'll start an channel 🤷♂️
Where did you get the audio for the song?
Hello can you do more sinking videos with fireworks and fire and things like that? Thanks!
“Cardboardmen, it has a privilege playing with you tonight”
Where did you get furniture please!!!
Hello. You could not show how you make at least one ship. And how you do and shoot inside the ship. Thanks in advance!
yk this is just great
wow i love this
The scene where the people are stuck behind the gate is tragic
I noticed cardboardia eight cardboardtanic is your best one built
Pls how you do it and how many days/Months/year you make it?
would you be able open to a section of the ships outside to be plastic so you can see the interiors from the outside? just a small suggestion
Pls makkkke a cardboard Luxury cruise ship. That’s also the largest ship You’ve made. USS CardVega
the royal carboardia.
Idea: Cardbordia 12 :THE SINKING OF CARDBOARD ESTONIA
Edit: the Estonia/Estline is a tragic ship sinking. It was on a cruise from Sweden to Estonia in the baltic sea. The ferry loaded cars in the car compatment. Early morning the opening to the compartment flooded with water then it broke off because the waves causing to much presure
which caused it to capsize
Edit 2: Wrong words
Edit 3: wrong episode
Can we have so.e more isolated soundtracks because a love them
Do you sell these cardboard boats just found your channel
I like all carborad ship it very good.
does the wreck still exist also can you guys show another video on the stern section of the wreck
0:40 what is that on the left side?
So how do make stuff like that sink i tried it and it never fully sank the top part just stayed floating i was mad pls teach me your ways
Not-so-fun fact: The people playing on the ship went down with it, so they died
I was just wishing that someone or something would take me out of my bad life, and there you are. i need cardboardia... war in the Ukraine? f--k that , i wanna watch cardboardships sink
same here!!
We’re the little figurines left on after it sank
Not sure if you’d want to but could you do a how to on how to make one of these?
Tou até a artist tou are pergect tô do cardbordias :)
Nice
Near my God
Why, this ship can't sink!
She's made of cardboard sir!! She can sink and she will!
Do wonders of the seas next
2:15
Titanic???
ur insane tho
in a good way.
@@rearspeaker6364 yessir
❤❤❤❤❤
why youtube make me un subscribed 😥
👍👍😭😥😓🤧
2:47 why why why the screaming
Titanic but its cardboard
I dislike the new theory sinking.. I enjoy more james cameron movie.Btw, the ship you make is nice
Oye amigo el mejor barco que esvito es el Titanic
Why i hear roblox Titanic
0:35 1912
Ohhhh
100TH COMMENT!
𝓅𝓇o𝓂o𝓈𝓂
Slayyu
Titanic movie is a really good movie! I am operating Titanic by making it RC. 😀😃😄
"Gentlemen, it has been a privilege playing with you tonight."