I feel like I have learned a lot about a type of fish might never have thought so much about. These creatures deserve more respect than I might have had before, I hope you manage to adapt to this fish's needs in time, you certainly seem to be doing a lot, I found you from Ohio FR
Amazing collection of fish and tanks Sir. Just wondering are those Pangasianodon gigas in the tank with 2 Peru piraibas or are they Pangasianodon hypophtalmus?
Thank you. No, never have seen true gigas for sale or in private hands. Some of our peers claim to have had gigas but none presented a convincing case in my humble opinion. I have only ever kept iridescent shark (hypophthalmus) and black ear (larnaudii). Never came across any other for sale and available to me.
Legendary. Always a pleasure watching. Would be wonderful if P. gigas could be attained. There are a few people in asia (i myself grew one out until it was no longer suitable for my aquarium) and i think some export to the states. Not sure on the exact rules
I appreciate your kind words. Yeah, gigas are a holy grail. Never seen one in hobbyist hands that I'd be sure 100% it was a gigas. Seems to be complicated with hybrids being offered as gigas too from fish farms and their experimentations. Honest or deceiving errors, I don't know. They are extremely highly regulated, near impossible to import into the US unless it's the very top tier Aquarium or Research Lab, I imagine.
It is more peaceful because the occasional damage is less consequential. The wyckii has improved a ton since the initial introduction in that it defends its space with less rigor and frequency, yet it's space is well defined still.
I heard they cross breed that’s the reason why they are so small it happens a lot Now I think it’s because of overfishing that’s just my opinion what do you think about that please answer me back?
I assume we are talking about the Peru piraiba and the dourada catfish too; not sure who cross breeds with who in your supposition. I know little but my current understanding doesn't involve any hybridization, I've never heard of this and I don't believe this. Natural hybridization happens exceedingly seldom and the hybrid offspring can be told apart from either parent; moreover such offspring is usually sterile or mostly sterile. I'd struggle too with tying overfishing in the wild with prevalence of "supposed" small size for specimen kept in captivity.
@@Fish-Story Thank you so much for getting back to me on this subject I didn’t truly believe that they were cross breeding I Was thinking The same thing as you about overfishing I wish you could have a wells catfish or even the Mekong giant catfish I don’t know if you have a true Gooch catfish do you I’m just wondering how long it takes the Gooch catfish to grow I’ve been trying to find information about it but thanks again for clarifying and clearing that up for me
Wels as you know we have. MGC is pretty much impossible to get in the USA. Goonch we have never had because we were told by an expert (highly esteemed Wesley Wong of Rare Fish) that our water gets too warm in the summer for large goonches. There is a healthy goonch aficionado and expert community on the Monster Fish Keepers forum, if you wanted to partake of their vast and 1sthand knowledge. I am on that forum as well but I only read about goonches, almost never participate as I've never had one.
btw,Those are near the very best,if not the THE best Arowanas on the net. I think those guys just might reach 4' in perfect health and very active. Some public aquarium I saw on the tube also had some very old and large Arowana in about the same size aquarium. They are also very good at reprocessing any dead mice caught in traps...one gulp and an Arowana smile.
Thank you. The aros got a pretty bad drop eye. They have a foot to go to 4', probably will never happen. Mice? :) Should I consider including mice as treats?
@@Fish-Story Dead ones..at that size they could handle rats. All dead for the safety of the fish too. I didn't really notice the drop eye. I suspect that a more varied diet would help...but mine would get that and I fed freshwater smelts,beefheart,and other salt water anchovy like fish. Looking back,maybe a few dead rodents would have cured that. I have an angelfish Viktor that had a balance problem..what I noticed is it would only eat flakes..ignored all other foods. So,I tried dried krill ( reconstituted) 2 weeks ago, it actually like them. Right now its balance isnt perfect,but much improved. Malnourished maybe,now better.
I agree. Diversifying feed is critical to long term success, unless feeding a high quality dry feed. Our aros have a pouch above the dropped eyes. Likely it is a fatty tissue that could be rather easily removed at home but one needs some practice. Too much non-aquatic fat in the diet from the cheap Ziegler pellets I used to feed. Yes, of course dead mice. I don't feed live as that would be unsafe and also sadistic in my book (just speaking for myself, no one has to agree or do as I do).
You probably don't put that light on over it unless like now..its being filmed. Some fish just are not aquarium fish. Pelagic fish being near the worst. Maybe one day Viktor you will come across a 10' or more round plexi aquarium. I had set up decades ago a summer pool that size and with a strong pump, a really good spin was kept going..the Red Hooks and Tinfoils migrated "upriver" constantly.
Thank you. You are right, I only flip the lights on for visitors and filming. Yes, pelagic... that's the problem with the dourada catfish. The 4500 gal tanks are semi-round, I could have easily made the water spin if I aimed the pipes for it. I had made a while ago a mental note to self to try exactly what you say next time I modify the pipes or add more pumps.
Hello sir is your lighter colour peru piraiba is platinum piraiba ? I've got offered platinum peru piraiba form seller it's more white but still not sure somehow look similar colour as ur lighter coloured one
Thank you. Depends on whether the conditions are right for it - year round temperature, dissolved oxygen, hardness, safety from predators, biofiltration, etc. Piraiba do live outdoors, they are wild animals :)
@@Fish-Story Thanks for the reply, I have a pair i've grown to around the same size, I'm hoping they'll spawn eventually, but info on breeding them naturally without hormones is hard to find.
I've never looked at this in depth but I recall channels breed for people rather easily in large natural ponds and lakes. If I recall correctly. I too saw it in passing one or a few times, not like a detailed account.
The body proportions are close but distinctly different to an eye that have seen enough of both. When small, the spotting is obviously different. With respect to adults, the false ones do not exceed 4 feet in the wild.
@@superdragon3060 From little that I know, B. capapretum aka false piraiba can be expected not to exceed 2.5ft-3ft in captivity after a decade; B. filamentosum from Peru aka Peru piraiba appear to maybe grow a bit bigger perhaps 3ft-3.5ft over a decade; B. filamentosum from Suriname aka Suriname piraiba would probably hit 6 ft in a decade. They live at least several decades but probably grow very slowly after the initial years. A 4ft piraiba, true or false, would be adequate in a 20x10x4, more is better.
They don't appear to grow fast, at least in hobbyist hands. The large size of the tank should help some for sure, but it may mostly result in having the fish with less or no injury to the snout; it may not necessarily speed up its growth rate.
Those are my favorite catfish. I kept the Dorado catfish before and just like you said they are very skittish. Mine would try jumping out all the time and ended up succeeding. I would recommend raising them in a large round aquarium/pond
I think they should be fine so long piraiba cannot swallow the firewood and the firewood doesn't get too aggressive when larger as some report. They both will outgrow the 3000 gal quickly, especially the firewood. Good luck, bro.
Try covering the side of the tank with those fake rock backgrounds. It helps a lot. I've kept mine in concrete tanks and they don't run into the wall. My theory is that they must be able to see the wall as they have bad eyesight.
Thank you for sharing your learning. Much appreciated. I assume you are talking about the dorado catfish. Yes, a non-transparent surface / pond or a round surface are two of the options we have identified as well, with the former being more efficient.
@@Fish-Story yup. They are also calmer if you have a few of them together. As long as they can see the wall, they always stop just in time... but with glass, they just run through.
Right. Thank you again. On keeping them together... I have only experience with small ones. I usually buy them at 2"-3" in groups of 2-3 and by the time they are 4", the bigger ones will bully the smaller ones badly even in a 240 gal / 1000 liter tank. I have seen it 3 times already with three different batches. So I separate them at that early age and never mix again. Are you saying i could mix them later in life?
@@Fish-Story From what I observe from mine all 4 was good living together... with 3 of my piraibas... they do squabble but not much. The piraibas keep them in check. All was going well and they got to about 12"... and then one fateful day I came back from work to find out... my dad didn't switch off the chlorine tap water. I lost all my fish. I can dig out the last video of them in my phone though
Wow. Great job and sorry to hear. Maybe you could muster strength and repeat. That'd be a masterpiece - blogging the raising of 4 dorado catfish and 3 piraiba together.
maybe you can put in some styrofoam against both sides of the tank (and the back) to prevent him from being damaged an swimming against the glass. Excuse the english. Love youre work👌
Thank you. I think it will do the same against the front glass. I will join some of our 240 gal tanks together to make 600 gal and 1200 gal and try this fish in there.
I am sure the champs of 10-12 feet must be very old, as I seem to tell you about all other huge catfish :) 50-100 yo. Sorry. Lifespan of fish is the poorest known thing about long-lived fish.
@@Fish-Story i use a foam like cover so when he bumbs in too it it doesnt hitt him that hard as normal glass instagram.com/monster_fish_freaks_original/ this is my instagram and this is my facebook group facebook.com/groups/809808769388862/
Thank you. I'm not on FB or IG but IG let me see a glance of your photos. Real cool! You are probably the first and only dourada catfish keeper I've personally met over my 12 years in the hobby with such a large specimen.
@@Fish-Story its a hard too get fish and extremly hard too raise butt you coverd that in your video i came across you when ohio fish rescue came by i was like i have too follow this guy youre european huso OR beluga sturgion are totally amazing you got Lucky there for sure that Suriname is mega size its jaw dropping sir i also run a few video's on my RUclips page so you can also look there btw i love youre mission you rock sir
Some of the best examples of exotic fish kept in America period.. could do a species breakdown on every fish in these 4500 gallon tanks
My god I would sit in front of this tank for hours and just enjoy it 😍😍😍😍👌👍
Thank you. I know one other aquaholic who'd do the same, a friend of mine :)
agreed
I feel like I have learned a lot about a type of fish might never have thought so much about. These creatures deserve more respect than I might have had before, I hope you manage to adapt to this fish's needs in time, you certainly seem to be doing a lot, I found you from Ohio FR
Thank you for your positive review.
my dream pond is a 40x20ft(massive) with a paroon piraiba and siamese carp
Very interesting, thank you for the video.
incredible mix
Thank you, that was very interesting.
fish look amazing mate, pacu with darker bottom half is really nice
Thank you, I appreciate it.
Been a while since I’ve seen you’re videos bro! This is incredible!!
I am glad you still like our primitive videos :)
Amazing collection of fish and tanks Sir. Just wondering are those Pangasianodon gigas in the tank with 2 Peru piraibas or are they Pangasianodon hypophtalmus?
Thank you. No, never have seen true gigas for sale or in private hands. Some of our peers claim to have had gigas but none presented a convincing case in my humble opinion. I have only ever kept iridescent shark (hypophthalmus) and black ear (larnaudii). Never came across any other for sale and available to me.
Legendary. Always a pleasure watching. Would be wonderful if P. gigas could be attained. There are a few people in asia (i myself grew one out until it was no longer suitable for my aquarium) and i think some export to the states. Not sure on the exact rules
I appreciate your kind words. Yeah, gigas are a holy grail. Never seen one in hobbyist hands that I'd be sure 100% it was a gigas. Seems to be complicated with hybrids being offered as gigas too from fish farms and their experimentations. Honest or deceiving errors, I don't know. They are extremely highly regulated, near impossible to import into the US unless it's the very top tier Aquarium or Research Lab, I imagine.
albino pacu what a rare one!!!🔥
I watch this video weekly, is there someting wrong with me?😂
Hahaha... not in my book. You got a mild case of brachyplatystomitis :) It's common among our peer folk :)
Hey Vic would u say the 4500 on the left with the peacock bass is far more peaceful? And has the Devil cat done well so far?
It is more peaceful because the occasional damage is less consequential. The wyckii has improved a ton since the initial introduction in that it defends its space with less rigor and frequency, yet it's space is well defined still.
Those fish 🐠 are massive
Esse tanque esta lindo de mais, tem alguns peixes que tem no meu Pantanal brasileiro
Parabéns pelo tanque está perfeito
This tank is too beautiful, there are some fish in my Brazilian Pantanal Congratulations on the perfect tank.
Thank you, you are too kind.
I heard they cross breed that’s the reason why they are so small it happens a lot Now I think it’s because of overfishing that’s just my opinion what do you think about that please answer me back?
I assume we are talking about the Peru piraiba and the dourada catfish too; not sure who cross breeds with who in your supposition. I know little but my current understanding doesn't involve any hybridization, I've never heard of this and I don't believe this. Natural hybridization happens exceedingly seldom and the hybrid offspring can be told apart from either parent; moreover such offspring is usually sterile or mostly sterile. I'd struggle too with tying overfishing in the wild with prevalence of "supposed" small size for specimen kept in captivity.
@@Fish-Story
Thank you so much for getting back to me on this subject I didn’t truly believe that they were cross breeding I Was thinking The same thing as you about overfishing I wish you could have a wells catfish or even the Mekong giant catfish I don’t know if you have a true Gooch catfish do you I’m just wondering how long it takes the Gooch catfish to grow I’ve been trying to find information about it but thanks again for clarifying and clearing that up for me
Wels as you know we have. MGC is pretty much impossible to get in the USA. Goonch we have never had because we were told by an expert (highly esteemed Wesley Wong of Rare Fish) that our water gets too warm in the summer for large goonches. There is a healthy goonch aficionado and expert community on the Monster Fish Keepers forum, if you wanted to partake of their vast and 1sthand knowledge. I am on that forum as well but I only read about goonches, almost never participate as I've never had one.
btw,Those are near the very best,if not the THE best Arowanas on the net. I think those guys just might reach 4' in perfect health and very active. Some public aquarium I saw on the tube also had some very old and large Arowana in about the same size aquarium.
They are also very good at reprocessing any dead mice caught in traps...one gulp and an Arowana smile.
Thank you. The aros got a pretty bad drop eye. They have a foot to go to 4', probably will never happen. Mice? :) Should I consider including mice as treats?
@@Fish-Story Dead ones..at that size they could handle rats. All dead for the safety of the fish too.
I didn't really notice the drop eye. I suspect that a more varied diet would help...but mine would get that and I fed freshwater smelts,beefheart,and other salt water anchovy like fish. Looking back,maybe a few dead rodents would have cured that.
I have an angelfish Viktor that had a balance problem..what I noticed is it would only eat flakes..ignored all other foods. So,I tried dried krill ( reconstituted) 2 weeks ago, it actually like them. Right now its balance isnt perfect,but much improved. Malnourished maybe,now better.
I agree. Diversifying feed is critical to long term success, unless feeding a high quality dry feed. Our aros have a pouch above the dropped eyes. Likely it is a fatty tissue that could be rather easily removed at home but one needs some practice. Too much non-aquatic fat in the diet from the cheap Ziegler pellets I used to feed. Yes, of course dead mice. I don't feed live as that would be unsafe and also sadistic in my book (just speaking for myself, no one has to agree or do as I do).
Beautiful fish mate,awsome, i have a question about the giant gourami with the black tail,what species is it ?
Thank you. Exodon aka elephant ear.
@@Fish-Story cheers!
You probably don't put that light on over it unless like now..its being filmed. Some fish just are not aquarium fish. Pelagic fish being near the worst. Maybe one day Viktor you will come across a 10' or more round plexi aquarium. I had set up decades ago a summer pool that size and with a strong pump, a really good spin was kept going..the Red Hooks and Tinfoils migrated "upriver" constantly.
Thank you. You are right, I only flip the lights on for visitors and filming. Yes, pelagic... that's the problem with the dourada catfish. The 4500 gal tanks are semi-round, I could have easily made the water spin if I aimed the pipes for it. I had made a while ago a mental note to self to try exactly what you say next time I modify the pipes or add more pumps.
beautifull fish ever
Hello sir is your lighter colour peru piraiba is platinum piraiba ? I've got offered platinum peru piraiba form seller it's more white but still not sure somehow look similar colour as ur lighter coloured one
Our both Peru piraiba looked the same at 5" when we bought them. The usual. When combined in one tank, one got paler and the other got darker, is all.
Great video . Piraba can live outdoor pond.plz tell
Thank you. Depends on whether the conditions are right for it - year round temperature, dissolved oxygen, hardness, safety from predators, biofiltration, etc. Piraiba do live outdoors, they are wild animals :)
@@Fish-Story 😍❤️
If we would like to visit this collection is the opportunity there??
Thank you for your high marks. We are close to opening to public with business hours. The info is on our webpage www.fish-story.com
Great video! Are those Channel Catfish In the second tank?
Thank you. Yes, two. Females it seems. 2 feet.
@@Fish-Story Thanks for the reply, I have a pair i've grown to around the same size, I'm hoping they'll spawn eventually, but info on breeding them naturally without hormones is hard to find.
I've never looked at this in depth but I recall channels breed for people rather easily in large natural ponds and lakes. If I recall correctly. I too saw it in passing one or a few times, not like a detailed account.
How do you tell if its True or fals piraiba?
Whats the difference?
The body proportions are close but distinctly different to an eye that have seen enough of both. When small, the spotting is obviously different. With respect to adults, the false ones do not exceed 4 feet in the wild.
@@Fish-Story do the false ones get any bigger than 4ft at all? and could they be kept in a 20x10x4ft pond?
@@superdragon3060 From little that I know, B. capapretum aka false piraiba can be expected not to exceed 2.5ft-3ft in captivity after a decade; B. filamentosum from Peru aka Peru piraiba appear to maybe grow a bit bigger perhaps 3ft-3.5ft over a decade; B. filamentosum from Suriname aka Suriname piraiba would probably hit 6 ft in a decade. They live at least several decades but probably grow very slowly after the initial years. A 4ft piraiba, true or false, would be adequate in a 20x10x4, more is better.
hello, if i got 3000 gallons tank, how fast will the flavican catfish grow?
They don't appear to grow fast, at least in hobbyist hands. The large size of the tank should help some for sure, but it may mostly result in having the fish with less or no injury to the snout; it may not necessarily speed up its growth rate.
Those are my favorite catfish. I kept the Dorado catfish before and just like you said they are very skittish. Mine would try jumping out all the time and ended up succeeding. I would recommend raising them in a large round aquarium/pond
is it ok with firewood?
ive got 70cm piraiba and 90cm firewood, but my tank is big 3000 gallons
I think they should be fine so long piraiba cannot swallow the firewood and the firewood doesn't get too aggressive when larger as some report. They both will outgrow the 3000 gal quickly, especially the firewood. Good luck, bro.
Try covering the side of the tank with those fake rock backgrounds. It helps a lot. I've kept mine in concrete tanks and they don't run into the wall. My theory is that they must be able to see the wall as they have bad eyesight.
Thank you for sharing your learning. Much appreciated. I assume you are talking about the dorado catfish. Yes, a non-transparent surface / pond or a round surface are two of the options we have identified as well, with the former being more efficient.
@@Fish-Story yup. They are also calmer if you have a few of them together.
As long as they can see the wall, they always stop just in time... but with glass, they just run through.
Right. Thank you again. On keeping them together... I have only experience with small ones. I usually buy them at 2"-3" in groups of 2-3 and by the time they are 4", the bigger ones will bully the smaller ones badly even in a 240 gal / 1000 liter tank. I have seen it 3 times already with three different batches. So I separate them at that early age and never mix again. Are you saying i could mix them later in life?
@@Fish-Story
From what I observe from mine all 4 was good living together... with 3 of my piraibas... they do squabble but not much. The piraibas keep them in check.
All was going well and they got to about 12"... and then one fateful day I came back from work to find out... my dad didn't switch off the chlorine tap water. I lost all my fish.
I can dig out the last video of them in my phone though
Wow. Great job and sorry to hear. Maybe you could muster strength and repeat. That'd be a masterpiece - blogging the raising of 4 dorado catfish and 3 piraiba together.
maybe you can put in some styrofoam against both sides of the tank (and the back) to prevent him from being damaged an swimming against the glass. Excuse the english. Love youre work👌
Thank you. I think it will do the same against the front glass. I will join some of our 240 gal tanks together to make 600 gal and 1200 gal and try this fish in there.
@@Fish-Story Nice! Would love to see that! Good luck👍
At 10:55 is that a huge Talapia??
Yes, there are two, Nile and Blue.
What’s the lifespan of the piraiba
I am sure the champs of 10-12 feet must be very old, as I seem to tell you about all other huge catfish :) 50-100 yo. Sorry. Lifespan of fish is the poorest known thing about long-lived fish.
@@Fish-Story how old is yours, looks like the size of a small car, definitely heavier than me
I got it at 18 inches in 2016-2017, so it must be around 4-5 yo.
my dorado is almost 2 foot ive you use a backround and also cover the sides it will be less on the nose
Wonderful. Good to know. Thank you. Where can I learn and see your fish?
@@Fish-Story i use a foam like cover so when he bumbs in too it it doesnt hitt him that hard as normal glass instagram.com/monster_fish_freaks_original/ this is my instagram and this is my facebook group facebook.com/groups/809808769388862/
Thank you. I'm not on FB or IG but IG let me see a glance of your photos. Real cool! You are probably the first and only dourada catfish keeper I've personally met over my 12 years in the hobby with such a large specimen.
@@Fish-Story its a hard too get fish and extremly hard too raise butt you coverd that in your video i came across you when ohio fish rescue came by i was like i have too follow this guy youre european huso OR beluga sturgion are totally amazing you got Lucky there for sure that Suriname is mega size its jaw dropping sir i also run a few video's on my RUclips page so you can also look there btw i love youre mission you rock sir
@@Fish-Story ruclips.net/user/dcover5 the video's are a bitt older tho i havent got the time latly for updates
Suriname needs a bigger space don't you think? without the Sperata :-)
Yup. Have been earnestly working on it for a few months, building a 10K. Yeah, I really need to sell the sperata and one of the jaus, no takers yet.
Fish Story, a DIY Public Aquarium & Fish Rescue I look forward to the video!! Please keep us updated! 😁😁