Some commenters don't seem to be aware this is from a time when dramas like this were transmitted live on TV. That's why the camera work is stiff and you can hear background noise often. It's essentially filmed as a play with limited sets and no outdoor scenes, which is why the wedding isn't even in a church. Given these restrictions it's actually not bad.
Thank you for your defending of this version of Jane Eyre. This adaptation was barely an hour long. Why people expect so many of these versions to faithfully follow the written word, when time and budget alone dictates the need for deviations, astounds me. Even though I am not a fan of Charlton Heston, he certainly portrayed Mr. Rochester very well.
Charlton Heston was such a great actor!!! Every role he played was excellent!! He's so believable in this role. The first second u see him, u can't take your eyes off of him
This is interesting. This story has always held my attention. I like them in the roles. Especially because they are more equally matched in age. I just wish they had filmed it more like a movie but I realize this was recorded as live theater.
They took Jane's best lines and gave them to him. She's too old and too American but he is masterly and forceful in just the right way. Nice one Chuck.
I had this on my Favorites on AOL now I can no longer access those Favorites and I thought I'd never see this again! I only had the proposal part! Thanks for posting all of it!!
@Capitolinattic I too would love to have all the Jane Eyre's. My dad HATES Jane Eyre so I take every chance i get to talk about it with him. He asks me how many I plan to watch and I tell him however many they make that I can find.
That is the best version EVER, so far - and I am writing this in late 2019, and have seen pretty much everything that has anything to do with Jane Eyre or with the Brontes in general :-) The second best for me would be the Michael Fassbender one, but the Toby Stephens version remains the best.
Yes the best version ever! Toby Stevens the best Rochester to date they nailed the look completely Ruth Wilson is the best Jane ever they certainly had screen chemistry !
Whatever you do don't watch RUclips videos on a Dell Venue. The sound quality sucks. For that matter, so does the venue. Should have listened to my sister and bought an IPAD.
Either the uploads missed a few episodes or the writing was very poor indeed. Perhaps it was written with a very stringent budget in mind! I like Charlton Heston's acting, but not in this movie...in this one he is very cold and stiff like most method actors. This is as enjoyable (not) to watch as the George C Scott version. I much prefer the Toby Stephens and the Timothy Dalton versions.
Dagnabit, get some decent writers! Seriously, this script sounds forcefully poetic. And while I applaud Mary Sinclair and Charlton Heston for trying, neither of them did very well in these roles. Especially Sinclair. She is way too breathy and sweet and... pretty. Heston certainly had the looks, voice, height and voice for Rochester, but a terrible lack of depth
I have not seen this version for some reason. From this clip it does seem like Mary Sinclair is too pretty and Charlton Heston lacks the incredible sorrow over his situation that Orson Welles displays.
Never knew this version existed. It's awful! Her age just hits you- his all American looks, and accent contradict the whole story, I love Heston, but he doesn't fit! And the writing is so bad...why do this at all?
That 'piano' sounds horrible. I don't care for it. I've seen it in other time period movie and I always wonder why people would play on it and think it sounds appealing,
Some commenters don't seem to be aware this is from a time when dramas like this were transmitted live on TV. That's why the camera work is stiff and you can hear background noise often. It's essentially filmed as a play with limited sets and no outdoor scenes, which is why the wedding isn't even in a church. Given these restrictions it's actually not bad.
Thank you for your defending of this version of Jane Eyre. This adaptation was barely an hour long. Why people expect so many of these versions to faithfully follow the written word, when time and budget alone dictates the need for deviations, astounds me. Even though I am not a fan of Charlton Heston, he certainly portrayed Mr. Rochester very well.
Charlton Heston was such a great actor!!! Every role he played was excellent!! He's so believable in this role. The first second u see him, u can't take your eyes off of him
you are right about charlton heston he is an irresitible man and i never can take my eyes off of him he like an actor is number one
We are in 2019.
80 yrs. later since this movie came out...
Wow what a diffrance😯
tehilovely _Only 71 years as of today, but I know what you meant_
I like how they included the "Good night, my--" line. Rochester's omission expresses so much.
Oh my god WHERE HAS THIS BEEN
why did it take me so long to discover this version?! i love charlton heston!
Wells, Dalton, and now Heston were the best Rochester I have seen.
This is interesting. This story has always held my attention. I like them in the roles. Especially because they are more equally matched in age. I just wish they had filmed it more like a movie but I realize this was recorded as live theater.
awww i like how adele played the piano while jane came down the stairs.
Wow. I had no idea Charlton Heston would be so good in this story.
thanks for this version...i love seeing them!
I love this proposal!! It's so sweet!
They took Jane's best lines and gave them to him. She's too old and too American but he is masterly and forceful in just the right way. Nice one Chuck.
Charlton Heston oh gawd how many versions are there! 2006 BBC masterpiece version is the best.
Heavens There seems to be countless versions right?
as many as Jane Austen adaptations
I had this on my Favorites on AOL now I can no longer access those Favorites and I thought I'd never see this again! I only had the proposal part! Thanks for posting all of it!!
Chuck Heston....what a face!
I completely agree. I'll even watch the foreign ones.
Me quiero matar!!! Mi Charlton Heston Interpreto a Edward Rochester en 1949.!!! Y Crei que me sabia toda su carrera cinematografica.!!!!!
Orson Welles is by far the best Mr Rochester.
@Capitolinattic I too would love to have all the Jane Eyre's. My dad HATES Jane Eyre so I take every chance i get to talk about it with him. He asks me how many I plan to watch and I tell him however many they make that I can find.
Well, why not talk about something your dad likes? My father is dead, and I'd love to do just that. :-)
Did you see the version with Toby Stephens?
That is the best version EVER, so far - and I am writing this in late 2019, and have seen pretty much everything that has anything to do with Jane Eyre or with the Brontes in general :-) The second best for me would be the Michael Fassbender one, but the Toby Stephens version remains the best.
Yes the best version ever! Toby Stevens the best Rochester to date they nailed the look completely Ruth Wilson
is the best Jane ever they certainly had screen chemistry !
oh my yes
Toby's mother is Maggie Smith (actress)
his brother is Chris Lawson (actor)
Cliff notes version....with much left out.
There should be a 20 year age gap! Where has it gone?
I love Charlton Heston but his Rochester lacked depth and substance.
no, that must be a joke, c.h. as rochester? absolutely out of question ( don´t want to offend anybody, but i`m really "shocked")...
Whatever you do don't watch RUclips videos on a Dell Venue. The sound quality sucks. For that matter, so does the venue. Should have listened to my sister and bought an IPAD.
This version had me laughing...I wanted to like it and take it seriously but there was no romance at all between the characters.
I have and I think he had the wrong voice, wrong height and he didn't look unattractive enough. But that is just me.
Why did they get married in the living room?
It was live TV and had limited sets and space.
¿PORQUÉ NO SUBTILAN ESTAS VERSIONES LO TENGO RECOMIENDADO VARIAS VECES NO TODOS SABEMOS INGLÉS. GRACIAS.
Either the uploads missed a few episodes or the writing was very poor indeed. Perhaps it was written with a very stringent budget in mind! I like Charlton Heston's acting, but not in this movie...in this one he is very cold and stiff like most method actors. This is as enjoyable (not) to watch as the George C Scott version. I much prefer the Toby Stephens and the Timothy Dalton versions.
Timothy Dalton made a marvelous Mr. Rochester, the best by far, I think.
Dagnabit, get some decent writers! Seriously, this script sounds forcefully poetic. And while I applaud Mary Sinclair and Charlton Heston for trying, neither of them did very well in these roles. Especially Sinclair. She is way too breathy and sweet and... pretty. Heston certainly had the looks, voice, height and voice for Rochester, but a terrible lack of depth
Deborah Ingle “Dagnabit” - my Dad promised my Mom not to curse around the children, but I did hear this word quite often😉
I have not seen this version for some reason. From this clip it does seem like Mary Sinclair is too pretty and Charlton Heston lacks the incredible sorrow over his situation that Orson Welles displays.
Never knew this version existed. It's awful! Her age just hits you- his all American looks, and accent contradict the whole story, I love Heston, but he doesn't fit! And the writing is so bad...why do this at all?
both are horrible in acting...
@acraftyperson Adele is so cute but I hate that type of piano it sounds awful and out of tune.
It's a harpsichord; it is what it was.
This was the worst production of Jane Eyre should never have been made.
Absolutely correct. So unbearable acting and all .......ufffffff....... .
WOW he looks menacing and he said the important words that belonged to Jane. Not a good rendition.
That 'piano' sounds horrible. I don't care for it. I've seen it in other time period movie and I always wonder why people would play on it and think it sounds appealing,
Christ this is creepy😂
This is by far the worst rendition of Jane Eyre I have seen. They condensed it so much and the acting is not believable. 😝
I love this proposal!! It's so sweet!