Mogubai Kurdikar Speaks About Kishori Amonkar
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 авг 2024
- The only Video I've Found in Which we all can see Mogubai Ji speaking live...
This is just a treasure I can say...
___________________________________________
Disclaimer :-
● I don't claim for the copy rights of this video .
● All copy Rights belong to Cinema Vision India.
interviewer is not prepared, knowledgeable.
both of them are legends.
This is fantastic !!! At one point the great Mogubai says " Usmein Kayda hei" Waah !! Thank you very much for sharing.
Dhruv Kapoor hey plz share it as much as possible
Very touching... to see a mother satisfied and proud of her daughter
What a special, candid and rare duo:
guru - disciple, mother- daughter. Both have so much clarity about their own musical calling. Thank you Dr. Jain.
This video is so valuable. The two musical angels sharing the space together. And the simplicity and humility in their character.
Just hearing this could change ones life forever.
Thanks a ton for the upload.
Why the person who is taking this interview is so unprepared and ignorant ?
Mogubai and Kishoritai are gems of classical music......both are legends 🙏👐👏👏
Totally ignorant! Kishori tai explored even semi-classical too, besides classical. Mogubai did not. And he is asking "Aap classical framework main kyun nahi aai?" Does he even understand anything about music? But I thank him for the video.
I guess he is Mr Siddharth Kak (of DD Surabhi fame). He seems unprepared for this interview.
The interviewer is an idiot !!! There is absolutely no humility in his manner of questioning, neither is there any understanding of the subject. These are two Hindustani musical legends and deserved far more respect.
Homage to Mogubai. A Music Festival is organised in her memory each year in Goa.
Where, when .
@@miteshb6665 - It was being held at Margao, Goa. Refer englishnews.thegoan.net/story.php?id=12848
भूमिका सिनेमातील दोघींनी गायलेला शुद्ध कल्याण ऐकल्यावर कळते की या दोघी किती ग्रेट होत्या.
अप्रतिम ।जैसे एक क्षितिजपर दो दैदीप्यमान तारका विलसत हो ।माँ और पुत्री दोनों को भावभीनी श्रद्धांजलि ।धन्यवाद ।
Two great legends in one frame....Salute 🙏🙏🙏🙏
I actually dont have words for it.....
What a beautiful n innocent relationship between mother n daughter as well as student and teacher 😊🙏
कितना संतोष और आनन्द है मोगूबाई जी के चेहरे पर ... प्रणाम 🙏
"You cannot segregate ” feeling ” in life from “feeling” in art; for their roots go right down to that land which everyone owns but no one knows-i.e. the human mind."
Kishori Amonkar.(10 April 1932-3rd April 2017)
Dr. Romil Ji Many Many Thanks 😊🙏 Gana Tapaswini Magubai Kurdiker Ji 🙏🙏🙏 Hume Blessings Dije Hume Bunamra Shradhanjali Kishori Tai 🙏🙏🙏 Give Me your blessings Meri Sangit Jiwan Safal Ho 🙏 Om Shanti 🙏
Saavan de rahya zora. Ghar aayo ji Shyam Mora re.... I hv just madly in love with Kishorijis Bhajan. How nice to hear her talking about her mother. So beautiful bonding between them! Naman.
Woww...what a combination..that's why Kishori amonkar Ji...reached in that level..❣️✌🏻👏
विश्वाचे आर्त माझ्या मनी प्रकाशले......दोन्ही विभूति ना प्रणाम विनम्र अभिवादन 🌹🌹
Interviewer himself confused, seems not prepared and slightly irritated both. Whereas Kishoritai and Mogubai were smilingly answered all questions.
Naman Kishori Tai.. Magubai ji ~ Mera Shradhanjali Yeh Dono Mahan Guni Ko 🙏🙏🙏🙏 ~ Vocalist Sri Adrish Mukherjee Ashirwad Dije Baikunth Se Mera Sangeet Jiwan Safal Jarur Ho 🙏
Doesn't have any idea whom he is talking to ..Great Mogubai ji and Kishori ji...legends of Jaipur gharana
Monti Paul yes
They are both legends of the Jaipur-atrauli gharana
It brought tears of joy to watch the mother and the daughter. Mogubai ji, such a towering musician, is simple and straight forward. My namaste to both.
🙏🙏गुरूंच्या समोर असताना कसं आदर पूर्वक असावं हे किशोरी जी यांच्या कडून शिकावं... ✨❤️ अशा या गुरु शिष्य जोडीला प्रणाम 🙏🙏🙏
I love mogubai so much. Best best best of India 🙏
She was a saint
Thank you so much, this is incredible! Two legends, two viewpoints.
Both of them are jewels!!
A treat to watch these two titans of Hindustani music!
Pity the interviewer!
# Great.Mogubai & my uncle Mohanrao Palekar were from same Jaypur atroli Gharana.So Mogubai sent kishoreji to learn Bandish from him.He taught her many bandishis
गानसरस्वती किशोरीताई
रवीन्द्र आमोणकर
पण मला नही भाग्यलाभल तुम्हाला दुरून तरि पहाण्याचं !
🕉️ मुर्तिमन्त नाद ब्राम्हणे नमः।
🌻🌺💮🌷🌺🌸🌷🌷🌻💮
🌝🌞 आचंद्र-सूर्य नांदो नितीमुल्य आदर्श आत्मानुसन्धानि महावेदवेदान्ति अविट मधुरातिमधुर ! अतीन्द्रिय
सुस्वरांचे !
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
👁️ 👃👁️
💦 💦
💦
💧
💧
💦
💧 💧
💧
💧
💦
💧💧
💧
💧
💦
💧💧
💧
💧
💦
💧💧
🕉️गानतपस्विन्यै नमः।
🕉️गानसरस्वत्यै नमः ।
Kya bat hai ..... Bohot accha video hai 🙏
This archival footage is truly wonderful. It would be fascinating if someone could interview Tejashree Amonkar and capture her reactions to this video. It could provide valuable insights and add an interesting dimension to the appreciation of her artistry.
Wao its a gem please upload more videos like this!😍😍😍😍😊😊
Anmol Mohsin School Of Music
Sure I will ... But plz share this video as much as possible cuz there is no video in which we could see mogubai ji live
@@romil2312 Yes you are right!
What a wasted opportunity. Deeply disappointing that the interviewer is struggling with his words, and cannot express himself well. What stories mother and daughter would tell if they were asked the right questions!
Thank you so much for posting this on youtube. I watched this video on the NCAA website. Very difficult to share. Now I can share this with my teacher. THANKS!!!
Yes please share it as much as u can
I am surprised WHY and How these 2 legends agreed to this Interview Ever ?
The person is either unaware of them or of his audience
Treasure ....She was such a patriot for purity
This is a classic example of how interviews should not be conducted. I am amazed at Kishori Amonkar’s patience.
Some times in life, words fail you completely! Only thing you could do is to listen and THIS is the time you listen!! 🙏🙏❤️❤️
So true!
Interviewer should have brought a konkani translator to get a real interview and allow Mogubai ji to express herself in her best way. But still, thanks for the piece of history.
But Kishori ji helped enunciating her learning, more open and universalised from Mogubai ji's: "sur jahan bhi ho...." ❤
Very good conversation🌸🌷🌸
Binamra Shradhanjali Gana Tapaswini Magubai Kurdikar Ji 🙏🙏🙏 Gana Saraswati Kishori Amonkar Ji 🙏🙏🙏 Ashirwad Kijie Meri Sangit Sadhna Safal Ho MAA
The interviewer has no idea who he is interviewing. poor guy! I think when interviewing stalwarts like Mogubai ji and Kishori ji the questions should be about music. That is what they know and want to share - I do not think they are interested in sharing their personal life. Though they really tried helping the interviewer.
While this may be a bad interview and we are left asking for more, I am glad we atleast found this one.
Your last words ... Are the only reason behind sharing this video
Yes. The interview should have been focused more on music
For example it is often said (especially for Classical musicians) s/he ‘(had a voice) could travel 3 octaves’
I am very rookie listener to classical music, but what I have understood is the best example of this is, when taking a taan, if the musician can actually go from taar -madhyam - mandra (or the reverse) and I have found IMHO only two or three maybe who have recording who can do that - Gaan tapaswini Mogubai and Surashree Kesarbai.
The recording for Mogubai has been taken down unfortunately, but that for Kesarbai is still there - Shuddha Kalyan in the alaap taane before the drut laya khyal.
These people were supernatural..
ruclips.net/video/ZKsGW0Kj4M4/видео.html 30:58 to the three harkats that the sings.
(The third person I am saying here is Bade Ghulam Ali Khan)
truly a treasure
Priceless !!!
Divine duo. 🙏
दोनो महान गायिका थी ! इंटरव्हिव लेते समय दिमाग ठिकाणे पे रखो ओर फिर सवाल पूछो !
जडन- घडन
इयत्ता ८ वी १९९८
बालभारती मराठी महाराष्ट्र राज्य पाठ्यपुस्तक निर्मिती मण्डळ
छान किशोरीताई मी खूप-खूप
धन्य आहे ! भाग्यवान मला हा माहितीपर पाठ होता तुमचा ! प्रेरणादायी !
गानतपस्विनी ...!
श्रीमती . मोगुबाई कुर्डिकर
क्लासिकलही पसंद है !
१०८ वेळा ही तान तंबोर्यावर आळव !
आध्यात्मिक आई !
खोट बोलुनकोस सूरही खोटाच लागेल ..!
गीता तीचु मराठी भाषांतर !
आताचा कुळात - कुळात आणि काळात हे कठिणच !
किती छान सूर जुळले !
माय- लेकींचे !
जणु कथा पोथ्या पुरांणातरीची !
नादब्रह्माण्डातुन- नादब्रह्म
सा रे ग म प ध नि सा
सूर ब्रह्मतो विश्वनिर्मिता ..!
गानसरस्वती कोकीलकणठी पद्म-भूषण पद्म-विभूषण भारगानतरत्न श्रीमती किशोरीताई रवीन्द्र आमोणकर
🕉️नाद ब्रह्मणे नमः।
🌻🌻🌻🕉️🌻🌻🌻
🇮🇳
👍👌🤝
💐
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
🌝🌞
🦚🦚🦚🦚
जय जय जय जयपूर-अत्रौली घराणा !
अजी पाँच सालकी उम्रथी इनकी माईच्या { सूरांच्यागर्भात खुलत राहायचं }
गर्भात असताना माई अल्लादियाँ खाँ साहेब यांच्याकडे जे शिकत होती त्याचे ((( ते आणि तसे --- स्वरार्थरमणी भारतीय शास्त्रीय संगीत रागरस सिध्दांत )))
संस्कार होत-होतच मी वाढत होते !
गर्भस्थ अवस्था ही अहंकार शून्य असते ! त्या अवस्थेत तेज्ञान जसे असते अगदी तसेच्या तसे घेतले जाते !
निःशंक ! निःसंशय !
राग ।। श्री ।।
माझा मुलगा त्याच नाव मी " श्री " असच ठेवल आहे !
बाबूला डाळींब फार आवडतात ! ज्याच इंग्रजी भाषुवर खूप-खूप प्रभूत्व आहे !
ललिता !
हम्म् !
बिभास - निहार
विवियन , आदित्य, तेजश्री , सगळे तेजःपूज तेजस्वी तेज या महाभूताशी संबधीत देदिप्यमान नावं ...!
भाग्यवान आमोणकर व कुटुंबिय !
संस्कारी , सुसंस्कृत , तत्त्वज्ञानात्मक , धार्मिक मार्मिक व परमोच्च
देश- काल- पात्र बंधन विरहित आदर्श
खरच भाग्यवान आचंद्र 🌝 सूर्य 🌞 नांदो स्वरब्रह्म मुर्तिमंत स्वरांचे !
🌷🌹🌸🏵️🌼🏵️🌼🌸🌸🌹🏵️🏵️🌸🌼🌸🏵️🌸🏵️🌹🌼🏵️🌸🌻🌻🌷🌷💐💐💐🌹🏵️🌼🌼🌸🏵️🌸🏵️🏵️
🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷।।🕉️।।🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
really a trasure,many thanks
Ganathapaswini mogubai kurdikar and Ganasaraswathi kishori amonkar ko pranams
whenever I see interviews of these great women singers of the past the interviewer clearly wants them to talk as he thinks and thus makes questions that they answer with just a few words...
I wish instead of the interviewer they would let Ma Kishori Amonkar & her mother talk.
LEGENDARY Moghubai
Pranams
Interviewer is pathetic!
Precious
The interviewer quite frankly didn't know whom he is interviewing. If only he did some research on the two great legendary vocalists, he would have dared not interviewed them in first place, because he practically seems to know nothing about Classical Music. There are many such sub-standard people in India like this interviewer who get great opportunities only because they have contacts with influential people. There is nepotism everywhere. These so called influential people dominating the classical music scene in India are squarely responsible for the decay that we see today in Classical Music especially Hindustani classical music in India in contemporary times.
Interviewer is unprepared as hell, he is interviewing two stalwarts of Jaipur style singing! He should have prepared some questions on a paper
Superb Video....So Heart quenching
Nice such smiling Mother Daughter combo.
Phrasing by the Urdu program interviewers is most polite,and no personal opinion to 'down' the great is used.
This man looks and sounds rude and difficult,please remember they are unique and no one is immortal.
Fantastic, a purist and a hybrid but amazing talents; and is conceptually the “Maai” of The Disciple based on her?
Thank you so much for sharing this priceless gem
heartchakra2 😊😊
दंडवत आईं ना!🙏🙏
Rare and badhiya.
There is great bonding between mother and daughter
खूप छान 🙏
माननीया मोगुबाई जी आणि गानसरस्वती किशोरी आमोणकर जी याबद्दल बोलताना तारतम्य बाळगून बोलावयास हवे.
या दोघीही माननीया देवाची देणगी आहेत.
विदुषी मोघुबाई एवं विदुषी किशोरीजी का इंटरव्यू कब लिया गया था बताने की कृपा करें
What a inoces smile
मराठी टेक्स्टबुक में इनके ऊपर एक chaptar था, 8th स्टँडर्ड में.......
Can u plz share it if possible ?
yes when I'm also in 8th std in1998
येस आय वास अलसो रीड इन मराठी बालभारती हो रिलीज फ्रॉम पुणे सीलाबस बुक यु कलेक्ट दिस टेक्स्ट लेसन फ्रॉम हिज मेन हेड ऑफिस
जडन- घडन
इयत्ता ८ वी १९९८
बालभारती मराठी महाराष्ट्र राज्य पाठ्यपुस्तक निर्मिती मण्डळ
छान किशोरीताई मी खूप-खूप
धन्य आहे ! भाग्यवान मला हा माहितीपर पाठ होता तुमचा ! प्रेरणादायी !
गानतपस्विनी ...!
श्रीमती . मोगुबाई कुर्डिकर
क्लासिकलही पसंद है !
१०८ वेळा ही तान तंबोर्यावर आळव !
आध्यात्मिक आई !
खोट बोलुनकोस सूरही खोटाच लागेल ..!
गीता तीचु मराठी भाषांतर !
आताचा कुळात - कुळात आणि काळात हे कठिणच !
किती छान सूर जुळले !
माय- लेकींचे !
जणु कथा पोथ्या पुरांणातरीची !
नादब्रह्माण्डातुन- नादब्रह्म
सा रे ग म प ध नि सा
सूर ब्रह्मतो विश्वनिर्मिता ..!
गानसरस्वती कोकीलकणठी पद्म-भूषण पद्म-विभूषण भारगानतरत्न श्रीमती किशोरीताई रवीन्द्र आमोणकर
🕉️नाद ब्रह्मणे नमः।
🌻🌻🌻🕉️🌻🌻🌻
🇮🇳
👍👌🤝
💐
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
🌝🌞
🦚🦚🦚🦚
जय जय जय जयपूर-अत्रौली घराणा !
अजी पाँच सालकी उम्रथी इनकी माईच्या { सूरांच्यागर्भात खुलत राहायचं }
गर्भात असताना माई अल्लादियाँ खाँ साहेब यांच्याकडे जे शिकत होती त्याचे ((( ते आणि तसे --- स्वरार्थरमणी भारतीय शास्त्रीय संगीत रागरस सिध्दांत )))
संस्कार होत-होतच मी वाढत होते !
गर्भस्थ अवस्था ही अहंकार शून्य असते ! त्या अवस्थेत तेज्ञान जसे असते अगदी तसेच्या तसे घेतले जाते !
निःशंक ! निःसंशय !
राग ।। श्री ।।
माझा मुलगा त्याच नाव मी " श्री " असच ठेवल आहे !
बाबूला डाळींब फार आवडतात ! ज्याच इंग्रजी भाषुवर खूप-खूप प्रभूत्व आहे !
ललिता !
हम्म् !
बिभास - निहार
विवियन , आदित्य, तेजश्री , सगळे तेजःपूज तेजस्वी तेज या महाभूताशी संबधीत देदिप्यमान नावं ...!
भाग्यवान आमोणकर व कुटुंबिय !
संस्कारी , सुसंस्कृत , तत्त्वज्ञानात्मक , धार्मिक मार्मिक व परमोच्च
देश- काल- पात्र बंधन विरहित आदर्श
खरच भाग्यवान आचंद्र 🌝 सूर्य 🌞 नांदो स्वरब्रह्म मुर्तिमंत स्वरांचे !
🌷🌹🌸🏵️🌼🏵️🌼🌸🌸🌹🏵️🏵️🌸🌼🌸🏵️🌸🏵️🌹🌼🏵️🌸🌻🌻🌷🌷💐💐💐🌹🏵️🌼🌼🌸🏵️🌸🏵️🏵️
🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷।।🕉️।।🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
@@bharatgurav2778 जडन- घडन
इयत्ता ८ वी १९९८
बालभारती मराठी महाराष्ट्र राज्य पाठ्यपुस्तक निर्मिती मण्डळ
छान किशोरीताई मी खूप-खूप
धन्य आहे ! भाग्यवान मला हा माहितीपर पाठ होता तुमचा ! प्रेरणादायी !
गानतपस्विनी ...!
श्रीमती . मोगुबाई कुर्डिकर
क्लासिकलही पसंद है !
१०८ वेळा ही तान तंबोर्यावर आळव !
आध्यात्मिक आई !
खोट बोलुनकोस सूरही खोटाच लागेल ..!
गीता तीचु मराठी भाषांतर !
आताचा कुळात - कुळात आणि काळात हे कठिणच !
किती छान सूर जुळले !
माय- लेकींचे !
जणु कथा पोथ्या पुरांणातरीची !
नादब्रह्माण्डातुन- नादब्रह्म
सा रे ग म प ध नि सा
सूर ब्रह्मतो विश्वनिर्मिता ..!
गानसरस्वती कोकीलकणठी पद्म-भूषण पद्म-विभूषण भारगानतरत्न श्रीमती किशोरीताई रवीन्द्र आमोणकर
🕉️नाद ब्रह्मणे नमः।
🌻🌻🌻🕉️🌻🌻🌻
🇮🇳
👍👌🤝
💐
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
🌝🌞
🦚🦚🦚🦚
जय जय जय जयपूर-अत्रौली घराणा !
अजी पाँच सालकी उम्रथी इनकी माईच्या { सूरांच्यागर्भात खुलत राहायचं }
गर्भात असताना माई अल्लादियाँ खाँ साहेब यांच्याकडे जे शिकत होती त्याचे ((( ते आणि तसे --- स्वरार्थरमणी भारतीय शास्त्रीय संगीत रागरस सिध्दांत )))
संस्कार होत-होतच मी वाढत होते !
गर्भस्थ अवस्था ही अहंकार शून्य असते ! त्या अवस्थेत तेज्ञान जसे असते अगदी तसेच्या तसे घेतले जाते !
निःशंक ! निःसंशय !
राग ।। श्री ।।
माझा मुलगा त्याच नाव मी " श्री " असच ठेवल आहे !
बाबूला डाळींब फार आवडतात ! ज्याच इंग्रजी भाषुवर खूप-खूप प्रभूत्व आहे !
ललिता !
हम्म् !
बिभास - निहार
विवियन , आदित्य, तेजश्री , सगळे तेजःपूज तेजस्वी तेज या महाभूताशी संबधीत देदिप्यमान नावं ...!
भाग्यवान आमोणकर व कुटुंबिय !
संस्कारी , सुसंस्कृत , तत्त्वज्ञानात्मक , धार्मिक मार्मिक व परमोच्च
देश- काल- पात्र बंधन विरहित आदर्श
खरच भाग्यवान आचंद्र 🌝 सूर्य 🌞 नांदो स्वरब्रह्म मुर्तिमंत स्वरांचे !
🌷🌹🌸🏵️🌼🏵️🌼🌸🌸🌹🏵️🏵️🌸🌼🌸🏵️🌸🏵️🌹🌼🏵️🌸🌻🌻🌷🌷💐💐💐🌹🏵️🌼🌼🌸🏵️🌸🏵️🏵️
🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷।।🕉️।।🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Wow
This is the problem: the interviewers are unlettered and unaware, hence lack class.
Interviewer is with Kishori amonkar and mugubai kurdikar I seriously doubt he is aware of that, he didn't listen to any of them !
दुर्मीळ, क्षण,
What a pathetic waste of time! Just about 7 minutes with the great Mogubaiji, and the interviewer doesn't know how to utilise it. She is a direct disciple of Ustad Alladiya Khan Sahab, and so many treasures could have been unearthed, at least scratched on the surface! Instead we have precious seconds wasted on camera adjustments followed by meaningless questions 👎
Really saddened.
Exactly, what a waste of a golden opportunity! Was it impromptu? Could have asked many relevant questions that would enlighten listeners for years to come but instead he wasted it on frivolous and well known aspects.
She also looked quite reticent in this video. May be she also was similar to Annapurna Devi - engrossed in music!
Nice
Interviewr might be siddharth kak
Stupid questions😑😑😑😑
Y dont they prepare proper questions
Onkar yadav very true
🙏
The interviewer is totally unprepared in terms of his ability to draw out the personality of the duo and relationship between them. He missed a great opportunity😬
All irrelevant questions. Hindustani classical music has no relevance. Baki Moghibai and Kishoritai... undoubtedly great !
Sorry I don’t think you can or should questions like how would you compare yourself to your daughter!!!
Interviewer Zindagi main kabhi shashtriya sangeet ke aaspaas bhi nehi Gaya hoga aur aise mahan sangeetkaar o ke samne hansi mazakh Kar raha Hai. He bhagwan!
Kishori tai permanently imbibed classical..but during young age she has also..tried semi classical..as usual all youngsters does...
yeh video kab shoot kiya gaya he?? kynki ab na mogubai kurdikar jinda he aur na hi kishori amonkar
Sidharth kaak is asking absolutely dumb questions here to two stalwarts of Jaipur style singing
6:12
Is this really Siddharth Kak who is asking such silly questions? Aap classical framework mei kyu nahi aai? I thought he understood music
The interviewer has no clue about music or musicians, not showing any respect to two great exponent of classical music. He is lucky not to be told off by Kishoriji . Only good thing is we could see clearly the face of Moghubaiji.
sham ganguly they should have gotten an inter who knows something about classical music and listens to classical music
The interviewer has not done any research on these great artists nor does he have any idea of their music. A very unprepared person behind the camera and wasted a golden opportunity!
Itne sundar daivi Kalakaron ki mulaqaat, itna ghatiya interviewer le raha hai, ye Doordarshan ki khaasiyat hai. Extremely unprofessional interviewer. Thank you Doordarshan for ruining something that had the potential to become a true master piece
Interviewer is clueless.
pdshukla very true
Why is the interviewer asking such stupid questions to these stalwarts?
The interviewer is totally ignorant. !!!
Ye dekho,😑 Kishori ji ko puch raha hai aap classical frame mai kiu nahi rahi. Kya bakwas baat karta hai yaar🙄. Phir puchta hai classical mei kya hai. Pagal hai ya kya hai vai.🤦♂️
This has to be Siddharth Kak's worst interview...these exponents have eaten him up.
stupid questions.. at least give some respect to the artists.
Poor interviewer
The interviewer is a novice.
So much of their time being wasted with bs. Ignoramuses steer clear of the real goods. Please
Kya chu interviewer hai 😔