The Glock shouldn't be in this comparison. Because yet again they rely on aftermarket to be equal. Also it has a massive flashlight hanging over to reduce recoil. The shadow systems would have been a better comparison.
Plus a lot of us already own a Glock 19. Buying a comp might be a more budget friendly option for me than buying a new gun, so to me it was useful information. 👍
Lets think bout it. I can get a xmacro for 800. I can get a g19 mos for 490 and I got the radian on sale for 240. Not a blem model. Just on sale then added a coupon code. I saved 70ish bucks. Never saw the MP carry comp in stores yet. But online going for 800 plus. Msrp was 900 iirc. So glock is the best bang for buck. All trusted guns. Dont own any hellcats so cant speak bout them. Shot my friends xmacro and its okay. Idk the guy on the right said the xmacro has a bigger grip. I feel a g19 or 45 is way bigger. Largest backstrap vs largest backstrap. Sounds like he full of it and being a salesman.
By the logic I am seeing here , I can buy a CZ Shadow 2 and add a comp. Might as well go full on competition pistol with a comp added. Why not throw in 5 or 6 thousand dollar 2011 with a comp. Let's see which shoots better. Having no limit for only one brand is not a real competition. For that matter many options without comps will shoot better.
Throw a DPM soft captured spring on the comped Glock and it'll take care of that slide issue you were complaining about. Buttery smooth with that combo.
The S&W is also considered a micro compact, but ya it looks closer to the full size G19. I've never got my hands on one of those Shields yet so I can't say if its as thin as the XMacro or the HC Pro Comp. Either way didn't seem like a fair comparison across the board.
@@willdogs4286that’s not the shield carry comp, it’s the compact carry comp with the polymer frame. The other one they make is an aluminum full size frame carry comp.
People have been having issues with shadow systems CR920’s models. The guns that’s are complete clones of the g19, g17, and g45 have no issues, without the comps of course.
The sig has always tracked well for me. It does feel a little snappy overall but for it's size it's very controlled. Despite it's size you don't give up capacity, you actually gain capacity over much bigger pistols.
It literally says “P365 XMACRO-COMP,” on Sig Sauer’s website. In this video Kaya said Sig doesn’t label it as being a comp because the barrel isn’t ported on the Sig.
I have one it is much thinner than the smith & Glock I have a DR 920P it is my favorite striker Fired Gun.I agree They should have had a Ported Shadow System Gun .That was not very equal.
As always, you have to upgrade Glock to get it to compete. They said the smith wasn’t snappy but in the video the barrel was snapping up all over the place.
so, I bought the ermox fire. it was on sale at a local shop, and classic had pitched it as a good gun. for the price, I was very impressed. I ended up putting in a 4.5 pd striker spring in it, polished up some internals and added a zaffiri ported g19 gen 5 barrel. it is currently my favorite carry gun, and I have $1000+ pistols
The confidentially incorrect RUclips comments never surprise. Porting is a type of compensation, specifically upward compensation. In other words, all porting is compensation, but not all compensation is porting.
@@TTime685 Hey, thanks for making my point. You're the one that said porting =/= compensation. Again, all porting is compensation. Not all compensation is porting.
While I agree that nuances like recoil impulses and trigger feel affect the shooting experience, what matters to me most is combat effectiveness. Without actually getting into a gunfight, the next best overall test that I have found is the FBI qual. It is objective, varied range, varied rapidity, requires holster draws, and strong & weak one handed shooting. Anything that helps in either speed or score I keep. Anything that doesn’t goes bye bye. If the comp helps, then 👍, otherwise 👎. Besides, maybe the P365 being snappy (which I agree that it is) isn’t because the comp isn’t doing its job, but rather that the recoil spring is letting the slide bottom out. I am getting a DPMS spring kit to see if that helps. So far, I keep coming back to my Beretta PX4 Compact Carry. No fancy comp, but it just makes the qual easier.
You missed the MR920XP, and honestly it is pretty awesome. I wouldn’t even count the Glock because it isn’t factory as to where the others come straight from the factory in the configuration they are in. And the 365 isn’t a comp in reality.
Hellcat RDP or HEllcat Pro Comp, MCarbo trigger kit, Streamlight TLR-8, Shield SMSC, blackpoint tactical leather wing holster....I prefer the HEllcat RPD to switch from the 10/13/15 rnd mags for carry options and ultimate comfort....ur welcome....All Glocks are either 2 big/bulky for my liking or dont have the capacity I want in a gun fight and aftermarket mags have issues
Comps are at the end of the barrel. Usually attached to the barrel but now come as part of the slide. Ports or Poppel Holes are in the barrel at the top. They are separate things but can be combined. The P365 X Macro IS A Comped gun. The other guns are Comped with Ports or poppel holes. In USPSA there are OPEN Guns that are comped and Open Guns that have a comp and poppel holes. Do rifles with a comp on the end of the barrel have poppel holes in them? No they don't.
I will add that having both a comp and poppel holes does improve the handling of the gun. The comp on the Sig is a comp because it does redirect gases upwards like a comp is supposed to do.
@@timothyholtzen6405 Correct. I have a P365XL that start as just a P365. I just upgraded again and put an X Macro slide on the XL frame. Huge difference in recoil snappiness. I'm currently waiting for an X Macro Icarus aluminum frame to replace the XL frame because of better ergonomics and fit in my hand. I'm sure that will also dramatically improve the shoot ability of it. The modularity of the P365 lineup because of the Fire Control Unit make it number one for me.
The sig isn't comp'd or ported my guy. You wrote all that just to get it wrong. Comps are threaded on or built in to the barrel. Ports are barrel holes. It is that simple. The only comp'd gun in this list is the glock...which really isn't even comp'd it's ported with a fancy flange over the top.
So a modified ballasted Glock is what you compare stock smaller pistols against? Were you also running training ammo through the Glock and premium defense ammo through the others?
Comparing a 1.4" wide compact with a light and aftermarket standalone comp to a 1" thick subcompact (large sub but still sub) with no light and slide comp cuts... why not compare a Sig MPX to a Ruger LCP while you're at it?
I own the P365 AXG Legion and the Carry Comp…the Carry Comp is very soft recoiling but the AXG is surprisingly flat shooting and gets back on target quickly
When Jason said he hated the hellcat pro grip I felt that😂 not so much due to how slick it feels but the shape of it. I can’t stand that it feels like I’m holding a 2x4. I carry with the sig they used and it’s fantastic. I haven’t shot the others but my xmacro is much less snappy than other full size pistols I have
The Shadow Systems CR920XP/CR920P, Bul Armory Ultralight Pro, Oracle Arms 2311 Compact Pro would’ve stomped all of these. Some might think it is too heavy, but I would have also included the Springfield Armory 1911 DS 4.25 AOS Comp as well.
The only comp'd carry that I have the P365 AXG Legion. Shooting it side by side with my P365 Spectre non-comp I did not notice much difference in performance with range ammo. However, with 124 +P the AXG definitely had less muzzle rise. But, for the average shooter's EDC, I question how much value they add. Certainly with highly skilled completion shooters they can cut time, but for EDC practice is of more value than a new gun w/comp IMHO. The video was a great comparison and shows that one size does not fit all.
Where’s the shadowsystems love? I’ve shot the XR920P and own an MR920P, both incredible factory comped firearms all around, and in my opinion they take a dookie on the ramjet cosmeticly & functionally!
What classifies a "comp" now. I've seen a lot of new guns with a single or even dual port being called a comp. Does it have to do with the size of the opening or maybe the number of holes in the barrel? Because many of the new comps seem like porting to me.
To be honest none of these guns are comp'd. The sig isn't comp'd or ported. The glock is the closest but with the radian system it's basically fancy porting with a flange over the top. There are no real comp'd guns in this video.
So a solid barrel that ends and then has an extension added that allows the gasses to be directed upward is a comp....the part added to the end of the barrel. Ports are milled into the barrell and allow the gasses to be directed upward before the bullet leaves the barrel. Both methods perform the same function of COMPENSATING for muzzle rise. And so they say the gun is comped. Comped via ports or comped via an extension added on called a comp. And you can also have a comp added on to a ported barrel for more comp power. Hope this helps
@@daymondcenteno6066Lol.. a comp AND a ported barrel? That's going to lose a lot of blowback pressure and velocity. Never seen that before in my life, but I guess people will do anything these days 😌 Porting is holes in barrel, compensators have holes/ports after barrel, it's a simple as that. Muzzle brakes on rifles do the exact same function.. they reduce recoil and muzzle rise. Although brakes are technically comps, not ports, but it all does the same thing like you said, which is redirecting gasses
@@benjaminlanzotti1374The Sig and all the others are indeed comped.. If they are redirecting gasses upward/outwardto COMPENSATE for muzzle rise/recoil then it's comped.. The Sig just not your traditional threaded barrel compensator, but it's still doing the job. It's just using the slide for the comp/ports. Porting is compensating and compensators have ports.. It's all the same inherent function. You people have no clue what you're talking about lol
The P365 Spectre Comp is the same as the X Macro in every way except the grip holds 12 rds flush instead of 17. Point being, they do use the term comp.
Good experiment, Thank you for making this good video for comp compare carrygun. One thing, This video will be perfect if all of guns has a same condition. Glock has a flashlight that make more weight infront of the gun caused less recoil.
Great video! You make a lot of great points, one specifically I think needs to be highlighted is everyone is a little different. A preference might not always reflect in enhanced performance in my experience, sometimes you shoot something you don’t prefer as much better. I shoot the g19 and X macro a lot and they’re my main two carry guns. And for the record I shoot the X macro a hair better for some reason unbeknownst to me. Really like them, I’m definitely intrigued by the new smith as well as some other new smiths! 😅
This video is proof that YOU have to shoot the gun YOURSELF to see how it shoots FOR YOU! Everyone's opinion can and should be different cuz no two people are the same. Gun reviews are helpful but should be used as a reference point and not gospel. IMO they should have used a factory gen 4 19C instead of a gen 5 with an aftermarket comp added...ijs
Whats your thoughts on these comp carry guns possibly causing shrapnel injury when fired at retention/super close instances? Given these are carry guns, firing at very close range (to you as the shooter) would be a possibility in a given situation. Is the trade off with shooting flatter bigger than the chance of losing an eye in a gun fight? (all-be-it better than your life of course but still....carrying a non-comp/ported gun wouldn't have that chance).
Sig has 3.1 inch barrel. Not an equivalent comparison. Show me any gun with 3.1 inch barrel that isn’t snappy. However, IMO best EDC on the planet for the money if your hands fit it and not bothered by a “snappy” firearm. 1.1 inch wide, perfect grip, weight and balance. with 17 round mag extension. Easy to conceal.
The New S & W carry comp. is the SHIZZZZZ!!!! & I'm a GLOCKTARD.....FANBOY....GLOCKTARD..... GLOCK IS KING!!!!! but S & W outdone their self with this one.....IMO
I own one and for how small it is it shoots better than most full sizes and for being “not a real comp” it sure performs real damn close to Hellcat comp which is apparently “a real comp”
@ClassicFirearms You' re missing four guns that are compensated from the factory and 50 state compliant. Shadow Systems Corp DR920P (G34), XR920P (G19x), MR920P (G19), CR920XP (G43X) I'd like to see any or all of these firearms in your next factory comped/ported head-to-head line-up. Please and thank you. P.S. The MR920P is my daily carry in case you were wondering.
They showing a lot of rapid firing but without showing the targets we can assume they are just spraying bullets everywhere, maybe one on target? Maybe?
What's the difference between the comp on the sig and the glock it's just a port built into the slide at the end of the barrell it's the exact same thing just the comp is integrated into the slide on the m&p and on the glock it's just an aftermarket attachment that's just put on the slide. But it don't see why that would change anything it's the exact same thing.
Dude, they can’t mention every single gun there is out there. I’ll be honest with you, these are some of the biggest names and the most commonly mentioned. That’s probably why these particular firearms were chosen.
@@SirClicks. i don’t have anything against the channel i’m just a fn “fanboy” it’s personally my favorite brand i also figured there choices might have something to i with price i believe the fn is way more… and i don’t get the complaints about the dagger it’s almost a off brand glock
I like Jason but I think he just burns through the mag as fast as possible. If he’s a great shot while doing that then by means keep ripping it. But I think his whole criteria is “how fast can I shoot it.”
The whole idea of a comped gun is to reduce muzzle flip and felt recoil and that is best demonstrated by rapid firing and at the minimum double taps. So he’s really the only one that did it correctly.
If the ONLY thing we want to figure out is how well a gun is compensated and negates muzzle rise, grid paper and high speed cameras are all you'd need to measure which one does the job better eliminating all human variables.
The Glock shouldn't be in this comparison. Because yet again they rely on aftermarket to be equal. Also it has a massive flashlight hanging over to reduce recoil. The shadow systems would have been a better comparison.
Who cares, it’s cheap so after market parts can be included in budget
It’s a gun that almost everyone has shot so that’s why it’s used as a comparison
Glock has less felt recoil with Ramjet side by side coming from shadow system owner. But randian gets hot to touch after a mag or 2 no like.
@@twotestticklez6096"its cheap" we are talking about the same glock right?
@@Myemnhk yeah, $500 is cheap for a gun you can trust your life with. Bout as cheap as it gets while still holding reliability.
Glock can't take credit for the Glock. The Afterburner did all the work. Nothing to do with Glock.
Afterburner and flashlight, too.
True but Glock made the original factory comped gun with the 19C and 17C
@@warweaponx6629 which nobody utters a word about. Few even know they exist. I'm willing to venture it sucks.
You have a light on the end of the Glock, which adds some weight and could reduce some snappiness. So not apples to apples.
Not sure what a customized Glock WITH a light is doing on a list of stock guns??
Because almost everyone who shoots can say they shot a Glock so it’s something people can compare to
Plus a lot of us already own a Glock 19. Buying a comp might be a more budget friendly option for me than buying a new gun, so to me it was useful information. 👍
@nickfogarty3062 but you're more likely to buy a new gun because who doesn't love a reason for a new gun
Lets think bout it. I can get a xmacro for 800. I can get a g19 mos for 490 and I got the radian on sale for 240. Not a blem model. Just on sale then added a coupon code. I saved 70ish bucks. Never saw the MP carry comp in stores yet. But online going for 800 plus. Msrp was 900 iirc.
So glock is the best bang for buck. All trusted guns. Dont own any hellcats so cant speak bout them. Shot my friends xmacro and its okay. Idk the guy on the right said the xmacro has a bigger grip. I feel a g19 or 45 is way bigger. Largest backstrap vs largest backstrap. Sounds like he full of it and being a salesman.
By the logic I am seeing here , I can buy a CZ Shadow 2 and add a comp. Might as well go full on competition pistol with a comp added. Why not throw in 5 or 6 thousand dollar 2011 with a comp. Let's see which shoots better. Having no limit for only one brand is not a real competition. For that matter many options without comps will shoot better.
Throw a DPM soft captured spring on the comped Glock and it'll take care of that slide issue you were complaining about. Buttery smooth with that combo.
Hmmm.... did anyone notice the Hellcat and P365 are smaller guns than the other two?
The S&W is also considered a micro compact, but ya it looks closer to the full size G19. I've never got my hands on one of those Shields yet so I can't say if its as thin as the XMacro or the HC Pro Comp. Either way didn't seem like a fair comparison across the board.
@@willdogs4286that’s not the shield carry comp, it’s the compact carry comp with the polymer frame. The other one they make is an aluminum full size frame carry comp.
Why did the g19 have an x300 light on it when the other guns didn't have any lights at all? This affects results. C'mon.
Came to say the same
Added weight in front.
One factor not discussed is barrel length. Of course a smaller barrel will be snappier. When you are comparing to other comped guns.
It all comes down to personal preference and what feels best in your hand.
The bigger guns shot better. Go figure.
My thought exactly!
Yall forgot the cr920xp😮💨
That's what I was hoping for.
Why not shoot that gun as a factory comped gun vs Ryan’s completely custom Glock.
Cr920xp is factory and it’s shoot flat I love mine 🤝
Came here to say this
People have been having issues with shadow systems CR920’s models. The guns that’s are complete clones of the g19, g17, and g45 have no issues, without the comps of course.
The sig has always tracked well for me. It does feel a little snappy overall but for it's size it's very controlled. Despite it's size you don't give up capacity, you actually gain capacity over much bigger pistols.
It literally says “P365 XMACRO-COMP,” on Sig Sauer’s website. In this video Kaya said Sig doesn’t label it as being a comp because the barrel isn’t ported on the Sig.
I have one it is much thinner than the smith & Glock I have a DR 920P it is my favorite striker Fired Gun.I agree They should have had a Ported Shadow System Gun .That was not very equal.
They are pretty biased and uneducated about these guns in general…😕
As always, you have to upgrade Glock to get it to compete. They said the smith wasn’t snappy but in the video the barrel was snapping up all over the place.
Kenzie & Jason both good additions.
Shadow Systems should have been included in this comparison..... especially the CR920XP. Great shooting pistol.
so, I bought the ermox fire. it was on sale at a local shop, and classic had pitched it as a good gun. for the price, I was very impressed. I ended up putting in a 4.5 pd striker spring in it, polished up some internals and added a zaffiri ported g19 gen 5 barrel. it is currently my favorite carry gun, and I have $1000+ pistols
Why cant people get ported vs compensated right.. Holes in barrel = ported, holes after barrel = compensator
yep, they need to pull this video and start over. Embarassing.
The confidentially incorrect RUclips comments never surprise. Porting is a type of compensation, specifically upward compensation. In other words, all porting is compensation, but not all compensation is porting.
@@Beakerz857 So tell me, what are the little holes that compensators use? 🤦🏼♂️ They are ports to redirect gasses upward and/or to the sides..
@@TTime685 Hey, thanks for making my point. You're the one that said porting =/= compensation.
Again, all porting is compensation. Not all compensation is porting.
@@Beakerz857 Huh? When did I say porting is not compensating? Lol.. Porting is compensation and compensators use ports.. Understand?
Would LOVE to see you include the SS CR920XP.
Was about to comment this!
Jason you shot the m&p so much faster then the rest . . . Can't help but wonder if that made the dot harder to track
While I agree that nuances like recoil impulses and trigger feel affect the shooting experience, what matters to me most is combat effectiveness. Without actually getting into a gunfight, the next best overall test that I have found is the FBI qual. It is objective, varied range, varied rapidity, requires holster draws, and strong & weak one handed shooting. Anything that helps in either speed or score I keep. Anything that doesn’t goes bye bye. If the comp helps, then 👍, otherwise 👎. Besides, maybe the P365 being snappy (which I agree that it is) isn’t because the comp isn’t doing its job, but rather that the recoil spring is letting the slide bottom out. I am getting a DPMS spring kit to see if that helps. So far, I keep coming back to my Beretta PX4 Compact Carry. No fancy comp, but it just makes the qual easier.
Bul armory is coming out with a ported and comped double stacked 1911 next year 👀
Wouldn't the m&p and the hellcat be more ported then comps while the glock and the sig would be more of a comp?
2 barrels are 4"...1 is 3.7"...and the last is 3.1". Not shocking that the last one would be snappier. Totally different shooting pistol.
This, the macro is such a good gun.
With that tiny barrel haha. I have the legion and love it.
This Chanel is the epitome of why you don’t take gun store clerks opinions on firearms. They don’t even know what they are talking about.
Jason is right about the Glock feel when shooting it, it have chugg feel to it, moving like some type Machinery that cut Lumber
You missed the MR920XP, and honestly it is pretty awesome. I wouldn’t even count the Glock because it isn’t factory as to where the others come straight from the factory in the configuration they are in. And the 365 isn’t a comp in reality.
You’re spot on about the grip of the X macro, I carry it or my g19 everyday and the grip on the macro prints more for me.
Hellcat RDP or HEllcat Pro Comp, MCarbo trigger kit, Streamlight TLR-8, Shield SMSC, blackpoint tactical leather wing holster....I prefer the HEllcat RPD to switch from the 10/13/15 rnd mags for carry options and ultimate comfort....ur welcome....All Glocks are either 2 big/bulky for my liking or dont have the capacity I want in a gun fight and aftermarket mags have issues
Comps are at the end of the barrel. Usually attached to the barrel but now come as part of the slide. Ports or Poppel Holes are in the barrel at the top. They are separate things but can be combined. The P365 X Macro IS A Comped gun. The other guns are Comped with Ports or poppel holes. In USPSA there are OPEN Guns that are comped and Open Guns that have a comp and poppel holes. Do rifles with a comp on the end of the barrel have poppel holes in them? No they don't.
I will add that having both a comp and poppel holes does improve the handling of the gun. The comp on the Sig is a comp because it does redirect gases upwards like a comp is supposed to do.
If you watch a slow mo video of the 365 firing it works as a comp
@@timothyholtzen6405 Correct. I have a P365XL that start as just a P365. I just upgraded again and put an X Macro slide on the XL frame. Huge difference in recoil snappiness. I'm currently waiting for an X Macro Icarus aluminum frame to replace the XL frame because of better ergonomics and fit in my hand. I'm sure that will also dramatically improve the shoot ability of it. The modularity of the P365 lineup because of the Fire Control Unit make it number one for me.
The sig isn't comp'd or ported my guy. You wrote all that just to get it wrong.
Comps are threaded on or built in to the barrel.
Ports are barrel holes.
It is that simple. The only comp'd gun in this list is the glock...which really isn't even comp'd it's ported with a fancy flange over the top.
@@benjaminlanzotti1374 oh ok I guess the gas shooting up in front of my muzzle isn’t real. It will even tear a paper target . But thanks anyway
So a modified ballasted Glock is what you compare stock smaller pistols against? Were you also running training ammo through the Glock and premium defense ammo through the others?
Comparing a 1.4" wide compact with a light and aftermarket standalone comp to a 1" thick subcompact (large sub but still sub) with no light and slide comp cuts... why not compare a Sig MPX to a Ruger LCP while you're at it?
I own the P365 AXG Legion and the Carry Comp…the Carry Comp is very soft recoiling but the AXG is surprisingly flat shooting and gets back on target quickly
Cz shadow2 compact with ports has to be the best aftermarket option
When Jason said he hated the hellcat pro grip I felt that😂 not so much due to how slick it feels but the shape of it. I can’t stand that it feels like I’m holding a 2x4. I carry with the sig they used and it’s fantastic. I haven’t shot the others but my xmacro is much less snappy than other full size pistols I have
The Shadow Systems CR920XP/CR920P, Bul Armory Ultralight Pro, Oracle Arms 2311 Compact Pro would’ve stomped all of these. Some might think it is too heavy, but I would have also included the Springfield Armory 1911 DS 4.25 AOS Comp as well.
The only comp'd carry that I have the P365 AXG Legion. Shooting it side by side with my P365 Spectre non-comp I did not notice much difference in performance with range ammo. However, with 124 +P the AXG definitely had less muzzle rise. But, for the average shooter's EDC, I question how much value they add. Certainly with highly skilled completion shooters they can cut time, but for EDC practice is of more value than a new gun w/comp IMHO. The video was a great comparison and shows that one size does not fit all.
Where’s the shadowsystems love? I’ve shot the XR920P and own an MR920P, both incredible factory comped firearms all around, and in my opinion they take a dookie on the ramjet cosmeticly & functionally!
Jason makes everything look so easy. Nice round check.
This is 💯 the comparison ive been wanting to see between all of these! Great video
What classifies a "comp" now. I've seen a lot of new guns with a single or even dual port being called a comp. Does it have to do with the size of the opening or maybe the number of holes in the barrel? Because many of the new comps seem like porting to me.
Exactly
To be honest none of these guns are comp'd.
The sig isn't comp'd or ported.
The glock is the closest but with the radian system it's basically fancy porting with a flange over the top.
There are no real comp'd guns in this video.
So a solid barrel that ends and then has an extension added that allows the gasses to be directed upward is a comp....the part added to the end of the barrel.
Ports are milled into the barrell and allow the gasses to be directed upward before the bullet leaves the barrel.
Both methods perform the same function of COMPENSATING for muzzle rise. And so they say the gun is comped.
Comped via ports or comped via an extension added on called a comp.
And you can also have a comp added on to a ported barrel for more comp power.
Hope this helps
@@daymondcenteno6066Lol.. a comp AND a ported barrel? That's going to lose a lot of blowback pressure and velocity. Never seen that before in my life, but I guess people will do anything these days 😌
Porting is holes in barrel, compensators have holes/ports after barrel, it's a simple as that. Muzzle brakes on rifles do the exact same function.. they reduce recoil and muzzle rise. Although brakes are technically comps, not ports, but it all does the same thing like you said, which is redirecting gasses
@@benjaminlanzotti1374The Sig and all the others are indeed comped.. If they are redirecting gasses upward/outwardto COMPENSATE for muzzle rise/recoil then it's comped.. The Sig just not your traditional threaded barrel compensator, but it's still doing the job. It's just using the slide for the comp/ports. Porting is compensating and compensators have ports.. It's all the same inherent function. You people have no clue what you're talking about lol
This crew is fun to watch...
Jason, give the S&W a 2nd try, and let us know.
That Afterburner is so good. It just is. I wouldn't own a plain Glock, but a Glock with an Afterburner, definitely.
I have a gen 4 Glock 19C, so they do come from the factory compensated. I also have an X macro comp and shoot it well.
Why not have the shield plus comp to compare to the Hellcat and Sig?
The P365 Spectre Comp is the same as the X Macro in every way except the grip holds 12 rds flush instead of 17. Point being, they do use the term comp.
Good experiment, Thank you for making this good video for comp compare carrygun. One thing, This video will be perfect if all of guns has a same condition. Glock has a flashlight that make more weight infront of the gun caused less recoil.
I love when you do multiple gun comparisons. Keep it up!
Great video!
You make a lot of great points, one specifically I think needs to be highlighted is everyone is a little different. A preference might not always reflect in enhanced performance in my experience, sometimes you shoot something you don’t prefer as much better. I shoot the g19 and X macro a lot and they’re my main two carry guns. And for the record I shoot the X macro a hair better for some reason unbeknownst to me. Really like them, I’m definitely intrigued by the new smith as well as some other new smiths! 😅
Another Banger
I love everyone’s insight & HONESTY
I prefer the compact.
This video is proof that YOU have to shoot the gun YOURSELF to see how it shoots FOR YOU! Everyone's opinion can and should be different cuz no two people are the same. Gun reviews are helpful but should be used as a reference point and not gospel. IMO they should have used a factory gen 4 19C instead of a gen 5 with an aftermarket comp added...ijs
Whats your thoughts on these comp carry guns possibly causing shrapnel injury when fired at retention/super close instances? Given these are carry guns, firing at very close range (to you as the shooter) would be a possibility in a given situation. Is the trade off with shooting flatter bigger than the chance of losing an eye in a gun fight? (all-be-it better than your life of course but still....carrying a non-comp/ported gun wouldn't have that chance).
Having the light on the Glock takes away some of the recoil!!! Not fair to the other 3!!
What about the Sig p365 with the radian afterburner ??
Sig has 3.1 inch barrel. Not an equivalent comparison. Show me any gun with 3.1 inch barrel that isn’t snappy. However, IMO best EDC on the planet for the money if your hands fit it and not bothered by a “snappy” firearm. 1.1 inch wide, perfect grip, weight and balance. with 17 round mag extension. Easy to conceal.
@@raymicciche8869 My comped 3.1 inch Shield isn't that snappy at all.. ;) The Shield is probably the smoothest shooting out of all the micros
I carry a 43x with a Harrington arms comp, runs flawlessly with oem spring
Good for you. Thanks for sharing.
What do yall mean by snappy? Like kick up, it going back to zero, ect?
Why not Sig Spectra Comp instead of the X-macro?
The s&w doesn’t have a pic rail does it?
The New S & W carry comp. is the SHIZZZZZ!!!! & I'm a GLOCKTARD.....FANBOY....GLOCKTARD..... GLOCK IS KING!!!!! but S & W outdone their self with this one.....IMO
My Glock 19C Gen 4 is all stock, over 12,500 rounds and I have zero complaints about it.
What about the shadow system cr920xp?
Does anyone know what glasses Kaya is wearing ? Thanks
Not going to lie calling the x macro snappy is kind of mind bowing to me.
I own one and for how small it is it shoots better than most full sizes and for being “not a real comp” it sure performs real damn close to Hellcat comp which is apparently “a real comp”
Take the light off the Glock to make a fair comparison. Cmon man.
🤣🤣🤣 yah, because the LIGHT was the only advantage of that decked-out custom comp Glock.
@ClassicFirearms You' re missing four guns that are compensated from the factory and 50 state compliant.
Shadow Systems Corp DR920P (G34), XR920P (G19x), MR920P (G19), CR920XP (G43X) I'd like to see any or all of these firearms in your next factory comped/ported head-to-head line-up. Please and thank you.
P.S. The MR920P is my daily carry in case you were wondering.
The DR920P is my favorite striker Fired Gun. Longer But very light.
Omg she's back. Second video in awhile. You gotta do those compatation videos again with the guy.😊 We miss you
I carry 1 of 2 depends its either my Cr920 Elite or my custom built P365
Should have used the shadow systems new comp instead of the glock aftermarket setup
They showing a lot of rapid firing but without showing the targets we can assume they are just spraying bullets everywhere, maybe one on target? Maybe?
What's the difference between the comp on the sig and the glock it's just a port built into the slide at the end of the barrell it's the exact same thing just the comp is integrated into the slide on the m&p and on the glock it's just an aftermarket attachment that's just put on the slide. But it don't see why that would change anything it's the exact same thing.
Should have included the Hellcat RDP also.
No P365 AXG legion?
Gotta be the hellcat pro comp
Awesome 👍 Please do a similar video with 45.
Compare the Hellcat pro comp vs the m&p shield plus carry comp!
I like my Hellcat Pro and was toiling over If should grab the comped version or just get mine ported
You need to try sig 365 with afterburner setup
Jason is trippen
You started off with MP which I'll watch a grande thumb rerun, good luck with that
Should have used the 19c glock it has a built in compensator
The Glock having a comp instead of port doesn’t compromise velocity 💯
Why no Shadow System comp pistol? Video Part 2
I wish the RDP got some love on these channels, gun is great for carry
I'm not surprised. I love S&W guns. They just work for me.
Shadow Systems CR920XP for hot summer days. Otherwise, XR920P.
M&P have really stepped up there game.
The smith and Wesson in the metal frame is an absolute tack driver.
I've had my eye on that Smith!
I’ll keep my sig macro-x comp. Favorite pistol I have. The fit in the hand is what I’m after. Compared to a hellcat not even a bit snappy.
Smith MnP always impressing 😮
Such a dumb policy that because you can't sell it you can't mention the guns, PSA Dagger Micro and CR920P deserve a spot. Do better CF.
These videos are just long commercials man
fn 509 cc edge should have been here…
Dude, they can’t mention every single gun there is out there. I’ll be honest with you, these are some of the biggest names and the most commonly mentioned. That’s probably why these particular firearms were chosen.
@@SirClicks. i don’t have anything against the channel i’m just a fn “fanboy” it’s personally my favorite brand i also figured there choices might have something to i with price i believe the fn is way more… and i don’t get the complaints about the dagger it’s almost a off brand glock
@@SirClicks. No if they don't sell it, they don't mention it. Ever.
No SS CR920XP???
I like Jason but I think he just burns through the mag as fast as possible. If he’s a great shot while doing that then by means keep ripping it. But I think his whole criteria is “how fast can I shoot it.”
The whole idea of a comped gun is to reduce muzzle flip and felt recoil and that is best demonstrated by rapid firing and at the minimum double taps. So he’s really the only one that did it correctly.
I’m not gonna lie I’m loving my shadow system MR920P
Haven't had the pleasure of shooting a MR920P yet but my CR920XP is nice!!!
@@kennyfogleman4042 once you get your hands on one you’re gonna love how flat it shoots.
If the ONLY thing we want to figure out is how well a gun is compensated and negates muzzle rise, grid paper and high speed cameras are all you'd need to measure which one does the job better eliminating all human variables.
Shadow systems mr920p instead of the glock 45.
A Glock with a afterburn/ ramjet and a light on it while everything else is stock is bs
And still lost
Should have done the shield plus comp
I wish im able to put my hands on these guns. I feel like the S&W is a beast