I like that Esmeralda and Quasi didn't end up together. It fits with the movie's themes. Both Quasi and Frollo want Esmeralda, but Frollo wants to possess her and would rather kill her than see her free of him, while Quasi just hopes that she might return his affection, but will let her go and stay friends with her if she doesn't. Quasi sees her as her own person, with her own free will, and he respects her, but he also somewhat idealizes her, literally referring to her as an angel. They wouldn't be on equal footing in a relationship. Frollo doesn't see her as a person, he sees her as either a thing he wants to own or a witch he must destroy, but not a human being. Phoebus is the only one who treats her as an equal, as nothing more or less than human, not an angel or demon. That's why them ending up together makes sense in my opinion. Thanks for coming to my TED talk.
Simply the point is that getting Esmeralda's love was never Quasi's dream, his dream was to live among other people, as everyone else. That was his dream, not Esmeralda. His dream is fulfilled at the end of the story so it's 100% an happy ending for him, he got what he always wanted. This movies is not a love story, there is love, but it's not about it. Plus a lot of people think that Quasi deserved Esmeralda because he suffered a lot, what's realistic about that? You're unlucky so you have to get a woman as a prize for it? It's just stupid, especially because Phoebus is absolutely the best person of the entire movie, he is generous, helps people, disrespects authority when they are evildoing even is it means death for him if he does, he never judges anyone according to their look or race (and he is the only relevant character who doesn't have any prejudice), only by their actions, always ready to step up to protect the innocents. Even without considering the look, Phoebus is absolutely the perfect man.
@@Kal911 *Is* he living 'as everyone else' does? There are several degrees of difference between 'not being lynched on sight', to 'being tolerated', to 'living like everyone else'. Why is Esmeralda the fixation of praise and adoration for so many of the viewers here, with only a cursory acknowledgement spared for Quasimodo? Not that you can't have it, but to such a disproportional extent that the supposed main protagonist becomes more of an afterthrought, which isn't a common trend for other Disney protagonists. Why are those same viewers also so keen on promoting the theory that Esmeralda did not reciprocate toward Quasimodo for 'putting her too much on a pedestal', while Phoebus saw her as an equal, when in reality they aren't really privy to Esmeralda's considerations? Even putting aside the sincerity behind that rosy presumption in and of itself, the closest we'd get to establishing the motivations of a fictional character would be through canon and the author's intent: Now, this whole popular culture surrounding the notion of "Don't put me on the pedestal" that most of the young viewers probably also heard from somewhere else the first time around is a relatively recent concept. Hunchback of Notre Dame, the source book, was written *more than 200 years ago*. At least half the fairy-tales or more mature romance tales form that period are *all about* putting the courted 'damsel' or 'lady' on a pedestal, with pompous and grandiose displays of affection, suitors saying how they'd fight the whole word for her, love her forever, etc, even during the first stages of meeting. So this cautionary dating advice from the 2000's about pedestals and equality definitely wasn't much of a thing back then, but you know what was? Not marrying deformed people. So these are all questions that need to be asked, which are apparently too uncomfortable for most people to ask themselves lest they realize that they've actually learned nothing from the movie's core lesson.
@@KaizerHiwatari I think the most substantiated theory, which could be deduced both from the film's explicit illustration itself a-la Occam's Razor and from psychoanalytical speculation is that it was *both*. Romantic love, distinctly from lust, is an extension of platonic love - with sexual attraction as an addendum. It's safe to say that you would feel compatible with and enjoy the company as well as the personality of your romantic love interest at least as much as anyone you would consider a friend. In order to discard what Quasimodo himself defines his sentiment as, it would be incumbent on the critic to present strong supporting evidence that Quasimodo does not truly feel a mental and physical attraction toward Esmeralda on top of a platonic connection. Employing all that we know about human psychology and sexuality to a young man who's been couped in a prison from which he can observe standard human affairs but never participate in them, I'd say the odds are heavily in favor of the classical interpretation: He felt the platonic love, gratitude, and the attraction, but Esmeralda only felt the former.
@@RukiyaReacts As French. It's scary and creepy. Frollo protrayed a villain in Real life. It's even frightening in French. "La Vie n'est toujours pas aussi rose"
What makes him really scary is that he doesn't have superpowers, he's not an over the top fun vilain like in most Disney movies. He's simply a man in a position of power, and he is VERY realistic. You can totally picture him doing what he does for ideological reasons, and in fact so many men through history do evil acts for the same type of reasons.
I think the reason why Esmarelda fell for Phoebus was because he treated her like a equal. Frollo treated her less than but I think Quasimodo treated her on a pedestal (I do believe they could've been great) but I think the main thing is is that Quasi had to learn how to love himself before anyone else (which is cheesy but it is true) I do like how they're all friends in the end because you can see they all care about each other :D
Please watch the second movie. I don't think this is really a spoiler since they say this in the movie description (I'm pretty sure), but they give Quasimodo a girlfriend@RukiyaReacts
Fun fact: Apparently the Romani (Gypsy) community had an issue with Esmeralda's red dancing dress. Apparently in their culture, red is not considered a lucky color. They associate it with misfortune, so they avoid having anything to do with red at all costs. Anything they have that has 'red' is usually an offshoot of the color, like pink or burgundy. It's a pretty dress no denying that and it looks good on her. Just thought I throw that bit in there.
maybe that was done on purpose as a way to foreshadow the misfortune that would befall the Romani people in the movie? Idk. I'm part Romani but I was never raised around the culture so I really have no idea exactly how disrespectful it is or if it is at all but if they did do it to foreshadow the misfortune that was yet to come then that's a pretty smart way to do it.
@@Furienna its still wrong obviously ppl dont know its a slur like only a few months ago i found that out. But educatign ppl and telling them how its wrong i dont think rukiya is gonna see this tho cuz its rlly uncommon for youtubers to look at comments on a video they made months ago
@@karilovecake2323 But we should be able to learn about history, even if some parts of it seem awful today. It is not like we can do a movie about Romani in the Medieval Era and pretend that they were called anything else...
13:40 One thing that is interesting is that Quasi is taught that the Romani people are bad, but Quasi himself is Romani as we know from the opening scene. Frollo is just instilling further self-hatred in Quasi.
I’ll keep it real, Frollo is THE most evil Disney villain of them all. Sure some villains look to world domination, control a person who is the object of their obsessions, or hell, just plain old greed, but Frollo? Sure the focus is that he wants Esmeralda in some sick twisted fantasy of owning her, but his magnum opus? Genocide of an entire race who he openly regards as sub human if not human at all. If that’s not the most evil thing a Disney villain could aspire to, I don’t know what would be.
think what makes frollo set up apart with other villains is he song hellfire isn't really being evil for the sake of evil it's moreso his frustration being unleashed and thrown to chaos compared to most other villian songs where it's "fun to be evil" @Rat the Ninja personally disagree with Governor Rafcliffe unlike other villians you just can't feel that intimidated by him and what's funny is pochuntus never actually meees him
Not only did Scar murder his brother and blamed it on his little nephew, but he wouldn't move the pride for reasons I don't understand even if they would starve to death. And there is also Shan Yu, who killed a whole village, and Rourke, who planned to let everybody in Atlantis die because of his greed. They are definitely up there with Frollo.
What I love about the Hunchback of Notte Dame… is Esmerelda. She’s my one of my top favorite Disney heroines. She’s beautiful, she’s free-spirited, she’s a total badass, she’s has a very certain way with men 😏😁… but most of all… she’s kind, good and pure.
I heard she was a Disney Princess originally, but they removed her, either because kids confused her with Jasmine, or because it was hard to market her when her film was so dark. At least she got some love in Disney's Midnight Masquerade .
No one talks about it but I must say the voice actor for a Clopin is incredible with the note he hits at the end of Bells of Notre Dame. I think it was a high D5 which is incredible for the adult male voice
Frollo is one of the darkest Disney villains simply because he doesn’t have the flair, the magic or the sidekicks of other baddies. He’s completely motivated by hatred and ignorance, so Frollo could exist in real life -Quasi is a completely underrated hero since he does things even though he knows there might not be a great reward, but because it’s the right thing to do Completely underrated movie
I read in the comments of a different reaction video that Phoebus was the best match for her in the movie. Phoebus saw and loved her for who she was. Frollo saw her as this evil seductress and Quasimodo put her on a pedestal and saw her as an angel. So Neither of them loved her (or obsessed for frollo) or saw her as an equal. Whether it be putting her above them (Quasimodo) or below them (Frollo).
@@RukiyaReacts it’s okay everybody makes mistakes, and I like the mistakes that I made. Most of them make me laugh, cry, serious, strong, learn, or even making me relax. Mistakes are a part what makes you into you.
@@RukiyaReacts Personally I don't really think there's racism in this movie. Back then, gypsies were notorious for being bands of cut throats and thieves (as we see in the Court of Miracles; heck, the movie begins with gypsies trying to smuggle themselves into Paris illegally) Because they lived outside the law, they were taking food and other goods that would be distributed among law abiding citizens, and in order to compensate importing additional goods that the citizens would need, the officials would raise taxes, which of course, gypsies would not pay. Then you have gypsies who were believed to be practitioners of black magic and conjurings aka witchcraft; something that most people were highly afraid of back then. In the musical, Frollo had a brother named Jehan; both of whom grew up as orphans who were taken in by Notre Dame. But Jehan was lured away by a gypsy girl and forsook the church in exchange for a life living in shallow drunken stupor that ultimately resulted in his death. So technically Frollo's hatred of gypsies stems not out of racial prejudice, but out of justified intolerance.
@@patrioticjustice9040 Have you ever considered that people didn't steal because out of malice. Sometimes they do desperate things in order to provide for their loved ones. And no racism? You're capping.
@@summerrose8110 And what? Gypsies couldn't learn an honest trade? They couldn't learn to farm, hunt, trade? It doesn't matter if you're stealing to feed your family if you're stealing from a family that is just as in a bleak situation as yours. And gypsy refers to a nomadic person, not really specific to a certain race. So again I say, technically not racist. It's like trying to say you're racist for hating a gang, yet that gang is comprised of people from multiple cultures.
What makes a monster and what makes a man... Kinda the theme of the movie. Kinda cool to see Disney embrace concepts like "physical beauty doesn't necessarily equal goodness. And looking different from the stereotypical concept of "what a person should look like" doesn't mean you're evil. Good on ya, Disney. It takes balls to break free from the "beauty equals goodness equals beauty," trope.
@@RukiyaReacts for me it's way more disturbing. Also, there are characters that don't appear in the movie. Btw, did you know that the names of the male gargoyles make a clear refference to the author of "Notre Dame de Paris" (the original work), Victor Hugo?
@@RukiyaReacts Huge spoilers for the real story. But to be quick, Frollo is a priest (if I remember well), he treated Quasimodo way better in the book but ended the same killed by him because of his obsession for Esmeralda. Phoebus is a bastard, fiancé to Fleur-de-Lys, he only want to spend time with Esmeralda for her body. Esmeralda is hanged because she's accused of bewitching Phoebus and refused Frollo's ""love"". Quasimodo died of hunger close to her body in a crypt. Not the most joyful end but at least it help saved Notre-Dame so...
If you loved this movie then I definitely recommend you The Prince of Egypt. Even though it's based on the religious story of Moses, both religious and non religious people can enjoy (or suffer with) this movie. If you were mindblown by this soundtrack, wait til you watch The Prince of Egypt (Stephen Swchartz at the songs, who also took part in The Hunchback, and Hans Zimmer at the ost). That movie also has amazing animation (it took 2 years to animate what it may be the most famous thing that Moses did), very interesting characters (above all the relationship between the protagonidt and antagonist) that show their humanity, very sad story...
The fact that Frollos song “Hellfire” is so different than other villains songs is because it’s an I want song. Which is normal reserved for the protagonist not the antagonist.
Normally the villain gets an “I am” song (which is very narcissistic of them) but since Frollo’s is an “I want” song, it lures you into his dark and twisted mind and makes you see just how messed up he is.
My favorite low-key part of this movie that doesn't get so much attention is how Quasimodo doesn't end up with Esmerelda. You really see this when he puts her hand and Phoebus's together. I love that Quasi doesn't "get" her for a few reasons. Women are people and "getting" one shouldn't be a reward for the hero. He sees what there is between her and Phoebus and her, and his approval really caps off their bromance nicely. And ending a note of friendship between him and Esmerelda seems important considering how many people still (ridiculously) think men and women somehow can't just be good friends. All of this is packed into a really cute, wholesome moment between this couple and their pal. BTW in my mind, it is now officially called a "trambone." 8)
Tony Jay, who was the voice of Frollo, was also the voice of D'Arque from "Beauty & the Beast" and Sher Khan in "The Jungle Book". His voice was on a whole new level. Only voice comes close is Patrick Page, who preformed as Frollo in the short-lived Broadway "Hunchback of Notre Dame", and was the original Hades of Broadway's "Hadestown".
Tony Jay was absolutely NOT the voice of Sher Khan in Disney’s “The Jungle Book”. That was George Saunders. You are correct about him being the voice of Mssr. D’Arque…we literally used his audition reading for the production, it was so good.
To be fair, their voices are pretty similar. Tony was also the Voice of Toyota for a few years in the 90’s, narrating all the Toyota commercials in his American accent. He was a magnificent talent and a really nice guy.
@@gtrous665 AH HA! I knew it! Right, just checked, Tony Jay DID voice Sher Khan... in "TaleSpin" and the direct-to-DVD Jungle Book sequel. But he was, at one point, the successor to George Saunders. That's what mixed me up!
Frollo is actually my favorite Disney villain because he’s so human. Not only does he crave power and commit suicide (like every other Disney villain) but he also feels lust.
I love this movie. Recently rewatched it as an adult. There is some heavy themes. The real story is so much darker it's heartbreaking.. The Deformed being ostracized along with the Roma (gypsies) and being killed/executed in genocide. Esmeralda and Quasi were switched at birth. Her real name is Agnes. Numerous men "love" her. Quasi kidnaps her and falls for her. Phoebes rescues her and she becomes smitten with him but he is engaged and only wants her as a bootycall. Frollo, in a rage calls for her execution. Esmeralda sadly ends up executed even though quasi initially saved her. Quasi throws frollo over the edge when he sees him smiling cruelly as she hangs. Quasimodo ends up laying next to esmeralda corpse in a mass grave. Their bodies become intertwined. Years later an excavation crew attempts to pry them apart and Quasimodo turns to dust. Tragic 😥 I must say I like the direction Disney went with it much better.
the stage version of this follows the original story a bit more, then! (minus quasi kidnapping her, and phoebus is generally similar to the movie version but less of a "knight in shining armor" type, but he does care for esmerelda and still follows the movie by refusing to murder innocents and helps save her etc) i watched a recording of the stage musical first before watching the movie (i either had never watched the movie before or it had been so long i can't remember if i'd watched it) and was honestly shocked at how dark the ending was - i figured they must've taken liberties or taken from another version of the story rather than the film. they also made quasi hard of hearing/partially deaf which is a nice touch as it's more realistic to how someone spending 20 years so close to loud bells. it follows a lot of the same beats as the movie with some elements from the original story and some new backstory for frollo and quasi thrown in - in the stage musical, quasi is frollo's nephew, the son of his estranged brother and a gypsy woman and frollo reluctantly takes him in after his brother dies despite finding him repulsive. they make frollo less of a irredeemable character and have him actually being more religious and caring about the rules of the church etc (they also show him actually kind of caring abt quasi, at least a little bit - there's still ). at the end, quasi initially saves esmerelda and claims sanctuary in the cathedral, but then esmeralda dies (i believe it's meant to be from smoke inhalation), and quasi blames frollo and throws him off the cathedral. it's a much more sadder and tragic ending as none of the characters get the happier ending we see in the film.
"I just love her! I want to be her!" You certainly got the look Rukiya 😍 All you need is a little 🐐 Love those editor-Rukiya interjections 🤣🤣🤣 Notre Dame stands out to me not only as a beautiful work of animation and song, but also as a passable adaptation of a very dark, very dense novel into something for children without losing the themes of anti-bigotry and religious hypocrisy. Frollo forgets the teachings of a certain gentleman in the Bible who recommends plucking out one's own eye rather than lusting... or does he not listen to JC?
Awe thank you!!🥰🥰 I’ll dress up my cat like a Lil goat to complete the cosplay haha!😂 I haven't read the novel but I agree that Disney handled those topics so well in this film. As I child I didn't notice the themes but now I can appreciate it as an adult. 🥰
The relationship between Quasi and Frollo is actually very similar to Rapunzel and Mother Gothel (tho she is not like afraid of her), even the song Mother Knows Best is very reminiscent of Frollo's song he sand to Quasi at the beginning!
Pocahontas, Mulan, and Hunchback were great films that addressed heavy themes while still being soaring, memorable musicals. I really hope the live-action Hunchback leans more into Disney's version than the novel, personally.
@@RukiyaReacts Yep! Though the last news we heard of it was last year. It's still going to be a musical, and to my understanding it's going to star Josh Gad from Disney's Frozen.
@@RukiyaReacts They better not make a live action Hunchback of Notre Dame. After that Mulan live action fiasco, Disney is on thin ice fucking with classics in order to sell out.
@@summerrose8110 same for Pocahontas. I’m 99% sure it would be “historically accurate” 🙄 considering how much of a complete mess Mulan was, including after Shang was originally not even going to be in it, but after a ton of fans being royally pissed about it chose to make Shang a complete douche who upon learning Mulan is actually a woman “loves” her… Anyways I don’t want a live Pocahontas at all UNLESS its the ‘95 Disney story more or less. Otherwise, if it is “historically correct” call it by her historically correct birth name MATOAKA. Otherwise its gonna get the exact same reaction the abysmal sequel received, a minority of descendants and history nerds not hating it as much and the majority beyond pissed and crucifying it for absolutely tearing the original love story apart
You know, a gargoyle's symbolism is to scare away evil spirits and demons so Frollo being scared of one is very fitting. I always imagined the gargoyle being like: "Oh no, not this bitch on MY Notre Dame you're going to a new home, IN HELL!" Also I've always wondered if Frollo is schizophrenic, I mean all those hallucinations during the Hellfire song, makes you think.
So about Quasimodo’s name… He was named that because Archdeacon Frollo (he was a priest in the original) “found” him on the day of the Quasimodo, or the Sunday after Easter. It was named that because it was almost (quasi) the norm (modo). It was doubly ironic since Frollo clearly also meant it because Quasimodo was “almost the norm of a man”.
Also, unbeknownst to most, Frollo was also a practicing alchemist, which especially then was seen as evil and against God’s teachings. Make of that what you will.
Something interesting I heard, during Hellfire with that little break of someone telling Frollo that Esmerelda escaped That was like God answering his prayers, before Frollo was deadset on either killing her or having her, he asked for her to disappear. The white light the guard came in with could be seen as "heavenly light" as the guard basically TELLS frollo "She's gone, let it go"
I love this movie. I seriously think this movie is underrated and it’s my favorite Disney movie of all time. There’s a lot of stuff I love in this movie. I feel as though Quasimodo is the most relatable Disney protagonist ever because there’s kids who are often shut indoors who can relate to him. Frollo is an amazing villain and I love how they made him so complex. The music overall is amazing and probably the best Disney soundtrack ever. This movie gets a 9/10 for me
This is a film I saw regularly as a child and have found a new appreciation for as I've gotten older, especially after 5 semesters of Latin in college. The music is also some of the best of the Disney Renaissance. •Quasimodo-Patron Saint of the Friend Zone •I looked it up; in France, serfdom did not end until 1789, when the feudal rights of the French nobility were abolished as part of the French Revolution. This film is set in the 15th Century. •Note that most Romani are actually Catholic too. •Prior to theaters, public torture/execution was entertainment, especially in medieval times. •Yes, Notre Dame is a church and one of the most famous cathedrals in the world. Even in the opening song, they say its bells are the soul of Paris. •In times when illiteracy was high, the stained glass was meant to help teach people the stories of the Bible. And yes, it is beautiful. •He has, but not with someone on his back. •Hellfire is one of the best villain songs in the Disney canon and one of Disney's darkest. •In French literature, the Court of Miracles was a slum in Paris, so named because of beggars who fakes being blind or lame to try to get money from people. •Actually, he's not; he knew if he told Quasimodo about his attack, that Quasimodo would seek out the Court of Miracles, so he followed Quasimodo and Phoebus. Quasimodo unintentially lead Frollo there. •He's an archdeacon. •In the book, the ending is a lot darker. •"And He shall smite the wicked and plunge them into the fiery pit." - not a direct quote from the Bible. •"I will not say 'do not weep,' for not all tears are an evil." - Gandalf the White
Fact: Quasimodo doesn’t mean ‘half-formed’, it’s the first Monday after Easter Sunday. I think this is a self joke Quasimodo tells Esmerelda when they first meet in the original book, it was definitely in one of the live action films though, but I can’t remember which one 🤣
Awwww that one was my favorite Disney movie when I was a kid back there in late 90s. I adored that so much that read the original book of Hugo and cried a lot because it wasn’t like in the movie 🥲 it was my first childhood trauma. But I still rewatch this sometimes and the music, holy cow, the music! Thank you for the vid! Also you’re comments after are interesting, that’s what some other reactors videos really lack
I remember being distressed as a kid when they tied Quasi down and the tint changed to red. Also, "fun fact," there's a fan theory that Frollo sells his soul during Hellfire, with the red choir representing the last vestiges of his conscience burning away.
this film's got so much weight to it and stirs up so much pure hatred for such an insidious villain such as frollo, and it's always satisfying to see other people feel that way too! WRT quasi not unaliving frollo himself: disney's got an unspoken rule in its storytelling that the protagonists aren't ever allowed to end the villains, they always have to do it to themselves 😩 that's why the majority of disney villains just fall to their death
you will be pleased to know, quasi does unalive frollo in the original story, as well as in the stage musical bc esmeralda ends up dying because of frollo's actions. i believe the way she dies is different in both - hanging in the original and smoke inhalation after quasi "saves" her from being burned at the stake in the stage musical - though the stage musical does paint frollo in a slightly more sympathetic light (while still remaining a disgusting human being and quasi 100% deserved the right to unalive him at the end)
11:53 I kind of had to laugh a bit because Notre Dame is one of the most well renowned Catholic Churches out there, so yes a movie titled the Hunchback of Notre Dame is indeed going to take place in a church. If you legit didn’t know that’s fine, I just think it’s pretty funny. Also great reactions I enjoyed the video
To be fair, it was the original Hunchback novel that made Notre Dame what it is today. It was falling into disrepair and might have been torn down. Then Victor Hugo brought attention to it in his novel and people started to campaign to preserve & restore it.
Hunchback of Notre Dame is my favorite Disney movie. I always loved how they subtly showed Quasi's super strength he acquired from a lifetime of ringing those bells. Like when he lifted Pheobus off the ground with one hand while Pheobus was still in his full plate armor, or when he tossed the stone cover of the crypt as if it was a piece of paper. That its subtle because he's been mentally and probably physically abused his whole life to be timid. That he had the metaphorical & literal strength all along when he starts getting away from Frollo. This movie is so underrated in my opinion and needs more love. The music of this movie is top tier and more people need to listen to it. Quasi's "I Want" song should be among the top ten of Disney I Want songs. :) I could go on and on about this movie.
I was a Quasimodo and Esmeralda Stan as a kid! I had a Quasimodo plushie that I took everywhere with me and an Esmeralda Barbie doll! I even went as Esmeralda one year for Halloween and I thought her purple Gypsy dress was the prettiest thing! It might have been where I got my life of off-shoulder sleeves, haha!
There's a gentleman on Tik-Tok that said it concisely, " if you are incapable of great violence you're not peaceful you're harmless, know the difference." He then went on to say that basically people who are peaceful or not that way simply because they lack any understanding of what is going on but is because they have mastered themselves so much so that anyone who seeks to undo their peace will basically be cut out from their lives any which way possible even if it means being violent for self-protection. Or protection of those you deeply care about.
You have a lot of poetic insight, it's really cool to see how you talk about the symbolic side of the movie. You seem very wise, and actually remind me of Esmeralda!
If you haven’t seen mega mind I would recommend it. It’s a hidden gem that did get over shadowed by Despicable Me. And a lot of people are rediscovering it and have enjoyed it immensely
May I request you to watch Atlantis? It's greatly underrated!! You would LOVE Milo and Kida! And another great one is The Prince of Egypt! The soundtrack is a ✨ masterpiece ✨ they went HARD on that movie, animation and all!!
@@RukiyaReacts YAAASSSS ✨✨ I'll look forward to it!! Also you are waaay too pretty....it's criminal and I'm low-key jealous 😂 I love your style too! Alright I'm done- I'm leavin-
@@RukiyaReacts would you be willing to do Pocahontas?? I feel she’s so amazing but just as underrated as Esmerelda despite being an official Disney princess
Rukiya, thanks so much for reacting to this Disney version of Hunchback Of Notre Dame. Honestly, I can see why it deviated from the book in so many ways. Seeing as the novel was much darker, I can see why they made the changes for this film that they did. Honestly, Hunchback Of Notre Dame is in my top ten favorite Disney animated films. I loved the songs, the animation, and the characters. I’m sad that many people bash on the gargoyles. I mean for crying out loud, they seemed to help out with Quasimodo’s character arc, especially Laverne. My favorite songs of this film were especially “God Help The Outcast,” Heaven’s Light/Hellfire,” “The Court Of Miracles,” and “Someday.” Does part of me have mixed feelings about Esmeralda marrying Phoebus instead of Quasimodo? Yes! Still, I can see why the writers went that route, especially with the whole riddle about who the monster is, and who the man is. I also felt like Hunchback Of Notre Dame had some really good symbolism, including when Quasimodo , and his chains symbolizing not only breaking free of Frollo, but maybe even his jealousy towards people like Phoebus, you know? And how could we not mention how symbolic Frollo’s death was, you know? Oh, and one other thing that I loved was how we had people like Frollo who had the legalistic attitude of Christianity, while people such as the Archdeacon had the love, grace, and mercy side of Christianity. And there are a couple things that I’d like to mention. One, I liked how Quasimodo soared Frollo’s life when one, he threw Frollo’s sword on the ground, and two, how he held onto Frollo’s cape, and saved his life once again. Yes, Frollo was clearly an evil man. Still, I liked how when Quasimodo did both of those things, he showed that he still loved , and cared for Frollo, and that he basically wasn’t going to repay Frollo evil for evil, but rather repay Frollo evil with good. That is despite Frollo still choosing to remain evil, and getting judged as a result. Finally, I think it’s cool that Kirk Wise, and Gary Trousdale directed 1991’s Beauty & The Beast, this 1996 film, The Hunchback Of Notre Dame, and 2001’s Atlantis: The Lost Empire. Speaking of which, I hope you react to those two fairly soon as well. Well, thanks again for reacting to this version of The Hunchback Of Notre Dame!
I loved your reaction to this movie! I've always loved the moment just after he breaks free of the chains where he stands, and you watch the chains slink off of him. It's the one shot in the whole movie where Quasimodo actually looks monstrous and ugly, and I feel like it was intentional on the part of the animators because it's the precise moment that he is finally claiming his power and his identity. It's like he's thinking, "If you want to call me a monster, then fine. You better be ready for me to terrify you."
@Taje Ono What an asshole thing to say. When Quasimodo breaks his chains, he not only broke the physical ones, but the mental chains that Frollo put him on. You calling him ugly tells me how shallow you are and missed the point of this film.
This is one of if not my absolute favorite Disney films so I am sorry for the long comment. It always makes me cry at least twice, the scene where Quasi is tied down and tortured at the festival and then the scene at the end where he holds her over his head and yells sanctuary. Esmeralda will always be my favorite Disney leading lady and I have told myself for years that the only reason she isn't an official "disney princess" for merch is because she's actually a Queen. I also have to say I think this film was rather gutsy for Disney. The main villain in a man of the church. He was elected as a Judge but during Hellfire you hear a soldier call him Minister. His entire villain song (one of the best villain songs disney's ever done) was a prayer. He was praying. His villainy is also realistic. People like him have and still do exist. Racist, sexist, ableist, xenophobic people who use their faith to excuse their hatred, use their faith to point blame onto others. Example, he was only committing the sin of lust because of Esmeralda's "spell" and the only way to make it right was to purify her (she becomes his) or kill her to break said spell. Also, there was a secondary villain. Society as a whole. He was an ELECTED official. Frollo forbid him from going to the festival and when Quasi went... it wasn't Frollo who tortured him. He didn't stop it but he didn't start it or even participate. That was the crowd. That was everyone around him laughing along. There's also so much morbid humor in the Court of Miracles song (real place btw with a really interesting history)) where the people Quasi & Phoebus are trying to save, without listening, without thinking, without questioning, jump to conclusions and are about to kill them with no questions asked. Like the lyrics of that song "We like to get the trial over with quickly because it's the sentence that's really the fun" and "But the dead don't talk, So you won't be around to reveal what you've found." or "here in the court of miracles where it's a miracle if you get out alive".... these are sung by the good guy side characters... the main singer is the frickin narrator As for Quasi not getting the girl, I actually like that. He didn't see Esmeralda as a person fully. He saw her more like an angel, a savior, the first person who showed him genuine kindness. He idolized her, while Frollo objectified her. Phoebus (in this film, not the book, book phoebus was an ass, but so was everyone) treated her more like a person. I didn't like the sequel but I'm glad he found love that made more sense and felt more real. I don't think in this film, he would have been ready to have real romantic feelings that are coming from a healthy place quite yet. I also appreciated how he handled it. He didn't get mad at her. He felt his pain, had a moment here or there of annoyance but he still helped her, still cherished her friendship because that was what was most important to him. I also think that, while the writers didnt intend him to be, I think the Priest is also a villain. Not a malicious one but he is responsible for Quasi having been isolated, emotionally manipulated and abused all his life. In WHAT WORLD does something think it is okay to punish a man, for trying to throw a baby down a well after murdering his mother, by forcing him to raise said baby. THEN allowing him to isolate the baby in the towers the priest controls. ANd THEN doesnt even check in!!! There's no indication that the Priest ever went to visit Quasi or invited him down to mass. Never. In fact it is shown he's explicitly not supposed to come down to church service. Not a fan. No.
(Sorry for this long reply, but anyway) I always thought about the same thing you said in the last paragraph. I guess he’s definitely meant to be a good character, it’s just that they needed to find a way to make a good priest at Notre Dame (for the sake of not misleading people into viewing all Christian leaders in a negative light) while also having a reason that Frollo would adopt Quasimodo and a dramatic “stop!” scene play out. I think the creators might have considered having Frollo decide not to kill the baby without prompting from another character, but that would have risked making Frollo look moreso like he might have a glimmer of goodness which is probably something they wanted to avoid. For “children’s” movies especially (although this is arguably not a children’s movie) you want to make the people committing horrific acts as totally evil as possible, because making them a little bit merciful can upset people since it might lead to too much audience empathizing. For children evil is made evil and good is good, usually as little mixing as possible is done. If they are to make the live action more complex and even less kid-friendly in the writing (which I would love, if done right) then maybe they *could* have Frollo decide on his own to spare Quasimodo. Maybe a beam of light with a sudden gust of wind suddenly appears or something, leading to a Hellish statue (reminds him of the risk of Hell) and then his eyes glance upwards towards the Godly eyes of Notre Dame. But anyway yeah when you actually think about the situation more, the priest seems like a cold idiot for thinking it’s a good idea for evil Frollo to raise him and to also not really check up on him in life or anything, like you said. But I just ignore that because like I mentioned, I feel like him being at the Notre Dame and saying “stop!” and everything was necessary for reasons of not offending or misleading the audience to dislike Christianity. Because it’s worse look for Christianity if you have only an evil Christian leader without any Christian leader in the movie who shows goodness, than if you have both the evil and the good Christian leaders, and the Christian leader just made a stupid recommendation you’re supposed to ignore, and he is just kind of not involved so much in helping out Quasimodo, which you’re also supposed to ignore for plot reasons.
15:20 The hooded figures are chanting "mea culpa" (latin for "my fault") and "mea maxima culpa" (Latin for "my most grievous fault"), so even Frollo's own subconscious doesn't buy his BS
Esmeralda is my favorite Disney girl because she is kind, warm harted, bedass, gorgeous and so graceful are every of her moves. Also she is a socially conscious character, and I love her song a lot. I am pretty curious who will they cast for the live action movie. I hope they stick to the plot of the Disney version.
Omg I just discovered you less than 24hrs ago and I've been bingeing your videos. Your commentary is hilarious and you watch actual gems not just popular films. Thank you and can't wait for my first notification from your channel ❣
I remember Tony Jay, the voice actor for Frollo, saying that the Hellfire song took a lot out of him to perform. I wish there was a live video recording of him performing it somewhere out there- I loved that song so much when I first watched the movie, I asked my mom to rewind the scene. XD The Archdeacon thought that Frollo would grow to be a better person by raising a child, but he was very mistaken. Also, if you want to see Quasimodo unaliving Frollo, read the original book. =D
If you are unsatisfied with the ending of the movie with Frollo I'd recommend watching the Hunchback of Notre Dame musical, the La Jolla production is here on youtube and it is the Disney version but a bit darker and truer to the plot beats of the novel.
I think you would enjoy The Prince of Egypt, they have incredible music and animation in that movie. I’ve loved it since I was a kid. Thank you for the video girl, enjoy your reactions 💕
I had almost forgotten how dark this movie was as a child, and it's still got some pretty disturbing and chilling parts to it that make my skin crawl, more especially how well-written Judge Frollo was as the most evil man ALIVE!!! But I still like the way Quasimodo comes out of his own shell and learns to love himself positively, and Esmeralda is still just as fine, brave, kind, fearless, and badass as she was the first time I saw her. Don't you worry Rukiya, I won't make a move on your girl Esmeralda 😂😀😉 But maybe you won't mind if I could try my best with you... 😘😉❤️❤️☺️
Even til this day this movie still stands up. Sadly though if it were written today you'd have a bunch of people calling it woke garbage just because thats what they do now
Absolutely agree. You could not make this movie today - I say that with full intentional irony (because that’s what people say about comedy, movies like Blazing Saddles, whatever) But the character of Frollo would offend so many people. Ironically at least one of the people who make fun of things being too woke.
In my grade twelve year, I was in a production of Hunchback (the stage play) and the vocals were intense but a lot of fun. Also, a lot more darkness than in this movie (obviously, Disney would leave out some of the more not child friendly things). SPOILER FOR STAGE PLAY I'm sure others have probably commented this before but in the show, Quasimodo is actually Frollo's nephew who was born after the brother ran away from the church to live with the Romani (Gypsies). Also at the end of the theatre production, Esmeralda actually dies...
i always thought the gargoyles were all in Quasys imagination. sure they do stuff when hes not around but I had imaginary friends as a kid and they got up to all sorts whilst I was in school
I would recommend you listen to the soundtrack of the actual play of the hunchback of Notre dame. Just the soundtrack alone will tell you in their songs the background of Frollo, the song tambourine which is Esmeralda’s songs describing how she welcomes her guests in her performances, the song named “esmeralda” which is a song describing how the whole town wants to kill her and at the same time the three different perspectives of Frollo, Quasi and Phoebus, AND as well the song that Quasi sings about being chained up it’s called something like “ Man of stone “. Really good music and really good awesome background story to all of these characters.
Frolo: "And he shall smite the wicked and plunge them into the fiery pit!" God: Well, if you insist... The thing about the idea of Quasimodo un-aliving Frolo is that Disney is always very careful not to have the heroes commit flat-out murder, with very few exceptions. The dwarves don't kill the evil queen. A random lightning bolt makes her fall off a cliff. Simba doesn't kill Scar. The hyenas do. Beast doesn't intentionally kill Gaston, he just thrashes when he gets stabbed and Gaston falls. Tarzan doesn't kill Clayton. His dumb @$$ accidentally hangs himself, etc. The only exceptions that I can think of are Prince Philip vs. Maleficent, and Prince Eric vs. Ursula. (Before you guys come at me too hard, it's almost 1 am, I'm tired, and I'm not racking my brain too hard over this. Feel free to add more examples if you want but be nice) Point is, Disney tries not to have the heroes kill the villains because that's part of what separates them FROM the villains.
It can be as cultural appropriation btw it’s Romani culture and people always used as hallowe’en costume but when they actually wear it we are judge for wearing our culture so it’s not the best idea
Fun fact: Frollo’s last words, “And he shall smight the wicked and plunge them into the fiery pit.” are a pretty loose adaptation of Isaiah 11:4 in the Bible. And before anyone says it, yes I know I’m named after that chapter.
I just love how Rukiya is both an Esmeralda simp and Frollo hater through the entire vid! 🤣😭 I'mma follow instantly!☺️✨♥️ Also Funfact! Frollo's horse is apparently called "Snowball", which is kinda surprising.
Great I can stay xD 2 different Esmeralda dolls (one regular dress, one red dress) 4 tamborines, 1 self made Esmeralda styled dress (my mom is a jewel to sew this....she hates sewing xD) combine all of that and you have little 6 year old me dancing around and terrorizing our dog that had to be the goat xD xD I miss childhood xD
14:43 I used to listen to this song on repeat on RUclips as a literal CHILD like it was a good song (it had a sick instrumental) but I never understood what the lyrics meant. But as a teenager, almost an adult, I get it now...
I mean, in the original novel (and the broadway version) he is actually the arch deacon rather than a judge that he is in the movie, so it would be correct to say divine right ;)
that's the Disney ending. Victor Hugo ending is quite different. Frollo hangs Esmeralda, Quasimodo throws him of the roof of Notre-Dame in rage, found Esmerald's body and goes to hidding and dies of starvation holding her. Years later, an excavation founds the intertwined skeletons and, when they try to remove them, they crumble to dust.
Fun fact about this movie: Ezmeralda is only 15 years old. Just 1 year older than Snow White. Also, Here is the thing that happens in original book: Ezmeralda was afraid of Quasimodo cause of the way he looked but he still loved her and so did Frollo of course. But when Frollo could not have her, he actually manage to kill her and then years pass and when a person visit Ezmeralda’s grave, they noticed another skeleton hugging her and that was Quasimodo. When she died, he could not live without her, so he crawl into her grave, hugged her corpse and stayed like that until he died. So to summarize: the book is dark but memorable.
(This information about Hellfire isn't mine): First of all, Frollo doesn't speak or sing to God, or Christ, but to Virgin Mary. Why? Because, in the first scene that Clopin sings about, when the archdeacon points out the statues, Frollo focuses above all in Virgin Mary. Then, a thunder resonantes, and for a very short time (and almost invisible), Virgin Mary opens his eyes and stares at him like saying "You've done a bad thing". Also, the Cathedral's name is "Notre Dame", which means "Our Lady" so... Secondly, now focusing on Hellfire, the dark blue colour simbolizes good, and Heaven. The red colour, Hell. That is why you see a big Cross above the chimney, but the fire's red light doesn't reach it, it's dark blue. Also, Frollo wants to be "pious" as those cardinals dressed in red, who are judging him ("Mea culpa"/"My fault"). But, as his actions aren't pious, in the end, when he positions himself against the wall, forming a very little cross ( which is very little compared to the shadows of the good cardinals and Saints that ascend to the blue side ) he stays in the red side. The scene when the soldier appears to tell Frollo that Esmeralda is gone. That solider is surrounded by dark blue colour. He's an angel who comes to give him an ultimatum: "leave her and come with me, or continue and you're doomed.
I like that Esmeralda and Quasi didn't end up together. It fits with the movie's themes. Both Quasi and Frollo want Esmeralda, but Frollo wants to possess her and would rather kill her than see her free of him, while Quasi just hopes that she might return his affection, but will let her go and stay friends with her if she doesn't. Quasi sees her as her own person, with her own free will, and he respects her, but he also somewhat idealizes her, literally referring to her as an angel. They wouldn't be on equal footing in a relationship. Frollo doesn't see her as a person, he sees her as either a thing he wants to own or a witch he must destroy, but not a human being. Phoebus is the only one who treats her as an equal, as nothing more or less than human, not an angel or demon. That's why them ending up together makes sense in my opinion. Thanks for coming to my TED talk.
Wow, that’s a really good point! Thank you for sharing your TED Talk haha❤️
FACTS I never thought of it like that
Simply the point is that getting Esmeralda's love was never Quasi's dream, his dream was to live among other people, as everyone else. That was his dream, not Esmeralda. His dream is fulfilled at the end of the story so it's 100% an happy ending for him, he got what he always wanted. This movies is not a love story, there is love, but it's not about it.
Plus a lot of people think that Quasi deserved Esmeralda because he suffered a lot, what's realistic about that? You're unlucky so you have to get a woman as a prize for it? It's just stupid, especially because Phoebus is absolutely the best person of the entire movie, he is generous, helps people, disrespects authority when they are evildoing even is it means death for him if he does, he never judges anyone according to their look or race (and he is the only relevant character who doesn't have any prejudice), only by their actions, always ready to step up to protect the innocents. Even without considering the look, Phoebus is absolutely the perfect man.
@@Kal911 *Is* he living 'as everyone else' does? There are several degrees of difference between 'not being lynched on sight', to 'being tolerated', to 'living like everyone else'. Why is Esmeralda the fixation of praise and adoration for so many of the viewers here, with only a cursory acknowledgement spared for Quasimodo? Not that you can't have it, but to such a disproportional extent that the supposed main protagonist becomes more of an afterthrought, which isn't a common trend for other Disney protagonists.
Why are those same viewers also so keen on promoting the theory that Esmeralda did not reciprocate toward Quasimodo for 'putting her too much on a pedestal', while Phoebus saw her as an equal, when in reality they aren't really privy to Esmeralda's considerations? Even putting aside the sincerity behind that rosy presumption in and of itself, the closest we'd get to establishing the motivations of a fictional character would be through canon and the author's intent:
Now, this whole popular culture surrounding the notion of "Don't put me on the pedestal" that most of the young viewers probably also heard from somewhere else the first time around is a relatively recent concept. Hunchback of Notre Dame, the source book, was written *more than 200 years ago*. At least half the fairy-tales or more mature romance tales form that period are *all about* putting the courted 'damsel' or 'lady' on a pedestal, with pompous and grandiose displays of affection, suitors saying how they'd fight the whole word for her, love her forever, etc, even during the first stages of meeting.
So this cautionary dating advice from the 2000's about pedestals and equality definitely wasn't much of a thing back then, but you know what was? Not marrying deformed people. So these are all questions that need to be asked, which are apparently too uncomfortable for most people to ask themselves lest they realize that they've actually learned nothing from the movie's core lesson.
@@KaizerHiwatari I think the most substantiated theory, which could be deduced both from the film's explicit illustration itself a-la Occam's Razor and from psychoanalytical speculation is that it was *both*. Romantic love, distinctly from lust, is an extension of platonic love - with sexual attraction as an addendum. It's safe to say that you would feel compatible with and enjoy the company as well as the personality of your romantic love interest at least as much as anyone you would consider a friend.
In order to discard what Quasimodo himself defines his sentiment as, it would be incumbent on the critic to present strong supporting evidence that Quasimodo does not truly feel a mental and physical attraction toward Esmeralda on top of a platonic connection. Employing all that we know about human psychology and sexuality to a young man who's been couped in a prison from which he can observe standard human affairs but never participate in them, I'd say the odds are heavily in favor of the classical interpretation: He felt the platonic love, gratitude, and the attraction, but Esmeralda only felt the former.
The thing about Frollo what makes him scary is that there is people like him in real life.
And the fact that he truly believes he’s just, righteous, good, even Saintly 🙈🙉🙊
It's beyond scary 🫣
@@RukiyaReacts As French. It's scary and creepy. Frollo protrayed a villain in Real life.
It's even frightening in French.
"La Vie n'est toujours pas aussi rose"
What makes him really scary is that he doesn't have superpowers, he's not an over the top fun vilain like in most Disney movies. He's simply a man in a position of power, and he is VERY realistic. You can totally picture him doing what he does for ideological reasons, and in fact so many men through history do evil acts for the same type of reasons.
@@leovk5779 He is truly a realistic Villain
I think the reason why Esmarelda fell for Phoebus was because he treated her like a equal. Frollo treated her less than but I think Quasimodo treated her on a pedestal (I do believe they could've been great) but I think the main thing is is that Quasi had to learn how to love himself before anyone else (which is cheesy but it is true) I do like how they're all friends in the end because you can see they all care about each other :D
Agreed!! Great point✨
I was so mad that they didn't end up together the first time I watched this
True
Please watch the second movie. I don't think this is really a spoiler since they say this in the movie description (I'm pretty sure), but they give Quasimodo a girlfriend@RukiyaReacts
@@Delulu668Elmo looks like he's about to kill someone
Esmeralda was minding her own business the whole time and these crunchy men were just obsessed.
Right?!! Like those pigs need to leave our girl Esmeralda alone!!
@@RukiyaReacts The only obsessed one was Frollo. Weren't you cabrònes paying ANY attention?🙄
@@RukiyaReacts yes
That should be the official blurb of the movie tbh
for sure although Phoebus saw her as who she was
Fun fact: Apparently the Romani (Gypsy) community had an issue with Esmeralda's red dancing dress. Apparently in their culture, red is not considered a lucky color. They associate it with misfortune, so they avoid having anything to do with red at all costs. Anything they have that has 'red' is usually an offshoot of the color, like pink or burgundy.
It's a pretty dress no denying that and it looks good on her. Just thought I throw that bit in there.
maybe that was done on purpose as a way to foreshadow the misfortune that would befall the Romani people in the movie? Idk. I'm part Romani but I was never raised around the culture so I really have no idea exactly how disrespectful it is or if it is at all but if they did do it to foreshadow the misfortune that was yet to come then that's a pretty smart way to do it.
That word that Esmeralda is constantly getting called starting with a g is a slur
@@salmontoenails4265 But that is what they would have been called in the past.
@@Furienna its still wrong obviously ppl dont know its a slur like only a few months ago i found that out. But educatign ppl and telling them how its wrong i dont think rukiya is gonna see this tho cuz its rlly uncommon for youtubers to look at comments on a video they made months ago
@@karilovecake2323 But we should be able to learn about history, even if some parts of it seem awful today.
It is not like we can do a movie about Romani in the Medieval Era and pretend that they were called anything else...
13:40 One thing that is interesting is that Quasi is taught that the Romani people are bad, but Quasi himself is Romani as we know from the opening scene. Frollo is just instilling further self-hatred in Quasi.
My favorite line was from Phoebus when he said “what a woman.”
What a woman, indeed 😌🤚
Fr thoo she was like my spring awakening 😃
I’ll keep it real, Frollo is THE most evil Disney villain of them all. Sure some villains look to world domination, control a person who is the object of their obsessions, or hell, just plain old greed, but Frollo?
Sure the focus is that he wants Esmeralda in some sick twisted fantasy of owning her, but his magnum opus? Genocide of an entire race who he openly regards as sub human if not human at all. If that’s not the most evil thing a Disney villain could aspire to, I don’t know what would be.
He’s up there with Governor Radcliffe from Pocahontas
They're French Disney Characters afterall
Ils nous appartient 🇫🇷
think what makes frollo set up apart with other villains is he song hellfire isn't really being evil for the sake of evil it's moreso his frustration being unleashed and thrown to chaos compared to most other villian songs where it's "fun to be evil" @Rat the Ninja personally disagree with Governor Rafcliffe unlike other villians you just can't feel that intimidated by him and what's funny is pochuntus never actually meees him
Not to mention he uses the name of the Ultimate good to preform evil.
Not only did Scar murder his brother and blamed it on his little nephew, but he wouldn't move the pride for reasons I don't understand even if they would starve to death.
And there is also Shan Yu, who killed a whole village, and Rourke, who planned to let everybody in Atlantis die because of his greed.
They are definitely up there with Frollo.
What I love about the Hunchback of Notte Dame… is Esmerelda. She’s my one of my top favorite Disney heroines. She’s beautiful, she’s free-spirited, she’s a total badass, she’s has a very certain way with men 😏😁… but most of all… she’s kind, good and pure.
I heard she was a Disney Princess originally, but they removed her, either because kids confused her with Jasmine, or because it was hard to market her when her film was so dark. At least she got some love in Disney's Midnight Masquerade .
I feel the same. Yes, Quasi is also a very likeable character by my opinion, but for me Esmeralda was way more interesting as character. 😗
She's actually from Romania 🇷🇴 living in France 🇫🇷
Me too.
@Optical Sorcerer It’s more likely that the movie wasn’t as successful financially as they wanted, so they didn’t see the point
No one talks about it but I must say the voice actor for a Clopin is incredible with the note he hits at the end of Bells of Notre Dame. I think it was a high D5 which is incredible for the adult male voice
Agreed!!💯
We love clopin ✨✨✨✨
Frollo is one of the darkest Disney villains simply because he doesn’t have the flair, the magic or the sidekicks of other baddies. He’s completely motivated by hatred and ignorance, so Frollo could exist in real life
-Quasi is a completely underrated hero since he does things even though he knows there might not be a great reward, but because it’s the right thing to do
Completely underrated movie
Agreed!!✨
I read in the comments of a different reaction video that Phoebus was the best match for her in the movie. Phoebus saw and loved her for who she was. Frollo saw her as this evil seductress and Quasimodo put her on a pedestal and saw her as an angel.
So Neither of them loved her (or obsessed for frollo) or saw her as an equal. Whether it be putting her above them (Quasimodo) or below them (Frollo).
Waouh I never thought about it that way
That's a really good point! Thank you❤️
@@RukiyaReacts 5:20 "who would make such a evil man a public official?"
Hey, many Americans still love Trump
This movie is very politically driven in addresses issues such as classism and racism
Right?!! I didn’t remember it being this political, but I love how they did it in this film😊
@@RukiyaReacts it’s okay everybody makes mistakes, and I like the mistakes that I made. Most of them make me laugh, cry, serious, strong, learn, or even making me relax. Mistakes are a part what makes you into you.
@@RukiyaReacts Personally I don't really think there's racism in this movie. Back then, gypsies were notorious for being bands of cut throats and thieves (as we see in the Court of Miracles; heck, the movie begins with gypsies trying to smuggle themselves into Paris illegally) Because they lived outside the law, they were taking food and other goods that would be distributed among law abiding citizens, and in order to compensate importing additional goods that the citizens would need, the officials would raise taxes, which of course, gypsies would not pay.
Then you have gypsies who were believed to be practitioners of black magic and conjurings aka witchcraft; something that most people were highly afraid of back then.
In the musical, Frollo had a brother named Jehan; both of whom grew up as orphans who were taken in by Notre Dame. But Jehan was lured away by a gypsy girl and forsook the church in exchange for a life living in shallow drunken stupor that ultimately resulted in his death. So technically Frollo's hatred of gypsies stems not out of racial prejudice, but out of justified intolerance.
@@patrioticjustice9040 Have you ever considered that people didn't steal because out of malice. Sometimes they do desperate things in order to provide for their loved ones. And no racism? You're capping.
@@summerrose8110 And what? Gypsies couldn't learn an honest trade? They couldn't learn to farm, hunt, trade? It doesn't matter if you're stealing to feed your family if you're stealing from a family that is just as in a bleak situation as yours. And gypsy refers to a nomadic person, not really specific to a certain race. So again I say, technically not racist. It's like trying to say you're racist for hating a gang, yet that gang is comprised of people from multiple cultures.
What makes a monster and what makes a man... Kinda the theme of the movie. Kinda cool to see Disney embrace concepts like "physical beauty doesn't necessarily equal goodness. And looking different from the stereotypical concept of "what a person should look like" doesn't mean you're evil. Good on ya, Disney. It takes balls to break free from the "beauty equals goodness equals beauty," trope.
I totally agree 👏🏾
I totally agree 👏🏾
To the people who think this movie is too dark for Disney... Wait until you know the real story.
Now I'm scared to look up the real story😭
@@RukiyaReacts for me it's way more disturbing. Also, there are characters that don't appear in the movie.
Btw, did you know that the names of the male gargoyles make a clear refference to the author of "Notre Dame de Paris" (the original work), Victor Hugo?
@@RukiyaReacts Huge spoilers for the real story.
But to be quick, Frollo is a priest (if I remember well), he treated Quasimodo way better in the book but ended the same killed by him because of his obsession for Esmeralda. Phoebus is a bastard, fiancé to Fleur-de-Lys, he only want to spend time with Esmeralda for her body. Esmeralda is hanged because she's accused of bewitching Phoebus and refused Frollo's ""love"". Quasimodo died of hunger close to her body in a crypt.
Not the most joyful end but at least it help saved Notre-Dame so...
Esmeralda is also only 15 and very, very naive… Great book though, very melodramatic story.
Yes... The real story was way more horrifying!
If you loved this movie then I definitely recommend you The Prince of Egypt. Even though it's based on the religious story of Moses, both religious and non religious people can enjoy (or suffer with) this movie. If you were mindblown by this soundtrack, wait til you watch The Prince of Egypt (Stephen Swchartz at the songs, who also took part in The Hunchback, and Hans Zimmer at the ost). That movie also has amazing animation (it took 2 years to animate what it may be the most famous thing that Moses did), very interesting characters (above all the relationship between the protagonidt and antagonist) that show their humanity, very sad story...
I love the Prince of Egypt!! I will try to make a video on it soon🥰❤️
@@RukiyaReacts Take as much time as you want.
Yes yes ye s y es y e s
The fact that Frollos song “Hellfire” is so different than other villains songs is because it’s an I want song. Which is normal reserved for the protagonist not the antagonist.
Normally the villain gets an “I am” song (which is very narcissistic of them) but since Frollo’s is an “I want” song, it lures you into his dark and twisted mind and makes you see just how messed up he is.
My favorite low-key part of this movie that doesn't get so much attention is how Quasimodo doesn't end up with Esmerelda. You really see this when he puts her hand and Phoebus's together. I love that Quasi doesn't "get" her for a few reasons. Women are people and "getting" one shouldn't be a reward for the hero. He sees what there is between her and Phoebus and her, and his approval really caps off their bromance nicely. And ending a note of friendship between him and Esmerelda seems important considering how many people still (ridiculously) think men and women somehow can't just be good friends. All of this is packed into a really cute, wholesome moment between this couple and their pal.
BTW in my mind, it is now officially called a "trambone." 8)
This is the guy who broke all the ten commendments
Hearing "Hellfire" in munchkin voice is *HILARIOUS!*
I know right?!🤣
I love that when Frollo sings not my fault, the figures respond with mea culpa, Latin for my fault. Such a small but incredible detail.
Tony Jay, who was the voice of Frollo, was also the voice of D'Arque from "Beauty & the Beast" and Sher Khan in "The Jungle Book". His voice was on a whole new level. Only voice comes close is Patrick Page, who preformed as Frollo in the short-lived Broadway "Hunchback of Notre Dame", and was the original Hades of Broadway's "Hadestown".
Wow, he’s done so many legendary roles
Tony Jay was absolutely NOT the voice of Sher Khan in Disney’s “The Jungle Book”. That was George Saunders. You are correct about him being the voice of Mssr. D’Arque…we literally used his audition reading for the production, it was so good.
@@gtrous665 You know what? That's my bad, mix up on my part. But yeah, Tony Jay knocked it out of the park as both Mssr D'Arque and Frollo, for sure!
To be fair, their voices are pretty similar. Tony was also the Voice of Toyota for a few years in the 90’s, narrating all the Toyota commercials in his American accent. He was a magnificent talent and a really nice guy.
@@gtrous665 AH HA! I knew it!
Right, just checked, Tony Jay DID voice Sher Khan... in "TaleSpin" and the direct-to-DVD Jungle Book sequel. But he was, at one point, the successor to George Saunders. That's what mixed me up!
Frollo is actually my favorite Disney villain because he’s so human. Not only does he crave power and commit suicide (like every other Disney villain) but he also feels lust.
I love this movie. Recently rewatched it as an adult. There is some heavy themes. The real story is so much darker it's heartbreaking.. The Deformed being ostracized along with the Roma (gypsies) and being killed/executed in genocide. Esmeralda and Quasi were switched at birth. Her real name is Agnes. Numerous men "love" her. Quasi kidnaps her and falls for her. Phoebes rescues her and she becomes smitten with him but he is engaged and only wants her as a bootycall. Frollo, in a rage calls for her execution. Esmeralda sadly ends up executed even though quasi initially saved her. Quasi throws frollo over the edge when he sees him smiling cruelly as she hangs. Quasimodo ends up laying next to esmeralda corpse in a mass grave. Their bodies become intertwined. Years later an excavation crew attempts to pry them apart and Quasimodo turns to dust. Tragic 😥 I must say I like the direction Disney went with it much better.
the stage version of this follows the original story a bit more, then! (minus quasi kidnapping her, and phoebus is generally similar to the movie version but less of a "knight in shining armor" type, but he does care for esmerelda and still follows the movie by refusing to murder innocents and helps save her etc) i watched a recording of the stage musical first before watching the movie (i either had never watched the movie before or it had been so long i can't remember if i'd watched it) and was honestly shocked at how dark the ending was - i figured they must've taken liberties or taken from another version of the story rather than the film. they also made quasi hard of hearing/partially deaf which is a nice touch as it's more realistic to how someone spending 20 years so close to loud bells.
it follows a lot of the same beats as the movie with some elements from the original story and some new backstory for frollo and quasi thrown in - in the stage musical, quasi is frollo's nephew, the son of his estranged brother and a gypsy woman and frollo reluctantly takes him in after his brother dies despite finding him repulsive. they make frollo less of a irredeemable character and have him actually being more religious and caring about the rules of the church etc (they also show him actually kind of caring abt quasi, at least a little bit - there's still ). at the end, quasi initially saves esmerelda and claims sanctuary in the cathedral, but then esmeralda dies (i believe it's meant to be from smoke inhalation), and quasi blames frollo and throws him off the cathedral. it's a much more sadder and tragic ending as none of the characters get the happier ending we see in the film.
"I just love her! I want to be her!"
You certainly got the look Rukiya 😍 All you need is a little 🐐
Love those editor-Rukiya interjections 🤣🤣🤣
Notre Dame stands out to me not only as a beautiful work of animation and song, but also as a passable adaptation of a very dark, very dense novel into something for children without losing the themes of anti-bigotry and religious hypocrisy.
Frollo forgets the teachings of a certain gentleman in the Bible who recommends plucking out one's own eye rather than lusting... or does he not listen to JC?
Awe thank you!!🥰🥰 I’ll dress up my cat like a Lil goat to complete the cosplay haha!😂 I haven't read the novel but I agree that Disney handled those topics so well in this film. As I child I didn't notice the themes but now I can appreciate it as an adult. 🥰
@@RukiyaReacts if you do read the book, be prepared for crying. Just saying.
@@RukiyaReacts Why not rescue a goat from slaughter? If you truly want one and can have one and care for one, that is…
In the book and the stage-musical version of this film Quasi straight up throws/push Frollo off himself.
I would have loved to see that in this film!!!
The relationship between Quasi and Frollo is actually very similar to Rapunzel and Mother Gothel (tho she is not like afraid of her), even the song Mother Knows Best is very reminiscent of Frollo's song he sand to Quasi at the beginning!
16:02 -16:04 "This is not an order this is a crime."
Gosh that's a great line.
Pocahontas, Mulan, and Hunchback were great films that addressed heavy themes while still being soaring, memorable musicals. I really hope the live-action Hunchback leans more into Disney's version than the novel, personally.
They’re making a live action??😱
@@RukiyaReacts Yep! Though the last news we heard of it was last year. It's still going to be a musical, and to my understanding it's going to star Josh Gad from Disney's Frozen.
I hope in the same, that they keep closer to the Disney version. 😊
@@RukiyaReacts They better not make a live action Hunchback of Notre Dame. After that Mulan live action fiasco, Disney is on thin ice fucking with classics in order to sell out.
@@summerrose8110 same for Pocahontas. I’m 99% sure it would be “historically accurate” 🙄 considering how much of a complete mess Mulan was, including after Shang was originally not even going to be in it, but after a ton of fans being royally pissed about it chose to make Shang a complete douche who upon learning Mulan is actually a woman “loves” her…
Anyways I don’t want a live Pocahontas at all UNLESS its the ‘95 Disney story more or less. Otherwise, if it is “historically correct” call it by her historically correct birth name MATOAKA. Otherwise its gonna get the exact same reaction the abysmal sequel received, a minority of descendants and history nerds not hating it as much and the majority beyond pissed and crucifying it for absolutely tearing the original love story apart
You know, a gargoyle's symbolism is to scare away evil spirits and demons so Frollo being scared of one is very fitting. I always imagined the gargoyle being like: "Oh no, not this bitch on MY Notre Dame you're going to a new home, IN HELL!" Also I've always wondered if Frollo is schizophrenic, I mean all those hallucinations during the Hellfire song, makes you think.
So about Quasimodo’s name… He was named that because Archdeacon Frollo (he was a priest in the original) “found” him on the day of the Quasimodo, or the Sunday after Easter. It was named that because it was almost (quasi) the norm (modo). It was doubly ironic since Frollo clearly also meant it because Quasimodo was “almost the norm of a man”.
Also, unbeknownst to most, Frollo was also a practicing alchemist, which especially then was seen as evil and against God’s teachings. Make of that what you will.
Something interesting I heard, during Hellfire with that little break of someone telling Frollo that Esmerelda escaped
That was like God answering his prayers, before Frollo was deadset on either killing her or having her, he asked for her to disappear. The white light the guard came in with could be seen as "heavenly light" as the guard basically TELLS frollo "She's gone, let it go"
I love this movie. I seriously think this movie is underrated and it’s my favorite Disney movie of all time. There’s a lot of stuff I love in this movie. I feel as though Quasimodo is the most relatable Disney protagonist ever because there’s kids who are often shut indoors who can relate to him. Frollo is an amazing villain and I love how they made him so complex. The music overall is amazing and probably the best Disney soundtrack ever. This movie gets a 9/10 for me
This is a film I saw regularly as a child and have found a new appreciation for as I've gotten older, especially after 5 semesters of Latin in college. The music is also some of the best of the Disney Renaissance.
•Quasimodo-Patron Saint of the Friend Zone
•I looked it up; in France, serfdom did not end until 1789, when the feudal rights of the French nobility were abolished as part of the French Revolution. This film is set in the 15th Century.
•Note that most Romani are actually Catholic too.
•Prior to theaters, public torture/execution was entertainment, especially in medieval times.
•Yes, Notre Dame is a church and one of the most famous cathedrals in the world. Even in the opening song, they say its bells are the soul of Paris.
•In times when illiteracy was high, the stained glass was meant to help teach people the stories of the Bible. And yes, it is beautiful.
•He has, but not with someone on his back.
•Hellfire is one of the best villain songs in the Disney canon and one of Disney's darkest.
•In French literature, the Court of Miracles was a slum in Paris, so named because of beggars who fakes being blind or lame to try to get money from people.
•Actually, he's not; he knew if he told Quasimodo about his attack, that Quasimodo would seek out the Court of Miracles, so he followed Quasimodo and Phoebus. Quasimodo unintentially lead Frollo there.
•He's an archdeacon.
•In the book, the ending is a lot darker.
•"And He shall smite the wicked and plunge them into the fiery pit." - not a direct quote from the Bible.
•"I will not say 'do not weep,' for not all tears are an evil." - Gandalf the White
I’ve always loved Esmeralda too. I want her “God bless the Outcast” at my funeral 💗
It always bugged the heck outta me that frollo never put the tile back right 🤪
Same!! 🫠
Fact: Quasimodo doesn’t mean ‘half-formed’, it’s the first Monday after Easter Sunday. I think this is a self joke Quasimodo tells Esmerelda when they first meet in the original book, it was definitely in one of the live action films though, but I can’t remember which one 🤣
Awwww that one was my favorite Disney movie when I was a kid back there in late 90s. I adored that so much that read the original book of Hugo and cried a lot because it wasn’t like in the movie 🥲 it was my first childhood trauma. But I still rewatch this sometimes and the music, holy cow, the music! Thank you for the vid! Also you’re comments after are interesting, that’s what some other reactors videos really lack
Thank you love🥰❤️
I remember being distressed as a kid when they tied Quasi down and the tint changed to red.
Also, "fun fact," there's a fan theory that Frollo sells his soul during Hellfire, with the red choir representing the last vestiges of his conscience burning away.
Oh cool! Thank you for the fact❤️
this film's got so much weight to it and stirs up so much pure hatred for such an insidious villain such as frollo, and it's always satisfying to see other people feel that way too! WRT quasi not unaliving frollo himself: disney's got an unspoken rule in its storytelling that the protagonists aren't ever allowed to end the villains, they always have to do it to themselves 😩 that's why the majority of disney villains just fall to their death
And credit for the actor doing his job to make us hate him.
If he were a real person irl I’d hate him, but as a character I love him and feel no hatred
you will be pleased to know, quasi does unalive frollo in the original story, as well as in the stage musical bc esmeralda ends up dying because of frollo's actions. i believe the way she dies is different in both - hanging in the original and smoke inhalation after quasi "saves" her from being burned at the stake in the stage musical - though the stage musical does paint frollo in a slightly more sympathetic light (while still remaining a disgusting human being and quasi 100% deserved the right to unalive him at the end)
11:53 I kind of had to laugh a bit because Notre Dame is one of the most well renowned Catholic Churches out there, so yes a movie titled the Hunchback of Notre Dame is indeed going to take place in a church. If you legit didn’t know that’s fine, I just think it’s pretty funny. Also great reactions I enjoyed the video
I'm not religious so I'm pretty ignorant of those things haha. But thank you for informing and enjoying the reaction🥰❤️
@@RukiyaReacts thank you for responding
To be fair, it was the original Hunchback novel that made Notre Dame what it is today. It was falling into disrepair and might have been torn down. Then Victor Hugo brought attention to it in his novel and people started to campaign to preserve & restore it.
The priest in the movie seemed so understanding and kind about everything
When I first saw this, I was shocked to see how Frollo tried to burn people alive if they didn't comply with the law
Right?!! It took all the power in me to not punch my screen when he did that 😤
Hunchback of Notre Dame is my favorite Disney movie. I always loved how they subtly showed Quasi's super strength he acquired from a lifetime of ringing those bells. Like when he lifted Pheobus off the ground with one hand while Pheobus was still in his full plate armor, or when he tossed the stone cover of the crypt as if it was a piece of paper. That its subtle because he's been mentally and probably physically abused his whole life to be timid. That he had the metaphorical & literal strength all along when he starts getting away from Frollo.
This movie is so underrated in my opinion and needs more love. The music of this movie is top tier and more people need to listen to it. Quasi's "I Want" song should be among the top ten of Disney I Want songs. :) I could go on and on about this movie.
The fact that this movie was hand drawn is still unbelievable to me
when quasimodo sing i see belle and i was so suprise and happy about it🤭
I was a Quasimodo and Esmeralda Stan as a kid! I had a Quasimodo plushie that I took everywhere with me and an Esmeralda Barbie doll! I even went as Esmeralda one year for Halloween and I thought her purple Gypsy dress was the prettiest thing! It might have been where I got my life of off-shoulder sleeves, haha!
There's a gentleman on Tik-Tok that said it concisely, " if you are incapable of great violence you're not peaceful you're harmless, know the difference." He then went on to say that basically people who are peaceful or not that way simply because they lack any understanding of what is going on but is because they have mastered themselves so much so that anyone who seeks to undo their peace will basically be cut out from their lives any which way possible even if it means being violent for self-protection. Or protection of those you deeply care about.
Nicely said👏🏾✨
You have a lot of poetic insight, it's really cool to see how you talk about the symbolic side of the movie. You seem very wise, and actually remind me of Esmeralda!
This is the best compliment ever!🥹 thank you❤️
If you haven’t seen mega mind I would recommend it. It’s a hidden gem that did get over shadowed by Despicable Me. And a lot of people are rediscovering it and have enjoyed it immensely
May I request you to watch Atlantis? It's greatly underrated!! You would LOVE Milo and Kida!
And another great one is The Prince of Egypt! The soundtrack is a ✨ masterpiece ✨ they went HARD on that movie, animation and all!!
I love Atlantis and The Prince of Egypt!!❤️ I'm going to react to them soon
@@RukiyaReacts YAAASSSS ✨✨ I'll look forward to it!! Also you are waaay too pretty....it's criminal and I'm low-key jealous 😂 I love your style too! Alright I'm done- I'm leavin-
@@RukiyaReacts would you be willing to do Pocahontas?? I feel she’s so amazing but just as underrated as Esmerelda despite being an official Disney princess
Rukiya, thanks so much for reacting to this Disney version of Hunchback Of Notre Dame. Honestly, I can see why it deviated from the book in so many ways. Seeing as the novel was much darker, I can see why they made the changes for this film that they did. Honestly, Hunchback Of Notre Dame is in my top ten favorite Disney animated films. I loved the songs, the animation, and the characters. I’m sad that many people bash on the gargoyles. I mean for crying out loud, they seemed to help out with Quasimodo’s character arc, especially Laverne. My favorite songs of this film were especially “God Help The Outcast,” Heaven’s Light/Hellfire,” “The Court Of Miracles,” and “Someday.” Does part of me have mixed feelings about Esmeralda marrying Phoebus instead of Quasimodo? Yes! Still, I can see why the writers went that route, especially with the whole riddle about who the monster is, and who the man is. I also felt like Hunchback Of Notre Dame had some really good symbolism, including when Quasimodo , and his chains symbolizing not only breaking free of Frollo, but maybe even his jealousy towards people like Phoebus, you know? And how could we not mention how symbolic Frollo’s death was, you know? Oh, and one other thing that I loved was how we had people like Frollo who had the legalistic attitude of Christianity, while people such as the Archdeacon had the love, grace, and mercy side of Christianity. And there are a couple things that I’d like to mention. One, I liked how Quasimodo soared Frollo’s life when one, he threw Frollo’s sword on the ground, and two, how he held onto Frollo’s cape, and saved his life once again. Yes, Frollo was clearly an evil man. Still, I liked how when Quasimodo did both of those things, he showed that he still loved , and cared for Frollo, and that he basically wasn’t going to repay Frollo evil for evil, but rather repay Frollo evil with good. That is despite Frollo still choosing to remain evil, and getting judged as a result. Finally, I think it’s cool that Kirk Wise, and Gary Trousdale directed 1991’s Beauty & The Beast, this 1996 film, The Hunchback Of Notre Dame, and 2001’s Atlantis: The Lost Empire. Speaking of which, I hope you react to those two fairly soon as well. Well, thanks again for reacting to this version of The Hunchback Of Notre Dame!
I loved your reaction to this movie! I've always loved the moment just after he breaks free of the chains where he stands, and you watch the chains slink off of him. It's the one shot in the whole movie where Quasimodo actually looks monstrous and ugly, and I feel like it was intentional on the part of the animators because it's the precise moment that he is finally claiming his power and his identity. It's like he's thinking, "If you want to call me a monster, then fine. You better be ready for me to terrify you."
Yes! I agree!👏🏾
@Taje Ono What an asshole thing to say. When Quasimodo breaks his chains, he not only broke the physical ones, but the mental chains that Frollo put him on. You calling him ugly tells me how shallow you are and missed the point of this film.
This is one of if not my absolute favorite Disney films so I am sorry for the long comment. It always makes me cry at least twice, the scene where Quasi is tied down and tortured at the festival and then the scene at the end where he holds her over his head and yells sanctuary. Esmeralda will always be my favorite Disney leading lady and I have told myself for years that the only reason she isn't an official "disney princess" for merch is because she's actually a Queen. I also have to say I think this film was rather gutsy for Disney. The main villain in a man of the church. He was elected as a Judge but during Hellfire you hear a soldier call him Minister. His entire villain song (one of the best villain songs disney's ever done) was a prayer. He was praying. His villainy is also realistic. People like him have and still do exist. Racist, sexist, ableist, xenophobic people who use their faith to excuse their hatred, use their faith to point blame onto others. Example, he was only committing the sin of lust because of Esmeralda's "spell" and the only way to make it right was to purify her (she becomes his) or kill her to break said spell. Also, there was a secondary villain. Society as a whole. He was an ELECTED official. Frollo forbid him from going to the festival and when Quasi went... it wasn't Frollo who tortured him. He didn't stop it but he didn't start it or even participate. That was the crowd. That was everyone around him laughing along.
There's also so much morbid humor in the Court of Miracles song (real place btw with a really interesting history)) where the people Quasi & Phoebus are trying to save, without listening, without thinking, without questioning, jump to conclusions and are about to kill them with no questions asked. Like the lyrics of that song "We like to get the trial over with quickly because it's the sentence that's really the fun" and "But the dead don't talk, So you won't be around to reveal what you've found." or "here in the court of miracles where it's a miracle if you get out alive".... these are sung by the good guy side characters... the main singer is the frickin narrator
As for Quasi not getting the girl, I actually like that. He didn't see Esmeralda as a person fully. He saw her more like an angel, a savior, the first person who showed him genuine kindness. He idolized her, while Frollo objectified her. Phoebus (in this film, not the book, book phoebus was an ass, but so was everyone) treated her more like a person. I didn't like the sequel but I'm glad he found love that made more sense and felt more real. I don't think in this film, he would have been ready to have real romantic feelings that are coming from a healthy place quite yet. I also appreciated how he handled it. He didn't get mad at her. He felt his pain, had a moment here or there of annoyance but he still helped her, still cherished her friendship because that was what was most important to him.
I also think that, while the writers didnt intend him to be, I think the Priest is also a villain. Not a malicious one but he is responsible for Quasi having been isolated, emotionally manipulated and abused all his life. In WHAT WORLD does something think it is okay to punish a man, for trying to throw a baby down a well after murdering his mother, by forcing him to raise said baby. THEN allowing him to isolate the baby in the towers the priest controls. ANd THEN doesnt even check in!!! There's no indication that the Priest ever went to visit Quasi or invited him down to mass. Never. In fact it is shown he's explicitly not supposed to come down to church service. Not a fan. No.
(Sorry for this long reply, but anyway) I always thought about the same thing you said in the last paragraph. I guess he’s definitely meant to be a good character, it’s just that they needed to find a way to make a good priest at Notre Dame (for the sake of not misleading people into viewing all Christian leaders in a negative light) while also having a reason that Frollo would adopt Quasimodo and a dramatic “stop!” scene play out.
I think the creators might have considered having Frollo decide not to kill the baby without prompting from another character, but that would have risked making Frollo look moreso like he might have a glimmer of goodness which is probably something they wanted to avoid. For “children’s” movies especially (although this is arguably not a children’s movie) you want to make the people committing horrific acts as totally evil as possible, because making them a little bit merciful can upset people since it might lead to too much audience empathizing. For children evil is made evil and good is good, usually as little mixing as possible is done. If they are to make the live action more complex and even less kid-friendly in the writing (which I would love, if done right) then maybe they *could* have Frollo decide on his own to spare Quasimodo. Maybe a beam of light with a sudden gust of wind suddenly appears or something, leading to a Hellish statue (reminds him of the risk of Hell) and then his eyes glance upwards towards the Godly eyes of Notre Dame.
But anyway yeah when you actually think about the situation more, the priest seems like a cold idiot for thinking it’s a good idea for evil Frollo to raise him and to also not really check up on him in life or anything, like you said. But I just ignore that because like I mentioned, I feel like him being at the Notre Dame and saying “stop!” and everything was necessary for reasons of not offending or misleading the audience to dislike Christianity. Because it’s worse look for Christianity if you have only an evil Christian leader without any Christian leader in the movie who shows goodness, than if you have both the evil and the good Christian leaders, and the Christian leader just made a stupid recommendation you’re supposed to ignore, and he is just kind of not involved so much in helping out Quasimodo, which you’re also supposed to ignore for plot reasons.
when i watched this with my mom my mom said "GO QAUSI YOUR SUCH A BADDIE"
15:20 The hooded figures are chanting "mea culpa" (latin for "my fault") and "mea maxima culpa" (Latin for "my most grievous fault"), so even Frollo's own subconscious doesn't buy his BS
It’s good to see I’m not the only one who has a serious girl crush on Esmeralda ❤
Great video
Fun fact that in the musical off Broadway version quasi picks up frollo and throws him off the edge into the fire
👍
Esmeralda is my favorite Disney girl because she is kind, warm harted, bedass, gorgeous and so graceful are every of her moves. Also she is a socially conscious character, and I love her song a lot. I am pretty curious who will they cast for the live action movie. I hope they stick to the plot of the Disney version.
Right?!! Beauty with brains and a big heart🥰❤️
I’m nervous for the live action because they tend to be a flop 😬 but I have hope it’ll be good🤞🏾✨
@@RukiyaReacts yes, right
@@RukiyaReacts I hope this time they stick to the cartoon by plot and characters and cast a really Esmeralda looking actress.
Rukiya threatening to throw her slipper is the funniest thing I've heard all day 😂
Omg I just discovered you less than 24hrs ago and I've been bingeing your videos. Your commentary is hilarious and you watch actual gems not just popular films. Thank you and can't wait for my first notification from your channel ❣
Awe you’re too sweet🥹 thank you so much for your support❤️
@@RukiyaReacts you're most welcome, love 💗💗
I remember Tony Jay, the voice actor for Frollo, saying that the Hellfire song took a lot out of him to perform.
I wish there was a live video recording of him performing it somewhere out there-
I loved that song so much when I first watched the movie, I asked my mom to rewind the scene. XD
The Archdeacon thought that Frollo would grow to be a better person by raising a child, but he was very mistaken.
Also, if you want to see Quasimodo unaliving Frollo, read the original book. =D
My favorite gargoyle was Laverne. Especially when he pulled a wizard of oz reference
If you are unsatisfied with the ending of the movie with Frollo I'd recommend watching the Hunchback of Notre Dame musical, the La Jolla production is here on youtube and it is the Disney version but a bit darker and truer to the plot beats of the novel.
"i had the biggest girlcrush on esmeralda growing up"
me, a lesbian: sweating nervousely
This is easily my favorite Disney movie !! Quasimodo is my favorite Disney character and Out There is my favorite Disney song 😍
This movie was classic Halloween 🎃 Hearts of EVIL of cruelty and Hated.
I recommend Atlantis: The Lost Empire. Now that is an underrated gem of a movie.
I love Atlantis! I’ll try reacting to it soon❤️
6:02 I love how the man in purple likes touching the men's hunchback instead of his arm
I think you would enjoy The Prince of Egypt, they have incredible music and animation in that movie. I’ve loved it since I was a kid. Thank you for the video girl, enjoy your reactions 💕
I loved it as a kid too!!🥰 I filmed my reaction to it, just need to edit it
I had almost forgotten how dark this movie was as a child, and it's still got some pretty disturbing and chilling parts to it that make my skin crawl, more especially how well-written Judge Frollo was as the most evil man ALIVE!!! But I still like the way Quasimodo comes out of his own shell and learns to love himself positively, and Esmeralda is still just as fine, brave, kind, fearless, and badass as she was the first time I saw her. Don't you worry Rukiya, I won't make a move on your girl Esmeralda 😂😀😉 But maybe you won't mind if I could try my best with you... 😘😉❤️❤️☺️
“I had the biggest girl crush on her growing up”. Me to, me to
I watch Rukiya apologize getting worked up over a fictional character while reactions of that caliber are the norm for me XD
Even til this day this movie still stands up. Sadly though if it were written today you'd have a bunch of people calling it woke garbage just because thats what they do now
Absolutely agree. You could not make this movie today - I say that with full intentional irony (because that’s what people say about comedy, movies like Blazing Saddles, whatever)
But the character of Frollo would offend so many people. Ironically at least one of the people who make fun of things being too woke.
My all time favourite Disney movie and villian😍! Glad to see you liked it like I did😊
This film is such an underrated gem🥰
In my grade twelve year, I was in a production of Hunchback (the stage play) and the vocals were intense but a lot of fun. Also, a lot more darkness than in this movie (obviously, Disney would leave out some of the more not child friendly things). SPOILER FOR STAGE PLAY I'm sure others have probably commented this before but in the show, Quasimodo is actually Frollo's nephew who was born after the brother ran away from the church to live with the Romani (Gypsies). Also at the end of the theatre production, Esmeralda actually dies...
Oh my God- chipmunking Frollos voice was so great it made my day
Frollo is not as cruel in the book as he is here.
He taught Quasimodo sign language when he went deaf from constant exposure to the ringing bells.
i always thought the gargoyles were all in Quasys imagination.
sure they do stuff when hes not around but I had imaginary friends as a kid and they got up to all sorts whilst I was in school
I would recommend you listen to the soundtrack of the actual play of the hunchback of Notre dame. Just the soundtrack alone will tell you in their songs the background of Frollo, the song tambourine which is Esmeralda’s songs describing how she welcomes her guests in her performances, the song named “esmeralda” which is a song describing how the whole town wants to kill her and at the same time the three different perspectives of Frollo, Quasi and Phoebus, AND as well the song that Quasi sings about being chained up it’s called something like “ Man of stone “. Really good music and really good awesome background story to all of these characters.
Frolo: "And he shall smite the wicked and plunge them into the fiery pit!"
God: Well, if you insist...
The thing about the idea of Quasimodo un-aliving Frolo is that Disney is always very careful not to have the heroes commit flat-out murder, with very few exceptions. The dwarves don't kill the evil queen. A random lightning bolt makes her fall off a cliff. Simba doesn't kill Scar. The hyenas do. Beast doesn't intentionally kill Gaston, he just thrashes when he gets stabbed and Gaston falls. Tarzan doesn't kill Clayton. His dumb @$$ accidentally hangs himself, etc. The only exceptions that I can think of are Prince Philip vs. Maleficent, and Prince Eric vs. Ursula.
(Before you guys come at me too hard, it's almost 1 am, I'm tired, and I'm not racking my brain too hard over this. Feel free to add more examples if you want but be nice)
Point is, Disney tries not to have the heroes kill the villains because that's part of what separates them FROM the villains.
I've never even thought about that before. Thank you for your insight.
Wow! That makes so much sense! Thank you ❤️
Esmeralda is another character you should cosplay as!
It can be as cultural appropriation btw it’s Romani culture and people always used as hallowe’en costume but when they actually wear it we are judge for wearing our culture so it’s not the best idea
Fun fact: Frollo’s last words, “And he shall smight the wicked and plunge them into the fiery pit.” are a pretty loose adaptation of Isaiah 11:4 in the Bible.
And before anyone says it, yes I know I’m named after that chapter.
A lot of people are actually attracted to claude frollo (for reasons I couldn't fathom). There's a lot of fanfiction on him.
Really?? I'm side-eyeing those individuals 🤨😒
Oh hell no.
Tony Jay, May he rest in peace, was spectacular as Frollo. That's disgusting how people get off on a genocidal murdering pedophile.🤢🤮
EWWW! that is some weird emotional abuse kink shit!
@@renitymoon3471 Daddy issues.
I loveee your reactions they are so similar to mine when i first watched the movie. Also, love Esmeralda very much too
In the original novel it's Quasimodo who throws Frollo to his death btw
Yay! I love that for Quasimodo❤️
I just love how Rukiya is both an Esmeralda simp and Frollo hater through the entire vid! 🤣😭 I'mma follow instantly!☺️✨♥️
Also Funfact! Frollo's horse is apparently called "Snowball", which is kinda surprising.
Great I can stay xD
2 different Esmeralda dolls (one regular dress, one red dress) 4 tamborines, 1 self made Esmeralda styled dress (my mom is a jewel to sew this....she hates sewing xD) combine all of that and you have little 6 year old me dancing around and terrorizing our dog that had to be the goat xD xD
I miss childhood xD
This is along with Princess & the Frog and The little Mermaid are my favorite Disney movies
I love me some Esmeralda she’s a gorgeous queen this movie is so good
14:43 I used to listen to this song on repeat on RUclips as a literal CHILD like it was a good song (it had a sick instrumental) but I never understood what the lyrics meant. But as a teenager, almost an adult, I get it now...
“How made this man a public official”
Divine right apparently
I mean, in the original novel (and the broadway version) he is actually the arch deacon rather than a judge that he is in the movie, so it would be correct to say divine right ;)
yasss look! I'm so excited to watch!
Thank you babe🥰❤️😘✨
21:38 SAY IT LOUDER👏🏾🤩👏🏾🤩👏🏾🤩👏🏾🤩👏🏾🤩👏🏾🤩👏🏾🤩👏🏾
Loved seeing him finally sit up for himself🥹❤️👏🏾
that's the Disney ending. Victor Hugo ending is quite different. Frollo hangs Esmeralda, Quasimodo throws him of the roof of Notre-Dame in rage, found Esmerald's body and goes to hidding and dies of starvation holding her. Years later, an excavation founds the intertwined skeletons and, when they try to remove them, they crumble to dust.
Wow.. that’s a brutal ending😳
Fun fact about this movie: Ezmeralda is only 15 years old. Just 1 year older than Snow White.
Also, Here is the thing that happens in original book: Ezmeralda was afraid of Quasimodo cause of the way he looked but he still loved her and so did Frollo of course. But when Frollo could not have her, he actually manage to kill her and then years pass and when a person visit Ezmeralda’s grave, they noticed another skeleton hugging her and that was Quasimodo. When she died, he could not live without her, so he crawl into her grave, hugged her corpse and stayed like that until he died.
So to summarize: the book is dark but memorable.
Oh wow, geez
That's such a tragic romance right there
In the books Esmerelda is 16. Disney changed to 21 for the movie.
(This information about Hellfire isn't mine):
First of all, Frollo doesn't speak or sing to God, or Christ, but to Virgin Mary. Why? Because, in the first scene that Clopin sings about, when the archdeacon points out the statues, Frollo focuses above all in Virgin Mary. Then, a thunder resonantes, and for a very short time (and almost invisible), Virgin Mary opens his eyes and stares at him like saying "You've done a bad thing". Also, the Cathedral's name is "Notre Dame", which means "Our Lady" so...
Secondly, now focusing on Hellfire, the dark blue colour simbolizes good, and Heaven. The red colour, Hell. That is why you see a big Cross above the chimney, but the fire's red light doesn't reach it, it's dark blue. Also, Frollo wants to be "pious" as those cardinals dressed in red, who are judging him ("Mea culpa"/"My fault"). But, as his actions aren't pious, in the end, when he positions himself against the wall, forming a very little cross ( which is very little compared to the shadows of the good cardinals and Saints that ascend to the blue side ) he stays in the red side.
The scene when the soldier appears to tell Frollo that Esmeralda is gone. That solider is surrounded by dark blue colour. He's an angel who comes to give him an ultimatum: "leave her and come with me, or continue and you're doomed.
Actually I would say,WILL YOU PEOPLE JUST SHUT UP, WE'RE DEATH HEARING THAT NOBODY WANTS TO SING HELL FIRE SONG ANYMORE!!!!!!!!!!!!
Rukiya, you should watch Anastasia, it’s such a great movie!
It strikes me how much fire is in this movie. My year-planned vacation to Paris was 2 weeks after the fire wrecked Notre Dame.
I wish the original had a happy ending tbh, they even say that they found esmeralda's skeleton hugging quazimodo's skeleton.
This is one of the most underrated soundtrack of all time. It’s amazing